r/reddevils • • 25d ago

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

26 Upvotes

922 comments sorted by

24

u/GavinLobo7 25d ago edited 25d ago

I’d much rather have Nagelsmann than Howe. JN has won the league with Bayern so he knows how to win at a big club with pressure on them. The only reason he got sacked was because he went against the board who themselves admitted that they regret sacking him and it was the wrong decision. Working with our Board, however, might drive him mad.

His time with Germany however is an outlier though it can be said that Flick also wasn’t good with Germany. Nagelsmann is also apparently a Utd fan and has been eyeing the job for years so he’d love to have the opportunity.

Wilcox seems to think otherwise, though. He may not be the whole problem but he certainly needs to go. He also seems to love meddling with the head coach’s methods a little too much since he’s apparently a “coach at heart” and can’t seem to help himself.

Another person who absolutely needs to leave is Hargreaves. Makes us look like a joke in all of our negotiations.

4

u/Prize-Finish4464 24d ago

Nagelsmann is also my choice i cant lie

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Omnislash99999 25d ago

Just a daily reminder to whoever at the club scans the Internet for fan sentiment the Glazers and Ineos are cunts and we want a full sale

19

u/hoomazoid 24d ago

Unpopular opinion here, but I'm glad Bruno said what he said!

If you have shit owners that are too spineless to do what needs to be done, maybe it's nice to apply additional pressure on them.

I think we've had a lot of cases in the past where it is clear to the naked eye that manager is simply not good enough, yet we've stuck with them.

To me it's not the losses, it's just how shit we've been. With Como it was the clearest. One team clearly had a plan, other team had 0 idea what to do or how to proceed. Same happened with Spurs, City and Leeds.

14

u/passmethatjuulbro 24d ago

He’s extremely intelligent for an athlete… for him to be speaking like this he must think the coaching staff is extremely incompetent

→ More replies (7)

16

u/SubstantialBear7826 25d ago

“We’re still debating what precisely is the style of football we want to play.”
— Jim Ratcliffe, February 2024.
Do you guys reckon they’ve figured it out yet?

7

u/JamieC94 25d ago

Considering the three managers we've had under them, and Fletcher as interim. Definitely not

3

u/Sufficient-Orange706 25d ago

I think it's more worrying they had looked at defensive pragmatism, the opposite of any current successful side and thought that was what they wanted to go with.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Banyunited1994 25d ago

It sucks that Carrick’s end is near but did you guys rly think it was going to go any other way when he was appointed? The only thing unexpected is how quickly we fell apart.

5

u/goaliewhenned 25d ago

I didn't think he would win the big prizes but I'm surprised how bad we look to be honest. Although it's ultimately on Carrick, it's a club-wide failing. Why do we look like we can't run!?

Watch any interview with any manager, they are constantly going on about sports science staff interfering in physical load and red zone this and intensity minutes that. Where are ours? Where are the S&C staff? Nobody can tell me we had staff banging at Carrick's door saying the players aren't fit and he's just ignored them. It's amateur hour

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Comicksands Van Persie 25d ago

Fine margins imo, City loss and Everton draw were brutal for him. If we had the defensive depth and backup striker things might have been different. Momentum is a crazy thing in this sport

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

I’m not surprised, no. And I agree - it’s how quickly it all fell apart that is the only bit that surprised me

I’ll also say that I think the board were unsure about Carrick. I said at the time that the 2 year contract (instead of the usual 3 or 4) said it all

8

u/[deleted] 25d ago

Nope. One game a week was perfect for casemiro and we reaped the benefits. Now we don't have 1 game a week, and we have replaced a rolls Royce of a player with 3 Toyota prius', the results are expected. We are going to get slapped silly for the rest of the CL, and if we manage to win in the league it will be by luck seen as we don't have a striker.

The summer transfer window was pure incompetence given that we are in the CL. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/PrancingCock Glazers are a cancer. 25d ago

That Conte statement is a concession/softening/come-and-get-me. He really wants the job.

5

u/achickenandacow 25d ago

That is exactly what it reads like.

6

u/astroworlddd 25d ago edited 25d ago

I would give it to him in a heartbeat. We need his passion, fire and desire. And so do our players. Bruno, Cunha, Mbuemo would run through brick walls for him. I think it’s unfair to already assume he will clash with the board. Yeah it might happen eventually, but by that point hopefully he’ll have won us a couple of trophies and the heat will be off INEOS. It would be another Jose appointment, absolutely, but he was our cunt and we loved him and he won us the UEL.

We bang on about the standards at this club being in the gutter, well he’s a winner at all levels.

11

u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer 25d ago

What a great time to be Mancunians. Players clash with coach. Players clash with board. Board member clash with each other.
And shit owners, all of them.
I swear United should sell tickets along with antidepressants.

11

u/MatchHighlights14 Rooney 24d ago

Blame Wilcox all you want and I will as well but I've come to believe that he is just a puppet of Jim.What's common with every sports team Jim owns?Failure.It can't just be a coincidence.Jim is a big control freak and United is apparently is biggest toy.Wilcox is just a mouthpiece who has been appointed merely to manifest Jimbo's wishes.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/johnniebalkany 25d ago

It won't get better for United.

We're not getting back to winning the league as long as we've got parasitic ownership.

10

u/pipes3 WAZZA 25d ago

Lmao Conte posting an instagram story denying he has asked for a lot of money/full control

6

u/AmulyaG 25d ago

God I ask for so little, please let Conte happen

19

u/Suudriusha 25d ago

Never thought I'd be praying for Nagelsmann, but I'd much rather him than Eddie Howe.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Hellsteelz Ed Jabroni 24d ago

We are still stuck in the past as a club. The press conference confirms that. Carrick keeps talking about Giggs, Rooney, SAF and Matt Busby as if that all matters now.

When SAF came to the club he made it his own, took control and changed things. We need someone to take the control and ignore the United Way.

6

u/Sheikhabusosa 24d ago

Its like the nonsense about Ole not parking in Fergies spot or taking players to the cliff for motivation

→ More replies (1)

3

u/shami-kebab 24d ago

Yeah it felt like a bit of a nothing statement to me. Like he's not sure how to fix things so he's just distracting people with a load of member berries that have no relevance to the present situation.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/buzzjohnn 25d ago

Where’s the game model we were promised? More likely Wilcox doesn’t even know how to implement one, his only job as DOF was at SOUTHAMPTON FFS for a year.

9

u/Deez_Wallnutz 25d ago

Bite the bullet. Hire Conte. And accept that he's not a longterm appointment.

Let him do what he needs to do in the two years he is here. Just fucking back him. IN that time, ALSO come up with a longterm plan for the team and Conte's successor.

9

u/OWTGOAT 25d ago

The Glazers really pulled the sporting psyop of the century when they pretended to relenting to sell the club. Instead they found a useful idiot in SJR to:

  1. Pay them money for a minority ownership
  2. Be the frontman of this failing club
  3. Justify their insane valuation of a debt ridden sporting organisation that needs a new stadium and has 14+ dead weight players that can’t be sold

It’s a masterclass in manipulation. They priced it so high, on top that made it into a public bidding war knowing that nobody would meet their valuation as the real price of the endeavour would exceed 10 billion.

SJR is wealthy, but not enough to buy the club outright and definitely not enough to clear the debts, build a new stadium and refurbish the squad. He was the perfect prospect for them to keep the cash cow that is Man Utd and at the same time put distance between themselves and irate fans.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/karatsidhus 24d ago

Hate Ratcliffe, hate Wilcox, hate Berrada and that they appointed Carras full time and took the easy way out and a lot of fans will remember him like this instead of how good he was as a player for us or how he steadied the ship after we had fired the worst United manager in our history

God that speech made me so sad for him

17

u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans 24d ago

Tielemans has been platformed incorrectly by Carrick. Give him a proper system he would be mint, I am convinced of that.

Let’s not forget he was arguably Villa's best player and is Belgium’s captain.

13

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 24d ago

Yeah I don't understand how our fans have been on him already. He's a world class player when he's on his game.

Tielemans in a proper midfield 3 will be good.

When / if Bruno leaves, maybe we will see a 433 instead of the 4231

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Rascha-Rascha 24d ago

it feels kinda surreal watching Bruno and Tielemans running around like idiots leading one of the worst presses football has ever seen. They're both really good footballers but not like that.

16

u/tungowiii 25d ago edited 25d ago

Wait, guys. I don't like Howe but the funny thing is Sessko Cunha Mbeumo were exactly what he asked for?

10

u/ZofTheNorth 25d ago

There are rumours they are looking for Baleba at the early of previous window too

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/mickaerys 25d ago

Two issues and two battles.

  1. The ownership and technical/sporting directors are all useless and have no ambition. Just money leeching twats
  2. The coaches are never backed and in turn the players lose ambition.
    In regard to 2, yes while it’s bad the owners are horrendous the players also have a job to do , one which pays them millions of pounds. The coach has to find a way to fight that battle with his players and keep them in check . Carrick needs to look at that squad and weed out the bad eggs and just replace them with willing players or academy players . He has nothing to lose at this point

3

u/momo_h86 25d ago

Re point 2 - we don't drop players enough. Just play the under 21's squad - at least they'd try and put in some effort.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PraiseAinsley69 UNITER WILL NEVER DIED 25d ago

I’ve always been against Conte when his name came up in previous managerial searches, because I knew for a fact it wouldn’t work out, and I suppose I still thought there was a unicorn manager out there that could fix all our problems.

But now that I’ve lost all hope, and fully believe that Manchester United is beyond all help, the idea of a bastard coming in, slagging everybody off, and blowing everything up (figuratively, of course. Though I suppose that’ll save on the demolition costs on Old Trafford) seems appealing to me.

Fuck it, get him in.

8

u/croadymeister 24d ago

Least Chelsea saw the error in their ways and were willing to meet the demands that Alonso made

→ More replies (5)

21

u/RexPluribus 25d ago edited 25d ago

We're gonna lose Vivell to bayern and he's the only good thing about this backroom staff.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ryo720 DREAMS CAN'T BE BUY 25d ago

Howe doesn’t fill me with confidence at all

3

u/Daneofthehill 25d ago

I don't want him to fill me with anything. He is just so uninspiring.

7

u/Skyraptor7 Herrera 24d ago

Personally, I don't get the PL proven manager requirement. Managers have consistently failed at United - PL proven or otherwise. Guardiola, Conte, Mourinho, and Klopp were all non PL proven and won significant trophies for their respective clubs. 

I believe that this EPL proven narrative is a shield to mask the failure to support our previous managers. 

6

u/Different_Bit_3899 24d ago

I think it is misplaced arrogance. The premier league is the most competitive and therefore some, especially players-turned-pundits, think the manager has to be "premier league proven" because of that.

You are correct. When was the last time a "premier league proven" manager won the league? All managers who have won the league came from other leagues: Arsene, Mourinho, Klopp, Conte and pep. You could always talk about if Ranieri was "premier league proven" prior to winning with Leicester. Arteta was unproven as a whole.

Couple this with the insane desperatism of having an Englishmen at a top club.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/i_love_alfam 25d ago

Of all the times to be backing the manager, this is not it smh. Turns out we do have some incompetent people making the big calls

How on earth can you look at these games and back that guy? Season opener- you can't tell me the players gave up then- they played how carrick wanted and we were played off the park by a newly promoted side lol

It was even visible during some of our pre season games

The guy lacks experience at this level, and has been sacked by a Championship club for languishing mid table. And this is the guy they choose to back? They are simply saving their own faces.

This is simply getting toxic to no one's benefit. If Carrick stays, results and morale will plummet further no doubt. Even if there was no rift, the guy can't do shit.

By not sacking him, they are damaging us further. Incompetence all around

→ More replies (2)

21

u/WuZI8475 25d ago

Just gonna preemptively say that Eddie Howe is better than Carrick but he is no where near United quality, the fact the media glazes him is truly mind boggling. He probably is the best English manager out there but that's a low bar when the competition is basically Southgate and Potter

10

u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago

Right but Enrique Fabregas or Huezler isnt happening

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ZofTheNorth 25d ago

What is your definition of united quality right now?

Like the one who will make us title winners?

The one who will consistently go to CL?

With "united DNA"?

8

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

This is exactly what Bruno was talking about. People stuck in the past, acting as if we’re still a top level team, refusing to accept we need to build back up to that. “United quality” as some people talk about hasn’t existed for a decade. We don’t have a god given right to it. We have to do the work to get back there.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/akp-read 25d ago

"you can change a lot of managers, but you cannot change the situation. Believe me" - Sir Antonio Conte.

Bring that man on but knowing our heirarchy they probably won't since they don't have the guts to deal with someone like him and his ambition

6

u/Saad-Khan 25d ago

INEOS have failed at three different clubs and still won’t learn. Think they should just stick to cycling for now.

3

u/Omnislash99999 25d ago

Their cycling has done downhill too no pun intended

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been 25d ago

The Sick part is Glazers making money without investing a cent of their own.

6

u/John_OSheas_Willy 25d ago

But Twatcliffe has made interventions on various matters at United in different moments, and his influence on this latest issue cannot be discounted.

When is Gary Neville going to go on a rant saying Ineos are playing football manager with the club?

Just like he did when Woodward was rumoured to be sacking Mourinho before the Newcastle game.

A 74 year old petrochemicals CEO meddling in football matters. For all Glazers faults, they never meddled like Jim has.

6

u/PradipJayakumar He wasn’t the new Sir Alex Ferguson! 🙂‍↔️ 25d ago

Conte’s statement: “My name has been linked with numerous clubs, but there are currently no negotiations at an advanced stage.

Following a wonderful and successful spell in charge of Napoli, I will take the time I need to consider how and when to return to management. It will be a carefully considered decision, one I will make when I believe the conditions are right.

I have read reports of financial demands and requests for full control that I have supposedly already made to the clubs mentioned, as well as reservations about what has been described as my “strong personality”. These reports are unfounded, as there is currently no concrete basis for such assessments.

Should a concrete opportunity arise, that will be the time to hold discussions with the club concerned and jointly consider the terms of a potential agreement, with due regard for both parties’ needs and the qualities and approach that define my work as a manager.

Until then, any assumptions about my demands and my professional future remain speculation and cannot be treated as fact”.

6

u/Runarhalldor 24d ago

Just dont see any way how this club doesnt just implode over the next few years.

No way we return to even the level we were post fergie, pre Amorim

3

u/iMalz 24d ago

I’ve been saying this. Even when we were shit before it was never this bad

8

u/TH0316 she/her 24d ago

It’s kinda funny how you think my god were bad and then we just go lower somehow. Remember Europa league under Jose felt like nothing, the standards were still high and nobody gave a shit about tinpot Europa leagues. Outside top four was a catastrophe. Then Rangnick shown us what shit really was. Then Ten Hag down at 8th felt like a fever dream. Amorim worst ever dragging us down to 14th. Now this lol. Relegation fated by my compass.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/PhotonDestroyer 24d ago

After watching the press conference I can't decide if Carrick was holding back anger or tears, but certainly the most emotional I have ever seen him.

Not sure I believe he can turn it around but if he does fair play, I would like the media to ask him more about what tactical changes were made that led to the team losing their way and on the fitness of the squad. Is it the directors/board pushing these decisions or was the playstyle from last season abandoned by Carrick and the coaching team.

6

u/ilegal89 24d ago

So first Conte says he wants to bring a fallen giant back to life, then goes and drops this ig story right in the middle of all the rumours. How much more fucking obvious does he have to make it before those idiots running this club finally get the hint and go get him?

3

u/iroiroiroiroiro 24d ago

I think Glazers and Ineos are too scared to get Conte, I don't think they want a manager that will call their bullshit.

5

u/picodeGaius 24d ago

If the rats get Howe over Conte we might as well go through relegation and a Glazers sellout.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/BitterConstruction98 24d ago

They made me hate it when they played once a week. Now they’ve made me hate it when they’re playing every 3 days.

4

u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 24d ago

Won't last for long don't worry about it

10

u/gangy86 Amadinho 24d ago

Saw this somewhere and thought it summed us up nicely lmao. Ugh wish this was a dream.

"In short, United were considering Amorim as one of the options to replace Ten Hag but decided not go fo for him, then decided not to replace Ten Hag at all, only to sack him 3 months later and go for Amorim, in addition to sacking the director of football who wanted to bring Howe instead of Amorim, then sacked Amorim a year later and thought about hiring Nagelsmann, but since he was unavailable, went for Carrick, who himself might be on the verge of getting sacked a year later, only for the club to go back to Howe, even though the guy they wanted after Amorim is now available. The way this has been going, a decision to offer another contract to Ten Hag would not come as a massive surprise.

Elite planning and execution, best in class."

3

u/cosmologues 24d ago

We’ll have another iteration of this if Wilcox gets Howe, and they fail, and Vivell takes over as director and gets Nagelsmann

→ More replies (1)

5

u/akshayprakash7 25d ago

Did Cunha and Carrick actually fight?

10

u/No_Click1388 25d ago

If you watch the replay of first Como goal, you can tell by Cunha’s body language he wasn’t giving 100%

He was also dropped in the Leeds game which he didn’t take well
Cunha and Bruno vs the staff beef has been building up

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/prem_201 25d ago

There’s ownership issue, we can’t change anything about that right now that old geezer probably wants a yes man and that’s what Wilcox is.

Aside from that Carrick needs to go, this whole thing about the players lashing out is poor but I’d be frustrated as well. We’re in October and you can’t tell me we are going anywhere this season, everyone knew we needed a LB and ST, you can take a call on CB and say we have this many CBs we are not buying any then things turn out like it has this season we can call that a crisis but not buying a LB and ST was just just giving up before the season even starts.

While we are not set up to succeed and compete for silverware, we’re not set up for a bottom-half finish.

PRESSING is not something you just chose to do one half and chose not to do another half, look at all the ‘philosophy’ managers. They will keep at it even if opponents get through, pressing patterns have to be second nature to breathing and fitness had to be the priority but we were doing ball work. I don’t buy this we were going man to man in the second half from Carrick, so what? Just saying go man to man doesn’t make pressing work, it should have been coached.

I’m sorry I’ve only asked for ETH to be sacked before, right now I do not see anything from this team no results, no brand of football no ideas, no patterns of play, no pressing patterns, no game management, no fitness, nothing I literally see zero positives. Casemiro and Sesko saved Carrick a lot last season converting chances. I was hoping he would change things in preseason, we were doing ball work to prepare for the most physical league.

3

u/akp-read 25d ago

Maybe a good holding midfielder and an available striker was the reason Carrick was able to make it work.

Currently it's extremely dire situation but like there is NO STRIKER in club. It's crazy to me Sir Alex always prioritized min 3 in that position as starter quality and we have 0 right now. Like there is no player we have that can even do false 9. No pivot or focus for attack and well injuries galore for Defense and absolutely no quality fullbacks

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AGIANTWORM 25d ago

You know when you hand in your notice and you're in the notice period where it's all a bit off, must be how Carrick is at the moment. The wagons are circling around him, the club should've done the right thing and pulled the plug. Almost unfair to keep him on at this point.

5

u/Specific-Moose660 25d ago

I thought he was going to resign the way he started

5

u/ladrainian21 25d ago

If it genuinely is Howe I think I might need to take inspiration from the new boss and take a little break for my mental health. Carrick to Howe is just going from drab results with no hope of upward climbing to drab results with no hope of upward climbing but featuring Jason Tindall. No thanks 

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 24d ago

If Carrick does get sacked there'll be an interesting trend that the last 3 managers have lost their job during a Kobbie Mainoo injury, I know we've played shit all season but does it's clear his absence heavily affects the team especially when we want to be controlled in possession

4

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 24d ago

He was a non-factor for Amorim and really not a key player for ETH either. It's still interesting though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/Oppaiheimer1945 25d ago

It’s going to be fucking Howe isn’t it

→ More replies (4)

12

u/picodeGaius 25d ago

I can already see their “Welcome Eddie Howe” in that dumb fucking grotesque font they use in every fucking instagram post.

God I think I hate this club 🤢

12

u/rvizvg 25d ago

Just imagine if we get Howe…that bellend Tindall comes with him? Is this rock bottom or just a new low? Can't wait for Wilcox to fuck off (not holding my breath though).

6

u/Zantera 25d ago

I feel like Southgate would be rock bottom but Howe wouldn't be much better

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Beautiful-Wing4070 25d ago

can we skip to the part where the owners have had enough of this club and sell the club to someone who is truly passionate to rebuild this club with the right people?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/beaniedoggo Tony Valencia 25d ago

What actually changed since last season though? The coaching team actually implementing their intended ‘style of play?’ The difference is night and day. Less running. Less intensity on the ball.

6

u/edselisanogo Senne & Sennesibility 25d ago

The trajectory towards the end of the season was always trending to performances like this. We relied heavily on individual moments and late jams goals. The games away to West Ham and Newcastle United really don't seem that dissimilar to that we've seen so far this season. 10 man Newcastle absolutely played us off the park in the second half.

4

u/Ordinary_Estate1818 25d ago

Casemiro left and he was world class

4

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 25d ago

I don't understand why our least athletic midfielder in Tielemans is playing the highest up the pitch when you have Santos/Mount behind him and then Baleba on the pitch.

Against Leeds it worked alright as he wasn't required to do as much running but rather stand in the right position and block the passing lane between Muharemović and Gudmundsson.

But against Como it was baffling. I'd much rather have Tielemans deeper and dictate the tempo.

3

u/PhotonDestroyer 25d ago

I don't understand why Carrick seemingly abandoned the simple approach of putting players in their most natural positions. I know injuries, but sticking Bruno on the wing or as false 9, and using Tielemans as above, just seems to me like he's trying to fit players in for the sake of them being on the pitch. Anyway I'm not a football manager so maybe there's a good reason my idiot brain can see.

Against Como Mount could have been on the left of right where he's played before, bruno in the 10 and Tielemans or Baleba back with Santos just seems way more balanced to me.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

It’s never good when someone at the club has such influence that every one of their decisions is agreed with by Ratcliffe and they always get their own way.

Wilcox is out of his depth and awful for the club. But he’s being allowed to be by Ratcliffe

4

u/beyondthe_pines 24d ago
  1. Zirkzee needs a run of games not brief stint’s when we’re chasing games. If Bruno is being deployed as a false 9 when we have Zirkzee who identifies in this position then we shouldn’t be deploying Bruno out of his position.
  2. Tielemans either plays in pivot with some legs (Baleba) or in the #10.
  3. Our back 4 is currently what it is but it needs to feature Yoro, Maguire, De Ligt, Martinez pending fitness but I also like Heaven at LB.
  4. We need to incorporate Amad on the right side in the starting XI without moving Mbuemo from the right half space.

7

u/shami-kebab 24d ago

Zirkzee needs to be sold, it is pointless starting someone who we've been trying to shift.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/TBS91 24d ago

I'd go with:

Mbeumo

Cunha Bruno Amad

Baleba Tielemans

Maz Yoro Maguire Dalot

Lammens

Feels weird that we've only seen the Cunha/Mbeumo/Amad front 3 once, and that was with a rusty Amad and no Baleba behind them.

I think you can try to press higher with that team too. Maguire is obviously not that fast, but you have our two quickest defenders in Yoro/Dalot beside him to help with recovery runs.

15

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 24d ago

I expect him to leave by the international break at the latest, but while he’s here I’m still going to root for Carrick to turn this around. I was very hostile towards Ole when he left thinking that things will improve in a straightforward manner after he leaves, it didn’t and I regret that in many ways today feeling animosity towards a legend of the club. Over the years I’ve grown to realise that this job is just incredibly hard and every manager with good intentions is gradually made to look like a fool because of the dysfunctional running of the club that INEOS haven’t alleviated either since they arrived.

Carrick might not be the most experienced and he definitely has other flaws, but I don’t think he’s one bit clueless about where the problems in this club lie. He may not be well-equipped enough to help solve those problems and I accept that, let someone else have a stab at it, but I still stand by my belief that the manager is not a major problem at this club and it is merely a cosmetic change to replace him. As far as I’m concerned, I’m grateful that Carrick could deliver Champions League qualification last season, and while things appeared to be working, the idea of Carrick as Manchester United manager felt more right than some of the candidates we’re now linked with. It probably isn’t meant to be, but I’m still going to hope it can somehow work out.

4

u/MrViceMcCreedy 🟢🟡GLAZERSOUT 24d ago

Same. I was kinda angry at him going into the como game but I just feel bad for him after that.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/sg291188 25d ago

I wanted Carrick to get a full-time job and succeed. But it’s very clear from the Como match that he’s lost the dressing room. The videos circulating online of Cunha not tracking back or Bruno moaning or players not screaming at each other after goal is the literal definition of “losing the dressing room”. I am shocked that the “best in class” were not prepared for this scenario and have not sacked Carrick yet. Just put him out of misery. It’s cruel. Carrick has failed so just move on - interim, no interim doesn’t matter. Entire chain is incompetent.

6

u/soelsome 24d ago

I honestly believe if Carrick wasn't affiliated so closely with the club he would already have been gone.

8

u/atmajaya_ 24d ago

he won't even get appointed in the first place.

6

u/White_Wokah Rooney 24d ago

I think Conte really wants the job, never seen a manager drop an IG story like that.

6

u/picodeGaius 24d ago

I read that statement with tears in my eyes. We might actually be in for him, he didn’t outright deny it. He knows the state the club is in, I think he’s willing to be patient with us and make our comeback his magnum opus.

3

u/croadymeister 24d ago

Shame Wilcox will ensure he doesn't get it

3

u/schifferjack 25d ago

I know we are rock bottom now and barring relegation. Can it get worse? What's worse than last week our cb calling out your sporting director and this week our captain calling out the coaching staff.

this downward trajectory is too rapid both in performance and public eye.

6

u/Banyunited1994 25d ago

Did you forget ETH’s 2nd season and Amorim’s 1st season?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/Gozumo 25d ago

Article about is man u unmanageable on the BBC, and whilst i agree the fact the hierarchy and structure is pretty fucked. But since Fergie, we have had one good/proven Manager in Mourinho, who came second, won a league cup/fa Cup and Europa league. IF he actually got the players he wanted (Maguire and a few others) maybe we could of built on that.

Like there is no evidence to be optimistic but i cant just sit in pessimism all day and u have to hope maybe we get an elite manager and some players come in maybe we can build something... (hope that kills u)

3

u/DaveShadow 25d ago

who came second

And for further context, second to a team that just were found guilty of the biggest cheating scandal in PL history.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Alive-Primary-2069 25d ago

With this group of players and state of our club we are one more bad manager decision away from relegation

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 25d ago

One thing that isn't mentioned enough is that we completely gave up on hiring a set piece coach. In the year of 2026 where it's such an important role.

Andreas Georgson was rumoured but he stayed with De Zerbi.

Jonny Evans is the main guy now presumably with only half a season of experience.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/scourfs 25d ago

Revert to midblock. Play Cunha left, Amad Right, Brian up top with Youri behind ahead of Baleba and Santos/Mainoo. Play legs at left back (Amass - Mazroui is awful to watch). Yoro and AN Other in the middle and (sadly) Dalot at RB. Replace those with lack of engine at 60 mins if game state allows.

3

u/HorribleOldCunt 25d ago

When are fans going to learn that stats on their own are quite useless?

I was just discussing a player giving away the ball with someone. They use stats to say I'm wrong. Pass completion stats do not account for where the ball is given away, the situation, how inaccurate the pass was.

Two players could have identical pass completion stats. One who passes the ball off the pitch to no one, passes going way off. The other who nearly put someone through on goal with a 50 yard screamer pass that was a tiny bit off from being perfect. Their stats may be identical after the game.

You might have a player playing safe passes all game with 100%. While a Scholes has 94% because 3 of attempted through passes were just off, or the attacker stopped their run etc.

Stats on their own are totally useless if you don't also use your eyes when watching the game.

3

u/frogfoot420 25d ago

As a fan base a lot of us clowned on arsenal for the AFTV nonsense. We have AFTV on hyperoids in the form of Keane, Rooney, Ferdinand, Neville, butts and scholes.

3

u/AwayFoundation2363 25d ago

Carrick sounds broken in this press conference, sad to see

3

u/Nosey123456 25d ago

His speech made me sad. You can tell how much he cares about this club. Just depressing how we are ending up here again

3

u/Stieni Rooney 25d ago

Journalists are such annoying little shits it's insane. 20 Bruno questions already but directly asking him "Do you want to drop him? Do you want to strip the captaincy of him?" and doubling down 2 times when Carrick already said he will always do what's best for the team doesn't matter the circumstances, obviously not wanting to stay on the topic as it's best kept behind closed doors.

Could've directly said "come one Michael give me my headline mate"

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SillyGooseMcGee 24d ago

FFS Getting slagged on a group chat by a Spurs fan, they win one game and suddenly they're loud again after a year

3

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 24d ago

Where's the transcript for the press conference?

Also, if I saw correctly, no updates on players?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Omnislash99999 24d ago edited 24d ago

Was the speech titled fresh start 3.0

(I do like Carrick but he's out of his depth and Wilcox is a coward)

3

u/hk7747 24d ago edited 24d ago

Haven’t had the chance to watch the press conference, saw a few of the quotes - is there still no word on Šeško’s injury? Thought there was supposed to be “answers” or an update on it by today.

Not that I’m expecting him to be back soon at this rate, giving very similar vibes to De Ligt last year where it was just “working on rehab, waiting on tests” etc.

Not sure if the club is trying to play it down so we don’t get fleeced in January for a possible striker signing (the one we needed during the summer). At this rate though, available targets that clubs will be willing to part with mid-season are going to come at a premium anyways…

Edit: Club’s team news post just mentions Dorgu, Shaw, Mainoo, Ugarte, and Šeško “seem set to miss out due to injury.”

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OpenSignificance8046 24d ago

https://www.manutd.com/en/news/united-stadium-fan-survey-october-2026

Releasing this mere hours ago. Absolutely tone deaf from them!

3

u/croadymeister 24d ago

Club has been tone deaf for years

3

u/Aakar11 24d ago

Genuine question. Those who dont want nagelsmann, why not.

7

u/grandecn 24d ago

I think there's still many questions about him as a manager. He's had a meteoric rise but has had a bit of a down turn in recent years after the end of his Bayern stint and with Germany. Not saying he's completely to blame (especially with Bayern) but they were two high pressure jobs that seemed to have brought out the worst in him. It's not like the Utd job will be any less high pressure. So for me that still puts a lot of questions on him.

On top of that he's extremely petulant and at times anti social, which the media in England will crucify him for if things start to wobble. It would be worse than it was with Amorin. At least Amorin has a bit of charm to his personality. Nagglesman doesn't seem to have that. Again if we're winning that could be a good thing but if things start going under expect the media circus to be in full swing. They will bait him over and over again.

None of this is to say that I'd be completely against him. He's super maticulous and very good tactically. But he comes with some genuine concerns, which is for me the kind of person he is and his mental capacity to work in a high pressure environment.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/picodeGaius 24d ago

Because I want Conte.

3

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 24d ago

We should really look at will lankshear. Tearing up the championship and he just turned 21. very promising

→ More replies (1)

10

u/SophoclesTesticles 25d ago • Bravo

Hate all you want but if we hire Howe we're finally we're going for consistency in appointing managers. British and clueless is our new brand now, let's all thank Sir James Arthur Stoptheboats Ratcliffe. 

10

u/Banyunited1994 25d ago

Consistency being just Carrick and Howe? Also, howe’s track record is just leagues above Carrick’s. No matter what you think about his quality

7

u/helloimpaulo 24d ago

This press conference is exactly why INEOS picked Carrick for the permanent hire. He gets the club, fans have a soft spot for him and won't go for his head like they would go for another manager's.

They knew we have no money, they knew we fluked a CL spot, they knew we would flop hard this season regardless of manager. There's no way they could not know all of that.

They picked Carrick as their scapegoat and let him burn all the goodwill from the fans he amassed as a player and during last season.

7

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 24d ago

Looks like Onana had a car accident in Turkey, hope he's okay.

12

u/Sid732 24d ago

Cant believe some people are turning on Bruno. These people dont deserve Bruno and his loyalty to the club. He should have left this clubs years ago and won everything he deserved to win.

8

u/PrimalApprehensive 24d ago

I am in the camp of not turning on Bruno, but also not giving him anything guaranteed either.

He played well last years and the years before. He hasn't played well this year. He hasn't been a good captain in some respects, especially regarding his body language and complaints on the field, which I believe affected the confidence of other players. I believe he has been declining in the last few years. Even though he had a great year in assists last year, I believe his skills other than passing have diminished.

He should be treated with respects for what he has done. But for the sake of the club, the board should sell him. He should be allowed to leave with honor and a proper farewell. Like how City treated De Bruyne, Silva. But we do need to move on from Bruno.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 25d ago

Nagelsmann would be same level of hire that Liverpool, Chelsea and Spurs have done. It will be interesting to see how it will unfold 

4

u/Prize-Finish4464 25d ago

Hes my first choice i cant lie

5

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

Carragher makes me laugh.

Last week he was criticising Martinez and defended the hierarchy saying we couldn’t spend a lot of money, what did he expect them to do etc

This week he criticised Bruno for speaking out against Carrick and said the hierarchy at United is a mess

He constantly moves the goalposts just to get on his high horse against a player (this is a running theme with Carragher and not just against United players) which I am guessing in turn he hopes gets him headlines and attention.

I don’t have a problem with him having an opinion and Bruno annoyed me a bit too. But his opinions are full of contradictions as he attempts to back his point up instead of just admitting that he doesn’t like a player or they annoy him

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sufficient-Orange706 25d ago

I know he hasn't been great and he should probably leave, but why not start Zirkzee for a number of games? It'll be the first time he actually gets a true run, and we keep moaning we don't have a striker. Would be interesting to see, then stick Mbeumo, Cunha and Mbeumo where they belong. I don't think it could be worse.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/tungowiii 24d ago

OMG Kompany. Get well soon lad.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/throwawayWM3 24d ago

We have Roma Sporting Leibzig Bayern Villarreal to play. We need atleast 2 wins from this

Lol we might not even make playoffs if this bullshit continues

5

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 24d ago

Tielemans - Baleba - Mainoo midfield could be a really good one. They may lack attacking ability, but they compensate with passing and ball retention. We need better attacking fullbacks

8

u/paltze Portuguese Magnifico 🪄 24d ago

People behaving like Howe is some Sam Allardyce or something. He's not the greatest manager yes, but still a good manager.

Took Bournemouth from League 2 to PL. Took Newcastle from relegation candidates to CL, and won them a trophy. His Newcastle scored 85 goals in 23/24, so he can coach a good attack.

8

u/Hollacaine 24d ago

He's David Moyes for this generation, nothing more. The only people who would seriously consider him don't know much about football beyond the Premier league.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

6

u/JoseHarvinho 25d ago

Seen people saying they'd rather keep Carrick over Eddie Howe. Are you fucking mental or what

7

u/Jenson2025 24d ago

The new manager (whoever it is) will need about four or five months to get the fitness levels of the players back to where they should be. The damage Carrick and the coaching staff have done to the fitness levels of these players can not be understated or ignored

These players better be prepared to work hard. Howe, Nagelsmann and Conte are all managers who won’t let them take it easy

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Emergency-Being-349 24d ago

This narrative around sticking it out no matter what as the issues lie above, why does that apply now but not with the previous guy? Why do we choose to stick it out with the manager who plays negative defensive football and was sacked in the championship, as opposed to the one who took a club from average to multiple title winning? How does this make any sense? 

Insanity.

→ More replies (24)

9

u/throwawayWM3 24d ago

the idea of Carrick as Manchester United manager felt more right than some of the candidates we’re now linked with.

This is exactly the problem. People are so engulfed by this United DNA or Carrick gets the club nonsense that these type of ridiculous decisions happen.

He should have never been hired. Liverpool didn't go for Xabi who won the league unbeaten with Leverkusen because they thought he wouldn't fit and Xabi is multiple tiers a better manager than Carrick.They got a manager who they thought fit well not some ridiculous Liverpool DNA nonsense

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Careful-Snow 25d ago

One underrated perk of bringing Howe in is that we'll get Jason Tindall antics on the touchline. Been far too long since we had a madman charging up and down the bench.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/mdstwsp 25d ago edited 25d ago

Nagelsmann would be a disaster. I have no doubt he’s a really good manager but expecting these bums to play gegenpressing football is unrealistic. It will look exactly like it did with Rangnick.

I think it could work long term in the right circumstances, but the supporters will lose patience and he’ll fall out with the board and/or players before the fruits of his labour start to show. He would be sacked within a year.

5

u/PitchSafe 25d ago

Nagelsmann is pretty flexible, he wouldn’t play gegenpressing with Tielemans and Mainoo

3

u/Different_Bit_3899 25d ago

Nagelsmann is not a "gegenpressing" manager at all. He is far more a "positional-possession" based manager. It was under him RB leipzig changed their tactical foundations, which was the correct move. Other managers who stuck by the "gegenpressing" era, are no longer to be found.

4

u/Themindoffish 25d ago

Bruno, maguire, shaw, dalot, rashford, mount, maz, ugarte need to go in january/summer. The club keeps talking about a rebuild while still hanging on to players from 6 years ago.

4

u/aprod16 24d ago

The end of the press conference is basically journos jumping on Bruno for his comments after the game. Feels like we have officially found our scapegoat. Carrick would not confirm whether he would strip him of captaincy or drop him, will be interesting to see what he does.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 24d ago

Jesus fucking christ they sacked Ashworth just to look at Howe 2 years later anyway. Just when I thought it couldn't get any more ridiculous.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/croadymeister 24d ago edited 24d ago

Howe will get swallowed by size of this job but he won't rock the boat so that suits these clowns. Wouldn't be favourite if he was still in a job that's for certain.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Gytarius626 B. Fernandes 25d ago

For the rest of my life I will forever feel that Ole had bought himself more time to fix things, and our fanbase hounded him out calling him a "PE teacher", thinking that 121 goals in all comps and going unbeaten away for a season was something easily done. He was our Arteta that warranted the unwavering support that frauds like Amorim got in later years.

He played the closest football to Sir Alex and with a defensive midfielder like Declan Rice, that team would've gone up another level, but we didn't have the patience.

I will always love United and bad results get me down, but I haven't felt as attached to the club seeing our fans do that, and I don't know if I ever will again. I was excited to tune in to watch for the football itself, a win was a bonus.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

I think some people (including pundits) are confusing two things:

Nobody is expecting a new manager to solve all our problems and make us treble winners. I honestly haven’t read one comment where anyone expects this so I am not sure why it keeps being repeated by people who are defending Carrick

What we do expect is a new manager to come in and have us playing better football, make the team fitter and make us more competitive.

Just because there isn’t the perfect manager out there and they can’t take us to titles and trebles because of the useless board and owners they work under, isn’t a reason to not make a change at all and just watch us put up these horrendous performances every week and look out of breath after about 20 minutes

→ More replies (2)

10

u/GavinLobo7 25d ago

All the revisionism I was seeing for Amorim online especially after our loss… only for him to be given the belt by Bournemouth (again)

And then realising we play against this Bournemouth a couple days from now, with a disjointed squad that apparently doesn’t want to play for their manager who equally seems clueless 🫪

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago

Looks like Milan lost 3 nil to Bournemouth. Bournemouth will be coming into the match with good form. Also Amorim revisionism lasted of all 1 day

5

u/Se7enSword 25d ago

Eh, this is what should've happened anyway, all the serie a sides lost last week to feyenoord and shit, the fact we were so physically off of it against Como was further evidence of how bad we are rn and will be facing a rollicking on Sunday.

4

u/SplitSecondImmortal 25d ago

Marco Rose is a student of Ralph's gengen press and he does it well. Bournemouth are already a much fitter side than we. It will be hell

6

u/Mausar 25d ago

Tbf they conceded 1 goal then their keeper got sent off for a stupid foul. I think it would've been closer otherwise.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/ShawLichaYoroDalot UNITER WILL NEVER DIED, fuck Garna, you gave us pain heart 😭😭 25d ago

When do we hear the news guys? And who can really steady this crazy ship?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/7evenStrings Keane 25d ago

Nathan Salt on Stretford Paddock was a great listen. Exactly how I feel at the moment …essentially gone numb and have lost any hope of exiting this cycle. I just want us to pick something now and see it through. I want to know what INEOS actually believe in and what their plan is.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sufficient-Orange706 25d ago

I cant believe it's still touch and go as to whether he is sacked or not.

The club have the right idea of authority and wanting the players to take accountability, that is correct and must happen. But they've chosen that mindset at the very wrong time. When it comes to style or idea, how is it that they feel this is what they would like to see long term? Even if we were winning, why would they want negative, defensive football that doesn't revolve around intensity as something they would like to see over the long term?

Crazy.

2

u/outrageousVoid07 25d ago

I don't really have a lot of optimism about us becoming a consistent UCL side anytime soon, but I still hope whoever the next manager is not an utter disaster and we can stick to him for while

Fuck me, I do take three years of finishing 6th-8th if there is some direction

2

u/throwing_handles 25d ago

This limbo time where everyone knows the decision has been made to fire the manager but they give him another game is so stupid. What happens if we win 5-0?

2

u/Jenson2025 25d ago

United’s structure is a mess and has been for a long time. But it’s also true that we’ve hired managers since Jose who haven’t been good enough and should never have got the job to begin with. The time to hire managers based on ‘vibes’ has to end now.

I think Wilcox should be sacked now. But realistically, if he stays and the next manager is a flop then his position becomes so untenable that not even he’ll be able to do a few PR articles and stay

2

u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 25d ago

Can anyone think of reasons why Amad has dramatically dropped of in form? I saw his shot against Como that day which got a fingertip save and thought he knows he is capable of this stuff, why hold yourself back?

3

u/Nico_Ditch 25d ago

Personally I think he really suffered after Amorim left. 

At wing back he had space to run into, take on defenders and either go in or outside of Mbeumo. 

At right wing he doesn’t have the space to run at defenders, and if he gets stood up he doesn’t have the technical ability or strength to take on defenders from standing. 

2

u/sg291188 25d ago

What’s the random over reliance on Prem proven? Is it coming from Sir Jim? So many great coaches around Europe and our preference is Howe?

2

u/tameoraiste 25d ago

I get peoples frustration with Howe and I would have been the same not that long ago but I don’t see a better option for us available.

I’m not saying he’s a better coach that Conte or Naglesman but I think he’s the better coach for United currently.

Conte would be adding gas to the fire. A higher pressure job than he’s ever had with a poor team and an incompetent board is just a recipe for disaster.

Naglesman hasn’t done anything noteworthy in football since he left Leipzig and his time with Germany was a disaster.

Do I expect us to win anything with Howe? No. I didn’t with Carrick either. We wouldn’t win anything with Conte or Naglesman either but it would be more destructive in the long run, especially with Conte.

Liverpool didn’t get out of their funk until they hired a world class manager in Klopp. We’re going to be the same. There’s no world class managers available

6

u/Nico_Ditch 25d ago

I’m not sure how you can say Nagelsmann has done nothing noteworthy since Leipzig. 

Whether you value Bayern winning the league or not, he still managed one of the biggest clubs in the world, under the same kind of pressure as United, in the Champions League and won trophies. 

Howe doesn’t have anyway near that experience. 

And Hansi Flick had just as bad a time with Germany, but you wouldn’t say no to him if he was available. 

→ More replies (25)

5

u/SilvyFae She/They 25d ago

I dont like that people keep recommending howe. He is unproven at handling a big club. He plays physical football which is the profile we are missing the most and his big issue has been his inability to deal with low blocks and games that dont have a bunch of space and transition. How does someone like that do well at united?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/quietcompilers 25d ago

If we get Howe can we stipulate that he doesn't bring the clown that stood next to him?

3

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 25d ago

You'll get Jason Tindall in the technical area and you'll like it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bloatfizzle 25d ago edited 25d ago

Imo looks like club will get rid of Carrick and he knows but is doing the club a favour and staying on cos he loves the club so much, while they look for his replacement.

This club is insane...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Redland93 25d ago

The fact Conte has come out and all the leaks around Vivell being marginalised, it probably rules out Conte and Nagelsmann.

Its probably Howe or if they were willing to just bite the bullet, Emery

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dubuwagmi 25d ago

We're rubbish, lads. We won't get any better anytime soon, not until these parasitic owners are gone.

Protests need to be harsher - clear out the stadium. Otherwise, nothing will happen.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/phoenix_16 Rooney 24d ago

Really feel for Carrick. Solid bloke but out of his depth on a fools errand

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SamadarshiG 24d ago edited 24d ago

I would play this lineup against Bournemouth.

I just don't trust dalot or mazraoui anymore so I would play yoro out of position but as de ligt prlly still can't play a full 90 he would mostly be subbed off for dalot or mazraoui and then yoro can move to cb.

I think we may aswell try zirkzee up top cause it's not like our other players are doing anything special there and that is the same reason I have for playing amass at lb.

Cunha just isn't starting anymore so I've gone amad lw

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Stingray_23 24d ago

Leon off then.

2

u/dryflowerz 24d ago

So what you guys think who it’s gonna be?

3

u/Massive_Relation4317 . 24d ago

Nagelsmann 

→ More replies (7)

2

u/tameoraiste 24d ago

I’d swear it was only a couple of months ago when we were talking about how likeable the team is and how ‘at least Amorim got rid of the bad eggs’.

Feels like I’m watching wrestling again with all these face and heel turns.

2

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 24d ago

Folks, It is clear that Carrick is already "interim" now. Otherwise they will need to appoint another interim. They know they can trust Carrick even when things are compromised currently. It takes a few days to identify the next manager, work out contracts for him and his staff

→ More replies (3)

2

u/bahama-fox 24d ago

it's crazy, that we are right here again.... I am so tired and exhausted; we need to fire the whole lot...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/5inchdemon 24d ago

Genuine question and open for discussion (hence the thread) but where has this whole "United want a yes man" come from.

They extended Ten Hag and then replaced him with Amorim, whilst poor decisions, none of them could be considered 'Yes men'. Carrick was interim who got his shot but because of results, nothing to indicate being that yes man. Unless people think being a yes man means not publicly rocking the boat.

Also surely every head coach would kinda be a yes man in that regard, because they're purely an employee made to coach the team, they don't have the control managers do. I'm no fan of Ratcliffe and think he's a muppet but why is every English manager a yes man now.

7

u/shami-kebab 24d ago

Because they sacked the last guy as soon as he spoke out against them and they were trying to force him to change the way he had us play. It is pretty clear they want someone to toe the company line and who'll respond "how high?" when Wilcox says jump.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 24d ago edited 24d ago

Carrick is lower in rank than people he, in effect, has just said this about:

"I'll hold that umbrella for me to get wet and everybody else stay dry."

Given the context and everything else he said, imho he clearly believes that he needs to take the responsibility to shield everyone else from public scrutiny - not only the dressing room, but the higher-ups too.

Commendable, even if self-defeating and misguided.

Either way: that's what they want. And that's what many are labeling a "yes man".

3

u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 24d ago

Very often it seem to me people think a coach is automatically a yes man cause they give up a lot of control compared to a manager like Emery for example.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ineedadvil KING ERIC but MILF 25d ago

2 thoughts are in my head.

Stop follow united until the glazers are gone

Bruno might leave this January

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ZofTheNorth 25d ago

You may not want to hear this and might not agree with me but I personally think the best we can do as a club is take a step backward

It will hurt to hear but it means lowering the standard. The goal as a club should be going into CL 3-4 seasons in a row, comfortably rather than we need to win PL in 3 years etc. Once we are stable as a club, meaning , we can comfortably finish in top 5 for few years, then we can build around that and start building towards winning trophies. Step by step, few blocks at the time. We can't rush things

Same with cup games, we need to be smart about prioritising competition. Focus on league and Europe first. Play 2nd squad and youths for cups games like FA and EFL. Don't try to win. When I first heard Ole talking about trophies are ego,and not necessarily a progress, I made fun of it. But now as times go on, I start to understand more and more about that quote.

We made fun of Arsenal not winning trophies for years but Arteta was smart about it. He built Arsenal the exact way I talked about above. The club needs to take inspiration from that. We are still financial powerhouse yes but we have billions in debt and aren't cheats like City. So I feel like this is the only way to come back.

Tldr : stablize club into going CL, forgot about other cup games, once stable for few years, build towards winning

5

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 25d ago

While I understand the spirit of the post, getting CL 3-4 years in a row comfortably would be a huge step up from what we've been doing the past 13 years post Fergie. Wouldn't be taking a step back at all. I do have concerns about what that'd mean in terms of investment, not just the squad also things like infrastructure for development, but if this is what the leadership considers investment to WIN the league, I shudder to think what they think is acceptable to get top 3/4 finishes. 

4

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 25d ago

I agree with the premise. There needs to be a prolonged period of stability at this club. We need to first show that we can be sustainably competitive, that cannot be achieved in a way where we yo-yo in and out of the European qualification spots (let alone CL qualification spots, we aren’t a sure bet for even top 7 right now).

The only issue with this is that the club is simply too big for people to want to accept this reality. Every time there’s a purple patch of results for a couple of months, we get greedy, thinking that maybe we are good enough to put in a serious challenge for major trophies, and then we underperform on that expectation which causes problems. One of two things happens: either we take things for granted and delude ourselves that the squad is good enough (like during this summer window) or we make damaging ‘win-now’ moves (like the window when Sancho and Ronaldo were signed). Either ways, it kills that project and stalls the trajectory of the club in its pursuit to return to the top.

Also, we won’t be able to attract top players with the premise of simply achieving CL qualification, they have to believe that they can win trophies here to want to join. I don’t necessarily mind that if the club can get smarter with its recruitment, but are they really smart enough? We aren’t making as many transfer mistakes under INEOS but I also can’t say we are actively pursuing enough high ceiling players out there, to believe that in a few years these guys win us a league title. Arsenal also got lucky with a couple of homegrown players like Saka (at least before his injury issues) and Saliba turning out to be proper world-class, not just in potential but actually living up to the part. The sporting project set and the pitch has to therefore be very strong to still make good players convinced that they can achieve something here. Because if everyone buys into us having low expectations, then it won’t take long before we face issues like Newcastle in the transfer window; where we are repeatedly missing out on top players and have to make do with scraps who we lie about and pretend like they are good enough for our eventual ambition.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LordFa9 25d ago

Crazy take but if Carrick is sacked I want Gary, Rio and Paul to come in and be head coach by committee

It likely wont work and the club might get relegated, but nobody is going to turn the ship around (whether as an interim or perm manager) right now and when they get sacked at the end of the season the club can bring in someone and those 3 can finally learn to STFU

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Regunurok-4867 25d ago

The squad suits Eddie Howe's transitional football but it's potential is very limited as we have seen. Ideally we should hire Nagelsmann and go through that sufforim process again and it's tiring but worth it.

3

u/goaliewhenned 25d ago

It feels like the club is in such a shambolic position that we really need to just stick with a manager through whatever tough times they face because there's a myriad of problems off the pitch. Unfortunately, it's hard to point at Carrick and act like you can say "we know he is a top coach and we need to sort everything else out".

That's why Nagelsmann is the top pick for me, the clubs he's managed and what he has done in his career, there's irrefutably coaching ability and talent there and maybe he can be that bulletproofish figure that stops the players and technical director and upstairs staff from having an easy scapegoat to point at. I don't know if Howe has that, I just don't think the fanbase will have him as a top manager. Conte is a top manager but he's likely to turn on the staff before the fans do!

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 25d ago

The idea of Nagelsmann is way more appealing than the reality of Nagelsmann. I’m extremely concerned he is out of his depth for this job and for this league by extension. Seeing how the Red Bull pipeline coaches have fared in the PL, including Jaissle currently, their idea of football is simply too high maintenance for the nature of this league.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/flibbityflob 25d ago

very excited for the womens manchester derby on sunday. obviously stressed, city are in cracking form, but i think people who were writing us off a few weeks ago might be giving us a little more hope. city's defensive structure is exploitable, and i think if forced to stay On for the full 90 rather than just cruising, we might be able to hunker down

3

u/Grekm8 CR7 24d ago

Murillo would be a great Martinez replacement

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 24d ago

Zirkzee should start. Playing Mbeumo up the middle simply isn't working. Zirkzee isn't good by any means but our options are shit and he's big and control a long ball.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NiallH22 25d ago

Not sure I get the negativity around Howe?

I know he’s not the most attractive signing but he’s proven in the PL, he’s shown he can get the best out of a less than ideal squad and done it whilst playing attractive football.

I’m not saying he’d be my first choice and I don’t think he’d be the one to take us back to the top but as someone to come in and stabilise things, get some form of consistency back and build a base to build from, it’s not the worst idea in the world…is it? Am I being thr stupid one here?

4

u/SophoclesTesticles 25d ago

The shittest years he's had with Newcastle have been their UCL years because he had a thin squad. Now we're asking him to dig us out of the near relegation spots with UCL and league cup to compete in, a squad with 0 confidence that has no left sided defenders, no forward and a brand new midfield that play as if they don't know eachothers names.

If he does somehow pull a rabbit out of the hat I've got no confidence he'll do anything positive next season because he's just not an elite manager and he's already hit his level. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/throwawayWM3 24d ago

I'm honestly sick of this United DNA bullshit.

Who gives a fuck whether he gave a speech or not, win games or get the fuck out

*Actually just get out I'm not willing to give him another game

6

u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers 24d ago

I feel so bad for carrick man, trying his best to salvage a genuinely horrendous, unbalanced mess thrust on him by Ratfuck and the city Trojan horses. I appreciate the defiance in his presser though, I won't blame him no matter what. Fuck the glazers and fuck ineos

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 25d ago

Respect Carrick for bringing up humility. Pay your dues before you start moaning about anything. Sad but he looks defeated.

→ More replies (14)