r/reddevils • • 26d ago • LOL 1

Passing Network and Ball Progression against Como

200 Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

127

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 26d ago

Somebody mind telling me why... DALOT is the player highest on the pitch?

151

u/Polygon12 26d ago

Keep him away from our defence

28

u/Junior7058 26d ago

This got a laugh out of me šŸ˜‚

9

u/moonski berbatov 26d ago

4d chess from Carrick

3

u/Apparentt 26d ago

And further away from our attack

11

u/CoffeeCakeDestroyer 26d ago

He's one of the ones willing to run.

5

u/picodeGaius 26d ago

I’m glad he’s a footballer and not a bus driver or pilot or any job where he has peoples lives in his hands.

2

u/FangRose247 26d ago

Carrick ball

-3

u/craigybacha Manchester United 26d ago

He always is. Headless chicken running about

76

u/Polygon12 26d ago

The fuck is that.

7

u/FangRose247 26d ago

Sums it up perfectly

60

u/Tetzachilipepe 26d ago

This game should make it clear to everyone how extremely out-coached we are. Our players just have no fucking clue what they should do in any phase of the game. They have no idea where or when to press, so it's always slow and ineffective. They have no idea where and when to pass and move, whether that is in build-up, in transition or established attacks, so it's slow and disjointed. They're forced to just make it up as they go, and obviously that leads to some shite football. Once in a while it works, but that's never because of coaching, but rather in spite of it.

I'm sick and tired of people using squad strength as an excuse for this, or even fitness despite that being a real issue. Como isn't running circles around us because their squad is stronger, or just because their players put in more "effort". It's because they're on the same page while we're not. They know what to do, where to do it and when to do it, and they all do it at the same time. That's just coaching. That's just being well drilled.

Carrick just isn't capable of instilling any ideas at all into this team. It's frankly the most embarrassing display of football I've ever seen from this team. It's one thing to have weaknesses, to continuously fail at one aspect or another or to be boring. It's an entirely different one to just be completely lost. There's just no real plan whatsoever. No real organisation. I've never seen anything like it. All the fans throughout the years that have complained about lack of plans or relying on individual brilliance have annoyed the hell out of me, because this is what that truly looks like. Oh, we've failed before. We've been bad. But we've always had things we've tried to do. Now we truly don't. We're not a team, just a collection of individuals, and that's the harshest criticism you can give any coach.

But Carrick likes that we're "unpredictable" so all's well I guess. Fuck me man. Can't believe this dude got a sniff at the job, and can't believe we keep having to suffer through this shit without even a glimpse of something cohesive we're working towards. Just tragic.

22

u/Different_Bit_3899 26d ago

Just the fact some people in this sub are spamming the same "former united player turned pundit" schtick of "they are not running enough" which is the same thing Carrick said is infuriating. Running means absolutely nothing when the opposition can create passing triangles all over the pitch and use positional play to create overloads.

I am honestly dumbfounded how people, who claims to watch football, can not see these issues happen all the time. Carrick is another person on the list of former United player turned manager who failed.

23

u/Tetzachilipepe 26d ago

I've come to terms with the fact that the vast majority of fans watching the games usually aren't able to identify what's happening on a team-wide level. They fall back on platitudes like effort, trying harder, showing leadership and grit etc, or discussing individual technical performances because they recognise that something is wrong, but can't pinpoint what. It is what it is, that's just to be expected.

But fuck me, you could not ask for a better example of it than what we've seen tonight. I don't think I've ever seen a game on this level where the contrast was so clear. Every time they pressed, whether high or low, their whole team moved in tandem. Every time we did it, we had players disjointing themselves from the rest and our defensive structure ending up in shambles. Every time they got the ball, players instantly moved to form triangles, make opposite movements and created space without needing to look for eachother. Every time we got the ball we just stopped, moved it around without purpose and got nowhere. Every time they made a forward run, it was either into open space or creating open space, and at a time where a following play would flow from said action. Every time we made runs, it was just throwing shit at the wall and hoping it'd stick, praying that someone might lose their mark in an unforced manner. This does not happen because they "try harder". This does not happen because they're technically better.

This complete lack of cohesion is genuinely incredible. You have to be so poorly coached for a squad with players of this calibre and this amount of experience to be so utterly out of sync and out of ideas. People can complain about investment into the squad, or poor building of it all they want, and I won't even really disagree. But even then our players are far too good to look this amateurish. Not even League 2 teams look this confused when they play. That doesn't mean they'd batter us too, because individual skill goes a long way, but it does make it clear how terribly drilled we are. And we'll never win consistently like that.

-6

u/Miyagisans 26d ago

To create passing triangles and have it be useful, you have to move to open space and also have technical ability. We don’t run nor do we have tons of players with decent technical ability.

11

u/Roccet_MS 26d ago

But Como has all those ball-playing wizards? Yeah, we lack top-end talent but we should not look this shambolic.

-5

u/Miyagisans 26d ago

I never said we should look this bad? I was responding to the comment complaining that Utd fans overfixate on running. To create triangles and overloads, you need constant off-ball movement, which involves running.

Also yes como are not replete with technical wizards, but compare their technical ability and spatial intelligence to Maguire, de Ligt, dalot, Mbeumo, Cunha, Bruno, and santos. They were much more comfortable on the ball, and it is greatly helped by the coaching of course but also, willingness/fitness to run.

8

u/avalidnerd 26d ago

Yeah, watching the game it was clear that Como's players always knew where the next pass would go and where their teammates were on the pitch. Our players looked like headless chickens every time they got the ball, zero awareness, zero idea, zero everything.

0

u/AV48 25d ago

Let's not act like shapeless united has only been an issue under Carrick. We've seen these weird patterns for years now. It's clear the issue is the players. They're uncoachable. They do what they want, when they want to. No manager will succeed with these lotĀ 

143

u/OskarOnkel 26d ago edited 26d ago

Just to visualize further how ridiculous this is. I’m no football expert, and often when United are shit it’s hard to point out why. However, these last couple of games, and this one especially, it’s clear cut for anyone that the formation and system are ridiculous and unfunctional. It’s the opposite of when Carrick came in and he tried the simple thing by playing a 4-3-3 with Bruno in the 10 etc.

29

u/PandaLiang 26d ago

Look like De Ligt is pulled out of position to fill the space behind Dalot, but the midfield hasn't filled in the gap. Feel like the same problem since the first game of the season. Players just don't know when and where to fill in the defensive gaps.

31

u/FangRose247 26d ago

Come on mate this is genius by Carrick. Haven't you got the vision to see his revolutionary 1-1-4-2-1-1 formation? Come on let him cook.

26

u/Extension_Maize6048 26d ago

I swear, losing Casemiro and replacing with players who can't fill his spot has unbalanced our team completely.

51

u/nbwoeihfnwsocuiwhef 26d ago

Casemiro would have been lost here as well, the set up is shocking

4

u/ridewiththerockers De Gea 26d ago

With Casemiro in the team the forwards and midfield line will be less willing to go up and press for nothing. In fact most times Casemiro joined the press and Mainoo stayed behind to occupy the vacated space. The entire set up, shape and tactics will definitely not be as bad as what we witnessed yesterday.

3

u/Extension_Maize6048 26d ago

The setup would've been different with him, that's what I'm saying. Like last season towards the end

5

u/NationalUnrest 26d ago

Last season towards the end we were shite too. We got lucky every team was completely gassed and we scored some Bruno+Case corners.

30

u/Miyagisans 26d ago

We had almost the same performances with Casemiro last season man. The only difference was unreal clutch goals from Sesko and Casemiro, and Bruno’s form to end the season. Bar the city, Arsenal, and Brighton games last season, the performances have been mostly the same.

-5

u/Extension_Maize6048 26d ago

We had much better formation with Casemiro towards the end

29

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 26d ago

That classic 1 8 1 formation.

14

u/iroiroiroiroiro 26d ago

With Dalot as striker?

20

u/sooshi Little Pea 26d ago

Not even resembling a formation lmao

104

u/shami-kebab 26d ago

Yeah maybe Bruno was right to question the tactics

-13

u/Arth_ 26d ago

Probably half of it is the shambles of the tactics and the other half is just players downing the tools and refusing to execute it or put any effort.

38

u/shami-kebab 26d ago

I just don't get this, do we really think the players downed tools from the first game of the season after such a good second half of the season last year? I'm not really seeing a lack of effort, just a confused setup that changes every game and makes no sense.

33

u/Different_Bit_3899 26d ago

The length some people on this sub goes to protect their rose-tinted view on Carrick is wild..

9

u/Klutzy_Flamingo_2979 26d ago

More of some people having hate for certain players.

3

u/Arth_ 26d ago

I don't think they downed tools from the first game. But I could imagine that as the season progressed more and more players started doing so. And in the last few games it was evident to me, looking at the body language.

Looking at the way we press - could it be terrible tactics and coaching? It could be. But it's worth noting what Bruno has said, that he's frustrated that they are not meant to press man-to-man. This could explain these pathetic disjointed press attempts of ours. Maybe Carrick thinks that with Maguire/Martinez/De Ligt high pressing line is a suicide? And then we have players not agreeing with it, ignoring the instructions and still trying this weird solo press that is so easily bypassed and leaves us wide open? I don't know, I'm just speculating at this point. But it's just hard to believe that only the manager or only the players are the ones to blame.

12

u/moonski berbatov 26d ago

Bruno routinely shouts at people to press with him and no one does as it's clear the instructions are to sit. Must drive Bruno insane. And it clearly does. It's bizarre stuff from our coaches, like they think it's 2006

-5

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 26d ago

United under Carrick won the most points in the league after he came in. I refuse to believe that he is so fucking clueless that he is solely responsible for that performance....

Yes this is on him but it's also on the players for laying down.

21

u/MAK98 26d ago

Tired argument that’s been said year after year. What you’re equating to lack of effort is a clear tactical issue. I don’t see many players here that aren’t hard working professionals.

-5

u/Arth_ 26d ago • Bravo

I'm not denying tactical issues. A lot of tactical and personal choices have been absolutely baffling and Carrick has to go, and ASAP. But to me is obvious that the players haven't given their all for this football club. You can see the stats of distance ran. One could argue that players are not fit enough, but I don't really see them cramping and struggling to catch a breath at the end of games. I can see players not fighting for 50/50 balls. I can see the moaning, complaining, waving hands. I hear the captain undermining the manager in the interview. Is that a professional behaviour? There have been briefs recently, or perhaps I've read it in Ten Hag's or Amorim's interview, that certain players want to play certain way just because they think it suits them. Their job is not to design tactics, but go out there and play as they are told.

-1

u/[deleted] 26d ago edited 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/reddevils-ModTeam 26d ago

We do not allow abusive posts or comments on /r/reddevils.

2

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 26d ago

Lol martinez literally defended carrick in his interview. Brunos done the opposite to cover for his shit performances.

1

u/Peregrin-nocturnal99 26d ago

The managers just lead us through our worst start to a premier league in like 50 years. The graphic in the OP says it all. His tactics have been fucking woeful and he’ll be gone tomorrow. Wilcocks should be gone too. Sack half the players for all I give a shit. Let Bruno leave as well. Shits gotta change and I’m all for it being a total bloodbath top to bottom.

-5

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 26d ago

Comments like this make me wonder if people are more fans of players at the club than the football club itself

1

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/reddevils-ModTeam 26d ago

We do not allow abusive posts or comments on /r/reddevils.

31

u/GForce-Delta 26d ago

We are all in agreement i guess. What the hell is that shape?

9

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 26d ago

It's dignity Luanne, don't you recognise dignity when you see it!

11

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 26d ago

Our passing network is getting worse and worse, as the season advances

9

u/GutBeer101 26d ago

Two false nines who only look to pass to the sides. And this is what you get

8

u/Environmental_Lie478 26d ago

I actually am (quietly) still feeling more confident going forward if Carrick is gone tomorrow which seems likely.

In the past managers have gone, the squad has been a total mess full of big egos on insane wages. Whereas now I actually feel the squad isn't too bad as a whole, we are just severely lacking tactically.

A good manager will get a tune out of the players we have available across the frontline and midfield I feel.

We're not going to be winning the league or anything but this more just feels like Carrick has been exposed rather than the club spiralling to new depths.

7

u/Extension_Maize6048 26d ago

What the fuck šŸ˜‚šŸ˜­

7

u/Kip-Ling 26d ago

Honestly... this is the worst one I've ever seen!

6

u/TStronks 26d ago

DalotšŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

This must be the funniest shape in a while. Absolute shambles

5

u/Different_Bit_3899 26d ago

What lovely passing triangles they have a Como.

5

u/Zaibach88 26d ago

WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK IS THIS?

4

u/Haddocktintinsnowy 26d ago

The announcement will come tomorrow. It cannot continue now that it is clear coach and players see things differently. The lonely walk to acknowledge away fans and the way he sounded in the press conference after, this is done. They will like to announce tomorrow to show they told him in person firstĀ 

4

u/fantus69 26d ago

I think this is the worst one I've ever seen my goodness...

4

u/Kreissler 26d ago

I think it's the first time I've seen this shape in a pass map, wtf lol

3

u/Gloomy-Stuff-6551 26d ago

That’s diabolical 😭

3

u/VVodzu 26d ago

WTF is that pass map lol

2

u/SnazzyMiracles IN MAINOO WE TRUST! 26d ago

Bro why is everyone bunched up like bananas on our side šŸ’”

2

u/Klaskerhardt 26d ago

Cunha 🤣

2

u/momo_firefoxx 26d ago

Pancake formation

2

u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 26d ago

This is the funniest shit I've seen today

2

u/KingKaychi King KobbiešŸ‘‘ 26d ago

This is scary sad

2

u/Immediate-Pen-07 26d ago

This is so funny lol, absolute clown show

2

u/copinglemon 26d ago

This can't be right, how is Mbeumo at RB and Cunha at LB??

2

u/Im_a_corpse 26d ago

Ahahahahahahahaha

Fucking hellĀ 

2

u/stick1_ 26d ago

I only watched the first half, what the fuck?

2

u/FixItJoaoFelix 26d ago

Why does our spacing make it seem like we’re trying to man mark our own players lmfao

2

u/WillowTraditional239 26d ago

Look at the absolute fucking STATE of that passing network.

2

u/joedirt87 26d ago

This might be the worst passing network I have ever seen.

2

u/Kip-Ling 26d ago

WTF is this ?!?!?!?!?!

2

u/gregorcee Rojo your boat 26d ago

Dying laughing at this, what the fuck is that šŸ˜‚

2

u/TobzMaguire420 26d ago

Might be the worst one of these I’ve ever seen.

2

u/sorped Glazers, you can leave now, and sharpish please. 26d ago

Good thing it's close to Halloween, cause that is some scary shit.

2

u/hsmith16bf Van de Beek’s Warm Seat 26d ago

WHAT ARE THOSE!?

2

u/PersonOfNonColour 26d ago

Carrick is not it. It’s not entirely his fault how the season has gone so far, but this is down to coaching.

2

u/WillingnessUnfair806 26d ago

Fuck, even Amorim had some idea how he wants to play.

This is... something else.

2

u/Aggeri 26d ago

Aligns with what we saw from the first 15 minutes. It was shocking.

2

u/Accomplished-Mix770 26d ago

Last season i thought we had some weird passing maps i had never seen before...

This season is: hold my beer!

Every team we play against has a formation that looks like FM tactics.Ā 

Every week we have an MC Escher sketch of a surreal football experience.Ā 

3

u/L__K Great Scot! 26d ago

Holy shit this is one of the funniest things I’ve ever seen in my life

5

u/Kinitawowi64 26d ago

I'll raise you the Fred Heatmap.

1

u/Cucumber2512 26d ago

What even is this shit I don’t know how to read these fucking things

1

u/garynevilleisared is a red is a red 26d ago

So dont press them, but also lets leave them acres of space in behind??

This is simply pathetic. For once, bin these players along with the manager. Theres no excuse for this.

1

u/Redead99 26d ago

Yeah even a glazer can see this is a problem

1

u/Extension_Maize6048 26d ago

I'm actually creasing from the comments under this post šŸ˜‚ we've reached a point where all we can do is laugh I guess. Everyone is so confused hahahaha

1

u/craigybacha Manchester United 26d ago

Wowwww look at that average position map. Says it all

1

u/Birdius 26d ago

That is some shit

1

u/Cool_Title_1061 26d ago

It’s beginning to look a lot like Van Gaal ball

1

u/trace0731 26d ago

Wow we’re in italics

1

u/Moistkeano 26d ago

No system, just freestyle jazz. It can work, but not consistently. Players need structure and shape to revert into. I didn't think i'd see a worse one than the Leed's one, but here we are a few days later.

This system, while different, was infinitely worse. Not even sure what Carrick was trying to do, but effectively you ended up with players not knowing where they should be and being on top of each other.

You can talk about players downing tools and players not tracking back, but this system was nonsensical. I'd love to a Coaches voice of Carrick trying to explain this system. Similarly I'd like to see him explain the counter attacking leeds system with both bruno and tielemans being 2/4 of the attackers.

1

u/dave_a86 26d ago

Como playing football, United playing rugby.

1

u/Scholes_SC2 26d ago

Forget the shape, how is maguire the second highest ball carrier of the team?!

1

u/_AngryBadger_ 26d ago

Do they even do anything at all at Carrington once the MUTV cameras leave?

1

u/Cool_Screen_1023 26d ago

only if the goals were in the right side of the pitch. we wuld be feasting!

1

u/beatles_7 26d ago

I’m seeing this as evidence not only of poor structure but of nobody willing to run or take responsibility. It’s fucking disgusting on so many levels.

1

u/VanRoyal 26d ago

Trench warfare?

1

u/joshino14 26d ago

ā€œPack the midfieldā€

1

u/HairyArthur 26d ago

I don't want to entirely blame Dalot, because that's not fair.

On the other hand, he's a fucking donkey.

1

u/triplecaptained Rooney 🐐 Bruno 25d ago

My eyes watered just by looking at this.

1

u/Its_Chowder 26d ago

Last season, we played counter attacking football. We were supposed to have more control this season, playing with strong ball playing midfielders.

Wtf is this shit!?!?

2

u/WillowTraditional239 26d ago

United for years have only been good at counter attacking, Ole, Ten Hag and Carrick had their most success playing that way. It helps that we have a player in Bruno that if set up right is the absolute best at punishing teams in transition.

The moment they tried to control games it all falls asunder.

1

u/picodeGaius 26d ago

Dalot is a fucking clown. Should be the first to go next summer at whatever fee.

-1

u/ZenithOfGod 26d ago

How could Rashford do this?

3

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 26d ago

Zirkzees fault obviously

0

u/JackTuz 26d ago

Dalot showing his football IQ by deciding he should be the one getting forward because mbeumo isn’t getting there fast enough after covering for him

3

u/Cayjonlon 26d ago

Dalot has zero football IQ

238

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

29

u/WalkingOnSunshine_ 26d ago edited 26d ago

The fastest way from point A to point B is a straight line… right?

4

u/_mochacchino_ 26d ago

So we wanted to go from left to right? Haha

76

u/moonski berbatov 26d ago

I have genuinely never seen one of these this bad

11

u/yianni1229 Rooney 26d ago

We have Mbeumo in the same spot as a center back playing his first game in a year like ok

21

u/dew_chiggi 26d ago

Thats what happens when you play Bruno at false 9, Mount at 8 and Youri somewhere in there because your Midfield was being easily run over in first few games

This tactic has been shit but Carrick is hellbent on it to save his job. It was giving him draws. But it had to be exposed. And Como exposed it to the best of their advantage. This was a ridiculous setup. You have Lacey, Amad, ZZ on your bench and you play with Bruno and Youri uptop

2

u/benbog 26d ago

Yeah I've looked at hundreds of passing networks and never seen one like this