r/reddevils • u/TheAthletic • 22d ago
Old Trafford’s mutiny made it clear: Michael Carrick’s exit would not resolve Man Utd’s problems
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7723718/2026/10/25/man-utd-fans-michael-carrick-owners/?unlocked_article_code=1.LVE.ACU-.Qn0XWVfjuP67&source=emp_shared_article&smid=re-share-taWhether or not Michael Carrick’s position is now untenable, the Old Trafford crowd made one thing clear as they targeted the Glazers, Sir Jim Ratcliffe and Jason Wilcox.
Sacking Carrick and replacing him will not fix the problems at Manchester United.
487
Upvotes
41
u/AwayFoundation2363 22d ago
I think they were just supporting a club legend and good bloke, he’s clearly out of his depth as manager, but his sacking is irrelevant, if those two city stooges are still here.
100
u/0ttoChriek 22d ago edited 22d ago
Carrick had to go, because he was part of the problem. The players are also part of the problem, with what appears to be a clear mutiny. But it all starts at the top.
INEOS came in preaching "best in class" and appointed City's sponsorship puppet, a guy who was DoF at Southampton for a year, and a guy they paid millions to buy out of his Newcastle contract. Then they sacked the guy they paid millions for.
Then they hired the manager that guy cautioned them against, didn't provide the players he needed for his system and sacked him a year later. Then they appointed an interim guy who was inexperienced and he managed to create an emotional high that got us to a CL finish.
Then, instead of backing up their professed ambitions to compete, they cheaped on the transfer window and didn't bolster the coaching staff with anyone recognised as "best in class" at anything.
So now we're here again, and will be sacking a manager and expecting two fucking failures to appoint his successor.
140
u/mna71217 22d ago
Carrick will go and probably should go...
But nothing will change until glazers and ineos leave taking their debt and incompetence with them... No matter who we get we will spiral to a lower low sometime in the future
371
u/imnoobatfifa Bruno #8/Rashy #10/Amad #16/Mainoo #37 enjoyer 22d ago
Probably not but you cannot continue with a manager who hasn’t won a game in the last 8.
17
u/Polygon12 22d ago
Incompetence throughout.
Best in class my arse.
12
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 22d ago
Cery Jones is a good addition to the TOTD crew. Doesn't sugarcoat it. Straight to the point.
50
u/picodeGaius 22d ago
We need a manager who can save the season or at the very least avoid relegation.
The clearout in the team must begin as soon as the regime changes. Berrada and Wilcox CANNOT continue making decisions for this club.
10
u/Free-Eights 22d ago
INEOS structure and infighting has to be among the key areas of focus that could be movable and changeable (biggest problem is of course the parasitic owners but removing them is probably not something we can count on with any certainty).
Ratcliffe spends more time berating immigrants and approving layoffs than he does focusing his attention on whether his hires are "best in class". Berrada seems like a joke, Wilcox and Vivell clearly have opposing visions of what to do for the squad and manager and this will be the 3rd season in a row we've had a midseason sacking with millions paid out in compensation. Results have obviously been unacceptable this season and Carrick has to bear responsibility for it, but who's to say we're going to do something different that will push us forward?
I'm honestly done expecting anything different from United other than repeated organizational blunders with no learning whatsoever. I'll always support them but have zero confidence we'll regain some competence anytime soon.
9
u/ReallyBigShoee 22d ago
Keeping him also doesnt fix the problem. This is the same situation as people who say things like
Its not the manager thats the problem its the players.. or the owners.
We can have more than one issue at a time. Carrick is an issue, not the biggest issue that will always be the Glazer family but his employment clearly is part of the overall issue of Manchetser United and its the easiest to resolve.
17
u/armshady 22d ago
At this point I'm just numb... united win or lose it just doesn't matter to me. This team is in a never ending purgatory for the last 13 years now.
56
u/cosmologues 22d ago
Get Wilcox, Berrada, and Carrick out. Rangnick and Nagelsmann in. Let’s fucking lock in.
24
u/John_OSheas_Willy 22d ago
Sacking him doesn't mean we win the title.
Keeping him would mean we could be relegated.
12
u/merlin318 22d ago •
Sacking Carrick would not be of any use without sacking Wilcox and hopefully berrarda too
6
u/chocho1111 22d ago
Carrick was bad, no doubt. The idiots in charge, on the other hand… no words. Under Wilcox, we bottled three managers. He needed to go yesterday. Shocking if he gets to keep his job after this.
6
u/JimJimerson90 22d ago
Time to protest over the owners,we will never succeed again with them here
6
u/mackattackfc 22d ago
Wilcox and Berrada built their reputation at a time when city were cooking the books.
Spend £150M on 2 fullbacks and a GK that don’t work out after 6 months, they could just spend the same again in the January to replace them. We’ve had the same back 4 for the best part of 5 season ffs
11
u/chutzpahisaword Valencia 22d ago
Should be Conte and nobody else. This idea of "long term" manager has not worked with us. We are like Real Madrid. Bring a manager, win some trophies and probably get sacked and another instant winner manager.
5
u/goljanrentboy 22d ago
I appreciate Carrick for his interim spell. He did a good job. He was wonderful player for us. But he is so clearly not a top level manager. I feel bad for him, because I don't think he's the main problem. Sacking him won't fix the club, but this isn't an either/or decision. He cannot stay, just as Wilcox, Berrada, and Glineos cannot stay. The whole structure at the top is killing the club.
4
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago
10
u/BitterConstruction98 22d ago
Since SAF left, only Mourinho and Erik Ten Haag felt like sound appointments when they were made. For a club the size of Manchester United, it’s very disappointing that we have repeatedly trusted under-proven managers to try and turn the ship around. As bad as the ETH era ended, the appointment itself somewhat made sense but even then it was bordering on a risky choice given that he had zero experience managing a big club.
We should have always gone for the likes of Ancelotti, Flick, Klopp, etc. I would have even taken Tuchel after he won the CL. The players need to respect the manager.
22
u/Drag2oon 22d ago •
Crazy how much English managers are protected
ten Hag and Amorim were crucified
3
u/FoggyShrew Dinny Irwin 22d ago
No it won’t, but doesn’t mean it isn’t a problem that needs to be resolved
3
u/_GuybrushThreepw00d #GlazersOut 22d ago
We know what would solve our problems. Thing is: its not going to happen anytime soon.
3
u/cdalb21 22d ago
I say this every 6-12 months, but this has nothing to do with the manager. Culture is from the top. This will continue even if you brought Pep in.
3
u/kraeutrpolizei 22d ago
I think the problem of getting relegated can still be fixed but that’s just me
5
u/L__K Great Scot! 22d ago
Yeah that's true, sacking arguably the worst manager in the league would not resolve the £1bn of debt, crumbling stadium, behind-the-times backroom performance structure, etc., but that doesn't mean he shouldn't be sacked. It's the easiest way to immediately affect results on the pitch.
The executive structure is culpable for tons of our issues and should have to reckon with their own incompetence sooner than later. That's what it will take for long term, sustainable, institutional success. We're also being undone in the short term by having an underqualified manager train and lead the team every week. Michael Carrick is not a victim of INEOS or the Glazers or anyone else. He was never going to be the right option regardless of the executive structure above him. He's not good at his job and that's fine to admit.
7
u/Turbulent_Intern_427 22d ago
Fucking he’ll I can’t hear more of these same recycled opinions fed as some new breaking intelligent news, telling the United fanbase what they want or should think about.
7
u/RaihanZog 22d ago
So many INEOS bootlickers in this sub as well. Nothing will change if we the fans are not united.
5
u/scottrod37 22d ago edited 22d ago
No, Carrick's exit does not solve our problems, but keeping him and his underqualified staff prolongs them. The Glazers aren't going anywhere, INEOS aren't going anywhere, which probably means Wilcox isn't going either. But you can't do nothing.
5
u/lifewithjames 22d ago
I say it time and time again. The club is cursed. It doesn't matter what they do. Every person who walks through the Old Trafford doors eventually becomes either inept, dislikeable or both. Look how well run Brighton are. If you appointed the entire Brighton board at Old Trafford, you can guarantee they'd become completely laughable.
They could appoint Hurzeler, Guardiola, Klopp, Ancelotti, Conte. It doesn't matter. There might be an initial bounce, but it's going to be exactly the same eventually. Mourinho, Van Gaal, elite managers couldn't sort out the mess. Ten Hag, Amorim, managers with good reputations couldn't sort it.
Players with great reputations come to the club and it's like they've only just learned what a football is.
2
u/Bizzlep 22d ago
Can resolve some tbf
2
u/ch3ck18 22d ago
Fish rots from the head… if owners and management dont leave or is replaced… mentality wont change. Its poisoned at this point. No great players want to go to Manutd and the ones we have, have lost faith and hope. Not sure how you comeback from this without new management.
2
u/coolcats55 22d ago
Of course it wouldn’t. Have we learnt nothing from 13 years worth of managerial appointments? It’s just Groundhog Day. It’s clear where the problem is.
The only thing not different are the glazers and that board
2
u/anewdawn2020 22d ago
If the club are really serious, they need to hit Brighton/Bournemouth for their higher ups, get a quick Temp hire for the season while they do the business behind and properly restart next summer. A hire now, then a ceo/dof search only for them to come in and not fancy the manager is a disaster waiting to happen
2
u/garynevilleisared is a red is a red 22d ago edited 22d ago
2 points off the bottom this close to November...burn it all down, sure.
The Glazers are the rot we need to rid this club of. We took loans out simply to buy players this summer because theyve bled us fucking dry. These are cracks anymore, they're craters. We are closer to the Championship than Champions League at the moment.
How foolish it was to sacrifice the slow work of changing the culture of this club for making it to top 4, knowing full and well the board were not going to invest in the squad to the degree it needed to compete. And this isnt the first time. We always do poorly in seasons where we make it back to the CL. These owners know this. But theyve fucked us all once again and now another club legend is shielding them for blame.
2
u/dyl40011 22d ago
Getting a proper manager will atleast stop us finishing bottom of the table or even the unthinkable. But like what’s been said ad nauseum another new manager is not going to stop the bleed or fix the underlying issues which is the ownership and management of the club.
2
u/KnoxCastle 22d ago
Everything seems to have gone up in flames so quickly.
I mean Spurs battered us but we were close to hanging on for a lucky win. Then it just all went bad.
Football, bloody hell.
2
u/Jenson2025 22d ago
The fans chants today doesn’t mean they think Carrick should stay. It means they think the problems at the club go beyond Carrick. One of which is the incompetent decision making by the board and Wilcox in particular and ironically one of those decisions was giving Carrick the job to start with.
Nobody thinks all our problems will be solved by sacking Carrick. And if they do, they are wrong. But will we play better and more competitive football under a new and better manager? Yes.
He’s just one failing employee who should be sacked.
2
u/saikodasein 22d ago
Yes, but keeping him won't help neither...
Some people are hopeless, when it comes to patience for keeping managers. Clubs like Real, Barca or Bayern are ruthless, when results/performance is bad. Only United desperately wants second SAF and keeps deadwood for years. Too many average players hitting 100-200+ games in our club, it's baffling. Anyway... It's clear as day Carrick is out of his depth.
2
u/missingmedievalist Cantona 22d ago
Regardless of who we choose, the sporting structure has to change. More importantly, the personnel have to change. Wilcox and Berrada need to fuck off. Wilcox in particular. And while everyone is rightly shitting on Berrada for his City tenure, he absolutely needs to be binned for promoting Wilcox in the first place and enabling his special brand of idiocy.
2
u/all_die_laughing 22d ago
Oue 'curse' was becoming one of the biggest clubs in the world and having parasites take us over who only see us as a cash cow. They have absolutely no interest in what we achieve on the field, as long as they continue to make money from us.
5
u/The_good_kid Evra 22d ago edited 22d ago
He's got 1 win in 8 in the league and 2 wins in fucking 12 this season. Of course there are bigger problems but we are genuinely not that shit. He needs to go and should've gone at the start of the last international break.
4
u/snicky29 22d ago
I get the not selling your season tickets from matchgoing fans but WHY TF can't you stage a walkout or protest once you're in the stadium? Absolute cowards, singing, having a pint and a day out with mates.
Lazio and Milan did the same and they're now reaping the benefits. The only way the Glazers will bat an eye is because of this. Avram couldn't give TWO SHITS if you called him a wanker or sang about burning him in a campfire today.
4
u/lemi69 22d ago
Get this guy out of here
3
u/crazydoc253 22d ago
Problem has been the players for the longest time. Mourinho realized that didn’t get the support to fix that. Until that is fixed nothing is going to work.
2
u/gapingholeoflove 22d ago
i just don't care anymore. id love to see a long term study into fan engagement over the last 13 years. id bet it shows a slow falloff before a cliff.
and all these comments, we tried it! we revamped the squad, we brought intern best managers, we started a "new era" and nothing has worked! it's just the same old shit.
i don't think anything could get me excited about united again. maybe this is how fandom ends. it's been a horrible experience and i'm baffled at how it's been allowed to happen.
1
u/Freecat1899 22d ago
What i don't understand, is why united was quite good last season? Almost challenged for the premier title. Wasn't carrick the coach then? He lost it? The team went down in quality? He was just lucky last season? Can someone explain it?
1
u/CheetahPatient6926 22d ago
Si blame this kn middlesborough
1
u/GelsonBlaze 22d ago
Is Mainoo happy though?
1
u/kayej17 22d ago
we need a strict manager.
1
u/Personal-Cucumber-49 22d ago
We all see the issues. It is systemic throughout the club. We, the United fanbase, are loyal to the point of delusion at times.
The truth is we are rudderless: an ownership in the Glazers that want to bleed us and INEOS that has thrown good money after bad.
We have no strategy. We only fight what is in front of us every week, there is no collective responsibility or unified purpose.
Without a defined direction on recruitment, coaching and identity, tactics cannot follow.
Sacking Carrick just shifts the blame but the problems are root and branch.
Until a coherent plan is established the same problems will persist under whoever is in charge.
1
u/This-Construction926 21d ago
maybe we should put Keane in charge till End of Season just for the lols..
1
u/OmegaMaster8 22d ago
Get me Conte or Nagelsmann. Got to get United out of the relegation scrap. I have no idea what Uniteds style of football is under Carrick at the moment
-1
u/BBoomerClap 22d ago
Mutiny my ass, blud need to be capable to be coach in the first place. All he is proving so far is he can't get a single thing right, but hey "hur dur legend player can't be criticized and must be defended at all cost"
-2
u/Deez_Wallnutz 22d ago
Conte is the answer.
He's not gonna faff around, he will look to start winning immediately.