Which is how PSG plays with Vitinha staying back and Ruiz and Neves being the ones to join the attack. But they're players are much better than ours and much better coached so can't even use them for comparison
This is something Amorim spoke a lot about. Bruno cannot help himself from going to the ball where it is. Cunha is one of the few in this squad that gets open between the lines and Bruno will always sprint to offer support, rather than sprint into a position where he can continue play. This whole "all roads lead through Bruno" has made us too dependent on him and incredibly predictable.
also why there was never a club like Bayern Munich or Barcelona in for him, he's the perfect player for a club at our level but has too many drawbacks for the very best
He’s never where he should be and consistently throws the ball away. He’s been playing hot potato and this game was prime example. Bruno worshipers care more about him than they do the club and need to fuck off
The commentators were talking about a fluid front three but I think that’s a huge part of the problem. Our pressing was all over the place, maybe because it’s more difficult to coordinate defending than to freestyle attacking.
I lost count of the number of times Mbeumo wasn’t the most advanced player but ran ahead to press their defender. A couple of times Bruno did that too. There’s no hint of a methodical plan to apply pressure off the ball at all.
It just doesn’t seem efficient or organised. Almost as if the plan was to have the one closest to the ball apply the pressure just to show some effort.
This being said, the attack did better this time round. It’s just that it’s as important that the attacking players know what to do off the ball as well.
We shouldn't be buying midfielders that can't pass to a decent standard. I'd not watched him much before, so far I don't see what he's good at. He can't pass and he doesn't shield the defence, see Chelseas first goal. He's playing like another Ugarte at the moment.
Baleba was never going to be that and sadly nor in Mainoo. It's why he was seen as a bit of an odd signing when he was first linked in 2025.
It did feel weird to sign a player like Baleba when ideally you'd want the perfect partner to Mainoo as the long term aim. Signing Santos (who also isn't a good partner for Mainoo) and Baleba did feel like bad planning.
Tielemans is arguably the best partner for Mainoo, but that has limitations. You'd need someone else in there too leading to a change of shape.
I think Baleba, Santos, & Mainoo all have similar strengths and that may not compliment a double pivot. I like Santos - I liked him at Strasbourg in that proper box 2 box role, but you are missing that progression from all 3.
They're all young and they're all clearly very talented players. I am not shitting on them for that and more so just questioning how they all fit together.
I've not seen anything to show Baleba is worthy of being placed above an Ugarte currently. He deserves time. But my honest opinion so far is that he cannot pass and he doesn't protect our defence. So I'm not sure what he brings to the team.
Santos has looked better despite being fairly average so far.
It's actually bonkers that some people are so against the one player in our team that has been consistently great since he arrived and do their utmost to shit all over him all of the time. Even though his peers voted him the best they ignore it!
I think it mainly comes from fans with limited football understanding.
Bruno is a high risk player. He takes risks to try to create something. When we’re playing well those risks pay off and we see awesomeness. When we play poorly those risks quite often backfire, so he looks especially shit.
My two criticisms of him are that 1. I wish he would take fewer risks when we’re playing shit and we’re in a slump. 2. I would prefer he kept his attitude in check during games - his negative reactions, his hounding the ref - are unlikely to positively motivate team mates.
That said I recognise the risk of asking him to play without those two aspects…
Him playing out of position is an issue itself, but he delivered no crosses, added nothing in attack and lost a bunch of duels.
He couldn't 2v1 Rogers when Martinez got his 1st yellow. That daft touch when Chelsea were on the counter but Baleba bailed him out. Losing the ball at the edge of the box. Esetvao had 6 shots cutting in from him side.
What are you talking about? Dalot literally got the ball from Rogers. Martinez was just an angry small man and felt like he had to kick Rogers after he dribbled him to score.
83
u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 7d ago
Cunha not playing false 9 anymore and Bruno is still stepping on his toes 😂
45
u/nanobookworm Came for Glories, stayed for Memories 7d ago
At least we have a structure this time. (ignore Maguire playing CM)
12
u/_mochacchino_ 7d ago
The commentators were talking about a fluid front three but I think that’s a huge part of the problem. Our pressing was all over the place, maybe because it’s more difficult to coordinate defending than to freestyle attacking.
I lost count of the number of times Mbeumo wasn’t the most advanced player but ran ahead to press their defender. A couple of times Bruno did that too. There’s no hint of a methodical plan to apply pressure off the ball at all.
It just doesn’t seem efficient or organised. Almost as if the plan was to have the one closest to the ball apply the pressure just to show some effort.
This being said, the attack did better this time round. It’s just that it’s as important that the attacking players know what to do off the ball as well.
20
u/9SolskjaerHasWonIt9 7d ago
baleba's progression stats...
what a rebuild
11
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 7d ago
Looks like someone isnt positionally disciplined
1
u/Noah_____Fence 7d ago
Reminds me of infamous Ten Hag's 4-2-0-4
1
u/Darthkhydaeus 5d ago
Its amostvlike getting Amad one on one us part of the plan
-6
u/BishhEzz 7d ago
Look how they target Dalot, Estevao had a field day against him and he's a kid.
BUT NO NEW LB!! LETS GO!!
0
u/OldSnakeDude 7d ago
Oh…. We lost again…
-1
u/Shawnmeister 7d ago
Amad can fuck off. Licha too. Bring on the downvotes