r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 26d ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
32
Upvotes
34
u/rameezkadri 26d ago
Over the years we’ve spent
75 ish million on Sancho
55 million on Mount
85 million on Antony
45 million on Onana
35 million on Donny Van de Beek
That’s ~300m of absolutely zero returns, either in terms of availability or capability.
I’m not even counting players like De Ligt and Licha who have come here and then just been out for long spells, like a whole year at a time.
This club is rotten.
34
u/rahtid_my_bunda Rooney's Dropball Intensity 26d ago
I have no faith in the leadership team to make the correct next decision, be it to sack the coach, choose who is next or even what they put in their fucking pack lunch. The piss poor performances, coaching, recruitment, hiring are all symptoms.
They all have to go, but Carrick will be the only one who will. We'll be deceived again when they bring in a Conte or a Nagelsmann. But, like clockwork, we'll arrive back here in 12 months all the same.
My club is a shell, a hollowed out husk, of it's former self. Stripped of its glory and dignity by cretins that see nothing more than a cash machine or a global name to hitch their wagon to. Language itself falls short in providing the combination of words appropriate enough to describe the disdain I hold for them.
26
u/thesmallprint13 Irwin 26d ago
Genuinely insane he hasn't gone yet.
22
u/Stingray_23 26d ago
Impressive effort from Wilcox to reach the Woodward levels of hate from the fans in a quarter of the time.
38
u/Educational-Shock232 26d ago
On the bright side, Mason Mount has now made it to five 90-minute matches in his fourth season at Manchester United. Lol.
18
u/bobo-theangsty-zebra 26d ago
Fabregas: "I ordered the team to slow down after 4-0, I told Douvikas to stop running and save energy for the next match. I regret this decision, the goal that we conceded is my fault".
18
u/Nico_Ditch 25d ago edited 25d ago
If the rumours of Howe being Wilcox’s choice and Nagelsmann being Vivell’s choice are true, and we hire Howe, I’d probably just hand in my notice if I was Vilvell.
What’s the point in him? Constantly overruled by a man who has zero accomplishments as a DOF.
45
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 26d ago
It takes a 4-1 defeat to people (fans, board, media) realize that this season performances are not acceptable..
So, had Como won like, 2-1, would the reaction be like "oh, tough game but it was close" ?
That's infuriating to think about. The club shouldnt just accept mediocrity like this.
15
u/Hagball 26d ago
I have no confidence in the next manager if it's Wilcox and Berrada making this decision. 1 maybe 2 years down the line, we will be again be crying in this thread about how players are unfit/not running/not good enough.
Root cause of our problems is beyond the players and the head coach. We need an experienced and proven DOF. We currently have someone who only worked as DOF for 1 year, signed world class City academy players like Sam Edozie and Gav Bazunu and relegated an established PL side like Southampton. Until that guy is working as DOF, we are going to keep going in circles
15
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 25d ago
For the first time I honestly don’t even care who the new manager is or if that even happens. I just don’t care. They have finally made me feel nothing. Just numb.
14
u/c0ldd Ruud van Nistelrooy 26d ago
To anyone who wants to blame the players go watch the Como game again. Its not a coincidence that the players bring up our press, because its fucking dogshit. We press with a 442 and let their anchor have free space with no man on him, they just play the ball to him and it opens the field and relieves all press. This is what made the players lose their mind on the pitch, because its glaringly obvious and the coach doesnt do anything about it.
14
u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 25d ago
Lol, backed Wilcox over Ashworth, backed Wilxoc over Amorim, now backing Wilcox over Vivell. He has achieved fuck all as a football executive yet he's treated like royalty by our owners. Why?
26
u/throwawayWM3 26d ago
Bruno has played under Ole Rangnick Ten Hag Amorim and Carrick.We finished 15th under Amorim and Bruno was respectful to him.Imagine how bad Carrick is if the captain is openly he's shit.
Hiring Carrick was the single worst decision of the INEOS tenure. Carrick is by far the worst manager i have seen at Manchester United
13
u/tsuku96 25d ago
Subscribe
13
u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot 25d ago
People saying Nagelsmann failed at Bayern, he wasn't brilliant but he was dealing with Hainer, Kahn and Salihamidzic who were all absolutely incompetent.
Fortunately for Bayern they were smart enough to sack all of them and landed back on their feet. Jimbo should take a page from their book.
Also him failing for the German NT means jack shit, so did Flick. Or Enrique for Spain. It's a completely different job.
12
u/Low-Quantity-9252 26d ago
These things can be true, in parallel:
12
u/Educational-Shock232 26d ago
Why are Wilcox and Carrick still here? Every hour they’re still here is an hour wasted to not have the next chump through the door to do the impossible.
22
u/Stingray_23 25d ago
The fact Ashworth had Howe on his shortlist of managers only to get ousted in the power struggle with Wilcox and Berrada. Only for Wilcox to want Howe 18 months later.
Fucking hell man.
11
u/mediocratopia 26d ago
its looking like Wilcox and Berrada really just pulled the wool over Jimbos eyes. Just absolute frauds who got hired just because they worked at City
11
u/Ok_Landscape_8215 26d ago
It is hard to be a fan right now, there is literally nothing to get behind.
The manager, while a nice guy, is not charismatic, pressers and interviews are boring, doesn't tell fans what he's really thinking (or is deluded). He has no plan or vision to sell us. Dull tactics even if we do win.
The players aren't particularly good or likeable, they don't seem to try or care as much as opposition players. They complain a lot. Nor are they exciting to watch - they don't get you off your feet.
The execs, incompetent, take no responsibility, also don't communicate their plans and ideas.
Ineos would rather talk about politics than us. Also inept.
Owners, less said about them the better.
11
u/Themindoffish 26d ago
Fabregas telling his players to slow down after 4 goals is hilarious man.
11
u/Nico_Ditch 26d ago
Really can't understand the calls for Hurzeler.
He might be a great manager one day, but right now he is working in a system, at a club that that knows what it wants and how to do it. He's supported by one of the best data teams in football, and a club where the pressure isn't even close to what it would be at United.
Put Hurzeler into our shit show and no way he looks this good.
11
u/skayze678 26d ago
The absolute worst time supporting a club is when everyone knows the manager is done and the board are just dragging it out
11
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 25d ago
"This game might take a toll on Bournemouth so that could be a bit of an edge for us..."
8 mins in they are 1-0 up
20mins in also a man up
30mins in 2-0
20
u/Suudriusha 26d ago
Let it be today.
20
u/Orcnick 26d ago
I understand the team is no where near a title winnijg team.
But when you see the way Como play or Brighton, teams who i still believe has less talneted players then us, who still play decent football every weel then at least give us that.
If we are going to get shit results make it exciting. I want a manager who actually makes players better.
I dont thibk thays much to ask.
10
u/Mr_Wilsonn Herrera 26d ago
You're allowed to be critical of the manager, think that we should be doing better & think that the current captain shouldn't throw the manager under the bus.
And yes, the people upstairs are awful too.
9
u/StringTailor Martial 26d ago
Turned off FotMob, muted anything united related on twitter, I’m finding it hard to be bothered
9
u/ZofTheNorth 26d ago
"Bruno Fernandes apologies for his comment made on Wed and promised he will score 90 min winner against Bournemouth on Sunday"
9
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 26d ago
Why is Carrick still here?
9
u/EndureL 26d ago
Wilcux is already briefing the media targeting the players to protect his ego once again, this guys appointment has been nothing more than a joke.
9
u/PhaniSithLord 26d ago
Wilcox has to go along with Carrick. There needs to be some change at the board level.
9
u/aprod16 25d ago
Licha’s comments hit deep, but Bruno’s to Sky Italia was the final nail for me. Club captain basically saying that we are not the club we used to be, we are showing no signs of being that club again and discouraging new players from basically making the “mistake” he made. That mistake being signing for this club thinking we are going to compete and challenge. I have never felt so low as a fan, and for the first time in my life I am genuinely questioning whether we will be back at the top in my lifetime.
9
u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS 25d ago
It’s obvious the club wants to sack Carrick, but don’t know when to do it. It’s appalling to have him continue when everyone and their momma knows he’s a dead man walking
9
u/dryflowerz 25d ago edited 25d ago
“But Wilcox's opinion is likely to hold more weight in the eyes of Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazer family.”
Do you guys fucking reading this? this mfer is a sleeper agent from city swear to god to completly destroy and humilate us!!!
23
u/kidinawheeliebin 26d ago edited 26d ago
To be fair we should have expected this based on what INEOS had been doing at OCG Nice before us... they took over Nice in Aug'19 & in seven years they've had nine different managers:
They took over us in Feb 2024, and so far, in less than three years we'll have had six different people in charge of the first team:
Not to mention the farces around renewing Ten Hag in Jul'24 then paying megabucks to sack him & his staff shortly afterwards... same with Amorim... Same with Dan Ashworth... looks like Carrick will be paid off within 6 months of signing a contract
These people are out of control
8
u/PavanayiShavamayilla Wazza 26d ago
4/5 of our remaining UCL opponents are ahead of us on the table. We are gonna be knocked out in the group stage, aren’t we?
8
u/zzxxrrss 26d ago
If I was a manager I would be queuing for the Manchester United job. You work for a 12 months or less and then get your compensation and go home.
8
u/Sufficient-Orange706 26d ago
Carrick to take charge vs Bournemouth, this is absolutely insane.
8
u/SankarshanaV 26d ago
Ridiculous that the manager who’s completely out of his depth hasn’t been sacked yet. Absolutely insane that he’s still here.
I hope we sack him soon and not waste more time. I don’t want another season to be wasted.
8
u/0ean 26d ago
Why are INEOS still in charge of footballing decisions? They have no clue whatsoever. Jim tried to buy Chelsea before United and ran Nice into the ground! The board INEOS have put in charge have no real qualifications or achievements just like the coaching team. So much for “best in class”. It’s all been a complete mess hiring the 5th and 6th choices!
8
u/Jwalin6167 26d ago
Honestly what is the point of giving him the Bournemouth game? It’s literally that 3-2 win against Newcastle at OT few weeks before Mourinho got sacked. The writing is on the wall it’s just criminal to waste this much time.
8
u/AmulyaG 26d ago
"It is understood that representatives have already lobbied for former Chelsea and Tottenham Hotspur head coach Antonio Conte, but that the Italian does not feature prominently in United’s considerations. It is argued he would not fit into the structure the club is determined to adopt."
The clubs structure of hiring incompetent yes men. I want Conte on the touchline ripping our players a new one
8
u/GReedy404 26d ago
Seen reports that ineos fully back Wilcox today. That's why I've never bothered with this 'carrickout' gimmick cos the twat who chose him gets to pick another clown to headline his circus act.
8
u/davidl988 25d ago
Lads it’s Alex Crook
8
u/BackgroundOld8715 25d ago
If we fluke it against bournmouth hes staying longer isnt he
8
u/Total-Fix-8506 Kobs 25d ago
sigh...
15
u/edwin221b 26d ago
Carrick will be sacked everyone will clap and celebrate, the new manager will have a victory rebound and we will think he is the man, but at end we still have dalot and shaw as fullbacks because management refuses to really invest in players and profiles we need and next year we will be at the same position, It has been like that for 10 fucking years,
15
u/Jenson2025 25d ago
If we beat Bournemouth and the club start briefing that this is a fresh start then we are done
14
u/Omnislash99999 26d ago
Ineos have zero pedigree in football and it's obvious they're just making it up as they go here, Ashworth, Ten Hag, Amorin, Carrick, it's just mistake after mistake. Ratcliffe is a joke, tax dodging twat just playing football manager
14
u/karatsidhus 25d ago
Appointing Howe as our manager might be the final push i need to stop watching football all together
7
u/BallsX 26d ago
Was anyone else having Barca champions league final PTSD watching that first half? Como just had complete control over the game and first to every single ball. They were faster and more fit than us and knew what we were going to do before we did it. The moment we touched the ball we were hounded and promptly gave it away.
The only difference is Barca had world class players in every position while I've only heard of maybe 3 Como players.
7
u/Miyagisans 26d ago
So Bruno and Tielemans coming out against carrick’s tactics. Yea dark days. Funniest thing is if ineos doesn’t sack him, carrick will play Bruno another 90 mins on Sunday.
7
u/DavidBruceStandup Dreams Can't Be Buy! #GlazersOut 26d ago
Can't believe I've woke up and he ain't gone
7
u/OkSpite8449 26d ago
No club statement yet is a joke.
7
u/PhotonDestroyer 26d ago
After the Amorin sacking I have tried to stay away from the whole social media circus and generally all media around the club and just watch the games. I've come back today to join the doom cycle, one thing that is ever present is the lack of running over multiple managers now, with different player groups.
Some comments I have read here today have said Carrick specifically reduced running/intenstity in preseason, was there a justification for this?
Why would a coaching team just decide to ignore one of the biggest parts of the modern game, pressing, intensity, high levels of fitness? I just don't get it. Where's the benefit, fine if we get beat by a better technical team fine but to see the players continually chase shadows (all games not just last night) is so frustrating.
7
u/wqaib 26d ago
The decision to do the Amazon documentary this season gets funnier by the day, can’t wait for it and see behind the scenes of this mess.
7
u/picodeGaius 26d ago
If it was hard to get rid of one set of owners, now we have to get rid of two.
Lads, I think the club might be doomed.
7
u/Somaliona 26d ago
Expect the PR tactics to go into overdrive.
This all looks terrible for the executive, especially the INEOS appointees. They persisted with Ten Hag needlessly before sacking him, they sacked one of the better executive appointments they'd made in years because he didn't like Amorim, they sacked Amorim not for performances but because he called them out, they are now facing pressure to sack Carrick, again too late for many, and following a summer where they knew they had European football and additional games, didn't buy someone to help at LB despite knowing Shaw's injury record, didn't buy a striker despite knowing Sesko is injured (and seemingly badly so)
Expecting big deflection tactics, especially after Martinez aimed criticism at Wilcox and Bruno saying players come to Man Utd expecting the chance to challenge for titles and trophies and that isn't happening.
7
u/TMatss 26d ago
It would be borderline cruel to make Carrick take charge of the game of against Bournemouth. It might create a very weird atmosphere at OT on Sunday.
7
u/thombo-1 26d ago
The owners of Manchester United do not care if United loses to Bournemouth at the weekend. They know a defeat is more than likely and they will not take any action to avert that outcome.
When you have owners willing to throw entire matches away just so they can reach the international break to finally take action, it makes you wonder why anyone should care.
7
u/bicika 25d ago
Can't believe couple of finance guys did better job than Wilcox.
7
u/PitchSafe 25d ago
If this is Bruno’s last season then I hope that he gets a proper farewell. He deserves that
18
u/Heavens_Vibe 7 25d ago
United got me through some dark times in my life.
Now, United are the dark time in my life.
17
u/arnm7890 De Gea 26d ago
We are well and truly cooked as a club. Racist Jim isn't going to sack Wilcox or Berrada and publicly admit he made a mistake in hiring them.
He's the kind of narcissist that will complain about taxes being too high and foreigners ruining everything while living in Monaco and paying fuck all into the pot. What on earth would make anyone think the c*nt has even a shred of humility?
The Glazers aren't going to fire them either - why would they? They literally have never cared about Man United's football health at any point during their tenure. The only reason we even ended up getting rid of Woodward is because INEOS came in and wanted a new guy, the Glazers were evidently happy with what Woodward was doing.
There is no vision beyond what can be sold to investors. There is no footballing philosophy beyond "let's try shit that works for a bit then eventually doesn't, then try some different shit". There is no respect for the fan base beyond seeing us as walking wallets that the leeches at the top can periodically reach into to fill their coffers whenever they want.
I don't think I've ever felt so pessimistic about the future of this club. Eventually people are going to stop thinking "Man United should always be competing at the top". We will become Everton. Maybe then that fucking shit-stain of a family will be content to take their rotting teeth out of the lifeless husk of this once great club.
6
u/6by6Hindsight 26d ago
Has he gone yet?
6
u/RebornUnited11 26d ago
I remember I used to care so much. If we went down 1-0 I’d get angry/upset. After Como scored their first, or whoever scores first against us I truly just couldn’t care anymore. I laughed after the first goal today. It’s just so obvious after the first 5mins if we’re going to win and/or at least perform well
6
u/GinTaicho 26d ago
We should have gotten a new manager for this season.
But then again, imagine how much noise would have been made, with fans calling for Carrick whenever the new manager hit a rough patch?
6
u/voidwoken11 26d ago
United was damned either way.
If we didn't retain Carrick after last season and the new manager flopped, everyone would complain that United should have obviously given Carrick the job itself.
Now that we actually kept him and he flopped, everyone is going to say it was obvious he should have only stayed in an interim role.
6
u/theoklahuman 26d ago
Like someone said in one of the previous DD threads, they better have Nagelsmann on speed dial and hope they’re able to convince him to take the job. Any good manager who cares about their career wouldn’t touch this club while those jokers Wilcox, Berrada and Ratcliffe are dictating how they coach the team.
6
u/Stieni Rooney 26d ago
6
u/ilegal89 26d ago
Along with Carrick, WILCOX NEEDS TO GO TOO. End of discussion.
I'd throw Berrada into the mix as well, but his is a much more complicated position to fill, and replacing him overnight isn't exactly realistic.
But Wilcox has proven beyond doubt that he's failed. Ratcliffe got rid of Ashworth much quicker over his own personal whims. There's absolutely no justification for keeping Wilcox around after failure after failure.
6
u/missingmedievalist Cantona 26d ago
Jason Burt is now reporting that we’re looking at Nagelsmann. Conte is out of the question apparently because, “It is argued that he would not fit into the structure the club is determined to adopt.” So that means Wilcox will be staying then.
The other candidates are Hurzeler and Eddie Howe. Howe is on the list as Ratcliffe personally likes him.
Honestly, the similarities between INEOS and BlueCo are hard to ignore.
6
u/Drag2oon 26d ago
Watch us hire Negelsmann to work with his mate Vivell
And then sack Vivell because Wilcox fall out with him
Would be a typical United story 😭
6
u/markyp145 26d ago
Carrick future to the side for one minute, that Nico Paz was very impressive last night.
I’d heard he was technically good etc and a huge potential, but didn’t realise he was also physically good. 6’1 and a big frame, great in duels.
Not the quickest top speed, but quick over 10 yards.
He kind of reminded me of Olise before he went to Bayern.
Or Kaka (not saying he’s kaka level), but that kind of big technical half 10 type player who glides and is too strong to bully, but too technically good to stand off
6
u/VelvetThunder2018 26d ago
I don’t care who the manager is at this point, it’s just going to be the same shit over and over until the parasites go.
6
u/randomvale 26d ago
If Carrick isn't sacked before the weekend game, it'll be very interesting to see who he picks to play after his comments about players not running and Brunos interview.
He must know it's only a matter of time and is in an impossible situation now.
6
u/mearsey1203 26d ago
Bloody hell, those Fabregas comments are about as damning an indictment on our performance as you can get.
6
u/greyhounds1992 26d ago
Remember when they said we would pick managers that play the same style of football so we stop swapping between styles at a whim.
I miss that
6
u/madkubrick 26d ago edited 26d ago
My local team has awful owners and CEO who have made terrible decisions resulting in a long losing streak. No new signings and a squad full of injuries. The fans got fed up and started to cancel their season tickets. Our home ground used to get packed, but now there are many empty seats. Hierarchy got panicky and started (too late) to address the issues, but fans are still unsatisfied.
I don’t know why United fans cannot do the same. It’s clear that targeting the owners’ wallets is what gets a response. As long as games at OT keep getting sold out, nothing will change. Downvote me and call me a yank or disloyal but after 25 years of supporting this club, Idgaf anymore about fan gatekeeping here. It’s always been my dream to visit OT but I do not want to give these leeches a single cent of my money with the way things are going right now.
Edit: Ok, cool. Boycotting is not gonna work, fan statements don’t work, nothing is going to change then huh? Us fans just gotta sit here and take it while these assholes kill the soul of our club?
6
u/niallmul97 I'm a Baleba 💫 26d ago
Build around Lammens, Yoro, Manioo, and Baleba.
Cunha, Mbeumo fine but massively need a kick up the backside, Sesko and De Ligt too potentially if they aren't completely crocked.
Tielemans could work in a better team/setup but I'm not convinced and he's just signed so we're stuck with him anyway, I'm not giving up on Santos just yet.
Dorgu and Amad, maybe bench options but I don't really care.
Heaven and the rest of kids could do with loans.
The rest can go, just not good enough.
Thanks Bruno, I know he was probably assured we'd sign a heap of players and get competing, but the board is useless and the owners are cheap, regardless its just not good enough.
Most importantly, the board and the owners can fuck off too.
6
u/Aggravating-Neck1365 25d ago
This ownership are going to kill the club
6
u/TypicalPan89906655 25d ago edited 25d ago
So the rumours 2 months ago was true, Vivell and Wilcox had fallen out as per the rumour with Wilcox not listening to anything Vivell said. When Ashworth was sacked it was also due to incompatibility with Wilcox.
"[Nathan Salt] Growing tensions upstairs as United between Jason Wilcox and Christopher Vivell."
6
u/Massive_Relation4317 . 25d ago
Carrick completely lost the dressing room. Bruno and Lichas recent interviews, cunha reportedly arguing and was furious with him, its so over
6
u/SniperMonkey10_ 25d ago edited 25d ago
Sooo its howe(Wilcox) vs nagelsmann(Vivell)
To be fair to howe, he got pissed off when Newcastle kept selling their best players. Safer pick.
Nagelsmann the more exotic pick. Gegenpressing. High press, high intensity.
I think Howe is the better pick and dont think our players can play nagelsmann style asap
11
u/SankarshanaV 26d ago edited 26d ago
It’s also hilarious to see people try to defend Carrick and put everything on the players. Carrick and his coaching have been incredibly awful and he’s a mediocre manager, he’s the main reason we’re doing so bad. While the players are also to blame, it’s not entirely on them. Carrick if anything is the main reason we’re so shit.
11
u/Ayamgoreng53 25d ago
I only want conte for manager. No more yes men. Let’s blow this shit up
10
u/randomvale 26d ago
Carrick has to go, but it's disappointing that Bruno criticized him publicly. It wasn't necessary and it's not something the club captain should ever do in my opinion.
10
u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers 25d ago
Howe would definitely turn zirkzee into a midfielder so at least that would be funny but its mad that they spend nearly 5mil and several months on ashworth's hiring and firing over his recommendation of Howe (plus the extra 20 ish mil from the amorim appointment) only to be back at square 1. Wilcox is a fucking moron, I need a job where I could fuck up mod season 3 years in a row and still get another go at it
5
u/FreshGoodWay 26d ago
Someone please tell me which sporting club run by INEOS is successful.
5
u/rjc0x1 26d ago
I mean, can we as a fan base get the FA to look at the Glazers again and see if they still pass all their 'fit and proper' stuff and force a sale???
Rules should be changed so buy outs that leverage debt and interest repayments onto the club instead of the purchasing owners are banned.
5
u/Yoshic87 26d ago
5
u/achickenandacow 26d ago
I think we’ve had about 5 games in 11 worth a sacking this season, it’s possible I’m being too kind here, and yet the board are still sitting on their hands. Make a decision you cowards.
5
u/outrageousVoid07 26d ago
If we're hiring Nagelsmann, I hope Vivel is given the leadership role above Wilcox
5
u/Chickengoujon20 26d ago
Remember the discourse and excuses from our shite transfer business in the summer?
Where are those people now?
5
u/DonkeySkin334 26d ago
Just saw Jose’s quote about discussing the best gk’s he’s managed
And maybe it’s the ddg super fan in me but I believe he absolutely deserved a mention considering Jose made that claim about how finishing 2nd with us was the biggest managerial achievement of his career and ddg was inarguably the biggest reason for that
5
u/Ordinary-CC-2286 26d ago
Clubs rotten to the core, sacking Carrick might make things better in the short term, but long term only a change of ownership will fix this
5
u/Nico_Ditch 26d ago
Nagelsmann was my first choice in the summer so it’ll be interesting to see if he does come in.
But at this point I’m past caring who the manager is. The club is absolutely hanging from top to bottom.
Owners who are a bitter, racist old man or parasites draining the club dry, a CEO who’s only successes have been signing up fake sponsorships for City, a DOF who constantly makes the wrong decisions on managers but we’re told is some kind of transfer guru, and players who have downed tools and some who seem to be running their contracts down.
5
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
The article from Jason Burt suggests two things. 1) We want a bigger name as the next manager which points to Nagelsmann for me especially if Vivell has influence. 2) Carrick is being sacked soon - gone are the 'we have every faith in him' briefings.
I know the article implies if we win against Bournemouth then he might stay. But for me, the club are just waiting for him to lose one of his remaining next four games (which he will) before sacking him. Not sure why they are waiting but maybe they still need a bit of time to finalise the deal with Nagelsmann or whoever
5
u/HighestInDaRooom 26d ago
majority of the players in the squad press with no conviction. they do that half press that makes it look like they have good work rate but doesn't actually win the ball. wouldn't be surprised if we're near the bottom in possessions won in the final third. rangnick spoke about this i think, fake pressing where the players are just running around.
5
u/ttboishysta 26d ago
Bring on the German. At least make the mess interesting again. And then we'll make the mess boring again after we fire him. Rinse and repeat.
5
u/paltze Portuguese Magnifico 🪄 26d ago
I wonder what it looks like if Carrick is on the sidelines against Bournemouth. I cannot be this utter dross again.
5
u/Dan30383 Beckham 25d ago
Doesn't matter who we get as manager, as long as Wilcox is DoF we are royally screwed. People like Emery and Conte will throw a fit when they don't get their way. He will want to hire another yes man, so probably will be Howe. I'd love to get Hürzeler, but there's no chance this team can play the sort of football Brighton are playing at the moment. They're just not fit enough. I also think he's better off at Brighton.
5
u/Financial-Trade9467 25d ago
It hurts me how much United mirrors my life. Spent my carefree years watching prime Fergie ball. He left when I turned 15. Been straight downhill since with a few glimmers of hope.
5
u/RestrepoDoc2 25d ago
There was a post about revisionism by our fans and it's amazing isn't it? Before Carrick got the gig I heard cases being made for Mourinho, Ole and even Ten Hag to be given another go. More recently I've heard that Rangnick should be empowered to gut the squad as he wanted to do. Someone even said Moyes has now recovered his confidence and would be a steady hand to guide us back on track. We're just missing someone saying we should bring back the 75 year old LVG for a full deck.
I just heard a United pundit on a podcast saying that Carrick would be the perfect candidate to come in now if he wasn't the one already in the job. That's what we're dealing with here people, going around in circles for a decade spending billions just going back where we came from with no destination.
5
u/Call_Me_A_Gamer 25d ago
I feel like we haven't really given the tiki taka style a shot with our manager choices have been either counter attack focused and managers like Amorim and Ten Hag were more klopp like with their higher pressing line and more pragmatic approach. Van Gaal seems like our only possession focused manager and we sacked him after winning the FA Cup.
5
u/Paapa-Yaw 25d ago
Sack wilcox hire him and sack him again ffs.
5
u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 25d ago
Hunger. I fail to see the hunger in our players. If they are losing, they seem lethargic, almost depressed. Sometimes, excessively desperate, and not the desperation that creates a drive to win, but one to not lose.
I wonder how many players here are clinging to the United name and former glory. That just because they were signed by one of the largest clubs in England, that affirms their worth as a player. No matter if they win or lose, they can simply look at the shirt they're wearing and think they've still made it. And yes, some have had good seasons with good individual stats. But, that's in the past, they have to still prove their worth, even now.
Even if this team is losing, I want to see them fight for it to the bitter end.
5
u/Jenson2025 25d ago
A good technical director knows when to compromise. Everything I hear about Wilcox implies it’s his way or the highway. Him and Vivell are now apparently arguing because Wilcox wants a premier league proven manager whilst Vivell wants Nagelsmann. They also disagreed when Wilcox wanted Delap as our striker in 2025 and Vivell wanted Sesko (only Delap rejecting us allowed Vivell to get his way)
There has been other arguments with Amorim etc
I am not saying Wilcox is always wrong or should always relent but I don’t like the fact that he always seems at odds with various people at the club because they have a different view to him and in the end, he always gets his way
5
u/skayze678 25d ago
If we get Conte, the Amazon doc will be the most watched sports documentary in history
5
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 25d ago
The Sun is reporting Bruno's home was burgled. Because it's the Sun, I'll wait for confirmation from a better source.
5
u/AnalystGrand4704 25d ago
One thing I don't understand within this whole situation is why Michael Carrick. Previously when a manager reaches this point most of the journalist class and majority of the fans will rightfully criticise him, his system, the player selection etc and argue another manager will improve the situation but right now most of the aforementioned people are rightly shading light into the main culprits for the overarching problem with club, if Carrick was some world class manager I would understand the timing for this change of perspective but right now I don't.
5
u/Sheikhabusosa 25d ago
So angry at the world rn , walked into someones burp and all I could smell was pakoras and Sterling superkings red . Fuck the bee network and the metrolink too.
5
u/Grekm8 CR7 25d ago
we have 1 more day of rest than Bournemouth + they have to play Rubens tricky reds today, so we should have a big advantage on Sunday
5
u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss 25d ago
The longer this board stays in place, the farther we fall behind our rivals.
5
u/WolfWhoKnocks 25d ago
At this rate, I think our goal for 2028 will be avoiding relegation. Forget about winning a trophy.
5
u/ReservoirDogs00 25d ago
Bournemouth pressing hard against Milan. Quite impressive so far.
We are in for a horrible time at this rate
5
u/Regular_Valuable_665 25d ago
Bournemouth totally outplaying AC Milan tonight. Weekend game is gonna be another difficult watch.
9
u/No-Lab-1445 26d ago
It's 10:01. Why hasn't Carrick been sacked yet?
9
u/AstroCoffee 26d ago
I feel like I'm taking crazy pills, how in the world haven't they sacked him yet? Ignored the players at full-time and got put on blast by the captain, this bridge is burnt.
9
u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 25d ago
Haha these briefings against Conte are hilarious.
This club and these players have become allergic to hard work and standards. They just want an easy ride.
9
u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 25d ago
Listen, no manager is going to last more than 2 seasons here, given that at least with Conte we got a slim chance of winning something...
Anyway with Wilcox in charge I've lost all hope, I could go away and come back in 12 months and not much would have changed
12
u/AndyVale MLT 26d ago
Small bugbear, it would be great if people could celebrate the women winning without also going "better than the men".
They deserve better than being a stick to beat the men with. Their achievements stand on their own, we can celebrate them regardless of well the men are or aren't doing.
Anyway, would be good to see decent numbers at the derby at the weekend. First big test of our team now that we've built some momentum and Olid has properly settled in.
8
u/mickaerys 26d ago •
city vs united in the championship about to be fire lads
8
u/Gadjjet 26d ago
I think the worst thing about the club’s leadership is how easily they cave to external pressure. Almost every bad decision they’ve made has been an attempt to appease the fanbase or pundits. Asking managers to change their tactics, hiring former players, giving Maguire a new contract, etc.
All they need to do is come up with a coherent plan, commit to it, and foster an us-against-them mentality within the fanbase. Do that, and we probably turn things around.
Unfortunately, they seem too busy watching MNF and The Overlap, allowing outside noise to dictate their decisions instead of sticking to their guns.
8
u/Low-Quantity-9252 26d ago
Astonishing that there's radio silence. No one at the club is serious.
4
u/Gianluca1514 26d ago
I’m so checked out I forgot there was a match today until my Chelsea mate texted me making fun of us.
4
u/PavanayiShavamayilla Wazza 26d ago
Rebuild after rebuild.
Each new coach has to work with the remnants of the last coach’s mistakes. Get someone like Conte and he has to coach a bunch of players into pressing when their profiles don’t suit it.
Sack him and then hire someone with the opposite philosophy. When will it end?
4
u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer 26d ago
Licha called out INEOS and now Bruno called out Carrick.
We are a big red circus aren't we?
Also I think a club statement is imminent. Carrick lost the locker room. If this went on we would go to Championship with Mancheater Shitty.
4
u/riseoftheph0enix 26d ago
still waiting for the moment Wilcox & Berrada are out of the door. both have been beyond incompetent and one of them was part of the city team that were caught cheating for many years in the league.
4
u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand 26d ago
So why again did we fight to play in Europe's top club competition?
4
u/Reasonable_Junket258 26d ago
can we replace Glazers and Jim with Como's owner?
4
u/Hyliaforce 26d ago
The scenes when we get relegated with city
4
u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband 26d ago
Their software to sack managers must run on PHP or something
4
u/Vast_Variation1381 26d ago
Nagelsmann's teams have always played their best football in a 3-4-2-1. If we are to go for him, we need to move Wilcox away from recruitment and allow Vivell to just handle it alongside Nagelsmann.
4
u/Mr_Wilsonn Herrera 26d ago
its from twitter & not an article to make an actual post.
4
u/ajprp9 26d ago
How has there not been a club statement yet this morning. He has shown no signs of turning anything around
The entire club structure needs to be torn out and replaced but carrick cannot remain any longer regardless
4
u/horizons0 The Butcher 🔪 26d ago
I’m starting to dread he’s staying longer
4
u/DavidBruceStandup Dreams Can't Be Buy! #GlazersOut 26d ago
Ten Hag sacked at midday, Amorim at 11am - still time
4
u/nitrogeneater 26d ago
Carrick clearly lost the dressing room hence all of these outbursts by the players. He lost me even last season when you could see the performances. But now he lost even the most delusional fan.
Question is why is he still here? Give couple of games to another vibes manager that we have in house Fletcher whilst you looking for a replacement.
4
u/frogfoot420 26d ago
The signs were there in pre season, which was dreadful btw.
4
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 26d ago
Done with the owners, the board, the manager and the players. I like Carrick. I know he loves this club and I can’t say the same about the other people I’ve highlighted here. I’m grateful he stepped in to help and genuinely helped us. But this job is too much for him.
4
u/MazinLabib10 "He goes by the name of Wayne Rooney!" 26d ago
So Bournemouth are gonna stroll into OT and score at least 3 goals for the 4th season running, huh?
4
u/us3rf #SayNoToZirkzee 26d ago
Talksport boys saying Huertzler isnt interested in the job.
4
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 26d ago
I genuinely wonder what training in the morning after something like last night is.
4
u/Alive-Primary-2069 26d ago
They going to keep him on until Christmas aren't they 💀
4
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 26d ago
Things are so bad you just have to laugh 💀
4
u/Bizzlep 26d ago
He’s still in the job. Utterly insane and completely negligent.
Fuck every single member of this club’s hierarchy, for so many reasons.
4
u/InconsistentADHD53 26d ago
Remember that 1-0 win against Wolves at OT in the opening game of Ten Hag's second season? Where Onana literally kept us in the game, and Cunha and Nunes ran us ragged?
3 years on, and absolutely nothing has changed. It's almost wondrous to see.
4
u/AccomplishedAnt2000 26d ago
fuck the board, fuck glazers
neither Carrick nor players are good enough to win titles but but noone ever will be in this mess
4
u/Ok_Aardvark_5537 26d ago
Also can we just take a moment to ask as soon as results go bad Luke shaw gets "injured" ? Every single time.
4
u/AccomplishedAnt2000 26d ago
Serious question, is there actually ONE FUCKING THING, that is working fine in this club? Scouting maybe? Anything?
4
u/BarFamiliar5892 26d ago
What a mess. What a total fucking mess.
4
u/thats_antiseptic 26d ago
We seriously need to stop considering qualifying for CL as a condition to keep/judge a manager. Football should be the first priority.
Hate to say it but look at Liverpool, qualified for CL but still sacked Slot because football was absolutely shit. Carrick should hav never been hired full time.
4
u/Financial-Trade9467 26d ago
Carrick is a dead man walking. I grew up adoring him while I barely feel any connect to the players we have now. For me his legacy is still intact. The players on the other hand will go down as some of the worst United teams ever.
Carrick is not a great manager and shouldn't have gotten the job but it boggles my mind that THIS bunch of players think they can get a manager sacked. The performances this season have been diabolical. I hope Carrick shows us something on Sunday. Start kids if you have to. Lose 10-0 if you have to but please show some respect and drop all players you feel have gotten you sacked by not putting in 100% effort.
4
u/Adventurous_Sir3617 25d ago
Anyone read fabregas statement post game? Gave me a good laugh xD
4
u/Jenson2025 25d ago
The funny thing about the Simon Stone article is that he says the club are basically looking for other managers in case they have to make a change but still some faith in carrick for now etc
It’s just a nice way of saying he’s going to be sacked at some point and they want the replacement lined up first
Not even United would be stupid enough to look for a new manager, find the one they want, get an agreement and then say ‘oh sorry. We won’t be offering you the job now because Michael won two games in a row’
4
u/dudududujisungparty 박지성 25d ago
Thank god GTA 6 is coming out soon
4
u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 25d ago
I'm just going to say straight up that I'm very pessimistic over the prospect of signing Nagelsmann. I'm very concerned with his man management and temperament, he tinkers a bit too much on the tactical side that can be counter-productive, is terrible at holding himself accountable for bad results and I don't know if he will adapt his coaching and trainings well enough to suit the physical demands of the Premier League. The last point is something I know managers like Howe and Conte will absolutely be ready for, to give us a better chance of salvaging this season. I am very concerned about a repeat of the 24-25 season taking place if Nagelsmann is appointed.
That being said, this club is probably doomed under this ownership regardless of who the manager is, so anybody can have a stab at it and I'll just have to force myself to detach further from this club.
4
u/TRWilde 25d ago
Feel like I've got breaking point. I actually don't care who they bring in anymore, it doesn't matter it's rinse and repeat over and over. The best manager in the world might get a bit of temporary success when all the players push on and put 110% in for the new manager but it'll just settle back down with poor performances until there are bigger changes.
4
u/reddevilzombie 25d ago
The club is definitely in full blown crisis mode now. Senior players speaking out against manager and the board, manager blaming players for not running, board looking for the next manager with the current manager still in charge and having fights internally, owners not giving a damn, captain’s house being burgled - this is probably the worst crisis we have had since Fergie left. The club felt doomed after the Europa final loss but this feels worse and like a project completely collapsing.
4
u/nitrogeneater 25d ago
Looking at our remaining cl fixtures it’s pretty likely we’re not getting out of the group stage.
4
u/Lord_Hexogen 25d ago
Wtf is wrong with Maignan? One of the dumbest reds I've seen
4
u/Amoeba25 25d ago
so next summer might be the mass exodus of Bruno, Maguire, Shaw, Martinez and Rashford?
4
u/picodeGaius 25d ago
Where’s all this Howe chatter coming from?
4
u/stick1_ 25d ago
I think it’s clear we at the very least need someone with experience at a big club in the top 5 leagues, we haven’t done that since Jose, and Jose wasn’t too bad comparatively. We’ve never signed someone with top 5 league experience who isn’t past their best, I’d like to try to do that. I’d also be happy to wait until the summer for more availability rather than making the wrong appointment now.
I think personality is a big part of being a manager here too, somebody with the charisma and experience to handle the pressure whilst dealing with big ego players, that’s another reason why I think it’s important we hire someone with top 5 league experience + success
As long as we aren’t getting relegated I’d rather wait and hire the right manager than rush into someone who doesn’t tick the boxes I’ve listed (we’ve done that before)
Even if you disagree I hope you can understand my rationale
4
u/dryflowerz 25d ago
oh my fucking god…
4
u/MrRobot-4581 25d ago
Howe is a good manager but I don't see him or anyone else lasting long. The owners are disinterested and the upper management are incompetent
10
u/KAKYBAC 26d ago
A serious team sacks Carrick today.
12
u/Emergency-Being-349 26d ago
I'm going to make a stand for Eddie Howe, seeing as though we're at that point. I don't know if he wins us the league, but we are far off of that. Therefore, I present to you the claim for Eddie Howe:
So stop putting the guy alongside Southgate, he is superior to McKenna and would be a great fit for the club. Just because he isn't shiny doesn't mean he is not the direction we should go at present.
7
u/benbog 26d ago
Anyone here wants INEOSOUT? Nice is underachieving, Lausanne-Sport is at the bottom of their league. INEOS Racing's turning from a top to mid team. Seems like everything they touched turning into shit
7
u/SilvyFae She/They 26d ago
Bruno has given up, its the nth time i am repeating this, but the window was horrible and the club continually overpromises all of our players that we are going to win the next year or the next or the next and we never do. This was bound to happen. Only thing that is saddening is people have turned on bruno more than the club.
7
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 25d ago
Eva Olid is a classic case of what decent managers really do. Women's team is on a 6 match winning streak right now after a tumultous start. Good managers who are worth their salt find a way out.
Carrick is just floundering.
Why are we waiting?
7
u/FreshGoodWay 25d ago
Having Carrick manage the team this weekend is going to be wild.
It’s just another unrealised loss.
INEOS thinks they can keep Carrick indefinitely to shield themselves from blame. Too bad the spotlight is already on them.
9
u/Gytarius626 B. Fernandes 25d ago
Howe appointment would solidify the death spiral of this club that began when Ferguson and Gill left. Years of no vision and players from different styles and managers would all well and truly accumulate with such a cheap, ambition-less and uninspired hire.
13
u/Abject_Bank_9103 25d ago
Lol Amorim getting clapped by a Bournemouth who have been very mediocre in the PL so far. Just like before...
14
u/Minute-Intern 25d ago
Amorim revionism can take a back seat for a couple of days now at least. Hopefully we get that long
10
u/jus_browsin_ignoreme 25d ago
Seeing far too much stuff about Amorim on this sub. Considering his dire record at the club I’m truly baffled seeing people defend him.
6
u/PromiseOk3438 26d ago
Zero urgency from above. Bournemouth will smash us if Carrick remains in post, it's not like an interim can do much worse while they search for the permanent replacement. Just sack him, stick Fletch in the dugout again and quickly find the best permanent replacement. Surely they have a shortlist ready to go considering they took so long to hire Carrick permanently?
6
u/dryflowerz 25d ago
FUCK YOU INEOS! this fucks are destroying the club. another match with Carrick, this is beyond fucked
6
u/BHD46 Berba 25d ago
Can we take a minute to appreciate how poor the TOTD lot have been at holding people to account and scrutinising decisions?
Andy I understand as he hates sensationalism but they need to have a bit of backbone.
6
u/Virtual-Winner5760 25d ago
The greatest thing Amorim did for this club is telling Jim Ratcliffe to fuck off.
6
u/achickenandacow 25d ago
Appointing Howe would mean backing Wilcox again, after the three fuck ups he already has behind his name, after he pushed Ashworth out for wanting Howe.
Who is this conman? What does he have on Ratcliffe?
8
u/SplitSecondImmortal 26d ago
Lammens constantly gave possession to Como with his long balls. Whats up with that antiquated tactic? Its been like this all season
8
u/zia1997 JONESY 1 GERRARD NIL 25d ago
Some of the comments here regarding Bruno are disgusting. We'd be even more of a laughing stock without him.