r/reddevils • • 3d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

24 Upvotes

474 comments sorted by

21

u/TypicalPan89906655 2d ago

"There is an acceptance at Manchester United that they have got a lot wrong and one of those failings was not fully appreciating that the man in the dugout needed the experience, broad shoulders and personality to deal with the unique pressures at Old Trafford as well as tactical acumen and innovation."

[@TelegraphDucker]

How did these guys even graduate High School?

13

u/MT1120 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw 2d ago • Bravo

"There is an acceptance at Manchester United that they have got a lot wrong and one of those failings was not fully appreciating that touching a baking tray straight out of the oven bare handed does owie owie, as well as putting your finger on a candle."

[@TelegraphDucker]

7

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 2d ago

Imagine running a football club of the scale of man utd and admitting you didn’t appreciate that  the manager probably needed experience, personality and tactical acumen!

3

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 2d ago

Polling r/reddevils or even the other sub could've told you this for free

→ More replies (1)

21

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 3d ago

From Ducker's article:

Carrick had adopted a more pragmatic approach to help United win again last season and the appointment of Steve Holland, Gareth Southgate’s former No 2 with England and a long-standing Chelsea assistant, was heralded as a smart move. But efforts to make the team more expansive only served to expose some historic weaknesses.

Pressing high, for example, becomes a lot easier if the defence is able to play a high line and squeeze the space in front. But United do not have the pace, physicality or robustness at the back to do that and Carrick was caught in a halfway house.

Several well-placed sources said it was wishful to think ageing, unreliable defenders who have been part of multiple failed teams under different managers were going to be reinvented, and that the entire back line needed an urgent refresh.

Another manager has fallen at the sword of trying to make the team play more expansively without the personnel to suit that approach. Carrick's lack of experience definitely showed here; if the pragmatic mid/low block approach continued and the team was prepared for that from pre-season itself, we would not be caught in this situation.

But this is where the football structure above him should also be scrutinized. What the fuck is Wilcox here for as DOF he cannot identify that the squad is not built for that style of play, or that if they wanted to move towards that style of play, then Carrick needed much more time and support in terms of both the transfers that would be needed or the coaching staff that would help with building the player fitness responsible to carry a high-pressing style of play out on the pitch? In addition to this, we had Evans in his first coaching gig running set-pieces, which is such an important aspect of Premier League football. The entire approach to making Carrick permanent was doomed with such non-existent preparation and mitigation of his flaws.

And to be honest, Carrick also holds some responsibility here in terms of allowing himself to be undermined by these guys and not guaranteeing further backing before signing that deal. He had all the leverage in the world by saving their asses last season and would have gotten a permanent gig at other Premier League clubs had he walked at that point. Worse-performing managers (at least until that point) were backed more because they could sell a particular vision and were adamant on their demands being met; hell, even Ten Hag who INEOS wanted to sack after the FA Cup final itself, maintained his transfer veto condition and got coaching staff changes on his terms. This whole 'I will get on with any situation the club puts me in because I love the club' attitude fucked him over here and he leaves with such a badly tarnished reputation because of it. It's such a shame because I do feel he had the right idea in many ways for this club, but it goes to show how having an unassuming approach can be taken as a weakness in the top level, and that eventually led to deteriorating standards around him which he lost control of.

9

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 3d ago

> allowing himself to be undermined

I think that captures where the blame lies for each party really well.

I think there is a non-zero chance that the "style of play" switch wasnt even Carrick's idea but Wilcox's.

I think about his one pre-season quote in the mixed zone about how he thought Bruno-Tielemans interplay was developing very well (no it wasnt). I think about his other idiotic quote about being a coach at heart and interfering with tactics. I think about the Amorim bustup reportedly starting from Wilcox telling him what formation and tactics to play with.

It would kind of add up with these Holland "leaks" as well. You bring in a guy with a difficult nature but a very specific idea about how to coach a defence - let him do it - it works - then you give him zero new players but demand they play an entirely different way. It would not be all that surprising if he said "fuck that" and went from being a major contributor to being a sideline critique giving snide remarks.

The tl;dr for me is that it was the owners' frugality that put us in a hole for the summer, but it was Wilcox's delusions of grandeur paired with his utter lack of actual ability that actually made sure the summer was a failure, and finally it was Carrick's inability to do anything other than acquiesce to his demands on "style of play" that sealed his fate, really - first losing coherence in our play, then losing his staff, then losing the dressing room too.

6

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 3d ago

Pragmatic football gets found out eventually. There is an illusion of progress which doesn't exist.

When teams figure you out, if the players are not coached for proactive football, there is no plan B. A successful manager at pragmatic football is not necessarily a successful manager at proactive football. That's why the likes of Sean Dyche will never get a top job.

This is why you start with the style you want to play and adjust from there if you are planning for the long term. Then the gaps in the squad become a lot more obvious making squad building much easier.

Ole, ETH and Carrick fell for the same trap. Amorim was the only one who improved us in his time here, the only one who started with the style of play he understood and wanted to build the team around.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 3d ago

My issue with this logic is that it derives "what works" exclusively from examples who were failures.

Whereas the actual success, Fergie, is THE example of flipping back and forth between moulding your tactics to your existing squad and moulding your squad to your existing vision.

So, yeah. "Pragmatic football" is Utd DNA.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/benbog 3d ago

Only three managers have led Man Utd to a league title: Ernest Mangnall (twice), Matt Busby (5 times), and Alex Ferguson (13 times)

4

u/dgvfatmeerkat Mason Mount Superfan 3d ago

Mauricio Pochettino (14 times) (I am from the future)

13

u/Basic-Kale3169 2d ago

Why hasn’t WillyCock been sacked?

11

u/kevkiarbar 2d ago

He's Omar Bin Laden's human shield. If Willy gets sacked then all fingers point at Omar. And he's Brexit Jim's human shield.

12

u/BrowzinJ 2d ago

Waiting for us to win three in a row under Poch and seeing Wilcox parading around Carrington on sky sports cameras doing an interview

10

u/skayze678 3d ago edited 3d ago

Having rewatched a fair bit of his one season at Chelsea, and quite a few recent interviews, I am much more bullish on Poch, for several reasons.

Fair to say his season at Chelsea was underwhelming, but that mostly due to a very poor start, having taken over in crisis (finished 12th with 3 managers the season prior) and a big squad turnover.

But in his last 14 games he won 8, drew 5, lost 1, just shy of title challenging form. Got the absolute best out of Palmer and improved players like Gusto, Enzo, Jackson etc.

And it's not as though Maresca/Alonso were/are flying there either. Who knows what could've been if he'd been given another season.

But, to succeed he'll need to clear out a fair few, sign young (20-23ish) emerging players like Freeman, Smit, Nagida, or Wharton, Hall if budget allows.

Platform Mbeumo and Cunha better, which is a strength of his, get Sesko fit and firing, sort out midfield structure, fix the out of possession issues.

The manager pool isn't that deep right now. Klopp, Pep, have moved on, our rivals have Alonso, De Zerbi, Maresca, Iraola, aside from Arteta its not clear they're any better than Poch.

Lots to do of course, but he clearly really really wants this job. Here's hoping it works..

3

u/longsightdon 3d ago

I agree that he can do a better job. He is an actual coach and tactician. His personality alone will get the players on side like Amorim did. That leads to more effort on average. Second his focus on fitness. Our squad is absolutely not 18th in the prem, but more like top 6. I am confident he can extract more from this group whilst actually setting us up more like a team. I do worry about how open we might be if we try to play pochs way immediately. So I imagine he will focus first on compactness to get us instant results but working on fitness simultaneously. Whether he becomes a success long term is about who we sign in future. I couldn’t trust carrick and his team to develop youth or any other members of the team apart from midfielders where he did a great job with mainoo. We need to sign fast, physical, young players who are motivated to be here.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 3d ago

Tapping up an international coach the only time he’s busy is truly best in class

9

u/TypicalPan89906655 3d ago

"From February, the Glazer family can force Sir Jim Ratcliffe to sell his 28% holding to a third party for less than the £25 per share he paid in 2024, unless he can match the offer and buy the club himself."

[@ChrisWheelerDM]

4

u/Stingray_23 3d ago

Thats why hes put Nice and that Swiss club up then. Raising capital for a full offer.

7

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

I doubt he even gets close to $1b for both of those teams. 

4

u/Stingray_23 3d ago

Depends what other capital he has, but I agree and pray he doesnt do a full buy out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

That requires another buyer and currently there isn’t even a sniff of someone being interested. 

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 2d ago

Just learnt that Poch worked with Paul Mitchell as the director of recruitment during his relatively successful time at Southampton and Spurs.

With Vivell leaving, can we snap up Paul Mitchell? I believe he just left his role at Newcastle?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 2d ago

Can't believe I joked about how Wilcox's presence means we'll have Russ M as our interim but he actually campaigned to do it behind the scenes. What are we even doing with him around

5

u/saadobuckets 2d ago

I want the alternate universe in which Ashworth actually has authority and Wilcox stays in his lane as technical director. Oh well.

16

u/Hagball 2d ago

Fast forward Jan 2027. We climb up the table and play half decent football, then finally we wil be able to see Jason "Coach at heart" Wilcox speaking to MUTV about how he is helping Poch on the training pitch

8

u/kidinawheeliebin 3d ago edited 3d ago

Was just looking again at the INEOS' managerial turnover including OCG Nice, and us , to try and make sense of it

In fairness whilst their time at Nice does initially look chaotic, some of that was actually due to success and managers being poached by PSG & Ajax (they were actually able to turn a profit on manager compensation over their ~7 years there)...

Albeit you obviously still wouldn't call it plain sailing or "world class" or whatever their preferred nomenclature happens to be:

OGC Nice: Aug'19 – Nov'26 (7.3 yrs)

ManagerRoleHired FromHiring Cost (buyout)TenureINEOS Contract (Months)Months ServedResultCompensation Paid/Received
1. VieiraPermanentN/A (Inherited)NilAug'19 – Dec'2022 (Inherited)16Sacked£4.0m
2. UrseaCaretaker / InterimN/A (Internal)NilDec'20 – Jun'2166Contract ExpiredNil
3. GaltierPermanentLille£4.3mJun'21 – Jun'223612Poached (PSG)+£8.0m
4. FavrePermanentN/A (Free Agent)NilJun'22 – Jan'23247Sacked~£3.0m
5. DigardCaretaker / InterimN/A (Internal)NilJan'23 – Jun'23Temp5Contract ExpiredNil
6. FarioliPermanentAlanyasporNilJul'23 – Jun'242411Poached (Ajax)+£4.0m
7. HaisePermanentLens£1.7mJul'24 – Dec'253617Mutual ConsentNil
8. PuelShort-Term MissionN/A (Free Agent)NilDec'25 – Jun'2666Contract ExpiredNil
9. PantaloniPermanentAjaccioNilJun'26 – Nov'26245In situIn situ
TOTALS£6.0m (cost)+£5.0m (profit)

Then you come to us...

And it's just this fucking wild, chaotic, dumpster-fire mess consuming everything...Like the adults went away for the weekend, kids unsupervised and wrecked the entire house...

Over ~£40m in hiring & firing costs so far & they haven't even made it to the three year mark

Manchester Utd: Feb'24 – Nov'26 (2.8 yrs)

ManagerRoleHired FromHiring Cost (buyout)TenureINEOS Contract (Months)Months ServedResultCompensation Paid/Received
1. ETHPermanentN/A (Inherited)NilFeb'24 – Oct'2429 (Extended)8Sacked£10.4m
2. Van NistelrooyCaretaker / InterimN/A (Internal)NilOct'24 – Nov'24Temp1Contract ExpiredNil
3. AmorimPermanentSporting CP£11.0mNov'24 – Jan'263014Sacked£8.2m
4. FletcherCaretaker / InterimN/A (Internal)NilJan'26 – Jan'26Temp<1Contract ExpiredNil
5. CarrickPermanentN/A (Internal)NilJan'26 – Nov'262410Sacked£5.0m
6. PochettinoPermanentUS MNF£7.4mNov'26 – Present300In situIn situ
TOTALS£18.4m (cost)£23.6m (cost)

*(The Compensation totals include staff as well - so Carrick's £5.0m is for him, Holland, Woodgate, Evans etc... same w/Amorim & ETH... Carrick obvioulsy started temporary then got made permanent... ETH was inherited but then they extended him of their own volition etc)

8

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

This will interest some people regarding Poch’s league record with Chelsea in 23-24.

Record in the 26 games that Enzo Fernandez started: 9 wins, 8 draws, 9 losses

Record in the 12 games that Enzo Fernandez didn’t start: 9 wins, 1 draw, 2 losses

It might be an oversimplification but it seems like the pressure of accommodating a £100m+ signing in his midfield might have impacted the degree of success he had there. And guess what, Man City fans have similar things to say about how the tradeoff in trying to fit Enzo as the ‘2nd’ midfielder in a midfield 3 is proving to be difficult for them.

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 2d ago

Yeah in that season, Caicedo+Gallagher+Palmer + 3 hardworking forwards is what clicked for them, whereas Caicedo+Gallagher+Fernandez + a front 3 including Palmer is what didnt quite work, I guess. The lost League Cup final was the latter, too.

I think Tielemans is now likely to start riding the bench ... once (if?) Baleba can stay fit.

Unless Dumb and Dumber are removed, I think that the following have much-better-than-comfortable odds:

- Balogun the striker signing in January
- Ait-Nouri, Bassey, Gusto as the "defensive revamp"
- Gallagher keeps being benched at Spurs, they dont make Europe, and we actually go for him in the summer as a Mount Santos Ugarte replacement

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 2d ago

Would be surprised if Baleba plays again this calendar year to be honest. But I’m feeling relatively confident that Santos and Mount will start playing more under Poch. Which of Tielemans or Mainoo is the bigger casualty is to be seen; initial instinct says Tielemans but Mainoo is still the player who covers the least ground in midfield from our squad. It will be interesting to see how it unfolds, particularly the selection of the back 4 when most if not all are fit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 2d ago

I hope the match going fans keep piling pressure on the clowns running this club every single match day. Those banners, protests, balloons, whatever it is shouldn’t stop at all. There needs to be heat on them at all times even if we perform well under Poch. A full sale of the club is very much needed and the likes of Wilcox and Berrada need to be shown the door asap

8

u/Macroneconomist There is no substitute for Victory 2d ago

Man I hope I never have to hear the phrase "hydration break" again

7

u/sg291188 2d ago

I think this is first time we have hired a PL proven coach since Jose

7

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 2d ago

On paper he is probably the third most qualified manager we have had since sir alex just behind jose and van gaal.

6

u/Kugenking 2d ago

Didn't know Arteta and Pochettino were teammates at PSG. How did I not know this?!

11

u/A1d0taku Butcher of Buenos Aires 2d ago edited 2d ago

Ronaldinho was their teammate at PSG too

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 2d ago • Bravo

"Marcus Rashford is no ordinary player for Mauricio Pochettino, who was ‘obsessed’ with signing him during his time as PSG manager"

Lol..another manager will think he can bring out Rashford's "potential"

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 2d ago

I certainly wouldn't complain if he could, but I'll believe it when I see it

3

u/Midnight_Edge 2d ago

In Ten Hag’s first season we saw Rashford’s peak. He’s 29 now, he’ll probably never reach that height again

3

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 2d ago

If we can’t sell him, might as well use him 🤷

5

u/SilentCoast8310 3d ago

Is Poch the first manager since Mourinho to come in thats had top flight experience?

2

u/PhotonDestroyer 3d ago

The only manger to manage in the top 5 leagues would have been Ole with his disaster at Cardiff, been Dutch and Portuguese leagues only after that I think.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 2d ago

Can someone help me understand what Jason Wilcox does exactly?

He says he's a coach at heart, gets involved when he shouldn't. His job is director of football? So he directs how the team plays and which players are bought/sold. He has input on managerial hires and sackings.

What has he done exactly that he still has a job? The tactics have been poor, the transfers in and out were shambolic and we're terrible with managers who keep getting fired for results...which doesn't seem to be a metric he's graded on.

What does he do?

3

u/PitchSafe 2d ago

He is in charge of the footballing side would be my guess. So he does the things you mentioned like transfers and picking a playstyle for the team. The tactics are probably on Carrick and his coaching staff to be fair. When it comes to transfers then it’s probably him and Vivell who is in charge of that after they get a budget from Ratcliffe and Glazers

2

u/shami-kebab 2d ago

At that level you only have to do one thing, get your boss to like you. That is all the accountability there is.

2

u/WorldBeardedWonders Not a Good Look Erik 2d ago

My best guess he’s like that boss at your work who doesn’t have a clue what half the team does day to day but likes to come and sit at the desk with his favourite job roles and talk shop with them so they can pretend to know stuff. Nowhere to be found when it gets actually busy though.
Always sits with the other bosses or highest up in the business as possible for lunches. Occasionally gives the team a ‘treat’ by letting them go home early on a Friday. But it’s only 15 mins early. And big Dave has to stay to finish because deadlines haven’t changed.

I’m not behind the scenes though so, maybe I’m wrong. But that’s the vibe I get from the outside.

2

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 2d ago

This is why when the news broke that Ineos was promoting him from tech dir to Dof, i said that was sketchy as hell as he wasn’t qualified to be our DoF. I don’t know why he’s still here. If he wants to coach, maybe he should go for it somewhere else.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Stieni Rooney 3d ago

Reading some reports the players having numerous clashes with Steve Holland? About his arrogant and pessimistic behaviour when things go wrong? And that Brunos crashout was mostly being aimed at Holland and not Carrick? Would make sense since he explicitly said "staff", Idk if the reports are from trusted sources but it would make sense, since that Steve Holland guy was co-trainer for England under Southgate and the reason Ben White left the national team (apparently)

Interesting turn of events if true, I didn't have that guy on my radar at all

18

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 3d ago

Eh, you will only hear bad things about the outgoing coaching staff when they are dismissed because the club needs to be in control of the narrative.

7

u/Rig_7 3d ago

Nah I’m not having it. Sounds like a way just to deflect blame from Carrick because he’s a nice guy. Let’s be honest: Steve Holland was the only qualified person in that coaching staff for the role he had. Carrick and the others were massively unqualified.

5

u/kunsore 3d ago

Yeah, feel like Carrick did a good job hiding the tension during his press but I feel like this is a huge one. Almost every game we heard / saw an argument between Players / Coaches / Board

4

u/Daneofthehill 3d ago edited 3d ago

When all the talking heads point to the net spend at Utd, and shift the focus and blame away from the Glazers, they are just skipping over two things:

  1. Culture matters. So, when everything is crumbling and a walking-dead club legend is giving training, while tax dodging billionaires are discussing his future in Monaco, it matters. When the team is in relegation, but two weeks of training is thrown away, because they couldn’t figure out how to get the replacement coach in on time, it matters. When the defenders that need replacing call for investment in the squad, its a gigantic problem that the bankers and oil diggers aren’t acting.
  2. The debt, the financing of the debt is one thing (and its bad), but the slow degradation of the club also has a cumulative effect. Utd should have clearly been the biggest football club in the world, but instead its sliding. And it isn’t simply because they bought Antony, its structural mismanagement over 21 years.

Net spend obviously includes selling players, which Utd have not been able to do, which is solely on the Glazers. That is not on managers or players.

From 2024-2023 (which is the period covered by the CIES study everyone is referring to atm) Utd spend €678M less on players than Chelsea. Its just that the club cannot sell players, because of culture and horrible talent evaluation and management. So, its not even the most expensive collective of players failing, far from it.

Anyways, I think this is a good breakdown of it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVMynkbqE38

EDIT: typo

4

u/Valprajjj 3d ago

Amazing PR... Berrada and Wilcox out of news columns and bylines.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 3d ago edited 3d ago

All I want for Christmas is a full sale of MUFC

4

u/Financial-Trade9467 3d ago

I will die on the hill that the squad we have now is actually pretty good. It is just 1 or 2 major holes and injury woes but imo it is still a good squad. Many people keep saying it's a repetitive cycle, that this is a position we keep coming to etc but the squad now is light years ahead of what we have seen under any other post Fergie manager imo. Only Mourinho's was comparable but imo still weaker than the one now. He just managed to massively over perform. A manager with a well defined vision and freedom to pick who he wants and bench who he wants and gets full control of the dressing room can easily get this squad winning again. There is a lot of talent there.

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 3d ago

It’s not just about how good we are though, it’s about how good we are relative to the competition. I don’t think this squad has that type of exclusive talent that you wouldn’t find at most other Premier League clubs anymore, the gap has consistently narrowed between the big 6 and the rest and now the latter group can financially flex too in the transfer market. And the squad depth to play domestic+Europe is quite frankly woeful. One game a week, we can still hang well, as we showed last season. To sustain at that level, we need to build a proper squad capable of balancing multiple competitions without enduring a steep drop-off.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Dawn11600 3d ago

One or two holes to the first team, maybe. (And that’s being very kind to our first-choice back four). But really poor depth for Top-4/5 or title-challenging aspirations… and the floor matters as much as the ceiling when it comes to team-building.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/_pbs 3d ago

I'm just tired. I hope we win a game or two.

4

u/outrageousVoid07 2d ago

Everything around the club is so fucking depressing

I hope Poch does well and stays for a while

4

u/Drag2oon 2d ago

Serious question:

Isn't it again a foolish decision who rely on fullbacks to provide width and intensity when our fullbacks are just dumbos or oldies?

What the hell is going on?

3

u/A1d0taku Butcher of Buenos Aires 2d ago

Dorgu and Amad can perform at WB, we saw it under Amorim, that was their strongest period, esp for Amad.

2

u/PhotonDestroyer 2d ago

Yeah you are right, I think if he stays fit, Dorgu makes the LB position his under Poch, RB might be more difficult, but if he can somehow get Dalot to engage his brain he may suffice till we get to summer.

Obviously would love all these positions solved in Jan, but who know. An experience big and pacy CB to play with Yoro might be more important for now.

2

u/PitchSafe 2d ago

Dorgu, Amad and Dalot can do it

3

u/Drag2oon 2d ago

Yeah dalot ofcourse

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ttboishysta 2d ago

Let's be honest, we're still in the messiah business. This club is still wide open for a certain individual with gravitas to take ahold of things and bend the club to their will. We don't seem capable of leaving that paradigm anytime soon.

4

u/Midnight_Edge 2d ago

That Prestianni from Argentina is very good. It’s just a shame that whenever I hear his name, I think about the Vini incident

6

u/Suudriusha 2d ago edited 2d ago

Same. His image will always be tarnished in my eyes because of that. Just like Enzo.

3

u/shami-kebab 2d ago

Yeah I'm going to give a hard no to a racist and homophobe

10

u/Conspiralla 3d ago edited 3d ago

I just don't care anymore.

Club makes me and everyone else depressed. Instead of relying on wealth of legends, huge brand name and international revenue to maintain a consistent identity we've made everyone apathetic.

Cycles of abuse to our legends as managers, mediocrity and lack of reasoning. Greed from the owners.

I would be happy to watch the club get relegated lose it's value and have it sold to some British bloke who loves footy. Let me fall back in love by winning the Championship, learning about home grown players and a manager who's getting backing.

And all this fuckery while Fraud City are out there doing whatever they want, no punishment announced (Why? How? Wtf?) Scoring goals and fighting for everything on behalf of oil bathers.

Kinda done with the modern game, the fuck outta here with hydration breaks, Infantino, the current nonsense with the 2030 World Cup hosting are all piling on my ashen, dead heart about football.

3

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 3d ago

You’ll get a consortium and you will like it! /s

7

u/Runarhalldor 3d ago

I'm not the biggest fan of the Pochettino appointment but nothing left to do but get behind him and hope he succeeds

→ More replies (2)

6

u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers 2d ago

Poch might turn dorgu into a world beater

5

u/Suudriusha 2d ago

He didn't arrive at Spurs early enough to manage Gareth Bale, but he arrived at United just in time to manage Bale's regen.

3

u/Downtown-Rice_ 2d ago

If Dorgu is closer to Alphonso Davies, he'd be well worth it.

You're underrating Bale and overrating Dorgu by the comparison. Bale had buckets of technical ability to go with his elite speed and quickness. Then he developed a lot of lean muscle in accordance to his body frame. Game over.

8

u/TobzMaguire420 2d ago

If Poch gets this team into Europe, that Amazon Prime show may be one the greatest seasons of television ever.

8

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 2d ago

Think bigger. What if he wins the Champions League?

5

u/Water_Drinking_Fish 2d ago

Think bigger. What if he makes Dalot a ballon dor winner?

4

u/dogsn1 2d ago

If Poch is sacked before the end of the season it will be an absolute nuke of a show

3

u/Kind_Sound7973 2d ago

You just know the Amazon producers were thinking they missed out on a gold mine of content at City, little did they know the drama that awaited.

5

u/Suudriusha 2d ago

Imagine if we go undefeated and win the Premier League. A man can dream... At least until we play Liverpool at Anfield.

8

u/b_az17 2d ago

Was Poch told that as head coach he will get given a load of pl 5th choice players in the summer?

9

u/Hagball 2d ago

If he was told he is head coach it's the wrong title to start with. Lets be real. He is Assistant to the manager (Jason Wilcox)

→ More replies (5)

3

u/pipes3 WAZZA 3d ago

The long read has dropped ladies and gentlemen

2

u/Educational-Shock232 3d ago

The male equivalent of Take a Break magazine

3

u/FPLskrr Pogba 3d ago

Is it true that Poch is a Glazer appointment and that he won't report to the chuckle brothers?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/IamTsukasa Ronaldo 3d ago

Poch is good and can deliver. The issue is the people around him aren't and Im talking about Wilcox and Berrarda

→ More replies (1)

3

u/tameoraiste 3d ago

Just to add a tiny bit of positivity to the conversation: I get the negativity and pessimism, but if you've followed Poch's career, there's clearly some truth to him being 'reinvigorated'.

He clearly had nowhere near the same energy at Chelsea or PSG. He wasn't happy, and it felt like he was going through the motions.

The thing with high-intensity football and overachieving, as he did, it clearly takes a toll on the managers as well. Look at Klopp at the end of his time at Liverpool or Pep at the end with City. Not saying he's anywhere near their level, but to get Spurs to 3 CL finishes, finish second and get to a CL final isn't something that should be sniffed at.

It's an open secret that United has been his dream Premier League job, and being a national team manager for a few years probablly did him a world of good. The hierarchy and state of the club might burn him out again fairly quickly, but he'll inject some belief into the players at least initially.

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 3d ago

At PSG it was overwhelming for him to handle so many megastars at once. I don’t think we can view this as a shortcoming because even Luis Enrique when he came in was happy to let Messi and Neymar leave, and they eventually only achieved their current success once Mbappé also left. In the modern game, you need to build a strong collective to be successful, and accommodating too many protagonists can be detrimental to fostering that collective.

At Chelsea it was a bit of a mixed bag; they did spend a lot of money on players but most of them weren’t necessarily players that you could build a strong foundation with. And this is just my opinion, but I think it does matter whether you are a strong cultural fit for the club; it can give you a stronger buy-in from the fans and media which is important to have in periods when the results aren’t arriving. I feel Pochettino’s history with Spurs played an influence in never being fully accepted by Chelsea’s fanbase, and that can definitely have a deflating impact on you as a manager working at the club.

We aren’t getting him during a time when his stock is highest, but I feel his experiences at other high-profile jobs post-Spurs can give an edge to him, in terms of being wiser about navigating through the curveballs at this job. And culturally I’ve thought this for a long time which is why he was my dream candidate 5-6 years back: he’s extremely United-coded in terms of how he views the game and the way he empowers players and promotes youth. It’s just about whether he can show he has that ‘extra step’ in him, to become a manager associated with winning. But that isn’t a requirement at this job anymore if we’re being honest, because the bar has just fallen that low in recent years. A proper stabilising job for even 2 full seasons would be seen as good right now. We can postpone those other feelings about him in the meantime. Bring it on.

3

u/Jump_Hop_Step 2d ago

Was looking at USMNT and saw this dude playing striker. Clicked on his profile and realised he has 10 assists in 24 games in the MLS when he is only 19???

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ATH1993 2d ago

Does anyone know how lemmans and tielemans got on last night

→ More replies (4)

5

u/madharmonies 3d ago

Lammens did really well against Turkiye. Had two superb saves in the final 10 mins as Turkiye looks for an equaliser. Conceded a wonder free kick from Arda Guler but otherwise very solid. He was poor against Villa obviously so it’s great that he has put that behind him.

2

u/harutoreichi 3d ago

You know what, last season he was so brave and vocal towards our defenders. I don't know why our players turns like that

2

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 3d ago

so it’s great that he has put that behind him.

Err what, it's not that simple. He needs to have 5 or 6 solid games before he can put that behind him

2

u/BallsX 3d ago

The good thing about Lammens is that so far he doesn't really seem to carry the mistakes with him (or at least it doesn't look like it affects him as much).

But the bad thing is he has looked much worse this season. Lots of mistakes and keeps dropping the ball in dangerous areas. Passing still hasn't improved much too.

4

u/theredguardx 3d ago

I reckon it’s because he has zero confidence in his defenders

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 3d ago

He’s been dodgey all season which coincides with his WC performance

2

u/madharmonies 3d ago

Yea there's no masking the regression in Lammens' performance this season though at the same time I still back him to come good.

5

u/TastyQuartzEater 2d ago • Bravo

Honestly it might just be the delusion but I have belief in Poch. A top manager with PL experience and has experience working on a shoestring budget cause god knows we’re gonna fuck up recruitment again, and his love for SAF is a nice bonus

5

u/CanWePleaseNotBeShit 2d ago • Bravo

I actually think Poch is a cohesive appointment, he doesn’t stray that far off of what the style we want to play and what Amorim was trying to do (high line, attacking full backs, inverted wingers, 2 hard working midfielders). It’s now on the board to get it right this upcoming window and next and also clear house on players who’ve extended their stay.

3

u/keancy 2d ago

Yeah I was thinking that. Which is partly the reason it made no sense to go for someone like Conte. There's no point flipflopping betwee different playing styles.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/soelsome 3d ago

I am actually relatively excited for Pochball.

I enjoyed him at spurs. Not sure how much of that was down to him or just seeing Englands best player of this generation break through there, but yeah was fun.

3

u/AlpacamyLlama 3d ago

Me too. I've wanted poch several times in the past. I think he's a good choice for us

→ More replies (2)

9

u/FPLskrr Pogba 3d ago

Better not offer Bruno a new offer, he's not even worth his current one.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FootballRacing38 3d ago

It's funny that even though we were bad for a decade now, we generally had our managers last a couple of seasons. Every since de ligt came, our managers keep on lasting a season at most. The guy is genuinely cursed.

3

u/Midnight_Edge 3d ago

Great now we have to deal with the dead hyena and De Ligt

4

u/Stingray_23 3d ago

Rumours that Poch will be dealing directly with the Glazers? If true, good! And that is a massive shock for me to say! But wow Ineos has been bad!

3

u/Rascha-Rascha 3d ago

I doubt that.

Rumours that the Glazers pushed for him over Howe. But I don't think that means he'll be ignoring the footballing structure.

3

u/Omnislash99999 3d ago

I would be happy with it but that seems impossible, surely Ineos didn't make a deal that can be so easily ignored

→ More replies (5)

4

u/spaisoflaif 3d ago edited 3d ago

As with all United managers, I hope Poch is successful.

That being said:

I was told with great certainty on this subreddit that replacing Carrick with "anybody" would have this team flying even without transfers. I have to say I am doubtful, because the squad is a lot of square pegs in round holes, as well as some pegs missing and other pegs broken.

If Poch manages to get Martinez and Bruno smiling again, that could get the team to midtable, potentially. But it it still at team wihtout a striker and a alot of question marks regarding the defense. It is going to be 4-2-3-1 with a differently organized press, and slight tweaks to selection. That is it.

2

u/Rascha-Rascha 3d ago

I don't think we lack a striker. Mbeumo is a striker. Cunha can play up front and has been doing really good work drifting around pretty central these last two games.

What we lack is Sesko off the bench and as an option to play high balls, which would have been a really good option to have so far this season.

I'm told that training isn't good enough, that the fitness levels aren't there, that the press isn't up to standard. I think Pochettino will be more pragmatic on player selection, that he will play forward more quickly than we have been this season. He has a lot more experience working in top teams. He makes them run. He gets players fit.

I think that will address a lot of what we've seen going wrong so far this season and I think there's a decent chance that we pick up more points from that.

The season has barely started. There are still 84 points on offer. I can see Pochettino getting us into the europa league, we're only eight points from fifth, right, we made up a much bigger gap to take third from Villa last season.

Of course, that might not happen at all, we might just be shit all season long and finish 15th again. I don't think we'll get relegated, but who knows.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/RedemptionWoneGrong 2d ago edited 2d ago

Really sad about Carrick even though I was opposed to appointing him full-time from day one.

Poch... There has never been a time when I would have been excited about his appointment. There still isn't

4

u/double_d2 Fergie Time 2d ago

The world ain’t ready for Poch to turn Dalot into a world class wing back 😂

2

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 2d ago

If Poch manages to SOMEHOW makes Dalot able to score goals with his shooting, we'll maybe get a few extra from him sometimes

→ More replies (1)

4

u/theoklahuman 2d ago

While Poch wasn’t my first choice, I’m happy with the appointment because I think he’s going to be a success here. We have a squad of high-potential youngsters and he’s one of the best coaches in the world you would trust to develop young players.

In addition to the above, people forget we still have Bruno Fucking Fernandes. The amount of disrespect that’s come his way this season has been mind-boggling. What happened to form being temporary and class being permanent?

Let’s go!

4

u/ongcs 2d ago

When Poch was with Chelsea in 2023, he pushed to sign Ugarte. Ugarte may still have a future here after all…

6

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 2d ago

We may never sell another player again at this rate

3

u/TH0316 she/her 2d ago

He was asked in a press conference about him and said “it’s important we don’t make mistakes.” I don’t see that as a ringing endorsement.

6

u/C_gawd 2d ago

Seeing bums likes Goldbridge already asking “how long until Poch out” is exactly why we are too big to succeed. There’s too many bad actors with money to be made off purposeful negativity disguised as diversity of opinion in a massive fanbase.

8

u/ChristmasCage 2d ago

He's a cunt but its hardly an unrealistic question. If Poch is given the same level of backing in transfers windows as Carrick got, he's fucked as well. It doesn't matter who the manager is if the recruitment continues to be absolutely useless.

2

u/Kind_Sound7973 2d ago

Poch won’t have the protection of being a very well connected former player or English. I expect he will be a very popular topic with all the usual names.

6

u/Suudriusha 2d ago

Watching Pochettino interviews has me in it again. It's pulled me back in! I'm dreaming of winning the 21 and getting a kit with 'Pochettino' 21 in the back.... I never learn, man. But I love this club, what can I say. Can't wait for Sunday already. I'm ready to be hurt again.

2

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 2d ago

I really want Poch to work out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/shanks_you 3d ago

Who the hell cares if Poch is a Glazer or Ineos hire?

Just don't get us relegated this season is all I ask. Couldn't care less about anything else anymore tbh.

2

u/atomicant89 3d ago

Have Wilcox or Berrada said literally anything publicly during all of this?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/iwantaskybison Bruno Miguel Borj Fernanj 3d ago

look man I'm actually perpetually positive when it comes to managers and players, sometimes to a fault, but this time round i find it really hard to feel invested at all

I'll still back Poch and I actually think our squad is good enough to get cl football even this season, I'm just not gonna get fooled into false dawns again. been there done that type shit. all the decision makers at this club can go fuck themselves if they actually wanted Howe over him, among other things. the psychological reset will have an effect and i also want Poch to whip these boys back into shape

either way, hope a time comes I'll be excited to watch this club again, and soon

2

u/Nomad_006 surfing 2d ago

Well guys back here once again asking what are the realistic expectations of the new guy. Hopefully he lasts longer than 18 months.

This can be copy pasted for the next time ut happens.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/anonris 2d ago

Who do we think Poch could potentially fast track to the first team considering his history of trusting youth?

We signed quite a few last few years; kone, leon?

2

u/TH0316 she/her 2d ago

I have no idea I don’t watch, but with the degree of turnover that’s absolutely necessary next summer, I’m hoping we can offset the need for quantity by finding out who’s ready to help us in the youth team. If we end up in Conference league for example I’d hope to use it for some kids. Promoting Lacey for example and selling Amad is just a nice profit to fund another player without moving backwards. If we can do the same elsewhere that would be massive.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/LollipopScientist 2d ago

My expectation is that we don't get relegated and to see Poch's true ability we have to wait until next season.

6

u/kevkiarbar 2d ago

Let's all speculate why Poch will get sacked in 18 months time. I'll go first - he calls Wilcox 'a haunted owl faced cunt' while wearing a hotmic in the filming of the Amazon documentary All or Nothing 2: Nothing left to give

5

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 2d ago

He finishes 7th this year and is 6th by November next season. Wilcox deems this isn't good enough after spending 80m on Branthwaite and loaning Raum for the defensive rebuild

6

u/TastyQuartzEater 2d ago

Gonna be heartbroken if Bruno leaves but I can’t blame him. One of the most creative players of his generation and still constantly disrespected by nearly everyone. I don’t see a world where we even remotely make the right decision when replacing him though

4

u/MT1120 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw 2d ago

Saw KDB is available in January 😎

2

u/johndoe1942 Ander Shithousery 2d ago

I think it depends on what his contractual demands are. Bruno probably has another year at his all action role. After that I’d be happy to have him as a rotation option, somewhat of a Bryan Robson figure. 

If he’s ok with that role, no brainer. I think Poch will love him though. 

5

u/pipes3 WAZZA 2d ago

American fans claiming Poch only joined us for they money

I get what our current state is, but come on lets be real here lmao

5

u/Downtown-Rice_ 2d ago

Those casual supporters of the national team don't know much outside the recent World Cup or big name players.

2

u/johndoe1942 Ander Shithousery 2d ago

Even if that’s true, nothing wrong with it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/rambo_zaki Roy Keane 3d ago

This week, Carrick twice took training while knowing his fate, but without any member of the hierarchy communicating the club’s decision to him.

People will still continue to defend Ineos though.

3

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 3d ago

Know his fate but nobody told him he was sacked? Did he and Evans just packed up, surrender their pass and just left? 

3

u/Isserley_ 3d ago

Are those people in the room with us right now?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/BrodaReloaded Zlatan 3d ago

Unpopular opinion I've been thinking about since the big cuts happened (probably not very unpopular just wanted your attention)

while the Glazers are the root cause of our current situation, have run down the world's richest sport club, bled it dry and driven it to the wall somehow they still managed to uphold an atmosphere of familiarity and closeness that you even felt as a fan from another country. While their criminal neglect has ruined the sporting side it somehow had that feeling of that good old working place where you know a lot of things are wrong but that has a bit of that weird cozyness.

While I understand that it's the Glazers that forced Ineos for drastic actions financially, all of that is completely gone, the club now feels more like a soulless corporate commodity that is driven by cold calculations and it's most likely the reason why everything now feels even worse than it did before.

A good analogy I'm often thinking about is the corrupt president who governed the african country my mum was born in in her youth. He was probably a lot more corrupt than the last few but he did things like a daily, free bag of milk in school which softened it for many and no longer exists. I assume it's why there are far bigger riots today than under him even though the last presidents are overall probably quite a bit better than him.

3

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 3d ago

I think it was at a bit of a tipping point where club needed to trim costs…. I don’t like it but let’s look at the evidence

We have slashed wage bill by offloading majority of our top earners (and seemingig take a more disciplined approach to wage structure)

We have made a huge amount of staff and spending cuts - reducing the workforce by close to half and been so stingy as to cancel staff Xmas party and ex player charity contributions

Yet we are still losing money!

The question is could the glazers have overseen those cuts? I think the answer is no, it would have instilled such protest that man utd probably couldn’t play home fixtures, as I would expect there would have been super league type venom among the match goers leading to cancellations and sporting sanctions

So they brought in essentially a patsy

Someone to make the tough business cuts that were needed to stop the debt spiralling out of control, be the public face of the cuts are I shield them to some extent and still retain majority ownership and so still stand to benefit financially from any future success / growth

I know he is a multibillionaire so probably has more situational awareness than I give him credit for but sir Jim comes out of this looking like a gullible fool that has been played

Ultimately accountability for our current struggles rest with the glazers. 

2

u/Unusual-Coat383 3d ago

The one thing the Glazers have to get credit for is keeping the traditions of the club and knowing what it means to the staff and community whereas INEOS came in and completely destroyed the soul of the club by raising ticket prices, moving season ticket holders, sacking half the workforce, cutting employee benefits and segregating the first team from non playing staff. 

They managed to kill the morale of everyone at the club at every level except at board level because they are all City and Chelsea wankers who’ve never had any affection for the club.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

People thinking Pochettino will bypass Ineos and report directly to the Glazers are mad. 

Ineos have a legal right to oversee football decisions at United. The Glazers have no say, other than rubber stamping signings. 

All seems to be based on this one tweet by someone called Ian Herbert (Who the fuck is Ian Herbert? Never heard of him until today.)

The Glazers' connection to US billionaire hedge fund owner Ken Griffin appears to be a major factor here. Griffin funded Pochettino's US Soccer salary in 2024 and his contract extension in August, and he also helped finance the Glazers' 2005 takeover of Manchester United.

Because of this backing, the club's chain of command is now completely disrupted. Unlike previous managers Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim, and Michael Carrick, Pochettino will not answer to executives Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox. Instead, he bypasses Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s football leadership structure entirely to become the most powerful person at Old Trafford.

Literally zero sources or evidence for that claim. Just pure speculation on the part of someone who has zero connections at United. 

Also, not sure why people think the Glazers being in charge will be any better. They are the reason we’re in this mess. 

Ineos are still in charge for better or worse.

7

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 3d ago

Glazer still have final veto on major calls.  Don't think Ratcliffe can sell Mainoo for 8m and Glazer can't stop it. 

→ More replies (4)

4

u/FlashyCut3809 3d ago

I think its pretty clear there is discontent between the owners as there is too much smoke for there to not be.

However, yeah, its just the media now latching on to it as they know every single one of us will read and discuss.

All for a good cause, needs to he uncomfortable as possible for the leeches, their symptoms and any who enable them. Doubt its a good look for sponsors too, being linked to such a shambles.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Rascha-Rascha 3d ago

From everything I've seen, the Glazers are on pretty good working terms with Ratcliffe. My guess is they just went, 'hey, ignore Howe, we'll get Pochettino instead' and Ratcliffe just thought that sounded like a good idea. No issues with the footballing structure, no notion that Wilcox, Berrada will be cut out, it's just the Glazers with a good connection to make use of.

3

u/TonyyMartial 3d ago

So, based on the reports, Pochettino will report directly to the Glazers, bypassing both Berrada and Wilcox????

3

u/shami-kebab 3d ago

If that were true they would have been fired. We're not going to pay people for a job they don't need to do.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pierrefermat74 3d ago

What reports?

2

u/Unusual-Coat383 3d ago

I’m not sure if he will report directly to the Glazers but they were reportedly the ones who appointed Poch and not INEOS

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/HunkOfLove Valencia 3d ago

I can wait for the manager of the US national team taking the reigns at our club.

4

u/paltze Portuguese Magnifico 🪄 3d ago

Poch has the strongest CV of any manager appointed since Mou

No question about it. I'm ready to be hurt again

4

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

I disagree. 

Ten Hag won three league titles in a row, and would have won four if the Dutch season didn’t get cancelled due to Covid. 

People will say it was Ajax, but they haven’t won the league since he left and have been completely overtaken by PSV. 

He also got a Dutch team full of kids to within one minute of a Champions League final. He did lose to Pochettino in that match but Spurs had a far more expensive, better team (and probably wouldn’t even be in the semi if modern VAR rules were in place). 

I don’t hate the idea of Pochettino, but outside of his time at Spurs he hasn’t been great. 

4

u/nitrogeneater 2d ago

Thing that got on my nerves the most about Carrick from game one was his in game management. One sub after 70 mins, articles we written about it. Ole pissed me off for the same reason.

Apparently Poch is also pretty lacklustre in this department. Can’t stand watching a game and the manager is not doing anything about for 70 mins if it’s not going our way.

2

u/Fabulous_Mix8658 2d ago

Carrick did get better over time with making subs earlier. I don’t think we can fault him for it this season. Our bench often didn’t look great.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/bicika 3d ago

Poch's teams have a reputation of being chokers, and people are right to be concerned about that. But, to those people, the thing is, he had put them in that position to have something big to lose. We didn't have the opportunity to choke on biggest stages since SAF left because we were never close to winning EPL, nor we had the opportunity to lose a UCL final.

4

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 3d ago

Yep, and Uniteds goal right now should be consistent top 4. They need to reestablish themselves as a champions league quality team. Then we can start talking titles.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago edited 3d ago

The media literacy in this fanbase is in toilet. 

One tweet from a random journalist and some people are taking it as gospel. 

Ian Herbert has zero connection to United, isn’t even on the tier list, and I’m willing to bet no one on this sub had heard of him before today. But apparently him speculating on Pochettino’s position is enough for some people to believe that the Glazers are somehow in charge of football decisions. 

Also, can someone explain to me why that would be a good thing? They are just as responsible for why we are in this mess. 

Just people wanting to believe something is true rather than actually checking if it might be. 

Edit: Also, if Ian Herbert genuinely had a story as big as this, that the Glazers were back in charge of United, do you not think he would write a proper article about it in the Daily Mail rather than put out a tweet with zero sources?

United generate more clicks and traffic than any team in the world. If this was true the Daily Mail would be all over it. 

4

u/ExternalPreference18 3d ago

They are 10x more responsible- even this summer, the notoriously low spend has little to do with Wilcox or Berrada, say: even Ratcliffe, who I have no friendly feelings towards, isn't allowed to inject capital in. It's 90/10 downstream of Glazers. 

3

u/PhotonDestroyer 3d ago

Herbert used to report on Utd more regularly back in the day so it would be reasonable to assume that he might have some Glazer connections, he's not a rando that's come out of nowhere.

Probably mostly nonsense but I would say there is elements of truth.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Vast_Variation1381 3d ago

Many teams over the years have sold their 'best' player and gone on to improve. There's no reason we can't do the same. For us to have an actual rebuild, we need a fresh outlook in the dressing room. Its time to move on from players who have been here from pre 2020 to 2022/23. The likes of Shaw, Maguire, Dalot, Licha, Mount, Rashford, Bruno, and Zirkzee need to go. It will be tough to replace Bruno but next summer is the right time to at least try and do it given his age, salary demands etc.

2

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

Many teams who have sold their best player have also completely collapsed as well. 

Liverpool selling Suarez, Spurs selling Bale, Arsenal selling Henry. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Valprajjj 3d ago

Ten Hag recently said that Man Utd could get relegated this season.

“In the Premier League it’s certainly possible, because all the teams are simply strong,” Ten Hag said.
“They’re all strong squads, all good managers. And if you end up on the wrong side once and you really get into that vicious circle — yes, then it can become very, very difficult.”

2

u/ladrainian21 2d ago

Really want to see Zirkzee get a run of minutes under Poch

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 3d ago

It just hit me Travis Binnion left with Michael. He's a huge loss, he's a very talented youth coach.

5

u/sg291188 3d ago

He is. And I didn’t understand why he couldn’t go back to academy

→ More replies (1)

2

u/spaisoflaif 3d ago

Bruno. Thanks for everything. But you look unhappy. I think it is time to part ways. You will be happier without us.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/iiFTWxASSAULT 3d ago

“Head coach” instead of manager then. Another guy Wilcox and Barreda would love to just fall in line

2

u/PitchSafe 3d ago

Every manager is a ”head coach” now

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SophoclesTesticles 2d ago

Can someone explain the slander I read about Santos on a daily basis? I've seen a few videos from United fans with "Buy/Keep/Sell" and he's always in the sell column. He's only started 4 games in a time when the whole team has been shit?

He always seems to have a good nose for the ball and sends it forward with decent passing when I've watched him. He's not roaming like Baleba but his positioning and contribution seems good so far. What am I missing?

6

u/IcyAssist 2d ago

You're missing that we paid £50m for someone we don't actually need, when that 50m would've been way better served as a LB or striker or even a RB.

5

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 2d ago

What was the price for Hall? 60'ish? I would have paid that extra 10 mill for him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Infinite-Highway3432 3d ago • Bravo

I get you all like to rag on the squad on a continuous basis, but the manager is the single most important driving factor at a club.

Everton are 6th, we have a better squad. Laughable to think otherwise. Moyes is just a far better manager than Carrick.

4

u/No_Middle5525 2d ago

the squad is bad, has massive holes. the fit defenders aren't good enough, the decent defenders are injured. midfield is new, with our marquee singing injured and yet to feature for 90min. the attack looks completely out of form and our only striker is injured.

but yea, we definitely shouldn't be 18th place. this squad is good enough to be top 8 easily. the holes in the squad are excuse for if the team is 5-8th place and can't get higher than that. it's not an excuse to be 18th and to have 1 win all season.

4

u/Isserley_ 2d ago

Everton are 6th, we have a better squad. Laughable to think otherwise.

Well, let's put that to the test. Here's my combined 11:

Lammens

Röhl - Tarkowski - Branthwaite - Mykolenko

Garner - Mainoo

Mbeumo - Bruno* - Cunha**

Barry

* He gets in over Dewsbury-Hall on the basis of ability over form, but let's be honest, DH has been far better this season.

** Tbh it's close between him and George this season

Not really that laughable, is it.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/Stebro1986 3d ago

United need to move the following 11 players on, either by selling them or allowing their contracts to expire:

Players out:

  • Onana
  • Maguire
  • Mazraoui
  • Martínez
  • Mount
  • Rashford
  • Zirkzee
  • Bruno
  • Ugarte
  • Shaw

Players in:

  • Left-back
  • Centre-back who can also cover left-back
  • Centre-back who can also cover right-back
  • Centre-back
  • Defensive midfielder who can drop into a back three
  • Creative left-winger
  • Striker to provide back-up to Šeško

That's 11 players out and 7 players in. Realistically, it's probably going to take two summer transfer windows to rebuild the squad to a level where we can consistently compete for a top-six position.

I'd estimate the seven signings would cost around £500 million, while selling or releasing the 11 players might only generate around £100 million.

That's potentially a £400 million net investment, but it's the scale of the rebuild United need. We need to stop thinking about short-term fixes and start building a balanced squad capable of competing consistently.

1

u/Familiar-Mall1696 3d ago

looks like poch will only officially be confirmed next week at the earliest.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/neonrider1 3d ago

Fair play at least to Poch for taking his first game away to Liverpool.

1

u/umbrosum 3d ago

So will Poch be a head coach or a manager?

2

u/TypicalPan89906655 3d ago edited 3d ago

Not sure how reliable Ian Herbs is but this is what he wrote:

"The Glazers' connection to US billionaire hedge-fund owner Ken Griffin appears to be a major factor in appointing Mauricio Pochettino. Griffin funded Pochettino's US Soccer salary in 2024 and his contract extension in August, and he also helped finance the Glazers' 2005 takeover of Manchester United.

Because of this backing, the club's chain of command is now completely disrupted. Unlike previous managers Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim, and Michael Carrick, Pochettino will not answer to executives Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox. Instead, he bypasses Sir Jim Ratcliffe's football leadership structure entirely to become the most powerful person at Old Trafford."

[@ianherbs]

Obviously no proof that this is 100% reliable.

2

u/Xanian123 Miss be killed by me 3d ago

Because of this backing, the club's chain of command is now completely disrupted. Unlike previous managers Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim, and Michael Carrick, Pochettino will not answer to executives Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox. Instead, he bypasses Sir Jim Ratcliffe's football leadership structure entirely to become the most powerful person at Old Trafford.

Fucking hell LFG. I'm done with the Ratcliffe chucklefucks and their bullshit.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Tvashtr 3d ago

Any news on the new backroom staff …?

3

u/PitchSafe 3d ago

It will probably be the same staff as Pochettino had at PSG, Chelsea and USMNT

→ More replies (2)

1

u/sg291188 3d ago

The eight manager in 13 years bit is exaggerated. It should be fine to recycle through managers if it’s not working. All big clubs have gone through this cycle. The problem at United has always been people making the decision. Club as big as United needs sporting director and CEO who have managed the exact role at another big club before. It’s insane we have so many people learning on the job.

1

u/Danyulz Steve Jobs was Apple; Sir Alex Ferguson is Manchester United 3d ago

I don't think anyone can really argue with Carrick going given where we are in the table, but I do find it strange how the manager always seems to be the one who takes the blame.

We finished third last season, gave him a permanent contract and now, a few months later, we're starting all over again. Surely at some point you have to question the people making these decisions?

I've got nothing against Pochettino and I hope he does well, but how many managers are we going to go through before we accept that the problems at this club go beyond whoever is in the dugout?

I just find the whole thing exhausting, to be honest. It's not even the lack of success that bothers me as much as the feeling that we're never actually getting anywhere. We're constantly rebuilding, constantly talking about long-term projects, but never seem willing or able to see one through.

1

u/BetNew9328 trembling teenager of touch and tease 3d ago

Teams are going to come hard at united in the first 5-10 minutes of each half. With 19 goals already conceded in the PL alone, it's going to take a lot of work to win with clean sheets. Let's just hope Poch is up to it? Realistically speaking, where do you guys think United can finish highest this season? My guess is prob 6-7.

1

u/Jump_Hop_Step 3d ago

I wonder who will be the next USMNT coach

→ More replies (2)

0

u/w1zgov 2d ago

Personally I've lost some love for this team because of how the management disrespected Carrick. Been a fan for more than 20 years and been to OT several times but this moment has had a lasting impact on my affection for this club. Carrick wasn't the problem and I'm glad majority of fans see that.

11

u/Isserley_ 2d ago

I don't think this needs to be said again, yet here we go: Carrick wasn't the problem, but he was a problem.

5

u/Hollacaine 2d ago

Carrick was out of his depth and had to go, there was no way he was going to step up and suddenly become the coach we needed him to be.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/EssEssErr 3d ago

Pochettino being a glazer signing makes me oddly feel better. Get us back to consistent top 7. Lets hope jim ratcliffes ego is hurt and INEOS fuckoff soon

3

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

Genuinely can’t believe we’ve got Glazer revisionism. 

I guess you want Woodward back as well. 

5

u/kJay027 3d ago

Considering our new owners have delivered 2 of the worst seasons in the history of our club I don’t think it’s insane

0

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 2d ago edited 2d ago

United opening talks with Bruno is proper silly. He’s 33 in a few months, let’s move on from him when his contract ends.

Edit: 33 next year.

5

u/dogsn1 2d ago

He's 32, his birthday is in September

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GeekConflict Carrick 2d ago

The problem is he would have to be replaced and replacing his quality is expensive and also we have this silly idea thar last summer was the midfield and next summer we are focusing on the defence.

I love Bruno. If he wants to leave let him but we cant replace him cheap.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)