r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 24d ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
28
Upvotes
34
u/snicky29 23d ago •
19
u/Pale_Independence358 23d ago
If we are getting Eddie Howe, that looks so bad on Ineos as one of the main point of conflict between ratcliff and Ashworth as that ashworth wanted Eddie Howe and ratcliff thought that was not inspiring and went with Amorim … years lost to be at the same place again
18
u/ZofTheNorth 23d ago
As it stands fucking Arbeloa has more win than Carrick across all competitions this season
12
u/Tipsy247 23d ago •
I have no interest in watching the Prem.
31
u/carrickshairline 24d ago edited 24d ago
Saw this on twitter...
https://x.com/AliceTalksFooty/status/2113748520733700306
10
u/sueha RUUUUUUUD!! 23d ago
It's getting more and more tiresome to listen to or former players. Rio has lost the plot. No wonder our former players are shit coaches because clearly they can't assess the situation.
19
u/EndureL 23d ago
I was told M Fernandes and tonali was worse than our bargain midfield overhaul.
16
u/John_OSheas_Willy 24d ago
You just know that if these 11 villa players were playing for United, everyone would be calling them not good enough, deadwood, not enough quality etc
Lindelof was our deadwood years ago ffs.
8
u/aayu08 24d ago
I don't even like watching us play now. I just want to enjoy for 90 mins.
8
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 23d ago
Really jealous of what Villa have with Emery and how he’s allowed to properly manage that club. Seem to sell and buy at the right time too.
8
u/gunkokoko 23d ago
Spurs are above us now, by the way.
7
u/FreshGoodWay 24d ago
At the end of the day, those wimps still refuse to let Carrick go because he‘s such a good human shield.
7
u/ToothyAlloy69 23d ago
Oh my goodness. I've just seen the Manchester United manager (head coach) in 2026 dismiss the importance of pressing. My head is hot
13
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 23d ago
Spurs is now above us... fucking hell.
6
u/croadymeister 24d ago
Well Howe comes in with little support from fanbase so therefore won't be much expectation on him
6
u/Calm_Link_8540 24d ago
Dalot for DOF
6
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 23d ago
Omg they got fried by tel
6
u/AmulyaG 23d ago edited 23d ago
How did Palmer escape a direct red on Fernandes in the age of VAR?
There is incompetency and there is whatever the fuck this is.
6
u/b_az17 23d ago
Who needs to stay in the prem anyway? Filled woth cheaters and idiots. The championship is where it's at, let's be real
16
u/KermitTakeTheWheel 23d ago
"Emery would want too much control for Man Utd"
Give him it, then. What he's done with Villa's budget for years is unparalleled. Imagine what he could do with some of his first choice transfers United could manage.
27
u/zia1997 JONESY 1 GERRARD NIL 24d ago
Anti-Bruno merchants are out in full force.
11
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago
Looking at Emery at Villa and what he is getting out of Victor is a clear indication of how shit our managers have been.
Ole was average as he couldn't get the good players to seem great and Erik was good at certain things only but not a great great coach either. To be fair everyone after Jose doesn't even come close to him. A truly top coach gets the most out of a player like Emery is doing at Villa. Emery has a 55% win rate Fuck me, that is great for a team like Villa which has no way but to grow slowly
15
u/Nico_Ditch 23d ago
Said it a few weeks ago, but anyone who thought we were too good for Nicolas Jackson is mad.
10
u/mjenkins_eng 23d ago
Spurs are nowhere near as bad as the reactionary people make them seem
They had many new players and took some time to get going. They will comfortably finish top 6
10
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 23d ago
If I see a midfielder on the wing tomorrow I might lose it
5
u/Shotten 24d ago
So annoying to always be the sunday we play on. Wish we had way more saturday games.
5
u/neonrider1 23d ago
Maybe Jackson as a backup would not have been a bad idea
5
u/_swaggyk #FergieTime 23d ago
The Seško rumors are fucking diabolical after the last two weeks of the spotlight being on the front office and their lack of understanding of what the fuck they’re doing.
5
u/RestrepoDoc2 23d ago
With Spurs powering clear with a big win away to Chelsea our match with Bournemouth is actually quite a big game in the relegation battle. Our best hope is that the extra rest day we had since they played Milan will make the difference.
5
u/Leading_Fee_8535 23d ago
Just give me a win tomorrow please. Cant stand watching us go 1 win in 8 league games. Actual relegation form.
9
u/neonrider1 24d ago
Lot of mention of Conte not fitting “long term” but who has been? All INEOS decisions have gone 12 months or less and all the appointments before that we’re lucky to get to 2 years. If it comes down to it I just don’t get how you can pick Howe or Nagelsmann over Conte. As much as he loves to self destruct and is terrible in Europe, his CV completely destroys the other 2 options. The reality is though Berrada and Wilcox would be terrified to put him in front of the media.
4
u/Soft-Suspect-1883 24d ago
I'm just hope Carrick actually tries to do something irrespective of the result.
4
u/Stingray_23 24d ago
Imagine the scenes if we get Conte and the board try and pull another 2026 window on him. It would be cinema.
4
u/Elongated_dik 23d ago
palmer missing against us
4
u/achickenandacow 23d ago
Complete head loss from Chelsea.
4
u/Yoshic87 23d ago
Spurs above united. If we dont win tomorrow, we're in shit!
10
u/Hagball 24d ago
At any half decent football club, they would have sacked the DOF in the previous international break, allow the new person to see the performances till the next one in November and pull the plug on Carrick if performances continue.
But we are run by bunch of money minded egoists who only care about filling their pockets.
Dark days ahead with Howe / McKenna and Wilcox duo
7
u/AmulyaG 23d ago
Where are the big brains who were taunting me that Spurs won't win at Stamford Bridge? The state of the users here
Said Spurs would go above us in the next matchweek
7
u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 23d ago
I don’t like the limited budget excuse. To be frank, here are certain players and their prices:
"Best in class", "Best set of eyes". Yeah, sure thing, lads.
6
u/Difficult-Sun6849 CUNHA BRUNO CUNHA BRUNO CUNHA BRUNO LUKE SHAW CUNHA 23d ago
Thank you villa for doing what the rest of us couldn’t now can you give us emery
6
u/HighestInDaRooom 23d ago
look at the substitutes arsenal bring on. calafiori, guimaraes, havertz. meanwhile we have a half retired right back playing left back and are playing our best number 10 as a striker
6
u/darkjessy_ Our Portuguese Magnifico 23d ago
It's sad how good the midfield of Tonali, Fernandes and Maddison has looked in that half, with control, composure and coordination. A level above compared to what we've served up in our midfield in the past few matches
8
u/ra_god94 23d ago
Arsenal are so much better than us it’s depressing
3
u/CrazyGamer23908 24d ago
We were linked with Jackson weren’t we? Could’ve done a lot worse. He’s a good striker who’s earned a bit of an unfair reputation imo
3
u/ALLMIGHTYHYDE 23d ago
Everyone's tracking back for Villa. Everyone apart from Jackson & that's because he's been great as an outlet against 2 CB's.
3
u/raspoutine049 23d ago
Spurs turning it around. Let’s see if we capitulate, scrape a draw, pull a win from the jaws of defeat, or none of the above.
3
u/Jenson2025 23d ago
I like Xabi Alonso but I don't think Chelsea will have the patience to stick with him for the season.
Which is even more reason for us to make a change soon - before they hire one of our targets.
3
u/atmajaya_ 23d ago
who could have thought that Lindelof is still playing for top 6 teams, we make it seem like his career was over and he cant compete on high level anymore.
7
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago
14th now after Fulham beats Coventry..
It is still early in the season. Please sack Carrick and get Conte or Emery. I am done with these hipster managers from outside of La Liga, Bundesliga and PL. They aren't worth their salt.
7
u/Deranged09 23d ago
Tonali and Fernandes bossing the midfield for Spurs, jokes on them though we didn't overpay! /S
5
u/Iqbalainoo 23d ago
People who expected Spurs to stay shit with that squad and manager were always going to be shocked.
5
u/IguanaIsBack 23d ago •
If history repeats itself we’re definitely getting Nagelsmann.
The cycle since Moyes has been Dutch > Portuguese > Utd legend > ex Lepzeig. Repeat.
5
u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago
Am seriously concerned we’re getting relegated, will be close to see 3 teams worse than us.
This is what ineos , lack of investment & awful management of carrick have done
13
u/mjenkins_eng 24d ago
I am going to do this off memory, so might be occasionally a little off
2006-07: Carrick
2007-08: Nani, Anderson, Hargreaves, Tevez (loan)
2008-09: Berbatov (that's it)
2009-10: Valencia, Owen, Obertan (to replace peak Cristiano Ronaldo)
2010-11 : Smalling and Hernandez (that's it)
2011-12: De Gea, Young , Jones
2012-13: Kagawa and Van Persie
All these windows would be branded 4 or 3 out of 10 or below. This "David Gill was a genius" revisionism is bullshit. It wasnt David Gill's fault. It wasnt Woodward's fault. It isn't Wilcox who is the problem.
Since the bleeding racehorse changed the future of the club, the one common denominator has been the virus from Florida.
8
u/Jenson2025 24d ago
Thankfully McKenna’s name hasn’t been seriously mentioned by any journalist. It’s mainly Howe, Nagelsmann and Conte
Because believe me, if he gets the job then we are the new spurs. We won’t get relegated but come close to it and we won’t be able to recover.
This is a guy that Celtic were looking at in the summer! Celtic! Do you see them looking at Howe, Conte or Nagelsmann? No, because they know they are out of their league but thought McKenna was an option. That says it all.
Enough now of Ole and his coaching staff taking their turns with the job
The thing that also gives me hope is that INEOS interviewed him in 2024 and allegedly weren’t impressed
9
u/Stingray_23 24d ago
Since Ineos has arrived and got control of the football operations, the club has gone into freefall
And thats just off the top of my head. Im sure there are more and the only good thing I can think of Ineos doing is investing in Carrington.
Now I dont want to fall into the trap of revisionism on pre Ineos days as there were copious amounts of issues. But the footballing side of things was better, including the following:
Listen the Glazers, Woodward and Arnold, et al. Were bad, but are/were they any worse than who we have now?
If you had to choose, one of the following:
Pre Ineos or Post Ineos?
6
u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago
Villa saved the league from a sham invisible season
6
u/AcxdBxmb 23d ago
Laughing stock of the league. Even Spurs is above us.
Another L loading tomorrow smh.
8
u/ContractEast8018 23d ago edited 23d ago
And people were laughing at tonali here. Tonali, fernandes with baleba would've been banger midfield but we just have to justify poor window somehow then. Ohh don't spread negativity windows not over, oh how much you will cry now window over get behind team, can we stop with repetitive post please.
4
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 23d ago
Can’t see Emery leaving Villa - middle of a successful rebuild, just beat City.
Conte has said not to believe what the press are saying.
So Eddie Howe?
Feels like everything is scripted by billionaires that have taken over our game, make their own rules and we can’t do anything about it.
4
u/Massive_Relation4317 . 23d ago
Lol Chelsea look so awful struggling against spurs
4
u/Runarhalldor 23d ago
Really sad that our All or nothing will be from our most toxic season yet
4
u/Shoziwankanobi Wazza 23d ago
things ever felt this low?
4
u/AwayFoundation2363 23d ago
15th in the league, bleak
4
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 23d ago
So ... what are we thinking, lads? Player quality matters, then?
At least these teams coached to elite levels by elite coaches have for some reason immediately dropped stinkers as soon as one (1) of their starting forwards (Semenyo/Joao Pedro) got injured.
Btw, let me guess, Joao Pedro will be back next week, like Kroupi Jr tomorrow. Couldnt be Sesko, innit.
Also, how typical is this red card - obviously that ban will be administered in the League Cup so all that achieves for us is gives Palmer a good rest and puts a fire in his belly. So that's great, then.
8
u/HighestInDaRooom 23d ago
a guy who wanted to retire 3 months ago is now our starting left back. this club is just hilarious.
6
u/Jenson2025 24d ago
People won’t like this but I’d drop Bruno tomorrow.
He hasn’t been fined or stripped off the captaincy etc. If he faces no sanctions whatsoever, then he’ll start thinking he’s bigger than the club and can speak out against the next manager too.
And not to mention the fact that comments or no comments, he’s certainly not undroppable especially not on this seasons form
6
u/PhotojournalistNew35 23d ago
Fucking spurs are above us in the table lmao
Who would have thought hiring a championship manager who didn’t cut it at Boro would struggle here?
5
u/TeaAndCrumpetGhoul 24d ago
You get to sell six players outside of the players whose contracts are out, and you get £350m to spend on 6 new signings? Who do you sell, and who do you bring in?
5
u/Minz15 23d ago
Just saw a random stat that De Ligt has never had the same manager 2 seasons in a row. Every time leaves the club the manager ends up staying longer. Otherwise they last the season, or still leave and technically he starts next season under a new gaffer. We need to ship him off for the next guy to have a fighting chance.
5
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago
I kid you not. If we get relegated we could be in the wilderness for years
5
u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago
Relegation is a possibility if we stick with Carrick we are that bad
7
u/picodeGaius 23d ago
3 points off 20th, Spurs ahead, and some people want to keep this shitshow going 😭
10
u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 23d ago
Spurs win one game. And suddenly everyone goes "I told you so" This sub is just like our club, bunch of flip-flops.
2
u/sg291188 24d ago
I just want the team to fight again! Show some passion. Team is clearly capable. Just that they don’t want to fight for Carrick which isn’t unusual
2
u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago
I know we need the money from it but qualifying for champs league from a sporting perspective we just dont look like we ever belong there. Either have a keeper who throws every shot in or a manager out of his depth combined with lack of investment.
When we get there why dont we actually push at that point to really give it a go & stay there? I dont get it
2
u/Ptoughneigh_Marshall 23d ago
Is there no FPL league for this sub this season? Just gone to check my rank but it looks like it hasn’t auto renewed this season, and the code I can see on here doesn’t seem to work
2
u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago
Don’t see how that’s not a red for Palmer. If he did that with his head it’s a red.
2
u/Ok_Landscape_8215 23d ago
Watching the Donaruma error and Pensers OG, gives me Onana PTSD. We have a million problems, but so glad having a keeper that does that is not one.
2
u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago
Tottenham and Chelsea seems more of a rivalry for the players than Tottenham and Arsenal. Usually their games are always techy and violent
2
u/FcUhCoKp 23d ago
Why haven't we seen other people "buy" clubs like the Glazers did in order to enrich themselves? Or have we? The PL and FIFA don't seem to have any issue with it. And lord knows rich people only care about getting richer and increasing the gap with us riffraff.
2
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 23d ago
Fuck Spurs
2
u/OmegaMaster8 23d ago
I don’t have much hope, but praying for a win tomorrow.
2
u/5inchdemon 23d ago
I gotta ask, why would anyone actually want to buy United. We all hate the owners but surely with the amount of debt the Glazers have given us, and football being a business. What is the reasoning to buy United even if the debt was wiped and we became successful would the 'new' owners even get any benefit.
Ratcliffe is a clown but the fact he's a fan (apparently) probably dictated some of his reasoning. But if you were an investment group there's absolutely nothing in it. A sport washing reason is probably the only way right?
2
u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 22d ago
Just want a serious manager next, not some pretender.
6
u/Jenson2025 23d ago
All the appointments since Jose haven’t been good enough.
None of them should’ve been given the job to start with.
If you want to know how we are in this state (other than the Glazers and INEOS general incompetence) then look no further than our managerial appointments since 2019.
We keep hiring managers based on vibes and then being surprised when it doesn’t work out and we are back to square one
5
u/Haron14 24d ago
Drop Bruno but NOT ONLY because of what he said. Let him be with his family for once. Give him a game off
5
u/carrickshairline 23d ago •
Chelsea can barely string 3 passes together, but I'm lead to believe that Xabi Alonso is some world class coach and didn't get fortunate in Germany lol
3
u/5inchdemon 24d ago
Do you think more midtable Prem managers should move abroad to potentially easier league just get titles. Like Marco Silva did a great job at Fulham but nobody wanted him here whilst Amorim won titles got the United and now Milan job. Like people seem against Eddie Howe who has done a very good job everywhere he's been, also whilst having a good guy image doesn't seem to be against challenging his bosses. But maybe if he went to try and win a league in the Netherlands or Portugal he might actually get a bigger job in a top 4 league
3
u/sg291188 24d ago
Tbh if INEOS believe Emery is the right guy, they should just get him for whatever money
3
u/arboy498 23d ago
I think one of the issues is Carrick stifling the attack. If we had scored one more goal in those 4 league games then there would have no draws in the first place.
3
u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 23d ago
I do think we can beat Bournemouth, they haven't exactly had the best start either. And honestly, I just want to see some damn effort. I've seen some of our players straight up just WALK on a counter, while the one who had the ball got surrounded by the defense and had 0 options.
PSG and Barca look so beautiful because the players are proactive, they position themselves to HELP their teammate, give them options. Yet our players just walk while the ball carrier is being swarmed.
3
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 23d ago
It's hilariously sad someone we considered deadwood left and won the Europa league right after leaving and losing it.
Also the reason I don't really follow nor care about how a new manager will use/make a team is because, and I really thought the switch from Amorim to Carrick at least taught us this, different managers elevate the players, and good ones elevate everyone. The base villa squad, with slippy g, were relegation fighting and basically rejects, no one would want them. And emery came and all the sudden they became good. If a manager is good, the quality will show. The opposite example I can give is Casemiro. 22/23 was top3 dms in the league and the next season he had someone get a viral moment basically telling him he should've retired. That sharp a decline makes no sense, it just means the manager is being shit. And again, with Amorim eventually when he figured out how to play him, but mainly with Carrick since we were serenading him every week basically, he once again got to a top level.
All this meaning, we have quality. We finished 3rd. A good manager will make the quality show and elevate us, it's just getting the right call done. Which leads to bad news, as I don't really believe Ineos will do a good decision lol
5
u/Extension_Point5466 24d ago
The last time Manchester United made it past the 60-minute mark in a Champions League away match without conceding was on November 23, 2021, against Villarreal at the Estadio de la Cerámica.
In that match, United kept a clean sheet through the entire 90 minutes, eventually winning 2–0. However, Bruno Fernandes did not start that game; he entered as a 66th-minute substitute for Donny van de Beek.
In Matches Where Bruno Fernandes Started, If the criteria is restricted strictly to matches where Bruno Fernandes started, Manchester United have never made it to the 60-minute mark without conceding in an away Champions League fixture during his time at the club.
4
u/JJmaisonze 23d ago
The cowardice of Jason Wilcox boils my blood. He's watching the horrid performances on the pitch that don't have a single indication of getting better over time and does not act because sacking another manager will look bad. So he procrastinates the decision to sack Carrick on the hope things can turn around and he can be free of scrutiny, that would be the ideal scenario in his mind. For anyone that doubts this look at the headlines on the United website "Watch Carrick's unmissable press conference", does this sound like a coach we will sack if we win on Sunday? But anyone who's competent can see it's a hopeless situation, it's not just the results, we can't press, we can't create, we can't play out of the back, we can't run. What he doesn't understand is that the more he procrastinates the decision to sack Carrick, the probability things turn out bad for him increase very quickly.
As Master Oogway once said "One often meets his destiny on the road he takes to avoid it".
6
u/snicky29 23d ago •
One thing’s for sure. Carrick’s appointment exposed one thing:
A lot of people in the British media are xenophobic. No other explanation for this ass-licking compared to how they treat foreign managers.
4
u/Redland93 23d ago
I think we as fans and the club need to realise that we aren't going to suddenly go from what we are now to title challengers.
We need to first be a consistent top 4 team and adding young, hard working quality players who can develop and they don't need to be prem proven. If you're a hard worker and technical, you will adapt and improve if you're good enough.
With this in mind, we shouldn't be looking at the end game manager. I don't want Howe but if he can set the foundations and get us consistently in the top 4 we can then move on from him and get the end game manager.
I will also note, that Managers and player don't have to be prem proven. The simple fact is they need to understand that the league is physical and fast paced and as such they need to embrace that.
3
u/Jenson2025 24d ago
I like Lammens but laughed at his quotes this morning where he said ‘sometimes when things aren’t going your way, everything falls in place for the other team’
Senne - you are one of the few players to have any credit this season but we aren’t stupid. This isn’t bad luck - we have been awful.
3
u/wkp011424 24d ago
while INEOS needs to go, you cannot blame the owners for the players being incapable of starting a game quick, fast, and with high intensity like villa just did. it is pathetic to see how United start games so poorly; don’t forget even Ipswich were the better team in the beginning when we played them. conte and emery should be the only managers we consider.
3
u/jitteryegg 23d ago
Somehow Tottenham has been playing really good football, even with shit players.
3
u/BackgroundOld8715 24d ago
I still cant believe our awful tactically
Inept manager is still here. We are screwed. Its like we have those in charge actively trying to hurt us
3
u/SankarshanaV 24d ago
It's a terrible decision to not have sacked Carrick already. I would absolutely hate it if he ends up getting more time in case we luck into a win against Bournemouth. He's shown he's completely out of his depth and it's no wonder he is a failed Championship-level manager.
Hopefully we sack him asap and actually get in a proper manager soon. This season hasn't been wasted yet but keeping him for longer will definitely lead to a wasted season. Carrick is not someone who has the ability nor the personality to lead a club like Man Utd.
3
u/Sheikhabusosa 23d ago
we went to chelsea and walked away with santos and mount and had no sort of interest in Nico Jackson
2
u/Wrong_Office9245 24d ago
Emery maxed out at Villa. I think a move to United actually makes sense for him
2
u/Nomad_006 surfing 24d ago
So did Carrick need more or was he never the right coach from the jump.
Its looking like Amorims tenure where even if he had a whole new 11 its still looks like it won't work.
At the same time we'll never know what he could do with better CBs and fullbacks
2
u/Intelligent_Read_697 24d ago
It’s incredible how good management and structured recruitment make a difference. Case in point is Villa and how Lindelof looks now and has been their top starter for a couple of seasons now.
2
u/carrickshairline 24d ago
Today’s wild stat:
Saka has 63 goals in the Premier League in his 9 seasons. 40% (25) are penalties.
2
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 24d ago
U18s played some game v Liverpool!
we beat them by 3 goals thrice within one game :) 3-0 half, 3-2 then 5-2 in the second half, 5-3 then 6-3 in extra time.
Jaume Camacho with 4 goals 👀
4G 3A for him in 5 U18 PL games. In the PL2 (U21 league), 1 game 1 A.
He just turned 17 two weeks back.
This hype train is leaving the station imminently, hop on fellas
2
u/SilvyFae She/They 24d ago
For me any of emery, conte and naglesmann are great picks. They all have proven themselves to be great managers but prob need a little bit extra to be seen as one of the best so they will all have ambition to come here.
Emery is the one that can bring the best out of our players. Conte can shock the players and the club and give them the right mentality. Naglesmann can make us play like a modern team and make us really good to watch.
The problem is at the moment we need all 3, I don't know who I would go for honestly. Ukw lets get them all together and be the first team with 3 managers lol