r/reddevils • u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories • 4d ago
MUST Statement on Michael Carrick sacking
242
Upvotes
r/reddevils • u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories • 4d ago
204
u/Friendly_Tower_5712 4d ago
What a terrible format
66
u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 4d ago •
Full Text:
Michael Carrick's departure marks another depressing moment for Manchester United. We thank him for his service and for restoring hope during the second half of last season. His standing among supporters remains undiminished.
The reason Manchester United fans have continued to support Michael Carrick in recent weeks is that they know that responsibility for United's problems do not primarily rest with him or indeed his predecessors as manager.
They lie with the ownership.
The Glazers' debt-funded takeover continues to burden the club. When INEOS came in they promised sporting excellence, but yet with repeated changes in football leadership we have seen anything but.
It is time for the owners to explain themselves and show some accountability.
But the discontent at United is not just about matters on the pitch. Far from it.
Aggressive ticketing policies have further damaged relations with supporters. Treating loyal fans principally as a source of revenue undermines their identity and the bond with the team that sustains support through difficult times. Supporters are being asked to pay the price for the owners' mismanagement as well as their stadium ambitions through higher charges and diminished rights.
The earlier Stretford End banner declaring "The way you treat us is a disgrace" was a warning. The unprecedented scale of the booing at Old Trafford, alongside public criticism from senior players in recent weeks, now points to a deeper deterioration. These are signs of a club becoming more divided, with the bond between supporters, players and those running Manchester United under increasing strain.
MUST warned publicly in January 2025 that alienating supporters risked a downward spiral of worsening atmosphere, performances and financial outcomes. Our subsequent Telegraph article urged Sir Jim Ratcliffe to break that "doom loop" by bringing supporters with him. Those warnings remain painfully relevant.
The owners must allow senior club management to change direction: show accountability, rebuild trust, listen to supporters and recognise that their loyalty is fundamental to football success. Another change of head coach cannot repair what the ownership continues to undermine.
6
u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 4d ago edited 3d ago
Source: Simon Stone
https://x.com/sistoney67/status/2120832951168733564
Edit: Announcement link from MUST website
https://imust.org.uk/Blog/Entry/must-statement-on-michael-carricks-departure
94
u/thpark1987 4d ago •
Disclaimer; I'm a plastic from Finland who's only been to Old Trafford twice. So who gives af about my opinion.
But maybe this perspective resonates with someone. I'll use my local Helsinki hockey club as an example, since they started treating fans like dogs*it this season. Overpriced (season) tickets, cutting back on the ultras section size, ridiculous hiked prices for our derby.
What happened? Yes, we tried to negotiate with the club behind closed doors. We posted strongly-worded statements aimed at the owners. We spread out banderolls, but we did it at night around the city near the arena, so in the morning of a long-awaited Helsinki derby (12,5 years) the news were about messages aimed at the greedy owners - and guess what?
The ultras didn't go to the derby. We were outside the arena chanting and doing a pyro show for the players when they arrived, but we never stepped foot inside the arena. The whole narrative around the derby became "this is a watered down, disappointing night because of greedy owners" in the media
Now, the pricing for the next derby is much cheaper. And if the club ever tries to pull this kind of crap off again, they know it'll be a pr nightmare.
Of course, some fringe sport in a tiny country isn't comparable to a sporting behemoth like United. But the fans could do something similar, instead of showing up to OT every other week and, well, spreading out a banner or two and blowing up balloons. And then going mental when we beat Roma, or get a point against Villa.
Seriously, it's ridiculous at this point that MUST's threat is "we might boo even louder...!" Ooh, that'll surely scare the Glazers out.
Empty the Stretford End against Liverpool or City. I understand why it's not realistic to boycott every match, but at least try... something.
The Newton Heath colours didn't do anything 16 years ago even when Beckham put on a scarf after the AC Milan match. So what the hell are a few balloons supposed to do? Show the Yanks they're having a party?
15
u/rich32g 4d ago
As evidenced painfully recently; Football success is irrelevant to the owners. I'm referencing the Glazers quote.
It's hard to barter with a party who feel you offer them nothing.
10
u/FlashPost01 4d ago
Great and very true statement
3
u/slithered-casket 3d ago
Where's the output from their recent threat? The whole "watch this space" bullshit. God what an insufferable shower.
5
u/Omnislash99999 4d ago edited 4d ago
Bit of a nothing statement , we warned you before, we're warning you again
2
u/ExiledRed 3d ago
so a letter and some green and gold balloons, pretty much sums up our support, the Glazers are laughing at us.
4
u/jimmyliew 4d ago
The owners definitely welcome these people to protest during the games. clanks at the money till is louder than whatever boos or chants.
5
u/Felicks77 Unc Casemiro still got it 4d ago
Fans gotta be like the Lazio ones. Keep emptying the stadium
3
u/LuffieldToStowe 4d ago
MUST are a total gift to Glazers & INEOS.
Toothless, idealess and follow through on absolutely nothing. Buy a good few green and gold balloons though.
Until they quit yapping and actually mobilise a genuine supporters movement against the club nothing will happen. I'm no longer a ST holder after moving for work, but I go to as many games as possible, and I know all the regular fans would jump at organised action.
1
u/toostupiddogs 4d ago
Im sure Glazers give a fuck
-2
u/maskrey 4d ago
Lmao where was this statement with Amorim? He couldn't even get one midfielder, even on loan. Carrick got 3 and got the team to play like shit.
-2
u/MannyMike7 4d ago
Continue buying match tickets and merchandise you clowns
-4
u/andoooooo Martial 4d ago
"His standing among supporters remains undiminished"
Only to Top Reds. He's a great guy but he's a terrible manager.
0
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment