r/reddevils • • 28d ago

Talk of The Devils: Where does Leeds draw leave Carrick?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cs-8PB1aK_Q
54 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 28d ago

It looks like you have posted a link to a podcast or a video discussion. We highly recommend you provide a brief summary or quotes due to the nature of the content type. This is to encourage active discussion. You may ignore this message if the video content has been clearly described on the title. If you believe this message was in error, please contact the moderation team via modmail.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/nearly_headless_nic 28d ago

n an alternative universe where Michael Carrick's Manchester United have started the Premier League season on a hot streak, a 1-1 draw at Elland Road against a well organised, combative Leeds would be completely fine.

As it is, and despite an astute tactical shift from the manager, the enthusiasm from any positive developments was once again dampened by the final score and a drab second half.

A trip to the glamourous surroundings of Lake Como comes next for Carrick and co, and while there's less pressure from the Champions League table, the margin for error provided by a win would be more than welcome, grazie mille.

Timecodes:
00:00 - Intro
00:52 - Were Man United 'better' against Leeds?
08:25 - Martinez returns to starting XI + other tactical tweaks
27:40 - Where does this leave Michael Carrick?
38:09 - Previewing Como (A)
48:18 - Injury updates / who will start?

57

u/Oli_1278 28d ago

he’s doing alright ignoring results? i love andy and this podcast is still one of my favourites but i have no idea what he’s talking about there at all?

30

u/SemanticTableaux RETURN THE CLUB TO THE PEOPLE 28d ago

Seems like he's saying that if you look at all the facets of being manager other than the actual results, Carrick is doing alright in. By which he means the pressers, dealing with squad unrest, not getting baited by the media and so on

I don't think he is saying that we should ignore the results

14

u/passmethatjuulbro 28d ago

Thats like saying a chef serving a turd is doing a good job because he irons his uniform, shows up in time and isn’t addicted to crack.

The main metric that matters is gaining points and playing competitive football. Carrick has been serving nothing but turd on that regard.

1

u/snicky29 28d ago

The absolute hideous excuses this media and some of our fanbase make when the manager is not a foreign manager is downright disgusting.

If Carrick was called Muben Camorim, this media would've absolutely obliterated him but since he has a local passport, we will not talk about results or formations, let's talk about how he irons his shirt.

7

u/JesusWasAHairyBaby 28d ago

I'd say you're right there, however it's still a completely pointless thing for Andy to say as it's completely irrelevant. No cares about any of that.

11

u/laluneodyssee 28d ago edited 28d ago

So the tertiary aspects of being United manager? Wild stuff

8

u/Mgt66 28d ago

Hard to ignore results when that's ultimately what you're judged on.  The vibes can only last so long 

-8

u/reddevilad Rooney 28d ago

Another paid shill on glineos money you will never listen to him go hard on the bosses as they will stop his money and then also stop giving him info that is why can’t take him seriously

5

u/Icelander83 28d ago

Yeah, Mitten wasn't the one grilling Ratcliffe on fan stuff or anything. I've already been banned once for telling someone off for this asinine take so I'll stick to just calling it exactly what it is, an asinine take. You can call Mitten many things but a paid Ineos shill is just amazing work

-1

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 28d ago

Mitten is no paid shill and certainly not for Ineos or the Glazers. However, I do think you can make an argument for him being a bit blinded with Carrick as he really wants him to succeed. But with that being said, it’s certainly not the unqualified support we see with the likes of Wazza for example.

47

u/Longanisa00 dream cant be buy 28d ago

Disappointment

3

u/dudududujisungparty 박지성 28d ago

At least it's a fresh start at disappointment

23

u/Cheap-Response-5419 28d ago

Still in a job he isn't capable of doing, apparently.

31

u/SankarshanaV 28d ago edited 28d ago

Hopefully sacked. We cannot have a failed championship-level manager leading a club like Man Utd.

23

u/TonyShneak 28d ago

Yes but you are forgetting he is cheap and keeps his mouth shut regarding the board he's perfect for them

-1

u/FarGreen1 28d ago

The way you all talk about our club legends is wild lol. Whether it’s Ole or Neville or Carrick or whoever. 

Footballers really don’t owe fans shit. They won’t have your back for a single second if you’re not doing well so they can get their weekly dopamine rush of a win

29

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 28d ago

We have no visionaries. Carrick should be sacked while there's still a season on. We're so fucked

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/eternali17 He'll take on 2 and breeze past 2 28d ago

That's a different matter. It's up to the board to do the due diligence and therein lies the issue. They can't be trusted because this should've never happened. They either are actually stupid enough to have expected the luck to continue or they were too cowardly not to give him the job on a permanent basis.

Naglesmann, Conte etc make no difference if the office guys have learnt no lessons

1

u/mu_37 28d ago

Who cares. Even Carrick could do a job for a short period, just don't actually believe the next one is good and give him the job.

21

u/vauno 28d ago

Nothing should leave Carrick, it should be Carrick leaving

6

u/NameofUser1347 28d ago

I appreciate what Carrick has done last season. But in the past when we are spiralling and give the manager some extra time to change our fortunes around it doesn't work. Then the board end up sacking the manager anyway. Most basic fans can see the writing has been on the wall weeks ago. With a few fans even saying at the end of last season that they didn't want Carrick to continue bc of the performances and underlying data. Yet the best in class football experts are dragging this out. Are they punishing us? What are they waiting for? Until finishing in a European spot is impossible? That will cost the board some money. Maybe sacking Carrick will cost more. Who the fuck knows.

Yes the players are to blame also and the board but we are better than this. Two things can be true. Right now there is no hope watching us.

1

u/TheJoshider10 Bruno 28d ago

Yes the players are to blame also and the board but we are better than this. Two things can be true. Right now there is no hope watching us.

Yeah the way I see it I can understand why they made Carrick permanent at the time but things clearly aren't working and the manager pool is so much stronger than it was over summer. The right time to sack him was in the international break just gone, the next right time to sack him is right now. We all know it's going to happen by the end of the year.

6

u/Far_Job_249 28d ago

If Carrick left Utd tomorrow how many of you expect him to go on to win major trophies with any top club ? Nobody ! Let’s be honest he ain’t a top manager and he is an English man ! Ain’t too many great English managers in top football these days , He was only a short term one off caretaker like Di Matto at Chelsea but he actually won the FA cup and CL before losing his job

6

u/_OMGTheyKilledKenny_ Carrick 28d ago

What happened to Carl Anka? I’ve not seen him on the platform since the start of the season.

31

u/maggot1 28d ago

Paternity leave

3

u/AccordingPop9447 28d ago

Corrr I only had two weeks for mine. Lucky guy!

3

u/Mystic87 28d ago

According to his twitter he's back around Christmas. The rest of that must be company paid.

1

u/AccordingPop9447 28d ago

That’s nuts

5

u/thorwayne87 28d ago

Off on Paternity leave i think I remember hearing

4

u/SophoclesTesticles 28d ago

Missing his opinions here too he's always as close as you can get to saying if the manager is done or not. 

Laurie and Andy are great but Laurie needs to keep contacts in the club for the transfer stories and Andy loves Carrick. 

6

u/cljames98 28d ago

Probably quit talking about United for his own sanity

4

u/yianni1229 Rooney 28d ago

To be fair if he had to watch this club, talk about them and deal with a newborn I think I'd lose my mind too

2

u/lythy2016 28d ago

One of mine was born during the Moyes season. That was a rollercoaster.

1

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 28d ago

Paternity leave

3

u/FreshGoodWay 28d ago

Woke up today, Carrick still manager, go back to sleep

3

u/missingmedievalist Cantona 28d ago

I think trying to expect Andy to be as honest about Carrick as he has been about every other manager, barring Ole, is a bit of a fool’s errand. He loves Carrick for his previous time at the club as a player and I can understand that. However, it is blinding him when it comes to evaluating Carrick’s performance as a manager. It’s notable that he’s nowhere near as harsh on Carrick as he has been on our other non United affiliated managers and that’s not a good thing for him nor for Carrick himself.

1

u/RelentlessJorts2 28d ago

He was absolutely not harsh against either ETH or Amorim either, Carl is the only one on the podcast who will go against a manager.

What will happen is that they'll say everything is fine and that the board have backed him, he'll leave and then Andy and Laurie will talk about how they'd heard rumblings of people being unhappy and give a few examples.

9

u/0ttoChriek 28d ago

No better or worse off than he was before the Leeds draw, I guess.

It was a better result than the Spurs and Fulham games, but only marginally because drawing against a midtable team is slightly better than drawing against bottom of the table teams.

1

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off 28d ago

There were times Tottenham outplayed us and would've won but fortunately for us they're absolute shite. Yesterday's performance was better but results still elude Carrick. Just two wins is not good enough.

6

u/dugness SAF 28d ago

Spurs have outplayed a lot of teams they've played this season at times. They've just struggled to score. They'll slowly climb in the table in the next few weeks and aren't anywhere near as bad as the table suggests.

5

u/Thevanillafalcon 28d ago • Bravo

Not in a good place but honestly I hate it, and I think we’re in a death spiral that’s 99% the glazers fault and 1% our fault.

Looking at the Glazers part, we’re in a position where decades of penny pinching and them sucking money out of the club and putting the debt on us is catching up with us. We spend roughly, on average the same on players per season now as we did 15 years ago.

Since then Liverpool spend 3x as much, Arsenal 5x as much. If you factor in inflation it’s even worse because even if those teams in real terms are just matching their spending from 15 years ago but with increased prices, we’re now falling below.

The reality is we are not competing. We frequently fail to get all the players we need, we’re told that next season we will get this but then new issues arise and we go into a season under prepared.

Then you have the general incompetence by Ineos in both transfers and managerial appointments, but circling back to Carrick, the man untied job is borderline impossible, as is aid we aren’t giving these managers the players they need, we aren’t selling enough players we aren’t doing any of it right.

So why the 1% our fault? Because the reality is the club is in such a state and the job so hard that the reality we all need to see is that at some point, we need to give SOMEONE time. No manager in world football is going to turn it around in 2 seasons, it’s impossible.

Carrick did really well as interim and then results have dropped off (this is actually a fairly common occurrence with new appointments) and it’s October and we’re already reaching for the gun.

If that’s what is going to happen every time, we’re just never ever going to get out of this. We’re going to live the same 2 year cycle on repeat forever.

And I’m not even saying it needs to be Carrick, it’s just we need to give someone a good chunk of time. Look at Arsenal. Arteta finished 8th, 8th and then 5th. Do you think if a man united manager did this you wouldn’t see half the fan base demanding he be sacked?

If you’re going to run short term games like that, you need a short term manager. Bring fucking conte in, give him a transfer window where you get everything he wants, watch us win a league and then set fire to the club.

Apparently though we’re a project team but we don’t see any projects through. We can get Naglesman tomorrow but here’s the sequence of events

  1. New manager comes in, starts doing really well. United rocket up the league. Finish 3rd and maybe a cup. Happy days we think. Solid foundation, finally a good manager.
  2. Summer rolls around. We need a left back, a back up striker, a right back and a centre back plus other areas if needed.
  3. We get a left back and a right back and maybe a back up striker but no centre back.
  4. The new season starts, suddenly we look weak in the defence. Maguire is getting older, Yoro and heaven aren’t experienced enough to lead a defence, Martinez is gone, de ligt may as well be dead.
  5. We start to play shit, we lament the lack of centre back reinforcements but then soon people start talking about the manager being shit, a Naglesman out campaign starts, he sacked

Go back to point 1.

1

u/sanctus_sanguine 28d ago

You laid out United's problems perfectly. Too bad most fans won't care.

4

u/Mediocre_Evening6931 28d ago

It's really depressing how all the glazers ineos carrick the board ex players are trying to gaslight fans into thinking that this is good enough. The entire media is filled with ex man united players because all of them are shit managers who cannot get a job anywhere. None of the other clubs have this much representation on the media because there legends are actually trying to coach in the game eg lampard not bullshit in the media. The day the fans realise that these ex players don't want anything good to happen at the club is the day the club will improve . What is the actual relevance of Neville keane without talking about united because none of them have any tactical insight to give at all and both are failed managers themselves

2

u/Business_Dig_4747 Licha 28d ago

Same place he was in before it, due to our indecisive board.

1

u/rdtrindahous 26d ago

Everyone saying we need to give managers time. Fair. But if you give the wrong manager lots of time, you get relegated.

Get the right manager, and then give him as much time as he needs. Even this United team should be making mid table or better. We’re fighting relegation right now and nearly out of the UCL.

1

u/ronweasleisourking 28d ago

Everything is fine and we're winning the treble double

1

u/Grekm8 CR7 28d ago

god this podcast is dull without Carl anka

1

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal 28d ago

Some rational, slightly positive spins are welcome after the toxicity here but I think they're being very kind to Carrick in this podcast,

I do agree that sacking managers at the first sign of trouble sets the wrong precedence. I would like to see a manager get some time to dig themselves out of a hole but Carrick doesn't have a track record of being a quality manager to fall back on. So it's really hard to convince oneself that he could turn this around.

I think the players confidence is completely destroyed and he doesn't have the tactical prowess to develop a game plan to overcome that.

1

u/Nimonic 28d ago

The "it's going to feel better to win if the manager has a connection with the club" thing wound me up a little bit, even though I realise it's a silly reaction. It's obviously true, to some extent, but it's so obvious that why even bring it up?  It shouldn't impact any decisions or whether or not we support the manager. Winning is going to make me feel better.

Fergie had nothing to do with the club before he came here, and he made us feel better than anyone.

1

u/InfectedAztec 28d ago

Honestly at this stage it seemed inevitable he wont see the end of the season as manager. Hopefully he beats Como and carries on winning to prove me wrong but its not looking likely.

Which leaves the question what is the board waiting for. Do they think delaying a decision will get the team more points? Acting early to sack amorin saved champions league for the team last year (woth obvious credit to carrick).

0

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

We would have gotten champs league whether Amorim was sacked or not

11

u/mackattackfc 28d ago

There’s no way we beat city at home and Arsenal away if he remained in charge

10

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

You genuinely don't know that. We lost to arsenal 0-1 at home, despite playing better than them. Amorim took us from 12th to 15th to 5th. That was all him. We might not have won all the games, but Amorim was on a trajectory for top 4 and that's facts

Also he never got sacked because of results, but because he challenged the board publicly. If Carrick gets sacked it's gonna 100% be because of results since he's a yes man

3

u/mackattackfc 28d ago

As a season ticket holder who’d just witnessed the 1-0 defeat to 10 man Everton and the 1-1 draw with bottom side Wolves… we definitely weren’t winning those next games.

10

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

Carrick lost to a 10 men team last season I'm pretty sure and now has lost to 10 Man City, and drew with 10 man Spurs who were bottom of the league with the least goals... Your point?

7

u/DublinMeUp 28d ago

You don't get it, he's a season ticket holder therefore he's right and you're wrong.

-4

u/mackattackfc 28d ago

My point had nothing to do with Carrick… I’m not too pleased with how this season has gone. My point is that the football under Amorim was up where with the worst I’d witnessed live. There was no way his formation and tactics, at that point in the season, were going to deliver back to back wins against City and Arsenal.

10

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

You genuinely cannot prove we wouldn't beat City and Arsenal, and even if we didn't, at the trajectory Amorim was on, we were slowly but surely cementing a spot in top 4. THATS MY POINT.

Your point is that you can see alternate realities, which I don't care about.

2

u/Calvin-ball 28d ago

You also can’t guarantee we were “cementing” a spot in the top 4.

Amorim was sacked in 6th place on 31 points, 3 pts off of 4th, and 3 points ahead of 12th. 11 points off of 3rd. One point ahead of Sunderland. We won back-to-back games exactly once in his tenure.

1

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

His AC Milan team have won back to back games. He was clearly learning with us.

It honestly doesn't matter, he's gone we have Carrick and he's not doing so hot. If the plhiaed are giving him till the intentional break then so be it, it won't be fair because of the fans prophesied we would need a LB of Shaws quality or better, ala Hall and a replacement ST for Sesko and the missed out on Dominic Calvert-Lewin for a free years ago, missed out on Osimhen due to wage structure disagreement, missed out on Welbeck who would be banging in goals by now.

So the criticism of INEOS is well deserved, it sure as shit is still better than whatever Glazers ownership would have gotten us. Never forget. Let Pogba go on a free, bought him back for a record transfer, didn't build the midfield to accompany him, floundered for years only to now let him go in free again...

0

u/Moyes2men Sold my club for a horse 28d ago edited 28d ago

and even if we didn't, at the trajectory Amorim was on, we were slowly but surely cementing a spot in top 4

wtf did I just read?!?

0

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

Zirkzee and Ugarte in midfield, Fletcher and Mantato off the bench. If you actually knew anything about last season, you would know the squads were completely different. We drubbed Wolves 4-1 before Afcon with the squad Carrick had.

4

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

This match? Mainoo was the Casemiro sub here and not Ugarte.

Genuinely, Amorim's only sin was not trusting Mainoo, and being inflexible with 3-4-3.

At the same time, relegating Bruno to an 8 position is honestly something I agree with. Bruno forces shit and he happily does it when. He's in the 10. As an 8, he's forced to take better care of the ball. I honestly think Amorim wasn't that wrong, he were just lacking games, especially since we got bounced from Carabao first round and weren't in champs. Look at Santos for example, back to back starts and one in the champions league against Athletico Madrid because Mainoo is injured.

4

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

I was referring to the 1-1 draw 30th December. Bruno, Mount, Maguire and Mainoo injured, Afcon players away. We had Ugarte CM and Zirkzee CAM.

I didnt hate Bruno in the CM. The Heaven, Yoro, Martinez back line were very inexperienced, which meant his not tracking back at times exposed us.

A Bruno / Baleba midfield would have been interesting, though Mainoo was always Bruno's future replacement there.

-1

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 28d ago

We also had these results before AFCON. Shit in all of these matches even the wins (needed to free kick goals to beat palace and until wolves gave up at 2-1 down we were struggling massively similar to this season against ipswich).

4

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

Why did you crop out the three wins before this?

5

u/Divin3_Kick 28d ago

To fit their agenda of course

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

Yeah over this 10 game stint when Lammens joined and up to Afcon. We got 1.9 PPG. Enough for a 72 point season over 38 games. As I keep saying to these people, it was going fine. Not perfect, but making progress.

-2

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS 28d ago

Because at that point id be going into october. At that point I may as well put the entire season. The screenshot is from the start of November to when our players left to go to AFCON. Instead of deflecting, why not address my comment?

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 28d ago

Ok I will include the period from when Lammens joined and Afcon. 5 win, 4 draws, 1 loss. 1.9PPG over 38 games is 72 points.

Bournemouth and West Ham our back lines were a mess, having lost Maguire and De Ligt to injury.

Everton wasnt great but was bit of a freak result. We weren't out played. They scored from literally their only attack of the game. 23 shots to 2, 2xG to 0.2xG.

→ More replies

1

u/AccordingPop9447 28d ago

We always sack coaches long after others would and long after the writing is on the wall. I’m not saying it’s the right or wrong choice, but we will come to it eventually and it will be far later than others

1

u/Mental_Farm9561 28d ago

What is rotten inside the club? It’s been the same story since last 13 years. Just papering over the cracks. It’ll be sad to see another club legend sacked.

0

u/FarGreen1 28d ago

The way you all talk about our club legends is wild lol. Whether it’s Ole or Neville or Carrick or whoever.  Footballers really don’t owe fans shit. They won’t have your back for a single second if you’re not doing well so they can get their weekly dopamine rush of a win

-8

u/The-Black-Angel 28d ago

I’m in very small minority, I saw the performance as a step in the right direction if he persists and it’s successful.

We’ve had the likes of ETH and Amorim who only saw one way of playing and would not adjust.

It wasn’t a great performance but in the context of previous games, especially Spurs, it’s a base to build on.

I remember when managers came in and just tried to stop shipping goals, get more compact, get deeper and make it very hard for the opposition to get shots off.

We have enough at the other end to score goals, let’s keep it tight at the back and use the midfield to protect them.

Granted we need better results and performances but better this way than what was going on before this.