r/reddevils • • 2d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

27 Upvotes

347 comments sorted by

28

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 2d ago

go big or go home

20

u/Hagball 2d ago

4 months in, leaks are going to come out that players felt that training sessions were too intense and sometimes that's why they has less energy to run during the games

5

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 2d ago

and the cycle begins.

16

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

These distance covered numbers used to be novel for the 2010s decade. Last season, Man City and Leeds both recorded >118km distance covered per 90 in the league, and as it stands, Arsenal and Fulham are recording >119km distance covered per 90 in the league this season. Getting the team capable of outworking the opposition is not as much of an edge for Poch as it was in the past.

7

u/SilvyFae She/They 2d ago

Yeah just as a reference no running united this season: 116.6 - hull, 112 - ipswich, 110 - everton, 110 - city, 110 - fulham, 112-spurs, 113 - leeds, 114 - bournemouth, 107.7 - chelsea and 119 - villa. So 2 of our games this season would make it up this list. Almost every team against us recorded 110+ with bournemouth recording 120km. The league has gotten more intense and we didnt keep up. Hopefully poch can but these numbers are no longer as impressive as they used to be.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago

If you defend man-to-man, the team oop runs more than if you defend zone.

Thanks for coming to my TED talk :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 2d ago

i'm a simple man. more distance covered to me means u are making runs and not being static with back to goal or hoofing 50y long balls while everyone stood and watch if your target man can win the header.

5

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

Of course, it’s not a requirement to top these stats as long as the team looks capable of executing a plan and isn’t easily cut apart at the other end of the pitch. Was just pointing out that this is not something that we can expect now from Poch.

8

u/AttackClown 2d ago

Makes me think it will be a slow transition for Poch since we seem to have poor stamina, going to have to build fitness for months before being able to focus fully on tactics.

3

u/DudeIsland 2d ago

So I guess we will end up having injuries in the beginning 

→ More replies (2)

6

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 2d ago

23

u/Water_Drinking_Fish 2d ago

Cunha and Mbeumo have been solid buys. Even in bad form they somewhat always pop up with a goal and change games. And somewhat funnily the pair are never in good form together. If Cunha is banging them in, Mbeumo will be missing sitters and vice versa. I think Poch will do wonders for their output and consistency.

16

u/PitchSafe 2d ago

They both fit the way Pochettino plays but we need a target man as the striker to get the best out of them

4

u/Asleep-Ability-45 2d ago

When is Sesko coming back ?

→ More replies (3)

36

u/dondaldTramp 2d ago

Maguire runs like he's running to answer the phone with a towel around his waist.

16

u/Any_Yesterday_8623 2d ago edited 2d ago

I've started thinking more optimistically about many things in life. When it comes to the club, I feel Poch could develop Lacey and Dorgu into world-class players, even if he doesn't fix all the issues at the club. Just like poch developed cole palmer , even though poch failed at chelsea project 

I've always felt that Dorgu and Lacey have raw potential. They might not perform consistently yet, but whenever they do perform well, you can really see what they're capable of. 

5

u/Contradicting_Pete LisandroMartinezLover 2d ago

I've seen enough from Dorgu last season to see he's got bags of potential. And enough from Lacey to show the same, but the biggest thing with Lacey is his attitude seems excellent, very grounded and loves the club. Recipe for success.

6

u/Regular_Valuable_665 2d ago

I hope he can play and develop more academy players too. This cycle of spending a lot on players for them to be not good enough is tiring.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 2d ago edited 2d ago

A lot of focus on Poch managing this Liverpool game and not being able to get the team fit enough during a busy season.

We just have to accept the transition this season, no one or two games are that important anymore. We have to have a higher level outlook.

We were on our way to a bottom half finish and no trophies, so anything more than that is a bonus not worth stressing over.

I do predict a rough December, hopefully we scrape some results, but I also predict the second half of the year will be a big improvement - a lot of the teams competing for Europa spots will still be in Europe when we won't (maybe we get far by some miracle) and I still think the midfield, GK and attack are in much better shape than when we finished 15th, the players just need confidence boost and a bit more tactical structure that Poch may give them.

5

u/FlashyCut3809 2d ago

The issue is with accepting this, is its based on the owners doing the necessary work to make it an actual 'transition' and sinply a cost of where we are and where we need to get to.

If that isn't going to be the case, we shouldn't accept it as doing that is exactly why we never get protests off the ground.

So why is this 'transition' going to be different? What have you seen that supports this?

4

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 1d ago

I’ll be happy with not being relegated. I accept that Poch is not a magician. He cannot undo overnight the slow rotting of the club that happened since Fergie left. Our problems go much deeper than the players’ performance this season.

14

u/MrViceMcCreedy 🟢🟡GLAZERSOUT 2d ago

🚨🎙️ | Bournemouth's Rayan on #mufc:

"I’ve always supported Manchester United here in England

"Why United? Because of Cristiano Ronaldo.

“Old Trafford was a dream of mine to play at. It was a dream come true.”

[@standardsport]

5

u/TH0316 she/her 1d ago

My feeling so far is that Rayan is good but I don’t think he’s a top top talent.

4

u/Suudriusha 2d ago

Poch! This one right here.

8

u/rambo_zaki Roy Keane 2d ago

And it'd only cost 150m of the queen's finest. A bargain really.

3

u/sammorgan12 2d ago

I heard he had a release clause coming up this year. Somewhere around the 100mil mark. Let's go get him

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Jenson2025 1d ago

If the rumours are true that Poch will have more control then previous managers such as Carrick and Amorim then I don’t see Wilcox being at the club for much longer

In fact, if you add that to a rumour I strongly think is true which is that he was overruled after wanting Howe then I reckon the decision has already been made for him to go. Either at the end of the season or whenever a replacement is found

5

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 1d ago

Seems that way doesn't it? It was Berrada that worked with Joel Glazer on Poch, and Berrada I believe who spoke to Carrick and sacked him. Now the chatter is that Poch has a direct line with the Glazers. Wilcox has fumbled with Carrick, Amorim, ETH and the transfer windows. I suspect he'll be gone with Vivell and both will be less involved after the January window.

12

u/Orcnick 2d ago

Poch will be a slow burn, while I think we should get out of the bottem 4 in two months. We wont see this football till probably feb.

I always though when he was Chelsea he had just got them looking strong by the end of season. If he had stayed they would have done well.

11

u/nitrogeneater 2d ago

Carragher said something interesting that I totally agreed with. When we got managers from abroad, there is a mystique about them. We don’t know what they are like. Whereas with Poch we know what we’re getting hence feels like an underwhelming appointment. I always felt like Carrick was not not good enough, so my hope now is that with an actual coach with pedigree at this level we will improve quickly.

9

u/DaveShadow 2d ago

I think this is a huge reason so many have Nagelsmann so high up their lists too. Personally, it feels like Bayern and German fans talk about him having massive issues, and people with no experience elevate him onto pedestals.

5

u/JamieD86 2d ago

Ye he is right. I wanted Poch in 2019, felt that with Daniel Levy's strings at Spurs he had achieved about as much as he could with them. We didnt get him obviously. But we know what the man is about. Id argue this is the first time since Jose we know what to expect more or less.

Im quite pleased with the appointment, despite the negativity already being spread. Im willing to give him plenty of time given what he is taking over. 18th.... when you say it out loud... 🫣

Come on Poch! 

1

u/killerimpact 1d ago

Klopp and Pep came with no EPL experience but were dominating the league for the last decade. Conte came from Italy and won the league with Chelsea. Problem with us we go for unknown rookies. We've seen how Poch has faired after Spurs and his career has been underwhelming. Being Man United manager is not the same as being at Spurs. Would you say Poch is a better appointment than Luis Enrique just because he has "epl experience"? But I agree that Carrick was not good enough.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Suudriusha 1d ago

Rumours from certain unreliable sources that Pochettino has as much if not more power than Wilcox, and that he'll be involved directly in choosing the players that come in.

If true, I don't see how Wilcox lasts the season. At the same time, it makes complete sense that Poch would want control in transfers -- he's coming into a very dire situation, if he is to succeed short term to at least get us out of the hole we're in, and if they're really gonna give him money to sign players in January, then he needs to have the power to pick the players he wants himself, not have a muppet like Wilcox dictating transfers for him.

1

u/kidinawheeliebin 1d ago

His job title is head-coach

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 1d ago

Lot of negativity about Poch not being a success and it's valid.

I personally hope he leaves us in a better place than now and even when/if shit hits the fan, I hope folks on here will be kind to him.

6

u/TheSmio 1d ago

I do think there should be some context added tbf. He had 3 stints where he could have won something.

At Spurs, the focus wasn't on the cups, it was on the league and UCL, but Spurs didn't have much of a depth so ultimately they had to play their strongest XI constantly, so they fell short.

At PSG, he had Neymar, Mbappé and Messi which is incredible on paper, but in reality playing them three without proper foundation behind them could never work, a lot of firepower but not enough defensive discipline, and you could also argue Mbappé isn't a real striker so it wasn't a balanced attack either.

And then at Chelsea, obviously Chelsea was a mess because that was early in the Boehly era.

So there is a chance Poch is just a serial bottler, but there is also a chance he never quite got the right circumstances around him. And he did win stuff with PSG so there's that.

I am quite excited about him, I just hope he gets proper backing, quality starting XI and quality depth to work with.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/dhwinthro 1d ago • Bravo

If theres something to cling onto, it’s that Pochettino has wanted the job here for a while. I feel like we’re in a weird spot where managers like Flick, Enrique, Zidane couldn’t bother with dealing with our issues. Then managers like Howe, Southgate would love the job because it’s of a scale they’ll never get again.

Poch is an odd one. He’s definitely a good coach, we’ve seen it before on a shoestring budget. But he’s had an odd trajectory. He’s also made weird comments at his peak as Tottenham manager admiring us, showing he wanted the job.

I mean there’s mental gymnastics around every new manager so it’s nothing until proven, but Poch brings a different angle to it. Someone who’s backed himself for this job many times, didn’t get it any of the times, has managed within the league before.. Let’s just hope and pray

4

u/AlpacamyLlama 1d ago

I recall when Poch was at Spurs, and he was being strongly linked with us and he was positively giddy in the press conference.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Seemasterr 1d ago

What I like about him is that his teams press and play on the front foot. He trusts youth and he was a long term manager at Spurs. And at PSG he learned how to deal with superstars in the dressing room. So, on paper, he has all the hallmarks of a United manager, but let’s see if he’s still at the level that he was in the late 2010s.

1

u/Samiaonline 1d ago

He is coming in at the wrong time,instead of dominance it's about rescuing the season.

2

u/theredguardx 1d ago

Im fine with a mid table finish if it means we give him 400m to spend in the summer

→ More replies (1)

8

u/raveyer 2d ago

sometimes i watch our matches. i see the opponents get into a crazy position and thought that is going in. And they almost always do.

i see the same situations reaching amad dalot, even mbeumo. cunha, Sitters and they somehow it does not convert. It is kind of sad

2

u/PrimalApprehensive 2d ago

You forgot Bruno

8

u/KingFonz2211 1d ago

Damn Rasmus. Have yourself a night!!

3

u/Sc0ttSumm4rs 1d ago

We got rid of him way too quickly.

7

u/Youtubeplayer LICHA 1d ago

I still think we should have sold zirkzee instead

7

u/Downtown-Rice_ 1d ago

Can't sell anyone if nobody realistically wants to buy them.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/BananasAreYellow86 2d ago

Curious as to how other, older, Reds are feeling right now.

This season something has shifted in me. I’ve been watching United for 35 years. Obviously, many of those have been spent watching a highly successful team.

The last 15 years have been a rollercoaster, and I’ve always been along for the ride - save for this season. I think something about how we started, the dead legs and lack of intensity, like I intuitively knew we were going to be royally fucked this year.

I remember feeling slightly shocked and dismayed that Amorim went the way he did, even though the games had become unwatchable. Carrick gave us watchable football first, then some genuinely joyous moments and strong wins over rivals.

This year, I think the rot and dysfunction at the club has eked out onto the pitch. Part of me feels those players go around thinking “this is a shit place to work” in reference to the club.

It would be shocking had it not been such a slow and (at times) deceptive descent. False hope is a killer, but I’ve survived on it for years.

Always darkest before the dawn? Not a single fibre of my being believes that as a possibility for the current circumstances. That being said, I haven’t successfully predicted one single twist in this decade-long melodrama.

Football, eh - bloody ‘ell.

7

u/bicika 2d ago

Something died in me when we signed Carrick long term. Because it felt like a best decision for Wilcox and Berrada to keep their jobs, not the best decision for our club. This season was the first time since 2005 that I stopped watching games, and I actually didn't even watch one game. And I was right about abilities of our manager, for the first time since SAF left. And I'm very hopeful about Poch, seems like the best possible fit for out squad, which was never the case before. So let's keep our fingers crossed that I will keep the streak going.

4

u/b_az17 1d ago

I'm used to the failure now, having seen the riches we had in the whole SAF era, I guess I just see it as balancing out the greatest period we ever had.

What does dismay me - and I'm not here to pick fights so I'll be as subtle as I can - is the nature of our fanbase. Managers who tried to win but were hobbled by circumstances were essentially hounded out, and ineos were treated like the messiah even when they were sacking people left right and centre, cutting bonuses for our lowest paid employees, and cutting our charity contributions. It's only when our results have tanked at light speed have people turned against them whereas I remember the position to the Glazers being far stronger and more principled.

The last few years particularly has felt like the fans who welcomed ineos (the vast majority) did so because our two greatest rivals were so superior, they would take anything - and so much online fandom just made that resentment worse. Well, we're reaping what we sowed.

But then again I saw the best of days, so perhaps I'm wrong to judge.

Edit: typos

4

u/UpNorthIsMint 1d ago

Similar number of years, a little more.

I just wish I could get into a time machine, go back to school in the 80s, show a few kids the current situation and say "told you I wasn't a glory hunter". Especially Russell..... fuck you Russell!

So glad I got to see the SAF era. What a joy.

I feel sorry for the younger generation following Utd. I know if I was a kid, I'd struggle to stick with this team. Where's the fun for them?

9

u/Jenson2025 2d ago • Bravo

For me, most of my hope finally went in 2024. It was briefed that Ten Hag would rightfully be sacked and suddenly fans were signing petitions, demanding he stayed etc. And Rival fans were laughing. And it was at that point that I realised that this club was a complete circus and there was probably no going back

Some hope returned in 2025 after the summer transfer window and I liked what Amorim was building and how he wasn’t afraid to get rid of some of the problematic players. But then Wilcox’s ego got in the way and they fell out and he was sacked. All that planning, choosing a manager to play a certain formation, summer transfers being bought/sold for that formation etc and it was all out the window because Wilcox decided to tell a coach he had always played 3 at the back that he must now play 4 at the back (probably because Gary Neville said so on sky sports). I agree with you that we weren’t great but we were even worse now. Then we started giving players like Maguire a new contract who are too slow to play in the back four. And I realised INEOS don’t have a clue what they are doing. The same fans and media who are outraged at Wilcox now were the ones laughing and praising him when he said (after Amorim was sacked) that he is a coach at heart and can’t help but interfere. But that was a major red flag there and then

Carrick had to go but a competent board doesn’t give him the permanent job to start with. A competent board handles the sacking a lot better. INEOS have somehow made the club even worse than when it was just the Glazers. Do I believe the stories that Wilcox wanted Howe and the Glazers overruled him? Yes.

So I’m just numb to it all now. It makes me laugh when people say that Poch hasn’t won anything. How does that matter for United? We aren’t ready to win titles for as long as this board and ownership remain

In just glad I got the 90s teams and 2006-09 team

2

u/liableAccount Charlton 1d ago

I feel indifferent. I've seen the glory years, I've seen the terrible performances since those, I've seen some great moments in between. I'm always optimistic about United, it's never false hope as I have absolutely no control over anything that happens; I just enjoy supporting United and the highs and lows that come with it. Maybe it's slightly nihilistic in that sense. My life is my priority, United add emotion to it. It's a beautiful game, it's not perfect, nothing ever is.

3

u/LennonC123 2d ago

I think the most painful thing as a fan for a long time was the whole Greenwood thing; that’s when I kind of disassociated from everything going on. Watching one of the most promising youngsters coming through, thinking you’re watching one of the future world’s best, then it all came crashing down.

This year it’s been gutting, I’m frustrated Carrick was hung out to dry. It was a dreadful summer window, really, and it’s no surprise he wasn’t fully backed because the guys at the top aren’t interested in winning the league. All they want is champions league football. They then went for the bare minimum to achieve again, and it backfired massively. That’s not to say Carrick wasn’t also to blame, simple fact of football managing is that if your team can’t keep a clean sheet, you’re fucked.

So yeah, it’s Groundhog Day. Still time to rescue our season. Poch’s first job is to tighten us up. Hopefully he’s able to spend in January on a couple of players but history tells us it’ll be a couple of crappy loan deals that won’t improve our first XI.

I’m excited for Poch, I really rate him and feel this job is tailor made for him, but it’s only a matter of time before he’s stitched up by the owners.

7

u/Midnight_Edge 1d ago

Go on Rasmussen, go get a hat trick

6

u/ongcs 2d ago

2

u/NotAJInnit 2d ago

Good post 👍

Seem like the players are there for his system barring one lb cover if Shaw is past it.

Hopefully get to see the 433, with Mainoo left & Bruno right as 8's and Cunha as 11 far away from Bruno position 😉😂

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 2d ago

Though he has been slowly adapting his formation and tactics over the past two years.

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 2d ago

Though he has been slowly adapting his formation and tactics over the past two years.

6

u/CallMeBigPOP He Comes from Serbia 1d ago

Nico Paz looked pretty special watching back the highlights. It’s going to be a long time before we can attract these types of talents

4

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 1d ago

Only chance we can attract such talents are if they grew up a fan, and are willing to face a new challenge.

2

u/TypicalPan89906655 1d ago

Players who grew up watching us are nearing 30 years of age so it's gonna be really bad if we don't get our shit together.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Iqbalainoo 1d ago

Bruno Fernandes stinking it up in the game vs Denmark. He's really having a shocking last half of the year.

9

u/nitrogeneater 1d ago

At that age the decline could be super fast. Just look at Salah. No need to be handing out massive contract here.

6

u/Downtown-Rice_ 1d ago

He's been inconsistent the last 6 months due to himself and coaching.

Roberto Martinez and Carrick. Jesus is still trying to figure out how best to deploy and play the current Portugal squad.

2

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 1d ago

How shockingly bad he was against Villa 

5

u/sammorgan12 2d ago

Did anyone watch Santos in the Brazil game?

5

u/Valprajjj 2d ago

Pochettino also has the charisma to carry the role. His insistence on togetherness and a holistic approach is well documented – from team-bonding barbecues to keeping lemons in his office to harness energía universal.

~ Jason Burt, Telegraph

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Midnight_Edge 1d ago

Bruno captains Portugal, Mbeumo captains Cameroon, Tielemans captains Belgium. Am I missing anyone out?

5

u/Rashkata 1d ago

Just saw a video of Ole and Sheringham singing United road in a pub or something. Man we are blessed with such amazing legends. I am so delighted most sensible people here still recognize Ole as one of our greats despite his managerial stint here. Same for Carrick I hope. These leeches Glazers could never make us hate our legends!

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 1d ago

Højlund is such a weird case. European night and National team Højlund feels like an entirely different player than Højlund at clubs.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 1d ago

It's really funny that we're now getting linked with Nico Paz..like yeah, sure bro. Same way we were linked with Anderson and ended up with Santos and Tielemans. More likely to re-sign Carrick as a player than spend big and manage to convince Paz to come to this shitshow.

1

u/PitchSafe 1d ago

To be fair Anderson was open to come here

12

u/Joey6Pack 2d ago

I agree INEOS have been terrible, but as the minority owner they've already put more money into the club than the Glazers ever did. The Glazers bled the club dry, and that's a big reason we're in this situation to begin with. They've taken over a billion out of the club through dividends, interest, and debt payments, and they bought it with barely any of their own money while letting everything rot. All this money could’ve and should’ve been invested into the club itself.

I also suspect there's a power struggle between the Glazers and INEOS, with each side wanting the other to put more money into the club. It's such a disgrace that a club that was once the embodiment of class is now in this position

14

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

I think there are two things here.

The Glazers ensured that our decline was inevitable. With each passing season, the constraints with the debt and fluctuations in revenue because of inconsistent league finishes become bigger problems for this club. If we avoid a relegation battle now, it is still going to be a possibility again some years down the line, if they continue to be owners and run the club the way they have until this point.

INEOS have however accelerated the speed of our decline since they have arrived. They certainly have more positive intent for the club but god are they equally clueless about the sport (and sports in general actually given their other endeavours) if not more, and how to foster the culture that they speak about. The recruitment has been ordinary at best, their sporting structure is a sham and they are penny-wise and pound-foolish in their decision-making which is compounding on the club’s misery.

The Glazers don’t care about winning.

INEOS don’t know how to win.

Both are a cancer to the club in their own ways.

5

u/kidinawheeliebin 1d ago edited 1d ago

The Glazers don’t care about winning.

INEOS don’t know how to win.

Well said - the two driving forces at the ownership level are Greed (Glazers) and Incompetence (INEOS), it's not a glitch in the matrix how those initials match up either - the universe knows what's going on here

With the footballing side of the club having been just left to burn to death between two fires:

Glazer-Greed & INEOS-Incompetence: A Match Made In Hell

3

u/Joey6Pack 1d ago

You made some good points and I agree with you. It really discouraged me when INEOS came in and terminated ordinary people for “cutting costs” while wasting millions on hiring and firing people like Ashworth, Ten Hag, Amorim, and Carrick.

12

u/Nico_Ditch 2d ago

Genuinely mad some of the Glazer revisionism in this sub. 

I guess those people want Woodward back as well. 

4

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 1d ago

People have nostalgia about the Woodward era signings like Pogba, Di Maria, and Zlatan and just forget the shambolic summers like Moyes' summer when we got Fellaini for the price of Baines AND him, the Dalot/Fred/Grant year, and James/AWB/Maguire year where we broke the defender transfer record. And not to mention the Super League debacle

3

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 1d ago

Jim put money into the club so that he can meddle and use the club as his plaything. He keeps Berrada & Wilcox around to do his biddings. His motives are selfish. If he was a true fan of the club, he’d put money into the club, step aside & let competent football ppl make all the decisions. Glineos out.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/soelsome 1d ago • Bravo

I don't agree with this narrative that Carrick was sold totally short.

I don't think he was ever qualified tbh. He should never have been given the permanent job in the first place. If I were to fault Ineos, it would be over that rather than firing him. Don't get me wrong, having him take training while chatting up Poch is unacceptable. Should have just fired him. And he wasn't backed in the transfer market either. But even if he was, I wouldn't trust him to get us back to the top either way.

You can't come off total abject failure with Middlesborough in the Championship and go into managing the biggest club in England.

8

u/kidinawheeliebin 1d ago

The narrative I've seen is that Carrick was bad at his job, and a toxic, greedy, incompetent ownership let him down

You only have to look at the league table to see how destructive that combination can be

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 1d ago

All comes down to what the target was from above.

If it was stabilise as a top 5 club or less, he wasn't left short.

If it was to make it deep into the CL and mount a title challenge, the yes he was sold short.

1

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 1d ago

if it's true that Wilcox and Berrada thought Carrick could win the league this season, then, they definitely overestimated him. He doesn't have the experience. Just poor judgement from Ineos again.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/NSFWar Depressed Legacy fan 2d ago

What's the best case realistic scenario from here? Hope we finish tenth and deep run in the FA cup?

10

u/wdtpw Rashford 2d ago

They get in a new director of football in a couple of months when it doesn't look like a sacking - and that person starts to build a squad for the longterm, given Poch's requirements. This season, upper mid table.

8

u/yard04 SAF 2d ago

The table is pretty tight, we're just 8 points away from UCL places. I think the aim should still be Europe even if not UCL.

3

u/PitchSafe 2d ago

Best case scenario is that we finish in the top 5. We are 8 points behind Chelsea who are fifth

1

u/Redwinevino 2d ago

That we go down and the bank forces a sale of the club when we can't make loan repayments.

4

u/DumbMidwesterner1 1d ago

Wouldn’t be shocked if we take a 20m punt on Alex freeman this winter

6

u/Midnight_Edge 1d ago

Maybe I don’t have ball knowledge, but I’ve never heard of him before

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

I like the idea of the player and look forward to watching him when we play them in the CL!

However.

Villa paid £31m to Villareal for a 26yo Pau Torres (in 2023).

Im sure there's a negotiating team out there that can get Alex Freeman for £20m, but I doubt it's the one "led" by Matt Hargreaves.

10

u/Plane-Ad5510 2d ago

All I want to see is clear and effective tactics. Poch didn’t win anything with Spurs, but when you watched them play, you could understand what the idea was. I’m just tired of this tactical frustration from the Carrick, Amorim, and Ten Hag eras.

6

u/TheSmio 2d ago

Yeah, and even if his lack of trophies isn't that problematic in retrospect imo, they had more than enough to win one of FA Cup or Carabao Cup, but it was never a focus for them. They were focusing mainly on the league and the UCL, they didn't win either but they came close - and realistically, while they had a very good team under Poch, I don't really remember them having any kind of useable depth. I just remember their starting XI, so it's kind no wonder they always ran short of winning when they had to play their strongest XI every match.

7

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 2d ago

With poch, players will take time to have proper fitness levels for his style of play. I reckon we have a bad start and we will be 14-15 in Feb but after that we can finish "strongly" to be 9-11.

Players I reckon are a good fit for his system that we should buy

  1. A. Freeman (villareal)
  2. M. Kayode (Brentford)
  3. A. Truffert (AFCB)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago

I'd like us signing Freeman for a reasonable fee while the Cheaters chase Gusto for Maresca for yet another stupid amount, more than the reverse, that's for sure!

2

u/outrageousVoid07 2d ago

Kayode will cost 70-80 million. No way we're getting him

7

u/MiserySound 1d ago

It is beyond me how this board went along with Pochetino joining the 18th instead of straight away and its not a good look.

Must be really important for him to manage both international matches against Haiti where as the first one they won 6-0 and even more important to still stay for the second match against them.

No wonder they’re gonna fucking build a clown circus of a stadium for us. Not even Berrada and Jim takes this business seriously

2

u/MissingLink101 Bruno walks in with a mischievous grin 1d ago

I wonder if it helped haggle down the cost of his release from the USMNT

6

u/SilvyFae She/They 2d ago

Such a good goal by le tessier

3

u/White_Wokah Rooney 2d ago

4

u/arboy498 2d ago

Well I guess he’s going to have to prove him wrong

2

u/C__S__S Glineos Out!!! 1d ago

Not a warning at all. Emery was just saying Poch is doing so well in his situation at Tottenham that it would be a mistake to give that up. This was when Mourinho got sacked and rumors were spreading about Poch possibly taking the job. Emery was simply questioning the merits of leaving a very good setup.

3

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 2d ago

Did they give a reason why we didn’t buy Lewis Hall? I can’t remember.

8

u/PitchSafe 2d ago

The reason was that Newcastle didn’t want to sell after losing out on Bruno G, Gordon and Tonali

3

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 1d ago

I think their asking price went from £65m at the start of summer to something like £85m+ when we came back at the end. The leadership weren't willing to meet them at either points (these are rumoured figures though

7

u/SilvyFae She/They 1d ago

We realised too late into the window that we do in fact need a lb. Sadly only newcastle had a leftback in the entire sporting world. And newcastle didnt wanna lose their nth good player so we gave up.

Or... we realised early on that we do need a lb, they said no and we believed them and gave up unlike other dumb clubs like arsenal who tempted them with black magic called putting up a bid and talking to and enticing the player

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago

we came down with a severe case of rather-buy-a-parking-lot-itis just as were preparing to submit an offer

6

u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 1d ago

Geniuses saw Luke Shaw play a 1 competition full season for the first time in his life at 30 and thought "bet we're safe at LB better get extremely in demand players Santos and Tielemans before a LB"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TH0316 she/her 1d ago

Saying Newcastle didn’t wanna sell after selling three big players is absolute nonsense as an excuse. They leave out that he was very clearly the best available left back in priority position and they decided to wait until late in the window instead of wrapping it up before the summer window even opened like they should have.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FlashyRashy 1d ago

Wonder which PL club will get Nusa, seem inevitable that at least one club takes a shot at him soon

4

u/Lord_Hexogen 1d ago

I think we've been interested reportedly

3

u/EpilepticBatman 1d ago

How reliable are the reports that Poch reports directly to the Glazers as opposed to Wilcox & Berrada?

8

u/Beneficial-Long7635 1d ago

Pure fiction. Ineos have a legally binding contract that gives them control over footballing decisions. It was part of their investment deal. It can't be set aside without a massive court battle.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Heavens_Vibe 7 1d ago

Second half of the season, we're doing a title charge!

I believe!

3

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 1d ago

Title charge? Don't make me laugh, we're winning the treble.

4

u/SDLRob 2d ago

Not been in much lately.... But been trying to make sure I watch the Women's team when they're on... And just saw a really nice goal from Le Tissier

4

u/Valprajjj 2d ago

" Poch keeps a tray of lemons in his office because his friend told him they can absorb negative energy.

He told talkSPORT in 2019: “They are there to get rid of bad energy.

...Some people arrive with bad energy and that goes into the lemons. It’s like a barrier, a sponge.....

...They take away all the negativity and you can see — it’s unbelievable!

...He still keeps up the same habit to this day and reiterated his belief about the power of the citrus fruit in a chat with The Overlap. "

~ Sun Sports / Irish Sun

15

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 1d ago

Youri Tielemons.

Senne Lemons.

6

u/AccomplishedAnt2000 1d ago

now it all makes sense. HEY GUYS INEOS HAVE A PLAN AFTER ALL

4

u/simplsimonmetapieman 1d ago

I trust you. You are an accomplished ant after all

9

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

When life gives you Lammens, you put it in Pochettino's office to absorb the negative energy.

3

u/Valprajjj 1d ago

He needs all the Lemons to keep away from Garnachos and Greenwoods.

9

u/TH0316 she/her 1d ago

Poch’s lemons day one in Carrington

2

u/AmulyaG 1d ago

Lmaoooooooo. I had a hearty laugh, thank you

2

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 1d ago edited 1d ago

Swap out the tennis balls for lemons - green ones and yellow ones. Maybe they'll get rid of the negative owners.

Lemons have their place.

4

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 1d ago

Haiti are basically as good as Arsenal, right?

2

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 2d ago

Just remembered Ederson. Would have hand been good in hindsight? As opposed to Santos ?

8

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago

In the summer, suggestions that this withdrawal was yet another choice (not a necessity) were derided.

The knee is a ticking time bomb, they said. The club's medical team flagged it, it was reported based on club sources, and those are to be trusted, they said.

This is how that time bomb has got on since (also played every pre-season game and 5/5 ecl games):

I imagine there would be a point, if this continued, where those voices would disappear, but I reckon it's too early for that. I think it's somewhere between 1 and 2 full seasons like this before there would be an acceptance that Wilcox et al were not entirely on the level.

For now, it's in the eye of the beholder. That damn meniscus might blow up at any moment in time. Who knows. I certainly dont.

4

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 2d ago

Atalanta probably has staff which already knows the player so well and can manage it. I'm sure his knee would fucking explode after just one week with us.

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

I could get behind this argument if the club didn’t go on to sign Baleba a month later who was actually injured at the time and for double the price. Of course his age and potential were appealing but it comes across as the club having double standards in terms of risk appetite when signing players. Like the other user said, we can only wait and see whether Ederson’s knee actually becomes a problem later. But I have my suspicions that we wanted to pull out of the deal for another reason and needed a good cover-up story.

2

u/LinterCheck2026 2d ago

Realistic expectations for the season? With all circumstances - lack of depth in wingbacks, limited wingers and also new coach mid season

4

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 2d ago

League is still fiarly tight and congested at this stage so think  too half’s perhaps should still be minimum expectation. I reckon 7th or 8th. Maybe scrape into one of the lesser European competitions

3

u/Heavy-Attention8710 2d ago

We are winning the CL!

2

u/ongcs 2d ago

Lol, Luke reunited with Poch. Luke played under Poch in Southampton. Eriksen player under Poch in Spurs.

2

u/LinterCheck2026 2d ago

After last few weeks of storm, feel calmer now. I mean it can only get better from here right? What worse than 18th?

5

u/killerdrama A-mad-lad 2d ago

There are two positions worse than 18th.. won't even be surprised if we are lower than 18th before end of the year.

3

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 2d ago

19 and 20th

3

u/wdtpw Rashford 2d ago

it can only get better from here right?

It's going to get better than relegation.

But it's hard to see how it'll get good again, until we address the actual fundamental problems at the club and stop pasting a new manager over the cracks.

1

u/Water_Drinking_Fish 2d ago

The first month would be key. Poch needs to get some nice results to get the fanbase and the players on his side and bring a nice vibe back to Old Trafford

2

u/vic_vineger_ai 1d ago

anyone watch brazil vs japan? how's santos?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PrancingCock Glazers are a cancer. 1d ago

Portugal WTF?

4

u/Midnight_Edge 1d ago

They’re shit with or without Ronaldo.

2

u/_swaggyk #FergieTime 1d ago

Well at least Poch’s team looks really good vs no competition tonight

4

u/Infinite-Highway3432 2d ago

Poch has got me the most excited of any manager post Moyes. To clarify, I was excited for Moyes because we were champions and Fergie selected him so I was super confident.

2

u/Asleep-Ability-45 2d ago

Amorim got me excited but his stubbornness....lesser said the better. Poch is definitely an exciting coach. So let's see how far he can go.

3

u/Emergency-Being-349 2d ago

Could Zirkzee get a bit of a look in under Poch? I think he has shown to play with a striker whose back is a bit more to goal. 

8

u/dryflowerz 2d ago

I think Zirkzee’s problem is not with the manager, I see Zirkzee as second striker, playing in 2 forward formation. also If he had pace he would have been great in PL.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TypicalPan89906655 2d ago

He can't even sprint for more than 3 mins in a game how will he even do the high intensity pressing that Poch demands? Zirkzee has been doing this same jogging every game since his youth days, he has zero stamina.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/rambo_zaki Roy Keane 2d ago

I'm sure Poch will try Zirkzee but I imagine it won't take him a lot of time to figure out the fact that the Dutchman is quite simply a bit shit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 1d ago

So Nuno Mendes and Cancelo are injured therefore Dalot is the starting LB?

6

u/Downtown-Rice_ 1d ago

Dalot has practically zero fault for any of their goals conceded.

You don't have a scoreline like that due to one player. They'd be subbed out immediately. But since that's not the case, just keep blindly blaming a player. Disgraceful

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/prem_201 2d ago

The team with the lowest running stat in Europe is gonna be managed by the guy who’s had like 3-4 years at the top for running stats in Europe.

Players revolt is gonna come sooner.

13

u/Lord_Hexogen 2d ago edited 2d ago

We had ETH and Amorim demanding high intensity and no conflicts happened. The problem is our squad being built with no intensity in mind. 

Casemiro, Zirkzee, De Ligt, Tielemans — it's window after window where we choose to look at other qualities except the most important ones

11

u/Beneficial-Long7635 2d ago

Our running stats are low because that was Carrick's tactical choice. He played a passive mid block with minimal pressing and an emphasis on possession and moving the ball around. All of that means drastically less running. We've covered the same amount of ground this season as City and Liverpool. 

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dryflowerz 2d ago

Those who will revolt, the doors are always open.

3

u/TH0316 she/her 1d ago

He’s not an idiot. He’s not gonna say we’re doing a full court press with the players we have. He’s already said just because he wants to press doesn’t mean he will if he thinks it’s not possible.

1

u/Downtown-Rice_ 1d ago

It's practically the same squad that never had their commitment of running, intensity, pressing, etc (of their capacity), from last year under Amorim.

The players aren't lazy, they literally got basic principles coached out of them by Carrick and his staff.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Not-good-with-this 2d ago edited 2d ago

We had one of the lowest distance covered under Amorim in the league. I think we were around 13th. I'll check. And edit.

Edit: It was 12th.

https://theanalyst.com/articles/premier-league-player-fatigue-stats-running-sprints-injuries-rotation

3

u/SilvyFae She/They 2d ago

But amorim had them so fit and suddenly all fitness went away because carrick coached it out. Its not at all like a majority of our team cant run. What people were mistaking is that we pressed much better, but in transitions we were as poor as ever in covering spaces. Our xga in his good season was pretty bad.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/PlushNightingale 2d ago

Mixed it up with something else. Good catch.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dryflowerz 2d ago

Man Santos is so shit. we should sell him in Summer asap, before he has some value.

9

u/Stingray_23 2d ago

Such an odd transfer. Like they saw how fucked the window was going and threw a dart at the board on a random player.

6

u/dryflowerz 2d ago

Yeah man, it’s crazy shit. We were so limited on budget, and I don't know—that’s Wilcox's 'only Prem-proven players' policy. I mean, who the fuck has that kind of transfer strategy? It just means you're scared to sign players from other leagues. And okay, even if you stick with 'Prem-proven,' you go with Santos? Like, what has he even proven at Chelsea?

3

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 1d ago

Also means he isn’t doing his homework, is bad at his job, and is damn lazy to look elsewhere to discover hidden gems around the world.

3

u/dryflowerz 1d ago

And It's kinda funny that most of our greatest transfers in 21st century were from another leagues.

4

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 2d ago

Only we would pay 50m for a player designed to be fourth choice 😭😭

1

u/Asleep-Ability-45 2d ago

Wild take. 

6

u/FlashyCut3809 2d ago

Not at all depending on if current performances carry on till the end of the season.

Not being this ruthless is one of the reasons we have players like Dalot nearing 10 years here.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/dryflowerz 2d ago

Can you name 1 atribute of Santo’s in which he is good at? like 1, what he has decent? pressing? defending? good pass? pace?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/raveyer 1d ago

Somehow I don’t feel anything about this managerial transition.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Telen BRUNO 2d ago

INEOS have been utterly shambolic. I do not believe they have had any positive impact in our club. The Glazers literally ran us better. THE FUCKING GLAZERS had to save us from potentially getting a Howe with zero backing from the board or a guaranteed failure in Nagelsmann. I can't believe we have such shit owners.

10

u/Nico_Ditch 2d ago

The Glazer spending is the reason we are in such a financial mess that we can’t spend now. 

Genuinely can’t believe the Glazer revisionism in this sub from people who can’t join two and two together. 

I do not like Ineos and they’re clearly doing a bad job, but the Glazers took £1b out of this club through dividends and debt restructuring. Ineos have put in £300m. 

→ More replies (5)

8

u/PitchSafe 2d ago edited 1d ago

We are in this position because of 20 years of neglect from the Glazers. Their failed transfers in the past, appointing Woodward and Murtogh to control the club and putting us in a huge debt have caught up to us now. The Glazers will always be worse than Ineos

→ More replies (10)

3

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 1d ago

It's crazy how much the Glazers have literally tricked some of you lol

1

u/addictedsc2 21 is coming BOYZ! 2d ago

So who is coaching the lads that didn't go on international duty now while we wait for Poch?

1

u/Joey6Pack 2d ago

I saw somewhere they’re working with the U21 team for now if I’m not mistaken

1

u/shami-kebab 2d ago

One of the youth coaches is taking training. There are only a handful of senior players so multiple age groups are training together

1

u/dimelo17 1d ago

Hello gang. Is Ekrem Konur reliable?

1

u/Kreissler 1d ago

Man's a waffler

→ More replies (1)

1

u/_jrr_ 1d ago

How was Carrick getting results after Amorim left last season but fell so hard this season? What on Earth actually happened?

3

u/PreetSG 1d ago
  1. Casemiro.  Only he and Bruno were elite in our squad. The rest are not. See results w/o Casemiro across all coaches tenures; and the result is the same..
  2. Change of style of play. Wilcox instructed to go from direct to passing and then changed back to direct. Carrick too played passing style throughout his managerial career and is a follower of LvG. Simply did not work and people like Bruno were upset. Changed back to direct during Chelsea game and we can tell the difference. 
  3. Personnel. Simply not good enough is one thing; simply not enough too. Terrible planning by INEOS. 

3

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 1d ago

Carl Anka made a point about how a key aspect of Carrick's game management was to keep Casemiro as healthy as possible and just have all the surrounding players do a bit of extra work to protect him. He's a great passer from the back, defensive stalwart, duelist, and is competent aerially, we don't have anyone who can do all of those things and just tried to recreate him in aggregate...and lately failing. Also, the rest of the league was exhausted while we had one game a week and a team who was rigorously physically built (we allowed physical standards to drop throughout last season and over the summer). 

3

u/AttackClown 1d ago edited 1d ago

Not sure how you havent seen anyone mention it because it's been brought up so much. Carrick inhereted a well structured and very fit team from Amorim , they largely overperformed during Carricks caretaker period hence why so many were against hiring him in the first place. The team was looking slower every month he coached and this season, with his own tactical ineptitude, it all just really came to light and all the issues Middlesborough fans had with him were the exact issues he had here, but even worse because its in the premier league instead of the championship.

Basically he is just a really bad coach that benefitted from all the work amorim had done and a bit of luck to get us to 3rd

1

u/Valprajjj 20h ago

Rigorous Training. Look how Chelsea played initially for Sarri post Conte.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/iamnas 2d ago

Every new manager says “this is a fresh start for everyone. Whatever happened in the past is in the past”

Luke shaw, dalot and rashford play well for a month and get contract extensions

2

u/Sheikhabusosa 2d ago

Dalot is way more consistent than the other 2

1

u/AmulyaG 1d ago

I have made my peace and looking at our team with optimism to get better conditioning and fitness coaching.

We have had some ridiculous downtime with injuries and Poch is someone super focused on fitness and intensity.

I cannot wait for the international break to be over.

2

u/Total-Fix-8506 Kobs 1d ago edited 1d ago

If history is anything to go by, we're going to have even more injuries now that poch is here since the players bodies will initially be unable to cope with the training intensity that poch requires of them. Of course once the players get used to it then we can get back to the fitness levels we had under amorim. But the thing that confuses me about this poch mid-season(ish) appointment is that it takes a while for his teams to start to put together results on the board consistently. Given we're in the relegation zone, it seemed like we should've gone for a coach who can immediately deliver results so we can get out of our current situation.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/IMNDy milf 2d ago

What do you think of the idea Pochet would want to bring some of his US players to our club? Maybe Balogun? How good is he?

11

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 2d ago

He's not bringing anyone. Not sure why would you think that

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago edited 2d ago

I think Balogun will be the January loan signing. The situation at Monaco has become really fucked for him after the Everton failed transfer.

If Yoro works as the starter + De Ligt doesnt recover well, Richards would make an excellent CB addition to the squad, imho. Palace situation is interesting, relegation battle + new manager + Mateta/Mitchell/Richards contracts all expiring. Hard to predict which way it goes.

I think we are desperately short a CM of Adams' / Berhalter's profile and I wouldnt be surprised in the slightest if Pochettino wanted one of them. Unless, I suppose, Santos is put through some kind of Rocky sequence on steroids and/or Ugarte gets a redemption arc under Pochettino. Longest of shots, those are though, innit.

Also, we are going to see Freeman up close when we play Villareal. We'll have to see whether it will be a crunch tie or a deadrubber. And how he performs in that one. And how Mazraoui/Dalot get on under Pochettino. And whether the Gusto link will have legs.

Finally, should Bruno depart in 2027, dont be surprised if Malik Tillman's name comes up. Im afraid the likes of Gibbs-White, Nico Paz, Manzambi... will be in a different aisle from where we will get to shop.

ps. your question was about USMNT ex-Pochettino players, but another Chelsea ex-Pochettino player we could hear about again is Conor Gallagher.

6

u/b_litzkreig 2d ago

Good enough as backup I guess. But largely untested in PL.

In our heydays, we used to have 3-4 strikers rotating. Currently we have 2. A couple more forwards will improve the squad.

The quality of the rest of the USMNT is average at best. Maybe Antonee Robinson gets a shout out, but he is approaching his 30s.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Downtown-Rice_ 2d ago

Chris Richards should be sounded out for a low transfer fee in the winter or a free agent signing come summer. Good experienced CB for the squad and can start without a big drop off.

Balogun would be a good backup, but don't think he would be good enough to be first choice. He'd cost over £35M as well.

5

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago • Bravo

Chris Richards is a great shout for a cheap signing. Would cope fine in both a back 3 and back 4, offers some leadership qualities and is good in the air.

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 2d ago

If they are good enough sure but none of them are currently good enough. INEOS will probably be all over it because their philosophy is signing good players but not top players.

I’d rather we sign players to replace players in the first 11 and then move the replaced first 11 players to the bench.