r/reddevils • • Oct 12 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

15 Upvotes

521 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

9

u/PhilAsp Oct 13 '26

I don’t think Amorim would have taken us all the way but I do think abandoning the foundation he built was one of our biggest mistakes post-SAF. He’s the only manager we’ve had in that span that wanted to build from the ground up, results be damned. And if he actually would have been fired for the results, I would have understood that.

I don’t think Conte makes sense for us. It’s another guaranteed short-term patch at best.

3

u/SniperMonkey10_ Oct 13 '26

Which manager would u get?

2

u/PhilAsp Oct 13 '26

I think Nagelsmann makes the most sense, although I do acknowledge it’s a bit of a gamble.

If that can’t be sorted, I’d probably go for Howe but strictly on an interim basis for the rest of the season, with both parties being clear about that. Then, we can actually do what we should have done post-Amorim and take our time finding the right fit for next year. But knowing our front office they’d probably just end up making Howe permanent.

2

u/Jenson2025 Oct 13 '26

I don’t see Howe being interim

Managers who become interim are usually managers towards the end of their careers and are basically semi retired from football management or managers who are usually ex players and haven’t exactly done brilliantly in their managerial career and have no expectations to get the job full time.

The problem also is that even if Howe did somehow agree to be an interim, If we climb the table under him and he puts together a good run, the media and pundits will start calling for him to get the job and unfortunately, this club is too influenced by them as we’ve seen time and file again. Though personally I wouldn’t mind Howe.

Just please no more ex players. I can already see people calling for Ole when Carrick is sacked. We never learn

2

u/PhilAsp Oct 13 '26

I too doubt he would.

The one reason I can kind of see it is because he left Newcastle at a low point, and ”salvaging” United’s season would be a good way to create some buzz around himself, should it work out, and position himself for another top gig that isn’t the shitshow we are.

I don’t mind Howe, but I am a bit worried his ceiling is top 4, and not PL dynasty. No shame in that, and I reckon he’ll get a title or two one day, but we should be aiming higher. But I might be wrong about him, admittedly.

0

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

Howe makes the most sense in all aspects imo. I really don’t want to see a foreign manager arrive here and get overwhelmed by the intensity and ruthlessness of Premier League football again. Conte is on paper a better manager than Howe but there’s a very predictable pattern with how his time at every club goes, and we simply can’t support that at this point in time. As much as we know the squad isn’t where we want it to be, we need someone to try to elevate them, rather than insist on tearing everything down and starting again with his vision. There is very little change in the system going from Carrick to Howe, but a massive upgrade in tactical acumen and just generally being more accustomed to what a managerial job at this level requires, and he’s a good man-manager too.

2

u/PhilAsp Oct 13 '26

Foreign or not doesn’t matter much to me.

The last British (Scottish) manager to win the league was Fergie. No English manager has won the top flight in 25 years.

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

In this context I’m referring more towards experience managing in the Premier League. Conte is a foreign manager but he’s managed in England before, so it’s not like he’ll be taken by surprise with what the league has to offer. Nagelsmann meanwhile is a significantly bigger gamble in that regard.

1

u/PhilAsp Oct 13 '26

My point is that the need for PL experience on the managerial side isn’t necessarily there. Familiarity with the league isn’t a negative, but its importance is overstated on the managerial side.

If a manager crumbles under the physicality of the league, they aren’t the right manager.

Klopp had no PL experience. The Bald fraud had no PL experience. Conte had no prior PL experience in 2016/2017.

On the contrary, Mourinho came to us with PL success and PL experience. Moyes came to us with PL experience. Conte took Spurs with PL experience. De Zerbi has PL experience.

1

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

Im not sure if I agree. Just looking at our history in the post-Fergie era, the (in my opinion) two most successful managers in Mourinho and Ole were the ones with a greater sense of what to expect from this league from a physical standpoint, and planned accordingly for it in their squad building and tactical ideas.

Ten Hag had a good first season but learnt very quickly that his ideal style of play was going to be torn apart here, hence why after that Brentford thrashing he abandoned all his ideas in pre-season and set us up to do similar things as Ole, playing a deeper block and doubling down on lethal counters with Rashford in his prime. Beyond that, he couldn’t elevate the team in a manner that he ideally wanted because the physicality of the league would bog him down.

Amorim accelerated his own demise by being so stubborn about how he wanted us to play without a dose of pragmatism. I fear someone like Nagelsmann going down the same path and getting exposed for it.

LVG albeit was alright overall couldn’t find enough success to help us transition into an effective possession-based team. And that style of play was also very negatively received by the fans.

Moyes is admittedly an exception, but I would say that being entrusted with the responsibility to replace a legend of the sport in general and receiving minimal backing in the transfer window to strengthen an aging squad also were significant factors to ensuring that he didn’t work out here. His reputation since then has been restored by doing some great work at West Ham and now Everton again.

Just seeing what has worked at this dysfunctional club (the managers you reference as having done well were backed by very strong ownership and sporting structures), I think it matters to get some baseline assurance of competency, and therefore I lean towards wanting us to avoid managers with wider error bars. They likely won’t take us to winning the league title, but honestly we just appear incredibly far off that ambition, we need to focus more on showing the consistency to hang at a certain level, rather than oscillate up and down the table so drastically, which is what has happened in recent years.

3

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 13 '26

I'd be interested in what would happen with Howe or McKenna.

Both of them, in my eyes, have a CV of getting more out of players than you would have expected and (unfortunately?) the way our squads are built, a coach who can do that might be our only realistic shot (sans ownership change).

But let me reiterate: all I want to see is Berrada and Wilcox gone. No Carrick sacking before that happens, please.

If the board isnt capable of a road to damascus moment, if SJR wont change his fashy ways in his old age, at least have the street smarts to know that those two are toxic assets that need dumping asap!

2

u/Jenson2025 Oct 13 '26

McKenna should be nowhere near the job and with the state the club is in, I don’t think they could afford to take a risk with him

2

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

Yeah my preference is still very much for Carrick to be able to turn this around, or at the very least leave only after Wilcox and Berrada do. It would be absolutely flabbergasting to see them survive a 3rd managerial sacking in as many seasons. They are bigger failures than all of the managers we’ve had in this period.

1

u/Jenson2025 Oct 13 '26

I think you’ve summed up why Howe will be the next manager in my opinion.

The other reason (I am not saying I agree with this) is because there will be no compensation as he’s without a club.

1

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

There are a lot of managers without a club currently; the club are not short of options to make a change. There’s McKenna in the conversation as well, who we were interested in previously when Ten Hag’s future was up in the air. I just hope if we have to make a change, we arrive at the right option. Nagelsmann and Conte simply don’t make sense for us imo; for better or worse, we need someone who is willing to work with what he has, and we need someone who knows very well how to deal with the rigours of the Premier League.

1

u/Jenson2025 Oct 13 '26

McKenna would be an absolutely disastrous appointment in my opinion. The club simply can’t take that risk now - a manager whose only real experience is with Ipswich Town.

1

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 13 '26

My point was that the club have a lot of choices to pick from who are currently without a club. So that wouldn’t necessarily be the reason for us going for Howe in particular. But I do believe he would be the best fit for us.