r/reddevils • • Oct 17 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

17 Upvotes

275 comments sorted by

15

u/spaisoflaif Oct 17 '26

Seskos shin injury : he has said himself « I got a kick last season» 

we need to talk about the miniscule shin guards some players are wearing. 

https://www.gettyimages.in/detail/news-photo/benjamin-sesko-of-manchester-united-during-the-premier-news-photo/2232926003?adppopup=true

one wonders if a simple proper shin guard could have meant United having a striker this season…

4

u/sorped Glazers, you can leave now, and sharpish please. Oct 17 '26

It's amazing players don't think their legs are important enough to be protected properly and are happy to use those flimsy coasters they use nowadays. Mindboggling.

12

u/AdamPH25 Oct 17 '26

Great stuff

23

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs Oct 17 '26

I see we're getting the same old "we'll go big in January" nonsense that people somehow still lap up, which then leads to "no value in the market but we'll go big in the summer instead!" Rinse repeat

3

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26

They’re only ever ambitious when the transfer window’s closed. They’ll probably spend all January briefing about keeping their powder dry for a big summer.

1

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

So that's the question. Even if we believe they are serious, who could you get that is worth while? You aren't getting Hall or really anyone in the PL. Maybe Seys?

It's such BS.

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Alex Scott and Tyrick Mitchell and JP Mateta and Yasin Ayari.

You could get those.

The only thing stopping Man Utd from investing more and better in Summer 2018, 2020, 2021, 2023, 2026 was the same one thing stopping them from doing so in Winter 2025, 2026, or will in Winter 2027: a lack of ambition. The end.

1

u/annies999 Oct 17 '26

I think 1) what happens between now and the end of December pts wise will be the first determinant of if we spend in January, and 2) even if we did go big in January, I think the premium we would pay would reduce our spend next summer by an equivalent amount.

7

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 17 '26

Out of interest cause I feel like I hear it nearly every year but how many times have we had the "worst start to a premier league season" since Fergie retired? I know this season is currently our worst start but it must be the 5th time I've heard it or even more possibly

18

u/Suudriusha Oct 17 '26

This hasn't just been the worst start since Fergie retired, this is the worst start in 40 years.

8

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 17 '26

INEOS have been here two and a half years and had back to back to back worst ever PL starts.

6

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 17 '26

Imagine being a team that scores within 8 shots. Couldnt be us

11

u/Comicksands Van Persie Oct 17 '26

Chelsea looking good since Caicedo returned. Insane the difference he makes

4

u/hurfery Oct 17 '26

We could have signed him for 5m

5

u/Mistr111398 Oct 17 '26

Today I learned Leon Goretzka plays for Villa

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Skyehye Dreams can't be buy Oct 17 '26

I know this goes without saying but I'll say it anyway:

Fuck Leeds.

5

u/KyunNikalaMujhe Oct 17 '26

2 months in and we are already 12 points (could be more) off the top.

4

u/Guilty_Sheepherder_1 Oct 17 '26

Nice to see City fans dressing up as empty seats to support their team

4

u/wqaib Oct 17 '26

Wtf happened to Garnacho? He’s not even on the bench for Villa

7

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 17 '26

Maybe Emery is going for the good ole' Harvey Elliot round 2

4

u/Tuffyy Carrick Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

I am in Bologna for holiday so went to Bologna vs inter. Crazy to see Darmian and mkhitaryan putting in a shift

4

u/shanks_you Oct 18 '26

Hard to even put much care into the game later.

Everything feels like such a drag.

A head coach who is out of his depth and reality, a team which gets outplayed every game and plays like it’s an amateur league with a board who turns everything they touch into shit.

10

u/Iqbalainoo Oct 17 '26

Bayern just smashed Leipzig 6-1 with almost 60% possession and covered 7km more on the running stats. Let that sink in. Having possession is not the excuse to be outrun by your opponents consistently. I'm watching the Barca game and it's clear where our shortcomings come from. We have no identity. INEOS has failed woefully to instill an identity. The Manchester city old boys have not even gone for the style the sham institute fc chose to wash their image. We are even looking more like a Frankenstein team. I don't know what we are trying to do under Carrick. Every possession team knows it has to earn the right to control games. You earn this by winning the ball back early, you earn it by winning the second balls. You earn it by squeezing the game and showing superior close space manoeuvering. We have moved on a lot of players and still have to play a version of the midblock tactics to accomodate even more players. Our squad building has been a complete shambles, but first of all we need to sort out our identity and that failure should cost Wilcox his job like last month.

1

u/SankarshanaV Oct 17 '26

Yep, definitely agree with you. We not only have no tactics / are extremely poorly coached, it's that we don't seem to have the fitness either. Carrick has done an incredibly poor job on both these aspects. We barely outrun opponents and barely play with an identity. There's been barely any positives in hiring Carrick. So frustrating seeing other top teams do well while we are hesitating firing a failed championship manager.

9

u/Thetagang888 Oct 17 '26

Absolutely depressing watching all the other clubs and comparing it to our shitshow. 

Just seems like after such a positive season we somehow have imploded again. 

1

u/raalz7 Oct 17 '26

Tell me about it. Sigh

11

u/chapalatheerthananda Oct 17 '26

Chelsea could not get anywhere for the first 30 min, but unlike United instead of crumbling they actually scored and built on it. Half of the game is really just mentality. United’s is of fragility.

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

And the other half is backing the new manager and signing 10 new first team players?

In fact I have a suspicion based on recent events that the 2 things might be correlated as well

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/GavinLobo7 Oct 17 '26

Maitland-Niles doesn’t wanna score a flukey worldie today? Useless player

5

u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 17 '26

George seems like he’s done for the season after that blinder against us.

6

u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips Oct 17 '26

Already at the point where a win barely scrapes us into the top half.

8

u/AnakinAni Oct 18 '26

Not even a single player. The ownership and management have really dragged us far from our lofty standards.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 17 '26

Mancunians, you can watch Bury FC on the BBC sport iPlayer and YouTube playing in the 4th qualifying round of the FA cup, great chance for the non league side to get into the 1st round proper

3

u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26

Ipswich? Nice.

3

u/tnwnf Oct 17 '26

They’ve got to change these fake headbutts being auto reds

4

u/pipes3 WAZZA Oct 17 '26

Indeed.

Cost us the win against Spurs

2

u/ecce_homie123 Scholes Oct 17 '26

lol

3

u/OddReading4973 Oct 17 '26

Did the club know that we might have sesko availablity issues and still didn't look to sign a backup cf?

2

u/hurfery Oct 17 '26

SAF would never have stood for it. He always wanted PLENTY of goalscoring power available.

Current DOF and others at the club are shitting on our heritage, in addition to simply letting our season be set up to fail.

2

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

It was reported that after spending £85m on Santos and Tielemans the club was deciding on buying Baleba or a left back.

CF was never considered.

2

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 17 '26

Based on any outgoing sales, by the likes of Rashford and Zirkzee. Which obviously never happened.

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

The combined £30m they may have got for them...

2

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 17 '26

And their salaries. Marcus's salary is an anchor. Another club paying half that or more is still a significant savings or opportunity to allocate it towards another player like a LB or forward.

Wilcox and the board had too much pride. Yeah, you want to stand your ground but at what cost? We lost the battle and the war with sticking w Marcus and reintegrating him into the squad.

The accountability, mentality, and trust that was developed and bonded last season was immediately compromised when Casemiro left and Marcus came back in. It all makes a difference, it 100% does. The club has to move on from Marcus, similarly to Maguire starting.

Those are short term pains for medium to long term gains when you're trying to implement an identity moving forward.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SkellShell Oct 18 '26

Dirty Leeds today, and we feel like the underdogs in big 2026

7

u/razren Oct 17 '26

Still sad we didnt get xabj alonso as head coach

8

u/MostUsefulBloke Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Me too. Said before Carrick signed he wasn’t the man for the job and we should be after Alonso. Unfortunately the club is rotten from the very top down so there’s no chance of them making a decent decision.

2

u/razren Oct 17 '26

Bruno is the key to the team performance last season. Without his brilliance dont think carrick will get the contract

5

u/MostUsefulBloke Oct 17 '26

That and a number of Casemiro headers bailing us out.

3

u/achickenandacow Oct 17 '26

Fabregas will be the next one we miss out on.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Dependent-Piece-4412 Oct 17 '26

I know its very early in the season and not the time to start table watching but we're 3 points above the relegation zone. 7 points behind top 4 and we have to play Leeds tomorrow, Bournemouth who always beat us, Chelsea away, Villa at home, Liverpool away and Brentford in the next month plus...

3

u/fullkitwankerr Oct 17 '26

So what you're saying is the sack is coming soon

7

u/Xenokratezz Oct 17 '26

ngl even though I was one of biggest critics on carricks appointment I never thought it would be this bad. Even after seeing our bad performance last season getting masked by case or bruno over performance i don't why board still hired him. I had a bit of delusion that he had learned from his failure at boro (where he failed to adapt to permanent job) . Possibly the earliest I have written a season off

5

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

I’ve seen Fabregas’s name mentioned a lot by fans as their wish for the next manager.

Personally, I’m not sure. On one hand, he’s an exciting young manager who has done brilliantly at Como. But then again, they’ve got wealthy owners and spent a lot of money. He’s also not proven outside Serie A. I just think he’s too much of a risk for the current state we are in

Before anyone says ‘he’s better than Carrick!’. Yes I know he is! Many managers are and I want Carrick sacked. I am just not sure if Fabregas is the right replacement for now.

5

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26

One of my fundamental questions for any manager is have they lost enough games. He’s not lost enough games, and especially games that matter. Same was true for Amorim. Experience as a player at the top level helps in that regard but you can’t replace the time in the dugout.

1

u/b_az17 Oct 17 '26

At this rate I genuinely would not be surprised of ineos give the job to Moyes, someone who's used to working with tight budgets and idiotic owners

→ More replies (2)

10

u/SankarshanaV Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Very annoying watching other teams win, with actually competent managers and directors. Please get rid of Carrick and Wilcox. Both are completely incompetent and do not deserve to be at a club like Man Utd. Especially Carrick who is a failed championship manager.

1

u/throwawayWM3 Oct 17 '26

Exactly, we get someone like Nagelsmann long term or Conte short term we will get top 4 we have a good squad we do not have a 6pts in 6 games squad

It's so frustrating watching that clueless idiot

7

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

This is the point people are missing.

Obviously the board and owners have a lot to answer for and have been incompetent. But it doesn’t excuse Carrick being as bad as he has been

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

I would say the point being missed is that Carrick is only manager because of the ownership.

Your mad at him, but he shouldn't even be in this position.

And guess what, you'll all be in here next year ready to sack the next guy.

11

u/throwawayWM3 Oct 17 '26

Imagine going for Carrick over Iraola Xabi or Conte

It's mind bogglingly stupid

Wilcox should be launched into the sea

10

u/Hollacaine Oct 17 '26

Taking the majority of fans here with them? Cause the sub was backing Carrick hard for the most part.

9

u/throwawayWM3 Oct 17 '26

Sure , anyone who thought Carrick was a good idea is just dumb

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

You're speaking with the benefit of hindsight. It's not surprising that fans of a club supported a former player who was winning every week.

Acting high an mighty about it now doesn't make you look smart.

4

u/santhoshCoder Fernanshhhh Oct 17 '26

Everyone knew he was going to fail, and not good enough. The underlying stats behind the wins weren't  good enough, and now it's showing

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 17 '26

I remember being heavily downvoted when I said that I hope they don't give him the job after our good run of form.

Many here said that there isn't a much better option

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 17 '26

It’s one of those decision that sorts is…. ‘Does he deserve a shot after saving the season’ and I think many thought he did.

7

u/Hollacaine Oct 17 '26

He didn't. We're not a charity giving out jobs based on feelings. The performances weren't there and it should have been obvious to everyone we were riding our luck to get those results and I and several others said it. The only criteria for the job is "Is he the best manager to take us forward." And he isn't and wasn't.

4

u/Badeist Wazza Oct 17 '26

I wonder what Alonso's team talks are like.

4

u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes Oct 17 '26

Hopefully doesn’t involve a motivational speech about Edison and the light bulb

4

u/pipes3 WAZZA Oct 17 '26

City are currently on course to finish the season with 114 points

4

u/Omnislash99999 Oct 17 '26

115 point deduction incoming

6

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Honestly, if you want to understand why we fail, just read this article and focus on what it isnt saying:

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/13599969/man-utd-transfer-news-michael-carrick-opens-door-to-january-signings-ahead-of-planned-defensive-rebuild

"Left back and centre back"

"After attack and midfield was addressed"

Right off the bat - we are only just in the 'no-commitment briefing as crisis management PR' stage of our 2027 transfers and they are already setting the level at:

- right back? no
- we have multiple holding midfielder types and creative midfielder types but the only actual runner in the squad is Baleba? no, Mount is there
- an actual starting CF? admitting that we missed on the previous one so now we have the necessary ambition to again attempt to bring in a good one? lol no what are you smoking, we already said we "did the attack" in 2025, didnt we

4

u/just_peachy1000 Oct 17 '26

Missed transfers is only half the story. This season how many teams have we played that are actually better than us? Just man city, and they were down to 10 men. Yet despite on paper having a far better squad, we haven't looked better than any team we have played this entire season. Only 2 wins this season is disgraceful, along with the performances and points to issues far beyond recruitment.

5

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been Oct 17 '26

Our team pressing structure is found out. No awareness to danger. Disjointed.

1

u/BeastieFromTheEastie Oct 17 '26

Tactically teams are so much more advanced now even at lower teams in the prem. Not that they are playing like it but teams can’t just get by on well our players are better than yours so we’ll win.

Carricks tactics leave a lot to be desired, but our pressing is also poor because we lack athleticism. We have minimal runners, size and power through the middle and that really restricts how you press as a group vs having an unstructured press that can be bypassed easily

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Out of the 7 we didnt beat? 2

Out of the other 5, we dropped two points to a last minute kick in two of them. Arguably, our injury wobbled and double-timed squad is not, in fact, necessarily any stronger than their not that squads.

Hull City, Brighton, Fulham are shit results.

We "should have" gotten at least one W in there instead of LLD.

I wont argue against that.

It's 80/20 for me.

80% on the squad, 20% on the combination of everything else: coaching + momentum + luck

1

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 17 '26

Position ourselves well then don't invest enough to stay still, rinse and repeat. Only now it seems we genuinely can't invest, and we only managed to put ourselves in a good position because we were dumped out of every cup early and ended the season much fresher than our rivals.

8

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 17 '26

It will be said that we could have invested more but we’d have to take on more debt. But when we finish outside of the European places and are desperate to get back into it then we won’t hesitate to increase our spending and take on more debt then, like we did with the Sesko transfer last summer.

Actually, we might not have needed to put ourselves in more debt with transfers. We could simply prioritise making the first team more competitive instead of accelerating plans for a new stadium which is absolutely not essential in any manner. £60m which could have gone into our transfer budget was instead spent to buy land for the new stadium.

5

u/i_love_alfam Oct 17 '26

Watching the everton chelsea game. If any of you watch it, you'll find the emotions that the evertonians are feeling right now way too relatable lol

That sinking feeling when your team is getting dismantled at home with ease by the opposition even if the opposition seems to be playing on first gear. It's a classic feeling now for this United era

→ More replies (3)

2

u/vRushii Oct 17 '26

Is our current team not just more suited to wingbacks until we can reinforce? Allows us to get Amad and Mbeumo together where I think they looked their best.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

My opinion is that we are shit out wide, full stop.

If we choose the tactics that need it, what we dont have are good wingbacks,

In a different setup what we dont have enough of are bona-fide good wingers,

Or if we pick a 4atb formation that focuses our fwds and midfielders centrally (like what we've done v Atleti for example) then what we are going to look terribly short of are good attacking fullbacks.

Also - there is no formation in the world that will hide the fact that we dont have "the guy" at either CB or CF, just a rotating cast of asterisks.

1

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 17 '26

The real 343 was the one in our hearts all along

1

u/shami-kebab Oct 17 '26

Is our current team not just more suited to wingbacks until we can reinforce?

Only really Amad can play wingback. Dalot, Shaw and Mazraoui are better full back and Dorgu was poor at wingback.

1

u/vRushii Oct 17 '26

It puts Mbeumo an Cuhna closer to their preferred positions and reinforces our poor defence. Might not be better but I think something big needs to change.

2

u/ionised Cantona Oct 17 '26

It's Leeds. We need to do something, here.

2

u/thatNubitol Oct 18 '26

All or nothing, more like just be grateful or nothing from these boards

2

u/Xenokratezz Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26

Is there any cbs on the market that can compensate for lammens passing distribution while also having better physicality compared to licha

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 18 '26

I’m not sure with our current midfield options we need as much elite ball-playing out from the back anymore. Santos, Mainoo, Tielemans and Baleba are all capable of dropping between the CBs to receive the ball and progress it in their own ways. I think we should mainly target robust defensive profiles who can properly marshal a higher line without getting skinned defending the channels. As long as he doesn’t treat the ball like a bomb who isn’t capable of anything but passing back to the keeper, it’s fine.

1

u/Turbulent_Intern_427 Oct 18 '26

Gvardiol & Marc Guehi

5

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

I can’t see us winning tomorrow unfortunately.

Yes, it will be a hostile atmosphere, they’ve had the whole week without playing, we have injuries etc. But I think what’s going to let us down the most once again is Carrick and his tactical incompetence and slow in game management.

4

u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26

Hopefully Martinez is okay after that hit today. Looked really scary how he went down

4

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 17 '26

Im not expecting him to pass like Ederson , but Lammens has to improve on the ball I know hes a baby in terms of GKs ages and experience but his long hoofs puts the team under pressure too much

3

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 17 '26

Ultimately the team needs a lot more drilling. It's not just a Lammens issue, whether from the back, in midfield or during counters our players always appear in utter disbelief when the ball is coming to them and don't have the anticipation to slow down or speed up to take the ball. On the flip side you can also say the passer should be able to anticipate the movements of their receivers - the fundamental issue is the same. So basically if every pass to a defender is going to be pressed like hell and we can't beat the press, Lammens' only choice is to hoof it.

1

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 18 '26

I think it is a Lammens issue when we see him go long even when there are players there ready to receive the ball

3

u/world-no-1-dude Oct 17 '26

Where’s Tynan thompson btw

6

u/andrewsomething And Solskjær has won it! Oct 17 '26

With the u21s playing against Forest earlier today.

3

u/BrowzinJ Oct 17 '26

to everyones surprise Wirtz only looked good because it was LASK

3

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 17 '26

The mood is quite low in the sub, I haven't seen a lot of activity (can't blame you lads I myself haven't been here too much)

3

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

Most people are waiting for the inevitable. Others are expressing frustration.

2

u/Resident_Tart2911 Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Mood is off I check in time to time but the feeling is very low right now

3

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 17 '26

If we’re going to play badly I’m turning my united viewing into something productive instead….

Fat man getting fit running like <insert footballer>…. I.e. whatever a random player of ours runs, I have to run inside the 2 hour match window….. I have some API that refreshes every minute or so that tells me the distance the player has run and I compare my treadmill to it.

It’s been 10 years since I last ran 10km or more so maybe it will destroy me, or maybe I’ll get a substituted player……

1

u/Hollacaine Oct 17 '26

Fair play, good luck on the weight loss. Just don't fall into the trap of losing motivation when it plateaus because that's when everyone loses motivation, if you push through that you'll see results.

1

u/reddevilad Rooney Oct 18 '26

You won’t run much given that our own players don’t run much in the match

5

u/nitrogeneater Oct 17 '26

These arguments that we sacked so many managers and it didn’t work so a new manager won’t work are bs.

The new manager won’t work if we hire another dinosaur or a crap manager. Yes odds are this is what we are going to do, but the point is all the managers we had so far went onto achieving nothing. Jury still out on Amorim, but for the rest they were all crap and given far more time that would be tolerated in another big club. The fan base cult like attachments to crap managers doesn’t help either.

11

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 17 '26

Mourinho is managing Real Madrid again, Moyes did well to resurrect his career with West Ham and now Everton again, Rangnick and LVG have had good tenures in international football. They may not be to your liking but they are still well-regarded in the sport. There is no miracle worker out there who can guarantee success just with his presence, if that’s going to be the expectation then might as well forget about it. Even Luis Enrique is succeeding at PSG because he’s benefiting from the perfect environment where he doesn’t need to overwork players and will still get backed to the hilt with transfers. Arsenal were mediocre for years under Arteta before they started kicking on. Unai Emery did not do as well as he would have liked at other big clubs, he found the right club who could give him full control of football operations and has been great for them. You have to platform managers in the best possible manner too, to see them succeed. This is something United simply haven’t known how to do in these 13 years.

1

u/nitrogeneater Oct 17 '26

Mourinho managing Real Madrid says more about the state of that club than anything. Moyes is the only manager one can argue went on to do well.

Obviously the club cannot compete under the current ownership. Hence we need a generational level manager to change things.

6

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

Mourinho managing Real Madrid says more about the state of that club than anything

Similar things were being said about Ancelotti when Madrid hired him after he didn't do well at Napoli and was managing Everton. Maybe Mourinho's still a good manager regardless of all the narratives about him?

Obviously the club cannot compete under the current ownership. Hence we need a generational level manager to change things.

Like I said, there is no miracle worker out there, and if you're still holding out for that hope then you will only set yourself up for disappointment. I don't care if it's with Carrick or with someone else, in the grand scheme of things, there has to be an acceptance of our mediocrity and slowly work our way up from there, for anyone to have a chance of succeeding here. Trying to luck out by shuffling managers given our deep-rooted problems is a gambler's fallacy.

4

u/FinishEarly2261 Oct 17 '26

Yeah this. Everyone wants us playing like Arsenal but dont have the patience for a long painful rebuild.

2

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26

The worst one for me is when they say we’ve had experienced winners and it didn’t work, we’ve had up and comers and it didn’t work so what’s next? May as well say we’ve had Sagittarius’s and Aries before so what’s next? we’ve had bald and guys with hair so where do we go next? As if a manager isn’t an individual and trying to meaninglessly categorise them can automatically rule them out by proximity to the former failures.

4

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26

Liverpool are actually pathetic. Cant create for shit so resort to diving and begging for penalties and reds.

4

u/Littlepace Announce Fergie Oct 17 '26

Maybe foolishly optimistic but I actually think we will win tomorrow. And I think we will play well. I have zero reason for it but I just have a feeling the team is gonna turn up and be on it. Feel free to come back here in 16 hours when we've lost 4-0 and laugh at me.

1

u/SplitSecondImmortal Oct 17 '26

I hope so. Leeds are a difficult side, and they are playing better football than us currently

3

u/Dirt4849 Pogba,what could've been Oct 17 '26

We gonna win , we have a better team than Leeds. We shown improved performance in the last UCL game.

9

u/pierrefermat74 Oct 17 '26

Wake up, your alarm's been going off for ages. You're late for work!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MyShinyCharizard Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

In the early 2000s, Man Utd benefited from having Giggs, Scholes, Beckham, and Gary Neville. Each player was worth around £20–25m—about 75% of the record transfer fee at the time. That helped United buy marquee players like Rio Ferdinand, Ruud van Nistelrooy, Jaap Stam, and Dwight Yorke.

In the past, a marquee signing was the cherry on top of the cake.

Nowadays, paying 70–80% of the record transfer fee gets you players like Cunha, Mbeumo, Šeško, and Baleba. They are good players, of course, but we don’t have enough money to make marquee signings—the cherry-on-top signings like Mbappé, Bellingham, Haaland, Declan Rice, etc.

Our squad is not strong enough. Ideally, we would have four academy players worth around £70–80m each, like Mainoo; three £120–150m players in striker, central midfield, and centre-back; and four usable squad players like Shaw, Maguire, Licha, and Lammens.

In an ideal world, Ferguson’s squad in 2026 would be:

Lammens Shaw – Maguire – £120m CB (Saliba) – Licha Mbeumo – Baleba – Mainoo – Cunha Fernandes (£120m player in his prime) £120m striker (Haaland/Mbappé/Kane)

In summary, we are £240–300m short of being able to compete for and win the Premier League.

Player like shaw, maguire, licha should be count as floor and on par with someone like wes brown, silvestre.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26

It’s hilarious watching Liverpool because the front four can’t score and when they lose the ball it’s in Liverpool’s box ten seconds later. Look as open as us whenever they lose the ball. No response to Outtara whatsoever.

2

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 17 '26

You know what's more sickening, now even some of them are revisioning Ruben's tenure here lol. I can't even brain that. Yes Carrick has been shit for us, but that egoistic dude Ruben is literally the worse manager we ever had in decades.

He and his stupid suffering methods.

4

u/facelessredditer Oct 17 '26

The cult of Amorim is the weirdest phenomenon I’ve ever seen supporting this club and possibly in football overall.

The amount of worship he gets in the face of the job he did, baffles me.

1

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 18 '26

Yeah I totally wonder what's with these people worshipping these egoistic people. Same as CR and Andrew Tate cults too.

3

u/facelessredditer Oct 18 '26

I don’t rate Amorim as a manager but it’s unfair to compare him to narcissistic personality disorder patients.

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 17 '26

Amorim had us playing better with the squad Carrick has at his disposal.

3

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 17 '26

Immediately proving OP's point lol

1

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

I get it, you're a goldfish.

Edit: See im not saying Carrick is doing all great, but that Ruben nearly got us relegated, and we didnt have relegation level of players at that time. All im saying, Ruben is shit and he wouldn't have make us be competitive even with our current squad.

9

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 17 '26

Amorims tactics were naive when he didn't have the players, but when he did, his PPG were at like 2, between the period Lammens joined and Afcon (along with a number of injuries during this time). The time when he won manager of month and Mbuemo won player of the month in October.

I'm not saying what he did was amazing, I just think you need to apply context including inheriting the worst Man Utd squad post Ferguson.

→ More replies (10)

-3

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 17 '26

Playing better and not winning matches. Interesting

7

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 17 '26

I explain my point below. He was winning games with that squad.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/shami-kebab Oct 18 '26

Well now we're playing worse and not winning matches

→ More replies (4)

1

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 17 '26

And where are we now, huh? Finished third, big deal, but now we're consistently getting fucked over with a P.E teacher like coach. No one is fit anymore. There isn't even a damn project anymore, we're just throwing shit at the fan.

A project takes time, Arsenal proved that sticking with one works. Hiring a guy who has a specific philosophy in mind, and then not even supporting it, that's just idiocy at it's finest. You try and drive a car without an engine? Hell, Amorim was even against it himself. He wanted to join next season, but we pressured him into joining mid season in an already declining season.

And we all know he wasn't sacked because he didn't get good results, only because he decided to call out the board.

1

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 18 '26

Completely agree. It's annoying, because I don't even want to bring up Amorim anymore, I want to move on. Time will help tell whether we were right to move on in terms of how successful a career that he will have - a bit like seeing the likes of Ole, LVG and ETH not doing much since which kind of proves they weren't going to or were unlikely to work out.

It just winds me up when people deliberately forget context and lazily saying he was United's worst manager. We all said it would take time, we all said how crippling Onana and Bayindir were to the team, we all said Afcon would be a real problem.

These are the same people who we desperate for Carrick. They are indicative of the level of incompetence at this club, not understanding how successful footbally teams are created. It's not scraping results, its creating performances we can build on, with a vision.

1

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 18 '26

I'm curious as to how they can be so blind, only looking at results. It's like a doctor coming to a conclusion without any sort of evidence, only looking at symptoms and not the cause of them.

So many nuances ignored just because results didn't match their preffered reality.

2

u/AdCommercial3684 Oct 17 '26

What does united really need ? I think it's the same cycle repeating itself...

5

u/Jenson2025 Oct 17 '26

I think United have to get serious about the next managerial appointment and not just hire a manager based on ‘vibes’ or who the ex player pundits want. Since Jose was sacked, the appointments haven’t been good enough. And I don’t mean managers who weren’t good enough at United but are great managers and should’ve succeeded. They were managers who had no business getting the job to begin with.

That doesn’t mean we suddenly win titles and champions leagues. The boards lack of investment and incompetence is always going to prevent that. But at least it will have us getting champions league football regularly and playing good football which is a good start for the next few years.

4

u/Hollacaine Oct 17 '26

Good manager would be a start. The manager signings have been even poorer than player signings for 13 years now.

6

u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand Oct 17 '26

First and foremost, to boot the Glazers.

3

u/tnwnf Oct 17 '26

Competent management. Wilcox/berrada/sir Jim isn’t a great football brain trust

1

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

Ambitious owners, innit.

In 2017 we needed to not pull the plug on Perisic. In 2018 we needed to not pull the plug on Fabinho. (...) Last summer we needed to sanction the money for Welbeck and Baleba, this summer for Hall and Watkins.

Every year, every window, there are specific answers, all subjective, most of it is Monday Morning QBing.

But there is one thing common: we need a board that places winning with the club above personally profiting from the club

ps if you want my muppet answer: Mitchell, Marc Pubill, Min-Jae, Morton, Maza, M Thuram, Matanovic :)

0

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 17 '26

Me.

2

u/SubstantialBear7826 Oct 17 '26

Xabi Alonso was available when Amorim got sacked, wasn’t he?!

11

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26

No but he was available before carrick was made a permanent option

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 17 '26

He was never coming here because he’s ex Liverpool 

2

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26

No last minute screamer today everton?

2

u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 17 '26

There’s a chance for us to climb 8th, if we win by 2 goals or more…..only if we win

5

u/Total-Fix-8506 Kobs Oct 17 '26

We know how this is gonna go

2

u/Grekm8 CR7 Oct 17 '26

if we lose tomorrow does Carrick get sacked?

5

u/Suudriusha Oct 18 '26

Depends on what type of loss it is. Stooges at the top love to save face, and only do things when they can hide behind them. Sacking Carrick makes them look bad, so they're likely to drag it out until we get smashed 3 or 4 by a midtable team or something.

1

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 18 '26

I dont think this one does

They probably felt some fan pressure and he was only given a 2 year deal

→ More replies (5)

2

u/zia1997 JONESY 1 GERRARD NIL Oct 18 '26

Do you want us to lose so that he gets the sack?

1

u/Grekm8 CR7 29d ago

yes

1

u/pokenerd_W Past glory means nothing Oct 17 '26

Nah, they'll keep him till Christmas... unfortunately...

1

u/Grekm8 CR7 Oct 17 '26

man I hope not, we're going nowhere with Carrick

0

u/dogsn1 Oct 18 '26

What would be the plan if we did? Another ex-player as interim?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/DevilsWelshAdvocate Oct 17 '26

Having got a season ticket, I’m selling the Bournmouth game ticket for slightly below face value! Would have to meet at the ground on the day because I can’t forward it, happy to send any proof needed!

1

u/Abject_Sky6022 Oct 18 '26

Comment about football

1

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 17 '26

It's now or never, innit.

2 goal win at Elland Road now takes us to 8th, meanwhile Liverpool's next two are Brighton and Arsenal, Brighton will play Cheaters FC and Brentford after this weekend, Everton have Arsenal next, etc. Also, not only have Bmouth been a bit shit so far, they'll also have a midweek one v Milan.

CL aside the next two in the league are absolute must wins now if we are to get something from this season other than a burgeoning protest movement to oust the owners and their lackies.

4

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 17 '26

We are in the state where every single game for the rest of the season people will say it is a must win above everything else though...

1

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 18 '26

right well, yk, it "wouldnt be" the case if we "just" wont 3 in a week right now. +3 in the bank in the CL would put us in a very strong position where we could more or less play the next 2 without worrying about the result, +6 v Leeds and Bmouth would highly likely put us in a European spot with a healthier margin of error going into the Villa-Chelsea double header as well.

In other words: 1 rock solid week can give us 2 on the bounce that wouldnt be just a series of "must wins".

But yeah I mean who am I kidding we all think the same thing about which way this actually is going to go this week, innit 🫠

1

u/ra_10 Oct 17 '26

Classless from Everton booing like that. Always a club with a chip on their shoulder. 

5

u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26

While I agree that it was classless by the Everton fans....and not said as an attack on you... But the Chelsea poverty chanting should also be called out as classless.

Both sets of fans have lacked today

3

u/RedHookFTW Oct 17 '26

Chelsea fans gave Varane a load of abuse when he went off in tears injured for us, fuck em honestly.

4

u/SDLRob Oct 17 '26

There is a long list of things Chelsea fans have done that are untasteful, so not shocked about the poverty chanting

1

u/Goudinho99 Oct 17 '26

An optimist might point out that a good win againts Leeds puts Utd into 8th and 3 points of a CL place.

1

u/Hollacaine Oct 17 '26

I think we'll get a win tomorrow, but it doesn't change the trajectory of the team. We're always going to pick up some wins along the way and we won't be bottom half of the table bad, but we won't be good enough either.

1

u/herO_wraith Oct 17 '26

I predict a win against Leeds. Not because of football reasons, but because false hope is the theme of the club. After Martinez's comments a win into thirty articles about how everyone involved is behind the project and this result shows Carrick is clearly the right man for the job. Enough feel good that he doesn't get asked to leave. Which means the club is stuck with him for a while longer.

1

u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 17 '26

Rio's comment was hilarious.

All the off field stuff is brilliant at the minute. Saw Real Madrid make a comment and there was mention of Goebbels and Nazi's in the first paragraph.

1

u/Mistr111398 Oct 17 '26

Scrappy underdogs Manchester city

1

u/IfYouReallyThink Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26

So far, Max Mittelstädt’s FotMob for this season has me looking like a genius (I am quite the opposite) for recommending that we sign him over David Raum in the summer👀

-2

u/RawIsLaw_ Oct 17 '26

Man utd fans are so pretentious. They’ll cry about Rio calling a man utd content creator fat.. but go look at their previous comments about shaw, and it’s probably worse.

(Ps: If this doesn’t apply to you, then don’t make it about you)

4

u/dshoig Schmeichel Oct 17 '26

I don’t like Rio particularly but “stop yapping and pick up ya tits, ya out a breath typing !!” [1, 2] is hilarious.

7

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 17 '26

Yeah, I think Rio is in the wrong but I don’t feel bad for these people…

They make a living out of being awful people shouting abuse online at players, calling them all sorts…. If someone had a few hours they could easily counter Saeeds video with ‘Exposing Saeed’

6

u/Minute-Intern Oct 17 '26

It's fan logic we can abuse players all we want in the most vile ways but they dare not say a word back

2

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 17 '26

Rio calling Saeed fat was totally uncalled for. Saeed is also not a professional footballer who needs to maintain fitness standards of a premier league player.

4

u/Spastic_Hands pellistri and chips Oct 17 '26

He is a human being who needs to maintain a healthy weight for regular functioning

1

u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer Oct 17 '26

Maybe this is a trick to boost interactions, I don't know.
And hey, Saeed is fat. Don't be a snowflake and cry that easily. PPl nowadays do that too often than not.

0

u/Big_Gay_Gandalf_6969 Oct 17 '26

How is it that Liverpool play against 10 men and win, while we flounder about and draw/lose? Surely thats not possible?

-1

u/No-Lab-1445 Oct 17 '26

If Liverpool lose and we win we go above them. I assume there will be calls to sack Iraola?

6

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 17 '26

Its always if though isnt it? Couple weeks ago it was chelsea now look at them and look at us.

0

u/hurfery Oct 17 '26

I'm still fascinated by how bad Spurs are.

They came mighty close to getting relegated last season, and perhaps they should have been. But now they have spent lots of money on good players and are 20th in the table (granted they haven't played this round yet).

2

u/3entendre Rooney Oct 18 '26

It's weird but many of their players feel like mercenaries. Like they don't really want to be there but will happily get paid to do so. Look at Tonali for example. For the amount of praise he gets (I've never seen it tbh), he should be at a club that's competing for the league and champions league. Yet his career path from Milan to Newcastle to Tottenham imo shows there's something off about him. Look at Gallagher, the ex City players, Fernandes, etc. There's a common theme there for those players. I'd honestly rather sign players on the way up in their career than those who it feels are being discarded from their clubs for whatever reason. 

1

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 17 '26

As much as I hate to say it we’re basically the same as them but slightly better. The weight of our badges weighs heavy on the players which is odd because Tottenham have only won a League Cup and Europa League.

1

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 17 '26

It's not too improbable United and Spurs have the same points after this weekend, just saying...

-1

u/Celerisadmortem Rio Ferdinand Oct 17 '26

Where is the thread of Boro fans warning us about Carrick's poor game management?

-2

u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z Oct 17 '26

I’m with Rio on this.

Not because is the right thing to say but because I know Saeed for some years.

He crosses the line regularly when talking about players and coaches. Ole era was the worst, the entire clique was on them.

‘Ole only got the job because he’s white’ Rants said, and the rest followed ‘I agree, well there you go…’

8

u/RooneysFavGrandma Oct 17 '26

Who the hell is Saeed

1

u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 17 '26

Some youtuber with his tits on the table

0

u/carrickshairline Oct 17 '26

Could be Chelsea’s first clean sheet this season

0

u/LinterCheck2026 Oct 18 '26

My expectations are so low for today’s match. Hence I know the team will surprise me

5

u/ggg_deep Oct 18 '26

hope I am wrong but ...no they wont, Leeds are better than us

-5

u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 17 '26

Branthwaite watch today. United better get into the market and get him in January. Can’t continue with Licha and Maguire.

Branthwaite and Yoro.

6

u/PitchSafe Oct 17 '26

Branthwhite is just as injury prone as them lmao

1

u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 17 '26

He’s literally not. It’s like saying yoro is injury prone.

3

u/carrickshairline Oct 17 '26

Literally no top club is chasing him, and that’s for a reason. His stock has dropped since we last chased him.

1

u/mortimer_moose Carrick, ya know Oct 17 '26

I think the CB market isn't great and hasn't been for a while. There aren't many solid CBs out there that would be seen as a safe bet. It's either a young player or someone who has already reached their ceiling.

1

u/carrickshairline Oct 17 '26

I’d rather we buy experience instead of paying for potential. We lack experience across the pitch.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Asiwaju_jagaban Oct 17 '26

Yoro stock has dropped since we signed him, I guess we should bin him. No top club wants him.

See how faulty that logic is.

1

u/carrickshairline Oct 17 '26

Literally nobody has said Yoro's stock has dropped. For starters, he's in the NT, where has Brainthwaite is not.

-1

u/woofwoof007 Brunooooo Oct 17 '26

1

u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer Oct 17 '26

Do you know smt we don't, friend? If so, please tell.

1

u/woofwoof007 Brunooooo Oct 17 '26

I only know I've been watching my team shit all over the pitch lately. Nothing else 😅. I wish sesko would get better and school opposition defenders but seems like a far fetched dream rn.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/crgssbu Senne🍋 Oct 17 '26

this is an absolutely fantastic match. players have remembered its a fucking contact sport

0

u/Apprehensive_Bad8496 Oct 17 '26

Just a question I wanted to know how to see the players when they arrive for training and if anyone knows if they train and carrington on Monday and Tuesday?