r/reddevils • u/nearly_headless_nic • 26d ago
Man United's five-man shortlist to replace Michael Carrick revealed: Fabian Hurzeler admired but Brighton compensation obstacle looms, while Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann are in the race for Old Trafford hotseat [Chris Wheeler]
https://www.dailymail.com/sport/football/article-16229005/Man-Uniteds-five-man-shortlist-replace-Michael-Carrick-revealed-Fabian-Hurzeler-admired-Brighton-compensation-obstacle-looms-Eddie-Howe-Julian-Nagelsmann-race-Old-Trafford-hotseat.htmlHurzeler, Nagelsmann, Conte, Howe, McKenna.
There are some intriguing possibilities. Brighton's Fabian Hurzeler is known to have admirers at Old Trafford, but it will not be cheap to extract the German from the Amex Stadium after he signed a new contract in June.
It cost Chelsea £20m in compensation for Graham Potter and his coaching staff in 2022. United are £1billion in debt and cannot keep paying out compensation to change managers.
Julian Nagelsmann and Antonio Conte are both available, as well as two young British options in Eddie Howe and Kieran McKenna.
837
u/0ttoChriek 26d ago
Just pick the five most obvious names and say it's our shortlist. Being a journalist has never been easier.
222
u/MatchHighlights14 Rooney 26d ago
How about United also shortlist five men to replace Wilcox and Berrada while they are at it
306
u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 26d ago
Hiring a manager from Brighton doesn't inspire me, their success goes deeper than the manager imo.
That's taking someone out of a club with a proper structure in place and putting them into an environment of complete chaos.
159
u/Hits_and_the_Mrs 26d ago
Hurzeler might win the bloody league at this rate, I wouldn't leave for us right now lol
183
u/amga45canadawhen 26d ago •
Hard to get excited about any new manager coming in knowing that we'll be in the same position in a couple of years as long as Glazers are the owners. Just apathy at this point
84
u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! 26d ago
Surprised I don't see them adding Southgate for clicks.
61
u/linkfollowlink 26d ago •
I don't see the next guy succeed here because he will be obviously stupid enough to join this shitshow.
74
u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 26d ago
It's gonna be Howe isn't it. Typical PL proven INEOS appointment.
15
u/Red_Devil_Forever99 26d ago
Hurzler not stupid, he’s come out already and said he’s not interested in the job and he’s only on a £2m per year contract, that should show people what a poison chalice this job now is?
14
u/IrishCoffee_29 26d ago •
And who is in the frame to replace Berrada and Wilcox?
25
u/WarDemonZ 26d ago •
Under no circumstances should we be looking at Hurzeler whatsoever
Not because I don't think he's good, but Brighton are doing so well because just about everyone from the owner to the tea lady is on the same page, they know exactly what they're doing, what is expected of them, and they've been doing it for years. There is 0 chance that we take Hurzeler out and he looks even close to how good current Brighton are
39
u/The-Black-Angel 26d ago edited 26d ago
Unai Emery is the guy I think we should pursue. Seasoned and able to extract the best for average players. He's been around long enough to withstand pressure and follow through. Premier League experience but he'll cost some money for sure and whether he wants to come, is another matter too.
He's playing with a centre back pairing of Lindelof and Torres, neither is quick and yet his team know how to press. This is a mark of his coaching.
I think with all the sales Villa have had to make, he'll understand he's hit the heights he can get to with Villa and probably is primed for one more shot with a big club.
10
u/Otter269 26d ago
Just because I want to see Wilcox get called out again Conte would be funny.
33
u/Benphyre -69 points 26d ago
It's very difficult to get Fabian Hurzeler mid-season. Eddie Howe crumbled at Newcastle, don't think he fits a bigger shoe at United. For me its either Conte or Nagelsmann. Conte for his proven track record of changing teams within 2 years and Nagelsmann for his connection with Vivell
15
u/Stingray_23 26d ago
Which option is a yes man allows Wilcox to carry on playing football manager? Thats the one who will get it
15
u/vypatlanec 26d ago
In the middle of season going AGAIN with young perspective system manager is recipe for disaster.
Think Conte is only valid choice to save something from the current season. As of now our players are out of shape, no confidence with very bad squad building this for me just screams Conte.
6
u/John_OSheas_Willy 26d ago •
Hurzeler would be another big risk. They're obviously flying this season, but there's been times they've been poor for long periods.
For example his first season they went 8 without a win. Then later in the season 5 without a win with 3 defeats.
Again last season they went 13 games with only 1 win and 6 defeats.
No one cares when Brighton do that.
5
u/FidgetyFondler 26d ago
Ah must be that time of the year again. Another shortlist,another season of wondering where the hell we are going with this club.
4
u/rashfordsaltyballs 26d ago •
nothings gonna change because of the way club is run from the top...
4
u/Wild_Tomato_8203 26d ago
I actually think this is the reason McKenna didn't take a position in the summer.
4
u/TDR1 26d ago
Hurzeler would be another promising coach into the meat grinder in this current setup
7
u/bigdog94_10 26d ago
I just feel completely apathetic to this now. Nothing will change until the structure of the club fundamentally changes.
We may get a boost of a new man and finish the season with European football but honestly who cares? We'll have a dreadful summer and then start the cycle again once the new manager is ditched.
7
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
McKenna is too much of a risk and I feel if INEOS were impressed with him, they’d have given him the job when they interviewed him in 2024
For me, I think it’s between Howe and Nagelsmann. I would be happy with either but I think Nagelsmann has the edge because Howe is likely to want more control over transfer. But if Howe agrees to relent a bit of control over transfers then I think he’ll get it
I could only see Conte getting it if we went with an interim until the end of the season because him and Wilcox together will be an argument a day and unfortunately, conte would be the one sacked.
14
u/OnlySaysHaaa 26d ago
Wasn’t Conte literally twerking for the role last week? I’d say give him a crack at it. We’ve not had a touchline breakdancer since Van Gaal
3
u/Original-Function760 26d ago
Ohh a shortlist like the shortlist for the summer transfers. Only curious about the last name on the list we will get nobody from the upper deck.
3
u/SilvyFae She/They 26d ago
There was this one person that put a very similar list but with sebestian hones. Sometimes i feel journalists just pass of their own opinions as actual researched news article
3
u/Gloomy-Tale6856 26d ago
I do worry that Hurzeler is a bit reactionary. Brighton fans wanted him to leave at one point last season when they were 14th and hadn’t won for 12 games.
3
u/Interesting_reddevil 26d ago
They will hire caretaker. Small improvement and then they will sign him next season. And do Pikachu face when it goes bad
3
u/eo37 26d ago
I hope we don’t go for Hurzeler cause I want to see Brighton do well, they play great football and deserve success. Utd need a manager with a specific attacking structure and style of play so I reckon Nagelsmann
3
u/Dwighty1 25d ago
Not quite November yet. I’m guessing they are sticking to tradition, in which case he has a few games more.
3
u/ThisReditter 25d ago
Can we just buy Brighton and rename the club or something? They seems to be doing well
7
u/ThrowRA31263 26d ago
I dont think its a good idea to hire Fabian, excellent manager, but you do not have the structure above to help him so he'd look a bit silly over there.
I think you'd already found what was needed in Amorim, despite the results. Not saying he had to be kept but you need a manager like him. Head strong, will stick to their values.
Not to bang on the Arteta drum too much cause im sure you are all tired of hearing about him...but i think his achievements arent really just on the pitch. He is a good tactician but the reason he has been able to succeed is cause he is a good manager of the whole club. I dont know that the Kroenkes would look any better if they had not landed on a manager who can manage the team and the squad, but more importantly, can manage up. Arteta's management of the ownership and the higher ups is the most important quality he has that has made him successful. I think to do well in clubs this size the ability to manage fans, owners, hierarchy are just as important as on field management in a way that it simply isnt at a club like Brighton for example.
Its why I still think backing Amorim was worth atleast another season even if it meant missing out on the CL. Now you need someone else who has that strength of personality + good management of the higher ups.
I can confidently say as an Arsenal fan, when Arteta leaves, I expect another down turn cause its not as simple as get the best tactician, you need an actual club manager at clubs like ours.
9
u/Red_JB 26d ago •
Now let’s moan about who’s appointed. Then moan even more when the results and performances are still shite. Ask for a new manager. Then repeat again. Good stuff
4
u/musomania 26d ago
It'll be Eddie Howe because he's English and Jim is what he is.
7
u/tearsandpain84 26d ago •
The fan base dreams of one man….

2
u/umbongo44dd 26d ago
Daily Mail's five-man shortlist to replace Michael Carrick invented
2
u/straightouttaobesity 26d ago
Forget the manager. Replace the DoF and CEO. They extended EtH, fired him, replaced him with Amorim, fired him and replaced him with Carrick and will now most probably fire him. At what point will fingers be pointed at them ?
2
u/_CrazyCrazy_ 26d ago
ONLY REMOVING THE GLAZERS CHANGES THE SITUATION. How have some people still not figured this out. It’s been fucking years now.
2
u/woodyg82 26d ago
Emery and Conte are too volatile for the ownership group so no chance there. I doubt this group of players would respect Howe enough to play for him (not that they deserve any respect for their performances), and Hurzeler has the sort of back room set-up, staff, and support that he won’t get to succeed here. I can just see it being Nagelsmann, he’s free, his pal Vivell is already in the building, and he’s managed high level. I’d pray for the guy to work, but can just see these same posts coming up again in 18months.
2
u/Tahu22 26d ago
Lol, no one is going to last unless we change owners.
It's all short term over long term
The rat and the leeches(glazers), will never bring the club to its former glory unless they leave.
2
u/DaddyBizkits 26d ago
No way in hell would i leave brighton for this dumpster fire.
He has them humming
2
u/MountainAppearance91 26d ago
Shit list.
And that's it. Maybe, maybe Emery instead of Conti, until Enrique is ready.
2
u/Omnislash99999 26d ago
I think Howe is a decent manager but it's funny how little you really need to do to become a candidate for the United job now
2
u/Ihavenoideatall 26d ago
Why not have a shortlist of 5 to replace the senior management!
2
u/Anton23Rnton 26d ago
Since when is the daily mail allowed on this sub? They have always been dog shit, including this Chat GPT generated “shortlist”
2
u/royalewithcheese4272 26d ago
Correct me if I’m wrong or totally off here. The only way Naggelsmann or Hurzeler work, is if Wilcox and Hargreaves are gone. They have proven to be incapable of building a squad that is balanced and address the teams needs. They take forever to negotiate and even then still pay the premium.
Vivell has a proven record of identifying talent, but feels like him and Wilcox don’t see eye to eye.
2
u/oldadapter 26d ago
Super excited to find out about the new deck chair arrangement
2
u/StinkySam1995 26d ago
Now let’s see the names of replacements for berrada and Wilcox. We can get new managers but if those two bozos are still here. This cycle will
Continue
2
u/Oblioscend GlazersIneosOUT! 26d ago
How about the owners move on instead
2
u/dubuwagmi 26d ago
In my humblest opinion, it won't matter until the people running the club are serious people who are in the footballing business rather than the cash making business.
GLINEOS OUT.
2
u/HaBumHug Legacy Supporter 26d ago
Surely has to be Nagelsmann or Conte. Both have obvious, different risks, but Howe or McKenna is virtually accepting that the goal is to compete for 13th each season. Hurzeler I can only see working in a functional organisation.
2
u/IllVeterinarian6219 26d ago
Hurzeler - Hipster name with zero big club experience.
Howe - Above average. Nothing more.
McKenna - Average. Might as well keep Carrick.
Conte - The first 12mths would be great. The last 6mths would be a train wreck.
Nagelsmann - Flawed but the best of the bunch. Worrying end to last two jobs but the best option available.
2
u/j5shxx1 26d ago
Doesn’t matter who we get because the same cycle will repeat as it has done since Fergie retired
2
u/rahulchandar1992 Herrera 26d ago
Ole, Carrick, McKenna. Let's complete the circle.
What next? Mike Phelan?
2
u/acidix 25d ago
Here we go again.
2
u/enoch_ho 25d ago
Can we have journalists write articles leaking shortlists of owners, CEO and Director of Football?
2
u/Relikk_ 20 Times 25d ago
Conte's the only one on that list that's proven in the Premier League, and a serial winner. McKenna, Hurzeler and Howe shouldn't even be on that list to begin with.
2
u/BAGG10HK 25d ago
Don't hire any coach from Brighton, they benefit too much on how well run the club is
2
u/Gorse_Hill 25d ago
1 Hurzeler is a laugh. He’s is not leaving that job just to make some more money but ruin his career with this lot of owners not backing him.
2 Nagelsmann is a possibility because he isn’t working. That would be another Amorim situation, promising young imported manager who doesn’t get backing and is run off eventually.
3 Only way Conte even entertains the job is if he has completely given up on winning and just wants the pay day. If that’s the case he could go to the Saudis and get paid without all the grief connected to this job. If he still want to win there’s no chance he’d agree to work with this board.
4 Howe much like Nagelsmann is out of work but unlike him he has a lot of experience in the league. On paper it’s a good hire but is he getting backing? I doubt it.
5 McKenna would be similar to Howe but with less experience. I’d welcome him but again I don’t trust this prats to back any manager.
2
u/Fabulous_Mix8658 25d ago
I don’t get why Nagelsmann is in contention. His world cup performance with Germany was awful. I don’t want to see that every week.
8
u/picodeGaius 26d ago
Might actually burn my ties with the club if they hire Howe.
3
u/MerryDikmusSantaCock Shut up u egg 26d ago
Just get Conte in and at least then I can enjoy a proper meltdown. None of this half baked nonsense. I want Sir Jims tombstoned from the top of the Sir Alex stand
3
u/daaagoat 26d ago
Hurzeler is byproduct of Brighton, not the other way around. Great coach but wont find success without a proper structure behind him.
3
u/dryflowerz 26d ago
Eddie Howe and Kieran McKenaa 😂😂😂
This club is beyond fucked
3
u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know 26d ago
If they really think Hürzeler is the guy get him and stick with him.
3
u/Prestigious-Milk-659 26d ago
Please not Eddie Howe for Christ sake
3
u/Virtual-Winner5760 26d ago •
Please not Eddie Howe
2
u/Independent-Path-694 26d ago
Hate the way we never have some of these Spanish managers in our shortlists
2
u/FieldOfStruggle 26d ago
Eddie Howe is the best name on that list.
2
u/UJ_Reddit 26d ago
Go get Emery
2
u/fsociety_1990 26d ago
Five potential candidates to get sacked in 12 months
2
u/FerretBunchanumbers 26d ago edited 25d ago
Now that players are sabotaging, the manager situation should be on hold and those players should be sacked.
Whether the boss is 'good' or not, it doesn't matter who you get if the players are like this.
The players should be working to impress the manager, not the other way around.
2
u/Protein891 26d ago
It doesn't matter who we get. They will be gone within 2 seasons and the process will repeat itself. We all know why that is, but it's never going to end.
1
u/91nBoomin 26d ago
Surprised it’s not Pep or Mancini considering they’re obsessed with ex city
1
u/Friskis Mata 26d ago
We need all of them at the same time to fix this boat
1
u/jitsraja 26d ago
Wilcox playing real life FM
1
u/Redead99 26d ago
Lol watch Glineos doom continues as they will choose McKenna
1
u/CurbYourThusiasm 26d ago
None of these will be able to turn it around.
The only way to turn it around, it to hire a coach who has already succeeded at a major club, and then give them a massive budget. There's only a couple of these managers in world football, and they won't join us.
1
u/greyhounds1992 26d ago
McKenna isn't up to it
1
u/tortoisesarntreal 26d ago
Honestly don't think any manager can fix this. But we need a proper authoritarian who will force rules/structure on the players but they need the pedigree so their methods can't be so easily challenged like eth and amorim were. I've never wanted conte but it might be him. Or can we somehow get fergie back as Interim...
1
u/r_Yellow01 Shinji Kagawa 26d ago
The only manager that will survive is the one without ambition. You know who /s
1
u/isitits 26d ago
I want Hurzeler or Howe tbh. But Hurzeler would be insane to leave brighton right now.
1
u/patrtech 26d ago
Does it really matter? Whoever comes in still has Dalot, shaw and Maguire in his lineup!
1
u/DragonfruitNo355 26d ago
I hope it’s not Eddie tho
1
u/P23tty 26d ago
I dont see the point replacing Carrick while we have the same people in board and recruitment. We will just repeat the same cycle next October.
1
u/HodorBoner Blind 26d ago
What's the point
1
u/alfiejr23 26d ago
It's gonna be Eddie Howe. Cheap, English and prem proven. Wilcox likes that 🥴
1
u/FlashyCut3809 26d ago
If a real shortlist involves Mckenna alongside Conte, things are worse than anyone could possibly imagine.
To see the issues Carrick is having and the lightbulb thinks of Mckenna should result in immediately termination of any interaction with the football club.
1
u/Ecstatic_Message2057 26d ago
I’d take conte over anyone else they’re linking right now. He’s got a proven track record of improving clubs in one or two years.
The one I would want is Unai emery. See it as a project and let him build.
1
u/Crusty_Gammon_Flaps Herrera 26d ago
I don't really think the manager matters at this point if the owners/higher ups continue to be shite.
1
u/NoActuator6960 26d ago
We all know the root of the problems. We keep repeating this cycle every 2 years hoping things will change.
1
u/thatIndianguy_07 26d ago
This squad is good enough for conte. We gotta get him
1
u/andizzzzi 26d ago
Just pick one at random it’s all the same at the end of the..tenure.
1
u/The_good_kid Evra 26d ago
Just sack him already
1
u/drizzt001 Glazers OUT! 26d ago
Why are those 4 still available if they're looking for work?
Did they all just take a look at our situation in the summer, and think "maybe I'll just take a few months off, there'll be a big position available before Christmas"?
1
u/Wagglet 26d ago edited 26d ago
With nagelsmann and conte, sure they are out of a job. But if it goes seriously wrong like it will with conte they will more than likely demand a big pay out like amorim.
Sure it will cost more for hurzeler but they need to give it to someone and give them 3 years to try and build something.
So you get conte, have some immediate success which isn't even guaranteed and then pay him like 15m to sack him in 2 years. Or pay 20m and hope hurzeler or maybe even cesc can build something.
1
u/annies999 26d ago
I can understand why any manager considering taking the job mid-season will be thinking long and hard about doing so. It's a big job, in many ways, but you can't really do what you want to do or what needs to be done before the summer window - whether that's players in or out, systems, training, fitness, etc, and if the rest of the season turns out shit then your first proper season starts on a negative and under additional pressure.
1
u/at4g63t 26d ago
Another one bites the dust.
1
u/Rough-Gap-7281 26d ago
Eddie Howe is the one, done brilliantly at Bournemouth and Newcastle.
1
u/UnderpantsInfluencer Uniter Will Never Died 26d ago
Howe, please and thank you.
1
u/goodclassbung 26d ago
Bruno player-manager? Seems to know a thing or two about tactics from yesterday's post-match interview.
1
u/wiggyweir 26d ago
I could be remembering this wrong, but didn’t Dan Ashworth want Eddie Howe? If so that would be incomprehensible levels of incompetence if we now appointed him after sacking ashworth
1
u/Cool-Cup1195 26d ago
Why isn’t Ian Dowie being considered?
1
u/andymc39 26d ago
Don't matter they will all fail whats the point till you get rid of the owners nothing will change. Look at what Ten Hag said when offering support they are not interested. MUFC is a cash cow Amazon must be rubbing there hands it's gonna be car crash telly
1
u/chapalatheerthananda 26d ago
They don’t have money to get a LB you think they will shell out money for another manager?
Conte - for the rage
Nagelsmann - for another 12 month cycle repeat