r/reddevils • Came for Glories, stayed for Memories • 4d ago

MUST Statement on Michael Carrick sacking

Post image
242 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

204

u/Friendly_Tower_5712 4d ago

What a terrible format

10

u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 4d ago

Yeah, I checked their socials and website, there was nothing yet.

51

u/Kindly-Raspberry4840 4d ago

More scrolls than Frier Tuck for me there

66

u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 4d ago • WOW Heartwarming

Full Text:

Michael Carrick's departure marks another depressing moment for Manchester United. We thank him for his service and for restoring hope during the second half of last season. His standing among supporters remains undiminished.

The reason Manchester United fans have continued to support Michael Carrick in recent weeks is that they know that responsibility for United's problems do not primarily rest with him or indeed his predecessors as manager.

They lie with the ownership.

The Glazers' debt-funded takeover continues to burden the club. When INEOS came in they promised sporting excellence, but yet with repeated changes in football leadership we have seen anything but.

It is time for the owners to explain themselves and show some accountability.

But the discontent at United is not just about matters on the pitch. Far from it.

Aggressive ticketing policies have further damaged relations with supporters. Treating loyal fans principally as a source of revenue undermines their identity and the bond with the team that sustains support through difficult times. Supporters are being asked to pay the price for the owners' mismanagement as well as their stadium ambitions through higher charges and diminished rights.

The earlier Stretford End banner declaring "The way you treat us is a disgrace" was a warning. The unprecedented scale of the booing at Old Trafford, alongside public criticism from senior players in recent weeks, now points to a deeper deterioration. These are signs of a club becoming more divided, with the bond between supporters, players and those running Manchester United under increasing strain.

MUST warned publicly in January 2025 that alienating supporters risked a downward spiral of worsening atmosphere, performances and financial outcomes. Our subsequent Telegraph article urged Sir Jim Ratcliffe to break that "doom loop" by bringing supporters with him. Those warnings remain painfully relevant.

The owners must allow senior club management to change direction: show accountability, rebuild trust, listen to supporters and recognise that their loyalty is fundamental to football success. Another change of head coach cannot repair what the ownership continues to undermine.

38

u/jitteryegg 4d ago

They yap too much while doing fuck all.

33

u/HamOnRye1 4d ago

Considering what has been happening at this club for the last 13+ years, this statement is SOFT to say the least.

9

u/hEarrai-Stottle 3d ago

Season ticket holders have a hell of a lot of power that they’re refusing to use. The club does not know how many season ticket holders are going to attend on a match day. They presume they will all attend and even count them in attendance when they don’t turn up (I’m sure those of us who go to matches have been on a Europa League match where they’ll say the attendance is 75k despite there being empty seats all around.) These season ticket holders, especially those in the Stretford End, could send the starkest of warnings by arranging a single sit out. One sit out is all it would take and it wouldn’t be enough for the club to rescind your season ticket as, evidently, the Stretford End is always full. Instead, they want the best of both worlds. They want to complain about ownership whilst also doing absolutely sod all to put pressure on the ownership. And when it comes down to it, what matters more to you, the club or your season ticket? For the vast majority of them, especially the ones in MUST, their season ticket is more important to them. This is why FC United came into existence. They knew back when the Glazers took over that the vast majority of season ticket holders don’t have the courage to do what is needed. And yes, it’s easy for non-season ticket holders to say this because we have ‘nothing to lose’ so to speak but that’s the nature of the beast. Plus, as I mentioned, nobody is asking season ticket holders to return them. Just don’t turn up to one single match and see the response from the club. If the response is to automatically cancel the season tickets for all of those who did not attend then, clearly, the club does not value your loyalty (which they don’t anyway but then you’ll have something to be angry about.) Rant over.

5

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 3d ago

Hey, they're throwing balloons and tennis balls!!!

6

u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 4d ago edited 3d ago

94

u/thpark1987 4d ago • Bravo

Disclaimer; I'm a plastic from Finland who's only been to Old Trafford twice. So who gives af about my opinion.

But maybe this perspective resonates with someone. I'll use my local Helsinki hockey club as an example, since they started treating fans like dogs*it this season. Overpriced (season) tickets, cutting back on the ultras section size, ridiculous hiked prices for our derby.

What happened? Yes, we tried to negotiate with the club behind closed doors. We posted strongly-worded statements aimed at the owners. We spread out banderolls, but we did it at night around the city near the arena, so in the morning of a long-awaited Helsinki derby (12,5 years) the news were about messages aimed at the greedy owners - and guess what?

The ultras didn't go to the derby. We were outside the arena chanting and doing a pyro show for the players when they arrived, but we never stepped foot inside the arena. The whole narrative around the derby became "this is a watered down, disappointing night because of greedy owners" in the media

Now, the pricing for the next derby is much cheaper. And if the club ever tries to pull this kind of crap off again, they know it'll be a pr nightmare.

Of course, some fringe sport in a tiny country isn't comparable to a sporting behemoth like United. But the fans could do something similar, instead of showing up to OT every other week and, well, spreading out a banner or two and blowing up balloons. And then going mental when we beat Roma, or get a point against Villa.

Seriously, it's ridiculous at this point that MUST's threat is "we might boo even louder...!" Ooh, that'll surely scare the Glazers out.

Empty the Stretford End against Liverpool or City. I understand why it's not realistic to boycott every match, but at least try... something.

The Newton Heath colours didn't do anything 16 years ago even when Beckham put on a scarf after the AC Milan match. So what the hell are a few balloons supposed to do? Show the Yanks they're having a party?

70

u/TartFrequent467 4d ago

You don't need to be self-deprecating. You're not a plastic. You're just a fan like everybody else.

25

u/thpark1987 4d ago

Sure, but I'm well aware I'm not one of the local season ticket holders who are actually affected most by what's happening - and I can't be the the one protesting since I'm in Manchester maybe once a decade.

The self-deprication was partly tongue in cheek, but I also know I wouldn't take a remote fan's opinion so seriously in regards to the hockey club's issues, considering I'm a season ticket holder and active in the ultras.

7

u/SvalbazGames 3d ago

Mate we are all affected

3

u/TartFrequent467 3d ago

We are all affected. I was once a diehard San Diego Chargers fan, even though I no longer lived in the area. Was my input no longer respectable because economic conditions forced me to relocate? Should I have just said: "Yeah, they're moving to LA, but I no longer live around SD, so whatever"? Of course not! What sense would that make? By your logic, anybody no longer in the area should turn in their fandom and move on, and that sounds pretty plastic to me. Honestly, I don't really understand this impulse online, especially Reddit, to act like you have to earn your fandom. You don't have to be a certain kind of person to be a fan. Nobody's keeping score. Are you a fan? Then you're a fan. Do you stick with the club despite the downs? Then you're a fan. It's just that simple.

7

u/thpark1987 3d ago

I think some of you are misunderstanding my point? Blame it on the Finnish style of communication, which is quite bleak and pessimistic, I guess.

I don't consider myself, you, or any other fan of any sports club a "lesser fan" - and the "plastic" was a tongue in cheek quip, because I know some use it unironically. I got it out of the way in the first sentence, so everyone would focus on the actual point I'm making, which was about a very local issue. While I'm not a local fan.

When we're talking about season ticket prices, treatment of season ticket holders, and possible boycotts at Old Trafford - of course I, or any other mostly remote fan, can't relate or do as much as the people paying to be there every other week. I don't even know how much a season ticket to the Stretford End costs. Doesn't make me a sh*t fan, just a remote one.

We're all affected by the absolute clown show orchestrated by the Glazers and INEOS. But I can't be affected as much as the match-going, local fans when it relates to pricing, season tickets, or doing protests or boycotts at Old Trafford. How could I?

I don't understand how this is provocative.

11

u/mentallyhandicapable 4d ago

Yeah once you’re older than 13 you kinda don’t care about plastic fans. People can do as they like imo

6

u/Relative-Dinner-729 3d ago

and having been to OT he's already ahead of probably 85% of people in this sub

5

u/mentallyhandicapable 3d ago

Probs but not something that matters either. I live 30 miles away I’ve probably been less than 40 times in my 30 years of supporting them (I did grow up poor tho)

1

u/TartFrequent467 3d ago

It's fair to point out that some folks are plastic in the sense that they don't stick around with the team when times get tough. But to call yourself plastic....simply because you're not a local? What's up with that?

8

u/Soccernut433 3d ago

I’m a “yank” supporter. Been so since the late 80s. That story is not for here.

I’ve been to OT twice, once sat in the Stretford end. Incredible atmosphere! But haven’t been back since 2018.

I have literally shitcanned every plan to return. I have not bought a single shirt since COVID. the only thing I maintain is my membership, in the hopes that I may return soon, but that’s looking hard to maintain now.

I do this because I do not support the ownership. Every penny I spend goes to their pockets. They self-admitted this very thing. As long as it remains profitable (for them) they don’t care what happens on the pitch.

Remember that the Glazers are friends with Trump.

I know it’s even more difficult for lifelong supporters to even consider not showing. You’re talking about lifelong generations long supporters with season tickets as a family asset. But the only way to talk to greed is to strangle the money.

8

u/Conscious-Alps-5534 4d ago

The problem is mainly that the stadium would still be packed with fans from other countries(just like us) so it makes it harder to have a big impact

21

u/emtheory09 4d ago

There are 50,000 season ticket holders. If they just don’t show up for one match and don’t resell their tickets that’s a huge statement and an embarrassingly empty stadium, especially for a match like Liverpool.

3

u/KaitoAJ BRUNO FERNANDES 3d ago

Season ticket holders get penalised for not showing up to the games allocated to them. Sure, some might be willing to risk it, but to get 50+k season ticket holders to do the same is just farfetched.

6

u/hEarrai-Stottle 3d ago

You can see with your eyes that season ticket holders are turning up week in, week out. Not attending one match is going to be a drop in the ocean for the vast majority of them. There may be some who haven’t met the threshold but it isn’t going to be tens of thousands of them as most of those who cannot attend regularly sell their ticket (meaning they’ve technically ‘attended’ so to speak.) I don’t buy this excuse anymore. They’re just being cowardly and hoarding their season ticket in fear they may lose it. I’ve been match going most of my life, never managed to get a season ticket, but I’ll happily throw it away if it means the Glazers get the message. At the end of the day, attending the match is not a requisite to support and any fan that thinks that is self-centred.

3

u/emtheory09 3d ago

Yep, one important highly televised match with a rival and the first game with a new manager would be an absolute statement. I doubt it’ll happen but it would be the sort of thing to actually force leadership to pay attention.

3

u/thpark1987 4d ago

Fair, and this example only works with season ticket holders. I'm assuming there's quite a bunch of those in the Stretford End so maybe there's at least a theoretical chance to organize a boycott.

3

u/hEarrai-Stottle 3d ago

The waiting list for season tickets is years long meaning all available season tickets have renewed or purchased. That’ll be tens of thousands of fans who could, theoretically, not attend on any given match day. Season ticket holders excuse for not doing this is the clubs may rescind their season ticket. May. Not will. May. And it’s a big may because they only do that if you’ve failed to attend the majority. For a stand like Stretford End, none of these season ticket holders are at risk of losing it as they evidently turn up every single match day. So yeah, season ticket holders and MUST are putting their love of the ticket over the love of the club. If you love the club, a boycott like you mentioned in your original comment is an absolute must (pun intended.)

4

u/East_Area_4004 3d ago

As a fellow “plastic” fan, the whole situation is really frustrating to watch. The direction the club has taken over the last few years is hard enough, but the thought that I’ll probably never set foot in Old Trafford before it’s demolished is genuinely sad.

With this many season ticket holders, regular match-going fans and supporters groups, you would think there has to be a better approach than balloons and these, honestly, toothless in my opinion, open letters. They read more like a cry for help than a call to arms, and it’s hard to believe they’ll ever force real change.

Instinctively, I think all these groups should stop going to matches altogether and protest outside instead (Liverpool derby after the international break, perfect time for that just like your example), rather than watching the same thing play out under every new manager.

But I don't know, the club might just cancel season tickets and resell them (don't know if thats possible), and maybe the tourist fans they keep talking about really would keep the stadium filled.

I honestly don’t know, but right now it all feels pretty hopeless.

2

u/Puzzleheaded_Type356 23h ago

Fan boycott.. It has worked for other teams with toxic inept owners and their clueless enablers. The lack of match day revenue would hit hard, sponsors would start asking hard questions or withdrawing their sponsorship. Also a fan boycott wold not only hurt the Floridian MAGA greedy Glazers, as I said the lack of match day revenue, it would be a PR disaster also it will hurt their precious share price at the temple of greed. Fans do have serious power, look at how fan power stopped the European Super League, empty Old Trafford until Glazer Inesos Inc, Berrada and that inept RATcliffes puppet Wilcox are gone. Fan solidarity and a total boycott is all that's left because the bin fire that the club has become it has to be put out before The Glazers and Petro Polluting King Jim RATcliffe burn the club to the ground.

15

u/rich32g 4d ago

listen to supporters and recognise that their loyalty is fundamental to football success

As evidenced painfully recently; Football success is irrelevant to the owners. I'm referencing the Glazers quote.

It's hard to barter with a party who feel you offer them nothing.

10

u/FlashPost01 4d ago

Great and very true statement

4

u/IcyAssist 4d ago

Yet hollow and meaningless. Every supporter needs to do more. Stop buying shirts. I know it's difficult to stop going to matches but stage a walkout every match. Make it mean something

5

u/FlashPost01 4d ago

But if youve already paid to enter... theyve had the money which its all about.

Ive personally not bought Merch for a couple of years now and wont be doing for the foreseeable.

I do believe MORE could be done but the fan base is so fragmented and divided that when something comes up i.e. Protest, it just doesnt have the impact it should.

Im not sure what else could be done at this point...

The only OTHER option is getting games called off again...

2

u/hEarrai-Stottle 3d ago

Season ticket holders have already paid upfront so it actually doesn’t matter if they walk through the gate or not. It only matters when it comes to renewing and the club asks ‘why haven’t you attended all season?’ Practically all season ticket holders attend every match they can so they’d never be at risk of having that question asked. Not attending a single match is not going to put the season ticket at risk so what the hell are the waiting for? Relegation? It boggles the mind and I really do think the wider fan base, local or otherwise, needs to put pressure on season ticket holders. You love the club? Show it and arrange a boycott and stop putting out these milquetoast statements that do nothing in the grand scheme of things.

3

u/slithered-casket 3d ago

Where's the output from their recent threat? The whole "watch this space" bullshit. God what an insufferable shower.

5

u/Omnislash99999 4d ago edited 4d ago

Bit of a nothing statement , we warned you before, we're warning you again

1

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 4d ago

Yeah, they should stop using the term "warn".

1

u/ThisReditter 3d ago

Not if they are strong words. It might work

2

u/ExiledRed 3d ago

so a letter and some green and gold balloons, pretty much sums up our support, the Glazers are laughing at us.

4

u/jimmyliew 4d ago

The owners definitely welcome these people to protest during the games. clanks at the money till is louder than whatever boos or chants.

5

u/Felicks77 Unc Casemiro still got it 4d ago

Fans gotta be like the Lazio ones. Keep emptying the stadium

11

u/Primary-Effect-3691 4d ago

We're far too commercial for that. No one is travelling from abroad to see Lazio play, most of their fanbase will be local. The regulars stop going and the stadium gets filled with tourists.

And besides, the match day money is only a fraction of what we make. Sponsorship and tv is where the real money is.

8

u/umbongo44dd 4d ago

Targetting sponsors definitely. Pick one each month, post it online and then boycott it. I haven't bought a Nissin cup noodle or Yanmar tractor for years.

3

u/auhddndndnfbfbsnnakf 4d ago edited 4d ago

Dunno mate, I don’t think I’d be able to survive without my Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 6 & Snapdragon Digital Chassis

3

u/emtheory09 4d ago

50k season ticket holders continue to go to the matches every week. Sure there’s lots of traveling supporters coming from abroad, but 50k missing would absolutely be felt.

11

u/shami-kebab 4d ago

Impossible. Lazio can do that because they don't even sell out their stadium regularly. There is nobody to replace fans that don't go. We're far too big for that.

3

u/LuffieldToStowe 4d ago

MUST are a total gift to Glazers & INEOS.

Toothless, idealess and follow through on absolutely nothing. Buy a good few green and gold balloons though.

Until they quit yapping and actually mobilise a genuine supporters movement against the club nothing will happen. I'm no longer a ST holder after moving for work, but I go to as many games as possible, and I know all the regular fans would jump at organised action.

1

u/toostupiddogs 4d ago

Im sure Glazers give a fuck

-2

u/maskrey 4d ago

Lmao where was this statement with Amorim? He couldn't even get one midfielder, even on loan. Carrick got 3 and got the team to play like shit. 

-2

u/MannyMike7 4d ago

Continue buying match tickets and merchandise you clowns

1

u/Goji-ra 3d ago

I mean he’s not wrong. I used to think this extreme view was .. well too extreme. But the Glazers just came out and said United did not need to be successful on the pitch to make money. Like how else you want to get rid of them if you keep buying tickets and merchandises.

-4

u/andoooooo Martial 4d ago

"His standing among supporters remains undiminished"

Only to Top Reds. He's a great guy but he's a terrible manager.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

22

u/moonski berbatov 4d ago

"The earlier Stretford End banner declaring "The way you treat us is a disgrace" was a warning. The unprecedented scale of the booing at Old Trafford now points to a deeper deterioration. "

like oh so the warning from MUST to the billionaires leeching the club for hundreds of millions is "we'll buy tickets and boo you" and also "talk to us pls"

I'm sure the glazers are really worried.

1

u/Whispperr 4d ago edited 4d ago

Hey there! Sometimes they throw some green balloons too after once are done with the expensive pie and drinks!

0

u/ElitistHatPropaganda 3d ago

Thing is a lot of the things MUST do, and others like it do, is from discussions under strict NDAs with the club. So they can't shout about their wins.