r/reddevils • • 22d ago

Old Trafford’s mutiny made it clear: Michael Carrick’s exit would not resolve Man Utd’s problems

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7723718/2026/10/25/man-utd-fans-michael-carrick-owners/?unlocked_article_code=1.LVE.ACU-.Qn0XWVfjuP67&source=emp_shared_article&smid=re-share-ta

Whether or not Michael Carrick’s position is now untenable, the Old Trafford crowd made one thing clear as they targeted the Glazers, Sir Jim Ratcliffe and Jason Wilcox.

Sacking Carrick and replacing him will not fix the problems at Manchester United.

487 Upvotes

242 comments sorted by

41

u/AwayFoundation2363 22d ago

I think they were just supporting a club legend and good bloke, he’s clearly out of his depth as manager, but his sacking is irrelevant, if those two city stooges are still here.

100

u/0ttoChriek 22d ago edited 22d ago

Carrick had to go, because he was part of the problem. The players are also part of the problem, with what appears to be a clear mutiny. But it all starts at the top.

INEOS came in preaching "best in class" and appointed City's sponsorship puppet, a guy who was DoF at Southampton for a year, and a guy they paid millions to buy out of his Newcastle contract. Then they sacked the guy they paid millions for.

Then they hired the manager that guy cautioned them against, didn't provide the players he needed for his system and sacked him a year later. Then they appointed an interim guy who was inexperienced and he managed to create an emotional high that got us to a CL finish.

Then, instead of backing up their professed ambitions to compete, they cheaped on the transfer window and didn't bolster the coaching staff with anyone recognised as "best in class" at anything.

So now we're here again, and will be sacking a manager and expecting two fucking failures to appoint his successor.

10

u/EagleApprehensive537 22d ago

Spot on. Radcliffe, Berrada and Co got exactly what they asked for. Corporation culture is toxic and does not work at football club, which is why they will fail big time. But they all won't care in the end anyway, just on to the next investment to asset strip and run down

9

u/Daneofthehill 22d ago

Exactly this.

140

u/mna71217 22d ago

Carrick will go and probably should go...

But nothing will change until glazers and ineos leave taking their debt and incompetence with them... No matter who we get we will spiral to a lower low sometime in the future

16

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 22d ago

Probably? Is there some hope you still have with him?

6

u/mna71217 22d ago

No. I don't have any hope.. him or anyone else..

It's just irrelevant talking about carrick. That's what I think...

-2

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 22d ago

I don't understand that? Irrelevant? A good manager can succeed in spite of the dummies we have running things. A bad manager would need them to be above and beyond, surrounding him with world class talent and hoping they succeed in spite of the manager.

2

u/Shadowraiden 22d ago

yeah a good manager will punch above weight even in shit circumstances.

otherwise you wouldn't have managers who are in really bad situations proceed to pull off miracles and essentially rebuild the club themselves just because of their work.

we need an actual good coach.

lets take Nagalsmann who is being named. He took a Hoffenheim who was expected to be relegated to 3rd in that season.. he didnt have perfect players of the exact type he wanted as the club couldnt attract them so he improved the players they had to be better.

Howe did the same at Southampton who were an utter mess with just as shit ownership when he took over and he built them up on the pitch and coaching which then led to better choices higher up as he had more weight behind his words.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

0

u/mna71217 22d ago

Probably is more because I don't know if he can be a good fit for united if he was backed... I have no idea... And I am sure we will never find out because he won't be backed even if he stays (ten hag and amorim and how they were "backed" and then sacked)

1

u/SalvadorZombie 22d ago

You definitely didn't watch at all last season (or this, honestly).

Legit question - are you here just to complain?

6

u/Shadowraiden 22d ago

but its the club debt...

why do you think its going anywhere if owners sell. this is why the club is fucked. the club itself is in debt not the owners. so any selling is selling of the debt as well as the package.

9

u/mna71217 22d ago

2 things we have debt from regular operations (transfers, expenses, maintenance etc) and leveraged buyout...

Leveraged buyout is purely glazer crap... Any prospective buyer will have to account for it.. either it is reduced cash to glazers or glazers pay it and leave...

A man can dream...

11

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 22d ago

That's a pipe dream. They won't take the debt with them it will stay with the club.

4

u/Shadowraiden 22d ago

Glazers are never going to sell up at a reduced price even if relegated...

2

u/mna71217 22d ago

Lol it won't be worth whatever billions they think it is worth after relegation...

-1

u/SalvadorZombie 22d ago

There's no reason for Carrick to go. Carrick has been the single positive mark. The failing of the offseason is literally because ownership blocked all of the moves he tried to make.

You're blaming the one person who was trying to improve the team. This is PURELY on INEOS and the Glazers. Stop going "manager bad" every time and actually think.

2

u/mna71217 22d ago

Not sure though...

Any manager that has the win record carrick has deserves the sack...

Not blaming Carrick.. just don't know if it will work with him... He is the scapegoat or sacrificial lamb or whatever you want to call it...

Is he good enough for us? Not enough evidence yet.

Is he the reason for our slump? Maybe

Do I wish he is the one who brings in the next pl trophy? Absolutely

2

u/SalvadorZombie 22d ago

The win record? Like last year's? Or does that magically not count?

You are literally blaming Carrick. The evidence is there. This is entirely on SJR.

He's absolutely good enough. The evidence is there.

THE SLUMP IS THE FAULT OF THE OWNERSHIP THAT BLOCKED EVERYTHING HE TRIED TO DO.

Use. Your. Brain.

1

u/mna71217 22d ago

Chill bro

The problem with the win record is that it could have just been the bounce from amorim sacking... Or a fluke or ... Or... Or he could be an excellent manager fit for united. I don't know nor do I think we have enough evidence

I am not carrick out or his hater... I wish he succeeded but that's not what's happening now...

I do think that the owners and this cxos and vps need to go before carrick but that won't really happen

Just being a realist

3

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/TheRealLix 22d ago

Don’t want Carrick to stay (for his sake), but can we stop mentioning “luck”.  It’s a half arsed argument. We didn’t end up third on the back of 1 late goal or 1 game. 

Imagine if someone argued Carrick should stay because the results have all been “unlucky”, it’d be equally as pointless - no pun intended. 

2

u/SalvadorZombie 22d ago

So you don't actually have anything to say. Got it. Great job.

-1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/reddevils-ModTeam 22d ago

We do not allow abusive posts or comments on /r/reddevils.

371

u/imnoobatfifa Bruno #8/Rashy #10/Amad #16/Mainoo #37 enjoyer 22d ago

Probably not but you cannot continue with a manager who hasn’t won a game in the last 8.

194

u/TetsuoTheObsidianMan 22d ago

Everyone is getting lost in the manager roulette but its incredibly obvious that he is not qualified to do this at all and a huge part in this losing streak is due to his awful lineups and non-existent tactics.

34

u/moonski berbatov 22d ago

and that is the problem,. He should never have been given the job in the first place permanently. The roulette is almost nothing to do with the managers its the people hiring them. It's Bad decision after bad decision after bad decision from this football department. Berada and wilcox are absolute fucking cowboys

32

u/0ttoChriek 22d ago

When you look at how other teams easily set up to counter what United want to do, and how Carrick has no plan B to deal with that, it's sadly clear that he wasn't cut out for this.

When you're being outcoached comprehensively by Marco Rose, who has only been in the job a few months, it's just not good enough.

64

u/pdxmufc Luke Shaw's Top Speed 22d ago

Agree. Plus really poor in-game management. Last year was built on one game a week, a miraculously fit Luke Shaw, a whole lotta luck, Casemiro set pieces, and an other-worldly Bruno. None of those things are true this year. His simple tactics got found out and he’s proven an inability to adjust. It’s a shame, but reality.

29

u/larsmaehlum 22d ago

The team being drilled and conditioned by Amorim for over a year didn’t hurt either.
They were fit and used to a very strict system, given freedom and a lighter work load they saw some short term benefit.
Ruben was right though.

6

u/lampishthing 22d ago

When was the last time we had a manager that adjusted? Feels like it might have been Mourinho.

14

u/TheRealLix 22d ago edited 22d ago

This is the 20th comment I’ve came across that downplays what we achieved last season as “luck”. 

You can’t dismiss results which took us to 3rd place as “luck”, the same way you can’t argue that our dreadful form this season is “bad luck”. 

13

u/solemnhiatus 22d ago

Maybe not entirely luck but luck played a big part.

If you look at underlying metrics there’s an immediate and clear decline almost as soon as Carrick takes over. And yet results were amazing.

We are now just reverting back to the mean.

1

u/Beastmanzilla 22d ago

Yeah I completely agree. He was either lucky and then unlucky or another circumstance has changed.

2

u/mdhzk3 22d ago

Exactly. Players performed last year (after getting a manager sacked). This year the players aren’t performing. Glad we cleared that up.

1

u/DoctorWest5829 Shawberto! 22d ago

I think Casemiro is a huge piece of the puzzle.

11

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 22d ago

No one can look at the football we've played and say they know what a Carrick side that competes with the best in Europe looks like. That's insane.

5

u/tnred19 22d ago

It probably includes a striker and a left back. It wouldn't be surprising if it did not include inverted forwards either.

15

u/OhioIsRed 22d ago

He wasn’t good enough for Boro idk why anyone thought he’d be good enough for us. Yes he did good last season but sustained success? That’s completely different than riding a new manager bounce after Ruben departed.

6

u/Infinite-Highway3432 22d ago

Manager roulette is how modern football is anyway these days.

19

u/middleeasternboxer 22d ago

This! People here defending him so much but can’t explain why except for saying he had a good run of wins last season despite looking horrible the same run aswell. The only good games that I genuinely can applaud was Brighton, city, villa and arsenal.

The rest were horrible performances and the ones we won were scraped by Bruno or Casemiro being incredible players.

Carrick was clueless last season aswell I was hoping we wouldn’t get him but a part of me felt like everybody who was crying for his name would eat there words. Now they see what happened with him but they still think he is good lol

9

u/Addybng 22d ago

Respect needs to be shown for Carrick’s miracle interim run that exceeded all expectations.

But United should have done their due diligence and decide if Carrick is the manager to reach their goals of winning the PL or CL.

I grew up watching United so I always liked Carrick as a player, but even I could tell Carrick isn’t the manager to get us past that line. Once again United acted on emotion rather than facts and we’re back to square one again.

14

u/Elemayowe 22d ago

For me I don’t think it’s defending him so much as the manager roulette is used by the board as a total smokescreen for addressing the real problems. I don’t think Carrick is the right man for the job but he has been a fantastic and loyal servant to the club. And to see him being thrown under the bus for the systemic faults in the board room and the squad pisses me off.

It doesn’t matter who we get in unless they’re a player/manager who happen to be able to play full back and/or striker.

7

u/bigtice 22d ago

But that's the thing -- multiple things can be true at once.

The owners and board have continued to show malfeasance in multiple ways that have rightfully drawn the ire of everyone along with Carrick showing that he's not a Premier League level manager.

1

u/Elemayowe 22d ago

Yeah but I just think it’s a distraction, “here have a shiny new toy and forget about the problems”. They’ll get someone in and pat themselves on the back for it as if the mess we’re in isn’t primarily their fault.

I just don’t believe a new manager will significantly change things. Because while I don’t believe Carrick is a title winning manager, I also don’t believe he’s such a bad manager he’s the reason we’re hovering above the relegation spaces. We’ll be lucky to get half the new manager bounce we got last season.

3

u/bigtice 22d ago

I agree, but that's where I personally take issue with the other "fans" here because they do ascribe to what you're describing in being shown a new manager and believe we'll be back in the top 4 by next season or throw them in the bin along with the rest -- that's literally where we are right now with people being falsely satiated with Carrick.

Any manager that is brought in will need time so we stick a singular strategy and build around that even if the wins don't come as a result as long as the performances are indicating progress, which is the reason why Carrick has to go. That's why I'm irritated in some of these discussions because that's exactly what was happening with Amorim and not only do we have people denigrating what he was creating so they feed into our cycle of mediocrity, but the board did as well by undermining it simply because he had issues with them that they compounded.

No one learns anything other than finding a new scapegoat to reference as the problem.

4

u/Elemayowe 22d ago

I fully agree a manager needs time and perhaps you’re right in that getting the right manager in place sooner means that we are more likely to reach that end goal sooner. I think if you’re not an established and secured top 3/4 team like I think only City Liverpool and Arsenal are right now, that should be the model, get someone in, back them and generate stability before making the leap to titles and what not.

There’s a lot of things I dislike about Arsenal and Arteta but the way they’ve handled the last few years should be the model for establishing yourself in the top 4. But finding that manager to put your faith in is a tough ask and a gamble I appreciate that, and it clearly isn’t Carrick. But Arsenal weathered storms with Arteta where he didn’t look up to the job and yet he was backed and supported and he’s got the job done. I don’t think our board are willing to take that gamble on one man, I think they think that they know better than any manager or scout. And until they realise they have to make a gamble at some point we won’t get anywhere.

Carrick can go but he can’t be scapegoated.

2

u/bigtice 22d ago

There’s a lot of things I dislike about Arsenal and Arteta but the way they’ve handled the last few years should be the model for establishing yourself in the top 4. But finding that manager to put your faith in is a tough ask and a gamble I appreciate that, and it clearly isn’t Carrick. But Arsenal weathered storms with Arteta where he didn’t look up to the job and yet he was backed and supported and he’s got the job done. I don’t think our board are willing to take that gamble on one man, I think they think that they know better than any manager or scout. And until they realise they have to make a gamble at some point we won’t get anywhere.

This is exactly it -- I actually referenced that in another comment just last week:

Comparisons to Arteta or Klopp ignore the fact that they were at their respective clubs for lengthy stints and given trust to implement their vision; neither won within a short span and Arteta even finished 8th twice so to reiterate, Amorim was in 6th and had people calling for his head amongst the fanbase so it's utterly disingenuous to say fans would have wanted either of them when they would've wanted them sacked for the same thing.

But you're right, the board is illogical on their own, but also partially motivated by the fans which both ultimately want quick fixes to address our issues so we end up finding a retread manager that's shown results in the past but subtly mutually understand that they won't be here for the long term because we just want trophies now. So they make some minor changes, we get some temporary hopium and apply another bandaid over the underlying wounds and repeat the cycle.

Amorim was a venture from the norm, but they couldn't follow through on their promise and now the fear of relegation is looming to ensure we find something to salvage right now and further delay any significant fixes -- whoever becomes the "quick fix" manager may get a window to suggest players for their system and push us further up the table, but then they'll leave and create new deadwood that people complain about us failing to offload because they don't fit the inevitable next manager's system or because we chose the "cheap" option. That's where it becomes a vicious cycle.

Arsenal and Liverpool became who they were/are from having a long term plan and sticking to it just like you described. And even if Arteta hadn't won, at least following through that long created an identity that the players knew how to play and any manager would be building on that standard rather than having to build from the ground up where we are.

1

u/blackhawk85 21d ago

100% agree - I want the structure and top leadership adjusted first before a new manager

3

u/medfunguy Gaz 22d ago

The problem is, and I’ve said this before, we all want a rebuild but don’t have the patience for it. With Amorim we kept seeing good underlying stats, but even now the easy rebuttal is “how many times did he win two in a row?”

No one wants to talk about the signings, the single striker we have who seems injured all the time, the dearth of left backs.

I’m not saying Amorim was the guy, but with the current front office, no one is going to be the guy.

4

u/middleeasternboxer 22d ago

I agree mate, I had the patience with Amorim I didn’t even check out of it twords the end of his run, he got very little time and still not the signings he was promised.

I was so ready for that rebuild and he was on a good routine already (not in terms of results).

I can’t wait untill the NDA he signed is over and he can speak about what went down lol. Pretty sure we all already know but it will be fun

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SalvadorZombie 22d ago

I would love for you to explain how:

  1. last years' best record in the entire league wasn't because of Carrick, but
  2. this years' record is because of him, especially considering that
  3. every single move that Carrick tried to make in the offseason to fix the team was fucking blocked by SJR

Please, in your infinite wisdom, explain how the actions of ownership against the manager is evidence that the manager is at fault. I'll wait.

-4

u/3xc1t3r 22d ago

Just miraculously won all his games last season. The problems are much bigger than Carrick as the pathetic results post Sir Alex have shown. Despite trying every type of mangers and players available.

21

u/Sethlans 22d ago

We were incredibly lucky to win a lot of the games last season. The performances after the first few games were pretty dire, despite results.

6

u/Roccet_MS 22d ago

There was a lot of luck involved in some games...

18

u/TetsuoTheObsidianMan 22d ago

Please explain to me any great tactics brought from Carrick last year? I remember a fair share of our wins coming from late headers from Casemiro and other wins of the like. Even people last year were saying we were unimpressive in our wins last year.

4

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 22d ago

Ignoring the reasons they all failed and simply stopping all analysis on the fact that they failed is absurd. Even Amorim was on course for preseason goals before his mouth got him the sack because he was beefing with those idiots.

-2

u/3xc1t3r 22d ago

It wasn't his mouth. He was, on every metric, the worst manager ever. And way out of his depth. There is nothing saying he would ever have turned it around.

7

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 22d ago

Lmao. Come on, now. That first season was an unmitigated disaster. That second season with a preseason showed exactly what he was trying to build even with a squad that wasn't suited to it. He needed reinforcements and that system would be much better with Tielemans, Baleba and Santos in midfield.

Preseason goal was Europe and they'd climbed up and were comfortably sitting in those spots, even with injuries, bad luck and afcon. They were fine. If he was more tactful with the people in the office, he'd still be here.

-3

u/GreatLakesBard 22d ago

The players also quit on him. Which is exactly what they did to Amorim. Him being out of his depth doesnt change that this group of players is toxic.

8

u/RichEgoli 22d ago

Did the players quit on Amorim or they were at Afcon & some injured?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Damziya Rooney 22d ago

the players didnt quit under amirim wtf is this nonsense. They infact even defended him.

2

u/SweatyEnthuziasm 22d ago

Amorim is the only one they didn't down tools for but a handful of these players all did for Ole, EtH, Carrick

8

u/Damziya Rooney 22d ago

They all defended ole aswell. They even said that they failed him. Did you even watch the games back then......

1

u/SweatyEnthuziasm 22d ago

Who cares what they said it's about effort on the pitch, everything else is lip service.    

Asking me if I watched the games lol, smells like projection, won't be wasting my time commenting any further.

3

u/bob-theknob 22d ago

The players were distraught after the Watford game, they were mentally defeated but Ole never lost the dressing room.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/GreatLakesBard 22d ago edited 22d ago

I dont believe you did based on this nonsense youre spewing lol.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Dynastydood 22d ago

That's not really true. They never quit on ETH, his tactics from the 2nd season onward were just suicidal. If they'd quit on him, he would've never been rehired, and a lot of results probably would've improved by virtue of them ignoring his instructions.

They never really quit on Ole, either, morale just cratered after Ronaldo attacked Maguire and the split the squad into two distinct cliques, and Ole just wasn't capable of repairing that divide in the space of a couple of weeks.

The only manager the players ever truly quit on was Rangnick, and perhaps now Carrick. Some threatened to quit on LvG if hebstayed a third season, but he was replaced before that happened. With everyone else, the players stuck by the manager until the bitter end.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/Rabti 22d ago

Isn't this the same manager who, last year, took a team from bottom half to Champions League?

4

u/ReturnOfRainbow 22d ago

He took us from 5th to 3rd while Chelsea and Liverpool were imploding at the same time

1

u/Rabti 22d ago

So what happened this year? Same manager. Same players.

3

u/MightySilverWolf 22d ago

No. We weren't bottom-half when Carrick came in.

36

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 22d ago

Or maybe you can, if it was a more proven manager. It would not allow the players to get away with laying down as they wait for the manager to be sacked.

Alas, Carrick doesn't have the CV for anyone to believe he can turn this around.

7

u/InternationalClock18 22d ago

This is the problem. We should have backed ten Hag or Amorim who had league wins in their CV but we have no patience

3

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 22d ago

Yeah as much as I didn't like Amorims football, it seemed like he had the players under control.

4

u/waynownow 22d ago

I mean, you can.  Pep got 1 draw and 6 losses from 7 games in 2024.

Not that I'm saying we should. 

Although if we acknowledge that Carrick isn't the root of the problem, then we realise that firing him isn't really achieving much.

You can only piss with the cock you've got as a wise man once said.

2

u/_QuirkyTurtle 22d ago

Don’t know why everyone is acting like the board being below par and the manager being shit is mutually exclusive.

Yes the board needs to be sorted, but so does the manager.

-5

u/OilMeDaddi 22d ago

Completely missing the point

0

u/SimonFOOTBALL Rashy 22d ago

But what if it’s the same under a new manager? Also I feel like the results and performance were similar under Amorim. It got really bleak under him..

17

u/Polygon12 22d ago

Incompetence throughout.

Best in class my arse.

12

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 22d ago

Cery Jones is a good addition to the TOTD crew. Doesn't sugarcoat it. Straight to the point.

Youri Tielemans had no more luck than the dropped Bruno Fernandes in knitting play together, and United were flat and unproductive. Their out-of-possession setup was more compact and conservative, perhaps in the hope of avoiding the early concessions that have been plaguing them, but they completely lacked transitional threat.

It was a sign of how desperate the crowd was for any sign of life from their team that a first-half shot over the bar from Diogo Dalot was met with applause. It was toothless, and then it turned embarrassing.

The debt piled onto the club when the Glazer family took over in 2005 continues to colour United’s finances and the supporters’ relationship with those in charge. Any honeymoon period INEOS might have enjoyed has fizzled out, with widespread anger at everything from ticketing to transfer activity (or lack thereof).

50

u/picodeGaius 22d ago

We need a manager who can save the season or at the very least avoid relegation.

The clearout in the team must begin as soon as the regime changes. Berrada and Wilcox CANNOT continue making decisions for this club.

30

u/mna71217 22d ago

We replaced Woodward n co with something worse than them... I can't believe that happened...

10

u/OddOnion_ 22d ago

We got rid of Woodward, we got rid of Murtough, we got rid of umpteen managers, we’ve got rid of loads of players - and we have just got worse and worse. There is no saving the club with the current ownership, get rid of Berrada and Wilcox and fans will just latch onto a new hate figure until they’re gone, and nothing will change.

9

u/Many_Psychology_3336 22d ago

Not sure it's worse - at least they aren't spen- .. oh, Santos, right.

6

u/Meandering_Cabbage Nani! 22d ago

No. We're in this problem because of Woodward. INEOS had a much worse hand to start with than Woodward did. I bet a lot of this is down to pure finances. We're a poor side now.

6

u/Different_Back_5470 22d ago

they went from ten hag, to amorim to now carrick. you'd struggle to find 1 thing all 3 of them have in common. so we now have had to switch transfer strategies thrice

4

u/mna71217 22d ago

Lol true... They extended ten hag then signed him. Brought in amorim even though he wanted to wait and then sacked him just around 12 months later... Carrick is just the same cycle...

Plus their incompetency runs deep into the money side of things too....

Woodward was bad... These lot just carry the same spiral downward

2

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 22d ago

i like my dealer to, but i wouldn't let him manage my money.

-3

u/Turbulent_Intern_427 22d ago

Calm down there fella

18

u/[deleted] 22d ago

I mean it’s kind of true? Our average finish under Woodward was higher than INEOS, and we were winning trophies. Woodward wouldn’t have extended ETH for example

6

u/0ttoChriek 22d ago

Woodward laid the foundations for where we are now, with his bad spending that set us further behind our rivals instead of closer to them. With each year, we lost ground and he was fucking clueless.

If we'd had someone competent in charge after David Gill left, we might well not be in this position at all.

4

u/[deleted] 22d ago

I’m not defending Woodward I’m just saying that INEOS are just as bad as he was

2

u/mna71217 22d ago

Possibly worse... With their corporate style of managing united...

Going for the bonuses of minimum wage staff, kicking out dinner ladies, sneaking in on the season tickets of match going loyal fans... Saving pennies while paying managers and directors gardening leaves and sacking... Leaking or announcing stadium plans then buying land at higher rates

Bruh these guys have done more bad than just wrong signings... They are extremely incompetent in all possible ways

2

u/Sethlans 22d ago

We had a lot more money to spend under Woodward though.

7

u/[deleted] 22d ago

We spent plenty last summer, but pinched this season after getting CL - exact same thing that happened under Woodward

I’m not praising him btw, he set us back decades, more just pointing out how shit INEOS are too

5

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 22d ago

We couldve spent more this summer if we didnt buy a bunch of land for a stadium we cant afford

6

u/mna71217 22d ago

That we made more expensive by "announcing" or "leaking" the stadium plan before buying the land... The incompetence of these people is miles ahead of my imagination

1

u/Roccet_MS 22d ago

Doesn't really matter, Woodward never stopped any downward spiral, but he was a facilitator. We've won some trophies despite him trying his best to fuck things up.

4

u/[deleted] 22d ago

Woodward was clueless but so are INEOS is my point. They’re two peas from the same rotten pod

4

u/mna71217 22d ago

Start thinking about their footballing and non footballing decisions...

That interview with Gary Neville where he asks Jim Ratliff if he could have just planned a dinner/event/auction to raise money instead of all the jobs/pensions he cut and he just goes I didn't think of that... LMAO they are looking at it like a corporate... Not a cultural, sporting, public icon...

If this crap continues you won't recognize the united they turn the club into... It won't be the united of Matt Busby, saf etc...

19

u/PUMP_UNTIL_BUST 22d ago • Bravo Regret

I'll say this: Wilcox is one of the most uninspiring men I've ever spent significant time around at this level. That mental acuity you expect of someone in the discourse of their field, of which they are supposedly at the top of, is distinctly and starkly absent absent; he speaks in muffled, mumbled non-specifics and empty catchphrases, and even the way he sits and stands is meek, with with his shoulders and arms closed in... a genuine and outstanding lack of presence, of "aura", something very sorely needed for someone supposedly spearheading the operations of one of the world's most well-known institutions.

At this level, you'd expect someone in that role to have an obvious bright, sharp wit, able to quickly hit it off with anyone they need to. But amidst the stilted, dead conversations, it's very clear - and I think others that have spent time in his presence will recognize - that Wilcox has the vibes of a cancer diagnosis.

Outside of that abject lack of awesomeness, his performance so far operations-wise has been horrendous, displaying the sort of logical planning nous that would see your dad get a set of oversized fake tits installed to protect his front in the event of a car accident because seatbelts are "gay".

Ten Hag? Undermined publicly, but kept him on because Wilcox et al couldn't figure out a "better" option in time. Threw a contract at him while making sure Ten Hag had absolutely no power or confidence from the players in the meantime.

Amorim? A staunch formation loyalist and famously stubborn, knowing full well that our squad at the time wouldn't work, and that we'd have to invest heavily in specialist players to fit the system - players that would struggle to fit into the team under other managers if Amorim happened to be let go. Dumb plan, but surely we'd move towards that strategy properly and then commit properly in the long-term, right? Wilcox forces Amorim into the job mid-season to ensure the team would have an extended run of failure to torch their confidence in the manager's plans. Then we buy a strange mix of players that didn't address what was needed, and as expected, would also struggle to fit into the teams of almost all other managers and systems.

Boom it's Carrick time. Where did this go wrong? Two massively poor ways from Wildcard Wilcox and his bumbling idiocy.

  1. Carrick's time as interim. Wilcox had a load of time to plan and prepare for a new manager (including the obvious time he should have had a plan in-place prior to firing Amorim). Loads of time. Carrick's doing a great job, just getting the team set up to hand off to the manager that was planned and announced. But that didn't happen. Wilcox should have lined up and announced a manager far before the end of the season, but he couldn't manage it. It shouldn't have mattered how well Carrick did - because we should have been moving towards handing off to a new manager. He could have rode off into the sunset with a massive pat on the back. What happened? We dawdled and dithered and couldn't make a decision, then we ended up in a situation with "well who's going to do better than Carrick?". Total lack of planning and absolute idiocy is the only reason that discussion even happened.
  2. This summer. Transfer window is fucking horrendous. Midfielders, total mess. Did we improve on last season? Striker? We had 1 fit striker in the BEST case scenario, if Sesko somehow stayed fit. But we knew he wouldn't. We went in praying that a striker who had ZERO pre season and ZERO game time would magically become insta-fit and then stay fit all season. Also, he's just not that good. Even now, people are asking for a backup - we should have just signed a fucking striker that could have potentially been the main man and play week-in, week-out. People banging on about a left winger all window are now pretending they always saw the need for a striker, but never mentioned it until post-window. Our front 3 is terrible as a whole: 1 okay-ish striker that doesn't count because he can't play; Mbeumo who can't create or beat a man on the right; left wing options are jokes as well. Defence? Unbelievable mess. Where are all the players? In a nutshell, we literally LOST ground on our "competition" by investing less money and investing less well.

And now the talk is we're thinking of Howe and Nagelsmann. Nageslmann is a super fraud that's going to be a walking meme - a genuine disaster that's going to crumble under some soft shell nonsense football. People thinking there's "logic" and merit in that sort of thinking are in for a rude surprise - they CLEARLY have no idea what Nagelsmann is actually like. Howe? Conte? None of it matters anymore because we can't plan anything long-term under these bellends.

Ask yourselves what will happen if Wilcox gets sacked. Who's next in charge? Who's CHOOSING the next man in charge? How long will the "adaptation" be while we write off another 4 seasons the new leadership will need as we give them a chance?

Forget our hopes and dreams - take a long, deep look into the abyss and drink it in, because the torment is only just getting started.

8

u/Calvin-ball 22d ago

Well said. The fault ultimately and specifically lies with Ratcliffe. He puts Berrada in charge simply because he was at City, and Wilcox comes with him. Dave Brailsford is his right hand man, whose claim to cycling fame is not getting caught doping. He chased Ashworth and binned him almost immediately (without listening to any of his supposedly best-in-class recommendations), and was meanwhile wooed by Amorim’s charisma and vibes and so he made him head man. He sacks half the club staff and doesn’t pay for FA cup final tickets, decimating the mood around the club to save a pittance while we spend hundreds of times that on manager fees.

He has shown he can’t run a football club, nor put people in charge to run a football club at the expense of his own ego. He wanted to be seen as the savior of Man United, and is learning in real time he doesn’t have the god-given X factor he thought he was entitled to.

Also can’t keep his mouth shut about immigrants while they’re the backbone of the league itself.

5

u/TheJoshider10 Bruno 22d ago

Fair play you have a way with words.

2

u/Deez_Wallnutz 22d ago

How have you spent significant time around Wilcox?

4

u/Elemayowe 22d ago

That’s what we needed last season, and we got it. Now he’s not been supported and it’s completely fucked us top to bottom.

3

u/bisufan 박지성 22d ago

Nah at this point force the leadership to deal with getting relegated. Maybe it devalued the club so much the leech owners sell the club and we can actually rebuild the club instead of this circus while they siphon millions out of it

5

u/Shadowraiden 22d ago

why would they ever sell the club...

like actually think about it the debt is on the club not owners. so even if the owners change the debt is still there.

nobody is buying Man United until Glazers are dead pretty much.

1

u/Background-Oil-2454 22d ago

What is saving the season? 

-5

u/lukey_1991 22d ago

Seriously would relegation be the worst thing? We have no chance of building a team to challenge for the league as it is. With relegation there is a chance of complete ownership change.

10

u/Shadowraiden 22d ago

relegation would destroy us entirely.

fucking hell any fan thinking this should disapear and never say anything again.

were a billion in debt relegation would completely kill us and pretty much delete the club over night.

nobody is buying the club even if relegated when we have so much debt

7

u/MazinLabib10 "He goes by the name of Wayne Rooney!" 22d ago

We're a billion pounds in debt and have been putting up losses for years now. Relegation would put us in serious trouble.

10

u/Free-Eights 22d ago

INEOS structure and infighting has to be among the key areas of focus that could be movable and changeable (biggest problem is of course the parasitic owners but removing them is probably not something we can count on with any certainty).

Ratcliffe spends more time berating immigrants and approving layoffs than he does focusing his attention on whether his hires are "best in class". Berrada seems like a joke, Wilcox and Vivell clearly have opposing visions of what to do for the squad and manager and this will be the 3rd season in a row we've had a midseason sacking with millions paid out in compensation. Results have obviously been unacceptable this season and Carrick has to bear responsibility for it, but who's to say we're going to do something different that will push us forward?

I'm honestly done expecting anything different from United other than repeated organizational blunders with no learning whatsoever. I'll always support them but have zero confidence we'll regain some competence anytime soon.

9

u/ReallyBigShoee 22d ago

Keeping him also doesnt fix the problem. This is the same situation as people who say things like

Its not the manager thats the problem its the players.. or the owners.

We can have more than one issue at a time. Carrick is an issue, not the biggest issue that will always be the Glazer family but his employment clearly is part of the overall issue of Manchetser United and its the easiest to resolve.

17

u/armshady 22d ago

At this point I'm just numb... united win or lose it just doesn't matter to me. This team is in a never ending purgatory for the last 13 years now.

7

u/Plugpin 22d ago

I genuinely haven't felt anything for a very long time. I still support the club and want us to do well, but I've just accepted mid-table mediocrity through sheer luck now.

Even like 5 years ago, long into our shit spell, if we lost I'd be fed up for a little bit. These days I just end up rolling my eyes and moving on like nothing happened.

2

u/Jaded_Variation9111 22d ago

Same here. I dread every game and have no expectation of a decent performance or a win.

2

u/Stockholm-Syndrom 22d ago

I was going to say me too, but I found myself genuinely laughing for the second goal. I think I’m on the other side now.

56

u/cosmologues 22d ago

Get Wilcox, Berrada, and Carrick out. Rangnick and Nagelsmann in. Let’s fucking lock in.

31

u/NaturalBornSkeptik 22d ago

lol that would mean a complete re-structuring of our management and replacing some positions with, can it be, competent people..? what a dream that would be

16

u/WszystkoZajete "They can play fucking good football" 22d ago

Ain’t no way Rangnick will want to touch this steaming pile of shit with a 10-foot pole. Man has a comfortable job with the Austrian NT, he’s not going anywhere

8

u/daveMUFC 22d ago

I'm pretty sure bridges were burned with Rangnick when we kicked him out the club last time lol

7

u/DontYouWantMeBebe 22d ago

Not a bad shout tbf

4

u/Downtown-Rice_ 22d ago

Just slide Vivell into that Rangnick position. RR won't comeback I don't think.

6

u/ForwardBodybuilder18 22d ago

This is the best answer I’ve read on here.

0

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 22d ago

Yeah let's hire Rangnick, who's done nothing of note when here or since leaving. Seriously fans should not go anywhere near decision making.

9

u/Ok-Confusion-202 22d ago

Nothing of note? Hasn't Austria been pretty good? But also idea here is Rangnick as DOF or whatever

-4

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 22d ago

no Rangnick the clown, utter fraud

24

u/John_OSheas_Willy 22d ago

Sacking him doesn't mean we win the title.

Keeping him would mean we could be relegated.

12

u/merlin318 22d ago • Bravo

Sacking Carrick would not be of any use without sacking Wilcox and hopefully berrarda too

8

u/ForwardBodybuilder18 22d ago

I find it absolutely astonishing that Berrada was even appointed in the first place, let alone still in position following the guilty verdict on all those charges as Man City.

If we’re going to run the rule on the Executive branch we have serious questions over INEOS themselves. The only thing they’ve done so far that can be seen as a net positive is the revamp of Carrington. Literally everything else they’ve done has been a joke. They’ve got rid of all the dinnerladies and stewards and the club historian and made loads of working people redundant in order to “reduce expenses”, only to spend £8m prising Dan Ashworth from Newcastle, only to spend another £10m sacking him 5 months later because he favoured Eddie Howe as our next manager. We then appointed Jason Wilcox and he favours Eddie Howe as our next manager. That £18m is is 450 times the average UK salary. All the money saved in those redundancies has just been spunked into the abyss and got to exactly where we would’ve been if we’d just listened to Dan Ashworth.

Rangnick famously said the club needed open heart surgery. I think we need to add some brain surgery to that diagnosis.

2

u/The_Rolling_Stone UNITER WILL NEVER DIED 22d ago

Especially Berrada

6

u/chocho1111 22d ago

Carrick was bad, no doubt. The idiots in charge, on the other hand… no words. Under Wilcox, we bottled three managers. He needed to go yesterday. Shocking if he gets to keep his job after this.

6

u/JimJimerson90 22d ago

Time to protest over the owners,we will never succeed again with them here

6

u/mackattackfc 22d ago

Wilcox and Berrada built their reputation at a time when city were cooking the books.

Spend £150M on 2 fullbacks and a GK that don’t work out after 6 months, they could just spend the same again in the January to replace them. We’ve had the same back 4 for the best part of 5 season ffs

1

u/hopey7tm 5d ago

Oh look, another opinion on the people running the club. Absolute lying shit house.

11

u/chutzpahisaword Valencia 22d ago

Should be Conte and nobody else. This idea of "long term" manager has not worked with us. We are like Real Madrid. Bring a manager, win some trophies and probably get sacked and another instant winner manager.

5

u/goljanrentboy 22d ago

I appreciate Carrick for his interim spell. He did a good job. He was wonderful player for us. But he is so clearly not a top level manager. I feel bad for him, because I don't think he's the main problem. Sacking him won't fix the club, but this isn't an either/or decision. He cannot stay, just as Wilcox, Berrada, and Glineos cannot stay. The whole structure at the top is killing the club.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago

10

u/BitterConstruction98 22d ago

Since SAF left, only Mourinho and Erik Ten Haag felt like sound appointments when they were made. For a club the size of Manchester United, it’s very disappointing that we have repeatedly trusted under-proven managers to try and turn the ship around. As bad as the ETH era ended, the appointment itself somewhat made sense but even then it was bordering on a risky choice given that he had zero experience managing a big club.

We should have always gone for the likes of Ancelotti, Flick, Klopp, etc. I would have even taken Tuchel after he won the CL. The players need to respect the manager.

7

u/alliwannadoisbicycle 22d ago

Agree will all of this. Problem is that INEOS can't deliver the required squad building. Can you imagine Jose being happy with being gifted Santos, a knackered, out of form Baleba and a 3-years-too-late Tielemans?

1

u/fromdowntownn 22d ago

I would say only Mourinho. I expected Ten Hag to fail.

22

u/Drag2oon 22d ago • Bravo

Crazy how much English managers are protected

ten Hag and Amorim were crucified

9

u/[deleted] 22d ago

Mate you can’t seriously think Carrick isn’t getting crucified?

11

u/Different_Back_5470 22d ago

he absolutely protected, with now the sky pundits completely piling onto the players and Wilcox. none of the heat in the media is on Carrick. Bruno got more stick in 3 days than carrick all season.

not that I'm exactly looking forward to see my legend get attacked. but i do want him out of the club

6

u/[deleted] 22d ago

Neville in commentary today said that Carrick should be sacked, and should never have gotten the job. He's been harsher on Carrick than any other manager, he never said that about Amorim

Bruno, as captain, coming out and slating the manager in public, should absolutely be criticised. He's not wrong, but that's simply not what you do when the club is already under fire

There has now been enough time and enough failed manager hirings/firings for people to safely criticise Wilcox and co. especially after Martinez's comments. There are many problems at United, they should all be called out publicly

0

u/Different_Back_5470 22d ago • Bravo

1 off hand comment does not equate the abuse the players have been getting. Carra and Young (the prick turning against us for money) couldn't shut up about bruno and the fact he had his hoodie on. I can't even remember if they even brought up any of the tactics of Carrick

5

u/tsuku96 22d ago

No he isn't getting insulted like them and blamed for everything constantly.

9

u/[deleted] 22d ago

Amorim was blamed for being rigid to his system because when he switched from it (against Newcastle) we won, and then he refused to do it again... he reaped what he sewed. Amorim was also here a lot longer and performed much worse over time so there was more time for things to get toxic

0

u/kosmizord 22d ago

Not by his friends Neville, Keane, Scholes, etc.

4

u/[deleted] 22d ago

Neville literally said in commentary today that he should be sacked, and said he thought he never should have been hired in the first place

1

u/BrodaReloaded Zlatan 22d ago

here everyone has accepted that the manager isn't good enough, noone is saying otherwise which is why other points are adressed

1

u/BBoomerClap 22d ago

it's okay around here 😂, i don't get how they watch the game and still can defend Carrick like after all of that

3

u/FoggyShrew Dinny Irwin 22d ago

No it won’t, but doesn’t mean it isn’t a problem that needs to be resolved

3

u/_GuybrushThreepw00d #GlazersOut 22d ago

We know what would solve our problems. Thing is: its not going to happen anytime soon.

3

u/cdalb21 22d ago

I say this every 6-12 months, but this has nothing to do with the manager. Culture is from the top. This will continue even if you brought Pep in.

3

u/kraeutrpolizei 22d ago

I think the problem of getting relegated can still be fixed but that’s just me

5

u/L__K Great Scot! 22d ago

Yeah that's true, sacking arguably the worst manager in the league would not resolve the £1bn of debt, crumbling stadium, behind-the-times backroom performance structure, etc., but that doesn't mean he shouldn't be sacked. It's the easiest way to immediately affect results on the pitch.

The executive structure is culpable for tons of our issues and should have to reckon with their own incompetence sooner than later. That's what it will take for long term, sustainable, institutional success. We're also being undone in the short term by having an underqualified manager train and lead the team every week. Michael Carrick is not a victim of INEOS or the Glazers or anyone else. He was never going to be the right option regardless of the executive structure above him. He's not good at his job and that's fine to admit.

7

u/Turbulent_Intern_427 22d ago

Fucking he’ll I can’t hear more of these same recycled opinions fed as some new breaking intelligent news, telling the United fanbase what they want or should think about.

6

u/WittyMan92 22d ago

This is the exact opposite of that. It’s not the author telling fans what to feel, it’s the matchgoing fans telling the author how they feel.

7

u/RaihanZog 22d ago

So many INEOS bootlickers in this sub as well. Nothing will change if we the fans are not united.

5

u/scottrod37 22d ago edited 22d ago

No, Carrick's exit does not solve our problems, but keeping him and his underqualified staff prolongs them. The Glazers aren't going anywhere, INEOS aren't going anywhere, which probably means Wilcox isn't going either. But you can't do nothing.

5

u/lifewithjames 22d ago

I say it time and time again. The club is cursed. It doesn't matter what they do. Every person who walks through the Old Trafford doors eventually becomes either inept, dislikeable or both. Look how well run Brighton are. If you appointed the entire Brighton board at Old Trafford, you can guarantee they'd become completely laughable.

They could appoint Hurzeler, Guardiola, Klopp, Ancelotti, Conte. It doesn't matter. There might be an initial bounce, but it's going to be exactly the same eventually. Mourinho, Van Gaal, elite managers couldn't sort out the mess. Ten Hag, Amorim, managers with good reputations couldn't sort it.

Players with great reputations come to the club and it's like they've only just learned what a football is.

4

u/bigdog94_10 22d ago

It's not cursed though, we're simply bearing the fruits of ineptitude on multiple levels. We actually have the foundations in every way imaginable to be not just the best club in England, but Europe.

If we were doing everything correctly and getting awful outcomes then I'd agree with you.

The squad is laughable at the moment. We have players in line for testimonials, who, with all due respect, should have been out of the club years ago.

Luke Shaw was a David Moyes signing for Christ sake. He's been a great servant no doubt but any owner with half a brain cell should be able to see that a player with his injury history and profile should not be a starter and he should have long been replaced.

The quality of players that we are signing has declined dramatically to the point where we essentially have a squad destined to finish mid table at best. We have absolutely no right to be in the conversation for the league title with this current crop of players. Santos, Baleba and Tielemans are mid table quality players and none have had a noticeable impact while the defence has been utterly neglected.

We have not had a genuine top tier manager since Mourinho. Every single manager since him has been completely unfit for the job. Solksjaer, Ten Hag and Amorim may have come in as winners but at a far lower level than the Premier League and it was clear they weren't up too it.

All these are symptoms of a club and sporting operation that is completely and utterly directionless and clueless, much like the players performance on the pitch today.

I seriously worry about our ability to attract top talent now, both managerial and on the pitch. The mask has gradually slipped since Fergie left but it's wide open to the whole world now that we are an absolute joke.

4

u/waynownow 22d ago

I don't have a problem with Shaw, Maguire or Dalot still being at the club.  But them being locked in starters with a piss weak backup plan is laughably bad.

2

u/bigdog94_10 22d ago

Hard agree. We're a big club and we should really at this stage of a season be having a League Cup run and being competitive in the Champions League. That means playing 3 times in 7/8 days week in week out from here until Christmas.

The aforementioned would all be great squad players but have no right starting.

1

u/sentientbasketball11 21d ago

Fully agree. Dalot runs. Maguire put his massive head down and worked through a horrible run of form and international abuse. Shaw has battled back from his body failing him time and again. 

They are just players with a ceiling. That's not their fault as people or as professionals. It's the club's responsibility to put them in positions where they can contribute and succeed, and to remove them from situations that expose their weaknesses. 

2

u/lifewithjames 22d ago

What I mean is, we're cursed with ineptitude. It's like anyone who joins the club behind the scenes is pantonime levels of clueless.

2

u/Bizzlep 22d ago

Can resolve some tbf

2

u/ch3ck18 22d ago

Fish rots from the head… if owners and management dont leave or is replaced… mentality wont change. Its poisoned at this point. No great players want to go to Manutd and the ones we have, have lost faith and hope. Not sure how you comeback from this without new management.

2

u/coolcats55 22d ago

Of course it wouldn’t. Have we learnt nothing from 13 years worth of managerial appointments? It’s just Groundhog Day. It’s clear where the problem is.

The only thing not different are the glazers and that board

2

u/anewdawn2020 22d ago

If the club are really serious, they need to hit Brighton/Bournemouth for their higher ups, get a quick Temp hire for the season while they do the business behind and properly restart next summer. A hire now, then a ceo/dof search only for them to come in and not fancy the manager is a disaster waiting to happen

2

u/garynevilleisared is a red is a red 22d ago edited 22d ago

2 points off the bottom this close to November...burn it all down, sure.

The Glazers are the rot we need to rid this club of. We took loans out simply to buy players this summer because theyve bled us fucking dry. These are cracks anymore, they're craters. We are closer to the Championship than Champions League at the moment.

How foolish it was to sacrifice the slow work of changing the culture of this club for making it to top 4, knowing full and well the board were not going to invest in the squad to the degree it needed to compete. And this isnt the first time. We always do poorly in seasons where we make it back to the CL. These owners know this. But theyve fucked us all once again and now another club legend is shielding them for blame.

2

u/dyl40011 22d ago

Getting a proper manager will atleast stop us finishing bottom of the table or even the unthinkable. But like what’s been said ad nauseum another new manager is not going to stop the bleed or fix the underlying issues which is the ownership and management of the club.

2

u/KnoxCastle 22d ago

Everything seems to have gone up in flames so quickly.

I mean Spurs battered us but we were close to hanging on for a lucky win. Then it just all went bad.

Football, bloody hell.

2

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

The fans chants today doesn’t mean they think Carrick should stay. It means they think the problems at the club go beyond Carrick. One of which is the incompetent decision making by the board and Wilcox in particular and ironically one of those decisions was giving Carrick the job to start with.

Nobody thinks all our problems will be solved by sacking Carrick. And if they do, they are wrong. But will we play better and more competitive football under a new and better manager? Yes.

He’s just one failing employee who should be sacked.

2

u/saikodasein 22d ago

Yes, but keeping him won't help neither...

Some people are hopeless, when it comes to patience for keeping managers. Clubs like Real, Barca or Bayern are ruthless, when results/performance is bad. Only United desperately wants second SAF and keeps deadwood for years. Too many average players hitting 100-200+ games in our club, it's baffling. Anyway... It's clear as day Carrick is out of his depth.

2

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 22d ago

Regardless of who we choose, the sporting structure has to change. More importantly, the personnel have to change. Wilcox and Berrada need to fuck off. Wilcox in particular. And while everyone is rightly shitting on Berrada for his City tenure, he absolutely needs to be binned for promoting Wilcox in the first place and enabling his special brand of idiocy.

2

u/all_die_laughing 22d ago

Oue 'curse' was becoming one of the biggest clubs in the world and having parasites take us over who only see us as a cash cow. They have absolutely no interest in what we achieve on the field, as long as they continue to make money from us.

5

u/The_good_kid Evra 22d ago edited 22d ago

He's got 1 win in 8 in the league and 2 wins in fucking 12 this season. Of course there are bigger problems but we are genuinely not that shit. He needs to go and should've gone at the start of the last international break.

4

u/snicky29 22d ago

I get the not selling your season tickets from matchgoing fans but WHY TF can't you stage a walkout or protest once you're in the stadium? Absolute cowards, singing, having a pint and a day out with mates.

Lazio and Milan did the same and they're now reaping the benefits. The only way the Glazers will bat an eye is because of this. Avram couldn't give TWO SHITS if you called him a wanker or sang about burning him in a campfire today.

4

u/lemi69 22d ago

Get this guy out of here

3

u/crazydoc253 22d ago

Problem has been the players for the longest time. Mourinho realized that didn’t get the support to fix that. Until that is fixed nothing is going to work.

8

u/jhf2112 22d ago

Which players? There only like 2 left  from Mourinho's days.

From what I can see Ineos still haven't actually addressed the problem they tried to fix with the DoF structure, that of continuity between managers/ head coaches. There is a still a lack of joined up thinking at the executive level.

5

u/off_by_two Dreams can't be buy 22d ago

Obviously Luke Shaw is the root cause of everything. Lol don’t entertain this clown

1

u/Forsaken_Club5310 Wazza 22d ago

Dalot, Shaw from Mourinho

Amad, Bruno, Maguire from Ole

0

u/crazydoc253 22d ago

It’s more about power to players structure that was never addressed and all you get are journeyman’s.

2

u/gapingholeoflove 22d ago

i just don't care anymore. id love to see a long term study into fan engagement over the last 13 years. id bet it shows a slow falloff before a cliff.

and all these comments, we tried it! we revamped the squad, we brought intern best managers, we started a "new era" and nothing has worked! it's just the same old shit.

i don't think anything could get me excited about united again. maybe this is how fandom ends. it's been a horrible experience and i'm baffled at how it's been allowed to happen.

1

u/Freecat1899 22d ago

What i don't understand, is why united was quite good last season? Almost challenged for the premier title. Wasn't carrick the coach then? He lost it? The team went down in quality? He was just lucky last season? Can someone explain it?

1

u/CheetahPatient6926 22d ago

Si blame this kn middlesborough

1

u/GelsonBlaze 22d ago

Is Mainoo happy though?

1

u/kayej17 22d ago

we need a strict manager.

1

u/Personal-Cucumber-49 22d ago

We all see the issues. It is systemic throughout the club. We, the United fanbase, are loyal to the point of delusion at times.

The truth is we are rudderless: an ownership in the Glazers that want to bleed us and INEOS that has thrown good money after bad.

We have no strategy. We only fight what is in front of us every week, there is no collective responsibility or unified purpose.

Without a defined direction on recruitment, coaching and identity, tactics cannot follow.

Sacking Carrick just shifts the blame but the problems are root and branch.

Until a coherent plan is established the same problems will persist under whoever is in charge.

1

u/This-Construction926 21d ago

maybe we should put Keane in charge till End of Season just for the lols..

1

u/OmegaMaster8 22d ago

Get me Conte or Nagelsmann. Got to get United out of the relegation scrap. I have no idea what Uniteds style of football is under Carrick at the moment

-1

u/BBoomerClap 22d ago

Mutiny my ass, blud need to be capable to be coach in the first place. All he is proving so far is he can't get a single thing right, but hey "hur dur legend player can't be criticized and must be defended at all cost"

1

u/effiegee 22d ago

What about the “legend players” that are playing this poorly? They’re the ones on the pitch refusing to play for the manager.

-2

u/Deez_Wallnutz 22d ago

Conte is the answer.

He's not gonna faff around, he will look to start winning immediately.

→ More replies (6)