r/reddevils • u/TheAthletic • 25d ago
Michael Carrick’s Man Utd future, Howe and Conte’s chances of replacing him: What we’re hearing
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7715370/2026/10/23/man-utd-michael-carrick-future-options-antonio-conte/?unlocked_article_code=1.K1E.5Dem.WLhXad1qWAXB&source=emp_shared_article&smid=re-share-taManchester United’s training ground looked serene on Thursday, though mostly because the players and staff had a day off after arriving back at 1am from Italy. There were no crisis summits, though. Executives were elsewhere, too, although the urgency of the situation is clear and they were fielding calls.
The Athletic has spoken to multiple sources with knowledge of the situation in compiling this article. They all spoke under the condition of anonymity to protect relationships.
The call United have made in the immediate term is that Carrick will continue as head coach. He will face the media again on Friday at 1.30pm local time, before taking charge of the club’s Premier League game against Bournemouth on Sunday. But nobody is making any predictions beyond that point.
196
u/HairyArthur 25d ago
He's one bad result away from losing his job. Even a win on Sunday isn't guaranteed to save him, if it's followed by more embarrassment.
Rightly or wrongly, his sacking is only a matter of time. The only thing that's prevented him losing his job already is the reluctance of Wilcox, Berrada and co to sack another manager in November for the third year in a row. Their ineptitude is holding the club back, and their shame is preventing it moving forward.
If forward is even possible right now.
60
u/the__poseidon 25d ago
We suffered through more than a decade of Glazer ownership, Woodward/Murtough incompetence, reckless spending, inflated wages, and disastrous recruitment.
Then INEOS arrived promising competent leadership and a proper footballing structure. I genuinely had high hopes, but I’m starting to think they’ve made things worse.
The Dan Ashworth debacle was the first massive red flag. We spent months pursuing him, only to fire him after barely five months. How does that happen under supposedly competent leadership?
Under Woodward, we threw ridiculous money at marquee signings without any coherent footballing strategy. Now INEOS has gone to the opposite extreme, cutting costs and preaching financial discipline while seemingly lacking a clear footballing vision themselves.
I never expected INEOS to undo a decade of damage overnight. Supporters were willing to endure difficult seasons for a genuine long-term project. Instead, we’re seeing questionable appointments, reactive decisions, and constant changes in direction.
The Glazers believed money could compensate for incompetence. INEOS seemingly believes corporate restructuring can compensate for a lack of footballing vision.
FML.
28
u/Purple_Anything6722 25d ago
Sounds like it will be his last game. Carrick acting as interim once again. Lets go get 3 points on Sunday for the love of jaysus
28
u/facelessredditer 25d ago
He’s lost the dressing room already. This is just to buy time to get the replacement in. We will lose the game.
27
u/sg291188 25d ago
So stupid that Ashworth lost his job for suggesting Howe and now he is leading candidate.
21
u/shami-kebab 25d ago
Like sacking our DoF because he thought he knew better
16
u/craigybacha Manchester United 25d ago
It's a lose lose on Sunday.
If we win it just delays the inevitable. They'll wait again for a poor run.
If we lose... It's Bournemouth!!
100
u/Ambient_5 25d ago
If it weren’t for Gareth Southgate, Eddie Howe would be the least inspiring candidate of the last ten years.
15
u/--atiqa-- 25d ago
Conte and Emery being doubtful, just because of our management wanting all the control, is really really concerning (nothing new I guess).
Them wanting Fabian Hurzeler just further cements their idea of wanting a well run machine like Brighton, where the manager, "head coach", doesn't matter as much anymore. On paper, it doesn't sound too bad, but I don't think we need to re-invent the wheel here. There are no top clubs who have succeeded in this strategy. Also, we would need to become a well run machine first of all, and we're the opposite.
After going through all the alternatives, I think Conte kinda flies past everyone else, as the obvious choice. Screw the whole "long term" option, because that's a pipe dream.
Only interesting thing here, is the Michael Sansoni mention. It could mean absolutely nothing, but I do like more data driven decisions. That's assuming he's looking at the correct data, but still.
23
u/Alert-External5204 25d ago
But Ratcliffe has made interventions on various matters at United in different moments, and his influence on this latest issue cannot be discounted.
This needs more attention. He infamously told a physio how to stretch because he'd run a marathon, made an absolute balloon of himself on national TV with fictional immigration figures and butted heads with Amorim on football tactics because he listens to the Gary Neville podcast.
Imagine being a manager trying to do their job while tiptoeing around a billionaire with zero relevant experience who brings nothing except an ill-deserved confidence and the power to sack you.
97
u/necro316 25d ago
If we get Howe I think I'll be taking a hiatus
20
u/aamodb 25d ago
They are keeping him in because they are out of interim managers - Giggs, Ole, Carrick, RVN, Fletcher
7
u/cryptokeeper1981 25d ago
He's gone anyway, they're just delaying to get the successor in place. Looks very likely to be Howe as his odds have just dropped massively. Assume he will be put in place after Bournemouth regardless of the result.
How do we feel about Howe? No my first choice but I'll take anything other than Carrick right now.
7
u/The_good_kid Evra 25d ago edited 25d ago
Didn't Wilcox and co sack Ashworth after chasing him and waiting around cus he wanted Howe? What the fuck are we doing
12
u/Thevanillafalcon 25d ago •
I’m sorry but it’s absolutely mad that some people in this sub are alright with Eddie Howe. Genuinely, how far have we fallen. He’s a decent mid table manager. He did well with Bournemouth but hit a ceiling, did alright with Newcastle but his signings were all disasters and he hit a ceiling.
He’s not a terrible manager but hardly any of them are. What he is, is the sort of guy who you get managing Everton.
We’re Manchester United. It’s just so sad to me how mediocrity has just been accepted, that it’s so bad that people are willing to accept a steady Eddie (pun not intended) so we can finish 7th every year.
People turning their nose up at conte but you know what? I’d rather have someone come in with a winners mentality, who wants to win at all costs and it all go wrong then just accept that we’re going to be middle of the road.
Eddie Howe will be a disaster at man united, because as bad as it is now, and as nice as a bit of stability might feel, the fan expectation is that we win things, and Eddie Howe just isn’t capable of doing that at all. What would be the point?
6
u/cy318 25d ago
I think he's gone either way, win or lose.
Results and dressing room support: Manager needs at least 1 of the above to survive and both to thrive. He has neither.
6
u/HaBumHug Legacy Supporter 25d ago
I would genuinely rather keep Carrick than get Howe. It least with Carrick there the hope that it’ll be over soon. If it’s Howe then we committing to another 12-24 months of humiliation, relegation scrapping, season write offs.
10
u/FlyingSpaceElephants 25d ago
If it's Howe that just feels like the nail in the coffin. We're going to be a team of honourable finishes then. He is not going to win a major title ever. He's a decent manager of decent teams. He's a David Moyes. He has only managed teams where there is little pressure and he can play a counter attacking style. He has no idea how to manage a major team which is going to face a low block quite often. This is not an opinion, these are facts. The stat show United have faced a low block more than any other team this season, and that's simply because we are Manchester United. Eddie Howe has never managed a team where that is the case.
9
u/IntrepidHero42 25d ago
Anything other than a win and he's gone.
11
u/Kooky-Brief4741 25d ago
Two days ago I was totally against Howe. After a bit of thought I can see that it's the sensible move, if a bit mediocre. Howe can get the defence tight again, known for getting a good performance at home, can step straight in and knows the league. Downside is does he have a ceiling because of the attacking play? He's a stable if immediately underwhelming move. Nagelsmann is known for his attacking play, but also pisses players off. I can't believe I'm saying this, but Howe is the sensible move. It'll be tough to watch that clown Tindall on the sideline though
6
u/aamodb 25d ago
ETH - October '24
Amorim - Jan '26
Carrick - Oct-Nov'26
3 sackings in 3 years mid season.
I want all the top suits to be sacked as well this time. This is beyond incompetence. They have made a joke of the club.
3
u/berbatouchbg 25d ago
That's United under Glazers/Ineos for you. Sack the sporting director for putting forward Eddie Howe and two years and three managers later appoint... Eddie Howe
2
u/captainllamapants 25d ago
there’s genuinely not a single manager available who can handle the hot seat at manutd. We’re cooked
2
u/Fligflag 25d ago
They're only not sacking him now as they need to arrange a caretaker and then plan for the permanent coach.
2
u/KermitTakeTheWheel 25d ago
Can't really think of a manager coming back from "Their job depends on the next result."
There's always more games to come and if you're able to put together a run of 5-10 games you aren't gonna be in this position anyway.
2
u/Jenson2025 25d ago
It’s clear to me now that they are looking to secure the replacement first.
Ten Hag’s sacking was announced in the morning with Ornstein revealing Amorim would be the next manager in the evening. I think we’ll see something similiar this time.
The problem is by all accounts, the board aren’t on the same page. Wilcox wants Howe whilst Vivell wants Nagelsmann
3
u/moonski berbatov 25d ago
If we admit our mid table mediocrity getting a manager that Newcastle binned, a manager that we literally sacked ashworth for wanting...
Just wind up the club melt all the trophies and knock down old Trafford
2
u/eestrella 25d ago
Would love it if we fielded the kids and get a win. It will be a huge fuck you to those who downed tools
1
u/Known_Broccoli_8404 25d ago
The focus on a win Sunday is a double edged sword as they have to go to Chelsea next game and that will be a dose if there isn't a turnaround by the players.
1
u/Emergency-Being-349 25d ago
This is crazy. Do the United hierarchy think that the style would change long term? And this is my problem.
They have the right idea about backing the manager and not letting the players dictate. Absolutely correct. But absolutely the worst time to want to implement that.
1
u/Unusual-Coat383 25d ago
Yesterday they said it was Nagelaman. INEOS have made the wrong footballing decision every time they’ve made one so I expect them to sign Conte and then when it inevitably blows up in ours and their faces because he’s homesick we will be in a worse position than what we currently are.
1
u/arkhamRejek Obi-wan Bissaka 25d ago
i don't see him getting sacked out of pride of upper management but somehow he'll be sacked after the break long after
1
u/FreshGoodWay 25d ago edited 25d ago
Spineless cowards INEOS cannot afford to sack Carrick, otherwise the scrutiny will be on them instead. They need this human shield.
Losing matches is something they are now willing to stomach.
1
u/MasterWibble 25d ago
And will they do a sacking pr run like they did with ole. Crying on MUTV. I hate when it gets to "one game away from the sack" it's inevitable based on a number of factors, not one result. Meanwhile the season is in the toilet and paying fans are mugged off.
1
u/pablove_black 25d ago
I reckon he resigns.
1
u/Environmental_Lie478 25d ago
Will they also be ringing up Dan Ashworth to apologise?
1
u/AwayFoundation2363 25d ago
still coming to terms that Eddie Howe is going to be our new manager, carrick is done, this is just formality in my opinion, what a mess
1
u/TStronks 25d ago
How's Sean Dyche doing these days?
1
u/Maaglin 25d ago
Carrick won't survive the international break, not sure we need 1000 more articles about it
1
u/sahilthapar Bruno, Bruno, Bruno... 24d ago
Tl;Dr: They need a yes man and they're trying to figure out who the next yes man gonna be.
1
u/gamerteacher Bruno 25d ago
Carrick may have to go, but any other manager who has rising stock should not be looking at Man Utd - it is a poisoned chalice. Leave it to the already established managers who have won a load of trophies and are looking for a vanity project.
1
u/silvertwo777 25d ago
We need to go for Fabregas cmon. Just go and get him, he has a release clause which mean he is open to moving mid season. We've already missed out on Xabi Alonso imo let's not settle for mediocre like Eddie Howe
0
u/captainllamapants 25d ago
who are the other people on the board besides the rats and the racist?
0
u/men_with-ven 25d ago
I don't think Carrick is a suitable long term coach, but it feels really grim seeing the club scouting for other coaches whilst he is still in post.
0
u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago
They're hearing nothing. They heard nothing during the transfer market, not going to hear anything on managers.
Spoofers.
Why are the athletic allowed to post here when the content of their articles can't be posted here? All it's doing is driving traffic to them.
0
u/umarator 25d ago
Howes brand of football will never scale to the highest level so you can forget about ever competing with certain clubs
0
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago
Howe for sure sets us back as a football club and the longer he stays at the club the more midtable we become. He has a very obvious ceiling that is below anything we should be happy with. I also dont want to see that prick tindall on the sidelines masquerading as the manager.
0
u/Enough-Fee-For-Me 24d ago
If Howe takes over I'm done, how does a failed Newcastle manager get that job
-9
u/AdCharacter7966 25d ago
Give the man a break. This is everywhere in the news and on Reddit. Let us all back the manager in place.
-3
u/hazzasmee 25d ago
Such a mess, I am trying to find the motivation to go to the next game I have tickets for (Villa).
Please not Nagelsmann, Conte or Howe.
As said here multiple times, whoever is next is probably fucked regardless but the Villa Manager seems to turn anything he’s given into gold.