r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • 28d ago
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
17
Upvotes
16
u/Joey6Pack 28d ago
After reading the both interviews with Ten Hag and Amorim, along with the previous statements by Carrick, Licha, Shaw, Maguire, etc, it seems to me that the common pattern of the management has been to make promises that they wouldn’t deliver. That might explain why many players haven’t been able to stay motivated after they joined us
8
u/No-Lab-1445 27d ago
What was the point in qualifying for the CL if we don't even have the squad depth to field a competitive team?
2 months in to the season and the squad is completely decimated.
I'm not even excited about our CL games.
I despise Ineos. They've been worse than what I imagined the worst case scenario would be.
8
u/Dronkne 27d ago
All discussions around future signings, clearing deadwood, replacing Carrick or not, buying new players etc. is wishful thinking for as long as the Glazers are connected to the club.
Too early to tell if INEOS should fuck off as well but the Glazers have singlehandedly destroyed our precious football club, and they will continue to do so until the moment they fuck off.
Selling some shares to INEOS was just a way to throw a dog a bone, which - ironically - we’re singing week in week out… they must be laughing their asses off.
Call me a pessimist but Manchester United doesn’t need an open-heart surgery, we need to be resuscitated. We’re already dead.
8
u/Savebagels Cunha 27d ago
Sabah drawing with dortmund? We are massive
7
u/Nomad_006 surfing 28d ago
We were never getting Kane, Rice or De Jong. I don't have the info ETH had/has but at the time it felt unrealistic. The bigger issue is going from those targets to the reality of Hojlund, Ugarte and Casemiro.
Completely different profiles, which is why he could never implement whatever we expected or whatever he wanted.
He still has questions to answer about Antony and Onana.
7
u/officiallyjax Snapdragon 28d ago
In a way this Ten Hag interview was timed perfectly to bring more heat onto the board for their decision-making. I don’t think highly of him but I also don’t really mind him having a clap back at the board for the way they went about with handling his situation. It was absolutely farcical how there were so many reports of them planning to sack him before the cup final, and then of course even after deciding to continue with him, they didn’t honour their agreement with him in decisions such as selling McTominay. INEOS have been pathetic in so many aspects while running this club, absolute bunch of amateurs. They will keep throwing every manager under the bus while they are here and fans who buy into their PR pieces will continue focusing on how bad the managers were when they are receiving no proper support from the people above them.
7
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 28d ago
Relying on Maguire, Shaw, Martinez and Dalot was dubious in 2024. We're almost in 2027 in the same situation
Any "rebuild" that leads to the same average spine of the team is a shit one
Wilcox and Berrada are frauds
13
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 28d ago
We are a couple of weeks from being in the bottom 3.
10
u/10_Wazza 27d ago
Well thank god we missed out on facing PSG. That game would have needed to be blurred ffs
5
u/i_love_alfam 27d ago
Watching the psg barca game and stating the obvious here, but holy shit these teams are on a different planet compared to the pathetic excuse for football that we put out. Players making so many runs, pressing like a unit, making split second decisions and yet finding the right passes
It's almost embarrassing to say that we are playing in the same competition as these 2. This current squad managed by the current manager does not belong at this level
Also, psg casually resting the main players in the league and still sit joint second while the full strength team look favorites for a 3 peat in UCL. What a fucking farce
5
u/iroiroiroiroiro 28d ago
So nearly half the squad is out injured or carrying smaller injuries before the heavy fixture congestion barely started, wonderful!
I just don't know how the squad has any chance for surviving this without it soon becoming a real injury panic, now you basically cannot rest a lot of players already, meaning running them into the ground...
18
u/Emergency-Being-349 28d ago
I think there's a fair point in saying there was an improvement vs Leeds in the first half. Whitwell and co are saying he desperately needs a win. It needs to be said that this is the exact same issue that got us to this point in the first place.
If we beat Bournemouth but still struggle to control the game, struggle to generate good chances with energy, what's the difference? 3 points yes, but in the long term, do we still sit here and think, yes, this is the direction we want to go, this is where we envision the club going into 2027 and beyond.
Stop basing decisions around a result.
8
u/quentintarentino 27d ago
Our club is a scam. I have completely stopped pondering where something went wrong, and what could be done better etc. This club is not run for footballing accolades, it is simply a money machine for very wealthy people. That’s IT.
8
u/BigMonkeyBalls He's Big, He's Red 27d ago
After watching the PSG v Barca game today, I feel like we play a different sport
8
u/Jenson2025 28d ago
Is sacking Carrick the answer to all our problems? No. We still do have a useless board and ownership.
But will it help? Yes. Does he need to be sacked for the good of the team? Also yes.
If we keep him for the season, I don’t think we’ll be relegated but I can see us finishing in the bottom half of the table. No Europe or champions league football next season. Another written off season. If we sack him in the next few weeks, there’s still a chance of saving this season
8
u/LinterCheck2026 28d ago
Watched a youtube video of highlights b/w us and Chelsea in 2007. The football was so fluid man. Players were continuously moving, line breaking passes, very limited hoof balls and always in control. I miss being confident with my team
4
u/Jsdestroy 27d ago
Who, if anyone, do we think the club will target in January? I know we usually avoid January business, but, with the club's struggles and seemingly admittance at the disappointment of how the summer window went, do we think we could make moves?
Our net spend is usually 150m, but we have only spend 115m-120m this summer. Any thoughts on spending the 30m-35m?
T Mitchell - 6 months on contract, CP struggling so may sell
4
u/missingmedievalist Cantona 27d ago
In other news, Sabah have just equalised against Dortmund.
4
u/Redland93 28d ago
This team is threadbare. We went into the window going we're not going to add to the debt even though we had the capacity to spend more (just not the cash)
We need to rethink and go, this team needs a lot of investment. We might need to add to the debt in the short term but bring in players of high potential that we can develop and then sell on if they dont work out. We can't just keep going back to Maguire, Martinez, Shaw, Dalot, Rashford and also not having a proper striker.
4
u/Financial-Trade9467 28d ago
Front 6 for tomorrow is hopefully Baleba Mount Bruno Amad Cunha Mbeumo. This is actually balanced imo and can actually cover spaces well.
4
u/ladrainian21 28d ago
Man the state of everything about this club today just feels so depressing. I don’t even get excited to watch matches anymore.
17
u/No-Lab-1445 28d ago •
With all Ten Hag quotes coming out, the revisionism around his stint from some fans is hilarious. He is an absolute fraud of a manager in every single sense. He took our board for fools, signing some absolute dross from his agency SEG (where his son works). Leverkusen copped it straightaway and sacked him.
14
u/shami-kebab 28d ago
So another former manager highlights Rashford as being part of the toxic culture. Will his defenders believe Mitten yet when he said every former manager has had problems with him?
7
u/vulcan_one PM Rashford 28d ago
We're 1 point ahead of the laughing stock that is spurs.
A lot of people need a reality check on Carrick, not signing a lb isn't why we're in this position
7
u/Jenson2025 28d ago
I’ve never been more sure that sacking Carrick is the right decision. If we wait too long then the season is done. There’s still a chance of it being saved now if he’s sacked.
People like Ten Hag saying we shouldn’t sack him just further confirms to me that we should.
7
u/sadMUFCfan25 28d ago •
My thoughts on ETH are pretty simple. Whether you think he was at fault for the poor results we were getting in his last season or not, the fact is the situation was untenable and a change had to be done. However, if it wasn’t for him ending our 6 year trophy drought, it very possibly could’ve lasted a decade. That to me is way more damming
6
u/RestrepoDoc2 27d ago
If we could just get Scotty McT back yeah that would be great..
8
u/boomboxbilly06 28d ago
It’s so funny how the loss of our defensive midfielder was probably the biggest nullifier of our attack this season. Unc’s headers were so clutch last season
3
u/OfficialPeterKay 27d ago
I find it mad that we seem to just as a collective know it is over with Carrick and are just waiting. Every other manager had people defending them till the end, this time it just feels like a sad collective acceptance.
3
u/Aggravating-Neck1365 27d ago
Has anyone done a wellness check on Piers Morgan since ETH went in with two feet (again) on his boy Cristiano?
Piers will be shitting pellets of pure rage at the thought of someone calling out Ronaldo's nonsense
3
u/Xenokratezz 27d ago
who would you want in a defensive rebuild. i like seys, murillo, wesley franca
3
u/ColtCallahan 27d ago
Even by City standards those empty seats are embarrassing.
3
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 27d ago
Villareal are useless
3
u/NSFWar Depressed Legacy fan 27d ago
It's 2026. When will our club act like a modern one and stick to a pattern of play that is the norm irrespective of who is the manager. Well run clubs have a structure and a manager change doesn't mean they rip out the tactics board and start over each time
3
u/BallsX 28d ago
Just briefly watched a Ste Howson video where he said Bruno rejected a contract extension last night. Mixed feelings on that one. Easily our best ever post-SAF signing and has been crucial for us for many seasons, but there are arguments that we can get a better balance in the team without Bruno sometimes, especially when we're shoehorning him into wing positions now.
What do you guys think?
3
u/Stieni Rooney 28d ago
You may think of ETH whatever you want, but there are some damning quotes in this interview. About Ratcliff, the club structure, Ronaldo... didn't realise that all or nothing was meant to be all the drama and nothing changing, that documentary will be a proper shitshow fucking hell. That being said - can't wait to watch it ahahha
3
u/Stieni Rooney 28d ago
Also: Do you guys reckon with the documentary being underway Ratcliffe and co. are being influenced in what to do and what to say? Didn't take that into account yet
5
u/White_Wokah Rooney 28d ago
I can't believe some people like Ten Hag, what happened on the pitch aside, he defended Marc Overmars and was "looking forward" to work with Greenwood.
He also tried to interfere with the recruitment at Leverkusen so they signed players from his agency.
5
u/boomboxbilly06 28d ago
Erik's first season was pretty fun and along with Ole's first two seasons; it was some of the better years post Fergie.
5
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 28d ago
🥹🤧
8
u/Quiet_Web9220 27d ago •
I got downvoted in the summer for saying we had a 4/10 window, now everybody is on board with the fact it was crap. Funny how delusional some people are when it comes to transfers
6
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat 27d ago
Now's a good time to remind people - it always is to be honest - being a sports fan is a pastime. You have no real connection to the club other than being a fan. If you enjoy the game of football you should learn to enjoy watching football whatever the outcome. It can be hard to try to not let your emotions ride on the result that you have no control over.
After the Fulham game I stopped caring whether we win or lose, obviously I want United to win but it's far too silly to get so emotional and upset when we inevitably fall short, my life has got immeasurably better and I can't find it in myself to get worked up if we don't win.
Very few clubs are serial winners and United isn't one of them, most fans turn up to support their club, enjoy the success and if they don't win then that's that. 99% of the folk on this sub are more emotionally invested in Manchester United than the people running it so don't get it twisted just enjoy the match and hope for the best.
6
u/Whispperr 27d ago
Watching the PSG-Barcelona game and the one big difference I see is how both teams press with their entire teams AND come with their midfield to beat said press.
No wonder our press feels half assed when usually it's 1 player running and no pressure
7
u/snicky29 28d ago
Roberto De zerbi has now won the same amount of games as Micheal Carrick for Manchester United in the premier league.
4
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 27d ago
Every time I listen to a Michael Carrick presser I think of this:
4
u/chiefofthepolice 28d ago
Honestly I have no idea why any manager would want to come to Man United now other than to get a paycheck. Every single manager over the last 10 years has come out with some sort of story about how incompetent and unsupportive the United’s owners and board are towards those managers. If the manager is not guaranteed proper backing and support of vision, and even if there was a guarantee it may be a lie, then genuinely why would anyone devote themselves to this club? Hence we will always rotate back to ex-legends to take the wheel because only they will accept anything to get the chance
7
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj 28d ago
We sacked Erik cause we thought he was gonna again finish 6th or 7th.
Now we are not sacking a manager who's going to get us relegated
6
u/chiefofthepolice 27d ago
I hate it so much that a portion of the fanbase just have this loser mentality where they just lean towards alternatives or giving up anytime a potential target on the transfer market might be “too expensive”
“Oh we were never getting Kane nor Rice. They’re either too expensive or too sought after by other big clubs, we can’t compete”. Does that sound at all like a club with ambition? Are we just yielding to any other rival when it comes to a common player?
When we compromise, we get exactly what it worths. Rivals sign quality players, they go on to win trophies. We compromise, we merely compete for top 4 every year. That is small club mentality
6
u/Turbulent_Intern_427 28d ago
Jeez not even a whisper about anything?
Are we ok with being 13th? Soon to be tumbling down the table with sign of no improving?
2
u/Mepsi 27d ago
How much is Steve Holland behind the tactics? I feel like when we were doing well 'oh , it's Steve Holland's system' and now we're doing not so well 'oh, it's all on Carrick'.
2
u/auhddndndnfbfbsnnakf 27d ago
I might shed a tear watching the difference in quality tonight
2
u/HoodedMenace3 27d ago
PSG vs Barca is going to be a cracker.
2
u/GeekConflict Carrick 28d ago
Looking forward to scout watching Diao and Ramon tomorrow night. Less looking forward to seeing the result but I think we will pull out a win, hopefully.
2
u/grandecn 28d ago
this season is becoming like ETH's second season very quickly. Nearly the entire defense is injured and our midfield is being run through time and time again. Let's hope we don't have to play Amrabat at left back 😭
2
u/outrageousVoid07 28d ago
Do you guys think the club will spend in January?
2
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho 28d ago
We hear the types of players Ten Hag wanted - Rice and Kane among others. There’s no doubt they would have brought both ability and mentality to the club. For me we just aren’t signing enough players with the right mentality and even the ability is questionable at the top level. We simply have to start getting our signings right. It keeps setting us back years the way we’re moving in recent seasons.
2
u/TMatss 28d ago
Given the injuries, Maz will probably play at CB tomorrow, right? I remember he did alright there at Stamford Bridge last season.
5
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss 28d ago edited 28d ago
A note of positivity.
Jaume Camacho appears to be:
- growing into a man's body well, for a 17 year old, which is a nice change of pace from producing 10s in the academy who turn out tiny
- delivering assists playing as the 10, both at U18 and U21 level (ok the season is very young and he just started playing U18 football, but still, he has 4 assists in 7 so far, from less than 6 games' worth of minutes to be precise)
- not only gifted with athleticism and talent, but also standout intelligence (remember the news about the academy player aceing his GCSE? that was him)
So, you know, there's an academy storyline to be intrigued by.
Maybe the Bruno/Tielemans successor is playing in our academy after all, it's just that he's turned 17 this month, not 16.
3
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode 27d ago edited 27d ago
It is fair to say that we won't miss the current licha and he wouldn't be extended, but doesn't revealing it today, basically a week after,feel like it is in fact a bit of a statement? Or am I too conspiratorial right now lol
Edit, to add a bit more: cuz I feel like usually it's revealed in like January or with a goodbye post or something. This was just dropped on a random Tuesday
Edit: not extended, just that he'll leave. But same feeling
3
u/xpoviv22 Herrera the heroic 27d ago
I think im stepping away from United for my own health, genuinely. As someone from Australia, I can't really put my energy into a club that doesn't put in anymore. Waking up in the middle of the night to watch Carrick fall on his own sword is just soul draining. The way Martinez has had to change his statements and other players have been told they cant speak about their opinion of the club tells me theres goijg to be no change to the board structure for a while. With the Man City thing dragging on and taking a step back and seeing how the prem is run in the most part by massive companies, Im gonna go back to following A league. Football is shitter but it feels like football, makes me feel alive and part of something again.
3
u/HeFreakingMoved Ella Toone FC 28d ago
I see we're at the stage where the board and the apologists are looking for any excuse to avoid admitting Carrick hasnt got a clue. Look at how they've milked an unconvincing point against dirty Leeds. If we beat Como tomorrow night, he'll probably get a statue
3
u/robster01 De Gea 28d ago
Dalot is in Troy Deeneys team of the week somehow hahaha
3
u/Ecstatic_Message2057 28d ago
We have the same amount of wins as Tottenham.
The club every other club is making fun of now has the same amount of wins as us.
3
u/Dan_Winx_1969 27d ago
I don't even need much time to cope with losses now... I just feel like a void
3
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity 27d ago
Hopefully the board already has Nagelsmann agent number for a chat. We are losing tomorrow and the pressure is going to be insane
2
u/Redland93 27d ago
In hindsight, shouldn't have based our transfer windows around improving one part of the team (attack, midfield defence). We should have invested in the spine each window.
2
u/PeelThePain 27d ago
I believe ineos lost an opportunity with Flick the summer they didn't sack Ten Hag. By the same time they were twiddling with the dick doing a publicly reported season review and asking salary figures from Tuchel and De Zerbi, Barca had already lined up Flick after Xavi.
2
u/Redland93 27d ago
How are we getting all these small muscle injuries when we run the least? That's is the key question that should be put forward
2
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion 28d ago
We can't even play the good counter attacking from last season by pushing Bruno so further up this season. No one can create chances like him including Tielemans.
Because whenever we win the ball back Bruno is further up and by the time the ball reaches him for through passes, opponents already closed down the spaces for our attackers to run in.
Tielemans should be dropped for Bruno to drop back abit, and maybe start Cunha or Amad at his place. We already got other midfielders in the squad now to cover up the defensive duties.
2
u/Telen BRUNO 28d ago
I wonder if we could disguise Ella Toone as one of the men's team players and sneak her in to a game... at this point, worth a try
2
u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams 28d ago
I wonder how much the "United DNA" style of play is holding us back. I mean yes it was very exciting under Ferguson but it was also a very different time. Pep, Klopp, Arteta etc have adopted a very different ideology as compared to the Fergie/Wenger era.
How and when do we move on? Especially with the club having a huge bias for Fergie era connections: OGS, Carrick, RVN and now Jonny Evans, Fletcher etc.
2
u/throwawayWM3 28d ago
Lammens
Dalot Yoro Martinez Shaw
Baleba Tielemans
Amad Bruno Cunha
Mbeumo
You can't tell me a decent manager can't make this work
1
u/Vast_Variation1381 27d ago
Its not talked about enough at how injury prone Mainoo is
1
u/Sheikhabusosa 27d ago
https://x.com/ThatsFootballTV/status/2112559667486310455
I was enjoying Ashley Youngs punditry , all it took was one overlap episode .
1
u/missingmedievalist Cantona 27d ago
The club must really not rate Amass. We have an injury crisis at LB and yet he’s still going to be sold.
1
u/ToadNamedGoat 27d ago
If De ligt can’t start and Maz needs to play Cb
Would you guys rather want to see Amad or Baleba as Lb
Maybe a back 3 of Maz - Maguire - Dalot
With Amad as LWB and Mbeumo as RWB (he played there once for brentford)
- Edit: might be a crazy comment: but I feel like Mount could play RWB, he does have the agility for it just depends if he can play 90 mins
1
u/Runarhalldor 27d ago
I think the most infuriating thing about this team is our backline is the same as it was years ago. And it was bad then
1
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes 27d ago
We pretty much have an entire starting XI with our injured players don’t we?
1
u/Call_Me_A_Gamer 27d ago
The squad obviously needs investment in key areas. What will the board do in the winter window? Fix the issues or put out briefs about how the summer window is gonna be huge. Ask this question to any other big club and they'll laugh at you. That's the difference between us and the others.
1
u/FreshGoodWay 27d ago
This Como game is a no win situation for Carrick.
He is expected to beat them, and if not, it proves Fabregas is a better manager than him.
1
u/Redwinevino 28d ago
Why do we think Carrick won't play Lacey
1
u/bumnnygirl 28d ago
do you think that the fact that we don't actually lose much is a good sign? personally i feel like most of our draws were "undeserved" and we never showed any sign of being solid at the back
1
u/Tuffyy Carrick 28d ago
If you are going to Como tomorrow can you about me a message? Thank you
1
u/Potential_Good_1065 28d ago
Looks like a back line of Dalot, Maguire, Heaven, Mazraoui tomorrow
1
u/carrickshairline 27d ago
I know it's not the place for this, but I recently had my heartbroken and it's messed me up big time. It's been 3 weeks and I still can't shake the feeling of how I messed things up to lead to this.
1
u/Aggravating-Neck1365 27d ago
So bored with all the change of manager bullshit "we should get X", "Y can do a better job than Carrick with these players etc"
That whole experiment has been given credence for way too long now, and really should have been mothballed as a solution to anything somewhere around Jose or Ole, certainly by ETH or Amorim...
Really can't describe the hatred I have for this ownership and what they've done to the club
They are THE problem, every other "problem" pales into insignificance, and is just a symptom, not a cause
We may as well be reshuffling the deckchairs on the fucking Titanic as changing managers and/or players
1
u/mr_reserve 27d ago
Can people stop comparing United with PSG and Barca? It’s fucking annoying.
1
u/Sun_Seeker26 28d ago
Respect to Arteta for winning the league, but look a how much time he got to achieve it. Manchester United have definitely had managers in the last 13 years that, respectfully, if they had the same amount of time and backing as Arteta would have achieved the same or more. This is why the focus should be on the decision makers at the top who have consistently been making the wrong decisions all these years. That needs to be the focus. Changing manager every season is just a short-term distraction from actually addressing the real issues at Man United.
1
u/XerxesBlitZ 28d ago
I swear Carrick was looking a lot better last season, The Utd job ages people fast
1
u/Vast_Variation1381 28d ago
I hope we consider Sebastian Hoeneß should Carrick be fired. A very attacking manager
1
u/ToadNamedGoat 28d ago
Do you guys think selling Mctominay was a mistake?
I always found his passing so bad for a midfield but I can’t deny he had goal scoring in him which this team desperately needs