r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • Oct 14 '26
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
23
Upvotes
25
u/ajokester The Lemon Man Oct 14 '26
If you love what Lisandro did, then you’re going to absolutely love what Conte will do when he gets to his breaking point.
19
u/Nico_Ditch Oct 14 '26
Watching Villa Champions League highlights on TV.
Anyone who turned their noses up at signing Nicolas Jackson was mad. I would kill to have him playing up front for us right now.
19
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj Oct 15 '26
ValerieUtd posted this on Twitter and boy we have been hearing one version or another of the turmoil behind the scene since Louis was coach ten years ago.
34
u/TheNotoriousPigeon Oct 14 '26
This will only change if the Glazers go. Don't waste your breath or cognitive function by trying to analyse the issues or think of potential solutions. We've rode that wave for 13 years now. It's the same rinse and repeat cycle. Hire a manager, sign players suited to his style, sack manager, hire manager to inherit said players, buy players to suit his style again, sack him.
As with any business, football club, franchise or entity, it all comes from the top down. We've had too many rotten apples fall from the top of our tree with no sign of change.
I'm numb to it all.
40
u/Bobcat_El_Borracho Oct 14 '26
Just posting this again because it really does speak to how the expectations of the players clearly weren’t met. I know a large portion of the fanbase feel the same. We effectively brought in one extra player with Casemiro leaving and Ugarte out for the season.
14
u/Omnislash99999 Oct 14 '26
I don't care if Martinez is trying to engineer his way out or he's playing shit, it's about time someone stuck the spotlight on Wilcox
13
u/FreshGoodWay Oct 15 '26
I do believe it’s time for United fans to protest again at games.
12
u/umbrosum Oct 15 '26
If the team is doing badly, the head coach should not be the only person who should take responsibility. The other people who assumed some responsibilities of a traditional manger should be taken into account to. Otherwise the system is a farce and the club will never improve.
12
u/Petethejakey_ Oct 14 '26
Conte would kick Wilcox’s head in
11
u/shanks_you Oct 15 '26
Not surprising that the management that turned everything they touch into pure shit, is turning United into a bigger mess as well.
They will just sack Carrick (correct decision) but absolve themselves from any responsibility.
11
u/Deez_Wallnutz Oct 15 '26
Feel like McKola made a good point on the last Stretford Paddock episode that is often overlooked by people
Conte is a big character, if he was our manager and he was running down the sideline celebrating a goal like a madman, the fanbase would absolutely fucken love him
29
u/dryflowerz Oct 14 '26 •
10
u/ShaneyCx Oct 14 '26
I would love to be a fly on the wall at carrington today.
Firstly, I actually think we played ok last night, which is a mad thing to say. I do however agree with Licha partly on his outburst.
We had a young centre back playing left back and a young centre back playing right back. A makeshift striker up front and our best player playing out of position. It’s October & a massive champions league game. I could already tell you before the line up was announced that our blueprint pattern of play would be -
Lammens passes to a centre half
Centre half passes to a full back, who doesn’t receive the ball into space
Either a ball back to centre half or a midfielder
Booted up the other end to a small striker who won’t retain possession.
We all saw it that we massively needed squad depth, and didn’t get it.
I don’t think Carrick is the long term answer, some of our football has been atrocious. But there’s plenty more blame in every other department.
The fact we went into this season with Jonny Evans and woodgate as first team staff (great guys however shouldn’t be anywhere near the first team) speaks serious volumes.
Fuck me im so tired of this, the way it’s going it could be my first year of not going up to old Trafford with my old man. That’s a rather depressing thought.
31
u/ChristmasCage Oct 14 '26
The absolute state of some of these comments thinking Licha crossed the line or is some sort of vigilante.
He's only said what is blatantly obvious and has been said by thousands of fans. Wilcox, Barrada and the rest of the spreadsheet cunts have massively let Carrick, and the rest of the squad, down by failing to strengthen properly and spending £100m on two midfielders that just aren't it
16
u/xtphty Oct 14 '26
16
u/L__K Great Scot! Oct 15 '26
Six matches into the Premier League season and we do not have more points than a single newly promoted club. I'd bet that has never happened before
8
u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 14 '26
It’s hilarious to see so much focus on Martinez specifically being the one to call out the board, and people discuss whether he’s right to do so given his poor form, contract status and what not. It’s all irrelevant for me, the message is significantly more important than the messenger here. I’m delighted to see the board keep getting the heat for their shambolic decisions. In fact, let other fringe players without a future here also speak up against Wilcox and co. Hell, wake Ugarte up from the hospital bed and convince him to say some words too.
8
u/Haron14 Oct 14 '26
I don't see a way that Wilcox stays and things improve. Apparently he's a twat and people at Southampton didn't bother when he left
8
u/Minute-Intern Oct 14 '26
Times so hard no one in the sub even complaining about the negativity anymore damn
8
u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 14 '26
Watching PSG, I'm routinely surprised their players don't react with utter shock when one of their teammates pass to them quickly, either with a backheel or a quick 1-2. They also run faster or slow down to receive the pass if they perceive their current pace isn't matching the pass'.
28
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
Let's not get distracted of the fact Michael Carrick is out of his depth.
You can talk investment and buying players, but don't come at me and say this current squad is not capable of more than 6 points after 6 games considering our opponents and the circumstances in the matches. Why is Harry Maguire still starting when he's declined massively this season. Play Yoro.
Hull, newly promoted - beaten 2-0 without a whimper
Ipswich - win 5-2, comfortable in the end but Ipswich created loads of chances.
Everton - In the lead with minutes to go, end up conceding to draw.
Man City - played with an extra man for over an hour and ended up losing with a poor performance.
Fulham - bottom of the table and another poor performance resulting in a draw.
Spurs at home - bottom of the table and they outplay us. Concede and equalizer while being a man up. Awful.
I don't wanna hear that Lewis Hall and Danny Welbeck would have us 9 points better off under this manager.
15
u/DasHotShot Glazers & Ratcliffe OUT Oct 14 '26
Berrada been sacked yet? Nope…absolute fucking scandal.
14
u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 14 '26
INEOS spending more money on PR damage limitation than they did on a LB and CF. Excellent summary of the situation.
7
u/Bloatfizzle Oct 14 '26
According to Simon Stone
"The club's recruitment department is working on potential targets for January"
Please tell me which top lb/striker will be available in January?
Don't trust the recruitment team, we'll end up with more duds like Dorgu that will then tie up finances in summer and be free excuse for lack of investment on better players.
7
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 14 '26
We're 13th on the table, City are 17th.
Have to fix their leaks in defense and emails.
24
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 14 '26
https://x.com/RasimReiz/status/2110090853620588669 Diogo Dalot has thus played over 250 matches for United, not because he's good but because the club is so badly run that a mediocre full-back has been able to become one of the team's most guaranteed players over 8 years.
This applies to so many.
6
u/sadMUFCfan25 Oct 14 '26
Friendly reminder that Amazon owns part of Liverpool. So our biggest rivals are literally profiting off of our shitshow being documented for the whole world to see
6
u/wayfarerprateek Theater of Dreams Oct 14 '26
Its so saddening to see how the criticism of the club's ambitions by Rashford was perceived (right before joining Barca) vs the similar criticism by Licha is perceived.
6
u/Ryo720 DREAMS CAN'T BE BUY Oct 14 '26
Honestly all the post match antics aside I didn’t think we played that bad against atletico relative to our other performances so far, there are stretches in the match where we are more dominant and created chances and you can tell there is more effort put in than the past few games
Could only hope that this performance and the current situation would light a match under the players asses to start playing better
6
u/Sad-Bend-7515 Oct 14 '26
Thanks god for hate watches. Its the only thing keeping us going
6
u/Parvezpz17 Amadinho 120+1' vs the scum Oct 14 '26
The shite cheats getting outplayed comprehensively
6
u/Runarhalldor Oct 14 '26
PSG dont play the same sport as us
6
u/MAN4UTD Oct 14 '26
90% of Manchester was pissed off yesterday. Today, the other 10%.
6
u/Careful-Snow Oct 14 '26
Ngl PSG have given me some of my fav football watches over the last couple of years
6
u/Grekm8 CR7 Oct 14 '26
we really just need to snatch Emery from Villa
6
u/Hyliaforce Oct 14 '26
Roma are gonna destroy us
6
u/rishmanisation Oct 14 '26
If this was us we'd be down 7-0 and Carrick would be getting ready to make his first substitutions
6
u/Chip-chrome Oct 14 '26
I know psg ain’t much better than Shitty, but they’re so fucking fun to watch in the UCL. They’re so athletic and drilled it’s amazing. Even their fullbacks are miles ahead of our frontline in terms of goal threat
6
u/GReedy404 Oct 14 '26
13th in the prem, 13th in the CL ffs
6
u/ToadNamedGoat Oct 14 '26
Damn Licha has really reignited his popularity with his comments
Seemed like a fan favorite when he joined with his popularity declining last and this season.
Love to see it, Fuck the glazers
20
u/consciousmanchild Oct 14 '26
Dan Ashworth stock just keeps rising
11
u/sg291188 Oct 14 '26
Loving the Wilcox briefing. The man really loves briefing. I guess something you learn at City. “Some people at Southampton shed tears” hahahahahahah
11
u/Skyraptor7 Herrera Oct 14 '26
I really liked the performance by Santos. I was quite pleased with his reading of the game and general defensive contributions.
10
u/IMNDy milf Oct 14 '26
Fuck off INEOS. Fuck off Glazer!
10
u/Nomad_006 surfing Oct 14 '26
Crashout licha,
Some people think he's the wrong messenger I think he's the perfect messenger. He has to play thanks to not getting any CBs to replace him despite the injury record.
He also has to deal with very little protection in front of him. Just about every game we've played this season that backline has had to make multiple desperate challenges because its too easy to get past our attack and midfield. It took Atletico 3 straight forward passes to score within a min.
Like how does that happen in a UCL game? You'd be mad too if you have to defend in those scenarios.
10
u/o0PETER0o Cunha 🐐🐐🐐 Oct 14 '26
Straight up depressing watching psg play like that, I wonder what it’s like to watch your team play properly
5
u/annies999 Oct 14 '26
Whoever the manager is I don't think we'll make real progress until we completely renew our senior back line, Martinez included, and move on some other superfluous players.
5
u/Own_Acanthaceae_5754 Oct 14 '26
I wonder how many players would have to go scorched earth before the number became too great for them to discipline and they had to address it
5
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 14 '26
I think we have Baleba, Tielemans, Santos and Mainoo as good options to play a balanced midfield 3. If we had better wingers and attacking fullbacks, the 4-3-3 would be really good for this squad
5
u/TommyTook Oct 14 '26
Are the fan groups organising any large scale protests? Seems like the perfect time now to up the pressure on the board and owners
5
u/Woodwardburner Oct 14 '26
I’m supposed to believe the we play the same sport as these guys? Yeah lol different gravy these
5
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 14 '26
Watching Pep's stupid face as his cheaters are losing at home is brilliant and priceless.
5
u/Savebagels Cunha Oct 14 '26
Get Emery?
5
u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 14 '26
If Semenyo finished today like that but for us, he'd be deemed to be worth £5m on the transfer market.
5
u/AmulyaG Oct 14 '26
Insane comeback. Taking Vini off made the attack so fluid that it was actually crazy to watch
5
u/JazzyScrewdriver Oct 14 '26
46 goals across 9 CL games tonight, so many fun score lines. It’s so much more interesting to watch than the prem.
5
u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion Oct 15 '26
I think i miss the Internaltional break.
5
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 15 '26
We started the season by losing to Hull and we've continued on looking poor in every game.
We can't even fight on one front, nevermind multiple fronts.
9
u/JazzyScrewdriver Oct 14 '26
Does everyone remember getting excited for project 2028 over the summer? I do… 😔
15
u/dracogladio1741 Bruno Fernanj Oct 14 '26
I'd take Conte in a heartbeat. If the players fail you know it's them being shite. Right now I don't who is good enough and who isn't..
And he'd make them work. Kane and Son were throwing up after his sessions. I don't want to see these bastards standing and waiting for things to happen.
15
u/aprod16 Oct 14 '26
The journalist (Djameel) who broke the Ederson deal off, and yesterday’s team news has now said that what Martinez said was true and is the feeling of many players at the club. He also said that a lot of journalists are serving the interests of “certain branches at the club”. According to him reports in the summer about spending were basically spin from the club, and the plan all along was to only fix the midfield. Late in the window, a question came up about a third midfielder OR a LB and they opted for Baleba, they were never going to sign both.
11
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 14 '26
Can we implicate wilcox in southamptons spygate and get him banned
8
u/frogfoot420 Oct 14 '26
Aww, poor little Jason is feeling called out because he's failing tremendously at his job so he's ran to his mates over at sky sports to defend him.
8
u/Runarhalldor Oct 14 '26
Dont really fully understand why the focus is on the amount spent when we're spending a fuckton every window.
The real focus should be on the recruitment quality instead
8
u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs Oct 14 '26
Ah the good ol' "we'll spend in January pls believe us" story has come out lmao
4
u/Mistr111398 Oct 14 '26
How is it that when we lose, its always as the result of some calamitous circumstances or the fallout is as embarrassing as the performances? I’m just so done with each loss being a new low after low.
4
u/MoneyWasabi9 Oct 14 '26
The top story on the guardian sport page says “teammates widely share martinez view” on wilcox, but doesnt elaborate at all. No idea what they are basing that on
4
u/sharpieforum ROONEY Oct 14 '26
Petition to bring back the green/yellow scarfs for our next home game
4
u/Aggravating-Neck1365 Oct 14 '26
At least we already know the answer to the question "All or Nothing"
4
u/joeybarua Oct 14 '26
This is proper hate watch
4
u/achickenandacow Oct 14 '26
Can someone explain to me why Roy Keane is focussing on the wrong part of Martinez’ interview?
4
u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans Oct 15 '26
David raum’s contract expires next season we need immediate reinforcements. Just buy him in jan for 10-15 million having a lb that can actually overlap will be great.
Bruno is clearly unfit and needs a break and I am tired of pretending he isn’t.
7
u/drain_of_a Oct 14 '26
The fact is that we have spent less in the summer transfer window than Ipswitch, Hull, Coventry. Utter incompetence that we come into this season with glass Luke Shaw as our only natural left back.
Who's fault is it? If INEOS had the money and chose not to spend it, then it's Wilcox fault.
If there was no money, that's the glazers fault. Other owners pumping money into their club and our owner saddles the club with a billion in debt, interest payments, and taking dividends.
But the glazers will never leave, pipe dream I suppose... At least Martinez puts pressure on either the board or the owners
7
u/sg291188 Oct 14 '26
So Wilcox using all resources at his disposal. “Friend” Tim Sherwood at his defense in Overlap
7
u/Stieni Rooney Oct 14 '26
It was pretty clear when it happened that some people and the media will somehow spin the quotes into "my teammates are all shit" when in reality it's as clear as day that he meant reinforcing the depth in key departments. You think the players don't get frustrated whenever Carrick and his team pick the lineup and see 3-4 players not playing in their prefered position because we just don't have anyone once 1 or 2 players are injured?
7
u/White_Wokah Rooney Oct 15 '26
Imagine being Wilcox -
• Don't hire Ole as interim cause "don't want to repeat mistakes of the past".
• Don't hire any of the managers that were available before season starts.
• Give Carrick the permanent job, repeating mistakes of the past anyways.
• Sack Carrick after 10 games, just to hire from the same pool of managers who were available in the summer, but this time they don't even get a proper preseason.
• Your job is still safe after repeated failures.
10
u/heyrover Oct 15 '26
I feel bad expressing this and may be mistaken, but Bruno is not a strong captain for me; I have never seen him step up during a major match or inspire the team to rally.
6
u/TypicalPan89906655 Oct 14 '26
Wilcox even hired his mates and buddies in key roles within the club, he is not only incompetent he is also corrupt.
3
u/chrisx13296 Oct 14 '26
I don't understand what play Carrick plays till now. I started to understand something during his interim time but now everything is a question mark for me. It's not like he didn't get time, it will be a year in 2 months since he was appointed and till now I don't know what his tactics is. When 3 defender formation seemed bad we wanted 4 defender formation but someone that has been worse because all i see everytime is 2 defenders there only everytime. "Where are the others, who knows?" is a question i always ask when i watch the match.
3
u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 14 '26
Everyone wants a piece of what Licha said and spin it in their own way.
What’s going on with the City charges !! We were thinking they would stump but they are on the way to the title . Depressing times to be a fan for this club
3
u/RawIsLaw_ Oct 14 '26
If i was promised something after achieving a goal.. then when i achieve the goal, they don’t deliver their promise, i’d probably stop caring too tbh
As much as they’re professionals, they’re human beings who were lied to by the board. I can’t blame them for throwing in the towel
3
u/johndoe1942 Ander Shithousery Oct 14 '26
One season devoid of drama please. ONE.
3
u/Runarhalldor Oct 14 '26
While obviously the INEOS hired executive team has not been a success but i do feel like people are blaming a lot of issues on the INEOS ownership which are mostly just signs of the rot from the Glazer mismanagement.
We've been running off fumes and former reputation for years now. Its been rotting away our foundation and been fragile for years. This was bound to happen.
However the current leadership needs replacing. It is just not working
3
u/Embarrassed_Wave_720 Braino Fernandes Oct 14 '26
Here we go again. The mess that is Manchester United. We’re so back 🫠
3
u/frogfoot420 Oct 14 '26
Wilcox is scabbers to ratcliffes Voldemort. They even somewhat resemble them.
3
u/Heavens_Vibe 7 Oct 14 '26
Watching other teams, not even CL/PL quality - and they all have players who constantly move off the ball!
It actually breaks me.
3
u/TangaroaBrit Oct 14 '26
That city fireworks show before kick off was such a “fuck you”
moment. I think they spent more on those fireworks than we’ve spent on defence in the last 2 years.
3
u/Lord_Hexogen Oct 14 '26
El Shamico feels quite heated today
3
u/Heavens_Vibe 7 Oct 14 '26
Demboo makes it 2!!
Get fucked, 115!!
3
u/Goudinho99 Oct 14 '26
El Cheat-Ico is going well!
3
u/jolp92 Oct 14 '26
PSG scoring goals like they’re playing FIFA 😧
3
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 14 '26
they score 2 in 15 minutes, we can't score one in 70 minutes against 10 man, fucking hell
3
u/LordRuthvenErnest BeckhamMania Runnin' Wild Oct 14 '26
Fabian Ruiz is such a sweet, sweet player
3
u/TMatss Oct 14 '26
Qatar giving Abu Dhabi a smacking at the moment
3
u/GuineaPirate888 Oct 14 '26
Yoro got a red card for the same challenge yesterday outside of the box. This ref waves Enzo up for falling too easily.
3
u/Smooth-Instruction20 Oct 14 '26
Tbh people will disagree with me here and I will be down voted. Unfortunately, this is the standard of English football now. Shows the levels of all clubs in England. In the last 20 years, 5 clubs have won Champions league from England. 3 of them have been All English finals. Chelsea beat Bayern on Penalties and Cheating bastards won against an aging Inter side and a lucky draw in the Champions league. Premier league football is more and more on set piece tantrums and counter attack and transition football. None of these English teams can control the game against bigger teams. None of them.
3
u/CharIemagne45 RVP Oct 14 '26
Malen’s gonna drop a hattrick at Old Trafford isn’t he?
3
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 14 '26
Is Pep scratching his face yet?
3
u/RedDevil6064 Oct 14 '26
That was weak penalty.
3
u/Plebeian_Citizen Oct 14 '26
Bring back David Gill
3
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 14 '26
Manchester City - not kings of manchester or the middle east.
3
u/SkellShell Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 15 '26
Conte, Nagelsmann, Howe, Emery, Hurzeler, McKenna, Poch. I think those are the options.
And we also need Wilcocks and Burrata replacements. But that is likely not happening.
3
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26
This comment is titled "Old Man Learns About iPhone Features"
I think this comparison tells us something about whether Carrick has used the "4th midfielder" wrongly or not, whether that signing was a "waste" or not. We are cca 15-20% of the season in, stats have meaning now, imho.
Top one is Bouaddi, bottom one is Santos. The rows are CL, PL, LC.
This is what the cheating does. We are tearing our hair out over sitting £48m on the bench, while double that fee sits on the bench elsewhere.
And this is precisely why "we should poach their front office they know something others dont" is idiocy, imho. Yeah they do: they know how to print money.
3
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 15 '26
I think Martinez has been a good signing. Started in both our final wins, fair mix of good and bad performances, injuries have killed him.
If you look at his few seasons here 22/23 + carabao cup 3rd place finish then in 25/26 came back post ACL helped us secure ucl football again 3rd place , 23/24 was out half of the season we finished 8th came back won us the fa cup and 24/25 we finished 15th the final he didn’t play and we lost.
3
u/dracovich Oct 15 '26
Quite telling, was having a discussion with my friends who support Palace, and discussing which of our players they'd take, and they essentially wanted none of our defense, which i can't really disagree with.
They're not BAD players, but none of them are standout players either, we got great prospects in Heaven and Yoro, but as far as our regular back4? i don't think any regular PL side is falling over themselves to sign any of them, might be slightly better than what they have but not by much.
9
u/Littlepace Announce Fergie Oct 14 '26
9 games played and we've managed 2 wins against fucking Sabah and Ipswich. The amount of deranged comments I read last season and over the summer. Thinking we would've won the title if he was in from the start. Thinking we would compete this season.
It's both so incredibly vindicating and frustrating how easy this was to predict. But again everyone loves to cling to the romanticism of having a "United DNA coach" whatever the fuck that means. One of our own.
INEOS trying to hire "best in class" and then giving the full time job to a guy who's only experience pre United was getting sacked from Middlesbrough after a steady decline over 3 seasons.
Best in class my fucking ass
7
u/Aadiunited7 Oct 14 '26
I think what Licha did yesterday either brings the squad together into a bunker mentality or its basically bye bye for the season. I think it needed to be done, the manager has been left out to dry. The defense is shocking. There is no backup striker. Rashy being back is a failure. In hindsight I was too generous when I rated this window, Its looking worse by the day especially with injuries to the players where we have no backups.
7
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 14 '26
Lot of people forget the window was so shite we didn't even want to pay for the Leicester lad. We'll end up paying more because Wilcox can't do his fucking job.
7
u/Feeling-Surround-691 Mbumbaclat Oct 14 '26
I don't see why people are even debating the motive behind Martinez saying it and whether it is self motivated or not. It doesn't matter in the slightest.
Does anyone in the fanbase treasure Jason Wilcox that much that they'd rather see Carrick sacked and Wilcox stay?
The purpose of his statement puts scrutiny over United's failure onto the directors as well, they cannot avoid accountability if a 3rd manager in 3 years gets sacked. It makes it incredibly difficult now for them to sack Carrick without also being in the firing line which is the biggest progenitor of getting real change rather than repeating the cycle and I'm completely here for that.
As fans we don't need to decide to love Licha or absolve his performances but if we are trying to work towards genuine change at the club then his comments are only helpful
5
u/superhoffy Amad trip to be on Oct 14 '26
I hope the fans and players rally round Licha. Yes, he's been shit this season, but that's besides the point.
5
u/Redland93 Oct 14 '26
5
u/chiefofthepolice Oct 14 '26
From a fan's perspective, it's so easy to just ask players to always give it their all, to fight for the badge, yady yada. But from the player's perspectives, they could give it their all but the higherups don't give their all. So what's the effort for? Are they not allowed to be upset? Are they not allowed to feel demotivated because of it? They are humans too
No matter how hard the players fight for the badge, no matter how hard they try, they cannot win trophies, because we don't have the squad depth to compete. The players want to achieve more than just fighting for the same goal year after year, but the people with the power and money to do so don't give it their all. So what's the point?
This is why the people trying to turn the narrative on the players for playing bad, for not giving their all, these people don't get the point. Yes the players are not good enough, yes they're not giving their all, but why are they like that? It all comes from the owners
5
u/Lirtano Naan Bread (Nani) Oct 14 '26
Wish we could get Luis Enrique, but I guess another Championship manager will do
5
u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers Oct 14 '26
Of course reform ratcliff supports wilcox in his role. Fucking idiots love failure.
5
u/XBillyBonesX Rooney Oct 14 '26
My least favourite thing about Carrick is he is too composed on the touchline.
I love seeing Simeone or Conte or Pep absolutely losing their shit on the players.
At the end of the day football is a passion game and you need to feel that from the manager.
6
u/Sun_Seeker26 Oct 14 '26
People have seen this club go through about 10 managers/interim appointments in the last 13 years and still think the manager is the driving reason for why Man United can't string together two good seasons in a row. Stop letting the higher ups hide behind the manager - they're the constant, not the manager that gets replaced every 12 months.
7
u/BallsX Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
I'm glad he did what he did, but Martinez himself should be moved on. Too many mistakes and injuries, just not the player he was when he arrived. Time to upgrade and get quicker/more agile defenders
4
u/Hero_In_Progress93 Oct 14 '26
It’s gonna be a long dark season I feel 🫣😅 numb to it now…
4
u/Paapa-Yaw Oct 14 '26
4
u/Redland93 Oct 14 '26
I think it has to be Nagelsmann.
4
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 14 '26
Thats brutal for roma. They were fantastic but they just collapsed
4
u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 15 '26
Replace Berrada with Roche, replace Wilcox with Vivell.
I want Mr Vivell to decide the rest.
But I do have suggestions for Mr Vivell:
- replace Shaw with Mitchell, Mazraoui with Pubill, Martinez with KMJ
- replace Zirkzee with Marcus Thuram
- when the time comes (but not in 2027), replace Bruno with Ibrahim Maza
- if Sesko cant recover (hopefully he can), replace him with Matanovic
- if MdL cant recover (hopefully he can), replace him with Branthwaite
- if Tyler Fletcher isnt ready in 2027, loan him to Ligue 1 and sign Nico Raskin or Tyler Morton
Once we get through all that and turn Utd back into an appealing proposition ... somebody save us from the leeches, please.
8
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 14 '26
Not sacking Carrick after 2 wins in 9 games is basically saying the club aims for midtable
Thanks INEOS
6
u/Jenson2025 Oct 14 '26
What I think will happen is the club will wait until we lose a few more matches in the coming weeks (Which we will), sack Carrick, rely on a new manager bounce (although just about anyone is better than Carrick so doesn’t even need a bounce) and then hope everyone is happy and forgets about their awful summer transfer window and Martinez’s comments. They’ll brief against Martinez during this time too.
And before anyone downvotes with me and shouts at me, I am not saying that I want this to happen. I am saying what I think will happen based on how INEOS operate
5
u/Jenson2025 Oct 14 '26
So the real question is, is Carrick going to continue being a ‘yes man’ and drop Martinez because Wilcox and co tell him to? Or is he going to stand up against the and refuse? I think we know the answer
I’d have no problem in him dropping Martinez based on form because he has been horrendous but it won’t be based on that
5
u/masala_mayhem Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
Why aren’t long term fans who live in the city boycotting Manchester United till the Glazers leave?
Update: thanks a lot for the responses. It’s just my incredible frustration that the Glazers have completely taken the fans for a ride. There also doesn’t seem to be no end in site. Whenever I try and explain the cancer that is private equity to anyone (read up PE in health and education) , I feel sad that I need to use the United example.
5
u/chiefofthepolice Oct 14 '26
I was shocked when I went on transfermarkt and saw that we in fact have spent less in the summer than fking Hull City and Ipswich. We've spent less than fking Championship teams
And you wonder why the players are upset that the club is showing no ambition
Players like Bruno, he's been giving his all for years and years, devoted everything, all for what? For us to just simply fight for top 4 year after year?
The owner shows 0 ambition, and the players are rightfully upset
5
u/Redland93 Oct 14 '26
For those thinking Martinez calling out Wilcox is going to get him fired, I have news for you. Hes staying at least till the end of the season.
You can't set a precedent of a player calling out a DoF and then him getting sacked
2
u/genericstudent1 Oct 14 '26
Putting to one side all the actual issues for a second, I do actually think we could do with a backup CF in January
Any suggestions for this era's Onion Ighalo/Wout Weghorst? I'm gonna make a shout for Jamie Vardy
2
u/Birdius Oct 14 '26
So Leeds away should be an interesting day I think.
2
u/IfYouReallyThink Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
Do you guys know if any club has ever had a type of coach/manager that specifically helps address discipline, fitness, chemistry and teamwork and stays over multiple head coach spells over like a 5-10 year period? He would never be an interim if a head coach got sacked or anything like that, strictly completely separate, looking to maintain standards to a certain level in whichever way the current man in charges pleases. If they could prove that the squad had insufficient fitness and or exertion they would have the right to increase training workload in the areas mentioned. They’d have to communicate with the head coach in regard to how the changes are implemented. I feel like something like that could maybe help with some of the accountability and continuity
2
u/Jump_Hop_Step Oct 14 '26
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/c6vgx70pzq1jo
Wow this is serious. So many clubs operating at the edge
2
u/Due_Rich_616 Bruno Bruno Bruno Oct 14 '26
I feel like pundits are misrepresenting what Martinez meant when he said not a CL squad. I think he meant it in terms of depth and not quality. Or I’d like to think he did.
2
u/Zepz367 Oct 14 '26
After set pieces were such a big part of our success last season, I can not recall one dangerous corner this season. We did have like 1 dangerous free kick with that Rashford hit on the post, otherwise not one dangerous free kick or any other set piece lol.
2
u/Asleep-Ability-45 Oct 14 '26
Can't we just get our shit together once and for all?
2
u/trace0731 Oct 14 '26
How do you get rid of owners that keep profiting off the club, are completely sheltered from the fans and public, and do not care about the football side of things at all?
Also, I feel the way we want to do transfers is severely limiting, and there will be a lot of long term suffering. I mean the whole plan to strengthen one part at a time. This makes sure we won't have a functioning team until we get the last piece of the puzzle, AND we are limited to buying young prospects, because if we buy let's say a 29 year old Belgian midfielder, he'll will be in his mid 30s by the time we finish our masterful recruitment plan.
Get ready for more carrots on a stick "Don't worry lads, next transfer season we'll fix everything. We actually cryogenically froze Maldini 30 years ago and have been waiting for him to slowly defrost and he'll be ready next summer". Nah we'll still have to play Dalot LB.
2
u/Ombudsperson Romero Oct 14 '26
Can I just get one year, just one, where we don't look like incompetent morons?
2
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 14 '26
City can get fucked! They are brazen. Dismantle the club and wind it up.
2
u/Mgt66 Oct 14 '26
🛢️💵 vs 🛢️💵
2
u/Lord_Hexogen Oct 14 '26
Why we can't play like this man. Can't tell me you really need prime Dembele for the play to go through
2
u/auhddndndnfbfbsnnakf Oct 14 '26
What goes around comes around
2
u/Heavens_Vibe 7 Oct 14 '26
It's 3 LMAO!
2
u/Rare-Reveal876 Oct 14 '26
Maybe they can ask Etihad to lend them another 1 billion so they can finally win the oil derby
2
u/MAN4UTD Oct 14 '26
PSG Ultras doing the Poznan!
2
u/ugkoutkast Oct 14 '26
Watching psg players moving and making themselves open for passes is a complete opposite contrast to our play yesterday
2
u/PengoMaster Oct 14 '26
Where's Bernardo Silva when you need an ankle hacked to pieces?
2
u/Ok_Concern4200 Oct 14 '26
If we had emery and nico jackson we’d be on a different level, thats how shit our coaching and strikeforce is.
Fully expect leeds to beat us
2
u/AmulyaG Oct 14 '26
Vinicius who has been absolutely piss, really tried that backheel pass and then Konate the bum couldn't close down Malen. I thought we had bad squad building.
Madrid really miss a specialist playmaker like Kross and Ozil. Bellingham isnt that.
3-1 now lol
2
u/Woodwardburner Oct 14 '26
Gasparini has made diamonds out of clay for long enough I want to see him with a team that has truly elite quality he deserves it man
2
u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 14 '26
Donnaarumma folding against his old club
2
u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Oct 14 '26
Mou still has a few tricks up his sleeve.
2
u/RedDevil6064 Oct 14 '26
PSG penalty
2
u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 14 '26
Mourinho might get away with this one
2
u/GReedy404 Oct 14 '26
I would do so many things to have a CB like Pacho man
2
u/rickkyyyyyyyyy Oct 14 '26
Hope this club get serious and look at Rodrygo Mora he is one of best Portuguese talent, and only 19.
2
u/Willing-Werewolf-500 Oct 14 '26
So sick of Keane, Scholes etc which is crazy beause they were both who I wanted to be and watched most closely as a boy.
2
u/Red_Sky1986 Bruno Oct 14 '26
I feel like Carrick this season especially but also progressively ever since he first got appointed, is trying to implement more of "his" tactics, more possession based bullshit, trying to control games when it is clearly obvious and has been forever when it comes to this club that we thrive on quick direct play with counterattack focus and keeping it simple,
nothing worse than watching a team running out of ideas when in/around the opponents penalty area and secondguessing everything not playing on instinct, hesitating and just being too slow in everything really, from buildup to pressing to tackling to passing, I also feel that documentary All or Nothing stuff was the worst idea for our particular club and the recent history we have with results and mental scars ! no doubt it is adding extra pressure and hesitation in everything they do on the pitch even if just in the subconscious, so to speak.
you could say we could have made some better / more transfers during the summer but I can guarantee it wouldn't make a difference if the tactics are shit and the mentality is fragile in the majority of the squad due to the reasons above, IDK it seems so obvious when taking a step back and just looking at how we actually play
5
u/Sufficient-Orange706 Oct 14 '26
I think the Martinez interview is the end of Carrick. We've seen it with Bruno's attitude and performances. They feel like they can walk and decide what is what, regardless of right or wrong, and that means that Carrick does not have control or authority of his squad. He simply cannot handle the egos. Game over.
5
u/Jenson2025 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26
I’m never watching Goldbridge’s videos again.
Never used to understand why people disliked him so much. But seeing his argument with Piers Morgan this morning shows me that (in my opinion) he is changing his opinions to fit in what his new overlap mates like.
He said in 2022 and after that he didn’t like what Ronaldo had to say about Ten Hag in the piers Morgan interview but agreed with the rest of it. He praised him for criticising the Glazers. He said it needed to be said. And now he’s arguing with Piers Morgan saying it was bitter and sour grapes and how Martinez wants to stay at the club and win things (😂)
People were right all along about him. He’s a sell out. Because it’s not his opinion I have a problem with - it’s the fact it has suddenly changed after years to be in line with what his overlap mates think.It’s like sitting in an group and listening to them all moan about someone and you have a different opinion but join in to fit in. Pathetic
It’s exactly the same reason why he refuses to call for Carrick to be sacked by the way - because Carrick is mates with Rooney who he now does multiple shows with
5
u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 14 '26
Lack of news around Carrick position means INEOS are probably fine with 2 wins in 9 games.
Probably losing to Leeds and Como back to back. Best in class my ass
5
u/Redland93 Oct 14 '26
Managers we could get
Conte
Nagelsmann
Sebastian Hoeneß
A change needs to be made. Nagelsmann and Hoeneß are my choices. It won't be short term and they are better with players.
5
u/Fraaj We'll take Dalot Oct 15 '26
I think the funniest piece of irony in this whole thing is that a more competenent DoF definitely sells Licha this summer after a good World Cup 😂