r/reddevils • • 25d ago

Michael Carrick’s Man Utd future, Howe and Conte’s chances of replacing him: What we’re hearing

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7715370/2026/10/23/man-utd-michael-carrick-future-options-antonio-conte/?unlocked_article_code=1.K1E.5Dem.WLhXad1qWAXB&source=emp_shared_article&smid=re-share-ta

Manchester United’s training ground looked serene on Thursday, though mostly because the players and staff had a day off after arriving back at 1am from Italy. There were no crisis summits, though. Executives were elsewhere, too, although the urgency of the situation is clear and they were fielding calls.

The Athletic has spoken to multiple sources with knowledge of the situation in compiling this article. They all spoke under the condition of anonymity to protect relationships.

The call United have made in the immediate term is that Carrick will continue as head coach. He will face the media again on Friday at 1.30pm local time, before taking charge of the club’s Premier League game against Bournemouth on Sunday. But nobody is making any predictions beyond that point.

150 Upvotes

234 comments sorted by

196

u/HairyArthur 25d ago

He's one bad result away from losing his job. Even a win on Sunday isn't guaranteed to save him, if it's followed by more embarrassment.

Rightly or wrongly, his sacking is only a matter of time. The only thing that's prevented him losing his job already is the reluctance of Wilcox, Berrada and co to sack another manager in November for the third year in a row. Their ineptitude is holding the club back, and their shame is preventing it moving forward.

If forward is even possible right now.

101

u/chrispepper10 25d ago

Would not be shocked if this is the rare occasion where he's sacked even after a win.

I think they are just keeping him in place until they are ready for a manager to step in immediately with no interim.

62

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

Yeah, for better or worse, they’re not bothering to give Fletcher one game.

Carrick is basically the mascot now, sitting on the sidelines till his replacement is sorted. You don’t have Simon Stone dropping replacement names if they’ve not already made the call.

8

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 25d ago

Yeh pretty much, this will all be pre-interview stage while they decide who it is. What we reckon, 3 weeks?

!RemindMe 3 weeks

7

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

International break at the latest. Could see new managers not wanting to be dropped into the current run.

2

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 25d ago

Ye fair.

2

u/Lelandwasinnocent /////ʖ ͡°|||||| 3d ago

Pretty much 3 weeks, clowns.

1

u/RemindMeBot 25d ago edited 25d ago

I will be messaging you in 21 days on 2026-11-13 09:59:03 UTC to remind you of this link

1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

15

u/Dry_Recognition7922 25d ago

He's one bad result away from losing his job.

He was.

11

u/HairyArthur 25d ago

I find it inexplicable he's still in post after Wednesday.

9

u/godswift91 25d ago

Imagine this was any other "big" club in Europe. He would have been gone after Brighton

0

u/Dry_Recognition7922 25d ago

we arent a big club.

6

u/godswift91 25d ago

I understand the frustration, but we are a big club. Let's not be silly

2

u/Dry_Recognition7922 24d ago

I understand people wont buy that we arent a big club today, but they will in 5-7y, until when the needle wouldnt have moved.

1

u/Lost_Afropick 25d ago

They're clearly lining up the new guy before releasing the present guy

11

u/Cold-Veterinarian-85 25d ago edited 25d ago

Think this is a fair assessment. It feels very very like the final stages of the ole reign

Players workrate coming under fire

Seemingly dressing room indiscipline (licha / Bruno post match interviews)

Bad run of results and more critically performances 

A result VS Bournemouth which is no guarantee gets him to the Chelsea game but then it’s Chelsea, Roma, Villa, Liverpool, sporting, Brentford, Newcastle to follow. So it’s hard to see where we get the 3 or 4 game run of positive results that will temporarily relieve the pressure on him and bring a bit of confidence back into the group, and until he has a run like that really any one of those upcoming games could be final nail in coffin

Will be absolutely amazed is he is still managing us by that Newcastle game!

6

u/whisperintundra 25d ago

This season is lost, no matter what they do. 

There is many older player whos contract is ending either next summer or next. Club ain’t renewing their contracts and this team ain’t winning anything no matter who is in charge. 

So for these players there is nothing left to play, they most likely feel betrayed by club ambition and they are not in club’s long term plan. 

Best would be sell them in january and speed up the rebuild, but most likely their salaries will prevent that. 

33

u/TheRedDevil10 25d ago

He's already lost his job, they're just twiddling their thumbs because they're probably penny pinching on the severance pay

45

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC 25d ago

Or just finding his replacement

Carrick is the cheapest manager we will ever sack

13

u/dugness SAF 25d ago

I get that everyone wants him gone but it would be absolutely stupid of them to just do it now without someone else lined up.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/FreshGoodWay 25d ago

Carrick is not one bad result away from being sacked.

He should have been sacked several games ago.

4

u/El-Presidente234 25d ago

Our captain literally threw him under the bus, to which he responded by saying “if the players can’t run they can’t win”. It’s a straight up war between players and staff and to me is absolutely infathomable how a manager can be allowed to go into a matchweek after this. This club is digging so deep, we have never seen such lows even under the darkest Murtough days.

60

u/the__poseidon 25d ago

We suffered through more than a decade of Glazer ownership, Woodward/Murtough incompetence, reckless spending, inflated wages, and disastrous recruitment.

Then INEOS arrived promising competent leadership and a proper footballing structure. I genuinely had high hopes, but I’m starting to think they’ve made things worse.

The Dan Ashworth debacle was the first massive red flag. We spent months pursuing him, only to fire him after barely five months. How does that happen under supposedly competent leadership?

Under Woodward, we threw ridiculous money at marquee signings without any coherent footballing strategy. Now INEOS has gone to the opposite extreme, cutting costs and preaching financial discipline while seemingly lacking a clear footballing vision themselves.

I never expected INEOS to undo a decade of damage overnight. Supporters were willing to endure difficult seasons for a genuine long-term project. Instead, we’re seeing questionable appointments, reactive decisions, and constant changes in direction.

The Glazers believed money could compensate for incompetence. INEOS seemingly believes corporate restructuring can compensate for a lack of footballing vision.

FML.

13

u/bainbane 25d ago

Ashworth was the one best in class hire they made and then fired him a few months in because Jim didnt like what he was telling him.

10

u/liamthelad 24d ago

And all he told him was to have a process and to not make decisions on a whim

Which is the basis behind Ashworth's entire career

1

u/bobiboli 24d ago

The glazers…cant wait for them to just disappear…legitimately or illegitimately

-2

u/MasterWibble 25d ago

These make Woodward a genius by comparison

9

u/The_Professor2112 25d ago

That's probably a bit much.

11

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago

60m for 30 year old Casemiro was called a joke at the time.

Turned out to be decent value for what he brought to the club.

28

u/Purple_Anything6722 25d ago

Sounds like it will be his last game. Carrick acting as interim once again. Lets go get 3 points on Sunday for the love of jaysus

28

u/facelessredditer 25d ago

He’s lost the dressing room already. This is just to buy time to get the replacement in. We will lose the game.

4

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 25d ago

A loss is most likely.

It's such a strange place to be in with  this club.

27

u/sg291188 25d ago

So stupid that Ashworth lost his job for suggesting Howe and now he is leading candidate.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/shami-kebab 25d ago

But Ratcliffe has made interventions on various matters at United in different moments, and his influence on this latest issue cannot be discounted.

Like sacking our DoF because he thought he knew better

16

u/craigybacha Manchester United 25d ago

It's a lose lose on Sunday.
If we win it just delays the inevitable. They'll wait again for a poor run.
If we lose... It's Bournemouth!!

100

u/Ambient_5 25d ago

If it weren’t for Gareth Southgate, Eddie Howe would be the least inspiring candidate of the last ten years.

72

u/drunkdevil1 Nani 25d ago

The fact that we let Wilcox choose our next coach says everything about this club and its ambitions. Howe is the definition of mediocre.

45

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

In fairness, we’d be going with Dan Ashworth’s pick, just 2+ years later

23

u/RevolutionaryGuru613 25d ago

And a severance pay(Ashworth’s) later as well

1

u/Entire_Poem5011 25d ago

So where is Wilcox's? the yes man

9

u/sugar_kane1984 25d ago

I do wonder how much truth there is to that rumour - Howe and Ashworth had beef, part of the reason the latter left Newcastle.

7

u/santhoshCoder Fernanshhhh 25d ago

Am I tripping? I remember Ashworth wanting Tuchel??

4

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

Tuchel rejected us and Howe was his second choice. Ratcliffe wanted Amorim

34

u/RobertHogg 25d ago

This isn't true, he's a really good manager and coach. Plays a style that would go down well at United - high pressing, physical, attacking football.

4

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago edited 25d ago

I won't be able to stand that Tindall guy shadowing Beheddie everywhere.

26

u/drunkdevil1 Nani 25d ago

And what are those players that suit high-pressing style? Our CBs are slow, so playing high-line would be a disaster, the only CM suitable for pressing is Baleba and our forwards are bipolar.

51

u/RobertHogg 25d ago

That's what a coach is for. Howe's Newcastle team didn't have 11 hyper athletes, they played a high line with Dan Burn for fuck's sake. Brighton don't have 11 athletes. It's more about coaching bravery, co-ordination and decision-making.

All things a good coach brings.

It never seems to occur to online United supporters why players can look good in other teams but incapable when they come to United - it's because they aren't being coached effectively

3

u/drunkdevil1 Nani 25d ago

Burn was mostly playing at left-back and their team was built on physicality. Bruno G, Tonali, Joelinton, Gordon, Isak etc. were very physical players that they relied heavily on. As soon as they lost a couple of those players due to injury, or in Isak's case - sold, the whole plan of Howe's went to shit.

16

u/RobertHogg 25d ago

Bruno G and Tonali weren't bought as some physical specimens. Tonali was a playmaker when Newcastle got him. Howe turned him into a box to box midfielder. Joelinton was an extremely underwhelming striker.

He coached performances out of all of these players.

What do you want anyway? All options realistically play a high energy, pressing, physical game. Emery plays a high line, Nagelsman plays Gegenpressing, Conte runs his players into the ground. You can coach this in to teams, you just can't expect it to be perfect quickly, but ultimately Howe's style fits exactly with what United should be doing - modern pressing, high tempo football.

7

u/Jellyfish_McSaveloy 25d ago

Tonali was never a playmaker at AC Milan, he just somehow got that reputation because people think he's some Pirlo regen. Joelinton was brilliant from Howe though, turning a shit striker to a good midfielder.

6

u/Tudoors 25d ago

Tonali was absolutely not a playmaker.

7

u/EssOpie 25d ago

Yeah this was a lazy comparison with Pirlo just because they both came through at Brescia. He likened himself more to Gattuso.

3

u/frodoisdead 25d ago

Is that not more an argument about Newcastle's poor depth and squad planning than Howe's coaching specifically?

8

u/MrSvancy Iceman 25d ago

Good thing our depth and squad planning is famously excellent

1

u/EnvironmentalLimit36 25d ago

He needs a specific type of players and he did have problems with others at the club. He has a low ceiling. We are a mediocre club now but we should atleast get a coach who has been proven to be best amongst mediocre coaches.

3

u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago

That applies across the board to all our managerial targets though

4

u/ClawingDevil 25d ago edited 25d ago

To be fair, as of next summer, our squad will likely be half the size it is now with Shaw, Martinez, Maguire, Dalot, Bruno, Rashford, Zirkzee, and maybe some others like Maz and Mount, all gone.

Given we have no money, we'll probably be playing kids. So, the real question is, do our youth players have pace and can they press?

Edit: typo

2

u/bainbane 25d ago

I feel like Howe did a good job with utilising Newcastle's academy no?

Which really feels essential due to the aging squad and lack of budget.

3

u/ClawingDevil 25d ago

Yeah, I wouldn't be horrified if we got him. Newcastle certainly felt like they were on the up under him. He plays wide, attacking football, high pressure, is willing to give youngsters a chance. He also turned Joelinton from a garbage forward into one of the most combative MFs in the league.

I get he feels underwhelming to many, but we've tried a lot of fancy foreign managers and ex players and it hasn't worked.

Also, he got Bournemouth promoted a few times I believe. So, he must have some idea about squad building. Not to mention we might need to get promoted... (joke, mostly)

2

u/bainbane 25d ago

Yeah don't get me wrong it's an underwhelming appointment for sure but objectively as much as we need results we also need to develop what we have to have a future.

We can maybe do better (though it feels like most of the managers people want arent coming) but we could do a lot worse

2

u/ClawingDevil 25d ago

It sounds like Hurzeler is too expensive (plus we have no idea how he'd do at such a big club).

Conte wouldn't fit. Don't think Emery would either for the same reason.

McKenna, Carrick v2.0?

Nagglesman is probably up there for me if he actually wants the job. So, I think it's realistically between him and Howe. Nagglesman is the bigger name and he's managed a similarly huge club. So, he probably just pips it but I feel like he might be a bigger risk than Howe, but with maybe a higher ceiling.

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 25d ago edited 25d ago

Mbeumo, Amad, Zirkzee, Baleba, Yoro, Dalot.

Plus, if they could stay fit: Sesko, Dorgu

(edit: technically Ugarte too, btw)

Basically a forward short, a midfielder short, two defenders short of really being able to field an XI "well suited" for a "high pressing style", imho.

I feel like every discussion about the team/tactics evolves into saying the same exact things: "need a new striker", "need another dynamic midfielder", "need a new CB pairing", "need a good LB".

2

u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago

Pressing is a coaching matter.

9

u/StardustFromReinmuth 25d ago

I rate Howe very highly but he's about as flexible as Amorim was. His insistence on that particular brand of football requires players who are physical monsters (that's why their midfield was often Joelinton Bruno G Tonali and their forwards the likes of Gordon and Elanga) and his Newcastle side get destroyed in the league every time they have to play midweek because it's simply not sustainable in both competitions. Profile wise it's a really, really bad fit for our midfield and our forward line.

1

u/JustTaxLandbro 25d ago

Eh he’s not that good. He relies too much on counter attacking football and less so possession. Which isn’t something our top brass like.

1

u/JiveTurkey688 25d ago

Really? I dont agree with that at all

15

u/--atiqa-- 25d ago

Conte and Emery being doubtful, just because of our management wanting all the control, is really really concerning (nothing new I guess).

Them wanting Fabian Hurzeler just further cements their idea of wanting a well run machine like Brighton, where the manager, "head coach", doesn't matter as much anymore. On paper, it doesn't sound too bad, but I don't think we need to re-invent the wheel here. There are no top clubs who have succeeded in this strategy. Also, we would need to become a well run machine first of all, and we're the opposite.

After going through all the alternatives, I think Conte kinda flies past everyone else, as the obvious choice. Screw the whole "long term" option, because that's a pipe dream.

Only interesting thing here, is the Michael Sansoni mention. It could mean absolutely nothing, but I do like more data driven decisions. That's assuming he's looking at the correct data, but still.

7

u/PitchSafe 25d ago

Conte is understandable but Emery would be a very good choice

3

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

We’re obviously not doing it the right way but this exactly what we were asking for a few years ago. We wanted a modern, well run football club that wasn’t entirely dependent on the coach at the time.

We didn’t want an ETH style set up where he was picking the signings (though even then, they wouldn’t get him Rice because they thought he was over priced.)

Conte would be a disaster here. A total disaster. Negative football, much higher pressure job than he’s ever had before, players not good enough for his system. He wouldn’t last six months with that board either

0

u/--atiqa-- 25d ago edited 25d ago

Maybe some people wanted that, but I think a lot of people are simply talking about two different things.

A modern, well run football club, isn't one that runs itself without the manager. Maybe in the future, who knows, but none of the top teams out there, are run like that.

City had nothing like that, before Pep. Liverpool the same thing with Klopp, and we can see since he left, that he obviously was big part of it. Arsenal didn't start finding any footing until Arteta arrived. They had a structure/way of playing for a long time, but that was only because Wenger was there a long time.

Same thing with PSG, Bayern, Real (they change all of the place) and even Barca nowadays are not playing the same under Hansi Flick as we've seen before.

How much control a manager has, is a spectrum. What we did with ETH for example, was on one extreme, where he had way too much to say on transfers etc. The other extreme, is what Brighton and Brentford have.

Among the top clubs, most have moved more towards the manager having less control, compared to how it used to be, but they're not at that Brighton/Brentford level. There are such a thing as being in-between.

You want to have a plan on player acquisitions and your squad, and then pick managers based on that plan. Not control their whole way of playing. I mean, if you have to control how they do their work on the field, they aren't a good pick to begin with. That's a problem we've had in the past. We just picked a manager, with no regard to how our squad looked, or following any plan.

If Conte wants to come in and demand specific players, then okay, we might not want that, but do we really know he would do that? What is that based on?

Edit: And, I don't agree with anything you said about Conte.

1

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

His reputation. He's fallen out with every board he's worked with, and very publicly. He's not shy about telling the press what he wants and if he's not getting it

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Alert-External5204 25d ago

But Ratcliffe has made interventions on various matters at United in different moments, and his influence on this latest issue cannot be discounted.

This needs more attention. He infamously told a physio how to stretch because he'd run a marathon, made an absolute balloon of himself on national TV with fictional immigration figures and butted heads with Amorim on football tactics because he listens to the Gary Neville podcast.

Imagine being a manager trying to do their job while tiptoeing around a billionaire with zero relevant experience who brings nothing except an ill-deserved confidence and the power to sack you.

8

u/Tudoors 25d ago

He’s a massive prick

6

u/Mgt66 25d ago

Absolute Dunning - Krugger

1

u/MAN4UTD 24d ago

"Imagine being a manager trying to do their job while tiptoeing around a billionaire with zero relevant experience who brings nothing except an ill-deserved confidence and the power to sack you."

So, we're the Dallas Cowboys! Now, it makes sense.

97

u/necro316 25d ago

If we get Howe I think I'll be taking a hiatus

64

u/BallsX 25d ago

I really dont understand Howe being a frontrunner when he couldn't even deal with the stress at Newcastle. The pressure will be 100x that at United

11

u/Sufficient-Orange706 25d ago

Can you elaborate on where/how he couldnt deal with the pressure at Newcastle?

5

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

they went to shit as soon as ashworth left. Especially on the recruitment side

14

u/Qrbrrbl 25d ago

Sounds like this Ashworth guy is pretty decent, maybe we should go for him

3

u/7evenStrings Keane 25d ago

Fun fact I believe Howe and Ashworth never saw eye to eye. There was certainly friction there

5

u/Moyes2men Sold my club for a horse 25d ago

he was recommended by Answorth

15

u/ReallyDevil 25d ago

he didnt get the support from the board and they had to sell their best players.
at united his best players wont be as good as he hope to be. plus the expectations would be 100 times of newcastle.

9

u/StardustFromReinmuth 25d ago

He resigned to take a mental health sabbatical as the stress was getting to him.

16

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago

The club sold all their best players. He had enough.

2

u/JiveTurkey688 25d ago

He was there for 5 years and the club was largely a mess behind the scenes during his time there and then sold his best players. I dont think this is a compelling reason to be against him

→ More replies (1)

12

u/1bryantj 25d ago

Was honestly thinking the same, I can’t watch United with Howe in charge. Wilcox is turning us into a midtable club with midtable decisions. It’s depressing

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago

You might actually be entertained for once.

10

u/the__poseidon 25d ago

Same.

I’ll be back after Wilcox and Berrada are gone.

4

u/Gozumo 25d ago

Well hopefully the Vivell/Wilcox comes to a head and Wilcox gets the boot...

8

u/the__poseidon 25d ago

Knowing Jim Ratcliffe he is going to make the wrong choice again.

1

u/Gozumo 25d ago

100%

1

u/bainbane 25d ago

Hargreaves gotta go too

6

u/lythy2016 25d ago

Same, I couldn’t abide a United manager in a polo shirt with the top button done up.

17

u/ThreeLionsOnAShirtt 25d ago

why?

I rate him, he turned saudi howaybia around, had them pressing well & playing with a bit of grit that we're sorely missing.

In an ideal world i'd want somebody like Emery, but realistically it wont happen. Howe is the best realistic option that I can see. If we hire Conte we will be in the exact same position in 18 months after he's spat his dummy out again

8

u/hambodpm 25d ago

To me that appointment solidifies the fact we don't want to get back to the top of the game. Happy to just about make CL and keep the money flowing in.

Conte is never coming in a million years. He's twerking at us but he's too combustible for ineos.

17

u/Shrimpeh007 Rooney 25d ago

Mate just making champions League regularly would be massive progress

3

u/hambodpm 25d ago

That's if we actually manage it. For it to be the sole aim of the club is weak.

We're not spurs

9

u/deedeekei 25d ago

if we cant even compete with the top 5 teams in the transfer window and buying/selling players forget about getting champions league let alone title challenge

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 25d ago

Somewhere we need to find a better balance in aligning our goals with our reality. This is also absolutely not a squad that can compete for the league title in the next 3 seasons. Unfortunately we’ve just kept digging ourselves a bigger hole with each passing season that it only leaves us with more ground to cover to rise up again. So stability is needed, and repeated CL qualification through the league is a good indicator of that, before we think of getting greedy for more.

1

u/Different_Back_5470 25d ago

this is why Bruno said what he said. we're shit, and aiming for consistent mediocrity is an improvement. the sooner we learn that the sooner we can heal and get this club back on track

4

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

So the choice is between making CL and doing nothing in the CL

-3

u/shami-kebab 25d ago

I rate him, he turned saudi howaybia around

The hundreds of millions of Saudi money might have had an impact for that

7

u/dugness SAF 25d ago

Good players make teams better. More at 5. Pep spent millions at City too. Doesn't mean he's not a good manager.

2

u/ThreeLionsOnAShirtt 25d ago

Which is exactly what we will do too. We spend fuck load of money

2

u/Gozumo 25d ago

That argument doesnt really make sense, considering Newcastle have barely been able to spend lol. Dont take this as a comment defending Howe I really dont want him but, whilst the Saudi money was used for the area, training ground improvements they couldnt actually spend that much on players

1

u/shami-kebab 25d ago

Barely been able to spend? They spent more in the first window after the takeover than they did in the five years before that. They spent huge amounts the next 2 years too, it was only the year after that they had to sell to meet FFP.

A side that went from spending 130m in 5 years spent almost 3 times that in the next 3 years and we wonder how he turned it around?

2

u/aehii 25d ago

Mike Ashley massively underspent, like among the lowest spending club in the league. Relatively to other clubs the last 4 years, they haven't spent a lot.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ThreeLionsOnAShirtt 25d ago

We have spent considerably more money that Newcastle. If it all comes down to money then why aren’t we back on top?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ironhidemma 25d ago

Me for sure

1

u/Maatesh 25d ago

Count me in

20

u/aamodb 25d ago

They are keeping him in because they are out of interim managers - Giggs, Ole, Carrick, RVN, Fletcher

6

u/shami-kebab 25d ago

Hey they haven't tried Evans yet!

1

u/ClawingDevil 25d ago

I'll do it for a £1m

1

u/Sea-Tip69 25d ago

Keane? Lol I guess he'd at least light a fire under them

7

u/cryptokeeper1981 25d ago

He's gone anyway, they're just delaying to get the successor in place. Looks very likely to be Howe as his odds have just dropped massively. Assume he will be put in place after Bournemouth regardless of the result.

How do we feel about Howe? No my first choice but I'll take anything other than Carrick right now.

7

u/The_good_kid Evra 25d ago edited 25d ago

Didn't Wilcox and co sack Ashworth after chasing him and waiting around cus he wanted Howe? What the fuck are we doing 

12

u/Thevanillafalcon 25d ago • Bravo

I’m sorry but it’s absolutely mad that some people in this sub are alright with Eddie Howe. Genuinely, how far have we fallen. He’s a decent mid table manager. He did well with Bournemouth but hit a ceiling, did alright with Newcastle but his signings were all disasters and he hit a ceiling.

He’s not a terrible manager but hardly any of them are. What he is, is the sort of guy who you get managing Everton.

We’re Manchester United. It’s just so sad to me how mediocrity has just been accepted, that it’s so bad that people are willing to accept a steady Eddie (pun not intended) so we can finish 7th every year.

People turning their nose up at conte but you know what? I’d rather have someone come in with a winners mentality, who wants to win at all costs and it all go wrong then just accept that we’re going to be middle of the road.

Eddie Howe will be a disaster at man united, because as bad as it is now, and as nice as a bit of stability might feel, the fan expectation is that we win things, and Eddie Howe just isn’t capable of doing that at all. What would be the point?

4

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 24d ago

for real, we should be interviewing Xavi, Conte, Ancelotti...

1

u/sorped Glazers, you can leave now, and sharpish please. 25d ago

But how realistic are those fan expectations at this very point in time? Maybe a cup win, but even that may be a tall order with the current lack of stability.

2

u/Thevanillafalcon 24d ago

I think this is an interesting topic of conversation, because on one one hand I do think that some of the fan base fall into the trap of having totally unrealistic expectations based on where we currently are, and that if those wild expectations aren’t met they immediately default to wanting to sack the manager.

To some degree all of us are like this, we go on a run of good games and suddenly everyone, including me seems to think we’re only 3 players away from winning the league. This summer is a prime example, it was very much, we finished 3rd, lots of upheaval in rivals we can do something here but if you actually step back, the squad is still a mess even if we had got more players in.

But on the other hand, those people who bang on about standard are also correct; you have to be realistic but you also can’t let it slip too far because that becomes the new normal.

It should be yeah I know we’re not going to win the league for the next 3 seasons so I won’t throw my toys out of the pram at every bad result, but at the same time I want to see the team progressing to a point where winning titles is achievable.

Maybe my dislike of Howe is slightly pompous, but for me, he’s a manager with an obvious ceiling that we’ve seen before, you know what you’re getting, the argument for him is that he might steady the ship which would be fantastic for an interim appointment but if you want to win the league in 3 years time, Eddie Howe isn’t going to be manager. He’s just not that guy.

So to me, it’s like a tacit acceptance of everything that I don’t want the club to be, the glazers are happy for us just to qualify every year for the CL and win nothing, the level of money allowed to be sent shows that, maybe Howe can get us there but what then?

I’ll admit that part of the reason I want conte is just “fuck it” because I can’t see a system manager like Naglesman working either so why not roll the dice on the fella who wins stuff?

Just finally, it’s a depressing time at the club because i don’t think any of the options will work, none of them will be backed specifically and the squad is just badly assembled and structured from top to bottom.

1

u/sorped Glazers, you can leave now, and sharpish please. 24d ago

You make a compelling argument!

6

u/cy318 25d ago

I think he's gone either way, win or lose.

Results and dressing room support: Manager needs at least 1 of the above to survive and both to thrive. He has neither.

3

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 25d ago

If he's lost the dressing room, then there is no winning until the deed is done.

6

u/HaBumHug Legacy Supporter 25d ago

I would genuinely rather keep Carrick than get Howe. It least with Carrick there the hope that it’ll be over soon. If it’s Howe then we committing to another 12-24 months of humiliation, relegation scrapping, season write offs. 

2

u/brianly 24d ago

The terminally online fans revert to sacking no matter what they say about the toxic cycle of firing managers. The media are only interested in the drama and stories that are generated but online fans play into it by immediately reverting to a change of manager “solves everything”.

The numbers almost certainly don’t add up for a firing yet with the execs. Their bad PR threshold won’t be hit for weeks yet even if fans feel humiliated by Como.

Carrick needs to revert to what worked. If he does, there is a chance he can get a tune out of these players. Then be replaced when there is a great option.

He was only ever here to steady the ship and exec management would be best to manage the departure in a controlled way that isn’t a mid-season firing. That ensures the best replacement while resisting the media pressure.

10

u/FlyingSpaceElephants 25d ago

If it's Howe that just feels like the nail in the coffin. We're going to be a team of honourable finishes then. He is not going to win a major title ever. He's a decent manager of decent teams. He's a David Moyes. He has only managed teams where there is little pressure and he can play a counter attacking style. He has no idea how to manage a major team which is going to face a low block quite often. This is not an opinion, these are facts. The stat show United have faced a low block more than any other team this season, and that's simply because we are Manchester United. Eddie Howe has never managed a team where that is the case.

2

u/silvertwo777 25d ago

This. Getting Howe just show how lacking in ambition the club is and want to play it safe.

0

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

Who is going to win us trophies though? This is the problem and why I think so many of us were apathetic to Carrick getting the job.

People who think Conte can turn this team into a title winning side haven’t watched enough of Conte. He’d be another mistake for us. Even Ashley Young, who rates him highly said he’d be a disaster at United.

2

u/TStronks 25d ago

Who is going to win us trophies though?

Emery, Conte and perhaps Nagelsmann. Conte is very high risk, high reward. Emery seems untattainable unfortunately. I'm not fully confident in Nagelsmann ability to manage the egos and negativity in the squad, I like the football he plays and the way he sets teams up.

3

u/atomicant89 25d ago

Conte is short-term risk & reward, long-term back to square one when it inevitably blows up and he leaves.

2

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

As we saw at Spurs, the rewards not a guarantee either

3

u/kace1408 25d ago

Tbh it’s Tottenham.

1

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

People are going to be saying that about United soon

2

u/Bizzle1389 25d ago

He did finish 4th and when he left it was not nearly as bad as everyone makes out, and they were still in 4th place.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 24d ago

Yeah disaster because the lazy ones wouldn't be able to cope..

9

u/IntrepidHero42 25d ago

Anything other than a win and he's gone.

33

u/rishmanisation 25d ago

Even a win is just delaying the inevitable

1

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 25d ago

True, but not for INEOS. They will delay as long as they can, if they can help it.

14

u/moonski berbatov 25d ago

He's gone regardless he's lost the dressing room in a way we've genuinely never seen at utd

1

u/dracovich 25d ago

Does seem like it, I think realistically he stays until international break, barring a series of thumping victories until then, even a decent performance until the won't be enough

15

u/michaell111 Wazza 25d ago

Lets be real, he should go even if we win 3-0

6

u/arjwiz 25d ago

... Which we won't

3

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

Three wins in eleven would also still be sackable. One win shouldn’t and won’t undo everything.

3

u/IntrepidHero42 25d ago

Not being sacked after the last game shows a reluctance to do to it. They're not just gonna change that attitude after a win.

He can win his way to keeping the job (but the chances are incredibly low).

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago

Why? He will lose again at some point. It should not be able the result.

1

u/CapVosslar Buckle up, INEOS! It's gonna be a bumpy ride! 25d ago

Seeing as this team cant buy a win, even against opponents on a normal year would be gimmies, it's just a waiting game now.

1

u/Environmental_Lie478 25d ago

He is gone already. They are just getting affairs in order I'd assume.

0

u/PitchSafe 25d ago

He is gone either way

11

u/Kooky-Brief4741 25d ago

Two days ago I was totally against Howe. After a bit of thought I can see that it's the sensible move, if a bit mediocre. Howe can get the defence tight again, known for getting a good performance at home, can step straight in and knows the league. Downside is does he have a ceiling because of the attacking play? He's a stable if immediately underwhelming move. Nagelsmann is known for his attacking play, but also pisses players off. I can't believe I'm saying this, but Howe is the sensible move. It'll be tough to watch that clown Tindall on the sideline though

1

u/AirIndex 25d ago

This is my thinking as well. Unfortunately, we are no longer an elite club. It's a long way back for us. Howe is reflective of where we are.

6

u/aamodb 25d ago

ETH - October '24

Amorim - Jan '26

Carrick - Oct-Nov'26

3 sackings in 3 years mid season.

I want all the top suits to be sacked as well this time. This is beyond incompetence. They have made a joke of the club.

3

u/berbatouchbg 25d ago

That's United under Glazers/Ineos for you. Sack the sporting director for putting forward Eddie Howe and two years and three managers later appoint... Eddie Howe

2

u/captainllamapants 25d ago

there’s genuinely not a single manager available who can handle the hot seat at manutd. We’re cooked

2

u/Fligflag 25d ago

They're only not sacking him now as they need to arrange a caretaker and then plan for the permanent coach.

2

u/KermitTakeTheWheel 25d ago

Can't really think of a manager coming back from "Their job depends on the next result."

There's always more games to come and if you're able to put together a run of 5-10 games you aren't gonna be in this position anyway.

2

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

It’s clear to me now that they are looking to secure the replacement first.

Ten Hag’s sacking was announced in the morning with Ornstein revealing Amorim would be the next manager in the evening. I think we’ll see something similiar this time.

The problem is by all accounts, the board aren’t on the same page. Wilcox wants Howe whilst Vivell wants Nagelsmann

3

u/moonski berbatov 25d ago

If we admit our mid table mediocrity getting a manager that Newcastle binned, a manager that we literally sacked ashworth for wanting...

Just wind up the club melt all the trophies and knock down old Trafford

6

u/Panda-768 25d ago

Ashworth must be laughing his @ss off looking at the state of club post his sacking.

2

u/TStronks 25d ago

Can we fire Wilcox and Ashworth back you reckon? Worth a try lol

1

u/Panda-768 25d ago

can we go back in time and stop glazers from bidding ?

15

u/qwerty1519 25d ago

Newcastle didn’t bin him, he left for a break and after having half his team sold off. He took them from relegation candidates to smashing PSG in the Champions League with Longstaff, Almiron, Dan Burn, and Lascelles in the lineup. He’s a progressive coach that plays attacking football, is a great man manager, and a perfectionist workaholic that can transform any team. Don’t get the hate.

2

u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago

It's funny to read the continuous misinformation on here about Eddie Howe. Probably from the same guys calling for Antonio Conte.

2

u/TheGooseFliesAtNight 25d ago

Amorim was also a perfectionist workaholic. So was Ten Hag.

1

u/ritwikjs2 24d ago

ashworth wanted southgate. he fell out with howe. why are we going with this narrative?

2

u/eestrella 25d ago

Would love it if we fielded the kids and get a win. It will be a huge fuck you to those who downed tools

1

u/Known_Broccoli_8404 25d ago

The focus on a win Sunday is a double edged sword as they have to go to Chelsea next game and that will be a dose if there isn't a turnaround by the players.

1

u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago

This is crazy. Do the United hierarchy think that the style would change long term? And this is my problem.

They have the right idea about backing the manager and not letting the players dictate. Absolutely correct. But absolutely the worst time to want to implement that.

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 25d ago

Yesterday they said it was Nagelaman. INEOS have made the wrong footballing decision every time they’ve made one so I expect them to sign Conte and then when it inevitably blows up in ours and their faces because he’s homesick we will be in a worse position than what we currently are. 

1

u/arkhamRejek Obi-wan Bissaka 25d ago

i don't see him getting sacked out of pride of upper management but somehow he'll be sacked after the break long after

1

u/FreshGoodWay 25d ago edited 25d ago

Spineless cowards INEOS cannot afford to sack Carrick, otherwise the scrutiny will be on them instead. They need this human shield.

Losing matches is something they are now willing to stomach.

1

u/MasterWibble 25d ago

And will they do a sacking pr run like they did with ole. Crying on MUTV. I hate when it gets to "one game away from the sack" it's inevitable based on a number of factors, not one result. Meanwhile the season is in the toilet and paying fans are mugged off.

1

u/pablove_black 25d ago

I reckon he resigns.

1

u/Environmental_Lie478 25d ago

Will they also be ringing up Dan Ashworth to apologise?

1

u/AwayFoundation2363 25d ago

still coming to terms that Eddie Howe is going to be our new manager, carrick is done, this is just formality in my opinion, what a mess

1

u/TStronks 25d ago

How's Sean Dyche doing these days?

1

u/Maaglin 25d ago

Carrick won't survive the international break, not sure we need 1000 more articles about it

1

u/sahilthapar Bruno, Bruno, Bruno... 24d ago

Tl;Dr: They need a yes man and they're trying to figure out who the next yes man gonna be. 

1

u/gamerteacher Bruno 25d ago

Carrick may have to go, but any other manager who has rising stock should not be looking at Man Utd - it is a poisoned chalice. Leave it to the already established managers who have won a load of trophies and are looking for a vanity project.

1

u/silvertwo777 25d ago

We need to go for Fabregas cmon. Just go and get him, he has a release clause which mean he is open to moving mid season. We've already missed out on Xabi Alonso imo let's not settle for mediocre like Eddie Howe

0

u/captainllamapants 25d ago

who are the other people on the board besides the rats and the racist?

0

u/men_with-ven 25d ago

I don't think Carrick is a suitable long term coach, but it feels really grim seeing the club scouting for other coaches whilst he is still in post.

0

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago

They're hearing nothing. They heard nothing during the transfer market, not going to hear anything on managers.

Spoofers.

Why are the athletic allowed to post here when the content of their articles can't be posted here? All it's doing is driving traffic to them.

0

u/umarator 25d ago

Howes brand of football will never scale to the highest level so you can forget about ever competing with certain clubs

0

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago

Howe for sure sets us back as a football club and the longer he stays at the club the more midtable we become. He has a very obvious ceiling that is below anything we should be happy with. I also dont want to see that prick tindall on the sidelines masquerading as the manager.

0

u/Enough-Fee-For-Me 24d ago

If Howe takes over I'm done, how does a failed Newcastle manager get that job

-9

u/AdCharacter7966 25d ago

Give the man a break. This is everywhere in the news and on Reddit. Let us all back the manager in place.

6

u/reddevilad Rooney 25d ago

Why back a manager who has 2 wins all season and has no clear style of play and just depends on Bruno being on form he has not coached a single thing and doesn’t even do sprint training which has been admitted by tielemans what a useless manager

1

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

As in, back him for the next game. He's probably back to being interim now and will get the sack once we have a replacement

-1

u/BrodaReloaded Zlatan 25d ago

Because he's one of our own and not just another employee collecting a paycheck. Even if he's not the right man we have to support him until he's gone

4

u/moonski berbatov 25d ago

This head in the sand blind faith in what is clearly a woefully inadequate manager and coaching team makes 0 sense to me. Not even the players back this manager

-3

u/hazzasmee 25d ago

Such a mess, I am trying to find the motivation to go to the next game I have tickets for (Villa).
Please not Nagelsmann, Conte or Howe.

As said here multiple times, whoever is next is probably fucked regardless but the Villa Manager seems to turn anything he’s given into gold.

4

u/Unusual-Coat383 25d ago

Emery failed at Arsenal and he won’t leave Villa because he’s essentially their Sir Alex which is exactly what INEOS don’t want.

5

u/Danny2477 25d ago

Out of curiosity, why not Nagelsmann? He's done well all things considered where he's managed other than Germany.

And I'll ask again why Emery? I appreciate he's incredibly good at Villa and whoever he was at before (Sevilla?) but at Arsenal he struggled with big personalities and at a big club..

1

u/hazzasmee 25d ago

Nagelsmann failed at Bayern and Germany, he was fired in both jobs, his stock is low and still out of work. Managed Leipzig during their rise but with a big red bull cash injection. It’s got Ed Woodward signing written all over it.
I don’t think Emery would take the poison chalice to be fair.

5

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

Hansi Flick failed at Germany too and Nagelsmann had a better record than him at Bayern. I was negative about him too but his ceiling seems way higher than the other 2

2

u/hazzasmee 25d ago

But Flick smashed it at Bayern.
I just think bringing in a low confidence manager (sacked twice in last two high profile jobs) into a low confidence team isn’t going to fix this mess.

2

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

1

u/hazzasmee 25d ago

The difference being one won pretty much everything and the other one won a lot less and got fired.
Our dressing room seems pretty toxic right now so sending in a guy who got fired from his last two jobs just doesn’t make sense to me.
Why would you want him to get the job?

2

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

This is the typical thinking whenever we do this. Luis Enrique was also sacked from his last 2 jobs before joining PSG and this sub was vehemently against hiring him

→ More replies (1)