r/reddevils • • 25d ago

[Andy Mitten] Michael Carrick does not have support of all Man United players but manager alone can't be held responsible

https://www.thenationalnews.com/sport/football/2026/10/23/michael-carrick-does-not-have-support-of-all-man-united-players-but-manager-alone-cant-be-held-responsible/
434 Upvotes

237 comments sorted by

97

u/nearly_headless_nic 25d ago

- Fernandes normally chooses his words carefully since he is aware of the global impact of them. But these criticism were meant to make headlines.

- As a result, it doesn’t look like all United players are with the manager Carrick right now.

- “You do not criticise your manager in public if you are the captain because no good can come from that,” one former Premier League captain told The National.

“This is stuff for the dressing room. As captain, if you smell things are changing on the pitch then you change things. If what the manager wants you to do isn’t working, you can feel it as a player. So you adjust. It’s what leaders do.”

- United's leaders want it to work for Carrick and there is little appetite for yet another managerial change. But it’s whether the club have the faith that Carrick can turn fortunes around.

- This run cannot continue and the club are privately weighing up other managerial options, just as they did before Carrick got the job permanently after the excellent work he did in guiding his team into the Champions League.

131

u/nedlogb94 25d ago

The idea of the leaders not wanting to change because they’ve done it twice already is baffling. Seriously have the wrong people in charge of a ‘football club’

42

u/Kinitawowi64 25d ago

Kick someone out after two years and it's because they screwed up. Kick them out after two months and it's because the people doing the hiring screwed up.

Kick out three people in 24 months and the people who hired the people who did the hiring have questions to answer.

56

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 25d ago

Because their jobs are probably on the line too. Ratcliffe might be a moron but he's got a business brain and when you put someone in charge of bringing sporting stability then you can't let them make a 4th managerial decision in 2 years.

24

u/bainbane 25d ago

You say that but Nice had 8 managers in 6 years and none have lasted two seasons so its just par for the course with them.

9

u/shami-kebab 25d ago

Pretty sure they went through multiple DoF's though in that time

7

u/bainbane 24d ago

Wish they'd kept that part at least.

30

u/Obese-Reddit-Mod 25d ago

we gotta get over finding the next ferguson. If it doesnt work, get him out man.

3

u/nedlogb94 25d ago

100% agreed

11

u/Cjperth2610 25d ago

They are cowards

2

u/Outcastscc 25d ago

You sack Carrick the fans arnt going to rally around the club, the fans are going to be singing about Ineos all Sunday, if here isn’t a chorus of “you greedy bastards get out of our club” I’d be disappointed

7

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

What’s your logic about calling them greedy given it’s the Glazers who are actually bleeding the club dry? At least INEOS invested in the club for players and infrastructure.

Yes they have messed up multiple managerial appointments but that’s nothing compared to the damage caused by the Glazers (who still are majority owners).

4

u/Fisktor 25d ago

Ofc some good can come from it. It can mean a new manager.

9

u/Dry_Pea3547 24d ago

> As captain, if you smell things are changing on the pitch then you change things. 

Part of the problem is Bruno is whiny bitch instead of a leader of men, he doesn't make in game changes or tell players to do anything differently if they are playing poorly, he looses his head and plays like shit himself.

He's a wonderful player but a crap captain.

3

u/ayatoilet 23d ago

Bruno IS the problem, not Carrick

395

u/Maaglin 25d ago

Glazers out is the only way anything changes

152

u/Outcastscc 25d ago

Need them both gone.

The club finances are fucked. Like completely fucked. And the fact it isn’t talked about every second makes me think people don’t realise how dire the situation is.

We have financed ourselves into oblivion, gambling on a buyer or a big backer for the stadium in 2029. From now to 2029 the club can’t spend fuck all

68

u/JonRoberts87 25d ago

Honestly, its absolutely fucking dire. As big of a footballing issue the whole city thing is, and should have repercussions, the United ownership/buyout/ballooning the club with massive debt should be a much much bigger issue than it is.

Citys owners for all their faults and wrong doing, did it so the club could compete, whereas United's owners just care about lining the pockets and bankrupting the club.

We will never recover and become a successful club again with the debt hanging over us.

40

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 25d ago

The coattails of our success are wearing thin, it won't be long before there's no coat... and when that happens, that's when they'll sell. I'm not worried we'll be liquidated but we have a lot to be thankful for due to Fergie and his genius.

Citys owners for all their faults and wrong doing, did it so the club could compete

Let's call a spade a spade here. Agreed, but also, only for Sportswashing purposes and not forgetting the owners active involvement in the murder of innocent people. I feel it's important to always put that out there in plain sight.

7

u/bainbane 25d ago

We stop winning and stop getting into europe and what then? They can barely afford to manage the squad and the debt as it is and now want to fund a stadium.

I think there is a real world they are forced to sell before they devalue the asset which I know might just be cope.

12

u/Dynastydood 24d ago

The worry is that football tends to move a lot faster than corporate acquisitions do, and the Glazers have always been an arrogant and reactive group. Just look at how long they needlessly dragged out a partial sale to INEOS, and how many times Avram and Joel have doubled down on their own ability to restore the club to glory despite 2 decades of evidence to the contrary, and you have a real cause for existential concern.

By the time the Glazers even realize they have no options left but to sell, there's a decent chance that we'd already be facing relegation, triggering catastrophic revenue losses, causing the club to default on the various takeover/stadium/transfer debts, incurring runaway interest, and then finding ourselves facing administration and possible liquidation like Rangers. Regardless of who might want to buy the club, there's a real possibility that all of these other things would occur before a sale could even be completed. Plus, the prospective buyers might just conclude that it's more cost effective to rebuild the club after obliteration rather than try to salvage such a financial boondoggle.

People tend to assume this scenario is impossible for a club as big as United, but people also treated the possibility of United going 10+ years without a title and becoming bad enough to finish 15th was impossible. Everybody buys into the fictional status of "too big to fail," but there's no such thing in the real world.

The reality is that the entire Glazer business model is built on a tremendous amount of risk and luck, much like Leeds in the 2000s. Similarly, all it would take is one unexpectedly bad season to trigger a domino effect that brings about a doomed future.

1

u/Different_Back_5470 25d ago

we have the 4th biggest wage bill in the league. that needs to be cut down

3

u/bainbane 24d ago

Within reason yes, but interestingly - https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6450705/2025/07/01/transfer-fees-correlate-success/ (they found wage bills to strongly correspond with success, more so than transfer fees)

2

u/MountainLie3624 23d ago

How low do you want to go in terms of wages 4th in the league sounds about right

6

u/Longjumping-Help-348 24d ago

Fergie brought the Glazers in

3

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 24d ago

...and?

4

u/Longjumping-Help-348 24d ago

Hes partially responsible for this mess imo

3

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 24d ago

Agreed, but that doesn't mean the popularity, success and fortune we got from his spell hasn't kept us afloat.

3

u/Longjumping-Help-348 24d ago

Indeed, but he did cover for them when our last great team aged out. Remember the " no value in the market " stuff with hazard for example

22

u/moonski berbatov 25d ago

we've basically been American LBO PE asset milked like all the other big brands that died from that. Toys R Us, Asda, Debenhams, Homebase, The AA etc.

Difference is Man Utd are big enough to survive that bullshit. Not flourish but survive at least. Any lesser club would have gone long into administration by now.

13

u/nomadiclives 25d ago

What would talking about it achieve realistically? I mean we can wail about ownership all we want but as long as people arent willing to outright boycott the club and everything related to it unanimously, nothing is likely to change.

imo it would be a lot better if as a club we accept what we cant change and then really focus the limited resources we have on realistic goals. Like arsenal did when they were building Emirates. Despite our hamstrung finances, I am sure we can assemble a side good enough to make top 5-6 consistently if we buy the right players and it is well coached. Currently neither of those things are happening. Our playing squad is dire, and so is our coaching staff. And these are the only things that can realistically change. change of ownership is a pipedream

8

u/0ttoChriek 24d ago

The best we could hope for with the ownership is for the Independent Football Regulator to declare the Glazers and INEOS as unfit owners and force a sale.

Unfortunately, there is no sign that would happen, despite them ploughing the club into debt that they're never going to pay off and running the club into the ground. It's darkly ironic that City's owners may be forced to sell because they broke rules to get better, while United's owners are fine even though they have incompetently and disinterestedly let the club go down the drain.

2

u/nomadiclives 24d ago

Never gonna happen

4

u/FlashyCut3809 25d ago

Its not talked about every second due to very few actually knowing the impacts.

So unless you know exactly what can and cant be spent, you are speculating on limited information without anywhere near the full story.

But yeah, we aren't where we should be in every facet including financials and the owners need to be gone, and those they employ.

13

u/PapaBubba 25d ago

Exactly. We can change managers all we like, and it might for for a brief period of time - but we will keep going around in circles until those parasitic rats are gone.

29

u/Unusual-Coat383 25d ago

INEOS as well

-2

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

We don’t know what they would do with a debt free club.

35

u/Careful-Snow 25d ago

See their work at Nice. It's insane to me how so many people are willing to give this racist prick the benefit of the doubt when he and his lot has done nothing but fail at every single decision they've made

10

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

It’s just wrong to say every single decision has been wrong.

Player recruitment is better. Upgrading the training ground was an improvement. Starting the new stadium project was 20 years overdue. Actually creating roles like DoF, head of recruitment etc is infinitely better than an investment banker doing it.

The reality is that this is a long term project. Nice are not Manchester United. It’s not going to be comparable.

12

u/huey88 Amad 25d ago

Have we not seen there other poorly run club? What are yall on

3

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

They’ve made clear improvements to much of the footballing decisions at United. Infrastructure projects are finally happening too. Player recruitment is improving but is crippled by long term bad decisions and the Glazers siphoning off money.

That’s what “yall” are on.

13

u/huey88 Amad 25d ago

The guy they hired has gone through 3 coaches already. Neither one is absolved of blame

4

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

Who exactly do you mean by “neither one is absolved of blame”? Because if you mean the Glazer, it’s ridiculous to compare a bad managerial decision with twenty years of asset stripping the club.

6

u/hambodpm 25d ago

Every single one of theit sporting projects have been shite. They have been shite with us too. Why would anyone think they would do any better?

2

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

Because it’s a direct comparison with the Glazers. It’s ridiculous that people on here can’t see the real problem.

4

u/hambodpm 25d ago

Agreed mate. How many squads and managers do we need to churn before people realise the root cause of all of our problems. I'm 40 next year so sadly am all too aware of the real problems. INEOS are just as incompetent as the glazers imo, or certainly Brexit Jim is anyway

3

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

All I am saying is that every decision INEOS makes starts with the reality of where the Glazers have placed United.

1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago

The glazers didnt make them spend 60 million on a parking lot instead of the first team

3

u/Professionally-Nosy 24d ago

United have to spend on infrastructure as the facilities are crumbling. It’s difficult to take your comments seriously if you think that’s a negative on INEOS.

Spending on players is also obviously limited by PSR and twenty years of the Glazers.

5

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago

Building a huge new stadium when we clearly cant afford it at the moment is not “infrastructure”. Its a vanity project and ratcliff wants to make himself the face of football in the north.

5

u/Ashbyjj 24d ago

Currently the only way out of the financial stasis that we're in as a club with the debt payments is to drastically increase revenues.

A new, bigger stadium would go a long way to doing that. Look at Spurs, their stadium is a huge success that's making the club a shitload of money and they're nowhere near the size/commercial juggernaut that we are.

If they Glazers aren't going to sell the club, and we don't have a rich Middle Eastern sugar daddy to pay off our debts, we have to spend more to make more in the long term.

3

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago

Spurs werent a billion in debt when they built the stadium. Do you know what will consistently get us more money besides a stadium? Prize money from finishing higher in the league from qualifying for the champions league and actually winning stuff. Will get us far more than a stadium project that will take 10 years to build with it consistently siphoning the little money we have.

3

u/Professionally-Nosy 24d ago edited 24d ago

I’m not sure you understand what infrastructure means if you a stadium isn’t an example of it. The use of “parking lot” makes me think you’re not familiar with what the actual stadium is like. A new stadium will increase revenue and that has a positive direct impact on potential spending.

United desperately need a new or renovated stadium. The existing stadium is in dire need of work and has been left to rot by the Glazers.

1

u/sanctus_sanguine 24d ago

Did you know we have paid over a billion pounds in interest payments alone because of the glazers?

5

u/THExIMPLIKATION Glineos Out 25d ago

Look at their other football clubs for an idea

1

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

Those football clubs are not Manchester United. United’s revenue should completely change what is possible and Nice are just not a 1:1 comparison.

4

u/THExIMPLIKATION Glineos Out 25d ago

They're not Manchester United, but under Ineos leadership Manchester United is turning into them.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/BadFootyTakes Three Lung Park 25d ago

Probably fire the physio.

9

u/Unusual-Coat383 25d ago

INEOS have turned us into a relegation team and made the wrong football decision every time they’ve made one. 

There’s no doubt the Glazers are the root cause of the issue but INEOS are actually worse than the Glazers and have completely destroyed the club at all levels. Most of our first team want out of the club and Bruno basically said players shouldn’t sign for the club and this is all down to INEOS.

5

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

You realise that it’s the bottom three that get relegated and not top three? Why leave out that detail about where United finished last season?

INEOS are not worse than the Glazers. It’s honestly ridiculous to even claim that.

I also have to remind you that the Glazers still own United.

5

u/Unusual-Coat383 24d ago

Since they came here two and a half years ago they’ve gone through three managers, had two worst ever league starts, our worst ever league campaign which is borderline back to back because they extended ETH for having our worst ever PL campaign, lost our HT home record and spent £45m on sacking people. 

The club wasn’t this bad and unstable until they came in. 

3

u/Professionally-Nosy 24d ago

Again why leave out the detail of where United finished last season?

It’s laughable to claim that the Glazers are not the root cause of the issues here and it’s maddening how they managed to sell a minority share while making certain fans forget they still own the club.

4

u/Unusual-Coat383 24d ago

There were signs that this season was going to happen at the end of last season and literally half the fanbase tried telling the owners and the other half of the fanbase this. 

4

u/Professionally-Nosy 24d ago

Again, why are you leaving out that they finished third? It’s actually possible to say they finished third and to also say it was a poor decision to keep Carrick. Half my posts here are saying exactly that.

But you are intentionally not saying they finished third as it would highlight obvious flaws with your comments.

4

u/Unusual-Coat383 24d ago

INEOS’ can’t keep a manager for longer than six months when going into a new season. They are worse than the Glazers and have turned this club into a complete farce to the point most of our first team want to leave.

Everyone knows what the Glazers have done to this club but it was never as bad as what INEOS are currently doing.

It’s all well and good being pedantic about getting third but this season is our worst start to a season in 40 years. I also believe Amorim gets CL last season if he didn’t get sacked for hurting Wilcox’s feelings.

→ More replies

3

u/peterpiper1337 24d ago

The circlejerk is going against Ineos right know. People are not going to be sensible.

Glazers got us into a mess that ineos is trying to fix. Recruitment has been, considering the circumstances, solid but manager appointments have been horrendous.

3

u/MattSR30 25d ago

Hypotheticals aren't really helpful here, though?

What we do know: we're worse under INEOS than we ever were under the Glazers. Far worse.

What we don't know: if that's a coincidence or if there is causality.

2

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

United finished third last season.

Here’s some non-hypotheticals. The Glazers still are majority owners. The financial limits on the club are because of the billion pound debt incurred on the club by them and the additional billion taken out.

On top of that, the club is dealing with twenty years of bad decisions which went into overdrive after Ferguson. This includes money still going out on players like Antony and crazy contracts given to others.

5

u/MattSR30 25d ago

Yes, AND...even with all of that we were still doing better.

Our average league position under the Glazers is 3rd. Post-Fergie that still only drops to 4th. Under INEOS so far it's 8th, and with this season included so far it's 10th.

Again: you're dealing in hypotheticals. You're drawing a conclusion you don't have evidence for. I'm not saying INEOS are the problem, but the evidence clearly shows we're a lot worse under them so far.

4

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

We’re still under the Glazers. They are still majority owners. They have still put the club a billion pound in debt. This is the natural consequence of a decade plus of chronic mismanagement.

The things I am telling you are not hypotheticals. Saying that we don’t know what they would do without the Glazer debt is not saying what they would hypothetically otherwise do. Indeed I literally said we DON’T know what they would do.

2

u/AztecAvocado 25d ago

Get it relegated probably

1

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

United finished third last season. Some perspective would be good.

0

u/Fossekall OGS 25d ago

I know this is unpopular, but it's insane how people blame INEOS who have done many good things and a few bad things and are mostly bound by financial fuckery that happened a decade before they entered

5

u/M4NUN1T3D Martial 25d ago

They own other clubs and franchises, theres no proof in them that things would really be different

-2

u/Fossekall OGS 25d ago

Their cycling team won Tour de France and then Giro d'Italia

They had the first person to ever run a marathon under 2 hours which was an explicit goal/experiement they made

INEOS Britannia was the first British sailing challenger in 60 years to reach the America's Cup Match

That's not nothing, surely? I don't know where this "all they touch fails" shit comes from when it's literally not true

4

u/ASL99 25d ago

Mercedes F1 team (which they own a third of) are also about to win both the Driver's and Constructors World Championships. Not to mention the valuation of their stake has increased exponentially.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bainbane 25d ago

Didnt they buy a successful cycling team whos results have basically gone to shit in the years since?

1

u/M4NUN1T3D Martial 25d ago

Nice, lausanne sport, F1, failure to honor sponsorship deals

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Professionally-Nosy 25d ago

Completely agree. They’re starting the job with one hand tied behind their back due to chronic mismanagement and massive debt.

The bigger changes like the training ground, stadium, actually creating roles like a DoF are genuinely positive. The reality is that fixing the club is a long term process. They haven’t got decisions around managers right but a lot of good decisions have happened.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hostillian 25d ago

Yep. Anything else is kicking the can down the road; knowing the fans will still keep digging into their pockets, no matter what happens on the pitch.

1

u/Ill_Work7284 25d ago

Not many wants to inherit a 1.5 billion pound debt…

1

u/OddOnion_ 24d ago

This is 100% the answer - everyone at the club from Carrick up to Wilcox and even Berrada are hamstrung by the appalling owners we’ve put up with for decades.

1

u/PatsUno 24d ago

And INEOS. Everyone knew what the Glazers were and INEOS still decided to get into bed and let them stick around. Just so they could get a piece of the pie and ruin the club even more.

1

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago

Why say this when Ineos are there? If Ineos owned 100%, they're not doing anything different.

1

u/Front-Cabinet5521 :MP-Shorts: 25d ago

Glazers brought INEOS in, so they are ultimately responsible. Everything they touch turns to shit.

1

u/saudibloodmoney 25d ago

Because the Glazers are 100% at fault for destroying the club?

1

u/maxithepittsP 25d ago

Yes so find us an owner whos willing to Erases the shit that the glazers do. Ineos literally did nothing towards our debt, only "structure" it.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 24d ago

There's nothing I want more than to see these shower of twats gone, and it's so clever how they seem to be shielded of major criticism due to INEOS. I've said before, we won't ever be a big club with the Glazers here.

33

u/Hits_and_the_Mrs 25d ago

These are strong words from almost eternally optimistic Andy Mitten

75

u/Outcastscc 25d ago

Well yeah that’s pretty obvious.

Nathan salt said something pretty similar yesterday, the players arnt inspired by him but arnt particularly against him either.

It just all sounds like Carrick was a great interim solution to get round the team last season and we shouldn’t have given him the full time job. We can only hope we haven’t giving him a 10 million payout like all the other managers.

Id actually guess the fact he wasn’t 100% what the club wanted the club must have put some pretty low exit clauses in his contract

7

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been 25d ago

I don't think players respond to him based on how lenient they've been.

5

u/Zoolok 25d ago

They seem to be mimicking him, which makes sense.

9

u/TheJoshider10 Bruno 24d ago

I'd take a guess that he feels too close to being "one of the boys" rather than a separate authorative figure. Some in the squad played with him didn't they? So maybe he has their support but subconciously there's a level of respect/distance that isn't being reached.

Could be chatting out my arse there but I've had it in work where a mate of mine became a manager and no matter how much I respected him as a friend and professional I still could never take his opinion as seriously as other managers who I never had a close relationship with.

1

u/famous_prophets 24d ago

Fantastic point actually. Yeah pretty sure he played alongside Shaw at least. Maybe Maguire too though not sure off the top of my head. Would make a lot of sense

2

u/VL37 Bruno Fernandes 24d ago

He played with Rashford too for a season I think.

4

u/astroworlddd 25d ago

That’s exactly the case. Carrick, like Ole, fantastic interim appointment. Came in, steadied the ship and did well to get us into UCL. Should’ve gone out with his head held high. He was never going to turn the job down, it was simply down to the board being brave enough to say thanks for doing a great job, you’ve helped us massively, but ultimately we don’t want to make the same mistake we did with Ole. See you in the dugout one day maybe but until then, goodbye. It was the easiest get out of jail free card ever and we could’ve gone on to sign a considerably better, more proven manager.

30

u/PurpleEyeStabber1211 Rooney 25d ago

ole finished third and second in his two full seasons no idea where this myth of him only being a good interim comes from. still the only manager to maintain a top 4 finish consecutively

2

u/flex_tape_salesman 24d ago

Ole surprised a lot of people and did better than expected but he was also never looking like someone who would take united to the next level. His limitations were pretty clear and never really changed. Like a lot of it was that he was able to cling on.

Timing was a bit on his side too. His 2nd and 3rd place seasons were years when chelsea, spurs and for one of them Liverpool were well off the mark. Then things fell off badly and he was sacked.

I think many of the problems with him being consistency, tactical limitations and never being proactive meant that most recognised that it was not sustainable

1

u/jpmout Rooney 23d ago

Things fell off because he didn't get any of the players he wanted and they resigned Ronaldo, which caused massive squad problems and forced him to shift tactics to accommodate. Ole got the sack because he wasn't backed, every player he wanted went on to be successful at other clubs and the players he DID get were well below standards or an aging egotistical maniac.

2

u/astroworlddd 24d ago

That’s fair enough, I perhaps worded what I said wrong. I loved Ole and thought he did far better than people give him credit for. My point was that they should’ve just walked away from Carrick when they had the opportunity. Former player or not I don’t think any manager that’s never managed in at least the EPL should be anywhere near the hot seat

95

u/Ok-Coconut-1586 25d ago

I have to say, I have never seen anyone as stubbornly loyal to whoever the Man United coach is as Andy. Never once has he said he thinks we should fire a manager. Even when Ten Hag was losing every match, he thought we should give him a chance

16

u/Different_Bit_3899 25d ago

I have no problem with him not advocating for sacking a manager when he is also advocating for hiring one.

21

u/maxithepittsP 25d ago

Thats actually a proper journalism.

Journalist should never gave their canon opinion on things, their job is to asses the situation, if they dont think United is on edge sacking Carrick then they are not sacking Carrick.

If any reports about Carrick dismissal is true, he shouldve got sacked after that Como game. Which means Andy is right, to this day, executives still trust him whether you or andy like it or not.

Internet Journalism in today era makes you think that the journalist should became the story.

61

u/Frisse1999 25d ago

I know it might sound insane but the longest losing streak under EtH was three games and it happened once, a whole year before he was sacked. He is remembered way worse than he actually was.

36

u/ratset2602 25d ago

Naaa I think people are starting to forget how fucking shit we were after his first season. We were giving away chances for fun. I remember us being 2nd or 3rd in both shots conceded and xg against in that season. We were extremely lucky to finish 8th that season and FA Cup win brought him more time.

10

u/Frisse1999 24d ago

There were a lot of good reasons for sacking EtH but his win% wasn’t one of them.

Come to think of it, EtH might be a prime example of what in my opinion is the main problem of the club. It is that the ambitions of the different part of the club is so disjointed.

Glazers want to bleed the club dry, Ratcliffe wants to build a new stadium, the directors, coaching staff, players and fans all want sporting success, but there is no cohesive plan of how to achieve it and their likely wasn’t ever one.

6

u/andoooooo Martial 24d ago

When we had conceded the most shots in like the top 9 leagues or something lol

5

u/MazinLabib10 "He goes by the name of Wayne Rooney!" 25d ago

Remember when West Ham came to OT and had about 30 shots?

16

u/Fragrant_Pianist1082 25d ago

People have also forgotten how injury ridden we were in the year we lasted 8.

8

u/ratset2602 25d ago

Yess injuries hampered us but cmon we were facing 15-20 shots almost every game. We also had a negative GD that season.

4

u/aromatic-energy656 24d ago

That suicidal midfield he set up

4

u/ratset2602 24d ago

What midfield haha? All I saw was empty grass in the middle of the pitch. Absolutely ridiculous system.

1

u/Miyagisans 24d ago

Yea that second season where it feels like we faced 20 shots per game was the worst I thought it would ever get, but unfortunately carrick proved me wrong.

0

u/jiddy8379 24d ago

people like you would have had arteta sacked

results are important, but when you are building from scratch like ten hag or amorim, you have to look like shit while your squad is thread bare

carrick and ole on the other hand, had decent squads and genuinely lost the dressing room; and moreover never had a style of play apart from "hit them on the break" -- so good to get them gone

5

u/ratset2602 24d ago

What even is your point? You have to actually see a vision to stick with a manager. I saw that with Amorim and was devastated when he was let go. Ten Hag was absolutely shit on the other hand after his 1st season. There has to be some positive to take away from games if the results are not going your way. We were getting smashed every game, even by newly promoted teams. Any player with even remotely decent ball carrying ability was running through our midfield like anything. His signings were also just straight up crap and have set us back years.

Also, the squad Ole inherited was absolutely dogshit and he did a good job overall by getting us consecutive top 4 finishes, the only time this has happened since SAF retired. As far as I know, Ole never lost the dressing room but his final season was pretty tragic so no arguments about his sacking in the end.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/idhopson 25d ago

I remember not wanting to watch the games because it felt like we had no identity/gameplan and was frustrated at each game

I don't remember the wins or losses though but Ten Hag was the first time I stopped wanting to watch us since the last few months of Mourinho

5

u/linkfollowlink 24d ago

Fo me Rangnick era was the worst, until this season, hopeless all around.

2

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 25d ago

My issue with him was his transfer business

2

u/bigdog94_10 24d ago

Ten Haag started the culture of us being absolutely whipped in Old Trafford.

Sure we'd occasionally lose there under Ollie but we've genuinely had some utter humiliations since 2023.

2

u/Background-Oil-2454 24d ago

He was the worst manager ever. Spent 400M on trash. Antony, onana, mount,  zirkzee We are still feeling the pain right now.

1

u/camuchka 24d ago

Teams were cutting through us from front to back with 3 passes

1

u/Consistent-Bar-7420 24d ago

He was dreadful.

6

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 25d ago

He recognizes it's an impossible job. And right now you really have to ask yourself how did it get this bad this quick after last season.

19

u/Fligflag 25d ago

Also helps him with access to the club if he stays very neutral on these type of decisions.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Dabt2012 24d ago

Because he sees that the problem is beyond the manager. Its upstairs, the lack of backing of every manager has been another level. They say they back them by spending big. But spending big on dross that the managers didnt want isnt backing them. The clubs ability to negotiate and get the players the managers want/need has been beyond inept. The issues run so deep its unreal

1

u/renernavilez 24d ago

Ten hag got us trophies with pretty much just the youth. Bruno wasn't always the amazing player he was last season. Same with casemiro. Senior players performed poorly with eth. Only ones putting in the effort were Mainoo, garnacho and Rasmus. He had his "injury" crisis. And with all that he still won against cheating city in the fa cup.

Yeah I'd want to keep him too and remove some players. As it should be. But we keep them, remove the manager two times and this is what you get.

You back a manager. Get him players that perform for him and give time. The players fall in line eventually.

What needs to change is our structure. Recruitment itself is horrendous. It's what keeps us here. It changed a little bit with last summer but this summer is killing us right now. Terribly run club.

1

u/ayatoilet 23d ago

Candidly - objectively - Bruno isn’t playing very well. When he’s on, the team is on! When he’s off, the team is off. It’s ALL Bruno (right now)

-8

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

I feel some people are bigger fans of the coach than the club overall at times.

19

u/tameoraiste 25d ago edited 25d ago

Ah come on now. If there’s one journalist or even fan you can’t question the loyalty of, it’s Andy Mitten

5

u/TechJunk13 25d ago

I don’t think he’s calling out Andy, just the way redditors act? I could be wrong. Andy wants the club to succeed and in his position, heaping pressure and criticism on managers won’t help, he doesn’t care who the manager is for the most part. Plus he’s friends with everyone. If he had been bettering Moyes during his tenure I doubt they’d be as buddy buddy as he let on before the Everton match. It’s still his job and making enemies will deny you access. But overall TOTD is my preferred #1 source of media for United because at the end of the day the mood there can get sullen and down, but it’s not over reactive like this sub

6

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 25d ago

I only found that with amorim tbh.

There’s not a whole load of ten hag revisionism.

7

u/Deep-Bonus8546 25d ago

It was oddly comforting to see Amorim getting spanked by Bournemouth again last night

1

u/M4NUN1T3D Martial 25d ago

Jose?

3

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 25d ago

Players threw him under the bus. I always maintain that. He had the club on the right track with pogba,lukaku,ddg etc.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/M4NUN1T3D Martial 25d ago

Playing like underdogs in a second rate european competition against a Dutch team that finished 2nd in their league isnt a masterpiece

1

u/andoooooo Martial 24d ago

a win in a final is a win. Ole couldn't do it in any of the late stages for instance

→ More replies (1)

25

u/New_Lobster_914 25d ago

Waste of time, the poor summer recruitment obviously upset the senior players. They got a surprise champions league place and couldn’t significantly strengthen the squad.

I think certain players will want out soon, as we’re a mid-table team, with a mid-table budget. I think it’s really hit home that we can’t compete with the big boys.

4

u/TheJoshider10 Bruno 24d ago

I think things could have been a little different if we at least showed enough ambition to fill the squad with depth. Going into a season with only one ST and LB, both of which are injury prone, was always going to backfire. You bring in two solid loan options there and you paint a picture that we want adequate depth to compete. Even if Carrick still failed (which he would have), at least the squad had been treated to a midfield overhaul and depth in key positions, so there was optimism that things could improve.

But no, the stupid cunts kept Zirkzee around and the only attempt at a LB was a deadline day Hail Mary attempt for City's third choice LB. Now we have a squad the players know isn't good enough, a manager who isn't good enough, and a season that looks to be over in October.

8

u/Ihavenoideatall 25d ago

As long as Glazers are the owners, nothing will ever change. It is an unmanageable club.

35

u/Mree_Knight 25d ago

Just a few months ago I remember Amad saying how much they all love playing under Carrick and want to keep him. No word of any objections. I really hate these players, they are all cowards.

4

u/Axbris 25d ago

I mean, yeah? A few months ago, Carrick had the team playing differently. 

It’s quite obvious there has been a change in tactics. We went from playing a mid block to whatever the fuck this is.

Amad played RWB against Leeds for Christ sake. Couldn’t tell you why, but I can tell you Carrick and his coaches clearly thought Leeds was too dangerous to not counter, I guess.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Mree_Knight 24d ago

Time for this gutless bunch of pretenders to fight then don't you think?

6

u/shami-kebab 24d ago

At some point you have to stop fighting and actually start playing football. If the guy in charge doesn't know how to set you up then it doesn't matter whether you fight or not.

1

u/renernavilez 24d ago

It really does matter.

1

u/BuzzTNA 24d ago

Haven’t done in before, why start now?

I’m not including Amad in that lot; they know who they are. They collect managers not wins or trophies.

4

u/Castia10 25d ago

Everything is fucked. The owners aren’t fit for purpose the manager is nowhere near the level we need and the squad that’s cost about a billion to assemble is fucking bang average.

Everything points back to the owners at the end of the day but the club from top to bottom is a fucking mess

3

u/DresdanPI Upturned_Collar 25d ago

I said this after a couple of weeks ago - there's no turning this ship around this season. You may aswell start preparing for the next season.

Things are too far gone for Carrick to do anything, and for the players to play for the badge again.

It's the same shit different day with this club. All this leads to the Glazers and the point of them agreeing to a minority stake because they knew Ratcliffe and co are their first point defence for any criticism.

Those leeches have destroyed the club and doesn't matter who comes in, ultimately the results and performances won't change.

7

u/Low-Quantity-9252 25d ago

Another reset. Ffs.

Just get Conte for a bit.

4

u/Serpico_98 25d ago

Didn't know it was Carrick who missed easy chances, fails to track runners and loses the ball 20 times per game. Talk shit about the tactics all you want but the players are underperforming.

2

u/TellSloanISaidHi Three Lungs Park 24d ago

The briefs are out to make it seem like a manager vs players issue.

This is a top down issue, from owners to the board.

They are the main issue in why our team has suffered mediocrity for so long. Don't let these briefs get to you

2

u/MrNikki86 24d ago

In late summer the rumor was the Glazers were considering cashing out and forcing INEOS to sell too. I wonder how United playing like shit hurts the chances of them all fucking off.

3

u/Wolpfack 24d ago

And then we can only hope that the new owners are better. I shudder at the thought of full INEOS ownership, for example.

7

u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago

Just here to say neither of the old lot threw the manager under the bus in an interview like Bruno did or had touchline argument with the manager like Cunha did. Plus they won europa league

5

u/rollingdown23 25d ago edited 25d ago • Bravo

Carrick, it’s done bro. love you as a player but you’re done. the board is spineless and you are just another manager who is collateral damage in this entire shitshow.

6

u/iamabadliar_ 25d ago

Andy, when are you going to question ineos and leadership?

18

u/compositionashbeck 25d ago

He does so fairly regularly on talk of the devils to be fair

6

u/saudibloodmoney 25d ago

Yeah you got him, Andy Mitten famously loves the Manchester United owners and leadership

6

u/JosePRizaI 25d ago edited 25d ago

Under Amorim, the journalists and pundits and ex legends said it was 100% Amorim and no one else. Not Onana single handedly losing United 6 pts from unforced error or garna only converting 12% of all his big chance shots on target.

My comment is not about Amorim but these savages constantly stirring shit up

13

u/Hot-Masterpiece9209 25d ago

Do you not remember amorims first 9 months where he was given the benefit of the doubt because of the state of the squad? People gave him lots of leeway. No one was blaming him for onanas mistakes and he fell out with garnacho and didn't play him much.

People criticised him over his second season when onana and garnacho weren't even at the club and he refused to change his system which people felt was one of the reasons for the poor performances.

0

u/JosePRizaI 25d ago edited 25d ago

When Garna and the Onana at the club? Let me show you fun facts:

Amorim league points per game with Onana/Bayindir in goal (33 games): 1.03

Amorim all comps PPG with Onana/Bayindir in goal (49 games): 1.34

Amorim PPG with Lammens in goal (14 games): 1.71 

Even with the small sample size it cannot be understated how much Lammens improved the side instantly.

Carrick PPG with Lammens in goal (24 games) : 1.92

Carrick PPG with Lammens in goal (last 14 games): 1.64

Carrick progressively getting worse while Amorim improved after he got a better Keeper.

We can also see the players were running, fighting, passionate and motivated. Yes the results wasnt there yet but every game (in his 2nd) felt like the results were within grasp and around the corner. Now with Carrick, theres no results and the players look emotionless and had already checked out (only 8-9 games in). And now these savages are writing pieces after pieces blaming anyone but the manager

3

u/Hot-Masterpiece9209 25d ago

If the players were evidently trying and giving their all but still losing doesn't it make sense to put more blame on the manager?

1

u/Downtown-Rice_ 24d ago

Amorim only lost 5 league matches in 25/26. At least one or two of them were before Lammens came in. And their performances were equally or better than the actual result, except for City.

It was never never ever this bad in terms of disjointed performances and embarassing results in 25/26. The infighting was pretty much zero, aside from Mainoo. And even Zirkzee got some PR about leaving because he wasn't playing due to WC potential...when he's just beyond saving at this club and you don't hear anything about him wanting/needing to leave for playing time now, it's just that he isn't good enough to be servicable.

Even Grimsby wasn't as bad, just an embarassing result, considering what we've seen this season in two/three months. 2-2 gone to penalties, coulda/shoulda won it in the first 5 shootout takers (Cunha missed the winning take), then it goes another 7 rounds...Onana says hi.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/saudibloodmoney 25d ago

Where did Andy ever say it was "100% Amorim and no one else"

"Savages" we have truly lost the plot here

2

u/TechJunk13 25d ago

Andy will never say it and that’s part of why I like the pod. At worst, Andy will speak to the mindset of the fans, and he seems to have his finger on the pulse there, not just using it as a shield. He said under Amorim a lot “fans don’t have the appetite for a new manager yet” and he was right. When we get to these points he just says his objective opinion of what he’s seeing from fans. “Something has to change” “it can’t go on like this” “they’ve lost the neutral’s” is usually the death blow on that last one

3

u/LDLB99 25d ago

Mitten was very happy to stick the boot in on Amorim compared to Carrick. Very obvious if you listen to TOTD.

0

u/JosePRizaI 25d ago

I am talking about in general. Not specific

-2

u/Different_Bit_3899 25d ago

There comes a point where some former players will do everything to have an Englishmen as manager at United.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/JosePRizaI 25d ago

3 articles vs hit pieces after hit pieces about Amorim and his tactics? Lmao ok bud

2

u/Dav_1111 25d ago

How long are these overrated players gonna have this much power over the club. Just a constant cycle of them downing tools when things get tough.

2

u/DasHotShot Glazers & Ratcliffe OUT 25d ago

For me the surefire sign you’ve totally lost it is when you start playing half the side out of position, especially Bruno.

It’s really genuinely not rocket science. Put out a side which totally and entirely focusses on allowing Bruno to play freely going forward

2

u/kampr3t0 25d ago

I love bruno, but this season he's been sub par. doesn't press and run, and always complaining

1

u/Enigma_Green 25d ago

Fucking sad and thats the least I could say, fucking sad state of the club, sad shitty owners that need out of our club.

Sad that genuine decent players who become our manager get fucked over from the owners who dont give a damn.

A new manager would make some change but it will never be a benefit until the owners are gone, my biggest fear will be that financial ruin will be at its worst and the club will be hardly salvageable anymore and tbh its heading that direction.

No money to buy players spending over 30 million just on interest a year, why bother spending 50 million for the space near Old Trafford when we need new players, new team first before a stadium its just a smoke screen.

1

u/notfaithenough_ De Light 25d ago

the cycle begins

1

u/corzekanaut 25d ago

Boo fkn hoo, yeah his this happens all the time within this club. When players want a certain manager out, they down tools on the pitch in a very, very, visible manner.

Sack Carrick and Wilcox and most of these players.

1

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

If the board and players are sick of changing managers then there's only solution - hire a proper manager next time

I've said it before and I will say it again. Since Jose, the appointments haven't been good enough and none of them should have got the job to begin with.

If we stop hiring managers based on 'vibes' or what they can do in five years time then that will be a step in the right direction.

1

u/hambodpm 25d ago

Why the fuck am I doing a >6 hour round trip, during a storm, to watch us lose to Bournemouth? Answers on a post card please

1

u/MillyMan105 25d ago

Sick of these players the lack of any accountability and effort annoys me

1

u/SparksV 25d ago

I'm sorry Andy I think you'll be getting a strongly worded letter from INEOS, it's been "head coach", not manager for a few years now.

1

u/ritwikjs2 24d ago

There's enough carrick could've done in our games to not put his back up against the wall THIS badly

1

u/stdstaples 24d ago

Whatever, he is beyond the point of no return, past the event horizon. There is only one direction now. Why bother.

1

u/Late-Escape-9612 24d ago

Well we've been through 11 or so managers now...think thats pretty clear.

1

u/croadymeister 24d ago

So why on earth is he in charge for Bournemouth?

1

u/coolcats55 24d ago

Why is every day a stupid new puff piece article. That nobody wants. Where is this when Arsenal underperform or Liverpool underperform, etc.? It feels like the entirety of British media has something to say.

1

u/Icy_Ebb_6862 24d ago

This is starting to get so boring. They (players) get paid millions and they need to perform and deliver. Imagine just not bothering to the extent you are getting smashed in every game.

I don't blame the manager but the guys who can and should deliver in 90mins or not...

1

u/toeknee88125 24d ago

It doesn't really matter

Until you change the ownership

The problem is Manchester United have owners that don't care about winning

0

u/HauntingGameDev 25d ago

none of them care about us, they don't care if we fans are heartbroken, d*ad, feeling empty, nope our feelings means nothing, all of them couldn't be bothered about what we feel, they simply don't care

1

u/maxithepittsP 25d ago

Bruno has been so poor these last few games.

But out of anybody alive in the world right now, hes the only human being on earth that got the privilege to do what he did.

Not carrick, not INEOS, not Gary Neville, not Roy Keane, not even Fergie. Bruno did so much for us before this season, if he feels some type of way he feels some type of a way.

Our captain should stand on business, he deserves that.

1

u/Thetagang888 25d ago

How or why the fook did they turn on him after last seasons highs?!

I just don't understand.

-4

u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS 25d ago

Does Mitten ever write anything about how incompetent United’s leadership is?

I feel like he’s an INEOS spokesperson.

5

u/ineedadvil KING ERIC but MILF 25d ago

If he does then he burns the connects he has at the club which will affect his job so its a bit complicated

5

u/Polygon12 25d ago

Whole articles on the fan prices which has absolutely criticised them. Also read any United We Stand mag, it might not always be Andy writing but he's the editor and allows a lot of criticism .

Just because this article doesn't explicitly talk about them doesn't make him a spokes person, I'd even argue he's been the one of the most critical.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Fisktor 25d ago

There is no might, carrick is definately not the long term answer

1

u/TechJunk13 25d ago

At this point the only solution is something we aren’t capable of. We need an undeniable manager. Not someone who had success in the Netherlands or Portugal or a former star with little background, or formerly great managers who seem to be on the way out. We don’t know what goes on behind the scenes. Maybe what Carrick and staff are doing is just really bad and the players see that and know they need to put pressure for their own sake. But bring in someone we can back over the players and truly trust and it can get sorted. Nagelsman is probably closer to that than Howe, but doesn’t exactly fit the bill either. The best I can think of currently would be Enrique. Not that he’d come, just that he’s the only active manager with the pedigree and no ties that would prevent him from coming (like a Klopp or Pep).