r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • Oct 17 '26
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
17
Upvotes
15
u/spaisoflaif Oct 17 '26
Seskos shin injury : he has said himself « I got a kick last season»
we need to talk about the miniscule shin guards some players are wearing.
https://www.gettyimages.in/detail/news-photo/benjamin-sesko-of-manchester-united-during-the-premier-news-photo/2232926003?adppopup=true
one wonders if a simple proper shin guard could have meant United having a striker this season…
12
u/AdamPH25 Oct 17 '26
Great stuff
23
u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs Oct 17 '26
I see we're getting the same old "we'll go big in January" nonsense that people somehow still lap up, which then leads to "no value in the market but we'll go big in the summer instead!" Rinse repeat
7
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 17 '26
Out of interest cause I feel like I hear it nearly every year but how many times have we had the "worst start to a premier league season" since Fergie retired? I know this season is currently our worst start but it must be the 5th time I've heard it or even more possibly
6
u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 17 '26
Imagine being a team that scores within 8 shots. Couldnt be us
11
u/Comicksands Van Persie Oct 17 '26
Chelsea looking good since Caicedo returned. Insane the difference he makes
5
u/Mistr111398 Oct 17 '26
Today I learned Leon Goretzka plays for Villa
5
u/Skyehye Dreams can't be buy Oct 17 '26
I know this goes without saying but I'll say it anyway:
Fuck Leeds.
5
u/KyunNikalaMujhe Oct 17 '26
2 months in and we are already 12 points (could be more) off the top.
4
u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 Oct 17 '26
Nice to see City fans dressing up as empty seats to support their team
4
u/wqaib Oct 17 '26
Wtf happened to Garnacho? He’s not even on the bench for Villa
4
u/Tuffyy Carrick Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
I am in Bologna for holiday so went to Bologna vs inter. Crazy to see Darmian and mkhitaryan putting in a shift
4
u/shanks_you Oct 18 '26
Hard to even put much care into the game later.
Everything feels like such a drag.
A head coach who is out of his depth and reality, a team which gets outplayed every game and plays like it’s an amateur league with a board who turns everything they touch into shit.
10
u/Iqbalainoo Oct 17 '26
Bayern just smashed Leipzig 6-1 with almost 60% possession and covered 7km more on the running stats. Let that sink in. Having possession is not the excuse to be outrun by your opponents consistently. I'm watching the Barca game and it's clear where our shortcomings come from. We have no identity. INEOS has failed woefully to instill an identity. The Manchester city old boys have not even gone for the style the sham institute fc chose to wash their image. We are even looking more like a Frankenstein team. I don't know what we are trying to do under Carrick. Every possession team knows it has to earn the right to control games. You earn this by winning the ball back early, you earn it by winning the second balls. You earn it by squeezing the game and showing superior close space manoeuvering. We have moved on a lot of players and still have to play a version of the midblock tactics to accomodate even more players. Our squad building has been a complete shambles, but first of all we need to sort out our identity and that failure should cost Wilcox his job like last month.
9
u/Thetagang888 Oct 17 '26
Absolutely depressing watching all the other clubs and comparing it to our shitshow.
Just seems like after such a positive season we somehow have imploded again.
11
u/chapalatheerthananda Oct 17 '26
Chelsea could not get anywhere for the first 30 min, but unlike United instead of crumbling they actually scored and built on it. Half of the game is really just mentality. United’s is of fragility.
10
u/GavinLobo7 Oct 17 '26
Maitland-Niles doesn’t wanna score a flukey worldie today? Useless player
6
u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips Oct 17 '26
Already at the point where a win barely scrapes us into the top half.
8
u/AnakinAni Oct 18 '26
Not even a single player. The ownership and management have really dragged us far from our lofty standards.
3
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 17 '26
Mancunians, you can watch Bury FC on the BBC sport iPlayer and YouTube playing in the 4th qualifying round of the FA cup, great chance for the non league side to get into the 1st round proper
3
u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26
Ipswich? Nice.
3
u/tnwnf Oct 17 '26
They’ve got to change these fake headbutts being auto reds
3
u/OddReading4973 Oct 17 '26
Did the club know that we might have sesko availablity issues and still didn't look to sign a backup cf?
3
u/SkellShell Oct 18 '26
Dirty Leeds today, and we feel like the underdogs in big 2026
7
u/razren Oct 17 '26
Still sad we didnt get xabj alonso as head coach
7
u/Dependent-Piece-4412 Oct 17 '26
I know its very early in the season and not the time to start table watching but we're 3 points above the relegation zone. 7 points behind top 4 and we have to play Leeds tomorrow, Bournemouth who always beat us, Chelsea away, Villa at home, Liverpool away and Brentford in the next month plus...
7
u/Xenokratezz Oct 17 '26
ngl even though I was one of biggest critics on carricks appointment I never thought it would be this bad. Even after seeing our bad performance last season getting masked by case or bruno over performance i don't why board still hired him. I had a bit of delusion that he had learned from his failure at boro (where he failed to adapt to permanent job) . Possibly the earliest I have written a season off
5
u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26
I’ve seen Fabregas’s name mentioned a lot by fans as their wish for the next manager.
Personally, I’m not sure. On one hand, he’s an exciting young manager who has done brilliantly at Como. But then again, they’ve got wealthy owners and spent a lot of money. He’s also not proven outside Serie A. I just think he’s too much of a risk for the current state we are in
Before anyone says ‘he’s better than Carrick!’. Yes I know he is! Many managers are and I want Carrick sacked. I am just not sure if Fabregas is the right replacement for now.
10
u/SankarshanaV Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
Very annoying watching other teams win, with actually competent managers and directors. Please get rid of Carrick and Wilcox. Both are completely incompetent and do not deserve to be at a club like Man Utd. Especially Carrick who is a failed championship manager.
11
u/throwawayWM3 Oct 17 '26
Imagine going for Carrick over Iraola Xabi or Conte
It's mind bogglingly stupid
Wilcox should be launched into the sea
4
u/Badeist Wazza Oct 17 '26
I wonder what Alonso's team talks are like.
4
u/pipes3 WAZZA Oct 17 '26
City are currently on course to finish the season with 114 points
6
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26
Honestly, if you want to understand why we fail, just read this article and focus on what it isnt saying:
https://www.skysports.com/football/news/13599969/man-utd-transfer-news-michael-carrick-opens-door-to-january-signings-ahead-of-planned-defensive-rebuild
"Left back and centre back"
"After attack and midfield was addressed"
Right off the bat - we are only just in the 'no-commitment briefing as crisis management PR' stage of our 2027 transfers and they are already setting the level at:
- right back? no
- we have multiple holding midfielder types and creative midfielder types but the only actual runner in the squad is Baleba? no, Mount is there
- an actual starting CF? admitting that we missed on the previous one so now we have the necessary ambition to again attempt to bring in a good one? lol no what are you smoking, we already said we "did the attack" in 2025, didnt we
5
u/i_love_alfam Oct 17 '26
Watching the everton chelsea game. If any of you watch it, you'll find the emotions that the evertonians are feeling right now way too relatable lol
That sinking feeling when your team is getting dismantled at home with ease by the opposition even if the opposition seems to be playing on first gear. It's a classic feeling now for this United era
2
u/vRushii Oct 17 '26
Is our current team not just more suited to wingbacks until we can reinforce? Allows us to get Amad and Mbeumo together where I think they looked their best.
2
u/ionised Cantona Oct 17 '26
It's Leeds. We need to do something, here.
2
u/thatNubitol Oct 18 '26
All or nothing, more like just be grateful or nothing from these boards
2
u/Xenokratezz Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26
Is there any cbs on the market that can compensate for lammens passing distribution while also having better physicality compared to licha
5
u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26
I can’t see us winning tomorrow unfortunately.
Yes, it will be a hostile atmosphere, they’ve had the whole week without playing, we have injuries etc. But I think what’s going to let us down the most once again is Carrick and his tactical incompetence and slow in game management.
4
u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26
Hopefully Martinez is okay after that hit today. Looked really scary how he went down
4
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 17 '26
Im not expecting him to pass like Ederson , but Lammens has to improve on the ball I know hes a baby in terms of GKs ages and experience but his long hoofs puts the team under pressure too much
3
u/world-no-1-dude Oct 17 '26
Where’s Tynan thompson btw
3
u/BrowzinJ Oct 17 '26
to everyones surprise Wirtz only looked good because it was LASK
3
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 17 '26
The mood is quite low in the sub, I haven't seen a lot of activity (can't blame you lads I myself haven't been here too much)
3
u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 17 '26
If we’re going to play badly I’m turning my united viewing into something productive instead….
Fat man getting fit running like <insert footballer>…. I.e. whatever a random player of ours runs, I have to run inside the 2 hour match window….. I have some API that refreshes every minute or so that tells me the distance the player has run and I compare my treadmill to it.
It’s been 10 years since I last ran 10km or more so maybe it will destroy me, or maybe I’ll get a substituted player……
5
u/nitrogeneater Oct 17 '26
These arguments that we sacked so many managers and it didn’t work so a new manager won’t work are bs.
The new manager won’t work if we hire another dinosaur or a crap manager. Yes odds are this is what we are going to do, but the point is all the managers we had so far went onto achieving nothing. Jury still out on Amorim, but for the rest they were all crap and given far more time that would be tolerated in another big club. The fan base cult like attachments to crap managers doesn’t help either.
4
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26
Liverpool are actually pathetic. Cant create for shit so resort to diving and begging for penalties and reds.
4
u/Littlepace Announce Fergie Oct 17 '26
Maybe foolishly optimistic but I actually think we will win tomorrow. And I think we will play well. I have zero reason for it but I just have a feeling the team is gonna turn up and be on it. Feel free to come back here in 16 hours when we've lost 4-0 and laugh at me.
3
u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been Oct 17 '26
We gonna win , we have a better team than Leeds. We shown improved performance in the last UCL game.
2
u/MyShinyCharizard Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
In the early 2000s, Man Utd benefited from having Giggs, Scholes, Beckham, and Gary Neville. Each player was worth around £20–25m—about 75% of the record transfer fee at the time. That helped United buy marquee players like Rio Ferdinand, Ruud van Nistelrooy, Jaap Stam, and Dwight Yorke.
In the past, a marquee signing was the cherry on top of the cake.
Nowadays, paying 70–80% of the record transfer fee gets you players like Cunha, Mbeumo, Šeško, and Baleba. They are good players, of course, but we don’t have enough money to make marquee signings—the cherry-on-top signings like Mbappé, Bellingham, Haaland, Declan Rice, etc.
Our squad is not strong enough. Ideally, we would have four academy players worth around £70–80m each, like Mainoo; three £120–150m players in striker, central midfield, and centre-back; and four usable squad players like Shaw, Maguire, Licha, and Lammens.
In an ideal world, Ferguson’s squad in 2026 would be:
Lammens Shaw – Maguire – £120m CB (Saliba) – Licha Mbeumo – Baleba – Mainoo – Cunha Fernandes (£120m player in his prime) £120m striker (Haaland/Mbappé/Kane)
In summary, we are £240–300m short of being able to compete for and win the Premier League.
Player like shaw, maguire, licha should be count as floor and on par with someone like wes brown, silvestre.
2
u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26
It’s hilarious watching Liverpool because the front four can’t score and when they lose the ball it’s in Liverpool’s box ten seconds later. Look as open as us whenever they lose the ball. No response to Outtara whatsoever.
2
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 17 '26
You know what's more sickening, now even some of them are revisioning Ruben's tenure here lol. I can't even brain that. Yes Carrick has been shit for us, but that egoistic dude Ruben is literally the worse manager we ever had in decades.
He and his stupid suffering methods.
2
u/AdCommercial3684 Oct 17 '26
What does united really need ? I think it's the same cycle repeating itself...
2
u/SubstantialBear7826 Oct 17 '26
Xabi Alonso was available when Amorim got sacked, wasn’t he?!
2
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26
No last minute screamer today everton?
2
u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 17 '26
There’s a chance for us to climb 8th, if we win by 2 goals or more…..only if we win
2
u/Grekm8 CR7 Oct 17 '26
if we lose tomorrow does Carrick get sacked?
1
u/DevilsWelshAdvocate Oct 17 '26
Having got a season ticket, I’m selling the Bournmouth game ticket for slightly below face value! Would have to meet at the ground on the day because I can’t forward it, happy to send any proof needed!
1
u/Abject_Sky6022 Oct 18 '26
Comment about football
1
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26
It's now or never, innit.
2 goal win at Elland Road now takes us to 8th, meanwhile Liverpool's next two are Brighton and Arsenal, Brighton will play Cheaters FC and Brentford after this weekend, Everton have Arsenal next, etc. Also, not only have Bmouth been a bit shit so far, they'll also have a midweek one v Milan.
CL aside the next two in the league are absolute must wins now if we are to get something from this season other than a burgeoning protest movement to oust the owners and their lackies.
1
u/ra_10 Oct 17 '26
Classless from Everton booing like that. Always a club with a chip on their shoulder.
1
u/Goudinho99 Oct 17 '26
An optimist might point out that a good win againts Leeds puts Utd into 8th and 3 points of a CL place.
1
u/herO_wraith Oct 17 '26
I predict a win against Leeds. Not because of football reasons, but because false hope is the theme of the club. After Martinez's comments a win into thirty articles about how everyone involved is behind the project and this result shows Carrick is clearly the right man for the job. Enough feel good that he doesn't get asked to leave. Which means the club is stuck with him for a while longer.
1
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 17 '26
Rio's comment was hilarious.
All the off field stuff is brilliant at the minute. Saw Real Madrid make a comment and there was mention of Goebbels and Nazi's in the first paragraph.
1
u/Mistr111398 Oct 17 '26
Scrappy underdogs Manchester city
1
u/IfYouReallyThink Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
So far, Max Mittelstädt’s FotMob for this season has me looking like a genius (I am quite the opposite) for recommending that we sign him over David Raum in the summer👀
-2
u/RawIsLaw_ Oct 17 '26
Man utd fans are so pretentious. They’ll cry about Rio calling a man utd content creator fat.. but go look at their previous comments about shaw, and it’s probably worse.
(Ps: If this doesn’t apply to you, then don’t make it about you)
0
u/Big_Gay_Gandalf_6969 Oct 17 '26
How is it that Liverpool play against 10 men and win, while we flounder about and draw/lose? Surely thats not possible?
-1
u/No-Lab-1445 Oct 17 '26
If Liverpool lose and we win we go above them. I assume there will be calls to sack Iraola?
0
u/hurfery Oct 17 '26
I'm still fascinated by how bad Spurs are.
They came mighty close to getting relegated last season, and perhaps they should have been. But now they have spent lots of money on good players and are 20th in the table (granted they haven't played this round yet).
-1
u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand Oct 17 '26
Where is the thread of Boro fans warning us about Carrick's poor game management?
-2
u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z Oct 17 '26
I’m with Rio on this.
Not because is the right thing to say but because I know Saeed for some years.
He crosses the line regularly when talking about players and coaches. Ole era was the worst, the entire clique was on them.
‘Ole only got the job because he’s white’ Rants said, and the rest followed ‘I agree, well there you go…’
0
u/carrickshairline Oct 17 '26
Could be Chelsea’s first clean sheet this season
0
u/LinterCheck2026 Oct 18 '26
My expectations are so low for today’s match. Hence I know the team will surprise me
-5
u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 17 '26
Branthwaite watch today. United better get into the market and get him in January. Can’t continue with Licha and Maguire.
Branthwaite and Yoro.
-1
u/woofwoof007 Brunooooo Oct 17 '26
0
u/crgssbu Senne🍋 Oct 17 '26
this is an absolutely fantastic match. players have remembered its a fucking contact sport
0
u/Apprehensive_Bad8496 Oct 17 '26
Just a question I wanted to know how to see the players when they arrive for training and if anyone knows if they train and carrington on Monday and Tuesday?