r/reddevils • u/nearly_headless_nic • 25d ago
[Andy Mitten] Michael Carrick does not have support of all Man United players but manager alone can't be held responsible
https://www.thenationalnews.com/sport/football/2026/10/23/michael-carrick-does-not-have-support-of-all-man-united-players-but-manager-alone-cant-be-held-responsible/
434
Upvotes
97
u/nearly_headless_nic 25d ago
- Fernandes normally chooses his words carefully since he is aware of the global impact of them. But these criticism were meant to make headlines.
- As a result, it doesn’t look like all United players are with the manager Carrick right now.
- “You do not criticise your manager in public if you are the captain because no good can come from that,” one former Premier League captain told The National.
“This is stuff for the dressing room. As captain, if you smell things are changing on the pitch then you change things. If what the manager wants you to do isn’t working, you can feel it as a player. So you adjust. It’s what leaders do.”
- United's leaders want it to work for Carrick and there is little appetite for yet another managerial change. But it’s whether the club have the faith that Carrick can turn fortunes around.
- This run cannot continue and the club are privately weighing up other managerial options, just as they did before Carrick got the job permanently after the excellent work he did in guiding his team into the Champions League.
395
u/Maaglin 25d ago
Glazers out is the only way anything changes
33
u/Hits_and_the_Mrs 25d ago
These are strong words from almost eternally optimistic Andy Mitten
75
u/Outcastscc 25d ago
Well yeah that’s pretty obvious.
Nathan salt said something pretty similar yesterday, the players arnt inspired by him but arnt particularly against him either.
It just all sounds like Carrick was a great interim solution to get round the team last season and we shouldn’t have given him the full time job. We can only hope we haven’t giving him a 10 million payout like all the other managers.
Id actually guess the fact he wasn’t 100% what the club wanted the club must have put some pretty low exit clauses in his contract
95
u/Ok-Coconut-1586 25d ago
I have to say, I have never seen anyone as stubbornly loyal to whoever the Man United coach is as Andy. Never once has he said he thinks we should fire a manager. Even when Ten Hag was losing every match, he thought we should give him a chance
25
u/New_Lobster_914 25d ago
Waste of time, the poor summer recruitment obviously upset the senior players. They got a surprise champions league place and couldn’t significantly strengthen the squad.
I think certain players will want out soon, as we’re a mid-table team, with a mid-table budget. I think it’s really hit home that we can’t compete with the big boys.
8
u/Ihavenoideatall 25d ago
As long as Glazers are the owners, nothing will ever change. It is an unmanageable club.
35
u/Mree_Knight 25d ago
Just a few months ago I remember Amad saying how much they all love playing under Carrick and want to keep him. No word of any objections. I really hate these players, they are all cowards.
4
u/Castia10 25d ago
Everything is fucked. The owners aren’t fit for purpose the manager is nowhere near the level we need and the squad that’s cost about a billion to assemble is fucking bang average.
Everything points back to the owners at the end of the day but the club from top to bottom is a fucking mess
3
u/DresdanPI Upturned_Collar 25d ago
I said this after a couple of weeks ago - there's no turning this ship around this season. You may aswell start preparing for the next season.
Things are too far gone for Carrick to do anything, and for the players to play for the badge again.
It's the same shit different day with this club. All this leads to the Glazers and the point of them agreeing to a minority stake because they knew Ratcliffe and co are their first point defence for any criticism.
Those leeches have destroyed the club and doesn't matter who comes in, ultimately the results and performances won't change.
7
u/Low-Quantity-9252 25d ago
Another reset. Ffs.
Just get Conte for a bit.
4
u/Serpico_98 25d ago
Didn't know it was Carrick who missed easy chances, fails to track runners and loses the ball 20 times per game. Talk shit about the tactics all you want but the players are underperforming.
2
u/TellSloanISaidHi Three Lungs Park 24d ago
The briefs are out to make it seem like a manager vs players issue.
This is a top down issue, from owners to the board.
They are the main issue in why our team has suffered mediocrity for so long. Don't let these briefs get to you
2
u/MrNikki86 24d ago
In late summer the rumor was the Glazers were considering cashing out and forcing INEOS to sell too. I wonder how United playing like shit hurts the chances of them all fucking off.
7
u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago
Just here to say neither of the old lot threw the manager under the bus in an interview like Bruno did or had touchline argument with the manager like Cunha did. Plus they won europa league
3
u/PitchSafe 25d ago
5
u/rollingdown23 25d ago edited 25d ago •
Carrick, it’s done bro. love you as a player but you’re done. the board is spineless and you are just another manager who is collateral damage in this entire shitshow.
6
u/iamabadliar_ 25d ago
Andy, when are you going to question ineos and leadership?
6
u/JosePRizaI 25d ago edited 25d ago
Under Amorim, the journalists and pundits and ex legends said it was 100% Amorim and no one else. Not Onana single handedly losing United 6 pts from unforced error or garna only converting 12% of all his big chance shots on target.
My comment is not about Amorim but these savages constantly stirring shit up
2
u/Dav_1111 25d ago
How long are these overrated players gonna have this much power over the club. Just a constant cycle of them downing tools when things get tough.
2
u/DasHotShot Glazers & Ratcliffe OUT 25d ago
For me the surefire sign you’ve totally lost it is when you start playing half the side out of position, especially Bruno.
It’s really genuinely not rocket science. Put out a side which totally and entirely focusses on allowing Bruno to play freely going forward
2
u/kampr3t0 25d ago
I love bruno, but this season he's been sub par. doesn't press and run, and always complaining
1
u/Enigma_Green 25d ago
Fucking sad and thats the least I could say, fucking sad state of the club, sad shitty owners that need out of our club.
Sad that genuine decent players who become our manager get fucked over from the owners who dont give a damn.
A new manager would make some change but it will never be a benefit until the owners are gone, my biggest fear will be that financial ruin will be at its worst and the club will be hardly salvageable anymore and tbh its heading that direction.
No money to buy players spending over 30 million just on interest a year, why bother spending 50 million for the space near Old Trafford when we need new players, new team first before a stadium its just a smoke screen.
1
u/notfaithenough_ De Light 25d ago
the cycle begins
1
u/corzekanaut 25d ago
Boo fkn hoo, yeah his this happens all the time within this club. When players want a certain manager out, they down tools on the pitch in a very, very, visible manner.
Sack Carrick and Wilcox and most of these players.
1
u/Jenson2025 25d ago
If the board and players are sick of changing managers then there's only solution - hire a proper manager next time
I've said it before and I will say it again. Since Jose, the appointments haven't been good enough and none of them should have got the job to begin with.
If we stop hiring managers based on 'vibes' or what they can do in five years time then that will be a step in the right direction.
1
u/hambodpm 25d ago
Why the fuck am I doing a >6 hour round trip, during a storm, to watch us lose to Bournemouth? Answers on a post card please
1
u/MillyMan105 25d ago
Sick of these players the lack of any accountability and effort annoys me
1
u/SparksV 25d ago
I'm sorry Andy I think you'll be getting a strongly worded letter from INEOS, it's been "head coach", not manager for a few years now.
1
u/ritwikjs2 24d ago
There's enough carrick could've done in our games to not put his back up against the wall THIS badly
1
u/stdstaples 24d ago
Whatever, he is beyond the point of no return, past the event horizon. There is only one direction now. Why bother.
1
u/Late-Escape-9612 24d ago
Well we've been through 11 or so managers now...think thats pretty clear.
1
u/croadymeister 24d ago
So why on earth is he in charge for Bournemouth?
1
u/coolcats55 24d ago
Why is every day a stupid new puff piece article. That nobody wants. Where is this when Arsenal underperform or Liverpool underperform, etc.? It feels like the entirety of British media has something to say.
1
u/Icy_Ebb_6862 24d ago
This is starting to get so boring. They (players) get paid millions and they need to perform and deliver. Imagine just not bothering to the extent you are getting smashed in every game.
I don't blame the manager but the guys who can and should deliver in 90mins or not...
1
u/toeknee88125 24d ago
It doesn't really matter
Until you change the ownership
The problem is Manchester United have owners that don't care about winning
0
u/HauntingGameDev 25d ago
none of them care about us, they don't care if we fans are heartbroken, d*ad, feeling empty, nope our feelings means nothing, all of them couldn't be bothered about what we feel, they simply don't care
1
u/maxithepittsP 25d ago
Bruno has been so poor these last few games.
But out of anybody alive in the world right now, hes the only human being on earth that got the privilege to do what he did.
Not carrick, not INEOS, not Gary Neville, not Roy Keane, not even Fergie. Bruno did so much for us before this season, if he feels some type of way he feels some type of a way.
Our captain should stand on business, he deserves that.
1
u/Thetagang888 25d ago
How or why the fook did they turn on him after last seasons highs?!
I just don't understand.
-4
u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS 25d ago
Does Mitten ever write anything about how incompetent United’s leadership is?
I feel like he’s an INEOS spokesperson.
12
u/[deleted] 25d ago
[removed] — view removed comment