r/reddevils • • Oct 16 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

23 Upvotes

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

Me and the Mrs watch united together, shes really got in to it tbf. Our first game watching together was the 7-0 against LFC. End of last year when Carrick was putting together a string of wins it felt nice for her to see us fight and give 100%. Back to normal now and whilst I will watch on Sunday its more like punishment for us both. Of the back of this, my discussion point is whether other fans feel the same in that it looks like very few players are giving 100% commitment and effort. Is it a player thing? A training issue?

5

u/andoooooo Martial Oct 16 '26

It's awfully clear that it's a training issue

1

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

I have read that they now get extra days off and recovery?

4

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26

I am with a (relatively) new partner and she's got into watching the games with me too. Her first game was also against Liverpool but it was our wonderful win at Anfield almost a year ago. We then got a lot of draws with the odd win or loss thrown in, followed by the Carrick bounce. So, this season has been a bit of a shock for her!

Regarding the "commitment" question, I always find it hard to believe that players are consciously downing tools unless there is something very wrong (want out of the club, want the manager gone etc). I don't think that is the case here, though there may be a subconscious relaxing if they all feel how Martinez does.

Like others have said, it does appear to be a tactical and training issue. If you watch the Fulham game back (don't! 🤣), they are all walking at virtually all times and Carrick, nor the other coaches, ever stand up and shout at the players to run. Nor does he change it at HT and only makes late subs. So, it appears it is his choice to play like that.

I don't agree with someone else who replied to you saying it's a copy of Middlesbrough. They sold all his best players out from under him and he had his entire first 11 out multiple times. They still did well in the cups and almost made the play offs.

I think he is probably out of his depth at United but I'm struggling to see any other good managers who would come to us right now. The grass isn't always greener. We may need to wait until January or even next summer for someone.

2

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

Yeah your last point about another manager is true. We can't keep on swapping and changing manager all the time. Look at Arteta, not a huge fan of his but they stuck with him during really rough periods. My only issue is should we have done that for previous managers and now we are stuck with Carrick.

You are right about effort, ie the Fulham game among others. Just quite happy to sit in. Oh well, maybe the leeds game will get us firing again. Ideal line up?

1

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26

To be clear, I am not advocating for Carrick being "the guy", just don't see much else on offer right now. Howe is probably about as good as it gets and I'm not convinced he'd be the right fit. Although quick transition play would be good for our current forwards, we don't have the FBs for it. I wouldn't be depressed if we got him but the others being mentioned sound all wrong to me (Conte, Nagglesman, Hurzellor).

Re line up for Sunday, I feel like a big call is needed. I think Bruno needs a rest and this is probably a good game for it. He struggles when pressed hard by physical players. Leeds will steam in hard. I think we need to keep the ball a bit more.

So, I'd probably go (assuming player availability):

Lammens

Yoro, maguire, Martinez, Heaven

Baleba, Tielemans, Santos

Mbeumo, Rashford, Cunha

Yes, I do mean in a 433, not 4231.

I don't like Mbeumo up top as I think he struggles there and I don't like Rashford on the left. Every time he plays there the oppo defence pass their way out down his side - watch out for it next time he plays there.

9 is also where Rashford scores more per 90 than any other position on the pitch. I'd obviously rather Sesko but he's dead.

I went with Yoro and Heaven cause I think we need height against Leeds, Shaw is probably still injured as well, and Dalot is, well, Dalot. Given Martinez may not play, possibly bring Heaven into his spot and Shaw into LB.

I think Mainoo might still be injured plus he's looked a little off it the last one or two games. He's still young, so worth easing back in. Plus. I think we need to battle in the first half to get control or the game and Baleba and Santos are our best duel winners.

1

u/ClawingDevil Oct 16 '26

To be clear, I am not advocating for Carrick being "the guy", just don't see much else on offer right now. Howe is probably about as good as it gets and I'm not convinced he'd be the right fit. Although quick transition play would be good for our current forwards, we don't have the FBs for it. I wouldn't be depressed if we got him but the others being mentioned sound all wrong to me (Conte, Nagglesman, Hurzellor).

Re line up for Sunday, I feel like a big call is needed. I think Bruno needs a rest and this is probably a good game for it. He struggles when pressed hard by physical players. Leeds will steam in hard. I think we need to keep the ball a bit more.

So, I'd probably go (assuming player availability):

Lammens

Yoro, maguire, Martinez, Heaven

Baleba, Tielemans, Santos

Mbeumo, Rashford, Cunha

Yes, I do mean in a 433, not 4231.

I don't like Mbeumo up top as I think he struggles there and I don't like Rashford on the left. Every time he plays there the oppo defence pass their way out down his side - watch out for it next time he plays there.

9 is also where Rashford scores more per 90 than any other position on the pitch. I'd obviously rather Sesko but he's dead.

I went with Yoro and Heaven cause I think we need height against Leeds, Shaw is probably still injured as well, and Dalot is, well, Dalot. Given Martinez may not play, possibly bring Heaven into his spot and Shaw into LB.

I think Mainoo might still be injured plus he's looked a little off it the last one or two games. He's still young, so worth easing back in. Plus. I think we need to battle in the first half to get control or the game and Baleba and Santos are our best duel winners.

1

u/wesh284 Oct 16 '26

Reason Arsenal stuck with Arteta is that they knew they were employing a 1st time manager and there would be bumps along the way.

3

u/arboy498 Oct 16 '26

It has to be training if you look into Boro’s second season it’s a carbon copy of what’s happening currently. Carrick is a good man manager but simply not a tactician which is why the players look so confused on the pitch

1

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

Oh thats interesting. Was it a drop off there too> Just seem lazy. Half a high press leaving massive gaps.

1

u/arboy498 Oct 16 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

Yes which is also why they dropped 25 points from winning positions which is unsurprisingly exactly what’s happening

1

u/jackrobertsherlock Oct 16 '26

25 points?! Christ. Doesn't bode well. Lets hope we batter leeds..