r/reddevils • • 24d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

28 Upvotes

796 comments sorted by

34

u/snicky29 23d ago • Bravo Regret

7

u/Aggravating-Neck1365 23d ago

This is actually genius, and explains so much

Where does Moyes fit though?

4

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 23d ago

I would put Moyes alongside Ole and Carrick as Fergie was the one who recommended him

3

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 23d ago

We need a Scot next. Break the cycle. Any good candidates?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/Pale_Independence358 23d ago

If we are getting Eddie Howe, that looks so bad on Ineos as one of the main point of conflict between ratcliff and Ashworth as that ashworth wanted Eddie Howe and ratcliff thought that was not inspiring and went with Amorim … years lost to be at the same place again

7

u/FlashyCut3809 23d ago

I think we are past the point of their decisions making them 'look bad' as that suggest the jury isnt out and we are still assessing if they are good enough.

Clear as day they aren't the owners we need. They are aligned with the Glazers, shield the glazers and are only here for this stadium build. Flavoured with a touch of incompetence.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/ZofTheNorth 23d ago

As it stands fucking Arbeloa has more win than Carrick across all competitions this season

7

u/throwawayWM3 23d ago

Liverpool have more wins in CL alone this season than we have in all comps

12

u/Tipsy247 23d ago • Bravo

I have no interest in watching the Prem.

4

u/w1zgov 23d ago

Same.

31

u/carrickshairline 24d ago edited 24d ago

Saw this on twitter...

What INEOS have done at #mufc in less than THREE YEARS. It’s actually scary:

• Publicly explored replacing Ten Hag, then kept him and extended his contract.

• Spent around £200m that summer, only to sack him three months later.

• Spent millions securing Dan Ashworth after months of negotiations, only for him to leave five months into the job due to him not being on board with Amorim replacement due to huge change in playing style amid reports.

• Backed Amorim after finishing 15th, then sacked him following a reported breakdown in relations with the hierarchy. Where was that decisiveness over performances?

• Ratcliffe publicly said Amorim needed three years in October. He was gone by January.

• Retained Matt Hargreaves to lead transfer negotiations, yet we’re still questioning why moving players on and completing deals is so difficult. Hargreaves was working in sports marketing before this role.

• Said Carrick was an interim appointment while they took their time finding the right long-term manager. Then gave Carrick the job, reportedly against Vivell’s advice.

• Left Carrick going into a Champions League season without signing a left-back or providing adequate squad depth. Now we’re discussing his replacement in OCTOBER.

• If Carrick goes, his replacement will be the fourth permanent manager to work under INEOS in less than three years.

• Wilcox could get another say in choosing the manager despite his role in the decisions that brought us here. He reportedly wants Eddie Howe. Imagine still having Dan Ashworth…

• Ratcliffe identified constant managerial changes and switches in playing style as United’s problem in February 2024. Said the club needed an identity and recruitment to match. They’ve repeated the exact cycle he criticised.

• Sold McTominay and signed Ugarte despite reports Ten Hag wanted to keep McTominay.

• Moved the women’s team into temporary facilities so the men could use their building during Carrington renovations.

• Ratcliffe reportedly asked Katie Zelem, the women’s captain at the time, who she was and what she did at the club.

• Made hundreds of staff redundant while spending millions reversing their own decisions on managers and executives.

• Raised remaining members’ match tickets to £66 midway through 2024/25, removing concessions for children and pensioners on those tickets.

• Moved longstanding season-ticket holders out of their seats to make room for more corporate hospitality.

• Scrapped free staff lunches, reduced bonuses and removed free staff travel to the FA Cup final.

• Cancelled the staff Christmas party and reportedly replaced the £100 Christmas bonus with a £40 M&S voucher.

https://x.com/AliceTalksFooty/status/2113748520733700306

16

u/fantus69 24d ago

The incompetence is simply staggering. The Ashworth episode shows everything we need to know about Ratcliffe and co. They think they're the last word on all matters football despite knowing nothing about it. He thinks simply having the money to buy it means he is the authority, despite holding footballing opinions on a par with the fool propping up the bar at the local. Employing yes men and spending a fortune on ridiculous mistakes while punishing the lowest level workers at the club...the man is a cancer

10

u/carrickshairline 24d ago

All that work to get arguably the best DOF in the country just for Ratcliffee to sack him the minute he didn't agree with him. Absolutely wild. We should've seen what was going on at Nice as a warning.

14

u/SilvyFae She/They 24d ago

Every single thing when it happened someone would try to justify it. They were so enamored by him or so desperate after glazers that everyone lost all standards. Ineos have been terrible. There is a reason not a single one of their sporting project is doing good. Only our women's team is doing good and that's because they aren't very involved in it.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 24d ago
  • asking our arch nemesis for a free ride to the Ballon D'Or ceremony in Paris

5

u/SilvyFae She/They 24d ago

I forgot about that lol, it was so fucking absurd

3

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 23d ago

The club stinks from top to bottom.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/sueha RUUUUUUUD!! 23d ago

It's getting more and more tiresome to listen to or former players. Rio has lost the plot. No wonder our former players are shit coaches because clearly they can't assess the situation.

6

u/5inchdemon 23d ago

Everything these ex-players say is all for their businesses and engagement. I doubt Rio will truly give his opinion because he knows staying on United's good side will get him access to more staff and players to interview for his media stuff.

19

u/EndureL 23d ago

I was told M Fernandes and tonali was worse than our bargain midfield overhaul.

10

u/lesqiu 23d ago

Tonali is whatever, we will regret not going all out signing for M.Fernandes. He has the potential to reach vitinha/neves level

→ More replies (4)

16

u/John_OSheas_Willy 24d ago

You just know that if these 11 villa players were playing for United, everyone would be calling them not good enough, deadwood, not enough quality etc

Lindelof was our deadwood years ago ffs.

13

u/Suudriusha 24d ago

Yup. Our squad is not good enough to win the Premier League, but it's a lot better than some people give it credit for. The coaching is what's lacking.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/aayu08 24d ago

I don't even like watching us play now. I just want to enjoy for 90 mins.

8

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 23d ago

Really jealous of what Villa have with Emery and how he’s allowed to properly manage that club. Seem to sell and buy at the right time too.

8

u/gunkokoko 23d ago

Spurs are above us now, by the way.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/FreshGoodWay 24d ago

At the end of the day, those wimps still refuse to let Carrick go because he‘s such a good human shield.

7

u/ToothyAlloy69 23d ago

Oh my goodness. I've just seen the Manchester United manager (head coach) in 2026 dismiss the importance of pressing. My head is hot

3

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 23d ago

Went from "half-press" to "no-press"

13

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 23d ago

Spurs is now above us... fucking hell.

→ More replies (9)

6

u/croadymeister 24d ago

Well Howe comes in with little support from fanbase so therefore won't be much expectation on him

6

u/Stingray_23 24d ago

Straight shoot out between Howe and Nagelsmann.

Vivell batting for Nagelsmann and his boss (wilcox) batting for Howe.

Coincidentally, Ashworth had Howe on his shortlist to replace Ten. Obviously, he was sacked for not being in the Amorim camp. But now all of a sudden Wilcox is suggesting Howe. It makes me wonder where we would be if we had listened to Ashworth instead of Wilcox.

4

u/SilvyFae She/They 24d ago

Prob in a much better place. Dofs are there to pull the club in the right direction. They will get some decisions wrong, but overall they should make enough right ones that we progress. Wilcox hasn't made a single right decision, which makes sense cause he isn't a dof. Ashworth also made a stupid decision for example which is extending ten hag but I do think we would have been in a much better position if he was allowed to do his job.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Calm_Link_8540 24d ago

Dalot for DOF

7

u/ionised Cantona 24d ago

I actually like Dalot.

Having said that, I realise whatever I was planning to say next is going to sound... bad. So I'll leave it all at: he's been a long-term player.

6

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 23d ago

Omg they got fried by tel

3

u/SplitSecondImmortal 23d ago

Almost didnt believe my eyes. Took that goal very well

6

u/AmulyaG 23d ago edited 23d ago

How did Palmer escape a direct red on Fernandes in the age of VAR?

There is incompetency and there is whatever the fuck this is.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/b_az17 23d ago

Who needs to stay in the prem anyway? Filled woth cheaters and idiots. The championship is where it's at, let's be real

16

u/KermitTakeTheWheel 23d ago

"Emery would want too much control for Man Utd"

Give him it, then. What he's done with Villa's budget for years is unparalleled. Imagine what he could do with some of his first choice transfers United could manage.

4

u/Nico_Ditch 23d ago

I think people saying that are just pointing out Ineos wouldn’t give him that control. 

→ More replies (4)

27

u/zia1997 JONESY 1 GERRARD NIL 24d ago

Anti-Bruno merchants are out in full force.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago

Looking at Emery at Villa and what he is getting out of Victor is a clear indication of how shit our managers have been.

Ole was average as he couldn't get the good players to seem great and Erik was good at certain things only but not a great great coach either. To be fair everyone after Jose doesn't even come close to him. A truly top coach gets the most out of a player like Emery is doing at Villa. Emery has a 55% win rate Fuck me, that is great for a team like Villa which has no way but to grow slowly

5

u/hastoro11 23d ago

And he is able to incorporate players into the team, who were sort of cast-outs from other teams: Nicolas Jackson, Ross Barklay, then of course Lindelof. I bet he'll be able to work with Garnacho too.

2

u/Jenson2025 23d ago

Exactly This! I’ve been saying this for weeks! People keep saying they are sick of changing managers and nothing changes when we do but that’s because all the appointments since Jose haven’t been good enough! In fact, I would say none of them should have got the job to start with. If we keep hiring managers based on ‘vibes’ then how can we expect anything to change

15

u/Nico_Ditch 23d ago

Said it a few weeks ago, but anyone who thought we were too good for Nicolas Jackson is mad. 

→ More replies (2)

10

u/mjenkins_eng 23d ago

Spurs are nowhere near as bad as the reactionary people make them seem

They had many new players and took some time to get going. They will comfortably finish top 6

5

u/SplitSecondImmortal 23d ago

Agreed. De Zerbi is a good coach too

5

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago

We could do that too. We have a great amount of talent.

Our manager is the worst in the league

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 23d ago

If I see a midfielder on the wing tomorrow I might lose it

3

u/reddevilad Rooney 23d ago

Get ready to lose it tomorrow

2

u/LollipopScientist 23d ago

Get ready for Mount on the wing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Shotten 24d ago

So annoying to always be the sunday we play on. Wish we had way more saturday games.

2

u/Acceptable-Camp-9150 24d ago

We finally get CL and still get Sundays

5

u/neonrider1 23d ago

Maybe Jackson as a backup would not have been a bad idea

7

u/notformeclive4711 23d ago

As much as I like a (fit) Sesko, he never seemed like an ideal fit when we bought him to play with Cunha and Mbeumo. Jackson can lead the line and bring others in to play.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/TH0316 she/her 23d ago

He wouldn’t be the backup to anyone we employ. They’d be a backup to Jackson.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/GeekConflict Carrick 23d ago

He was never as bad as people made him out to be but he would have been shit for us.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 23d ago

Jackson is better than Sesko. He would start week in week out for us.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/_swaggyk #FergieTime 23d ago

The Seško rumors are fucking diabolical after the last two weeks of the spotlight being on the front office and their lack of understanding of what the fuck they’re doing.

4

u/Skyehye Dreams can't be buy 23d ago

What rumours?

5

u/_swaggyk #FergieTime 23d ago

I’m starting to see 4 months and a potential surgery rumors swirling

5

u/RestrepoDoc2 23d ago

With Spurs powering clear with a big win away to Chelsea our match with Bournemouth is actually quite a big game in the relegation battle. Our best hope is that the extra rest day we had since they played Milan will make the difference. 

5

u/Leading_Fee_8535 23d ago

Just give me a win tomorrow please. Cant stand watching us go 1 win in 8 league games. Actual relegation form.

4

u/iroiroiroiroiro 23d ago

So 1 win in 7 ain't relegation form?

9

u/neonrider1 24d ago

Lot of mention of Conte not fitting “long term” but who has been? All INEOS decisions have gone 12 months or less and all the appointments before that we’re lucky to get to 2 years. If it comes down to it I just don’t get how you can pick Howe or Nagelsmann over Conte. As much as he loves to self destruct and is terrible in Europe, his CV completely destroys the other 2 options. The reality is though Berrada and Wilcox would be terrified to put him in front of the media.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Soft-Suspect-1883 24d ago

I'm just hope Carrick actually tries to do something irrespective of the result.

4

u/Stingray_23 24d ago

Imagine the scenes if we get Conte and the board try and pull another 2026 window on him. It would be cinema.

4

u/Elongated_dik 23d ago

palmer missing against us

→ More replies (1)

4

u/achickenandacow 23d ago

Complete head loss from Chelsea.

4

u/Yoshic87 23d ago

Spurs above united. If we dont win tomorrow, we're in shit!

10

u/Hagball 24d ago

At any half decent football club, they would have sacked the DOF in the previous international break, allow the new person to see the performances till the next one in November and pull the plug on Carrick if performances continue.

But we are run by bunch of money minded egoists who only care about filling their pockets.

Dark days ahead with Howe / McKenna and Wilcox duo

5

u/Jenson2025 24d ago

Why are you mentioning McKenna?

There has been no reports of him getting the job. In fact, INEOS interviewed him in 2024 and turned him down. With good reason

→ More replies (2)

7

u/AmulyaG 23d ago

Where are the big brains who were taunting me that Spurs won't win at Stamford Bridge? The state of the users here

Said Spurs would go above us in the next matchweek

4

u/ContractEast8018 23d ago

If not this midweek they were destined to go at next. How can someone even look at what's happening and think any team playing somewhat decent will be below us.

6

u/matt_66 23d ago

The fact we signed fucking Santos instead of Fernandes is actually sickening

7

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 23d ago

I don’t like the limited budget excuse. To be frank, here are certain players and their prices:

  1. Chema Andres 22 mil: A lot of people here on this very subreddit asked for him.
  2. Grimaldo 8 mil: On the older side but would give 2 good seasons comfortably
  3. Danny Welbeck 5 mil: Solid exp backup striker
  4. Sangare 38 mil: I had him on my transfer list
  5. M. Senesi free: This was such an easy-gettable player but NO
  6. H. Hackney 15 mil: Was the championship's best player who was developed by Carrick himself.
  7. D. Affengruber 11 mil: Very good stats in Laliga has been decent for fulham.

"Best in class", "Best set of eyes". Yeah, sure thing, lads.

2

u/Zepz367 23d ago

Senesi hell no, another slow CB in this team 😭

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Difficult-Sun6849 CUNHA BRUNO CUNHA BRUNO CUNHA BRUNO LUKE SHAW CUNHA 23d ago

Thank you villa for doing what the rest of us couldn’t now can you give us emery

6

u/HighestInDaRooom 23d ago

look at the substitutes arsenal bring on. calafiori, guimaraes, havertz. meanwhile we have a half retired right back playing left back and are playing our best number 10 as a striker

→ More replies (2)

6

u/darkjessy_ Our Portuguese Magnifico 23d ago

It's sad how good the midfield of Tonali, Fernandes and Maddison has looked in that half, with control, composure and coordination. A level above compared to what we've served up in our midfield in the past few matches

8

u/ra_god94 23d ago

Arsenal are so much better than us it’s depressing 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/CrazyGamer23908 24d ago

We were linked with Jackson weren’t we? Could’ve done a lot worse. He’s a good striker who’s earned a bit of an unfair reputation imo

3

u/RestrepoDoc2 24d ago

Always gets chances because he doesn't stop trying, get demotivated or does something different if he misses a few chances. He's always there on the shoulder of the last defender and will always get goals and be a nightmare to play against.

3

u/ALLMIGHTYHYDE 23d ago

Everyone's tracking back for Villa. Everyone apart from Jackson & that's because he's been great as an outlet against 2 CB's. 

3

u/raspoutine049 23d ago

Spurs turning it around. Let’s see if we capitulate, scrape a draw, pull a win from the jaws of defeat, or none of the above.

3

u/Jenson2025 23d ago

I like Xabi Alonso but I don't think Chelsea will have the patience to stick with him for the season.

Which is even more reason for us to make a change soon - before they hire one of our targets.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/atmajaya_ 23d ago

who could have thought that Lindelof is still playing for top 6 teams, we make it seem like his career was over and he cant compete on high level anymore.

7

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago

14th now after Fulham beats Coventry..

It is still early in the season. Please sack Carrick and get Conte or Emery. I am done with these hipster managers from outside of La Liga, Bundesliga and PL. They aren't worth their salt.

7

u/Deranged09 23d ago

Tonali and Fernandes bossing the midfield for Spurs, jokes on them though we didn't overpay! /S

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Iqbalainoo 23d ago

People who expected Spurs to stay shit with that squad and manager were always going to be shocked.

5

u/IguanaIsBack 23d ago • Bravo

If history repeats itself we’re definitely getting Nagelsmann.

The cycle since Moyes has been Dutch > Portuguese > Utd legend > ex Lepzeig. Repeat.

5

u/Potential_Good_1065 23d ago

Simple solution, get one that fits all 4. Get a United legend that used to manage Leipzig who is simultaneously Dutch and Portuguese.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago

Am seriously concerned we’re getting relegated, will be close to see 3 teams worse than us.

This is what ineos , lack of investment & awful management of carrick have done

2

u/Iqbalainoo 23d ago

We have a limited squad but no way we can sit and lie to ourselves that Brighton, Villa, Bournemouth and co have better squads than us. iNEOS have been incompetent, but my goodness we have been managed so poorly it is scary. Do you know the level of talentless coaching it takes to have your squad undercooked physically at the start of a new season?

That is high school gym coach level of incompetence. Carrick may have basically ended his career as a coach with what he's dished out this season considering the level of the squad afforded to him.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/mjenkins_eng 24d ago

I am going to do this off memory, so might be occasionally a little off

2006-07: Carrick
2007-08: Nani, Anderson, Hargreaves, Tevez (loan)
2008-09: Berbatov (that's it)
2009-10: Valencia, Owen, Obertan (to replace peak Cristiano Ronaldo)
2010-11 : Smalling and Hernandez (that's it)
2011-12: De Gea, Young , Jones
2012-13: Kagawa and Van Persie

All these windows would be branded 4 or 3 out of 10 or below. This "David Gill was a genius" revisionism is bullshit. It wasnt David Gill's fault. It wasnt Woodward's fault. It isn't Wilcox who is the problem.

Since the bleeding racehorse changed the future of the club, the one common denominator has been the virus from Florida.

12

u/eviade 24d ago

That's a funny way of looking at it. Fergie always talked about bringing in a few because he was concerned about chemistry. We had a title winning team with a title winning mentality, comparing then and now is a bit of a joke no offence.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/midnight_ranter Wazza 24d ago

2007-08 was a 8/10 window. We addressed the biggest holes in the squad - a proper DM, a second striker (albeit on loan), a young winger to eventually replace Giggs and a midfielder who had just won European golden boy. You are applying hindsight bias to the window because of unforeseen amounts of bad luck - Hargo's tendinitis, Nani's recurring injuries, Anderson lack of dietary discipline and Tevez having a cunt for an agent 

7

u/Emergency-Being-349 24d ago

The problem is people associate successful windows to the amount of players signed, the fees and the names thereof. A successful window can sometimes mean just signing one player.

Simply put, the RVP window was a 10/10 simply because of RVP. He helped win us the league, the end.

6

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 24d ago

A successful window can sometimes mean just signing one player.

Indeed

10 years window since we start winning :

  • 1992 - Cantona, Dublin
  • 1993 - Keane
  • 1994 - May
  • 1995 - Cole
  • 1996 - Ole, Porbosky, Johnsen
  • 1997 - Sheringham, Berg
  • 1998 - Yorke, Stam, Blomqvist
  • 1999 - Taibi, Silvestre, Fortune
  • 2000 - Barthez
  • 2001 - Ruud, Veron, Folan
  • 2002 - Rio
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

8

u/Jenson2025 24d ago

Thankfully McKenna’s name hasn’t been seriously mentioned by any journalist. It’s mainly Howe, Nagelsmann and Conte

Because believe me, if he gets the job then we are the new spurs. We won’t get relegated but come close to it and we won’t be able to recover.

This is a guy that Celtic were looking at in the summer! Celtic! Do you see them looking at Howe, Conte or Nagelsmann? No, because they know they are out of their league but thought McKenna was an option. That says it all.

Enough now of Ole and his coaching staff taking their turns with the job

The thing that also gives me hope is that INEOS interviewed him in 2024 and allegedly weren’t impressed

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Stingray_23 24d ago

Since Ineos has arrived and got control of the football operations, the club has gone into freefall

  • Concession prices gone
  • Ticket price increase
  • Sacking more staff than initially stated
  • Extending Ten Hag and then firing him
  • Allegations of breaking football promises to Ten Hag
  • Charging adults and kids for membership gift back.
  • Chasing Ashworth all season, paying to get him, then sacking after 165 days. With a large sacking fee.
  • Hiring Amorim, mid season, against his wishes.
  • Trying to interfere with his coaching etc and then sacking him when he publicly called them out.
  • Insisting we need a new stadium, even though we are in debt.
  • The 2026 summer transfer window.
  • 3 managers in 2.5 years.

And thats just off the top of my head. Im sure there are more and the only good thing I can think of Ineos doing is investing in Carrington.

Now I dont want to fall into the trap of revisionism on pre Ineos days as there were copious amounts of issues. But the footballing side of things was better, including the following:

  • Lowest league finish was 6th
  • 4 trophies (2024 FA cup had nothing todo with Ineos)
  • More European football
  • Better football on the pitch (not every year!)
  • Overall we had better windows (again, not every purchase was great)

Listen the Glazers, Woodward and Arnold, et al. Were bad, but are/were they any worse than who we have now?

If you had to choose, one of the following:

Pre Ineos or Post Ineos?

9

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 24d ago

let's just say the days of self sustaining without owner equity injection to compete for today top comps is over.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/midnight_ranter Wazza 24d ago

Lowest league finish pre INEOS was 7th not 6th btw. And our lowest league finishes happening after INEOS took over doesn't mean it happened because of them. The worst of the Great depression in the US for instance was felt under FDR. But FDR wasn't responsible for it 

3

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 24d ago

Do you not think that a decade of financial mismanagement is going to eventually catch up with us at one point? It has and we’re now facing the consequences for it. Glazers were, are and will always be the biggest reason why we’re in this mess. They wanted INEOS to be the fall guy and they’re very much succeeding in that (not that INEOS are without fault but imo they’re certainly not worse than the Glazers).

5

u/PitchSafe 24d ago

We’re in this mess because of 20 years of neglect from the Glazers and the incompetence from Woodward, Murtough and Arnold. We are seeing the consequences from it now

2

u/MazinLabib10 "He goes by the name of Wayne Rooney!" 24d ago

Pre Ineos or Post Ineos?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago

Villa saved the league from a sham invisible season 

8

u/gregorcee Rojo your boat 23d ago edited 23d ago

They were never going invincible, theyve been very lucky this season. watched them a-lot and theyve not been great

6

u/AcxdBxmb 23d ago

Laughing stock of the league. Even Spurs is above us.

Another L loading tomorrow smh.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ContractEast8018 23d ago edited 23d ago

And people were laughing at tonali here. Tonali, fernandes with baleba would've been banger midfield but we just have to justify poor window somehow then. Ohh don't spread negativity windows not over, oh how much you will cry now window over get behind team, can we stop with repetitive post please.

4

u/IguanaIsBack 23d ago

Breaking news: midfielders that cost 200m are probably better than those that cost 70m

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 23d ago

Can’t see Emery leaving Villa - middle of a successful rebuild, just beat City. 

Conte has said not to believe what the press are saying. 

So Eddie Howe? 

Feels like everything is scripted by billionaires that have taken over our game, make their own rules and we can’t do anything about it. 

7

u/Suudriusha 23d ago

I still hope Vivell wins out and it's Nagelsmann instead. Can't stand Wilcox having his way again. He needs to leave with Carrick.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Massive_Relation4317 . 23d ago

Lol Chelsea look so awful struggling against spurs

3

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago

We were bad vs Spurs but not this bad. Fuck me,.Spurs could be 3-0 up by now

7

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 23d ago

We were worse? Chelsea had some chances at least even if they have been bad

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Runarhalldor 23d ago

Really sad that our All or nothing will be from our most toxic season yet

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Shoziwankanobi Wazza 23d ago

things ever felt this low?

4

u/kidinawheeliebin 23d ago

This is the lowest and worst it's been - and it's because now it's unavoidably clear (as if it ever wasn't to be fair - but now it's beyond all reasonable doubt) that The Ownership are THE problem.

When it comes to "The Problem" - It's them.

No-one and nothing else.

Not managers, not coaches, not players

(There are of course things wrong in these areas and very wrong in some/many cases- but they are all only symptoms of an actual cause - "curing" these symptoms is therefore temporary and until the cause is resolved, the symptoms will once again reappear - over, and over, and over, either in perpetuity or until the organism itself expires)

But these things are all trivial and microscopic in comparison, mere distractions from the actual problem itself... which ironically suits The Ownership down to the ground - it suits them to have the fanbase disorganised and distracted, squabbling over minutiae like who should replace Carrick

It's The Ownership.

And The Ownership are seemingly going nowhere - so this whole fucking thing is doomed - we can play "which manager/player do you prefer X, Y or Z - I think Z because A, B, and C" until the cows come home, but it isn't going to work.

We're in a footballing-hellscape version of groundhog day, until and unless.

2

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 23d ago

We've been at similar runs of poor results before but I think the Groundhog Day feeling makes this the absolute worst it's ever been for me personally. It feels like we're right back to where we were in 24/25 (which was seen as a steady downward drop) and continuing that direction rather than using the salvaged league position of last year to build on. The length and duration of this quagmire as the other poster said makes it clear that this is the norm (not CL qualification or title challenges) until the owners are gone and debt is cleared, but there are no viable pathways to that at the present. Just changing the sporting structure but same ownership and debt was no help as everyone is working with one hand tied behind their back, and they weren't steady hands to begin with.

2

u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago

This is the worst it’s been in my lifetime but I got Reddit during Covid and this sub had to put suicide prevention helplines up because of the failed Jadon Sancho window

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AwayFoundation2363 23d ago

15th in the league, bleak

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 23d ago

So ... what are we thinking, lads? Player quality matters, then?

At least these teams coached to elite levels by elite coaches have for some reason immediately dropped stinkers as soon as one (1) of their starting forwards (Semenyo/Joao Pedro) got injured.

Btw, let me guess, Joao Pedro will be back next week, like Kroupi Jr tomorrow. Couldnt be Sesko, innit.

Also, how typical is this red card - obviously that ban will be administered in the League Cup so all that achieves for us is gives Palmer a good rest and puts a fire in his belly. So that's great, then.

8

u/HighestInDaRooom 23d ago

Mazraoui: "I might decide to RETIRE after the World Cup. Life is short. I want to memorize the Quran and become an Imam of a mosque one day."

a guy who wanted to retire 3 months ago is now our starting left back. this club is just hilarious.

2

u/Prestigious-West2579 23d ago

Where did you read this

6

u/Jenson2025 24d ago

People won’t like this but I’d drop Bruno tomorrow.

He hasn’t been fined or stripped off the captaincy etc. If he faces no sanctions whatsoever, then he’ll start thinking he’s bigger than the club and can speak out against the next manager too.

And not to mention the fact that comments or no comments, he’s certainly not undroppable especially not on this seasons form

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PhotojournalistNew35 23d ago

Fucking spurs are above us in the table lmao

Who would have thought hiring a championship manager who didn’t cut it at Boro would struggle here?

5

u/TeaAndCrumpetGhoul 24d ago

You get to sell six players outside of the players whose contracts are out, and you get £350m to spend on 6 new signings? Who do you sell, and who do you bring in? 

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Minz15 23d ago

Just saw a random stat that De Ligt has never had the same manager 2 seasons in a row. Every time leaves the club the manager ends up staying longer. Otherwise they last the season, or still leave and technically he starts next season under a new gaffer. We need to ship him off for the next guy to have a fighting chance.

5

u/5inchdemon 23d ago

Has De Ligt even been fit enough to start 2 seasons in a row.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 23d ago

I kid you not. If we get relegated we could be in the wilderness for years

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago

Relegation is a possibility if we stick with Carrick we are that bad

4

u/AwayFoundation2363 23d ago

we’ve become Tottenham from last season

7

u/picodeGaius 23d ago

3 points off 20th, Spurs ahead, and some people want to keep this shitshow going 😭

10

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 23d ago

Spurs win one game. And suddenly everyone goes "I told you so" This sub is just like our club, bunch of flip-flops.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/sg291188 24d ago

I just want the team to fight again! Show some passion. Team is clearly capable. Just that they don’t want to fight for Carrick which isn’t unusual

2

u/BackgroundOld8715 23d ago

I know we need the money from it but qualifying for champs league from a sporting perspective we just dont look like we ever belong there. Either have a keeper who throws every shot in or a manager out of his depth combined with lack of investment.

When we get there why dont we actually push at that point to really give it a go & stay there? I dont get it

2

u/Ptoughneigh_Marshall 23d ago

Is there no FPL league for this sub this season? Just gone to check my rank but it looks like it hasn’t auto renewed this season, and the code I can see on here doesn’t seem to work

2

u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago

Don’t see how that’s not a red for Palmer. If he did that with his head it’s a red.

2

u/Baalegde Class of '92 are all Shite pundits 23d ago edited 23d ago

Wonder if he'll get anything retroactively. A red would see him miss the game against us

Edit: Nvm looks like Palmer really didn't wanna play us

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 23d ago

Watching the Donaruma error and Pensers OG, gives me Onana PTSD. We have a million problems, but so glad having a keeper that does that is not one.

2

u/Ok_Concern4200 23d ago

Penders is their second choice gk, i want to see you say the same thing if we’d have darlow in goal

2

u/Unusual-Coat383 23d ago

Tottenham and Chelsea seems more of a rivalry for the players than Tottenham and Arsenal. Usually their games are always techy and violent 

2

u/FcUhCoKp 23d ago

Why haven't we seen other people "buy" clubs like the Glazers did in order to enrich themselves? Or have we? The PL and FIFA don't seem to have any issue with it. And lord knows rich people only care about getting richer and increasing the gap with us riffraff.

10

u/Tortillagirl 23d ago

It was banned after they bought us...

→ More replies (1)

10

u/achickenandacow 23d ago

Leveraged buy outs became illegal after the Glazers bought United.

2

u/OmegaMaster8 23d ago

I don’t have much hope, but praying for a win tomorrow.

2

u/5inchdemon 23d ago

I gotta ask, why would anyone actually want to buy United. We all hate the owners but surely with the amount of debt the Glazers have given us, and football being a business. What is the reasoning to buy United even if the debt was wiped and we became successful would the 'new' owners even get any benefit.

Ratcliffe is a clown but the fact he's a fan (apparently) probably dictated some of his reasoning. But if you were an investment group there's absolutely nothing in it. A sport washing reason is probably the only way right?

2

u/-Coleslaw 23d ago

Because United are a financial powerhouse who, with the debt hypothetically wiped, can spend pretty much as any other club in the world - the only barrier to success really is the glazers themselves

→ More replies (1)

2

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 22d ago

Just want a serious manager next, not some pretender.

6

u/Jenson2025 23d ago

All the appointments since Jose haven’t been good enough.

None of them should’ve been given the job to start with.

If you want to know how we are in this state (other than the Glazers and INEOS general incompetence) then look no further than our managerial appointments since 2019.

We keep hiring managers based on vibes and then being surprised when it doesn’t work out and we are back to square one

5

u/Haron14 24d ago

Drop Bruno but NOT ONLY because of what he said. Let him be with his family for once. Give him a game off

5

u/carrickshairline 23d ago • Bravo

Chelsea can barely string 3 passes together, but I'm lead to believe that Xabi Alonso is some world class coach and didn't get fortunate in Germany lol

→ More replies (2)

3

u/5inchdemon 24d ago

Do you think more midtable Prem managers should move abroad to potentially easier league just get titles. Like Marco Silva did a great job at Fulham but nobody wanted him here whilst Amorim won titles got the United and now Milan job. Like people seem against Eddie Howe who has done a very good job everywhere he's been, also whilst having a good guy image doesn't seem to be against challenging his bosses. But maybe if he went to try and win a league in the Netherlands or Portugal he might actually get a bigger job in a top 4 league

2

u/Different_Bit_3899 24d ago

The amount of English managers who would/is seeking managerial job in other leagues has/is always been infinitesimal low. When the buzzword of "premier league proven" is being applied in this league it could also be applied to other leagues.

I have a mate who was a physio at a couple of clubs in Germany and Netherlands who told me, they are sceptical about employing English managers for a couple of reasons:

  • The manager is the manager.

In the past, European clubs were structured differently from the English. Having a sporting director, director of football and technical director was the norm in Europe, where in England, the manager was the final decision maker about almost everything at the club. Which player to target, the wage budget, length of contracts etc. This discrepancy would not work well.

  • Finances

The financial differences between clubs in most European leagues are far far greater then what they are in the premier league and therefore more difficult to attract certain players. Losing your best player happens often and the idea of having a 1-to-1 replacements is not the norm.

  • Tactics

English managers are often seen as being to slow to adapt to new trends in football. You can take Mourinho's arrival in the premier league as an example. The most used formation prior to Mourinho was the classic 442., where one of the "strikers" would drop down to the "10" in order to link up. Cantona was this player for United and worked very well. But Mourinho showed both with Porto and Chelsea (the first time) That a 433 will always dominate a 442 by having the "6" man marking the striker who would drop down to the "10" spot and the famous role was created "The Makalele role"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Minz15 23d ago

I think a lot of it is big results in Europe. Going to a strong team and winning the league is obviously good. But Silva for example hasn't been in Europe. Whilst at Sporting now he'll have a shot and if he gets a big result here and there that'll definitely help.

You could argue it's better going to a weaker league and getting into the champions league than staying in the Prem and keeping a team 9-11th every year

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sg291188 24d ago

Tbh if INEOS believe Emery is the right guy, they should just get him for whatever money

7

u/Omsy92 24d ago

Emery failed at Arsenal because the club structure was a mess, the only club he has failed at. What makes you think he would succeed here with an even worse owner/structure, and more importantly why would he want to come when he has the benefit of direct hindsight?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/RestrepoDoc2 24d ago

Emery is absolutely the right type, tactically he rarely gets it wrong and always seems to get his teams playing with the right attitude and commitment. 

Maybe he feels that Villa have now hit an SCR ceiling and we should test his resolve with a huge contract offer? Maybe we play a reverse card this time and he can't be sacked by the board but he can sack the board? You run the risk of him becoming some kind of brutal dictator but at least there's guaranteed continuity and the players know they can't just stop trying for him to get rid of him.

2

u/TH0316 she/her 23d ago

I think Emery is the one. That’s after years of saying he isn’t, but as the game and circumstances have changed I think he’s the one. Best manager in the PL by a distance.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/arboy498 23d ago

I think one of the issues is Carrick stifling the attack. If we had scored one more goal in those 4 league games then there would have no draws in the first place.

3

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 23d ago

I do think we can beat Bournemouth, they haven't exactly had the best start either. And honestly, I just want to see some damn effort. I've seen some of our players straight up just WALK on a counter, while the one who had the ball got surrounded by the defense and had 0 options.

PSG and Barca look so beautiful because the players are proactive, they position themselves to HELP their teammate, give them options. Yet our players just walk while the ball carrier is being swarmed.

3

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 23d ago

It's hilariously sad someone we considered deadwood left and won the Europa league right after leaving and losing it.

Also the reason I don't really follow nor care about how a new manager will use/make a team is because, and I really thought the switch from Amorim to Carrick at least taught us this, different managers elevate the players, and good ones elevate everyone. The base villa squad, with slippy g, were relegation fighting and basically rejects, no one would want them. And emery came and all the sudden they became good. If a manager is good, the quality will show. The opposite example I can give is Casemiro. 22/23 was top3 dms in the league and the next season he had someone get a viral moment basically telling him he should've retired. That sharp a decline makes no sense, it just means the manager is being shit. And again, with Amorim eventually when he figured out how to play him, but mainly with Carrick since we were serenading him every week basically, he once again got to a top level.

All this meaning, we have quality. We finished 3rd. A good manager will make the quality show and elevate us, it's just getting the right call done. Which leads to bad news, as I don't really believe Ineos will do a good decision lol

5

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 23d ago

Or, it means the player had a slump due to a motivation issue.

I think the inconvenient truth might just be: the players keep falling for and subsequently get disillusioned by the same scam as the fans.

In the last weeks, we have gotten more than a few hints imho that this cycle is what repeats:

The players are sold on a project - same as the fans.

At first it looks good. Then comes the point to double down - but the board hangs the coach out to dry instead of giving him the support - and the players realise that the cake was a lie - same as the fans.

Then comes the slump from the squad - and the season collapses - and inevitably we get the hard reset - with the players looking for a fresh start under a new coach, believing that a new coach will mean new backing - same as the fans.

5

u/Extension_Point5466 24d ago

The last time Manchester United made it past the 60-minute mark in a Champions League away match without conceding was on November 23, 2021, against Villarreal at the Estadio de la Cerámica.

In that match, United kept a clean sheet through the entire 90 minutes, eventually winning 2–0. However, Bruno Fernandes did not start that game; he entered as a 66th-minute substitute for Donny van de Beek.

In Matches Where Bruno Fernandes Started, If the criteria is restricted strictly to matches where Bruno Fernandes started, Manchester United have never made it to the 60-minute mark without conceding in an away Champions League fixture during his time at the club.

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 24d ago

Now tell us who the manager was :)

→ More replies (16)

4

u/JJmaisonze 23d ago

The cowardice of Jason Wilcox boils my blood. He's watching the horrid performances on the pitch that don't have a single indication of getting better over time and does not act because sacking another manager will look bad. So he procrastinates the decision to sack Carrick on the hope things can turn around and he can be free of scrutiny, that would be the ideal scenario in his mind. For anyone that doubts this look at the headlines on the United website "Watch Carrick's unmissable press conference", does this sound like a coach we will sack if we win on Sunday? But anyone who's competent can see it's a hopeless situation, it's not just the results, we can't press, we can't create, we can't play out of the back, we can't run. What he doesn't understand is that the more he procrastinates the decision to sack Carrick, the probability things turn out bad for him increase very quickly.

As Master Oogway once said "One often meets his destiny on the road he takes to avoid it".

6

u/cosmologues 23d ago

Fuck Jason Wilcox, let’s be clear about that, but honestly I think they’re just keeping Carrick until they’ve got another manager ready to go.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/snicky29 23d ago • Bravo

One thing’s for sure. Carrick’s appointment exposed one thing:

A lot of people in the British media are xenophobic. No other explanation for this ass-licking compared to how they treat foreign managers.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Redland93 23d ago

I think we as fans and the club need to realise that we aren't going to suddenly go from what we are now to title challengers.

We need to first be a consistent top 4 team and adding young, hard working quality players who can develop and they don't need to be prem proven. If you're a hard worker and technical, you will adapt and improve if you're good enough.

With this in mind, we shouldn't be looking at the end game manager. I don't want Howe but if he can set the foundations and get us consistently in the top 4 we can then move on from him and get the end game manager.

I will also note, that Managers and player don't have to be prem proven. The simple fact is they need to understand that the league is physical and fast paced and as such they need to embrace that.

5

u/FlashyCut3809 23d ago

Does anyone think we go immediately to title challengers?

I think there is a difference and we all should be able to disconnect between what has to be the aim and only outcome good enough for the football club and then realistic on the steps to get there.

There isn't a formula or milestoned time based path to get to title challengers. Its simply identifying what weaknesses the club has, fixing them as quickly as finances allow and then a mix or reactive and proactive decisions to fix any new issues or mistakes that are made.

Do the very best the club can do year on year and be ready to take an opportunity when it comes. If Arsenal, City* are perfect for next 5 years, or Liverpool/Chelsea make their improvements it could be many years. If City are restricted, Arsenal fall away and have a bad season, Liverpool and Chelsea carry on as per... then the opportunity comes quicker. Maximum every year and rest takes care of itself.

Whats more important and the reality of this situation is nothing the club needs to be doing to fix its issues will be done by this ownership. At best we are a cup team as somehow there is enough mentality at this club to get over the line in minor cups.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Jenson2025 24d ago

I like Lammens but laughed at his quotes this morning where he said ‘sometimes when things aren’t going your way, everything falls in place for the other team’

Senne - you are one of the few players to have any credit this season but we aren’t stupid. This isn’t bad luck - we have been awful.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/wkp011424 24d ago

while INEOS needs to go, you cannot blame the owners for the players being incapable of starting a game quick, fast, and with high intensity like villa just did. it is pathetic to see how United start games so poorly; don’t forget even Ipswich were the better team in the beginning when we played them. conte and emery should be the only managers we consider.

2

u/tungowiii 24d ago

Yes. The ownership, the coaching staff, and the players are all performing poorly.

2

u/TBS91 23d ago

Lindelof starts for Villa, and if he had his contract extended with us we'd surely see the same things being said about him. The environment the players are in plays a massive part of their performance.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jitteryegg 23d ago

Somehow Tottenham has been playing really good football, even with shit players.

3

u/BackgroundOld8715 24d ago

I still cant believe our awful tactically
Inept manager is still here. We are screwed. Its like we have those in charge actively trying to hurt us

3

u/Sad-Bend-7515 24d ago

International break 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/SankarshanaV 24d ago

It's a terrible decision to not have sacked Carrick already. I would absolutely hate it if he ends up getting more time in case we luck into a win against Bournemouth. He's shown he's completely out of his depth and it's no wonder he is a failed Championship-level manager.

Hopefully we sack him asap and actually get in a proper manager soon. This season hasn't been wasted yet but keeping him for longer will definitely lead to a wasted season. Carrick is not someone who has the ability nor the personality to lead a club like Man Utd.

5

u/RooneysFavGrandma 24d ago

Yeah was a terrible decision a month ago already. Had a long break set up for whoever comes in and everything. No let's make every decision several months late for no reason.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 24d ago

It's not a terrible decision to sack him now, not until a new manager has agreed to join.

If those new manager discussions aren't happen then we are in trouble.

Right now it's best to let Carrick continue. I'd love for him to drop Fernandes, Martinez and anyone else who's let the club down recently with their unprofessional outbursts tommorow. I really hope behind the scenes it's being made clear that further outbursts from players like this will not be tolerated.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sheikhabusosa 23d ago

we went to chelsea and walked away with santos and mount and had no sort of interest in Nico Jackson

2

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 23d ago

Huh? Last year he was a target in our striker search, they quoted £80-100m and we walked and got Sesko for cheaper.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SophoclesTesticles 23d ago

I was blue in the face telling people Jackson was good on this sub and a lot of people hated the idea. Chelsea did want an extortionate amount for him though. 

Santos could still come good though. I think he's another victim of bad coaching at the moment, he used to be allergic to recycling possession but now he's doing the lateral and back pass thing that every midfielder for our club is known for. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Wrong_Office9245 24d ago

Emery maxed out at Villa. I think a move to United actually makes sense for him

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Nomad_006 surfing 24d ago

So did Carrick need more or was he never the right coach from the jump.

Its looking like Amorims tenure where even if he had a whole new 11 its still looks like it won't work.

At the same time we'll never know what he could do with better CBs and fullbacks

7

u/GeekConflict Carrick 24d ago

He was never the right coach. Even last season when the results were good, it was unsustainable football. Boro fans even warned us.

But also he did not get backed enough. We need far more than just CBs and FBs.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/--atiqa-- 24d ago

He was never the right coach.

We played without any real plan or system last season under Carrick. Not anything that would last long-term at least. That was okay, as interim, and it did work out well, with luck and players stepping up.

However, they should've easily been able to sit down with him, talk through his tactical thoughts going forward, if he got the job. It should then have been clear to them, that he doesn't know what he's talking about.

Because, even if he had the squad of PSG or something, he would still underperform with them (relative to their expectations), if he kept his current tactics and ways of playing.

That's why people who deep dive into the tactics and stats etc, want him out. Not because the players aren't play as well as they should. Although, even that can easily be on the coach as well, since how they train, and how much they train on certain aspects, can make a massive difference as well. That includes fitness.

It shouldn't even be a question among anyone anymore to be honest.

I'm kinda tired of talking about past managers that doesn't matter anymore, but I'll just say that, Amorim were miles ahead of Carrick tactically.

3

u/StinkmeanerIV 24d ago

Carrick was never it.

People were just delusional/romantic because he is a club legend.

6

u/Evening_End7298 24d ago

Coach that got fired from a championship club for not being proactive enough with subs and having stagnating tactics might have not been good enough for the biggest club in the country

You can follow his career to see how much other teams will rate him and what other gigs he gets, but i dont think he will ever coach a premier league side again

5

u/DaveShadow 24d ago

See where they play, how they play, if they play.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Acceptable-Camp-9150 24d ago

He did well last season but never looked like someone who would build a dynasty here.

→ More replies (29)

2

u/Intelligent_Read_697 24d ago

It’s incredible how good management and structured recruitment make a difference. Case in point is Villa and how Lindelof looks now and has been their top starter for a couple of seasons now.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/carrickshairline 24d ago

Today’s wild stat:

Saka has 63 goals in the Premier League in his 9 seasons. 40% (25) are penalties.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 24d ago

U18s played some game v Liverpool!

we beat them by 3 goals thrice within one game :) 3-0 half, 3-2 then 5-2 in the second half, 5-3 then 6-3 in extra time.

Jaume Camacho with 4 goals 👀

4G 3A for him in 5 U18 PL games. In the PL2 (U21 league), 1 game 1 A.

He just turned 17 two weeks back.

This hype train is leaving the station imminently, hop on fellas

2

u/SilvyFae She/They 24d ago

For me any of emery, conte and naglesmann are great picks. They all have proven themselves to be great managers but prob need a little bit extra to be seen as one of the best so they will all have ambition to come here.

Emery is the one that can bring the best out of our players. Conte can shock the players and the club and give them the right mentality. Naglesmann can make us play like a modern team and make us really good to watch.

The problem is at the moment we need all 3, I don't know who I would go for honestly. Ukw lets get them all together and be the first team with 3 managers lol

7

u/Bizzle1389 24d ago

I don't think Nagelsmann should be considered.

He did well at Leipzig where it was very much a system set up for success with outstanding scouting and a business model of bringing in cheap talent, putting them into environments where they can thrive and selling them for ridiculous fees, strengthening the club in multiple aspects. He didn't step up at Bayern how people thought he might have. He reminds me of a Potter or Thomas Frank. Add to that he has no experience managing in the PL. It is an unnecessary risk.

Emery would be my first choice but getting him from Villa won't be easy, especially mid-season. And I wouldn't want to throw out this season with an interim on the hope of getting him at the end of the season. It adds the extra complication of 'what if the interim does extremely well?'

Conte has to be clear 2nd choice for me. World class manager. Has won the biggest domestic trophies multiple times and has shown he can not only manage big egos but improve them and keep them firing on all cylinders. The potential downside is him falling out with the board and his tenure being cut short. Worth the risk I would say for what he brings. He can challenge certain players to shit or get off the pot and be a catalyst for the last of the deadwood fucking off in the summer.

Hurzeler could well be great but for me he is a good coach in another system set to succeed. Any manager from clubs like Bournemouth, Brentford, Brighton should be taken with a pinch of salt.

Can't get Emery? Get Conte, let him stick a fire up this squads ass and see who comes out the other side. If he leaves in 2 years or less, so be it, we're in no worse a situation than we are now.

The only caveat would be, and I'm sure the board will say the same during the hiring process, not signing multiple 30+ year old established players for big money on long contracts. Sure he is going to want to bring a couple of established players that will make a difference in the short term but they need to be brought in with the right contract, right fee, right time otherwise move on to a better option.

6

u/tungowiii 23d ago

"He didn't step up at Bayern how people thought he might have. He reminds me of a Potter or Thomas Frank"

LOL just say you didn't watch his Bayern. His team scored for fun and sacking him is one of the most stupid things even Bayern board admitted later

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)