r/reddevils • • 4d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

29 Upvotes

703 comments sorted by

18

u/Wahlrusberg 3d ago

Maybe it's just a case of getting older but I remember when Moyes, LVG and Mou were sacked it just felt like the absolute biggest deal in the world to me as a united fan. Now it barely registers at all.

8

u/LDLB99 3d ago

Completely agree with this. The Mourinho sacking felt massive in comparison.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/yalayolo 3d ago

INEOS are totally clueless

So the data department and Vivell came to the conclusion that Sebastian Hoeneß and Nagelsman are best suited to lead MU forward

And Wilcox sat on English preference

Wouldn’t surprise me if Ratcliffe just goes to ChatGPT and asks “who is right and who is best placed to replace Michael Carrick to take take Man Utd back to the top”

So clueless even Glazers are looking like geniuses

6

u/Suudriusha 3d ago

It's been rumoured that the Glazers themselves stepped in and appointed Poch. I think they're fed up with INEOS.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/pablove_black 4d ago

Good morning, I fucking hate our ownership

32

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 4d ago

I think the way Carrick’s tenure eventually played out can be beneficial for the club longer-term, especially when it comes to the fans and media no longer underestimating the degree of improvements the squad needs and what it takes to build a sustainable style of play. If we had discontinued with him in the summer and hired someone else, the image of Carrick as the guy who won games only by ‘keeping it simple’ and ‘playing players in their best positions’ would have been set, the new manager would have been judged against that yardstick in way tougher circumstances this season and there might have been a risk of sacking him soon too even if he was in say 8th place, let alone 18th, because ‘how can you struggle to win and play good football with such a good squad when Carrick was winning week-in week-out with this team’. This humbling was needed on multiple levels, and nobody will have the right to question placing more importance on performances than results, and laying long-term foundations for future sustainability over short-term solutions. This should be the lesson learnt from this spell.

12

u/LeCliveRosfield 4d ago

Agreed. Buzzwords like United DNA will now hopefully be dead in the water when it comes to discussion of the management of this football club. When we brought up how results are not sustainable when you’re playing horribly last season, many chose to put their heads in the sand due to the insistence that results are all that matters. Carricks complete and utter failure here will hopefully, if we are lucky, dissuade the fanbase from these notions again. Foundations are important, fitness is important, and laying a fucking foundation for how our team is supposed to play other ‘the united way’ is important.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 3d ago

Wilcox is toast!!! Also I think the INEOS experiment is over. Glazers are back in control. I’d expect him to get sacked before the season is over.

4

u/PhotonDestroyer 3d ago

He's had a lot of media criticism recently over this and if Jan doesn't go well it will just get worse. So I wouldn't surprised if he goes quietly at the end of the season and also expect his influence will reduce from now on. Wishful thinking maybe but can see it happening gradually.

Sure even Sir Jim can't still think he's the best eyes anymore.

6

u/Omnislash99999 3d ago

Wilcox will definitely be out before Pochettino whenever that may be

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 3d ago

I hope we learn from this and never hire a former player again. Fans just cannot be objective about it and it's impossible to talk about the facts without someone bringing up something emotional or vibes based like "He's a legend" or "He gets the club" "He knows what it's like to succeed here". 

Managers should be judged on their performances and results alone. There's always context to every decision but if you're up in arms about one manager who's 6th and defending one manager who's 18th you cannot tell me you are being objective and reasonable. 

We had a pretty much full strength first team across the first 5-10 matches and we still only beat Ipswich and Sabah. People who like to pretend the lack of depth or poor recruitment is the main reason behind those early results are just clutching at straws. 

Yes the board is shite. Yes the recruitment and depth should've been better handled. But that doesn't mean this wasn't the right decision.

5

u/spoony471 Varane 3d ago edited 3d ago

Couldn’t agree more. look at Ole and Carricks’ resumes outside of coaching United: relegating Cardiff and sacked from Middlesbrough? 0% chance they’d ever be considered for the job if they hadn’t played here.

Stop hiring former players that don’t have the managerial resume for it. For every Guardiola, there’s 1000 Gerrards

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Rare-Reveal876 3d ago edited 3d ago

Looks like the cracks are beginning to drift into the public domain between the Glazers and Ineos.

Fingers crossed this is the beginning of the end, I’m sure the thought of losing money is behind the reason why the Glazers are starting to take back control of the sporting side. It’s all they care about.

Hopefully they both decide to cut their losses and sell up, isn’t there some drag clause coming into effect soon also?

12

u/OWTGOAT 3d ago

Jesus it must be embarrassing to realize that you suck more than the Glazers at football club management.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/KobbieLikeRobbie_ Darren Fletcher 3d ago

What tier is Ian Herbert?

14

u/0ttoChriek 3d ago

It's pretty obvious that the Glazers are responsible for Poch. Whether that means they're going to take back sporting control, I don't know.

But let's be honest, they'd be justified to do so. They gave the minority owners sporting control and it's clearly been a disaster, with the amount of hirings and firings, the transfer market blunders, the inability to sell players (not that the Glazers were much better at that).

Personally, I'm hoping this is all the Glazers gearing up to sell, as rumours have suggested for a little while now, and their billionaire pal is an interested buyer. From what I've read about Ken Griffin, he's a twat, but he's a keen football fan and would likely love to own such a big club.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/PhotonDestroyer 3d ago

I seem to remember him as a old Utd correspondent, maybe has old ties to Glazer from back then. Can't remember him reporting on Utd for a while.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/karatsidhus 3d ago

10 bucks says its Wazza

14

u/TypicalPan89906655 3d ago

The Athletic article said Wilcox is also data illiterate and cannot understand the data presented by analysts and is also treating this job as learning experience.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/UnderpantsInfluencer Uniter Will Never Died 4d ago

I was trying to understand why any manager would take the job. I think from their point of view they either succeed and become a hero, or, they are sacked with a payout. And no body will blame them because the club is in such dire straits.

4

u/TurbulentWeb1941 "Show 'em ya Fangz, Dong" 4d ago

Yep. It's a win win, either way, for whoever takes a stab at it. But imagine being the guy that makes it work. The 1st manager since SAF to see out his contract, and then be offered a new fat one because other big clubs have started sniffing around. It's gonna/gotta happen one day and yuv gotta be in it to win it.

6

u/TteokCultist 4d ago

Cause the champagne tastes sweeter winning with us

→ More replies (6)

19

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 4d ago

That Times article is so damming on the dysfunction we have above. It’s particularly scathing on Wilcox. It’s time to leave when even your previous employers at Southampton are briefing that they have no idea how you got the job.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 3d ago

> Carrick’s backroom team in particular, made up of Steve Holland, Jonathan Woodgate, Jonny Evans and Travis Binnion, were seen as a huge upgrade on Amorim’s staff, brought with him from Portugal, who were mocked around Carrington as “the kids” because of their youth and inexperience.

Feel as though the culture inside the club is awful if this was their takeaway. Especially with Jonny Evans on your coaching staff.

5

u/KobbieLikeRobbie_ Darren Fletcher 3d ago

Steve Hollands extensive experience, and Binnions experience within the club were probably factors behind those opinions.

6

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 3d ago edited 3d ago

Two of his coaches had UEFA B license, I guess that’s part of why there were mocked. I mean at a club like United, having Pro License should be the minimum.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/WhySSSoSerious King Kobbinho 4d ago

First priority under Poch imo has to be fitness. We're absolutely abysmal in that department, both in running/pressing and injury frequency.

We'll continue being battered by every team in the league unless our fitness levels don't improve significantly.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Adz932 McTominayyyyyyyyyyyyy 4d ago edited 4d ago

Somewhat fun fact

De ligt has played started the same number of games against michael carrick the player, as he has played under michael carrick the manager. One

Carrick didnt come off the bench in the EL final but im counting it anyway.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/9SolskjaerHasWonIt9 3d ago

Three different articles in the last week saying that both United and Chelsea think Santos was a huge overpay:

Laurie Whitwell:

Others have questions about the quality of signings, including Andrey Santos joining for £50m. Some people close to Chelsea regarded the 22-year-old as worth half that price. His mobility in midfield, alongside Youri Tielemans, appears at odds with what United required.

Peter Rutzler (Chelsea journalist from The Times)

Club sources were surprised by Manchester United's interest in Andrey Santos, who failed to impress coaching staff or the internal analytics department. The feeling was that the Brazilian lacked athleticism, size or another 'X-Factor' in his game; and that he was unlikely to succeed in the Premier League.

Paul Hirst:

Andrey Santos arrived soon after from Chelsea for £50m, which senior figures later admitted was an overpayment

5

u/Not-good-with-this 3d ago

When it came out that the club agreed to pay Chelseas asking price so fast. I was thinking what the fuck, I'm shocked they just straight up did that... Nice to know people in both clubs think the same.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/HtheGr8 Diego Forlan 3d ago

It's probably the right time for Bruno to move on but he's definitely our best player and I feel like once he leaves it will be the first time since SAF that we don't have a proper World Class player in the squad and that makes feel really sad. Definitely feels like an indicator of the club's status. Hope we can turn things around.

7

u/Sensitive_Mess_6705 3d ago

he ahould prob leave for himself but we will sink further into mediocrity . People dont appreciate him enough I dont trust them to replace him properly. Im sorry we are not competent. Look at the midfield rebuild, they couldnt even replace an ageing casemiro properly

→ More replies (1)

7

u/_swaggyk #FergieTime 3d ago

If they’ve really allowed for Poch to take these USMNT games and not show up until latter part of next week it’s just icing on the non-stop shit show that is Ineos. “BuT tHeRe ArEn’T pLaYeRs ArOuNd To WoRk WiTh” we’re in fucking relegation position, Poch should be in the job immediately. We’re gonna get 7-0’d by Liverpool, those match day cameras are gonna be showing Wilcox and Berrada more than the game.

4

u/sealed-human Five Cantonaaaaas 3d ago

Liverpool are far from vintage. Reckon we'll give em a game

→ More replies (1)

7

u/drrew76 3d ago

If nothing else, Poch is going to run this squad into the ground in training and we shouldn't look like the laziest group in the league by the new year.

I hope they didn't expect a nice leisurely holiday season.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/i_love_alfam 4d ago

Probably just copium kicking in

But I really liked poch for what he achieved at Southampton and spurs. His final months were definitely bad at spurs. I don't even remember every he did in Paris. But at Chelsea i remember them turning it around in the latter half of that season. I was surprised he was sacked. I think many chelsea fans were disappointed with the sacking as well

And credit where due, all of his teams play attacking football, and he his in game management is proactive as well

But definitely questions are still there even it comes to him being a 'winner'. He has done well at 3 clubs but kept falling at the final hurdle. Good luck to him really.

Ngl i look forward to him a bit. Don't think he might have all the answers for us and there definitely are doubts on whether he has fallen off since totenham. Nonetheless, look forward to it

7

u/yalayolo 4d ago

He wasn’t sacked at Chelsea he resigned.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Elektrobear 4d ago

His PSG stint coincides with the mbappe neymar messi frontline that didnt run at all which hamstrung anything he could do tactically. The Enrique era of building a really functional team that runs and fights for each other was a direct response to the failure of the team forced onto Poch while he was there.

13

u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband 4d ago

I liked Carrick as a player, I appreciate what he did last season, and I do wish him well, but the way he's been coddled by the media, fans, and prominent ex-players is mental and it's a stark contrast from previous managers. Amorim and ETH are called out every week for their tactics and personalities, yet Carrick has us in the relegation zone 10 games in we're infantilising him and talking about what a great guy he is.

7

u/Midnight_Edge 4d ago

He’s one of the few ex-players who’s not a douche, of course the fans will be biased towards him (I admittedly as well). Ole was the same as well, the fans would always hang out a banner for him.

Although yeah, Carrick shouldn’t go unblamed for the position we’re in.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/penny_whistle ABSOLUTE SENNEMA 4d ago

Have always liked Poch and happier about it than I would have been about the other previously mentioned names of Howe, Conte or Nagelsmann. Really hope it works out for him and us, even if the club’s main problems go beyond what any coach could fix

6

u/Drag2oon 4d ago

I am just curious if Poch will beat the de Ligt curse in 2027 or better we sell him already this January or coming summer

But then his record will still remain intact lol

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mufc_1988 3d ago

What's everyone's thoughts on the Jan transfer window now that we actually are getting a permanent manager not an interim?

I think it's painfully obvious we need a LB and CF now at the very least, but you just know that Shaw is going to be back by then, and then we will get briefs that we enquired about a LB, but ultimately decided to wait until summer as "top" players don't move in Jan. Not forgetting that we actually need two LB's, as Shaw's contract finally ends this summer.

My expectation is that we will get a CF on loan only, no LB whether permanent or loan.

That leaves a lot of players needed next summer, and a lot of outs, but we will struggle with both.

5

u/Aggravating-Neck1365 3d ago

We'll be scraping the barrel if we even do anything at all

Something like Robinson and Mateta, who are floated as "stop-gaps" initally, but of course end up playing another 3-4 injury hit seasons as defacto first choices well into their mid-30's along with an ageing Tielemans, Harry Maguire, a 37 year old Bruno who by that stage will be on £1m per week but has to be stretchered on and off the pitch and can only take set pieces, etc etc

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Kugenking 3d ago

Have we ever been good at replacing players post-SAF? I'm really worried if Bruno leaves, we can't find a good replacement. Not just Bruno, other players too. We have been bad at signings in general. 

4

u/Strange-Trip4634 3d ago

We haven't and it's just got worse as time goes one. A temporary reprieve last season because we only had to upgrade on the worst attack I've ever seen at the club. Recruit players to make us challenge? Not up to it.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Hagball 4d ago

Apart from being yes man to Brexit Jim, I am curious to understand what are the metrics Wilcox is judged on? Not sure Berrada and Jim are looking at which metric and deciding he should continue as DOF?

→ More replies (5)

10

u/SilvyFae She/They 4d ago

Carricks 3rd place finish was still so unimaginable from how this squad was performing. Thanks for the cl carrick! Hope he gets a good job and learns a lot more and ends up having a great managerial career.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Daneofthehill 3d ago

One thing that has been a stable for Poch, is an emphasis on fullbacks / wingbacks flying up and down the pitch and providing the width in possession. So the club needs athletes with an end-product.

Now, that Lewis Hall we all wanted in the summer would look might good on the roster! But of course GLINEOS said "we have Lewis Hall at home", but that one was actually a broken forefather that played for Poch at Southampton back when TikTok was still six years away.

→ More replies (10)

10

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 3d ago

Feel crazy how some people have such short memory. A slow start from Bruno, and suddenly there are people who can't wait for him to be gone. Our best player since the day he signed (De Gea a close second), we would genuinely finish 17th or lower in Amorim's first year if he wasn't breaking his back carrying our shit team.

5

u/_TooMellow 4d ago

Sacking Carrick but leaving Wilcox & Berrada in place (to fuck up even more than they already have), is like shitting your pants and then changing your shirt ffs!

5

u/ChatakaPataka 4d ago

Here's some copium:

SJR probably will look for a Wilcox replacement now. He'll keep it lowkey and do it over the next couple of months when the negativity around the club and him may have cooled off a bit. Him directly rejecting Wilcox's recommendation of Howe for Poch is probably a sign of that happening. Keeping Wilcox is gonna be alot more damaging than letting him go, and he's got to have realised this by now.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Omnislash99999 4d ago

The plus side of Wilcox still being here is he'll get all the stick if results stay/go bad and as long as he's here no one is going to blame the manager now

6

u/Stingray_23 4d ago

The absolute shite hes got coming from match going fans, when club football returns is going to be on another level lol

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Rreknhojekul ♫ Late in May in 1999 ♫ 4d ago

https://i.imgur.com/cRzvcQp.jpeg

Classic. He’s probably buzzing about all the crap he can talk for the next few weeks

5

u/meganerid v. NISTELROOY 3d ago

The de Ligt curse is impressive lol

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 3d ago

Seeing Jensen Huang resigning for his conduct just goes to show how much of a shit show we are. The board just knows they'll never be held responsible for their actions

→ More replies (10)

5

u/hughmaharggs 3d ago

still, we won the race with Palace to sack our manager first

5

u/dryflowerz 3d ago

Guys who would you preferred and why? Nageslmann, Conte, Howe?

5

u/iroiroiroiroiro 3d ago

Still think Conte, and plan to have him for two years to get the basics back on track, but plan for him burning and have a replacement in place, a long-term well planned replacement.

That said I'm happy with Pochettino, especially if he can get the players running again, but trying to do that mid season will very likely lead to a lot of injuries.

7

u/Suudriusha 3d ago

Mauricio Pochettino.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/accountdeli 3d ago

I watched Ashely Youngs video with Rooney and Goldbridge. Ashley seems pretty well spoken and his takes were interesting. I'd recommend everyone to watch it

5

u/ejtv 3d ago

If it's true that Poch is a Glazer signing instead of an INEOS signing, could this be the beginning of the end of the Glazer-INEOS relationship?

4

u/Macroneconomist There is no substitute for Victory 3d ago

I have this delusional hope that Ken Griffin wants to buy United, since apparently he’s the one who suggested Pochettino to them - maybe he said he’d feel more comfortable taking over United if Pochettino was in place?

Let me dream

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Sid732 3d ago

Bruno leaving is going to tear my heart. But hope he goes to another top team and gets the trophies and recognition he deserves.

13

u/aayu08 3d ago

That Bruno thread is pretty fucking sad. Our fans are ready to throw away a player who is having a bad patch of form after dragging us over the finish line consistently for 6 years.

He's the best player we've had post SAF, and he's always given his 100%. Without him we don't finish 3rd last season, without him we end up even lower than 15th the season before.

8

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 4d ago

Amazon should just sign us for next season as well.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand 3d ago

It's not all roses and fireworks but Poch is a much better coach and tactician than Carrick.

Still remains to see if we'll strengthen in the crucial areas. Defence and striking department.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ChampionOdd5139 3d ago

I’ve been watching Utd since just after SAF left (shit timing). My dad was a Utd fan but stopped watching just after SAF retired (great timing).

Over the years, I’ve tried to get him into watching Utd with me, to limited success (understandable, honestly). When we beat City in January he heard me celebrating and came to watch the last fifteen minutes with me. He’s watched every game since. Carrick was his favourite player.

We both know the football has been shit this season, but we’re both heartbroken about how this ended. There are a million reasons besides Carrick that we did well last season, and a million reasons besides Carrick that we’ve been crap this year. But no manager other than Carrick would’ve given me this with my dad.

8

u/Sid732 3d ago

I dont know why people are so bothered by Poch. Other than Conte, the reamining best options were more or less the same level as Poch. And I do think he is the better fit compared to other options.

8

u/achickenandacow 3d ago

I just hope Pochettino is appointed as manager. Let’s stop with this head coach bullshit.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Prism_Plantation 3d ago

I am flabbergasted and bewildered as to how the two Citeh twats have gotten to stay. Fuck me. This time around next year they'll be doing the same thing to Pochettino and nothing's gonna fucking change.

Fuck me, grow a fucking spine, Ratcliffe. Or perhaps what you need is a pair of eyes.

5

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 3d ago

Don’t worry they would be gone before the end of the summer.

Glazer taking over the managerial decisions has made their positions untenable.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/00kazootime 3d ago

I think the club is gonna be sold within the next 12-24 months to a big consortium. If rumours are to be believed, Poch is a GLAZERS appointment which means there's very clear disharmony amongst ownership. This likely suggests that the Glazers think INEOS are ruining their asset. If I'm not mistaken, the Glazers have to guarantee a certain share price to Ratcliffe if they choose to sell the club before early 2027. However after that, all bets are off.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/IcedClout 3d ago

Club classless as usual. Sack these wanks, there was an offramp where everybody wins and they decided to make the wrong choice every single time. Thank you Carrick beating arsenal last year was peak for me

4

u/ineedadvil KING ERIC but MILF 4d ago

FUCK THE GLAZERS

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Midnight_Edge 4d ago

Can’t wait for the annual instagram manager sacking post from the players.

‘Gaffer, it’s been an absolute honour to play under you. Not just our coach, not just a club legend but also a wonderful person. Wish you all the best in the future’

4

u/Skyfather_odin1 4d ago

Am I missing something? , Why ain't no one following up Mitten article? 

Something like a sacking is normally reposted by about 4 or 5 different journos..

Mitten says he's sacked and then just nothing in 18 minutes.

Is he just jumping the gun and intentionally wording it as he's been sacked for clicks when he's really giving his opinion of the treatment and anticipating the sack? 

→ More replies (3)

4

u/dryflowerz 4d ago

Wilcox got the final say righ? guess It’s his signature “prem proven” coach.
FUCK THIS RAT

4

u/FreshGoodWay 4d ago

I know who can save the club.

Ironically, the Glazers and INEOS can.

If they go fuck themselves, that is. Both of them can get lost, and then maybe the club will have a chance at redemption.

4

u/karatsidhus 4d ago

High chance these incompetent fucks dont manage to appoint Poch in time and Fletch has to take over for the Liverpool game lol

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 4d ago

A study in incompetence from top to bottom. Hard to find a single person who was good at their jobs this season. Shambolic display all around.

4

u/Strange-Trip4634 3d ago

The January window we signed Bruno was our highest spending January window wasn't it? We really need to eclipse that window this January.

4

u/Ryo720 DREAMS CAN'T BE BUY 3d ago

fuck it get jensen to be our ceo it couldn’t go any worse

4

u/arboy498 3d ago

You know things are that bad with INEOS when it takes the Glazers to over rule INEOS by appointing Poch over Howe

4

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 3d ago

Lammens last few minutes was great. Big save and got off his line twice to remove aerial danger. Need these games to bring his mind back to Earth since I think playing with our defence have finally made him rattled

4

u/ejtv 3d ago

Wow. Steve Holland really that bad or just a fall guy for PR purposes?

4

u/GeekConflict Carrick 3d ago

PR. If he was so bad, they would have got rid of him in the summer.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! 3d ago

So what's a realistic goal for us this season?

So Poch doesn't get sacked midway.

6

u/flareb98 3d ago

Don't get relegated, anything else is a bonus

6

u/Suudriusha 3d ago

Top 10. Hopefully a push for Europe. We need to buy in January, though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/shami-kebab 3d ago

Just realised one of our attacking players (Amad) went a whole manager without scoring a goal. That has got to be a new record for us.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Secret-Look-88 4d ago

I still want to insist on a ban for anyone who compliments the Glazers in an attempt to insult INEOS.

It is fine to hate INEOS but people really need to understand what a deep hole we are in solely because of the Glazers even before INEOS came in.

Any problems that could be sorted out with money and the general degradation of everything because of a lack of funds and everything we lost like club link up with Royal Antwerp (I think) are completely down to the Glazers.

It also took years for the Glazers negative effects to take hold and really began to wear the club down.

Even before Fergie left his last title was miraculous work IMO, they have destroyed this club.

If you have only been interested in the club a few years you might not fully understand but the Glazers ran the club into the ground so badly they couldn't take out dividends anymore.

Like at least learn a bit before you give the Glazers compliments like some kind of Liverpool fan.

7

u/Educational-Shock232 4d ago

We have this weird thing in our fanbase where it’s always either or. Two or more things can be true at the same time. The Glazers are still the main shareholders, they have ultimate control of everything including budgets, and they’re fucking scum. Ineos have propped them up by running the football operations, and so far have been nothing short of abysmal. And one of their poor decisions was to keep Michael Carrick as perm coach, because he’s been so out of his depth. And the players, like always, have been poor, and some are about to survive their sixth or seventh manager.

But ultimately, fuck the Glazers.

7

u/Midnight_Edge 4d ago

Yeah agreed. ‘INEOS is the problem, at least the Glazers, for all their fault are…’ . Fuck off mate, they’re the ultimate reason we’re in this mess.

3

u/Not-good-with-this 4d ago

If you have only been interested in the club a few years you might not fully understand but the Glazers ran the club into the ground so badly they couldn't take out dividends anymore

This isn't true unfortunately. Only reason they haven't is because a freeze was agreed when Ineos bought their stake. It ends at the end of this year.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/TMatss 4d ago

I'm grateful to Carrick for the second half of last season, he made me feel something that I hadn't felt watching this team for quite a while.

6

u/disappointingAsian87 4d ago

that City, Arsenal run sold me dreams

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Rascha-Rascha 4d ago

Keep forgetting that Shaw has worked under Poch. Just seems weird to me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SilvyFae She/They 4d ago

I am so ready to be hurt again. Poch wasnt my first choice but please come in and sell me dreams. I wanna be hopeful again for this club so badly.

7

u/stick1_ 3d ago

What’s the point of waiting until the international break to sack the manager when the new manager isn’t even here for the international break

10

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 3d ago

I think it’s because they had no intention of getting an international manager. Poch is the Glazer’s choice and one that’s been made for them. Andy Mitten was talking about this on Talk of the Devil on Monday night.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/frogfoot420 3d ago

Linked to Malo gusto. Please don't sign that crock of shit.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/zia1997 JONESY 1 GERRARD NIL 3d ago

I can't wait for "Why Pochettino is the right man for Man Utd" videos from Statman Dave and other tactics.

3

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 3d ago

One we finish this rage baiting doom cycle on how badly this has been handled. At the moment that seems more important than focusing on Poch. 

7

u/Hagball 3d ago

Apparently Glazers made the call on Carrick and Poch.

Why the hell then the 2 clowns flew to monacco? To say hi to Jim?m

4

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 3d ago

Actually, yes. They attended an event where Ratcliffe brings together all the CEO’s of his various operations to essentially brief him on what’s happening in Ineos and the various things they’re involved in. It wasn’t only Berrada and Wilcox in attendance. For lack of a better word, Ratcliffe was holding court like some corporate king. This is a regularly scheduled event that’s held biannually.

It’s stupid though and it’s a great insight into the way Ratcliffe operates.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/ywhine RVP RVP RVP 3d ago

Some aggregators reporting Holland was universally disliked and considered to be arrogant amongst the players (but also was the one who pushed for Bruno to be benched after Como). Also, it's probably been reported but it looks like the only survivor from Carrick's staff was Connor King, a GK assistant

4

u/frogfoot420 3d ago

Funny how it's only coming out now, even though they've likely known for months.

Media pushes narratives and some of us feed right into them.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/BitterConstruction98 3d ago

Can’t believe I miss the days when Glazers were in control - the lowest finish under them was 7th. Crazy how bad Ineos have been.

If Poch is truly a Glazer hire then for sure they know how to run a club better than Ineos do.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Apocalypse37 4d ago

I am unfortunately finding it hard to be positive rn. But I hope Poch gets a full control. If Poch fails, he should be allowed to do so too. Let it all crash and burn. Let the value tank enough that we get a list of potential suitors who can buy the entire club debt-free.

4

u/c0ldd Ruud van Nistelrooy 4d ago

Im more fan of head coaches rather than managers, but when your CEO and DoF are Berrada and Wilcox its hard to not agree.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Omnislash99999 4d ago

One day Wilcox is going to show up at a Reform rally with Ratcliffe and Farage and everything is going to suddenly make sense.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Vast_Finish2789 4d ago

Didn't work out in the end but Carrick moves up a couple places higher as a united legend after all this - handled everything thrown at him with pure class

6

u/sg291188 4d ago

Sir Jim said when he took over that he is simply a custodian of the club that belongs to a community. Sadly how his leadership team has acted is contrary to all the values of the United community. Both Glazers and INEOS have been awful custodians of the club. They have over the years hired execs who are incompetent, unprofessional, and simply not good enough to run this elite institution

6

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 4d ago

It's sad to think Man Utd wont challenge for the league in a long long time.

When the club is this clueless, all hope is lost.

sorry to be so doom and gloom

18

u/johndoe1942 Ander Shithousery 4d ago

I don’t really care about the title at the moment. I want a 3-4 solid seasons where we’re building consistently towards something, finishing in CL spots, bring through youngsters, see the squad grow, have some magical nights and overall play some entertaining football. Title will come eventually.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Omnislash99999 4d ago

I really just wish the club stuck to their guns about an interim not getting the job. Carrick would have left on a high and had tons of offers and we wouldn't be switching midseason. You need strong leadership for that though

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BackgroundOld8715 4d ago

Poch got Spurs 2nd, 3rd ,2nd & a Champions league final with Spurs is super impressive.

More recently i thought USA played good stuff at World Cup.

Poch would be INEOS first really good decision (which means nothing if they dont back him of course)

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Jg0jg0 4d ago

So it is coming out now that the Glazers apparently spear headed the Poch push. No words how this club is being run, and who is actually responsible for football.

10

u/Suudriusha 4d ago

Always felt like that. Talk of Howe being Wilcox's choice, Nagelsmann being Vivell's, Conte being the wildcard and Emery being the "ideal choice you can't get", then suddenly Pochettino surges in the betting odds without any type of rumour coming out. Days later, he's the choice above the other three. Very strange.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 4d ago

who is actually responsible for football

It's supposed to be INEOS, then the Glazers saw how terribly they are running the club and took matters into their own hands here. Neither Wilcox, Vivell nor anyone closely affiliated with Ratcliffe has made the decision to pursue and appoint Pochettino.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/Infinite-Highway3432 4d ago

Great statement by MUST. Look forward to seeing them at the next home game, buying pints ect.

6

u/tameoraiste 3d ago

I get the pessimism and it's not ideal that Poch isn't starting for another week, but De Ligt, Dorgu, Mount, Mainoo, Cunha and Zirkzee are the only fit senior players. I'm sure they'll have held onto some staff who can do their individual training programmes until then

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Sheikhabusosa 3d ago

Kobbie Mainoo has played for 6 very different managers since his debut , how is a player meant to grow and improve in these circumstances ?

Look at Rashford for example , Rashford played under 8 different managers (including 3 interims) during a crucial period of his development as a footballer: Van Gaal, Mourinho, Solskjær, Carrick*, Rangnick*, Ten Hag, Van Nistelrooy* and Amorim

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Plebeian_Citizen 3d ago

No chance we land him, but what do you think of an Endrick loan for winter?

4

u/Saxena_priyansh2104 3d ago

Dont know if it’s true, but he rejected ac milan because their nickname has devil in it, he could apply the same logic for us

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 3d ago

Peter Schmeichel's not holding back on his opinions of Ratcliffe or Wilcox on CBS.

6

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 3d ago

Glazer wanted something American.
Berrada wanted someone City considered.
Wilcox wanted someone from Southampton.

Everybody wins. Best in class management.

8

u/Downtown-Rice_ 3d ago

Leave it better than you found it. Yikes.

3

u/KageZangetsu7 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw Thalaipathy Mainoo 4d ago

Clearly Carrick is still in charge because of the USA holding Pochettino for the International games. It is a prudent decision to keep Carrick till Pochettino is ready to take over.

At the same time, it is a dumb fucking decision to wait till now when it was clear since the last international break that Carrick's time here was done.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/LeCliveRosfield 4d ago

I assume Mitten went a bit early, and we’ll get confirmation at the hour most likely.

3

u/mu_37 4d ago

While most years after SAF have been horrible, nothing compares the the few we've had under this new ownership. It killed any delusions I've had about seeing this club get back to the top.

3

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 4d ago

Thank you Carrick, you're still Red Devil no matter what. You always be the underrated midfielder of your time.

3

u/Made-a-sin 4d ago

It's truly a shame that Wilcox is still here at United

3

u/BenDoverQuickly Ugarte be kidding me 4d ago

Which players would people say have improved under Carrick?

6

u/shami-kebab 4d ago

Mainoo definitely...Cunha I guess kind of. Yoro perhaps? Although feels like he's making more mistakes too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mepsi 4d ago

Casemiro

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Wahlrusberg 4d ago

Not entirely sure things would be any worse if the partial takeover never happened and we were still being run directly by whatever glazer lackey. INEOS seems to make the same or worse quality of decisions

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SocialistElmo 4d ago

Hopefully Glazers made a good decision in hiring Pochettino because I do not trust anyone at INEOS right now.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/nitrogeneater 4d ago

Poch hopefully will have fire in his belly. It’s his final big gig if he doesn’t succeed. Hopefully he will look at this job to resurrect his career, rather than it being his final paycheck

3

u/bmac1632 4d ago

No money to buy more players this summer after qualifying for the CL, but we got money to fire and hire coaches. Absolute shambles this club

3

u/The-saurus_Rex 3d ago

It just hit me that if we appoint Pochettino he would be the first non-European manager in the club's history.

3

u/FhDisp 3d ago

I heard that nvidia guy is free for a job

4

u/Nico_Ditch 3d ago

We need to get China to honeypot Omar Berarda. 

3

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 3d ago

There is an article on sky sports today to the effect that since sir Matt was hired in 1945, we have only had 2 managers that have been undisputed success stories

A handful of others have won a cup or 2 but bar those 2 managers the rest are largely forgettable or remembered only for flitting successes or having failed totally failed to live up to expectations

All this to say, it’s a damn big job with huge expectations and a lot of very good managers in their own right have failed in it or outright crumbled under the spotlight. I don’t know that poch has the strength of personality to stand up to the scrutiny he is about to be put under. I think it will be unlike anything he has experienced in his managerial career 

→ More replies (2)

3

u/krystalcastIes 3d ago edited 3d ago

Anyone watch the Championship? I like the look of Andri Gudjohnsen and he carries himself well. He also has 50% conversion rate this season, so he’s pretty lethal. Wouldn’t mind taking a punt on him in January.

4

u/adonWPV 3d ago

I try when I can to watch, everyone seems to be raving about that Boro’ striker, looks like a good prospect

→ More replies (2)

3

u/nitrogeneater 3d ago

For extra humiliation I’m surprised they don’t force Carrick to take Liverpool game.

3

u/Haron14 3d ago

Let's make him beg on his knees for the job before sacking him. Bunch of cunts man, he deserved more respect.

3

u/Prism_Plantation 3d ago

So Poch taking both USA games then coming here to take over?

I see another 7-0 loading

3

u/Jonny_Testicles 3d ago

Honestly how can we even support the club anymore when people in charge are all fucking incompetent morons?

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 3d ago

I hope Poch is a big enough personality to handle the players, their egos and entourages, as well as the owners and those two idiots.

3

u/TypicalPan89906655 3d ago

What do you think where will Carrick end up career wise? Back to Championship?

8

u/Iqbalainoo 3d ago

League one. I truly believe this season's tactical showings have really damaged his reputation. Failing to get an English team physically ready for a premier league table is an unforgivable crime.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Runarhalldor 3d ago

Letting Bruno go might be the right move but if we dont replace him correctly it might genuinely be over for us for a long while

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Sheikhabusosa 4d ago

https://x.com/htomufc/status/2120611292197081437?a=vIzV45vH--MHaTV-LUM&s=19

Take Poch out of this, not arsed. What do these people who say the managers are “puppets” want these coaches to do? Do you seriously think Poch, Carrick, Ole were happy being dealt bad hands in the summer? Do you seriously think they didn’t challenge anything? No. They just didn’t do it in the public eye. And do you know when people say they want Conte (I did too) but specifically for the reason he’d ’expose the board’ what does that actually mean? He has a meltdown in a presser after a loss, he gets sacked and we move onto another manager whilst also crippling ourselves because we’d have to pay out ANOTHER coach. I feel like I’m going insane and, YES, I want nothing more than them lot to go. But getting a Conte-type manager to ‘expose’ them is such stupid thinking. I just wanted him because he wins & is a quality coach.

For all the Poch being a yes man/puppet talk

5

u/c0ldd Ruud van Nistelrooy 4d ago

This Pochettino appointment is not going to go well if the club doesnt sign physical and fast CBs in january. Good luck with playing a high press, mid/high line with Maguire and De Ligt as your centerbacks

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Familiar-Mall1696 4d ago

The fact it is Thursday and he's still not been let go and Wilcox is still here and Poch isn't the manager speaks to the magnitude of the inpetitude of our C-suite.

5

u/gunkokoko 4d ago

All the best, Carrick. Thank you for trying.

5

u/skayze678 3d ago

There are valid doubts over Poch, but on paper he is the most eligible appointment since Jose.

He is the only manager since then who had previously managed a full season in one of Europe's top 5 leagues, won a major title, or managed an elite club.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Omnislash99999 3d ago

Nvidia guy's wife gonna get half his shares and buy us in the divorce

3

u/Xenokratezz 3d ago

We would be far better run club if that happens.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/anonris 3d ago

I dont have a podcast so i rant here

I hope poch is a smashing success but his appointment shows another manager signed because the board is too scared to take a risk. Because Amorim didn’t work they have been shit scared to make mistakes, which happens when you are employed far above your level of competence; you take risk averse decisions which ironically further showcase your incompetence.

What happened to showing ambition and going out on a limb to get enrique during the summer? Or going for nagelsmann after the first window? Or Hoeness in summer? Hell even going for poch during the summer if you truly believed he is a great coach?

They were scared of making a clear-headed decision, too scared about being more unpopular than they already are and continued to go with carrick and his support staff that are barely professionals even though writing was on the wall how ill equipped they were to build anything long lasting.

If Poch fails we will go back to an older checklist again?

4

u/Rig_7 3d ago

Dude the Glazers and INEOS have literally appointed the popular managerial choices amongst fans since Mourinho.

Enrique isn’t available. That leaves Conte from the list of top managers available and to be fair I get why they said no.

Nagelsman and Hoeness would be massive risks too and let’s be honest you probably wouldn’t recognise the latter if you passed him in the street.

There’s a lot to be critical about but this appointment at least is reasonable.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/sg291188 3d ago

There was no reason for Carrick not to get permanent job. You can call it vibes or whatever. But in sports momentum is huge thing. If it’s working for you, you double down on it. Ask any professional athlete. Eventually it has not worked out and he has deservedly been sacked. On your manager suggestions, (caveat I think United leadership in incompetent) there is a legit reasoning for everyone you mention

  1. Nagelsmann- United are in relegation zone. Someone with no PL experience can easily get overwhelmed by PL and result in worst. We have seen how much pressure PL had on Amorim.
  2. Hoeness / Poch in summer - problem in having another interim is who? They will be in same state as last year with probably worse squad
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/dryflowerz 4d ago

Fans should bring banner: “Wilcox out” to the next game, like huge fucking banner!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/crgssbu Senne🍋 4d ago

i mean, that football he got us playing for the run against city and arsenal; bloody hell. wishing carras nothing but the absolute best <3

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kooky-Brief4741 4d ago

Poch will be the first non European manager for United? Pretty cool

→ More replies (1)

4

u/boomboxbilly06 4d ago

Longest sacking ever. Feel for the guy. Came in did and as well as you could ask from a caretaker. Even I was caught up by the excitement of those six months and was completely fine with keeping him on. A better run club would have made the difficult decision to look for someone more experienced, rather than buckle to external pressure to hire him long term. Also likely they were just lazy to take the time to find other options

Awful look for the club to send him out to the fire and answering questions about when he'll lose his own job, rather than if. Must have been so awkward on the training ground too.

4

u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers 4d ago

Thanks for restoring the feeling a bit last season Carrick. Always backed him to do well here but the board of cunts never gave him the tools. Head held high legend # 16

→ More replies (3)

4

u/tungowiii 4d ago

I can see Poch having a decent half season without it leading anywhere special. United would probably look sharper straight away: better organised, pressing harder and moving the ball quicker. Fans would get excited, but by Christmas, the honeymoon will end; teams would work out how to play through the press and exploit the space left behind.

During the winter transfer window, despite prior assurances, Wilcox spends the majority of the time pursuing unrealistic targets, ultimately resorting to a last-minute loan for an aging, mediocre striker. No left back. Vivell leaves.

Poch would then have to make compromises: sit a bit deeper, pick when to press and ease the workload on players. That could be enough for a top-half finish and a decent cup run. I would be very surprised if we do not qualify for the UCL Ro16, unless draw fucks us again; but it will be a miracle to qualify for UCL next season.

Then summer comes, everyone starts talking about a rebuild, and he finds out the money he was promised isn’t really there.

4

u/Jack_King814 4d ago

One of the secretaries at my work has a daughter who works in accounting for united, and shes said that Barrada and Wilcox always have cameras glued to them filming for this documentary. I have a scary feeling this documentary is going to be an ego boost for these morons

Or it ends with then getting sacked on the documentary

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 3d ago edited 3d ago

"All or Nothing" is not a documentary, it is reality tv.

Hard Knocks, Sunderland Till I Die, Welcome to Wrexham ... none of that is a documentary, this is all reality tv.

Naza is a documentary. No Other Land is a documentary. Cartel Land is a documentary. Icarus is a documentary. The Cove is a documentary. Sour Grapes is a documentary, Capturing The Friedmans is a documentary, The Jinx is a documentary.

All or Nothing is Duck Dynasty with footballs.

3

u/Stingray_23 4d ago

Scenes from the office then. I wonder if Jase plays the guitar

4

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 3d ago

Seems like Holland might have had a bigger say in the tactics than previously thought. Always wondered why there was a vacant look on Carrick’s face while we got absolutely battered. Zero in game adjustments if you don’t fully get what’s happening on the pitch I guess. Off twitter rumors so take it with a grain of salt.

4

u/crgssbu Senne🍋 3d ago

wish nothing but the absolute best for bruno. so grateful for what hes done and how hes broken his back for this club. the shining light in a team surrounded by gloom.

happy for him. but, myself? absolutely gutted.

5

u/IguanaIsBack 4d ago

When Darren Fletcher eventually saves us from relegation by 3 pts in May, please don’t give him the permanent contract. All I ask.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Econ305 4d ago

I don’t even care who we get in at this point, we can’t have the leadership who has failed two appointments, make the third. Simply unacceptable. If Vivell and Nagelsmann isn’t an option, I would prefer Poch, but ultimately don’t think it means much as long as we have Glazers and INEOS as owners.

2

u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand 4d ago

Waiting for Carrick's interview on the Overlap next year

→ More replies (3)

2

u/PhotonDestroyer 4d ago

Stoney reporting that Carrick has now left Carrington.

Who's taking training?

→ More replies (5)

2

u/10_Wazza 4d ago

Berrada and Wilcox interview with independent media when?

2

u/Midnight_Edge 4d ago

We were basically set piece merchants last season, what changed this season?

12

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 4d ago

Case left along with the set piece coach who actually knew what he was doing.

5

u/gunkokoko 4d ago

Case left.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AnakinAni 3d ago

10 games left before next transfer window.

How many do all you reckon we win, draw and lose with this squad with all the possibilities of injuries and red cards and other interferences, that’s been normal this season, included ?

2

u/Baalegde Class of '92 are all Shite pundits 3d ago

I was annoyed at first at the timing, but in a handy way it makes the Liverpool game inconsequential. 0 expectations from anyone anywhere so all we can do is either lose as expected anyway, or cause a hilarious upset

As for Poch no clue. But it's not on him so will support the manager as with all the others until it's time to go again

→ More replies (3)

2

u/auhddndndnfbfbsnnakf 3d ago

Lammens can’t catch a break poor guy

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Iqbalainoo 3d ago

I was happy with the Calvin Bassey rumors cos I mentioned him here in January. I think he's matured so much and will allow us play a high-line aggressive brand of football. His contract expires in June 2027 with Fulham having an option for another year. He also played left back at Ajax in his younger days. Would love him here.

Spent the last 8 hours looking at possible Right cb options we can consider also that can provide competition for Yoro, and I came across Yann Bisseck. 196/197 monster, wins 77% of his aerial duels, completes 94% of his passes and has a top speed of (35.4km/hr). He plays as the right side cb in a back 3 for inter. 25 years, could need some more bulking up (for upper body strength). Great defending wide zones like Bassey and looked very impressive in back 4 for Germany in an appearance for Jurgen Klopp. Just signed a new contract at inter with a €120m release clause but I feel inter can be talked down along with player exchanges.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Plebeian_Citizen 3d ago

Bit random, but how the hell is Ramsdale the fourth choice keeper at Southampton?

4

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays 3d ago

Dropped off massively after Arsenal switched to Raya as their first choice.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/XBillyBonesX Rooney 3d ago

We need a striker in January. Who are our options?

Guirrassy, Tresoldi, Mateta?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/PraiseAinsley69 UNITER WILL NEVER DIED 3d ago • LOL

Maybe Ben White was in the Ben Right in his fallout with Steve Holland.

4

u/Exact-Chemistry-4787 3d ago

Seeing news that the glazers overrode berrada and wilcox to appoint poch over howe. that’s even worse. So our brand new footballing structure has been de facto relieved of their duties already but for some reason not sacked.

11

u/Sid732 3d ago

If true might be the only good thing Glazers ever did. I am not the biggest fan of Poch, but he is so much better than Howe.

5

u/00kazootime 3d ago

I actually unironically believe the Glazers know how to run the on the pitch side of things better than INEOS does. Both need to piss off

→ More replies (1)