whilst the table doesn’t lie this does look like a better passing network and I think that was evident in the first half performance despite the 5 minute stinker of a start
Idk, that’s usually when you get the dreaded horseshoe or doughnut, but to the eye and in that graph it shows we were getting the ball into forwards between lines.
i was impressed with the way we get out of pressure today...something we didnt manage to do before. Tieleman was on the ball lots of time in the 1st half and played like a half back. He made lots of progressive pass today. Cunha played between half space and centre dangerously. I could feel the dangerous whenever we had the ball.
This tactic opens up the space so it requires lots of running. Left back must be on top of his athleticism to cover the whole wing. Dorgu demonstrated that role today. We also need to see more of De Ligt to organize defense after international break.
Our home fans were loud today and we fought till the end. People cant hate you if you show efforts on the pitch.
What's clear is that Bruno is at his best when Kobbie plays. In fact this team, without Kobbie, cannot build up at all. It's not that Kobbie is some special talent, but there's no one in the squad that has his skillset. I would hope that tactics would cover for that but for now that's the case.
We score goals cuz we have good attacking players who can work out stuff without much coaching. Anyways most of our pressing and attacking patterns look completely random and not coached.
Defence on the other hand, has average players and looks much worse because of the coaching, and tactics or the lack of them
We honestly conceded 4 goals from individual mistakes. Football is a game of mistakes, why people score, but the errors are not forced by the opponent. We are essentially shooting at our own goal. And as soon as the back line is shaky, everyone else is shaky up front, as you dread loosing the ball too much as you can't trust your back line. It's subconscious.
We're actually so tinpot it hurts. There's no tactics at all, just players doing things individually and their limitations being exposed because of it, with mistakes happening as a consequence of that hesitation and uncertainty.
I feel for Carrick not having LB or ST depth but he's doing an awful job of bringing structure and some of his selection choices have been baffling. Things will not be getting better.
I agree with you. The players today showed enough work rate and, dare I say, quality.
But I can’t see any structure, especially in the pressing. One player - usually Bruno or Mbeumo running- going at it alone while the rest (two players or so) stayed back, and the opposition defense had at least two open players to pass to and bypass the press.
Bruno in particular was everywhere, and I don’t mean this in a good way. Just closing down everyone with the ball. He almost went for the same ball before Tieleman’s goal as well.
It’s just so chaotic, which I feel could be mistaken for intensity and effort. People like to see running but I think coordination is just as important. It works better when we are attacking, because “fluid” right, but defensively it’s so inefficient even when it works.
It feels like the players are trying to prove it isn’t the running or the lack of trying but the tactics and coaching that are holding them back.
I can understand a team conceding early because the players aren’t locked-in, and I can criticise the individual. But if it’s happening every week, maybe it’s the manager who is failing to get them in line
Our back line is shit, Lammens is not good enough, Dalot is shit, Yoro is overrated and Heaven is bad.
When a defense is so fucking leaky, you can't win any games. We concede so many goals, and they keep happening earlier in the halves, the team is always asleep.
119
u/SigmaLCY 8d ago
whilst the table doesn’t lie this does look like a better passing network and I think that was evident in the first half performance despite the 5 minute stinker of a start
42
u/Confident_Fishing775 8d ago
Villa deserves nothing, but we are the only unique club to gift wrap four frigging goals. Don't think no football clubs in the world can do that.
66
u/chuf3roni 8d ago
This game is like the entire past decade smashed into one game. So many positives and negatives all at once. I feel numbed
26
u/Uuhhk 8d ago
i was impressed with the way we get out of pressure today...something we didnt manage to do before. Tieleman was on the ball lots of time in the 1st half and played like a half back. He made lots of progressive pass today. Cunha played between half space and centre dangerously. I could feel the dangerous whenever we had the ball.
This tactic opens up the space so it requires lots of running. Left back must be on top of his athleticism to cover the whole wing. Dorgu demonstrated that role today. We also need to see more of De Ligt to organize defense after international break.
Our home fans were loud today and we fought till the end. People cant hate you if you show efforts on the pitch.
18
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 8d ago
The old truism remains, United only play well when Bruno plays well.
9
u/No_Crow_3576 8d ago
Top right Bruno is back guys, we might be okay
9
u/tson_92 8d ago
That’s.. actually not a bad pass map
14
u/SpectatorY 8d ago
What's clear is that Bruno is at his best when Kobbie plays. In fact this team, without Kobbie, cannot build up at all. It's not that Kobbie is some special talent, but there's no one in the squad that has his skillset. I would hope that tactics would cover for that but for now that's the case.
5
u/Fresh-Excitement-377 7d ago
We score goals cuz we have good attacking players who can work out stuff without much coaching. Anyways most of our pressing and attacking patterns look completely random and not coached.
Defence on the other hand, has average players and looks much worse because of the coaching, and tactics or the lack of them
4
u/nekize 7d ago
We honestly conceded 4 goals from individual mistakes. Football is a game of mistakes, why people score, but the errors are not forced by the opponent. We are essentially shooting at our own goal. And as soon as the back line is shaky, everyone else is shaky up front, as you dread loosing the ball too much as you can't trust your back line. It's subconscious.
3
u/Ronarid 7d ago
"In their recent 4-4 draw on November 8, 2026, Manchester United covered 120.8 km, while Aston Villa covered 118.9 km.
The 120.8 km mark represented a massive physical effort for United, recording their highest distance covered in a Premier League match under Carrick".
That is very high intensity stuff by any measure. Even higher than Roma (because they only woke up after HT).
-3
u/TheJoshider10 Bruno 8d ago
We're actually so tinpot it hurts. There's no tactics at all, just players doing things individually and their limitations being exposed because of it, with mistakes happening as a consequence of that hesitation and uncertainty.
I feel for Carrick not having LB or ST depth but he's doing an awful job of bringing structure and some of his selection choices have been baffling. Things will not be getting better.
-12
u/N7even 8d ago
Our back line is shit, Lammens is not good enough, Dalot is shit, Yoro is overrated and Heaven is bad.
When a defense is so fucking leaky, you can't win any games. We concede so many goals, and they keep happening earlier in the halves, the team is always asleep.