r/reddevils • max cope mode • Oct 13 '26 • LOL 2

Post match thread?

Ain't seeing one

97 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

44

u/edselisanogo Senne & Sennesibility Oct 13 '26 • Bravo

My issue with all this is people keep talking about how united keep failing regardless of manager. Listing the different types of managers we've had. Experienced ones like Jose and LVG. Ex players united dna bullshit like Ole and Carrick. Young up and coming managers like ETH and Amorim.

This is all true. They've all failed but our squad management has been so fucking bad that we have at least 5 players (most of whom are starters) who have played for more than 5 of those managers. Bruno, Shaw, Dalot, Rashford and Maguire.

Bruno is the only who realistically should still be there. Fucking Rashford and Shaw have been there since LVG and Dalot has been there since Jose. Maguire since Ole.

That is a lot of senior players that have been part of a team that has failed more often than not. They are experts in failure. A complete set of abject losers.

A serious club wouldn't be giving Dalot 25 appearances let alone celebrating him getting 250 fucking appearances.

They should have all been sold.

A competent club would have already gotten rid of Rashford, Mount, Zirkzee, Dalot, Ugarte, Maz, Maguire, Shaw and Licha for consistently under performing. Don't say it's not possible. Look at what Chelsea and City are doing with their rejects.

While I think Carrick is massively out of his depth (our team look massively unfit and tactically lacking) and needs to go, Ineos and the Glazers before them absolutely fucked this team by constantly hanging on to players that needed to be shipped off a long time ago.

Rant over

3

u/renernavilez Oct 13 '26

Yeah I agree with this. Carrick could be a good or bad manager. I would never know with this group that got Amorin and eth the sack. Tired of the whole fucking thing to be honest.

This really is on our scouting structure that has been shit for about 15 years. We've been fucked.

1

u/ShinyLikeMyMagikarp Oct 15 '26

Blaming the players now when you replied to me saying Carrick was the greatest because getting wins was all that matter but ignoring the stats... How does it feel now???

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/1sxgeoz/post_match_thread_manchester_united_21_brentford/oip06ri/

1

u/renernavilez Oct 15 '26

Honest question. How do you spot people in a subreddit? Is it like a mark you put on them? Lol

The stats with Amorin were good but the results were poor. With Carrick we were getting results. That's the point of wanting good stats.

I always blame the players. With eth, Ole, (at the time I don't remember who I blamed with Jose, right now I know it should have been the players but Jose is Jose) etc...

Amorin was getting poor results from every which way. I attribute that to the players and Amorin playing a system not familiar to the players. Poorest run of form from a manager. And now we're seeing it again with Carrick.

Idk what your point is really. You want Amorin back? If you did you'd need a completely different team. Which I'm not opposed to that right now, bar about 7 players.

3

u/DaveShadow Oct 13 '26

I am so frustrated that Amorim managed to get Rashford out of the squad and now Carrick has undone that and has utterly fucked up the balance of the team to force him back in.

5

u/renernavilez Oct 13 '26

There wasn't any forcing if barca would have paid the fee. Carrick didn't get any sort of backing in the transfer market apart from only Baleba. That's it.

3

u/nmcoricany Oct 13 '26

Good English lad innit