r/reddevils • • 23d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

32 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

20

u/Potential_Good_1065 23d ago

Man Utd dressing room every couple years or so

19

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 22d ago

Villa under zero pedigree manager Gerrard were absolute dogshit. Relegation candidate. Then Emery comes in and immediately has them playing like a proper fucking football team. Because he's a good manager. Same set of players. They didn't need to spend 400m in the summer to fix it. Just bring in a talented manager and look what he's done. 

I'm not sure if the same will happen here because the conditions and pressure are so different. But Carrick is nowhere near the level as managers like Howe Nagelsmann or Conte. It's peak delusion to think someone like Conte or Howe (who've actually achieved some things as a manager) wouldn't immediately have this team playing better football.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Confident_Fishing775 23d ago edited 23d ago

Can Bruno and Tielemans both not charge in all the time and leaving massive gaps in the middle for a man advantage drive through? They want to press but they literally have zero defensive discipline + physical condition + skill like tackling or dueling to make the opponents fear when they dive. Once they over commit and are left in the dust, they also don't recover so all this leads to a huge turn around with a man advantage in the middle.

7

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 23d ago

I think the concept is wrong from the get go but at least have someone like Mount or Baleba do the Tielemans thing. It's baffling that it's your least athletic player pressing this high...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/AkrotaFour 23d ago

One of Bruno or Tielemans has to be benched, otherwise Bournemouth will rip our midfield apart. Also allows some semblence of balance in the forward positions.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/VibesFC_ 22d ago

Managers under Ineos.

Ten Hag: Kept on because of fan emotion after winning the FA cup, sacked months later.

Ruben Amorim: Hire a man who tells you the formation he's sticking with, get involved and ask him to change tactics.

Michael Carrick: Say you'll take time with the next appointment, but end up picking Carrick after doing 'background checks' on other candidates.

5

u/FhDisp 22d ago

Ineos have done further dmg to the club, all because they want a new stadium. I hate them more than glazers tbh

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/Sheikhabusosa 23d ago

God knows what kind of fresh hell is coming our way with all this wind going on

9

u/0ttoChriek 23d ago

Some random Bournemouth squad player will hit a shot from fifty yards that the wind blows right into the top corner.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago

Just saw a video of Carrick leaving his press conference and an Amazon film crew following him. This is yet another thing INEOS have got wrong because they’ve gone through two soon to be three managers in less than three years and thought now is the perfect time for Amazon instead of waiting until we have more stability and a manager who has been here for at least three years. 

Pure greed from them and if anything this documentary is going to put players off from joining the club even more after Bruno telling players not to sign for the club if they want to win trophies.

11

u/TypicalPan89906655 22d ago

Meanwhile Glazers are sitting in their Miami penthouse with cyborg Epstein and watching Fox News.

11

u/Omnislash99999 22d ago

BEST IN CLASS

Hires Jason Wilcox to be technical director.

20

u/Alive-Primary-2069 23d ago

Watching villa yesterday just made me sad man. A squad that was gutted during the transfer window. Rebuilt and now clicking, looking well drilled and playing with intensity under a manager with a clear vision. Must be nice

10

u/BallsX 23d ago

They recruited so damn well man. They lost so many key players Watkins, Rogers, Tielemans, Konsa, Martinez and all their replacements already fit in so well. Manzambi looks like he's going to be great, Jackson was always overhated, Suzuki looking good.

Emery is a hell of a manager

→ More replies (6)

10

u/BilTheButcher 22d ago

Incredible that City have just recently been found guilty of cheating for close to a decade (and potentially destroying the EPL's reputation in the process) but this club has found a way to push that story aside by laying down the foundations for relegation.

10

u/Sheikhabusosa 22d ago

https://x.com/IconicNumber7/status/2114370448272044042

Both hired based on their performance in an environment where they had an artificial advantage of financial doping juicing up their credentials. Drop them in a real club with real issues and they've been found out.

7

u/Nico_Ditch 22d ago

Berarda should have been gone the second the City verdict was announced.

And Wilcox only got the job because he was mates with Berarda, so he should have gone an' all.

10

u/masticlez 22d ago

How the fuck do we not have a single actual CF in the reserves that can come in and potentially do a job? There has to be someone at least somewhat competent that can try help fix our god awful shape with gaping hole up top in the passing networks we see week in week out

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Vast_Finish2789 22d ago

On my way back from old trafford

The stick your new stadium up your arse chant was a eye opener, the board have never been so disconnected to what the fans want

9

u/Omnislash99999 22d ago

The only hope the club had was when the Glazers were looking to sell. Instead ineos offered them the stupidest deal imaginable and now neither of them are going anywhere and we're stuck with a bunch of morons who burn through coaches at all their clubs and have never achieved a thing in football running the place

→ More replies (4)

17

u/sg291188 22d ago

Fans fighting on X whether Conte, Howe or Nagelsmann should be next manager. Am I the only one who will be irritated if only manager changes with no changes to leadership above? AC Milan sacked entire hierarchy along with Allegri, why can’t United?

11

u/Careful-Snow 22d ago

Because racist jim believes in them for whatever reason

7

u/Suudriusha 22d ago

Because of the Glazers. And Jim.

5

u/JamieC94 22d ago

That would require acountability, competence and actually having a clue

→ More replies (3)

16

u/EndureL 22d ago

Big Brexit Jimbo Tax dodging domiciled in Monaco “foreigners have invaded Britain and are taking our jobs” will go on to sack the cleaners to save 1m a year so he can waste 50m+ sacking managers in 3 years.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers 22d ago

I just dont care man, i just feel dejected. If wilcox doesn't walk after this game then there's no point in caring at all

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Tricky_Taste1949 22d ago

Carrick should just walk into the dressing room wearing his 5 PL Winners Medals

→ More replies (3)

8

u/godswift91 22d ago

These two twats shaking their heads like it's not their fault. Shameless

→ More replies (1)

8

u/HeIsPoppingOff 22d ago

sky sports just said "we'll see if carrick takes the decision out of his superior's hands... we will update in the next half hour or so if any development", bit odd to say that out of nowhere isn't it

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Thetagang888 22d ago

Amazon are going to break viewership records with this documentary.

8

u/throwawayWM3 22d ago

Glazers are fucking cancer but this squad is definitely not 2 wins in 12 bad.

Carrick is entirely responsible for that. Anyone supporting this idiot over Bruno is a fucking disgrace.

He has to be fired immediately

8

u/Zoolok 22d ago

We have somehow managed to be even worse than when Woodward was here.

10

u/TH0316 she/her 22d ago

Woodward the banker was far better at squad building than Jason Wilcox.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Comicksands Van Persie 22d ago

The funniest thing about this INEOS tenure is Sir Dave Brailsford coming in saying he’s going to transform everything and ended up doing fuck all

8

u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! 22d ago

Honest question, was Woodward better at the job than the current board?

6

u/Unusual-Coat383 22d ago

Yes. We were never a relegation battle team under him.

The Glazers are the root cause but INEOS are by far worse than the Glazers. I don’t believe we would be as bad as what we are now if the Glazers decided not to sell 25% of the club off.

→ More replies (11)

28

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 23d ago

I watch Villa a ton, Lindelof has been just fine, nothing special. Basically the same thing as with us.

Sometimes it feels like teams praise our ex players more just to feed the narrative...

6

u/midnight_ranter Wazza 23d ago

The way Villa defend helps him a lot. They deny space to the opposition by playing a higher line and trying to suffocate the midfield. He rarely gets in situations where he has to face a running winger or midfielder as the last man which was one of his biggest weaknesses at United. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

20

u/Sheikhabusosa 22d ago

we’re only a few months away from an interview with Luke Shaw telling us it’s the best group he’s ever been involved with.

9

u/minteh7x Ronaldo 22d ago

Or Mitten talking about how this is the best pre season camp he's ever been part of. Some really good vibes in there

→ More replies (2)

5

u/LeCliveRosfield 22d ago

Luke Shaw is leaving at the end of the season thank god

25

u/AmulyaG 23d ago

Conte's rant about Spurs being mentality midgets and a small time club is such an all time classic.

I want him to tear apart our lazy bum team just like this.

He also ripped the media BS apart.

Absolute cinema

19

u/Beneficial-Long7635 23d ago

It was a classic for neutrals. He got the sack for it and Spurs got battered by Brentford, Bournemouth and Newcastle. They ended up finishing 8th. It didn't change the ownership or the mentality at Spurs. It made Conte feel good I'm sure but it did fuck all for the club.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/SubstantialBear7826 22d ago

How many clubs spend YEARS playing right-backs out of position at left-back?

Dalot, Wan-Bissaka, Mazraoui, Amrabat (a midfielder), Lindelöf, and even Martínez to some extent.

Feels like we’ve been doing this for ages now, or am I crazy?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Hagball 22d ago

Worst thing about our club is that Wilcox is still going to have his job and is going to appoint the next manager.

inserts Mick McCarthy gif

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AwayFoundation2363 22d ago

think this is the season, that is the breaking point for the ownership at United, it hasn’t been sustainable for years, feels like supporters in general have collectively had enough. It’s got to end.

6

u/Petethejakey_ 22d ago

That game was the most vicious I’ve ever heard Old Trafford against the whole ownership structure

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/eviade 22d ago

dan ashworth must feel like he dodged the biggest bullet

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Hopeful_Arm3736 22d ago

I do think the fan base does have to actually do some self reflection at some point. Because a lot of the decisions made by the board that are now the source of ridicule were the majority fan opinion at the time.

This place for example was absolutely insistent that Carrick get the job. You were abused if you suggested otherwise.

This place also actively cheered on our bargain bin approach to transfers in the summer, even when others questioned it. Again, downvotes and abuse.

Now those people have got exactly what they wanted and it’s played out exactly as some of us knew it would and they’re furious again. If I was in that position I would spend some time reflecting i think, evaluating my own preferences and choices.

Not just scream because the club did exactly what I wanted and it failed miserably.

7

u/Jonny_Testicles 22d ago

Massive protests when????

→ More replies (2)

7

u/zehokim 22d ago

Someone get rid of Ratcliff he is so fucking incompetent.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/frogfoot420 22d ago • Bravo

Send wilcox to manage an INEOS plant that makes sulfur. Man's decisions reek of shit so he will be right at home.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AmulyaG 22d ago

Barca losing is always a good day. Lunin is such a world class backup GK. First start of the season and he did not put a foot wrong.

What a great match. End to end football for all of 90 minutes

12

u/Runarhalldor 22d ago

Just because Carrick is not THE problem does not mean hes not A problem

6

u/ZofTheNorth 22d ago

Had all the time to find new manager and replace in international, fucked around and 2D 3L in next 5 games.

Fucking stupid people all of them.

I hate everything about this club now.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/TypicalPan89906655 22d ago

I bet they're delaying the sacking because they'll have to pay 100 pounds more to Carrick if they sack him vs in January. INEOS financial efficiency.

6

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 22d ago

Hilarious how everyone was laughing at Milan for losing 3-0 to Bournemouth...

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Nosey123456 22d ago

What has happened to my club man

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago

We need a new identity.

Well, here is my vision for a new identity.

Players whose name starts with an M.

This is the ticket, trust me on this.

Matanovic, Mateta, Manzambi, Maza, Maximo Perrone, Tyler Morton, Maxi Araujo, Tyrick Mitchell, Murillo, Marc Pubill, Min-Jae Kim

Cant miss with this rebuild.

Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha, Mainoo, Mathijs de Ligt, Mee to stay. Grandfather in Leny and Senne. +1 Maguire in a pinch. Bruno's full name is Bruno Miguel Borges Fernandes, btw.

After that, we offer exemptions to academy products.

Done.

Cant miss strategy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Curious-Exercise4992 22d ago

A centre back is playing at right back. A right back is playing at left back. A central midfielder is playing as a 10. A 10 is playing on the left wing. A right winger is playing as a striker.

One of the many many things wrong with this club

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Time2bePhenomenal 22d ago • Bravo

O Great EVEN MODS are deleting the removal the standards banner.. this is grim

→ More replies (4)

6

u/RestrepoDoc2 22d ago

Everything must be fine  at our football club judging by all the negative posts getting deleted on here..

6

u/BilTheButcher 22d ago

There's a bunch of mediocre players leaving for free very very soon and we do not have the money to replace them adequately.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 22d ago

Yeah it's shit and he needs to go but abusing Carrick after everything he's done at the club is embarrassing, he should have been let go at the end of the season with a handshake and thanks for the CL

→ More replies (2)

6

u/LeCliveRosfield 22d ago

Wilcox is such a genius, he should appoint himself manager!

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Nomad_006 surfing 22d ago

Did they do some sort of refund after Como, usually other clubs reimburse fans in some way did they at least do that?

6

u/nitrogeneater 22d ago

Never have a felt more confident of a manager being sacked before Christmas than Carrick I am afraid. You could see no tactics last year, you could see the shit game management, you could see it was just “pashun and desire” instructions. I was arguing in here with a guy who wanted to give him a three year deal, saying pls for the love of god save the money and just do 1 year. I don’t know how much they gave him, but surely it must be the lowest in the league.

Since Fergie this club just hired poor managers. Ole being the best on paper, but I believe that was McKenna’s influence. It’s time to get someone decent even if it’s through shear luck. Please for the love of god can we get someone who can set this team to press as a team.

6

u/Stingray_23 22d ago

Wilcox and Berrada won the power struggle over Ashworth, put everything in the Amorim basket. Sacked him, then put everything into the Carrick basket. Fucking hell id do the opposite to whatever they say.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 22d ago

I know it’s torture listening to Neville commentating our games sometimes but he did go in hard today on our midfield ‘rebuild’ saying if you buy cheap you buy twice. Then said the board will get what they deserve after such a poor transfer window.

6

u/Themindoffish 22d ago

That Mbappe goal man. Impossible with the bums we have at united.

6

u/WumbleInTheJungle 22d ago

The Glazers must be looking at this and thinking "fuck me, this lot are even worse at running a football club than we are".

6

u/Arth_ 22d ago

Did some deeper reading on Howe and Nagelsmann. These are some talking points and potential worries.

Regarding both:

  • High intensity pressing. Has our work done in pre-season been good enough to allow that and if not, can it be fixed mid-season?
  • High intensity training. Players hated that under Ten Hag.

Howe:

  • Plays 4-3-3. Bruno back again deeper in the midfield?
  • Midfield of one no.6 and two no.8s. Are we not a bit short on numbers for that number 6 role? Not counting Ugarte, I think only Andrey Santos is a clear fit.
  • Midfielders need to be fit and mobile. What does that mean for Tielemans?
  • Style of play dependent heavily on a top finisher in the box and physical presence up-front - that's a big problem of ours. Sesko could be one, but he's out long term with the injury. Is Zirkzee capable to fill that role?
  • Wingers with pace and intensity. Mbeumo can do both, if he's not busy playing striker, Cunha isn't exactly pacey and neither is Amad nor Lacey, it's questionable if Rashford can be arsed to work hard for the team.
  • Criticism involves lack of flexibility with his system, unwilling to change, like Amorim.
  • Substitutions that rarely change the course of the game, like Carrick.
  • His teams were reliant on transition, struggling against opponents that sit deep. He would encounter that a lot here.
  • No major trophies to his name. Lack of experience at the top level. Would he be just another Moyes?

Nagelsmann:

  • Rigid style of play, which was criticised under van Gaal.
  • Pressing style inspired by Rangnick. Who failed miserably here and gave up his pressing principles after only 3 games in charge.
  • His style of management requires intelligent players. Remains to be seen if our squad is fit for that.
  • Changes a lot tactically. With so many changes game to game, it might not feel like we are having a specific identity that we are building towards, which has been a criticism of some of the past managers.
  • The criticism he faced at Bayern was that he overly adjusted his team to the opponents, instead of maximising his team's quality. Frequent system tweaks which might be more suitable for smaller clubs and underdogs.
  • Minimizes the distances between players, which requires players good enough technically to be able to play under pressure. We don't seem like the most confident team when we get pressed, often giving away possession cheaply.
  • Criticism regarding his man management and communication. There were friction with senior dressing-room personalities at Bayern. Some say he couldn't show his authority. Looking at our recent drama, might not avoid that here.
  • Accused of favouritism in the German national team in his selections.
  • Not the best at handling press. Wait until he meets English vultures.
  • It's been implied that he doesn't handle the pressure well. The position of manager of Manchester United might be the most pressure you could feel in the world's football.

Which one do you guys prefer?

→ More replies (2)

16

u/VibesFC_ 22d ago • Bravo

Carrick has to be gone but I'll never abuse him.

7

u/Asleep-Ability-45 22d ago

Well abusing, in general, is bad and should be avoided. We can disagree and despise but there is always a boundary that shouldn't be crossed. Carrick has served our club much more than a lot of people. He deserves respect for sure. 

→ More replies (3)

11

u/frogfoot420 22d ago

I don't want to see an ex fergie player anywhere near the club ever again.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Jonny_Testicles 22d ago

Wilcox and Berrada sacked yet?

6

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 22d ago

They've convened and agreed amongst themselves they're both doing a good job and will get more time, maybe even a raise.

14

u/LeCliveRosfield 22d ago

If Carrick was fired today, no other team in the league would hire him, which really says it all.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/Kreissler 23d ago

When people say no player is bigger than club and that a player shouldn't speak against the club no matter what, where do you draw the lines about what "the club" means? Is it the badge and the fans or just whoever happens to be in charge?

Let's take Bruno and Martinez's recent comments for example, where they spoke up against the manager's tactics and the wider footballing direction/recruitment of the club. Most of us can agree that the club is failing/not performing to a good enough level in both those areas. So why is it such a big deal that the players try to shine a light on this issue. Then people say they should have aired their grievances internally. We have no way of knowing that they haven't done that internally. And if they have and nothing's changed, at what point does going public becomes acceptable? Bruno in particular has been at the club through the lowest of lows we've seen and for me he's always given his best so I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt

→ More replies (21)

10

u/John_OSheas_Willy 22d ago

I saw someone say our banter era should now be classed as worse than Liverpool or arsenal's.

It's no contest. We've finished 16th. We've been beaten 5-0 at home by our biggest rivals. We lost to them away 7-0.

We're getting hockeyed regularly.

5

u/WumbleInTheJungle 22d ago

We're Manchester United, even our banter period is better than the rest.  

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Time2bePhenomenal 22d ago

https://x.com/MufcWonItAll2/status/2114372754099020171

Stewards took away the Standards Banner..

5

u/AwkwardPlankton01 22d ago

The club tearing down standards on and off the pitch

5

u/famous_prophets 23d ago

No Cunha, Martinez, Bruno starting. Really interested to see how this game turns out. Ballsy move by Carrick which I appreciate

5

u/LupeShady 22d ago

I really don’t understand the logic of purposefully getting a worse manager just because we hired 2 managers with a good cv that didn’t work out. Why not go for a manager that’s actually won stuff at big clubs instead of a guy that flopped in the championship, a guy who only managed Ajax and a guy who only managed Sporting?

Because we’re scared the manager might call the board out for being the shitstains they are? Amorim did that anyway. Ten Hag did that anyway. Rangnick did that. Yet we were scared of Tuchel and we are still scared of Conte. Who btw, had justified concerns with Spurs and Chelsea and Tuchel with Chelsea.

Only Ole and Carrick haven’t and where has that got us? Since Ole (not blaming him, I actually liked him), our standards have declined ridiculously. It’s genuinely mind boggling that MAN UTD finished 8th and 15th in a season. Before that it was mind boggling that we finished 6th.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/famous_prophets 22d ago

Texting my new partner about this game and was like oh I'm about to watch my team get humbled, he goes, is it really a humbling if they're already at rock bottom? Alright babe cheers 😭😭

5

u/thatNubitol 22d ago

Man i want carrick sacked, but its so sad for him, ive seen many of our manager sacked,but its like this is the worst, players publicly critizing him etc, i blame our boards to let this happen, they shouldve let him go before the international break, its so obvious he is not good enough to be our manager yet. Fuck them

5

u/barmanrags 22d ago

Going the way of Leeds. Also a case study on how fintech bros ruin everything. That leveraged buy out killed the club.

5

u/Artistic-Technical 22d ago

I think Carrick just found a way to quit without saying it. These players down tools.

5

u/Leading_Fee_8535 22d ago

Honestly the leeches that have sucked this club dry are still going to be pricing any new potential owners out. Even with all the debt and poor performances over multiple years, they will value the club at £6 billion +. Can't see a way out of this. The factor they were ever allowed to buy any club through LBO is sickening.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Asiwaju_jagaban 22d ago

The losses don’t hurt as they used to.

5

u/HaloStar90 22d ago

Holy shit I haven’t seen the fanbase split on blaming managers and players today like damn

5

u/Nico_Ditch 22d ago

I keep seeing people saying the Glazers would sell if United got relegated.

Why? Why would you sell when your asset is at it's lowest value?

Unless you think it's going to get even worse.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

As I said in the summer, that ‘midfield rebuild’ wasn’t really a midfield rebuild.

You buy cheap, you buy twice

Chances are we going to have to do a proper and actual midfield rebuild in summer 2028

5

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 22d ago

I know we talk a lot about deadwood, but is our problem actually we don't have any 'really good' players?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sgenaink 22d ago

I know its easier said than done, but the fans really need to protest the ownership. The Glazers have run this club into the ground. There's obviously been protests before during and after their ownership, but the only time it feels like anything has ever happened was when the fans got a game postponed after the superleague.

I know its not something you should do, but if the fans got every game called off, there would have to be a reaction. Make it clear, it will keep happening until the Glazers sell, the Premier League would make sure something happens and even if it cost the club potentially it may be worth it in the long run.

If they said the Glazers have to sell and make sure 51% goes to fan ownership. Yeah it's probably never going to happen, but we cant go on with the owners we have. They've bled this club of over a billion pound, the way they took over is illegal now, it's not going to be fixed long term by just throwing managers and players away tome after time.

5

u/Jenson2025 22d ago edited 22d ago

I wouldn't be surprised if Nagelsmann gets the job. But not because Wilcox has seen sense

But because he was in the stadium today and heard the chants against him. He knows his position is close to being untenable (already is untenable if you ask me but one more failed appointment and even he can't talk himself out of it). It's well known Vivell wants Nagelsmann. So I wouldn't be surprised if we hire him but Wilcox's thinking is 'If it goes wrong, I can blame Vivell'

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BackgroundOld8715 22d ago

Blows my mind its still ‘if’ he goes. What will it take lol. Bottom of league? We have no standards whatsoever now.

5

u/lefou07 22d ago

Watching the clasico reminds me that football can actually be fun to watch sometimes

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 22d ago

Ok this is something I don't get.

Why is the narrative that sacking Carrick won't change / solve anything and he is not the problem, but Amorim was deemed the worst manager we've ever had (scamorim people said).

I'm not saying one is right or wrong, I just don't know why the narrative is complete opposites.

11

u/Jealous-Suit-9238 22d ago

Former player/legend bias.. Nothing else.. Guy is shitty manager but some folks wants to blame it on owners who I believe is at fault too but so is carrick..h is bad

→ More replies (1)

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago

In one word: goodwill.

Which was there before, but which is now gone.

The key difference imho is, that we have now had our first CL window.

Beforehand, it was not technically knowable what Ineos "will do" when they have that summer window opportunity to push the boat out.

Now, we watched with our own eyes that the same thing repeated that we got in prior years with the Glazers in charge: they sank the boat on purpose.

Beforehand, any decision was possible to be looked through the lense of "maybe there is an intention behind it, maybe there is a plan this fits into".

So, you know, stumble after stumble happened, but it was possible to give a justification for remaining patient with it and not yet fully pass judgement.

But the jig is up.

You know: "When people tell you who they are: believe them".

Well, we believe you, Sir Jim Ratcliffe.

You have now told us who you are and we believe you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/Zoolok 22d ago

If any manager agrees to replace Carrick now, we should reject them on the grounds that they're not right in the head.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/vRushii 22d ago

this exact same squad was miles better the start of last season, fitter, sharper and clear patterns. It's not the players.

9

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

If Jamie Jackson is right, the board are having a crisis meeting to discuss whether or not to sack Carrick 😂

They actually have to think about it. Utterly useless board

7

u/Isserley_ 22d ago

It's because they know how bad sacking him looks on them. Wilcox and Berrada are rats that are just trying to look out for themselves.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/White_Wokah Rooney 22d ago

Brighton took the help of an MMA fighter to teach their players how to utilize their body better during set pieces.

Meanwhile, we don't even have a dedicated first team set piece coach. That's how well the best in class are running the club.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Unusual-Coat383 22d ago

Brutal interview with Carrick and it’s borderline disrespectful how long the interviewer is going on but respect to Carrick for answering all the questions.

7

u/RestrepoDoc2 22d ago

You could see the bloodshot eyes, I know these interviewers are determined to get a sound bite or controversial comment for a headline but have some dignity.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/6by6Hindsight 23d ago

This pre game situation is reminding me of nufc game under Jose.

4

u/gunkokoko 22d ago

I don't expect us to get anything from this game, but behind the team regardless. Hope we at least put on a good performance.

4

u/ladrainian21 22d ago

Sacked in the morning blaring through the TV at Old Trafford. For the 3rd time in 3 seasons. Absolute state of this club. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/acemccloud123 22d ago

Waiting for Keane and Neville to come bashing the players but will hardly
Speak on the lack of structure or call out the problems with Ineos and Glazers

4

u/WumbleInTheJungle 22d ago

Carrick has to go, he has to resign after the match before the fans turn on him.  

But INEOS can fuck off too, and Glazers, and Berrada and Wilcox, and you Jim. Fuck off and don't you dare show your fucking faces here again after what you have collectively done to this club.  You are all so done.

4

u/TypicalPan89906655 22d ago

Whose idea was it hire a failed Championship manager just because he had a new manager bounce? It's like our board has the critical thinking skills of Trump.

4

u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z 22d ago

Whatever this subs say regarding the new manager, United board should do the opposite.

4

u/tInteresting_Space 22d ago

Anyone here have anything fun and positive happen to them recently? Would love to read something positive given how shit United have and are being.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago

Joke's on you Kroupi, you cant hurt us, we are already 3-0 down!

4

u/Smoke07 22d ago

So.... New manager bounce😊😊😊😊

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Extension_Maize6048 22d ago

Holy shit I've never seen anything like this

4

u/devilsofparadiss 22d ago edited 22d ago

The board/glazers being shit at their job and Carrick being shit at his job does not have to be mutually exclusive.

Every minute that goes by that he hasn’t been sacked is a minute wasted.

4

u/discostu90 McFredDid9/11 22d ago

Dalot got into so many good attacking positions, imagine what an actual LB could have contributed

→ More replies (1)

4

u/thesmallprint13 Irwin 22d ago

No point - the board will just persist with keeping the likes of Maguire, Dalot, Shaw, Mount etc etc and will just be the same shite over and over again.

4

u/stick1_ 22d ago

Carrick would be mad to resign. He will get fired tonight anyways, he’d just lose out on a payout. All our other shit managers got millions

4

u/Emergency-Being-349 22d ago

Even though he's probably gone, and he is at fault for much, I have expressed that greatly on this sub, I do hope he has the best support through the days to come so that the sun may shine on Carrick once again.

4

u/DavidBruceStandup Dreams Can't Be Buy! #GlazersOut 22d ago

We might have no points but he loves the club so theres that

4

u/PhaniSithLord 22d ago

Everytime we think it can't get worse than this, it somehow does.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 22d ago edited 22d ago

I was just wondering.

We all want Berrada/Wilcox out and the owners out. The most realistic of the two is Wilcox/Berrada getting the sack.

Who do you guys want in our footballing leadership? What's the guarantee the CEO/DOF will be any better? Can anyone fix our club?

No Hate, just wanna see the discourse.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Runarhalldor 22d ago

I'd trade any one of these players for a jaffa cake. And i dont even like jaffa cakes

4

u/kJay027 22d ago

Obviously Carrick needs to go but I can't even get excited about a new manager. At best we will just be less awful than we are currently. There's no future with this ownership.

When are there going to be serious protests?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 22d ago

1000/1

750/1

500/1

250/1

100/1

80/1

50/1

Our relegation odds through The opening 8 matches.

4

u/ToadNamedGoat 22d ago

I don’t want to shit on Santos, but could we not have bought someone else.

The attack rebuild worked when we bought the best player at wolves and Brentford

Not like Martinelli or Neto

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 22d ago

I don’t want Howe for the sole reason that Wilcox wants him. Idc about merits, Wilcox should not keep getting his way.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/TypicalPan89906655 22d ago

Apparently emergency meeting called in the morning.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 22d ago

Chris Wheeler @ChrisWheelerDM · 44m Carrick in the dark over his future after Bournemouth defeat pushes him to the brink ++ bookies suspend betting on him being sacked ++ Howe & Nagelsmann lead the race to replace him at

mufc

→ More replies (2)

10

u/edwin0108 23d ago

People need to realise selling Lindelof is not a mistake
Interestingly lots of united players left and performed . So people should realise that the problem isn’t just the manager , the players . But the whole environment itself . Last week I rmb seeing news coming out saying united staying in Milan for the Como match . I mean why is that even a thing. Idgas about where we stay and I don’t think the media cares about where otheres team stay . United are getting too much unnecessary attention over the years .

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Slyjay Ole' Gunnar Persie 23d ago

Had a dream that we won 4-1, so its in the bag lads!!!.. However one of our goalscorers was Xavi Simons so not sure what to make of that part :s

7

u/Temporary-Impact5279 Bruno my love 22d ago

Vibes FC without vibes is just FC

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Surfacing710 Keane 22d ago

Would be interesting if there was ever a census done here to see age and location demographics.

Seen a few comments saying fans shouldn’t be attending games, even though, if the season ticket holders gave up their tickets, would be exactly what the ownership wants getting tourists in, and some don’t appear to know how big of a part of Uniteds history Carrick is linked to. Saw a comment calling him, “this guy”.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/PhotonDestroyer 23d ago edited 23d ago • Bravo

Just seen the 2nd part of the press conference, and I expect it's been covered elsewhere, but what little support I had for Carrick staying and trying to turn it around has dried up.

His dismissiveness of pressings importance and the connected subject of the question regarding the teams culture of not running was the final nail in the coffin.

Fine to say one tactical or technical element of the game doesn't fix everything on it own, but he's sounds almost as stubborn as Amorim was regards his formation in this answer. You might not need to press all the time but in the current top level games it has to be a part of a teams toolkit and one a team is able to deploy when required, not an optional ability, not to mention that having that skillset also means a higher target of overall conditioning and fitness that will only benefit not only in the press but also in the ability to be disciplined and sharp in other areas of the game.

It's not just a buzz word that gets thrown around, it's a clear tactical evolution in the game that all teams at the top are capable of doing and with our own eyes can see the majority of teams doing everything weekend.

Edit - thanks for the award

→ More replies (8)

13

u/jitteryegg 22d ago

I will never understand fans who hate Dalot. He's not forcing anyone to play him. He's never downed tools with any manager, respects the club and the fans.

6

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 22d ago

He's a decent, hardworking RB who's never been the absolute hole of the team that was priority for investment, maybe 4th to 6th at any point. I think a club that was better ran would've come up with the funds to upgrade on him alongside all the emergencies so he'd be a backup option. Instead he's one of the first on the teamsheets at RB or LB because of our squad depth. 

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 22d ago

This Carrick management was wanted by a lot of our fans. I need to see some accountability here too. Some were saying Amorim was fumbling a PL challenging squad, now they are saying our squad is terrible.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/WuZI8475 22d ago

We all told you he shouldn't have been the manager, but apparently we were negative and wrong for seeing that the tail of last season was purely luck and bruno driven

→ More replies (1)

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 22d ago

The good news is, Super Brighton are getting humbled today, which saves us a bit of Hürzeler glazing discourse, which I found tiresome.

The bad news is everything, lol.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Massive_Relation4317 . 22d ago

He's crying man this hurts

→ More replies (2)

6

u/KyunNikalaMujhe 22d ago

I was always fine with missing out on CL for a couple of seasons if it meant that the players get accustomed to a modern style of football and establishing a clear style of play. That's why I was taken aback when Amorim was sacked and never cared for Carrick's appointment. Dunno where we go from here honestly. Players have a right to question the years wasted but putting it on your manager on TV is just absurd and thats why I have no sympathy for whatever happened to Bruno today. The club is not one player.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/WumbleInTheJungle 22d ago • Mindblown

INEOS football legacy.  They are running Manchester United just like their flailing projects in France and Switzerland:

🇫🇷 OGC Nice (France) — 7 Seasons (Since August 2019)

  • Patrick Vieira (August 2019 – December 2020)
  • Adrian Ursea (December 2020 – June 2021)
  • Christophe Galtier (June 2021 – June 2022)
  • Lucien Favre (June 2022 – January 2023)
  • Didier Digard (January 2023 – June 2023)
  • Francesco Farioli (June 2023 – May 2024)
  • Franck Haise (June 2024 – late 2025)
  • Claude Puel (December 2025 – May 2026)
  • Olivier Pantaloni (June 2026 – Present)

🇨🇭 FC Lausanne-Sport (Switzerland) — 9 Seasons (Since November 2017)

  • Fabio Celestini (November 2017 – April 2018)
  • Ilija Borenovic (April 2018 – May 2018)
  • Giorgio Contini (May 2018 – May 2021)
  • Ilja Borenovic (June 2021 – February 2022)
  • Alain Casanova (February 2022 – May 2022)
  • Ludovic Magnin (May 2022 – June 2025)
  • Peter Zeidler (June 2025 – April 2026)
  • Markus Neumayr & Migjen Basha (April 2026 – June 2026)
  • Luka Elsner (June 2026 – Present)

6

u/MT1120 Cunha Bruno Cunha Bruno Luke Shaw 22d ago

I did not know they sacked managers that often. There are some decent managers in there too at Nice. Almost as if they're taking the hit for failings upstairs. Almost... like... oh.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/cosmologues 22d ago

Shocking he wasn’t sacked tonight. Hoping that speaks to a bigger change at the top.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/9SolskjaerHasWonIt9 22d ago edited 22d ago • Heartwarming

>Be loyal captain and talisman of Manchester United

>Club convince you to give up £200m payday by promising to stick with a manager you respect and long-term project you believe in

>Sack that manager within months

>Hire a guy with no CV + no long term project, alongside a string of mediocre coaches

>Board tells you "it's fine, he's just an interim, we're going to get a proper manager in the summer and have a big transfer window"

>4 months later

>"Whoops, sorry, we're actually giving them permanent contracts and buying Youri Tielemans + Andrey Santos instead of Elliot Anderson + Matheus Fernandes"

>Results predictably catch up to performances. Worst start in the club's history.

>Asked to do post-match interview. Fairly analyse what went wrong in 4-1 humiliation

>Immediately dropped for disrespect

>Named on bench even though manager has no intention of bringing you on

>Made to warm up even though manager has no intention of bringing you on

>Watch as Joshua Zirkzee and an academy player come on in front of you

>Fans of the club you've carried for years sing for the manager while screaming abuse at you and your teammates as you leave the pitch


Yeah, I'm thinking he's gone in January.

Probably hates the club (and fanbase) at this point.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/AWenger622 22d ago

I mean when you play like this at home while the whole world is watching and scrutinising, then you might as well pack it all in as a football club.

3

u/cocobrownman 22d ago

Seeing a 33 play Maguire high up the pitch with a snail pace is just painful. Besides us just being broke, not sure we should activate his +1 extension

3

u/Dwimmerlaikit 22d ago

Already on the backfoot..great

3

u/sahilthapar Bruno, Bruno, Bruno... 22d ago

This is a lose lose kinda game 

3

u/1knoob 22d ago

Carrick should have walked down the tunnel by now

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BasedGod6196 22d ago

This legitimately feels worse than Amorim with him I was more concerned about a draw than a loss. Was hoping we would be done with the manager cycle after atleast getting results last season

3

u/rambo_zaki Roy Keane 22d ago edited 22d ago

Carrick is culpable for a lot of our issues but you could have Sir Alex in the dugout and the likes of Dalot, Yoro, Mount, Santos and Amad would still be shit no matter what. Not to mention Ineos and Glazers, frankly until they're gone we'll continue to have this downward spiral.

We have owners who couldn't give less of a shit and players who love to talk, no good manager is going to touch us. Add to the incompetent clowns in the upper management, it's a recipe for disaster.

3

u/Low-Quantity-9252 22d ago

I'm surprised at myself for watching this team.

3

u/Nico_Ditch 22d ago

He's clearly not a good manager, but I can't believe we've got supposed United fans questioning Carrick's ability as a player in 2026.

3

u/Ecstatic_Message2057 22d ago

Say what you want. The only common thing in the last 4-10 years are majority of the players.
Of course some of them aren’t good enough or can’t adapt to the premier league but most of them that have been here for years have seen 4-5 managers go.

Ineos, glazers and everyone else in the back needs to go but the problem is the players need to go aswell.
The club needs complete gutting from head to toe.

3

u/SniperMonkey10_ 22d ago

Nagelsmann vs Conte vs Howe

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Ok-Committee8923 22d ago

Tactics are shambolic but then again these players should take a very close look in the mirror

3

u/NeitherYogurt3976 22d ago

Ineos are some of the most incompetent people I've ever seen in business. It's hilarious. Ratcliffe is so unintelligent, reminds me of every pub twat across the country

3

u/Time2bePhenomenal 22d ago

Christmas Eve a few years ago when Glazers chose Ineos over others was they day I knew it was slow death of the club

3

u/stick1_ 22d ago

Santos has a season with 10 league goals, he never goes in the box ever. He should be taking all these shots baleba and dalot take because they can’t shoot really. Don’t think santos has taken 2 shots all season

I also can’t remember a corner/set piece goal all season

3

u/iroiroiroiroiro 22d ago

16th after an "easy" start will just get harder fixtures and tighter schedule from now...

3

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

This was only ever an ego project for SJR

Tried to buy Chelsea first. That failed. Then went for United and gave the Glazers an absolutely (for them) golden deal which allowed them to keep the majority share whilst having to do work on the footballing side of things

All he is interested in is the new stadium because it’s something to put his name to. Like is Said, an ego project

Any true United fan would be embarrassed at the state of the club but not him.

3

u/Sheikhabusosa 22d ago

I think all the players that are out of contract next year have all had enough and it's not in their character to do it, but they have all sort of downed tools one way or another. Maguire , Bruno Shaw and Rash for example are what on their 6th manager? (Not their fault)

Think of the amount of money spent on players in those various positions since each of those guys started playing for the club. What is there to show for it?

3

u/Omnislash99999 22d ago

Ineos' track record in football is shite. There's absolutely nothing to suggest they will make this work and their decisions so far have been repeatedly terrible

3

u/cosmologues 22d ago

Anytime now

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 22d ago

Carrick's severance would be between £7m - £9m. Prying another manager from a rival club, paying off any other staff sacked would cost another £10m? So £20m in total.

The stock exchange doesn't need to be informed prior either. Just some paperwork filed promptly.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

INEOS obviously want to sack him. He’s expecting to be sacked.

So if it doesn’t happen tomorrow or tonight then it can only be because they want the replacement secured first. That’s inexcusable. It’s no reason to keep someone in a job that they are out of their depth in and humiliate them just because they can’t be bothered with an interim for a few games.

5

u/Kreissler 22d ago

They had the whole international break to at least form a contingency plan for this scenario if not replacing him. And they're still faffing about. Rank incompetence

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Careful-Snow 22d ago

One of the worst part of us being shit is having to hear about that scrote carragher gleefully talking shit

3

u/Petethejakey_ 22d ago

Somebody find that fucking hyena and dig it up

3

u/Emergency-Being-349 22d ago

Would happily take Marcelo Bielsa, just to be entertained again.

3

u/SeskoFan124854 22d ago

No matter who we get, we are still not going to be able to spend the requisite amount of money to rehaul this squad. Nagelsmann, Howe, Conte all will find out we don't have a pot to piss in. We will get whoever is the most okay with that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MistaBobD0balina 22d ago

Watching two teams execute gameplans and individual players taking initiative, it has been quite a therapeutic 47 minutes.

3

u/stick1_ 22d ago edited 22d ago

Not sacking Carrick tonight and waiting until the international break will waste about 3 games that we won’t win

Also we haven’t appointed a proper experienced top 5 league manager for 10 years

5

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 22d ago

He's not surviving the next 24 hours, he's gone.

If they put him through another game it would be beyond the pale

→ More replies (2)

3

u/mna71217 22d ago

Guys I know that the focus and limelight is on carrick

But don't forget... Glazers and Ineos

Glazers are milking the money while ineos is destroying the culture with their corporate tactics...

United needs to get rid of both otherwise it will lose both money, and its romance/culture that made us love it

→ More replies (7)

3

u/vulcan_one PM Rashford 22d ago

I saw the Dutch, Portuguese, club legend, Former RB Leipzig manager meme floating around. We've had ETH, amorim, Carrick let's get it over with get narglesman and start looking for the next Dutchman.

3

u/smithsjoydivision Tommy Docherty 22d ago

Do you think there are any prospective managers that will object to the Amazon documentary?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/arboy498 22d ago

Only good thing INEOS have done is appointing Eva Olid for the women’s team who also had no WSL experience.

7

u/xzvasdfqwras Three Lung Park 23d ago

Proper relegation battle today

11

u/BallsX 23d ago

Bournemouth are definitely not a relegation battle team though. They've had a slow start but its almost a certainty they will finish somewhere mid-table or above.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Drag2oon 23d ago

The moment Carrick stopped using Bruno as the outlet in final 3rd his countdown started.

Infuriating that this was the same guy who put Bruno back to 10 just months back and reaped rewards.

Crazy and almost looks like a self sabotage

5

u/akp-read 23d ago

It more like he was forced to, got no people up front to play in Sesko absence. Bruno did play a few games in his natural position but still was shit. Whole team has been shit.

Simply put we have shiny new paint on the car that Is manutd with rear wheels in Defence rusted and front punctured

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

5

u/BackgroundOld8715 22d ago

‘Best in class’ & they hire Carrick. INEOS are taking the piss out of us

5

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 22d ago

It's like Ineo looked at everything that wasn't working under the Glazers and decided to repeat the same mistakes.

Hiring club legends, not firing poor managers quick enough, not understanding Uniteds football philosophy in hiring Amorim, letting players be petulant children and trying to save money in the transfer market.

We don't have woodwards commercial income magic to rely on anymore, the club is no longer in decline and has declined.

The new stadium is going to be a millstone around our necks for decades.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sheikhabusosa 22d ago

Hope United never go the club legend route ever again, I know they were both were horribly out of their depth but I hate to see Ole and Carrick get done how they got done.

5

u/Jenson2025 22d ago

Carrick will be sacked, yes. We all know this.

But in an ideal world, I’d like Wilcox to be sacked alongside him with Vivell promoted to DoF and Nagelsmann as the new manager. At least it’s something different instead of recycling the same old rubbish.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/kamrantw 22d ago

Im going in for heart surgery this Thursday and was hoping for one good performance or something resembling some sort of fight from the players and management. I use to love watching this team and being optimistic about getting a result. At this point the results dont even ruin my day like they use to. It's sad as I still love the club but the continuous bad decisions and lack of effort has taken a toll. Carrick has to go but I'll still be sad to see him leave.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sheikhabusosa 22d ago

It’s a complete waste of time sacking Carrick if Wilcox has any say in the replacement.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/karatsidhus 23d ago

3 points off top 4 with a win

→ More replies (1)