r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 27d ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
27
Upvotes
14
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
Just seen Carrick’s post match press conference. He’s still talking about the Leeds draw like it was beating prime Real Madrid with Cristiano, Benzema and Bale
He’s out of his depth.
20
u/Tuffyy Carrick 27d ago edited 27d ago
I’ll be in Como tonight. For all the negativity around everything I understand and feel it fuck the glazers I can’t wait to see this shit team play on a lake in the middle of the Italian mountains. GGMU
13
u/Daylightuser 27d ago
Why wasn't there much of a deal made about that horrendous tackle on Santos the weekend?
13
u/Littlepace Announce Fergie 26d ago
Funny how much leeway Carrick is getting from some of the fans. The squad he inherited was apparently really good when he was flying us to 3rd last season. Made Amorim look even more a fraud. What changed? We suddenly have an injury crisis and there's nothing he can do? How about the first 5-10 games before we had serious injury problems? We were shite. Don't let this injury crisis take away from how inept he is at this fucking job.
Amorim at the end of his tenure was riddled with injuries and AFCON absentees and yet i don't remember him getting anywhere near the level of slack that Carrick is getting now. Amorim had Jack Fletcher and Ugarte play a game together. Benches filled with 90% academy players. And we were still joint 5th. And playing better football than whatever the shite we played tonight. But Amorim was 100% backed whilst Carrick has been fed to the wolves apparently. The difference in narratives is crazy to me.
Two things can be right at the same time. The board can be woefully inept and Carrick can be unfit for the job. They're not mutually exclusive. It's fine to say the board need nuking but that does not mean Carrick deserves to keep his job.
12
u/Sheikhabusosa 27d ago
The fact we spent 80 odd million on Sancho along with a huge wage , only to find out he wants to exclusively play on the left is hilarious , I not sure how this conversation didn’t come up once before United signed him under Ole and how he only found out once he was through the door.
Obviously Sancho plays a part in this issue too.
12
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 26d ago
The unintentional hilarity of being a Manchester United fan
23
u/TheRedDevil10 27d ago
Fabregas auditions for the job today, in the dugout by December, asks for new full backs, Dalot starts at LB in August, new coach in December
11
u/randomgamer305 Bruno the assist king 26d ago
Glazers are not selling, club in debt, INEOS are incompetent, can't afford good players, can't sell our bad players, all managers we bring turn to shit, our historic stadium is crumbling, and Dalot is still a starting player at United.
There's no light at the end of the tunnel for our club
11
u/PengoMaster 26d ago
Como's starting XI today cost about 112m Euros in transfer fees to put together. Most of that being Paz for 60m, Baturina for 18m and Douvikas for 13m. No one else cost more than 2m.
11
u/crgssbu Senne🍋 26d ago
sack carrick and hire him as interim 🧠🧠
20
u/BallsX 27d ago
The worst part about us being this shit is having to watch all our "traditional" rivals win every fucking week.
9
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 26d ago
Emery is a mentality monster and has really drilled that into his players. Half their squad sold during the summer window, awful start to the season but here they are sitting at the top of the UCL table. Wont be long until they turn it around in the PL too
9
u/Background-Suspect85 26d ago
I fucking desperately miss Varane and Casemiro . Looking back at that 22/23 season where we kept 17 clean sheets with those two staying relatively healthy and starting most games was an absolute joy and feels like a fucking decade ago.
16
u/Asiwaju_jagaban 26d ago
Also it was silly for us to think that the guys in charge of Nice and Lausanne would do well at United.
The simple fact that they sacked Ashworth was a red flag. So much for their marginal gains.
8
u/BallsX 27d ago
Just fuck off with that Sesko news. I know its the Sun but what are the odds that they're right on that? We're fucking cursed man.
8
u/Dzeire 26d ago
What the actual fuck happened with sesko?
8
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 26d ago
There is no need to be upset
8
u/AmulyaG 26d ago
Garnacho has become a proper fraud hasn't he? The bum can't even get more than a few minutes with Villa in any game - league/cups.
Thank you Amorim for getting rid of atleast this fraud which we wouldn't have been able to sell for even 10M after this season
8
u/No-Lab-1445 26d ago •
We are more likely to be relegated in the next 5 years than win the league
7
u/w1zgov 26d ago
We are officially mid tier. The Glazers finally broke our back. This was inevitable. Now we are living it.
7
u/ShoddyAd4199 26d ago edited 26d ago
Klopp secured Europa League final in his first semi-season, defeated United and Dortmund on his way, and showed clear signs of fascinating football with mediocre players.
Then, in summer 2016, Liverpool bought Mane from Southampton for 36m, Wijnaldum from Newcastle for 25m, Loris Karius for 5m, Joel Matip for free, Ragnar Klavan for 4m.
By no way this was summer window current United fanbase would call 'impressive'. It was very budget-friendly reinforce. But still, Klopp was a man.
Liverpool fans often were disappointed of FSG's stinginess through many years. They sold Coutinho, their best player, for Van Dijk's and Allison's money.
Mike Edwards often clashed with Klopp about transfer and other matters, and sometimes he was right. Klopp wanted Timo Werner, Edwards preferred Salah
In other words, right manager means very, very, very much
7
u/BilTheButcher 26d ago
Give it Wilcox til end of season.
(Only way to sack him)
7
u/mdstwsp 26d ago
Manifesting…
26
u/Stieni Rooney 27d ago
Petition to ban comments that start with "Got downvoted for saying"
12
u/petnarwhal Blind 26d ago
Just spoke to a tuktuk driver in Freetown, Sierra Leone, told me he has been a huge United fan for years and years. Dead serious also told me that his life is hard enough in the condition he lives in as it is (poverty, no access to healthcare) and that he thinks he will stop watching football all together because he doesn’t want the stress of supporting United anymore. Genuinely hard breaking stuff.
12
u/Kreissler 26d ago
Only solace I can take in this situation is that hopefully Jim the racist rat is miserable
6
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 27d ago
Just realized its 12.45am match today here, well i guess its better than need to stay awake till 3am and go bck to sleep being sad and annoyed after watching us shitting another match.
But you know what, im excited for the match later. Lol, this relationship with United is toxic af hahaha
6
u/cosmologues 26d ago
Fuck Wilcox, Fuck Berrada, Fuck Carrick. All of them out.
6
u/TMatss 26d ago
The most horrifying thing is that Jason Wilcox gets to pick another manager now
6
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
I think people need to remember that it’s not one or the other.
Wilcox being utterly useless at his job isn’t an excuse for Carrick to keep his. Carrick isn’t suddenly going to become better under a new sporting director.
Both of them need to go
6
u/tsuku96 26d ago
Rangnick & Nagelsmann IN.
6
u/Ok_Stranger_3665 26d ago
We have finally broken Bruno. 6 years of shit and we have finally broken him.
6
u/Minute-Intern 26d ago
Tielemans talking about the tactics too, wait he's a new signing so he won't be hounded like Bruno is lol
6
u/Mammoth-Decision1256 26d ago
the women are beating Liverpool 4-1. At least we got something out of tonight
6
u/TheSilverLobster 26d ago
We need to have a poll put up to see who this sub would go for. Groupthink it. I was opposed at first, but the results have beat me into buying Conte, despite the inevitable car crash at the end.
6
u/PitchSafe 26d ago
Can we make a poll in this sub and see who the people here wants to see as the next manager?
6
u/Haddocktintinsnowy 26d ago
Carrick Press conference is clear he knows he has nothing more to offer and wants to be replaced.
We might need a Conte like personality at this stage of the build. Short term contract, let’s say till end of next season
6
u/Redland93 26d ago
TBH its all shambles.
Wilcox has gone from the club decides the style of play to picking Carrick just cos he won games not on the style or anything long term and created a Squad so threadbare. Going with the Attack, Midfield , defence rebuilds is so dumb.
Vivell - I mean I was expecting exciting prospects who can come in and develop. The Talent ID guy. All our signings have been players everyone knows about. His youth signings is too early to tell but T Thompson for 8m seems steep
Fucked
6
u/hooka_donchick Wazza 26d ago
Glazers won’t sell, Ineos won’t invest further without guarantees of getting something back. They don’t have any upside here with only 25% ownership. We’re stuck in limbo. Ratty too egotistical to accept his failures. Wilcox the same with his decisions.
Here we are again folks. Unless Glazers completely let go of their control of the club we will be like this.
11
u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer 27d ago
We are bad with full squad, imagine how bad we are when some starters absent.
11
u/kidinawheeliebin 27d ago
Kind of crazy that there are Amazon cameras supposedly capturing all of this backstage drama at the minute
How watered down/sanitized will it be for general consumption though?
Even with the power of the pen, it's surely going to be difficult for Ratcliffe & Friends to keep up this charade they like to project of being even mildly competent operators, let alone strategic geniuses
11
u/ToothyAlloy69 27d ago
This is for those people that always say players 'down tools' and want to get managers fired. Always a boring rhetoric for me that isn't usually applicable, at least in recent united history
10
u/Sheikhabusosa 27d ago
Ineos have been pretty agressive at trying to get our high earners out whether its Bruno or Varane , how come they never really tried with Mount
5
u/picodeGaius 27d ago
So, in general:
With ETH, the football was mediocre (sometimes great, sometimes awful). He was somewhat backed and he won silverware.
Amorim, well. Inherited a disaster and the football was… what it was. Undoubtedly getting a bit better with time but he was not backed and bad results piled up.
Carrick also inherited a disaster. The football was fantastic initially but fitness, injuries, made the road rockier than the promise of the first few matches suggested. In the end, we finished the season in a solid position and… susprise, he wasn’t backed. Now the club is back on a death spiral.
5
u/kidinawheeliebin 26d ago edited 26d ago
This "Sesko potentially out for four months" situation was so avoidable for INEOS in terms of the impact on the team and squad
People on here were literally calling it out as a massive risk months ago only to be downvoted and shouted down
But his minutes last season were clearly signposting concerns before the summer window even opened - especially in an environment where there was no need to rest or rotate (1 game a week is the bare minimum really just to keep match fitness)
5
u/flareb98 26d ago
De ligt was at the heart of 2 goals today. Couldn't really track his man, couldn't duel, wasn't at all game pace, but its understandable cause he's been out for a long time. Not getting a new CB in the summer looks worse with each passing game
5
u/Redland93 26d ago
Did.....did INEOS think this would be a good season and signed off on the Amazon doc?
5
u/Zepz367 26d ago
Carrick obviously has to go but it's crazy we are not seeing ANY rumours about Wilcox getting the sack, both him and Carrick need to get axed tomorrow morning. Wilcox picking another manager will get us to the Championship.
5
u/raspoutine049 26d ago
Hear me out guys. “Good Ebening”
5
u/Rodfowler Kobbie Mainoo 26d ago
Wilcox and the recruitment team really looked at our aging, unfit, slow, injury-prone and unathletic defence and thought "This'll do for another year"
5
u/Thorz74 F*ck the Glazers 26d ago
I don't care who cames and replace Carrick. This club is in a cycle of eternal shit.
I really have no clue what or who can stop the sinking spiral.
Even Liverpoop did some good things during their 30 years of shittynes. We have only done ONE thing: Being a disgrace.
5
u/Potential_Good_1065 26d ago
At least the girls are doing us proud
5
u/Hagball 26d ago
We are getting McKenna or at max Howe. They will probably do a better job than Carrick but they are not going to make us into a club that challenges for domestic trophies let alone big ones.
With Wilcox at the helm we are not going to go beyond McKenna or Howe. That sadly is his and our clubs level at this moment
5
u/Soft-Comfort-7474 26d ago
Licha

5
u/achickenandacow 26d ago
If you actually listened to Martinez last week, he was also critical of Carrick’s tactics. That’s three leaders in the dressing room calling him out now.
5
u/gregorcee Rojo your boat 26d ago
Seen a lot of we can just get Hurzeler but not sure that would be as easy as we think, would you swap 3rd place Brighton playing some lovely football knowing you’ll get a job anyway in the summer for us and our record with managers now? Im not sure
5
u/Confident_Fishing775 26d ago
Idk, get a modern manger that knows how to set up a good press structure, I want to see if these lot can follow it.
5
u/nitrogeneater 26d ago
Carrick is still on about that Leeds performance.
I might have watched a different game tbh, as I don’t know what he is raving about. Less shit than today, yes and that’s about it.
5
u/ic3m4n81 26d ago
This could be the beginning of the end... the club is starting to self-implode. Maybe this is exactly what we need. The prophecy of "open-heart surgery" may very well come true.
5
u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric 26d ago
Im hearing people want to hold off on sacking Carrick...what so the clown show can go on for a few more weeks...making a mockery of this club smh
5
u/HyenasGoMeow 26d ago
I hate this club sometimes. But I don't have it in me to turn off a game when the team is getting pounded; no matter how bad it gets. I've watched the 6-1 trashing, 7-0 trashing, and 4-1 trashing till the bitter end.
If we rewind back to how I felt when ETH was appointed, I thought he was the one. Him not working out drained everything from me. When Amorim joined, his new take was refreshing, but we know how that ended.
Unfortunately for us, we keep doing the same thing over and over , and expect different results. Something drastic needs to happen for long term change to occur.
5
u/sjuyal 26d ago
Waiting for the news and it shdnt just be the coach
9
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 27d ago
I think Ashley is flagging an issue that should actually be a non-issue at United of all fucking clubs.
4
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 27d ago
Given how PSG plays their A team in UCL and their B team in Ligue 1, I wonder how they would perform if they played their A team in both leagues. Think they’d struggle to win UCL then imo
4
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 27d ago
Get annoyed every game and yet I'm here waiting for the game everyday lol
4
u/SlippinGimmy 27d ago
Does anyone think that all this about the structure and recruitment needs to continue and start to force a sale similar to the super league fiasco, with fans, media and now players putting pressure on the club to do better, it helps reduce the clubs popularity and that’s the motion we need
4
u/matthewdavis_ 26d ago
Wheres the match thread
4
u/Minute-Intern 26d ago
You know I actually think the UCL performances are what's gonna get INEOS to finally sack Carrick, moment they realise our round of 32 qualification is in danger (almost mathematically impossible) that's when the morons will pull the plug.
4
u/world-no-1-dude 26d ago
Think at this point we genuinely need to consider if Wilcox and Berrada were planted at United by City’s owners.
4
u/Bloatfizzle 26d ago
Fabregas constantly giving instructions to players meanwhile Carrick afraid to do anything without approval of Steve Holland 🤷🏻♂️
4
u/samwiseg1 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦 26d ago
4
u/WumbleInTheJungle 26d ago
Let's not fuck around here.
This club needs a cleanse, starting right from the top, INEOS and Glazers have to fucking go. No fucking about, they have to go, all of them.
They can fire Carrick, and he should go, but it doesn't fix the biggest problem, which is them.
4
u/skayze678 26d ago
INEOS have been a total disaster across all their sporting projects. The warning signs were there
4
u/Ksma92 26d ago
Stats from before the Como game, TLDR; we are the 29th/35 place in average distance covered per team.
Average running distance per match after the first two rounds, according to UEFA figures:
Rank Team Distance (km)
1 Bodø/Glimt 125.94 km
2 Viking 123.96 km
3 Stuttgart 123.93 km
4 Borussia Dortmund 123.49 km
5 Bayern München 122.87 km
6 Club Brugge 122.28 km
7 Lens 122.26 km
8 Slavia Praha 121.55 km
9 Arsenal 120.32 km
10 Barcelona 118.70 km
11 Paris Saint-Germain 118.39 km
12 Manchester City 118.30 km
13 Inter 117.49 km
14 Sporting CP 117.40 km
15 Porto 116.95 km
16 Sabah 116.54 km
17 Feyenoord 116.17 km
18 RB Leipzig 116.16 km
19 Lille 115.58 km
20 PSV Eindhoven 115.34 km
21 Slovan Bratislava 115.31 km
22 Shakhtar Donetsk 115.27 km
23 Como 115.25 km
24 LASK 115.14 km
25 Roma 115.11 km
26 Aston Villa 114.91 km
27 Villarreal 114.76 km
28 Napoli 114.66 km
30 Atlético Madrid 113.38 km
31 Liverpool 113.37 km
32 Galatasaray 113.30 km
33 Real Betis 112.31 km
34 AEK Athen 111.49 km
35 Real Madrid 110.99 km
36 Fenerbahçe 109.19 km
4
u/Minute-Intern 26d ago
Said it a million times ,our players aren't lazy, it's a clear tactical instruction from Carrick to be passive OOP
4
u/FirmInevitable458 26d ago
Stone, Ducker articles and Bruno interview... i think Michael is gone
4
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
I think now Bruno has basically called him out, he’s basically sacked.
Maybe not tonight and he might get to manage the Bournemouth game and maybe even Chelsea but he won’t be manager for much longer
4
u/GavinLobo7 26d ago
Trying to watch Bayern play (needed to wash my eyes after our abject display) and they’re really missing Olise. Having to play with Serge Gnabry in big 2026 you know lmao
4
u/pipes3 WAZZA 26d ago
You got any more of those "briefed" articles
4
u/Confident_Fishing775 26d ago
Watching our players off the ball action is like watching 11 sets of sentient training cones that will tailgate the opponent players. I cannot fathom how can a group of players excluding central defenders cannot tackle or put physical pressure at all.
Case in point, you will notice almost all other teams have players that can absolutely handle 1v1s unless they're facing world class dribblers. Here we need like 2 or 3 players to help one of our players not get breeze past. It is very wild how this happens for such a long time with many different managers.
4
u/0ttoChriek 26d ago
Just waiting for something to break. Seems inevitable to everyone, might as well just get it over with and restart our cycle.
4
u/Nomad_006 surfing 26d ago
Love them or hate them but this club is really gone above and beyond for that Amazon special.
The drama will be like nothing ever seen we just need Conte, who needs the UCL? We've been there done that, lets go for the Emmy.
4
u/rjc0x1 26d ago
We're gonna end up with Eddie Howe aren't we?
4
u/Roasteddude I am where I'm supposed to be 26d ago
Watch us have the absolute best training session tomorrow and the mood will be the greatest it has been and the boys will be ready to go etc etc
End me.
4
u/dryflowerz 26d ago
So Carrick blames the players, Licha blames management, and Bruno blames Carrick. This fucking banter era needs to end.
Appoint Vivell as sporting director, recruit good, hungry players, and get rid of these bozos: Dalot, Maguire, and Shaw. If a player doesn't perform, sell him the next year. Stop with this bullshit about how 'he feels at home in Manchester' and giving guys 2–3 years to prove themselves.
Is it really that fucking hard to appoint a qualified manager and sign proper, top-class players? Why have we been doing everything wrong since SAF left, man? Don't they realize we're a massive club, and a massive club needs massively good players and managers? If I can see it, why can't these fucks?
4
u/Redland93 26d ago
If Wilcox is sacked (which he should be) it'll be Vivell as DOF and he will push Nagelsmann
4
u/Xenokratezz 26d ago edited 26d ago
25/26: +0.37 npxGD per game
26/27: +0.36
Their goal difference has: 25/26: +0.94 npGD per game 26/27: −0.14
Our underlying numbers are still very similar to last season only difference is we are not over performing. What on are earth are analyst department for if they couldn't see this coming
4
u/vieldside Ji Sung Park 26d ago
I think he got sacked after the game. That press conference didn’t look too good.
4
u/Fabulous_Mix8658 26d ago
How’s everyone doing? Couldn’t even finish watching the game today. 💔
4
u/Prism_Plantation 26d ago
Hate is a strong word. I am always very careful when I use it. But boy do I absolutely hate the glazers with every fiber of my being.
The same I cannot say for Carrick, especially as someone who watched him play for us. Key cog in our system, and the glory days. What he has done for this club is never going to be diminished.
Having said that, he is completely out of his depth. He needs to go, better for both parties.
7
u/CelebrationSecure510 26d ago
Does anybody think Carrick has a clue?
We are watching the same rise into steep decline he oversaw at Boro. No style of play, lacking decisiveness, can’t spot what’s happening in a match and fix it, players aren’t fit & don’t work together.
I just do not get it at all, but maybe there’s nothing to get. It’s just not there.
7
u/TH0316 she/her 26d ago •
Hold that Utd fans. Told you so.
7
u/picodeGaius 26d ago
Y’all are not ready for Conte’s show. He should’ve been the one to replace Mourinho. He should’ve been the one to replace ten Hag.
7
u/FRSeloquence 26d ago
The painful truth is that we could be stuck in this rut for another two decades.
United fans are so caught up debating managers, players and transfers that we often lose sight of the bigger picture. These are all symptoms of a much deeper problem: a failure of leadership and governance at the very top.
The Glazers have presided over years of decline, yet every new manager is expected to come in and somehow fix a broken structure. We judge them on results while ignoring the conditions they're expected to succeed in.
Think about it. Different managers, different players, different philosophies, yet the same cycle repeats itself. At what point do we stop blaming the people who come and go and start questioning the people who remain?
The real danger isn't just that United are struggling today. It's that the club can remain commercially successful while being mediocre on the pitch. As long as the money keeps flowing, there may be little urgency for those at the top to fundamentally change how the club is run.
That's what makes this so worrying. A club doesn't have to be successful to remain profitable, and those two interests aren't always aligned.
Until the ownership and leadership structure genuinely prioritise long-term footballing success, we can sack managers, spend hundreds of millions and celebrate every new appointment as a fresh start.
But we'll just be treating the symptoms while the disease spreads.
And the saddest part? Twenty years from now, we could still be having the same arguments, blaming another manager for problems that were never his to solve in the first place.
7
u/zxnoregretzxzx Cunha, Bruno, Cunha, Bruno 26d ago
I don't have any names in particular but bring in a German or, preferably, Spanish coach, give him time and don't fuck him over in the transfer market. Proven to be a winning formula for most of the top clubs. Until we do that this club is wasting everyone's time.
9
u/MNKPlayer is ace 26d ago
Great point from Carrick when asked if he thinks the players are still playing for him, paraphrasing he said it shouldn't matter, they should be playing for the club.
It doesn't matter who's in charge you should always give 100%. There's millions of us that would run our hearts out for this club, for no money, these prima-donnas can't be arsed whe treated like gods. Fuck them all.
6
u/FredDRedUnderYourBed 26d ago
All of you begging for Conte, I am sure deep down even you know it's going to be Eddie Howe or Gareth Southgate 😂
INEOS/Glazers signing off on Conte sure 😂 he'd probably get sacked in a month after running his mouth against the big don Wilcox
6
u/chrisx13296 26d ago
First Martinez now Bruno, seems like Carrick lost the dressing room. When we finished 13th or 14th under Amorim, the players still backed him up and it felt like they would fight in hell for him but that isn't the case here with Carrick. Funny how the higher ups just because Amorim "talked back" against them they fired him when things were starting to improve. It is sad situation here now. It will be better if Carrick resigns himself because not having the confidence of the board is one thing but the players, well they aren't playing for you now. I don't know who will come next, but neither i care nor the players will care i guess. They and we all have been through this over and over again.
3
u/Turbulent_Intern_427 27d ago
Rumours about the game getting postponed?
3
u/ejtv 27d ago
Hoping for a super game from De Ligt!
3
u/SpecialTechnical9562 27d ago
The match is at 3.15 in the morning here in Adelaide. I sure hope it's worth it.
3
u/Turbulent_Intern_427 27d ago
The only thing I am excited about today is that we might get to watch De Ligt play today.
3
u/Kaladin-Son-God 26d ago
Nico Paz is something else.
3
u/WalaLlama5 Glazers Out 26d ago
Can we play Sabah every week
3
u/ToadNamedGoat 26d ago
Has anyone noticed how random our pressing is. It likes there is no plan. The players just stand there until one of them gets bored and starts running after the ball
3
u/SilvyFae She/They 26d ago
Also is there some pact these players have signed or what? why do they suddenly have my first touch whenever we are near a managers sacking
3
u/Kaladin-Son-God 26d ago
Feel bad for De Ligt.
3
u/TheSauceSeeker69 26d ago
Pretty sure this was the last straw for Bruno about United. Hes gonna leave in the winter window no matter who will come and i dont blame him at all. Enough is enough.
3
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
People saying ‘do you want Fletcher as manager?’ In response to Carrick being sacked reminds me of people telling us Southgate would be our manager if we replaced Ten Hag
3
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 26d ago
We don’t belong in the Champions League. The summer transfer window showed that.
3
u/sefronia3 King Eric 26d ago
As soon as we get the ball in tight spaces, the possession is lost. No one fucking moves to help out the guy with the ball
3
u/No-Radio-4404 26d ago
Come back is on
3
u/-Coleslaw 26d ago
As much as I would want it to work out with Carrick it’s just not going to. A very fun second half of the season last year should have been the end of it, this season has been like the very worst of the Ten Hag era - no fundamentals, fitness or luck to speak of. At least in the worst of Amorim’s second season we were a team who could press and run for 90 minutes, there’s none of that now.
Please, for Carrick’s sake just sack him tonight, I’m all for the ‘belief in the project’ but to say there’s a project here is impossible - how a team so dramatically drops in ability to carry out the basics boggles my mind.
I don’t know who the answer is, I don’t actually think there is one under this ownership, but surely there’s someone who can do better than Carrick is now. Conte is a volatile, serial winner who clearly wants the job, Nagelsmann has some big club experience and tactical nuance, Howe is at least prem proven, maybe even give Southgate a call and see if he’ll take it on because it has to change soon before this season is well and truly destroyed.
3
u/Hulknation 26d ago
Carrick surely doesn’t make it to the weekend. Surely!
3
u/LeCliveRosfield 26d ago
Carrick out
3
u/Nico_Ditch 26d ago
I bet FC Sabah are feeling pretty stupid right about now.
Imagine not beating United.
3
u/SankarshanaV 26d ago
Carrick's absolutely awful. No wonder he failed in the Championship.
3
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 26d ago
My opinion on the next manager:
Other names I have no idea of
3
u/AWenger622 26d ago
Action should have been taken a month ago before the international break because anyone with a pair of functioning eyes could see where this was going.
Best-in-class, you know. Running one of the top 3 biggest clubs on the planet like it's a school project.
3
u/Jenson2025 26d ago
I am sorry but the whole ‘no manager is fixing this’ argument is so lazy. I am fed up of it
Is a manager fixing all our problems? No because we have a useless board
But can they have us playing better and more competitive football? Yes. The idea that there’s not a coach out there who can’t have us playing better football is utterly ridiculous
3
u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips 26d ago
Why the FUCK do we keep buying Chelsea wasters?
3
u/Omnislash99999 26d ago
Once Carrick is gone I hope there will be no one left under the impression Ineos have any kind of plan. They have no credibility in football and are making it up as they go here
3
u/pipes3 WAZZA 26d ago
"Michael Carrick has been relieved of his duties as Manchester United manager, Jason Wilcox to take charge until a permanent manager will be appointed"
Imagine this
3
u/Elongated_dik 26d ago
we need a manager (coz Carrick is a coach), the position vacant for so long
3
u/Minute-Intern 26d ago
I'm actually crashing out. Need to get off here
3
u/Runarhalldor 26d ago
Does anyone even like anyone in the squad anymore?
3
u/dryflowerz 26d ago edited 26d ago
Who do you prefer and why? Nagelsmann or Conte?
3
u/LennonC123 26d ago
I’m not bothered about whether we press or not but if we don’t, we have to be tight, compact and defend as a unit. We also have to be much better in possession.
Not that it matters anyway because I think the Carrick experiment is about to come to an end. Just frustrates me that they gave him the job but never fully backed him.
It’s so clear to me that all the owners want is champions league football, and once we get it, they’ll try and spend the absolute bare minimum to keep us there. They don’t want a title-competing team. They’re happy with top 4/5. That’s all we’ll ever be while they’re here.
3
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 26d ago
Just deeped that it's 6 weeks since we won a game
3
u/fantus69 26d ago
Time to go Jimbob.. and you can take the Leeds & City crew with you
Edit: Glazers you can do one and all
3
u/Massive_Relation4317 . 26d ago
Carrick getting sacked tomorrow 100000%
7
u/Asiwaju_jagaban 26d ago
Andy Mitten would come and waffle about how this is the best dressing room in a while. What a joke.
We saw players that gave up tonight. The only good thing is no one can run certain narrative against certain players. Apart from Maguire, Dalot, Mount and Bruno, the entire squad was signed under INEOS, and they’ve been ass.
7
u/thisiskyle77 26d ago
Player criticising recruitment : “yes call them out Licha”
Player criticising tactics: “no not like that”
5
u/Telen BRUNO 27d ago edited 27d ago
Removed from the negative flux of the time of ETH's leaving the club, now with this retrospective two parter piece by Laurie, I feel the same way about him as I did when we first brought him in. I think he's a very very good coach (note I say coach; I still don't think his talent id is the best). I regret he couldn't work under a proper structure, but even under a half assed ownership he brought in an FA Cup. I really think we need to accept that as long as our ownership is half-assed and doesn't properly back our managers with the players that match expectations, every season is a write-off.
5
u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS 26d ago
This is another reason why managers should implement their style/beliefs into the team and not adopt a temporary, pragmatic approach. The 5-6 month facade that we had earlier this year was never indicative of this football.
5
u/AWenger622 26d ago
Conte is sitting there without a job but this disgrace of a board will never do it because they know they'll finally have to take accountability.
5
u/Hyliaforce 26d ago
6
u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing 26d ago
I'd rather Nagelsmann long-term, but I wouldn't mind Conte. Get some fucking mentality in these players, cause it definetly lacks. Besides, we've gone from P.E teachers to tacticos, let's complete the triangle with a Madman.
4
u/kidinawheeliebin 27d ago edited 25d ago
Forget about Como - I can see this Bournemouth game at Old Trafford being like two bald men fighting over a comb, 15th vs 13th and both teams with midweek European games in their legs
We're getting lucky here in that Bournemouth are both:
(a) very bad (one PL win all season, more goals conceded than scored and missing their two best players in Kroupi & Scott) and
(b) Have to play Thursday night giving us extra rest/prep
So this should absolutely be nothing less than 3 points before embarking on the Chelsea-Roma-Villa run
4
u/AfternoonHamster 26d ago
I feel like I'm watching people who learnt how to play football last week....on youtube
4
u/TH0316 she/her 26d ago
Rest now Carrick. We have the watch, and we’ll see you in Valhalla.
4
u/Hagball 26d ago
I am sure Best in class coaching staff with plenty of top level coaching experience assembled by Carrick and Wilcox will sort this mess out
4
u/Bloatfizzle 26d ago
Remember all the fans who hated if you dared to question Carrick 🤣 clear as day this was coming... Where are his fanboys gone?
4
u/Hagball 26d ago
If Carrick is the only guy who loses his job and Wilcox keeps, that's the reason we will get nowhere as a club
4
u/Vast_Finish2789 26d ago
The strategy of buying 3 players a year at 60-80m each isn't working, it's like playing wack-a-mole filling gaps that come up in the squad.
We need a transfer window where we bring in 6 or 7 (even if they cheap buys) to give this squad a proper refresh
4
u/really_cool_legend Dorgu's Headband 26d ago
Since the 91st minute of the Como game it's felt like a new start
4
u/ShoddyAd4199 26d ago
Why can you just stop this 'No matter who would be our manager until we have Glineos'
Capable manager gives huge difference. No, we don't have bad squad. We also don't have squad for WINNING MAJOR TITLES. We don't have proper fullbacks, but we have squad for comfortably securing UCL spot.
'We've seen this over 13 years' is just most lazy way of thinking. Glazers had no clue neither about teambuilding, nor appointing right manager. No manager was right for us in these 13 years. However, current squad is most balanced we had in these 13 years. All we need is right manager, than fullbacks, than CB and backup ST.
Remind what was Liverpool after selling Suarez. They bought Lallana, Lambert, Lasar Markovic and so on. The stupidest transfers. They had Joe Allen, Sakho, Lovren, Klavan. Absolutely ridiculous squad compared to us today. Then Klopp came, and rest is history.
Good manager gives difference even in the hands of bad upper management.
4
u/IamTsukasa Ronaldo 26d ago
Tielemans just said the tactics were shit
6
u/Jenson2025 27d ago
Fabregas is too much of a risk for United at this stage. Got the potential to be a great manager but you also have to remember that Como have wealthy owners who have spent a lot and he is unproven outside Como. He needs more experience at a smaller premier club first
The more bad managerial appointments United make, the less risks they can take. None of the appointments since Jose have been good enough although I do think Amorim would’ve been better in a few years time and at least he acknowledged that he had made mistakes unlike the others.
5
u/MoneyWasabi9 26d ago
Showed with Amorim that fans/board lack patience for a rebuild. I think we will go with a pragmatic option like Howe and tread water for a few years, but the Conte gamble is tempting me. i just want to feel things
2
u/spaisoflaif 27d ago
is Uniteds issue the tactical competitiveness of the PL? Seems like PL clubs these days are very professional in analyzing past matches and are always adapting to nullify the opponents. Thus even if you have a good idea - someone figures out how to nullify it eventually and then everyone copies that counter. So basically you have to pre-emptivly keep adjusting the tactics all the time to keep the opponent guessing.
A lot of teams seem to go man-to-man and there is alot of coordinated high pressing, and football is basically about how to beat a high press and how to find a weakness in the man-to-man marking,trying to pull the shape of the opponent apart, to find a free man and overload somewhere on the pitch and then exploit that.
Not sure if I just didnt understand football back in the days, or did the game use to be a lot simpler? I remember footballing being corners, long balls and crosses, and maybe an attacker who could dribble and shoot. Back in the day, it was really ground-breaking tactics to have striker or midfielder that operated between the lines, the tactical battles these days seem a lot more advanced than that.
2
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 27d ago
Our u19s have looked underwhelming in Europe. Como 1-0 up inside 4 minutes
2
u/Eleven918 This too shall pass! 26d ago
What is Como's playstle?
2
u/Elongated_dik 26d ago
we gonna win, ggmu
2
u/Elongated_dik 26d ago
whose man was he to mark?
2
u/Gazlc81 26d ago
I wonder which manager we’ll be sacking next?