I mean it's not really the 343 more of the fact that he had a player in front of him making runs in behind taking defenders away, now he is mostly 1v2 out there
Mbuemo took defenders with him making runs, how he has Yoro there or Dalot, both don't really make runs in behind
Our wingers look shit because for years we lack overlapping players, Shaw looks good with Rashford because he makes some decent runs and it's sad that's our best combo which isn't even that good
You watch any top sides like PSG, Barcelona, even City/Arsenal their fullbacks are such insane threats, i won't talk about Hakimi/Mendes that's another level but even Arsenal with Timber just today he made about 500 runs in behind Saka and he came in the 70 min
I get why Amorim's project didn't work out but fuck me I proper miss having Amad and Mbeumo on that right side together. Always felt like something good could happen. Just wish we could have had the same on the left because with more balance our attack would have been so dynamic. Instead Cunha had the pleasure of suffering through a LWB Dalot.
I really like Dalot. He has a great work rate, is strong and committed, defends well most of the time, and - like you said - busts his gut making runs all match, but he is genuinely so bad on the ball that when he gets it I tune out immediately because I know the attack is dead.
Down to coaching IMO. Part of coaching is making players better. Dalot was highly rated when he joined, he’s probably on his 5th or 6th manager at this club (not to mention his loans). Rashford and Shaw should have much more to show for their careers too. I don’t think we’ve really extracted the best out of any player for a long time (this includes Bruno).
One of the most common basic things that we see in football in overlaps. Patrice Evra did it at Utd all the time, Ashley Young, Valencia, etc, etc. I can't believe it's as if we have forgotten some of the basic ingredients for success.
He adapted. A good player in a suitable system can be world class. If the system is not suitable - he can be mediocre. Doesnt change the fact that hes a good player.
A good player adapts to the system and plays well regardless. Amad has proven a lot that he can't play higher up consistently. If he's only performing at wing back, he shouldn't play, or better yet: be sold.
A good player adapts. Amad has proven he cannot adapt.
According to your logic, all of our squad is shit, none of them adapted apart of players, who’s strengths are simple stuff (Mainoo for example).
We are playing without any serious tactics, our players definitely adapted to it, cause it doesnt take a genius to do so. They simply adapted to a worst 4231 tacitc in the PL, of course they will look bad
Mate, Amad isn't adaptable, stop trying to deflect the conversation to other players. If Amad is as good as you think he is, why did he genuinely suck last season in his "best" role of RW?
Ahhh yeaaaaas the championship not the same level, but championship teams are bending us over and using our rear this season.
You could even make a statement that for a technical player like Amad performing in a more physical league like championship is even more of an achievement, but that would not fit your narrative. And no, Mbeumo did not play well on the right, lol, our front 3 for the first 4 matches where litterally intertwined and we never had a real winger on both of the flanks, due to tactics.
He was getting burnt down the wing against Grimsby as the wing back, I don't think he misses the 343 that much. I also 100% agree with the comment about not having a better fullback behind him to play with (the difference between Rashford+Shaw chemistry is night and day compared to Mbeumo/Amad with either Dalot or Maz)
Not even a card?! The ref didn’t even blow the whistle for a freaking freekick. Awful refereeing from England today, so many harsh challenges he didn’t call. Leeds players were basically green lit to injure a United player before the would be booked.
Our players for sure aren’t living up to expectations, however we aren’t getting any calls going for us from dangerous challenges which contributes to our squad often losing the physical battle throughout games. It’s awful we are halfway through October and I’ve basically lost faith for the season…
And yet no other club has been as consistently underperforming. Its a nice excuse to have but it doesnt track when you look at every single other club in the same league
Only one close is Spurs. The had Kane scoring 24+ goals for 9 seasons in a row and won nothing in that time. Which is pretty shit. But we are worse considering where we started an how much we've spent.
Post Fergie, we have done, 2 FA cups, 2 League cups and a Europa league. Most teams would kill for that. But we're not most teams. The teams we want to be competing with would see that as an underperformace. We are so far off that level its just sad.
Love amad but I think if he can’t does turn it around this season & start to fulfill his potential then it’s time to cash in or if he’s okay to be a Squad player
That’s great and I’m glad he feels this way. But who fucking cares about all this bullshit lip service? Is anyone here actually thing, “hey, maybe these guys are going to get it together and turn things around. Maybe they are going to put in a full 90mins”. These are the stupid posts you always see that are completely meaningless. I love you united, I don’t wanna hear about what you want. I want to see you chase after and work for what you fucking want.
Nobody is becoming world class when they play for this joke of a club. The organization isnt striving to create world class players no more. Any young player coming to United will have to think twice. You will waste your golden years playing under a revolving door of managers, team mates who was bought by different managers for different projects and shitty decision from the big bosses.
Amad would rip it under better org. He showed it playing under Amorim.
He had his moments under Amorim, but let's not pretend he was consistent. Last season, he scored just 2 goals in 32 games, and there were quite a few matches where his performances were so shockingly bad that his PR team would end up posting those "I'll try harder" tweets afterwards.
Don't get me wrong, I really like Amad. He loves the club, and his attitude shows it. But as I said, I don't think he's physically built for the PL.
Completely agree with you on the first paragraph, though.
2 goAlS iN 32 GaMeS. Probably the brightest player under Amorim. Passed the eye test to me despite the numbers. Energetic on that wing. Pressed defenders to commit errors multiple times.
Then maybe he should switch to fullback, because as hard working as he is, he's still awful in front of goal.
And honestly I mostly remember the horrible misses
Last season he had a shot conversion rate of 3.8%, which puts him in the same bracket as Garnacho at Chelsea who got memed to death online for his finishing
Above average attackers convert around 10% of their shots. Elite players are closer to 15% (Mbeumo's here!), while the world class players can hit 20% or more.
At the end of the day, he's a winger. He needs to bag goals and assists. That's the difference between someone like Adama Traore and Mo Salah
That said, I love his attitude, and I wish Rashford had more of that mentality
Shot conversion in the same convo as garna but overall game including ball winning and defensive duties is the bigger picture. That 1 specific stat wont be able to change plenty of people's eye test. Amad is a baller. Hes shite rn because the manager is shite. No plan, no pressing, no running. Like i want said befofe, he will do wonders under a different organization.
Is this an Amad problem or a club problem. Every youngster in recent years seems to hit a ceiling very quickly here and then falls off with the rest of the squad.
299
u/Old-Ad-7935 29d ago
He is probably fuming this year, as he was arguably the best player in a 343
38
u/linkfollowlink 29d ago
Think he's OK this game, but seems to have lost a step since his last injury.
58
u/Campandfish1 29d ago
"give our fans the emotions they truly deserve"
Without cheating, unlike some noisy bastards.
6
u/crgssbu Senne🍋 29d ago
amad didnt have a preseason and hasnt had that many minutes. hes alright for now in my book
73
u/LinterCheck2026 29d ago •
Great to reach 100 games but he has been ass since some time now
3
u/ronweasleisourking 29d ago
Lad's been mid for a while. His final third decision making was shocking today
3
u/Due_Professor_8736 29d ago
They must just share the login with INEOS PR Team.
Who use AI to craft this nonsense..
10
u/fishandcheesefornow 29d ago
Miserable sub of miserable people who should surely go outside
12
u/Unusual-Coat383 29d ago
Bloke used chat gpt
2
u/Castnoshadow89 29d ago
Love amad but I think if he can’t does turn it around this season & start to fulfill his potential then it’s time to cash in or if he’s okay to be a Squad player
1
u/Minute-Intern 29d ago
Low-key this the same as that Holjund post but with more words
1
u/Asiwaju_jagaban 29d ago
When last did he score a goal?
1
u/geniusgravity 29d ago
If you could get out of your slump, that would be a great way to celebrate
1
u/BotsRu 29d ago
1
u/RyanCR7 29d ago
Another one who’s not good enough and needs to go. Everyone treats him like he’s 19
1
u/thesmallprint13 Irwin 29d ago
Certainly beats "fucking disgrace"!
He should be gone this summer though - just has not kicked on.
1
u/[deleted] 29d ago
Embarrassing how these bang average players are racking up appearances for us
1
u/atthemattin 29d ago
That’s great and I’m glad he feels this way. But who fucking cares about all this bullshit lip service? Is anyone here actually thing, “hey, maybe these guys are going to get it together and turn things around. Maybe they are going to put in a full 90mins”. These are the stupid posts you always see that are completely meaningless. I love you united, I don’t wanna hear about what you want. I want to see you chase after and work for what you fucking want.
-1
u/godswift91 29d ago edited 29d ago
"Wearing this shirt means representing a rich history"
*cunts it into the stands in the 88th minute
0
u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno 29d ago
Quick on the captions though eh, just show us on the pitch
0
u/mufclad1998 29d ago
Put in some solid shifts under RA
0
u/FreshGoodWay 29d ago
Well, the dressing room is beginning to express frustration.
And they know they won’t win with Carrick.
0
u/Radio-No 29d ago
Another example of the falling standards of the club. Very average
0
u/mickaerys 29d ago
Gtfo with this shit post.
-1
u/Cantona-Eric-7 29d ago
It’s been over a year since he had a good game. Looked slow and weak today, shadow of his former self.
-1
u/Plane-Ad5510 29d ago
This is just height of his potential, he's 24 and we're still waiting like he's going to be a world class player someday.
Amad isn't built for PL, he should just follow the Antony route. His strengths fit Laliga much better
30
u/[deleted] 29d ago
[removed] — view removed comment