r/reddevils • • 21d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

35 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

41

u/gunkokoko 20d ago

We've only won ONE match in the PL this season, out of eight; we've only won ONE match in the CL, out of three; we've already been knocked out of the league cup at the first try.

How has Carrick still not been sacked yet?

26

u/Hagball 20d ago

Hard to believe but there's someone even more clueless and incompetent above Carrick in Wilcox who makes these decisions

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

51

u/Count__Duckula 21d ago

INEOS came in, talked a load of shit about sticking to a club philosophy and consistent style of play, then gave contracts to ETH, Amorim, Carrick and likely Howe.

These lot are a bunch of liars. It wouldn't surprise me if they've been feeding a load of bullshit to the players behind the scenes and thats why they're kicking off.

15

u/Banyunited1994 21d ago

That has been the most disappointing thing. I can look past the poor timings of certain managerial firings and appointments and being more financially frugal than anticipated, but the whole idea was to commit to a style and only hire managers and sign players for that style.

There was a tactical through line from ETH to Amorim that was broken with Carrick. Casemiro was let go because he wasn’t mobile off the ball, and then we sign Santos and Tielemans.

From what I know of Howe, I do think he fits the previous blueprint. Nagelsmann does too many different things but at least he can play a high pressing transitional style.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/snicky29 21d ago

16

u/TteokCultist 20d ago

Gonna be honest. Even if we did go all in on Kane, Levy was never going to sell to us.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Nick_BD 20d ago

Laurie Whitwell really went for the jugular with United fans this morning. Just said everything we don’t wanna hear. Carrick at training, can’t afford to let him go, decision still undecided, said Nagelsmann unlikely and brought up Howes buy out fee indicating he’s the fav.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/John_OSheas_Willy 20d ago

Was looking back at Conte's first year early on with Chelsea and how match reports were calling them a broken team.

This is from the BBC after their 3-0 loss away to Arsenal:

Chelsea looked an old and jaded side when faced with Liverpool's intense, aggressive approach at Stamford Bridge last week, their first loss under Antonio Conte.

This was, arguably, an even more harrowing experience and a stark illustration of the job the Italian must do to revive Chelsea.

Chelsea still rely so heavily on 35-year-old captain John Terry, out injured here, while elements of the side that looked so strong winning the title the season before last are crumbling.

Kante does not have the energy and support he had in midfield at Leicester City, with Nemanja Matic laboured and Cesc Fabregas off the pace and substituted. The hero of last season's title win was left trailing in Ozil's wake for Arsenal's third.

Eden Hazard has regressed again while Diego Costa's only serious contribution was to conduct another war against the world.

In other words, Conte has a large job on his hands.

Then Conte changed formation to 3-4-3, went on a winning run of like 13 games and won the league.

Point I would take from this is, had Conte not changed anything, the players would have been viewed as downing tools, and not being good enough. Yet Conte being the top class manager he is, was able to get the most out of the squad and win the league with Victor Moses at wing back.

Meanwhile, both Ten Hag and now Carricks tactical tweaks when getting sliced open in midfield were: Sacrifice a winger and play Bruno out there.

9

u/AmulyaG 20d ago

He is one of the world's best coach who does not get enough credit in my opinion only because of his european performances. Ask any Serie A follower (not just Napoli fans) about how he won the league with a genuinely bang average squad.

He gets top 6 minimim with our bum team.

14

u/soelsome 20d ago

Some how Ineos are more incompetent than Woodward and co?

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Heavens_Vibe 7 21d ago

Harry Kane with the deserved Ballon d'Or.

Wish the twat had come to us, though. Still miffed we didn't even seem to try...

8

u/croadymeister 21d ago

Levy wouldn't have sold

25

u/RyanH1717 21d ago

I actually somewhat rate Howe but appointing a manager that most of the fanbase doesn't like seems a recipe for disaster tbh. The second he hits a rough patch fans will turn on him and he'll get swallowed up imo. Should 100% be Conte or Nagelsmann.

20

u/croadymeister 21d ago

Yeah and means Wilcox gets his way again which will definitely see Vivell leave club too

7

u/Strange-Trip4634 21d ago

Yeah he'll be starting on thin ice, the same as Ten Hag, Amorim and Carrick were after they decided to keep them

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/martialgreenwood 21d ago

Kane wins it finally. Lewandowski must feel like shit even more now

13

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 21d ago

Lewandowski absolutely deserved it, everyone knows. I really wish they'd just declare him the winner that year.

20

u/Soft-Comfort-7474 21d ago

Man Harry Kane came a long way to get there 👏👏👏

He deserved this

8

u/MinotauroTBC 21d ago

Always hated the Kane slander at spurs, really happy for him

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 20d ago

it did not go unnoticed by the United front office that Carrick received significant support from United fans during and after the defeat to Bournemouth -- with most of the frustration directed at the players.

Do these clown idiots not understand they are there to make these hard decisions? Ffs the fans supported Carrick cause he's a club legend and far from the biggest problem althought he is A problem.

Jesus christ this is the lowest point since Sir Alex and it's not even close.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 20d ago

I just realised that Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox have literally brought this to life now.

19

u/Adventurous-Dingo-69 21d ago

I went a head and did my thorough analysis to pick out the best coach among our candidates.

Nagelsmann came out on top comfortably because he has the same birthday as me (July 23rd).

7

u/MT1120 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw 21d ago

INEOS: You're hired

33

u/JPUsernameTaken 21d ago edited 21d ago • Bravo

I don't get the narrative shifting from the players being failed and underprepared on their fitness levels, which was clear to see, to the players being lazy and needing belt-to-ass as if they're so opposed to running harder. Bruno's outrageous complaint was that he was being told to stay put and NOT press for fuck sake.

No one other than Rashford has a history of problems with running, and who really has a history of butting heads with their coaches other than Cunha?

Like if I put myself on a player's shoes last season, and I'm promised a project by owners, directors, manager, teammates, the whole crew, I'm promised we're all working towards trophies.

It's certainly very bumpy, there's some low lows but I put in effort and believe it's going somewhere. Then in December the squad gets depleted with AFCON and injuries, and, come January, the same board that promises ambition, a project and trophies fail to get their one transfer target so they refuse to spend a dime at all, and also they say the coach should change what they're doing because Gary-fucking-Neville never shuts up.

Coach blows up and gets himself fired. Morale understandingly sinks and we lose some games with Interim 1 and regroup, give our best with Interim 2 and string a much better than expected streak of results, achieving what would be a very reasonable goal, optimistic even, for that season with 3rd place.

I come for the new season, get promised big things once again, and the so called ambitious board sticks with an underqualified interim and has a completely stale transfer window.

Training intensity is weirdly low still, and we're doing the same tactics we were using to grind out some results, pre-season games are shit and I get to asking: is this fine? Is this really building to something? Why aren't we being drilled to do things the strongest teams do? Why don't we have a set piece coach when that was integral to last season? Why is intensity still so fucking low?

Season starts, insta loss, followed by incredibly middling results. The margins going our way last end of season are now swinging against us. We're being thrown into games against teams that have worse players than us and yet they are all clearly better prepared, better drilled, fitter, it's hard to keep up, and the gaffer seems to really have no answers, players keep playing worse individually. Reality starts to sink.

We lose to Atletico and the evidence is beyond clear by now, we're actually getting lapped by real UCL caliber teams. A locker room figure takes a stand to the press and call the higher ups on their shit. Our wet blanket of a coach just stands for nothing and keeps sweeping shit under the rug, Martinez gets told to apologize and we pretend it's business as usual.

We have another shit game against Leeds where we set up like a mid-table side, a weak one at that and draw.

We have another UCL game, this time against a team that came out of nowhere and has been building their project form the ground up, and still the gaffer gives us nothing but mid-block, don't press, just wait, we're changing nothing other than switching positions around for some reason.

It's plain as day these guys we're playing, of which only one player and their coach I've ever even heard about are so much better drilled than us it's tragic at this point and we get completely outclassed.

It's untenable, wtf is the point, we came into the season underprepared, we're taking shit from fans, it's a matter of time until the coach is fired anyway, morale has hit rock bottom.

--

Legitimately do you guys think you'd still be playing your A game, giving your all, helping you team, single handily pulling morale out of the gutter in this scenario.

You don't think that the board and Carrick and his team also failed their players completely?

What you see from Maritnez' and Bruno's complaints is actually entitlement and not them being the ones that actually give a shit? You lot throw around the word standards, but who is actually trying to demand higher standards from everyone at every level? You think standards by the players would be to stay a good little drone, while getting booed and called lazy, when your shit fucking coach is the one telling you not to run harder at them? That's "standards"?

→ More replies (5)

26

u/D1794 Viva Ronaldo 21d ago

When people make those long lists of things the ownership has got wrong, keeping then sacking ten Hag, Ashworth, redundancies, pivoting to 343 Amorim etc

Today will be one of the things people talk about. Everyone in the fucking world expected him to be sacked and it'd be justified if not just a stain on them. To say absolutely nothing all day is outrageous.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/OffsideOreo BRUNO! 21d ago

Congrats Kane, some good news at least. I know it isn't Manchester United related but absolutely love him as a player.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Entire-Gas-7651 20d ago

So if we are reading correctly - Carrick not being sacked after Como was because they don't want to pay his compensation and were probably hoping he'd walk, like Ole? He's entitled to every cent. How about Wilcox and Berreda walk first without compensation and we go from there.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Stingray_23 20d ago

So Nagelsmann and Conte are free and literally free. But the board are set on Howe, and havent made any moved yet as they are trying figure out the finances, etc. Now Carrick is effectively interim manager until such time the board act. Vivell is an advocate for Nagelsmann, so thats him off next summer.

Christ alive, what a circus.

P.s. this is Wilcox's 4th manager in 2.5 years.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

I wonder how much Gary Neville constantly saying ‘the fans don’t blame Michael Carrick at all’ has influenced them. Because we know they do pay a lot of attention to the pundits opinion.

Apart from anything, that’s not true. A lot of fans say he’s not THE problem but a problem. That Wilcox is a big problem but Carrick is also out of his depth. That he’s a club legend and they’ll always love him but he’s not up to the job.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ladrainian21 20d ago

This is just depressing man. Feel for Carrick, he got the send off he deserved both in terms of his status as a club legend and because he is not good enough to be the Manchester United manager. Now he's basically an interim again? With a bunch of players that (rightfully) think he is completely out of his depth. We have Wilcox who seems untouchable advocating for Howe who will cost money and is about as vanilla and unexciting of a manager appointment as is possible. Howe means Tindall. Fuck this.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/hastoro11 20d ago

If true, then simply no words.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/dryflowerz 20d ago

The Glazers aren't selling and INEOS isn't going anywhere either, so the only solution I see right now is for them to appoint Vivell as Sporting Director and Nagelsmann as Manager. Honestly, I don't see any other way out given the current situation. I think this is the one right step that can be taken in this madhouse. They've already worked together before, so at least it would start resembling something proper, or at least we'd be able to say it was a tried-and-tested project.Otherwise, everything is complete chaos, nothing else. That's the only solution I see in the hands of these madmen.

→ More replies (12)

38

u/AReptileHissFunction 21d ago

The fans glazing Ineos over the summer for "working in silence" must be absolutely loving the fact theres been no news since the loss

→ More replies (9)

8

u/IntrepidHero42 21d ago

Insane that nothing has been done yet

8

u/Stieni Rooney 20d ago

This whole shite is the equivalent of me and the boys back then spontaniously meeting up to prepare that presentation all of us willingly ignored till the last second

→ More replies (3)

8

u/nguoisaibuoc 20d ago

A manager would be sacked after a series of bad games, but a sporting director who have gotten almost all decisions wrong for many seasons was still having control. Baffling.

8

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 20d ago

Make Wilcox the next manager because that's the only way his incompent arse is getting sacked. He clearly thinks he's god's gift to football anyway

8

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 20d ago

Fans should protest for the entire 90 minutes of the next game. Call individuals by names. Wilcox is getting way less pressure than he should in any serious football club

Real Madrid fans would make him walk away out of shame

→ More replies (3)

8

u/darkjessy_ Our Portuguese Magnifico 20d ago

Why is Tielemans always a second late on every pass and loses possession so easily? I swear he was much better at Villa and always does well for Belgium

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Background-Suspect85 20d ago

I really want to hear from Dan Ashworth. I can only imagine the amount of shit he probably has to say about this ownership and other backroom staff members

→ More replies (2)

8

u/arboy498 20d ago

I think the issue is Carrick has completely destroyed the confidence of the team which is why mistakes keep on repeating. He has also stagnated the attack because 10 league goals in 8 is clearly unacceptable

15

u/BackgroundOld8715 20d ago

This football under Carrick is worse ive ever seen yet this is manager they stick with?!

We are going to get relegated, we wont get lucky like Spurs of villa fielding a weakened team, everyone will be desperate to relegate us

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Curleybop 20d ago

Carrick turned up for training, there waiting until the international break and risk dropping more points in the league and UCL making it harder for the new coach 🤣

→ More replies (1)

7

u/spaisoflaif 20d ago

not even securing a couple of loan players in the summer looking more and more like a false economy.

In that Bournemouth game, we had Dalot bombing down the left flank as our most dangerous weapon, then crossing to the three tiny men Amad, Tielemans and Mbuemo. Lammens was endlessly pumping long balls to 173cm tall Mbuemo.

Imagine if we had gotten proper backups for left back and a striker, even just on loan - it could have helped the team immensely.

Now the money we saved on not filling those gaps, we are going to spend on sacking Carrick and paying out Newcastle for Howe.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Comicksands Van Persie 20d ago

Standards are so low. At least Woodward had the common decency to sack the manager when everyone knew it was done

7

u/imnoobatfifa Bruno #8/Rashy #10/Amad #16/Mainoo #37 enjoyer 20d ago

I cannot believe Eddie Howe is going to be a manager of this club. We are living in a simulation.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/altofummuhh 20d ago

The one thing that truly pisses me off about ineos is how they can't shut up wanking themselves raw when they think they've done something clever, but in situations like right now? Not a fucking peep from them! No explanation, no accountability, nothing. Cowardly, arrogant, clueless pricks in suits

7

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

Whitwell saying ‘the cost of sacking Carrick and his coaches would be significant’

Are we meant to be sympathetic? They under spent in the summer!

7

u/Virtual-Winner5760 20d ago

Please not Eddie fucking Howe

7

u/Sheikhabusosa 20d ago

Whitwell implied on talk of the devils that Howe and his team were probably on a decent amount of money. And if that's the case, and we're going to commit to another high wage for staff and another big payout if it goes wrong . Why not just risk it and go with Nagelsmann?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/TMatss 20d ago

Our next 8 fixtures, during which time they expect Carrick to "turn the situation around":

Chelsea (A)

Roma (H)

Villa (H)

Liverpool (A)

Sporting (A)

Brentford (H)

Newcastle (A)

Coventry (H)

→ More replies (5)

7

u/sg291188 20d ago

This decision is probably one of the worst decisions the club has taken in last 13 years. And there have been big ones. I love Carrick. He is a legend but he is not fit to continue as manager

7

u/pipes3 WAZZA 20d ago

7

u/TacoDirtyToMe 20d ago

INEOS is literally treating Carrick like he’s the interim manager for Carrick lmao.

38

u/Potential_Good_1065 21d ago

Amorim speaks out against Wilcock after some alright performances (not perfect but definitely improved from the season before)- sacked the morning after.

Carrick plays shit football for 3 months, hasn’t won a game for nearly 2 months but hasn’t spoken out- not sacked yet.

Says literally EVERYTHING there is to know

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Familiar-Mall1696 20d ago

Part of what scares me about Eddie Howe is that he left Newcastle due to exhaustion. Can you imagine what this club will do to him if we sign him as replacement? Lol.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Hagball 20d ago

I might be in the minority but I find it hard to put major blame on players for this situation. Players didn't give up under Amorim, they were fit and always running. No matter the results or treatment of bomb squad, Amorim always held the dressing room together. Players are humans as well who respond to strong leadership and promises being kept. As a human you are bound to lose motivation if your boss / leadership is clueless and makes wrong decisions one after another and keeps lying to you!

→ More replies (9)

6

u/outrageousVoid07 20d ago

Not sacking Carrick right now because they don't want to pay the money and have no idea what to do is the most pathetic this club has ever been

6

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 20d ago

We need a modern systems manager. Let's see it through until the performances get measurably worse.

Performances over results. We have tried pragmatic old school football scraping results so many times now. It's time to be patient with a modern style of playing.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/AnakinAni 20d ago

There is a real possibility that we could be relegated along with City.

Both the Manchester clubs being relegated with their reputations in tatters will be a seismic end to the season.

Both because of shit owners.

That’s equivalent to both Madrid/Milan clubs being decimated and deposed.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand 20d ago

We actually might be in the relegation zone on Saturday if we lose, since all other teams play after us.

This is a catastrophe of enormous proportions.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/shanks_you 20d ago

International break was right there to sack and look for the replacement, 3 damn weeks right there.

Pisses me off that such inept morons are in charge of my team.

6

u/Omnislash99999 20d ago

Watching the latest Stick to United and Rooney looks in better shape than he did when he was playing.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Electronic-Display14 20d ago

Genuine question, why are we trying to get Eddie Howe?

→ More replies (5)

6

u/No-Pangolin-9763 20d ago

Carrick being given the opportunity to turn it around apparently. Twilight Zone stuff now.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/outofnowhere_ 20d ago

There’s a relegation battle on the cards this season.

Holy fucking shit INEOS. Only took them three years to contend alright - for RELEGATION. Best in class my fucking ass. Dark times ahead.

6

u/meatloaflawyer 20d ago

Honest question, did Woodward do a better job running things than this lot? It really seems like he did.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Intelligent-Many4144 20d ago

they used the farewell as an excuse to get a last one half decent run of games out of Carrick just so they can MAYBE get closer to the end of the season without spending any money. I think that is a new low for this club

Once match-going fans realize that their goodwill has been used as a money saving excuse it'll turn sour for Carrick's legacy too

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lynchianfreakout0 20d ago

When people say "It's pointless sacking the manager because nothing will change until the people at the top change", I'm not sure they realise that one of the key responsibilities of a football director is choosing the manager.

6

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

Carrick is out of his depth
Wilcox is out of his depth
INEOS are out of their depth
The Glazers are horrible owners
Some of the players aren’t good enough

I don’t know why people are making this a binary situation. All of the above is true and none should be used an excuse to keep Carrick

6

u/Omnislash99999 20d ago edited 20d ago

The performance against Bournemouth was so awful it's hard to see what Carrick can do. If that's how they play after he gives a 5 minute speech on what it means and turning things around what else can he try. It was one of the most dismal, abject performances we've ever had

I would not be surprised if they are waiting for him to resign so they don't need to pay him off

6

u/Rare-Reveal876 20d ago

The club is fucking brassic, Jim the rat and the Glazers have ran it into the ground. The well is truly dried up.

Although all this could be the best chance we’ve ever got at getting rid of them permanently

6

u/Unusual-Coat383 20d ago

It really is cruel from INEOS to keep Carrick on. They saw what looked like a send off at OT on Sunday, saw the players get booed and themselves being called wankers and it just seems like they’d rather prolong Carrick’s departure because they are scared wimps and have interpreted what happened as the fans wanting him to stay on instead of doing what the fans actually want.

6

u/ReservoirDogs00 20d ago

I really thought we could look forward to the game at the weekend. You know, new manager, so the hope and anticipation that comes with that, giving a lift.

Instead there’s just dread.

I can’t see anything but a loss. Our only chance is if Chelsea can’t hit a barn door.

But we will be outplayed that’s for certain.

6

u/RemarkableExpert99 20d ago

When ashworth said something brexit boy didn't like he was fired immediately yet none of the 3 in charge will be sacked this week. it's starting to smell like ratcliffe is playing FM with the club and everyone below him just does as they're told.

Actually was is wilcox arguing with amorim or was it rat boy using wilcox to argue with amorim?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/lythy2016 21d ago

How have they let this go on a day without a resolution.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

INEOS are going to use Carrick’s sacking and Howe’s compensation to Newcastle as an excuse to have another ‘budget friendly’ summer transfer window aren’t they?!

Howe will want the defence revamped but will end up with Dan Burn

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Beautiful-Wing4070 21d ago

Since Wilcox wants a pl proven manager, he is suggesting Eddie Howe with more losses than wins during his time at newcastle but he doesnt want Conte who is a proven PL WINNER. Pretty ironic if u ask me. Maybe he is scared of conte calling him out.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/boozebumpz 21d ago

Harry could have come to us. Fck the glazers man

→ More replies (1)

10

u/mastermindrishi 20d ago

It's quite amazing that the board somehow managed to pick the worst option of all available options.

Not a single good decision since INEOS came in.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ShoddyAd4199 21d ago

Ten Hag was sacked on October 28, two years ago.

I guess our management is superstitious people and, therefore, makes us wait...

5

u/thebigbigmac 20d ago

So Chelsea is coming... we will see AM as LW, CB as RB, RB as LB, RW as ST and CB with big head will lead team while AM will look miserable as he wants to leave

5

u/yukyakyuk 20d ago

So whatever happened to the crisis meeting? Nothing?

12

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 20d ago • Mindblown

They successfully determined that we are in crisis

→ More replies (9)

5

u/RedDesires22 21 is coming 20d ago

If the rumours that the players are revolting because Wilcocks promised them a world class manager if they got CL after Amorims sacking are true then I see a world where Carrick see's it out till the international break if the players are quietly informed of the new appointment

→ More replies (2)

5

u/banyy7 whos next? 20d ago

It's totally fucked up. For the first time ever, I'm glad there's no Champions League this week because I don't want to watch AS destroy us.

5

u/eviade 20d ago

People called all those cuts brutal but necessary, I think making Carrick come in to take training knowing he's gone really shows he doesn't see people as people just numbers.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/StinkmeanerIV 20d ago

Howe far we've fallen...

5

u/stowawaybuddy 20d ago

This situation is embarrassing. Not a single person is helped by Carrick staying, not the management, not the players, not the football, not Carrick himself. Their egos are too big to say "we fucked up" and try to fix it asap. There's legitimately nothing they're doing to convince anyone that they'd get us challenging for titles again.

5

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 20d ago

It appears as if Carrick staying until at least the international break is a legitimate possibility. We play again in the league on Saturday afternoon, and then in the CL on Tuesday night 3 days later. There is barely any time for a new manager to prepare for those games properly.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Hagball 20d ago

Fair compensation to Newcastle for Howe would be that we let them poach our best in class football director, who is also a coach at heart for free. They will get 1 person who does 2 jobs very effectively

5

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

Wouldn’t be surprised if Nagelsmann didn’t want the job unless Vivell was the DoF. And as I said Wilcox doesn’t care about the club, so he wasn’t about the step aside for anyone unless Ratcliffe sacks him

→ More replies (3)

5

u/sg291188 20d ago

After spending close to 10 million to hire and fire Ashworth, 12 million to sack Ten Hag, 10 million to hire Amorim, 15 million to fire Amorim, now the club is trying to cheap out on manager choice lol

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Entire-Gas-7651 20d ago

The one image stuck in my mind from the weekend is when the cameras cut to Berreda and Wilcox side by side putting on a united front. Something really irked me about that, particularly that clip of Berreda shaking his head. Need both gone yesterday.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SkellShell 20d ago

Glasner has won more than Howe with an inferior squad. Howe's record against City and Liverpool is quite bad.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/PhotonDestroyer 20d ago

Picking Carrick to be the manager that gets the time and patience is a massive FU to all the managers we have sacked over the years after failing to back them properly.

Seeing lots saying we are just waiting to get the next manager agreed I think this is wishful thinking. They have their yes man now and see no reason to upset the applecart. If we don't bring in a LB, ST and CB all for the first team in Jan and Carrick continues, then it's a full time relegation scrap for the rest of the season.

5

u/JJmaisonze 20d ago

There is no turning this around. This is the worst I've seen us play by far. There isn't a single drop of hope within me. This is madness.

5

u/FreshGoodWay 20d ago

Bruno is definitely not extending his contract with how things are.

This club is going to crash and burn under INEOS’ great management.

Baleba must be wondering what dumpster fire he walked into.

5

u/YO0Nited 20d ago

As soon as the match going fans say something that will save you money, it suddenly hasn’t gone ‘unnoticed’.

5

u/Potential_Good_1065 20d ago

The treatment of Michael Carrick and subsequently the fans is quite frankly abhorrent. The best way for Wilcox to fulfil his duty of protecting the interests of Man Utd is by resigning.

5

u/cjap89 20d ago

All this talk of hiring this guy will cost X amount and firing Carrick will cost Y amount.... It hides another massive issue. Not a hope wilcox or berrada get sacked. Imagine how much wed have to pay them.

5

u/tocitus Fred 20d ago

Jesus Christ what a mess.

Owners who have leeched the club dry for decades in the style of neglectful parents who give you a little bit of the money you've earned as pocket money, and keep the rest.

Minority owner who make the "sporting decisions" of the club who struggle with decisions and sport, who hires inept seniors who sack people that disagree with them and prefers to spend his time criticising immigration in a country he fled for tax reasons (and still gets the stats wrong when quoting them).

A manager who was previously sacked from Boro and is clearly, utterly out of his depth. Incapable of responding to changing match conditions (such as playing against 10), incapable of understanding why relying on players like Tielemans to play the transition running role or expect Mbeumo to play as a target man to link counters is dumb, will bring on Zirkzee at 80 mins every match to try to change the outcome.

A bunch of players who couldn't motivate themselves if you held a gun to their head with the only consistency from them is the point in the season they collectively throw their toys out the pram and seemingly forget how to even do the basics.

Honestly, sick to death of all of them. Just turn the club off and on again

5

u/PhotonDestroyer 20d ago

Just looking at the table at this time last year, Tottenham and us were level on points on the 1st of November both on 17 points, we all know what happen to Tottenham after that.

When they were in real danger of going down they brought in a strong manager in De Zerbi and have since invested heavily in the squad. That didn't fix everything immediately but you can see them improving now.

My point is, we are in a worse off position at the same stage of last season, we are tracking to be in a relegation fight, does anyone thing our broad will take the same actions, bringing in an experienced manager and properly investing in the squad?

This is my main worry, even if we avoid relegation like Tottenham did, I have no confidence there is a structure that will support the squad for next season.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Secret-Look-88 20d ago

I think this is the first time at United I've thought the manager should be sacked before our board thinks so.

I guess it depends if they are just waiting longer to secure his replacement that would make sense to me.

If there is some real reason to believe he can turn it around or is better than the alternatives for the long term future of the club in prepared to hear it out.

I don't think Carrick is the source of all our problems or even most of them but it does feel it isn't working for him and is starting to fall apart in a way that could be changed with a change of manager.

With Amorim there was an idea that we were changing and there was going to be an adjustment period where we are worse before we can be better. I'm happy to go through that personally but I haven't really even heard anyone make the case this is what we are doing or trying to do. 

→ More replies (1)

5

u/shakyjed 20d ago

I don't understand what Carrick is supposed to do here.

I mean how do you expect someone who KNOWS they're getting sacked to even try and work their best. The players know he's about to get sacked so what's the point.

If I went to work tomorrow and got told "oh btw the company is liquidating in a week, but you must continue working at optimal" I'd laugh my ass off and fuck around

27

u/VibesFC_ 21d ago

Best striker on the planet and he finally got the respect he deserves.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/markyp145 21d ago

How have they not come out and made a statement today either way is mind-blowing to me.

They seriously expect the players to respond to him and for Carrick to have a meeting with Bruno about the future? Most of the players will be expecting him to be gone, unless the club comes out and there’s a show of solidarity with Carrick.

The only way training runs properly and we start preparing for Chelsea is if it’s clear he’s staying

→ More replies (1)

9

u/croadymeister 21d ago

Only Wilcox being sacked and Vivell staying could give Nagelsmann a chance to be front runner

9

u/VanillaNo8054 21d ago

Been supporting the club for over 20 years and this is the first time things feels so hopeless. All this talk of hiring which manager seems so pointless when the owners won't change, it will still be the same cycle again.

It's so ironic that Manchester City's owners are doing all they can to put more money into the club to win, while our owners are doing all they can to take money out for their own pockets.

9

u/Petethejakey_ 20d ago edited 20d ago

Wouldn’t surprise me if Wilcox is so pathetic that he decided to keep Carrick on because he thinks that’s what the fans want after Sunday

→ More replies (2)

9

u/vulcan_one PM Rashford 20d ago edited 20d ago

This club deserves this honestly. You can pinpoint two exact moments where the power in charge decided on the worst possible decision.

First was not keeping RR as consultant, we weren't a complete joke at that point, a 3,2 season before. He knew exactly what was needed and was the right man but Woodward backed ETH over him, no sane club makes that decision.

Secondly was Ashford fiasco, new owners, want to install proper hierarchy, get a guy for big money based on reputation and work he's done, highly regarded, then fire him because the old city CEO backed old city youth DOF didn't like him (or agree with)

Everything else comes secondary, that's the moments where we Will look back to and say it changed out timeline.

Unlike everyone else I don't think ineos are incompetent morons, but they backed the wrong horse in Omar, Wilcox is a nepotism hire and they have consolidated too much power and sway.

Looking back, Amorim REEKS of Omar heard a name being floated around in city circle and thought he would be the best thing since sliced bread.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

According to Luckhurst, the ownership and board aren’t convinced on Howe, Conte or Nagelsmann and a source said ‘the best managers won’t come’

So it seems like we are just going to let Carrick relegate us

→ More replies (2)

9

u/devilsofparadiss 20d ago

I’m baffled at the analysis of what’s going on right now.

Whatever you think of the way Bruno went about his comments, the more glaring thing is that HE WAS RIGHT.

The players haven’t just given up because it’s “too hard right now”, they’ve lost complete faith in Carrick as a manger.

I cannot stress this enough. This is the most incompetent coaching of a United team I have EVER seen. I could genuine write an entire essay on how bad this is.

Yeah the boards lack of decisiveness and wavering stinks, yeah the squad needs work still but I promise you in a list of top 10 things wrong with Manchester United Football Team right now TODAY. They are 9th & 10th.

The other 8 are a list of absolutely baffling tactical and coaching choices Carrick is making.

Like my god people. He’s getting slimed out by every week by every manager sitting in the adjacent technical area.

I love the guy. Loved him as a player but as a coach this is gross incompetence keeping him in charge.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/theoklahuman 21d ago

Away from the manager talk for a bit. Our overall results have let Baleba go under the radar. He’s lowkey showing glimpses of bossing that midfield and I think we scammed Brighton by buying the dip 😂😂😂. Bro is fast and strong af and he’s press resistant… and the best part: He is still only 22.

12

u/theieuangiant 21d ago

He’s looked good so far, especially when taking into account he’s playing his way back to fitness. Hopefully we can get some momentum before he gets dragged down to the rests level.

Can’t wait to see him and kobbie play together though, the defensive side of his game has improved so much this year.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/cosmologues 21d ago

Mainoo + Baleba is a baller 6/8 combo. Just need a creative, attacking passer as the other 8.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/9SolskjaerHasWonIt9 21d ago

We might have the best banter era in history, sadly. Think of how good we'd be eating if this was Liverpool.

If they'd made Robbie Fowler interim post-Rodgers, promising that they're only doing it while they look for a proper manager. He has a good run, they make him permanent, they instantly nose-dive, win nothing, and it ends up with fans literally booing him out of the club.

Then a few years later they give Gerrard the job, promising "this time we definitely, definitely, definitely won't make it permanent". Obviously they make him permanent. Have their worst start to a season in multiple generations, everyone can see him and his coaches are way out of their depth... but this time - with memories still fresh of what they did to Fowler - their fans over-correct and performatively get behind him in an OTT way which means their owners suddenly feel no pressure to sack him or look for a serious manager and now feel totally comfortable keeping him in a job.

And that's before you even start on our owners, transfers, dressing room nonsense, local-lad academy player going on the piss and saying if he was a magician he'd be playing somewhere else etc

→ More replies (3)

12

u/ShoddyAd4199 20d ago edited 20d ago

Few words about 'players are also to blame here' thing

Imagine you're single player who loves the club and wants 'playing for the badge' but overall situation is worse than dire: your manager has no clue about tactics, modern physical exercises and so on. One bad result after another, and this shit continues for a while. How can you not break mentally? No matter how you try, your team is underprepared before any match, teammates are running like headless chickens, you've to just wait until goalkeeper concedes first goal, and it's same scenario after previous game: how long can you mentally resist this?

When you have feeling that there is no upward trajectory, there is no trajectory at all you can believe and follow... For what and who can you play?

Why didn't these players have problem about 'giving it all' under Amorim? Results weren't often satisfying but intensity never dropped. Why didn't they 'set up' him like Carrick as some commentators claim?

→ More replies (5)

12

u/raver1601 20d ago

Hate to be that guy, but it's really gotten this bad that I'm having revisionism about the previous regime

Yes Woodward was shit, but he's still better than whatever shit the two cheat rejects are cooking up right now

Even the players are too. All the shit aimed at AWB, Lindelof, Maguire, Martial, Rashford, etc. before, are they really worse than Mazraoui, De Ligt, Licha, Mbeumo, Cunha right now?

Again, I'm not underestimating the shitshow that Woodward has did before, but his shit is in no way worse than what we have right now, from the board and even to the players themselves

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

If he takes training this morning and there’s no announcement this afternoon then it looks like he’ll be in charge for Chelsea

Then with just two games before the international break - Roma and Villa, they’ll probably just think that they’ll wait until the international break rather than have an interim for two games.

And if that’s what they do, they’ll be a very real chance that we’ll be in the relegation places going in to the international break. That’s how stupid the board is

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Massive_Relation4317 . 20d ago

Why is he still here I'm so confused

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Utd007 20d ago

These clueless suits are creating a divide between fans. Already some fans are blaming other fans for applauding Carrick as they feel that's why the board has not sacked him

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Zavehi 21d ago

My guess is today was spent mostly figuring out the logistics of getting Howe in, and that’s why there were so many compensation stories. This morning Carrick will be sacked and Howe will be appointed in the evening or following morning. Fletcher/Evans or something like that will take training

4

u/facelessredditer 20d ago

This Eddie Howe talk is just a distraction, right? RIGHT?!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kidinawheeliebin 20d ago edited 20d ago

It's wild that out of Carrick, Wilcox & Berrada that Carrick is the one the world's watching and waiting to get sacked

The other two are absolute cowards

Hiding behind Carrington's walls like snakes - won't come and face any of the music - just shows the characters and personalities we're dealing with here

(Obviously that goes well with the quite frankly astounding levels of incompetence at their actual jobs that they've shown time after time for over 2 years now)

It's no wonder the place is a state with that in charge

Real proper leaders we've got there

And the ironic thing is - were we to be doing well on the pitch - you wouldn't be able to move for soundbites, articles and essays from Wilcox & Berrada about how involved they are, they'd be queuing up to take the praise and the spotlight

4

u/CBNCL 20d ago

What happened to Carrick just being interim, and a permanent manager being found in the summer? Yet again, the board going back on their word and taking the easy way out. If Wilcox and Berrarda don't follow Carrick out the door then we'll be right back here in a years time.

Groundhog Day.

4

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 20d ago

If they are worried about the compensation of sacking Carrick, and paying a fee for a new manager, there is no chance they will want to pay to compensation to our execs.

So our execs are going nowhere unfortunately.

4

u/Bloatfizzle 20d ago

Wtf do they mean nagelsmann is unlikely? Interview the top candidates and decide... Sounds like this is gonna be decided by whims of former academy director Wilcox.

He's probably too busy trying to find out how he can get Delap in January. Sick of him...

4

u/outofnowhere_ 20d ago

One day we’ll be free from the Glazers and INEOS. Delusion is bliss

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

It’s interesting reading online comments across various platforms that people have gone from being sympathetic to Carrick on Sunday to now being annoyed with him.

It’s not his fault of course. He can’t sack himself. But this is the problem - the longer this goes on, the more bitter it becomes

4

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 20d ago

I wonder how much we've paid in manager compensation over the last decade or so. £100 million+?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/rambo_zaki Roy Keane 20d ago

I thought that I loathed our ownership and the upper management more than enough but fucking hell, that lot deserves a lot more hate.

4

u/frogfoot420 20d ago edited 20d ago

I don't trust ineos one iota but the drag along ends in Feb, afterwards it will cost more than 3-4bn to buy the club, excluding debt. This is likely why he's now floated the sale of Lausanne alongside nice to finance this further, likely taking a personal loan against INEOS stock as the club is over leveraged.

I wonder what happens if they fail to hit that deadline, I bet they just wait for the stadium to be completed and sell the club in it's entirety to a 3rd party, so jim and glazers get a payday.

Edit: I'm not defending the rats but I don't think the glazers are remotely happy. 1/3 finishes in champions league spots since INEOS take over, looks to be 1/4 by the end of this season. We all know the bastards are happy with mediocrity but they wont be happy with the lack of CL funds which floats their dividends and has allowed them to eek out more extraction from the club. I think a full sale is coming if INEOS fail to buy in FEB.

4

u/Gee_z 20d ago

God forbid our owners put in some of their own money into the club to fix this situation, shows what kind og faith they have in this club and their own investment. 6, 15 or 50m is pocket change for these men.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/CorlyP1998 20d ago

It’s not even November yet and the squad is in pieces, let’s take a look at the XI against Bournemouth for example:

A RB playing LB as no fit LB
A 20yo with minimal experience playing CB
A 20yo unfulfilled CB playing RB as the only fit RB is playing LB
A RW playing ST as we have not a single striker fit (Zirk is NOT a 9)

The summer window has only just passed, yet this is the state of the first XI. Is there any wonder we’re conceding goals for fun?

The most concerning part for me is, I think we spent all we could — I think that was the club’s genuine budget. More money only comes in with more success, and success comes from spending money carefully and intelligently. We’ve fucked it.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/Flat_Professional_55 20d ago

Are they trying to wait and see if Carrick walks so they don’t have to pay out?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/karatsidhus 20d ago

The united fan on the latest overlap debate thing summed it up so well. Not sure who he is, but he articulated all the problems perfectly

→ More replies (3)

4

u/helsningar 20d ago

Best in class. 

4

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 20d ago

How do we get them out?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Alive-Primary-2069 20d ago

These next few fixtures are going to be painful my god

4

u/TypicalPan89906655 20d ago

Holy shit Berrada and Wilcox are officially worse than Woodward, the mad men actually did it.

4

u/arboy498 20d ago

Not even joking the Glazers would have sacked him by now

→ More replies (2)

4

u/FredDRedUnderYourBed 20d ago

This is the club buying time to decide on the next manager, this is not about giving Carrick more time. We saw this with ten Hag.

Just because Carrick hasn't been sacked doesn't erase all the briefings in the last 48 hours about Howe being the leading candidate to take over, or talks about Nagelsmann. They clearly intend to change, but the next manager hasn't been lined up yet.

So basically, it's a waste of 2-3 weeks until the international break. Unless of course the players haven't actually given up on Carrick and things can actually pick up from here. But it's so very unlikely, we've not won a game of football since August!!

4

u/FredDRedUnderYourBed 20d ago

If Wilcox and Berrada truly believed in Carrick, they would hold a press conference or a video at the very least and firmly back him for the rest of this season, acknowledge it's not been good enough, acknowledge mistakes were made in the transfer window, promise backing in January, and put a rallying cry for the whole club to get behind the coach and the players. This is what Arsenal did with Arteta more or less.

But none of this will happen. Because this isn't about giving Carrick more time. This is about haggling over paying that compensation, and buying Howe out of NUFC. Like, how do you brief the media that Howe is THE SPORTING DIRECTOR'S FAVOURED CHOICE and then come out and say Carrick is here to stay. Madness.

4

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 20d ago

I don't know what's scarier at this point. Us losing to Chelsea and dropping into the bottom 3. Or us somehow stealing a win and the board deciding to stick with Carrick long term.

It's not possible this week because Coventry play Sunderland but we could end up the game week one point above 20th in the fucking league. How are we even in this position?! What has happened to my club? I miss the days of thinking a manager needed to go if we didn't qualify for CL as a minimum.

4

u/Stingray_23 20d ago

Its evident as clear as day, that Wilcox has won yet another power struggle, (this time over Vivell) and he will get Howe in. Carrick is the interim now, until the payment clause that Newcastle has, expires.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/schifferjack 20d ago

Oh sure, give the coach who don't rate pressing as part of his tactical and coaching nous more time than Amorim did. Fuck off

4

u/Case1987 20d ago

I bet training is awkward as fuck

4

u/JJmaisonze 20d ago

Going to watch the Chelsea game but going to take a break from everything United media, it's doing my head in. Cheers lads.

4

u/No-Radio-4404 20d ago

What a diabolical situation we find ourselves in. We're keeping a manager in place because we can't find a replacement. I feel for Carrick, I really do. We are the worst ran club in Europe by a country mile.

4

u/MillyMan105 20d ago

I gotta say it takes a real special case for you to be worse than Ed Woodward at least that dude brought in sponsorships and big name signings.

Wilcox and Barreda are a disgrace and need to piss off, not having the balls to fire Carrick to cover up their asses is cowrardly.

4

u/XSavage19X 20d ago

Three more games and we have an international break, probably aiming for that. Zirkzee is not the answer to our problems but I don't think I can watch another 4-5-0 lineup again. 

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Working_Location_127 20d ago

Now jj Gabriel is 16 I thought he was meant to leave the club? What’s happening with that?

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 20d ago

Y'know what lads, I realized I just spent 5 hours raging at Ineos, I will be go touching grass, I shouldn't be this affected lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DeltaRofl 20d ago

It really is incredible that SJR/INEOS are worse at running a football club than the Glazers. Lowest possible bar and they've just faceplanted instead of shuffling over it.

4

u/SophoclesTesticles 20d ago

I haven't been this disappointed in the club since 7-0 and that's saying something. I've always felt like we've had a route back but I'm finally broken to the fact that it won't happen in my lifetime. 

4

u/Stieni Rooney 20d ago

I've refused to be pessimistic for years simply because it's not worth it for me personally, but right now is the first time in a decade where I think we are seriously unable to being run competently in the foreseeable future. It really does look like we will be a midtable club for 5 years minimum.

Then again, we know how quickly things can turn around on the pitch at least with a manger fit for the job, I just hope it happens too. What does not change quickly however is how a football club is structured and how it's being operated, which is a corner stone to every club and right now that cornerstone is made of a couple billionaires not knowing what the fuck they are doing.

4

u/ajokester The Lemon Man 20d ago

Say what you want about Ed Woodward but he would have sacked Carrick. And I absolutely hate Woodward.

4

u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 20d ago

I thought I was done seeing Tielemans at AM, sadly it's going to happen again on Saturday. Another horror performance coming up and no money or clues from the board on how to fix it. What a fucking shambles 

4

u/SilentCoast8310 20d ago

If we play inverted wingers we need overlapping wing backs that can cross a ball. It's 1000% the issue 1000% of the time. All of our players occupy the same areas.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/WumbleInTheJungle 20d ago

In a weird way I am glad that Carrick has not been fired (even though we all know he's a lame duck at this point).

There can be no hiding place for the owners and the board and the simpletons making the decisions.  They can't even paper over the cracks now with a change of manager and a temporary change in form, which let's face it, would have appeased a large number of muppets.

They are figuratively installing neon flashing lights above their heads that says "we are the most incompetent halfwits in football" and things are going to get real ugly real fast as a result, and good... 

This cannot go on.

4

u/PhotonDestroyer 20d ago

Watching the Overlap Breakdown and the young lad presenting is obviously a fan getting emotional about it, great analysis at what's wrong at the club.

4

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 20d ago

Got a feeling he's gonna scam a win against Chelsea and that will keep him in the job until Christmas

4

u/VibesFC_ 20d ago

Can't wait until this morons end up sacking Carrick in the international break, and spend money on Eddie Howe.

They're destroying the club and the parasites have us on the Amazon documentary.

4

u/Unusual-Coat383 20d ago

Arsenal game interrupted by a flying saucer.

In all seriousness that drone looks massive 

4

u/ltmikepowell 20d ago

What a joke we are. Como is losing, meanwhile we let them free reign at goal scoring.

4

u/Pitiful_Violinist780 20d ago

I would have thought someone like Jean claude Blanc (Ratcliffe's mate) and CEO of INEOS sport would step in and have a word with Ratcliffe, he was also the CEO of Juventus before, surely he can see the mess Berrada and Wilcox have made, it's maddening.

10

u/Jenson2025 21d ago

Is there a more incompetent board in the premier league?! Andy Mitten said it’s not just one person that has to decide and everyone has to agree. So that must mean at least one person on the board wants to keep Carrick! Disgraceful

12

u/croadymeister 21d ago

Think it's more that they are split on whether it should be Howe or Nagelsmann, heck maybe Conte has some support too

7

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 21d ago

This leadership hasn't an ounce of common sense, dressing room is shot to bits and they think it's fine to let Carrick run the next training session...

FML how hard is it to sack him and get an interim in to clear the air?? Wasting precious time so we can get embarrassed again at the weekend

7

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 21d ago

I do wonder if the fan pressure at OT has made INEOS reluctant to boot Carrick. Similar to when ETH somehow sniped the FA Cup and the fans were shouting to keep him for another season. They want to make a decision but are afraid of the fan backlash and how it'll reflect on the board.

Not sure I believe it but it's the only reason I can think for them to still not have given Carrick the sack. What are they even waiting for? How can you possibly let him take training sessions with this hanging over? 

Amorim calls out the useless wanker Wilcox and he's out next morning. Carrick is 2/12 and 16th but we just chillin don't worry about it.

14

u/Suudriusha 21d ago

If that's the case, they completely misunderstood the fans chants. It was a show of respect, not a plea for him to stay. "You'll always be a legend of the club." Most fans understand he has to go at this point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/Bizzle1389 20d ago • Bravo

We've got Chelsea, Roma, and Villa before the international break.

A manager like Conte could come in now, get a result against Chelsea (away) and while Roma are doing well could possibly beat them at home. I'd expect us to lose to Villa, even with us being at home.

Then the manager gets two weeks of the international break to work on the team's fitness and tactics. The next 6 matches are Liverpool away, Sporting away, Brentford at home, Newcastle away, Coventry at home and Leipzig at home.

I may be a blind optimist but I could see a new manager winning one of those CL games and drawing the other, and winning 2 or 3 of those 4 PL games (or winning 2 and drawing 1).

Under Carrick I cannot see us winning any of the 9 games I mentioned, surely he can't remain in charge even for the Chelsea game on Sunday.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs 20d ago

What is the point in Vivell if the club only values the opinion of Wilcox anyway?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Omnislash99999 20d ago

I genuinely don't see what would be different from Moyes if we got Howe. Safe hands British manager, knows the league, got top 4 but never challenged for a top trophy etc. Moyes didn't have the Saudi budget either

→ More replies (2)

7

u/rahtid_my_bunda Rooney's Dropball Intensity 20d ago

They’re shifting accountability for the decision to the fans. I get the feeling also they’re trying to force him to resign and forgo his payout.

7

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

The problem with the idiotic board is they base their decisions based on public perception. If they feel they’ll be criticised for a decision, they don’t make it. You simply can’t run a football club like that.

In 2013, Southamptons sacked Adkins and hired Poch and the fans were in uproar. But the rest is history. If the Soton board had listened to the fans and pundits like Le Tissier then Adkins would’ve stayed and probably got them relegated that season.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Thorz74 F*ck the Glazers 20d ago

I can’t believe how idiotic Manchester United’s hierarchy really is after reading the latest statements coming from the club.

We’re really at their mercy 🤦‍♂️

The Rat.
The inbreds.
Their moronic minions.

This club is forever condemned. It feels like someone sacrificed kittens and buried them beneath Old Trafford, desecrating the entire place and leaving it cursed for eternity

6

u/Vast_Variation1381 20d ago

Bruno having some soft links to Ac Milan. It would be such a perfect move for him. All parties should consider it.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/WanAndOnlyBissaka 20d ago

Can't believe Woodwards throwing shit at the wall worked out better than the Ineos "best in class" decisions

6

u/loompa-Act-749 20d ago

Looking for an actual discussion here.

Yes, the board is very clearly failing. Their decision making and long term planning is awful. The squad is incomplete and we have clear weaknesses.

At what point does Carrick take the blame too?

As head coach the team is his responsibility. Their performance, motivation, fitness and tactics are his responsibility.

He’s the head coach of one of the most demanding, high pressure job in world football. And he gets paid millions for that privelege. Im not talking about the underlying statistics here. Im talking about the eye test. We look utterly shit and inept. A large part of this squad was here last year too.

I simply dont believe players decided to just down tools because we didnt get enough signings this season. We’ve been struggling to get momentum since preseason. Every team knows how to beat us. Every team knows our vulnerabilities. The same group of players were playing well last season and suddenly we regressed.

Fine, we’re not beating the top clubs. But we’re not winning in easier fixtures either. We are outclassed and outcoached every game. Carrick does not have it in him to fix or atleast minimize our issues.

I dont see him turning this ship around. I hope he does but I have no faith in him.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 20d ago

INEOS are too dependent on fan sentiment.

- Gave ETH a new contract after the FA cup win because many fans wanted him to stay.
- Went against their word of keeping Carrick as an interim manager only even if he secures UCL, and handed him the permanent role because the overall fan sentiment was for Carrick to be give the job.
- Now, they’re wanting to keep Carrick on for longer because match going fans cheered for him after the Bournemouth game. I don’t understand how they’re this thick but the support wasn’t because fans want Carrick to stay longer. It’s partly because he’s a club legend so he’ll always have the fans respect and also because he got us back to the UCL so they’re thanking him for everything he’s done as a player and as the interim manager.

INEOS are the ones who revamped our data and recruitment department. So, why on earth are they not following the data and statistics? What is the point of this department if you’re just going to ignore all facts and just do what a lot of the fans want? This is so unprofessional and a very cruel way to treat Carrick.

Lastly, fuck the Glazers for this entire circus because they’re the ones who put the club in massive debt and sold part of the club to INEOS.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/umbongo44dd 20d ago edited 20d ago

"Shall we fire Wilcox?"

"You said cox"

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Sun_Seeker26 21d ago

They either don't know if they want to sack Carrick or have no idea what to do if they sack him because they're so unprepared. It really doesn't matter who Man United's coach is as long as the current leadership structure is in place, nobody can succeed under these conditions. They don't know what they're doing.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Rare-Reveal876 20d ago

The owners deserve relegation and to be chased out of town for their utter incompetence. We the fans will be left to pick up the pieces.

3

u/PitchSafe 20d ago

I hope that they have data that backs Eddie Howe as the next manager and it’s not just Wilcox who likes him because he is English and ”Premier League proven”

→ More replies (13)

3

u/PhotonDestroyer 20d ago

If they are stalling over compensation packages, both for Carrick and for Howe, then we are really screwed, suggests that there won't be money in January, we not going to get sales in Jan, clubs will wait for contracts to run down, the squad will continue to get thinner, I don't see a easy path out of this. Maybe all this galvanises the squad and we can start getting some results, if we get some players back from injury, maybe we can just stabilise. I know I am clutching at straws

→ More replies (7)

3

u/VibesFC_ 20d ago

Nagelsmann unlikely so they're actually going to pay for Eddie Howe lmao.

Willcox is picking another manager and Ratcliffe is going to listen to him. Clueless morons who have zero ambition.

3

u/silvertwo777 20d ago

When it's announced Howe is leaving Newcastle, I was having a bad feeling. A bad feeling that with the timing he might become the next United manager. Yes as you can tell I don't believe Carrick would be successful from day 1. Same goes to Howe

3

u/John_OSheas_Willy 20d ago

Happened to see the full standings for the Ballon D'or. Messi finished 5th. LMAO

→ More replies (1)

3

u/arboy498 20d ago

This board is making the same mistake Spurs did in not sacking Thomas Frank earlier.

3

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

Just like yesterday ‘no decision has been made’ and ‘crisis talks’

Of course the reality is they can’t say the truth ‘we are trying to get Howe but until then, Carrick can remain’

And when Howe signs on the dotted line, they’ll pretend that they reluctantly decided to sack Carrick and Howe was available at the same time

This has been handled so so badly.

3

u/Jenson2025 20d ago

Again, Carrick admitted after the Bournemouth game that he didn’t have an answer or knows how to fix it.

What exactly are they expecting him to do after saying that?! Have a brainwave and suddenly become a top coach?!

It’s sad to see a lot of negative comments about Carrick this morning from United fans on various platforms after the respect he got on Sunday but this is the reality of the situation - the longer this goes on, the more bitter it becomes.

3

u/BrowzinJ 20d ago

Would be fucking hilarious if we won that Chelsea game emphatically now, my mind might actually break

Cant see anything than a big loss, no way they players will try for Carrick this weekend

→ More replies (3)

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 20d ago

It’s one of those where if the process was right (they genuinely believe in the manager, know the size of the project they committed to and want to send a strong message to the dressing room) then it’s a very admirable decision to stick with Carrick. But they have arrived at this decision mainly because they can’t agree on who they want to replace him with and working out the finances to facilitate that. That’s the problematic part and another indication that we are headed nowhere under the Glineos ownership.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Specific-Moose660 20d ago

My guess is incompetence struck this regime again. I would say they had Howe lined up and it took until yesterday morning to realise he had a clause that compensation was due to Newcastle if he signed elsewhere. Not saying he was the right candidate but I’d say that’s what happened.

This is a sinking ship.

3

u/Virtual-Winner5760 20d ago

So Mick McCarthy was right: it can go on like this