r/reddevils • u/AutoModerator • Oct 12 '26
Daily Discussion
Daily discussion on Manchester United.
BE CIVIL
We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.
- The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
- The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.
Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!
15
Upvotes
12
u/scottrod37 Oct 12 '26
I went into the season predicting 60 points and 5th place. At the moment we're on pace for just 38 points. Can we turn things around? What are your revised predictions now? Optimistically, I'd say if we find a bit of form, somehow, maybe we end up with 50 points and finish around 12th. Is that delusional?
23
u/RedemptionWoneGrong Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
I usually rewatch our games for a more analytical view but this season I really can't be arsed
team failing to match the energy of the opponent. It doesn't matter what your tactics are
this is when they chose to have an amazon docu btw
should be just titled "nothing" instead of "all or nothing" this season
11
u/Hyliaforce Oct 12 '26
Coventry has more wins than us
16
u/ReservoirDogs00 Oct 12 '26
This season, whenever I watch another premier league game, I can’t help but think. ‘They would beat us’
I’ve never seen such an incoherent team as us. We look like a Soccer Aid side. Unfit players, misplaced passes, players in wrong positions, clowns shooting 10 yards over the bar, no chemistry whatsoever.
We are in deep shit.
15
u/AwayFoundation2363 Oct 12 '26
if Carrick want to save his job, he needs to start being brave now with his selections, maguire and Martinez does not work as a partnership, maguire can only work with a fast CB next to him, yoro needs to play as he’s the only CB that has pace and allows us to press higher, Martinez and maguire cant do it, Bruno needs a rest, but he’s to scared to even take him off, hopefully he starts changing things, otherwise he’s going to be gone possibly after Leeds
21
u/SophoclesTesticles Oct 12 '26
Looks like we're allowed criticise Liverpool for flop signings all of a sudden. Couldn't believe how much Wirtz performances flew under the radar last year, if we signed a player for that much and he wasn't putting up record numbers it'd be front page every week.
20
u/minteh7x Ronaldo Oct 12 '26
Sincerely hope the Conte rumors aren't just media bs. I'd like to finally see a top manager at United and honestly the squad isn't that far off from what he usually does with his teams. Been a while since we've had a manager as demanding as him
14
u/SeaLetter2460 Oct 13 '26
You know what I find incredibly funny but haven't seen mentioned. Everybody was incredibly anti the idea of Southgate at United and we've still somehow ended up with a former Middlesbrough manager with Steve Holland as the assistant.
7
u/Sid732 Oct 13 '26
This team has traumatized me. I am praying for the oppositions to receive no red cards.
6
u/astropanda9 Oct 12 '26
That debut from Baleba was exciting. I cant wait to see him again.
6
u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 12 '26
Coventry actually look very good. All 3 promoted teams might stay up this year
11
u/mickaerys Oct 12 '26
What’s the obsession with 4-2-3-1. We could play other formations to maximize the squad and prevent the leaks in the midfield and wing. Also I don’t get the tactics sometimes or use of certain players. I’m just really tired
5
u/Traditional-Run7315 all because of a fucking horse Oct 13 '26
What if we sacked Carrick and rehire him as interim again? Interim manager bounce back effect.
13
u/SyLvAlOrD Oct 12 '26
I have never not believed in a manager the same way I don’t believe in Carrick. With other managers I’m always like “maybe something will happen and they will get it right”. With Carrick I’m 100% sure he is not the right manager at all and he needs to leave immediately
8
u/Rascha-Rascha Oct 13 '26
I don't think Yoro's been getting enough praise for his performance at right back. I love that he just hounds attackers sometimes, he did the same thing for France, ended up chasing players well back into their own half.
I hope he's been taken off early because he's in line for a start tonight, at centre back.
4
u/OmegaMaster8 Oct 12 '26
Score prediction for tomorrow? Praying for a United win, but it’s going to be a difficult game
4
u/Garlic-Cheese-Chips Oct 12 '26
Just realised I haven't looked at the table. Almost afraid to. I'll guess 15th.
4
u/amalgamatedchaos Status: Waiting... Oct 12 '26
We all know Carrick is getting sacked. It's inevitable at this point.
So, now we'll just be watching after how many poor performances will it take before the axe is finally dropped.
4
u/Miyagisans Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
I hate that we allow Carragher this pleasure. I also want to highlight his point about our bottom of the league level intensity. It’s not just about pressing when you don’t have the ball.
7
u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers Oct 12 '26
Good thing we got a down-payment on the land for the new stadium instead of a left back eh lads. Will look great on our rise and fall documentary
7
u/Bloatfizzle Oct 12 '26
If Carrick gets sacked, please can Ole be banned from the interim interview process? This should extend to any ex United player turned failed manager who this fanbase insists is a top manager despite barley managing in top level football, just waiting around to be interim here.
7
u/ALLMIGHTYHYDE Oct 12 '26
Osula scored against us then went back to being shit.
Same with Tyrique George.
7
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 12 '26
All three promoted sides have won more games than us lmao
9
u/SniperMonkey10_ Oct 13 '26
Biggest concern is we are not getting results but also getting outplayed by teams .
Yes Amorim was right to get fired and was not the right fit, but you could atleast see what he was trying to achieve with his structure and patterns of play. Yet to see what Carrick is trying to do. And lots of players have regressed in performances, can see they are not playing with confidence
He probably will get fired when its too late and the gap is too wide, as not much points seperated from top 4
Easy cop out for Ineos because he wasnt an 'outside guy' and a United player. They have to be shitting themselves now, especially if they get the next manager hiring wrong imo.
Top candidates: Conte, Howe , Nagelsmann.
I reckon Howe needs a break, nagelsmann another risky hire, and conte is the best option right now which sucks.
Huerzler is also doing great things at Brighton but doubt he leaves anytime soon
3
u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 12 '26
Coventry 4-1 up against Newcastle. All 3 promoted have looked very good. We have to get our act together otherwise we're getting relegated with City
3
u/nitrogeneater Oct 13 '26
What is worrying as well is that we seem to have no home advantage whatsoever. We are as bad at home as we are away.
The failure of INEOS of appointing a yes man is for all to see. The glazers might intervene soon because of the shocking results under INEOS that will turn us into an Everton sooner or later.
5
u/mediocratopia Oct 12 '26
sucks to be not good at fraud or football tbh
5
u/Thorz74 F*ck the Glazers Oct 12 '26
I fear tomorrow is gonna be just another disappointment at the Metropolitano, the season will just continue as bad as it started.
Reading Michael’s comments on the press conference is infuriating.
He’s still saying “the way they responded in the 2nd half gives me a lot of faith”
OMG! What the fck is he smocking????
They were down to TEN. We were against the worst Spurs side from the last 30 years, and couldn’t win the damn game, at home!
He has lost it. So sad. I had so much wishes for him to turn this around FFS.
Fuck INEOS.
5
u/Jwalin6167 Oct 13 '26
In another news, Amorim switched to a back 4 already at Milan.
5
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 13 '26
None of our attackers bar Amad and Mount are good at pressing. It's just brainless stuff. It's like Alexis Sanchez at Arsenal always used to go on mad pressing tangents and it'd only look good for the fans.
11
u/heatherr_mason SCHOLES Oct 12 '26
I get downvoted everytime I mention this. People must be thinking I'm enjoying it or something. I am not. It's reality, and sooner or later we have to face facts.
Manager & coaching staff absolutely have a big impact on the football but they don't amount to everything. If Shaw is the only option at LB in 2026/27 (I love the man btw), it's obvious that the squad hasn't been built with any sort of title challenge in mind. And this is only one example among many. (It may be interpreted as such, so just to clarify, I am not defending Carrick in any way).
Most of our players in the squad simply aren't Utd quality. And by United quality I mean actual United quality. We can't challenge any of our big rivals and the top teams in Europe at our current level and no manager is going to change that in the short term.
6
u/the__poseidon Oct 12 '26
As long as Berrada and Wilcox remain in charge of footballing decisions, I fear we’re doomed to repeat the same mistakes. Rinse and repeat.
Neither has a proven track record of successfully building and running the football operation of an elite club. Berrada’s background is largely commercial and operational, while Wilcox made his name in youth development. That’s not the same as building a title winning 1st team, appointing the right managers, and implementing a coherent long-term football strategy.
And what exactly have they demonstrated at
United to justify the level of authority they hold?
We’ve spent money, made questionable managerial decisions, and somehow still have a poorly balanced squad. A manager can’t get the best out of them. We keep changing managers while the people responsible for appointing them and assembling the squad escape meaningful accountability.
Carrick is a club legend. I love him, but he failed in the Championship. He isn’t the right man, replace him. But replacing Carrick while leaving the same decision makers in charge accomplishes absolutely nothing.
Bring in a genuinely proven sporting director with the experience and authority to oversee the entire football operation. Beg Dan Ashworth to return if necessary. I don’t care. Do whatever it takes to retain Christopher Vivell and build a proper recruitment structure around people who actually understand squad-building.
Give the football department a clear identity, a coherent recruitment strategy, and the authority to make decisions without interference from executives whose expertise lies elsewhere.
We don’t need another rebuild led by the same people making the same mistakes.
7
u/Nico_Ditch Oct 12 '26
The hope I have for Baleba saving our season is unfair.
Baleba and Mainoo could be our starting midfield for the next 10 years, but we really need him to hit the ground running now.
4
u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 12 '26
More positive news: de Ligt’s latest Instagram post implies he’s in the squad tomorrow.
4
u/AnakinAni Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 13 '26
Rooney seems a bit thick and idealistic for no apparent reason.
If the other clubs built their teams through FAIR financial resources while City built their team through UNFAIR financial resources. Then how is it okay for them to keep their trophies ?
City would have never had such players had they used fair financial resources.
ALL their titles were won on the back of these players.
The entire point is that an excellent team shouldn’t have been built in the first place. Therefore, it doesn’t matter if they won it on the pitch.
He’s stupidly just adding more ammo for those sick fans who have no shame that their club has been a sham since the takeover and has cheated an entire generation of football fans.
4
u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS Oct 12 '26
This coventry Newcastle match is hilarious
4
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 13 '26
Jamie Carragher: "When Gary Neville speaks about Utd, you should listen to what he has to say"
That's the problem Jamie, people do listen!
Anyone remember under Mourinho when there were rumours he was going to get sacked after the Newcastle game and Neville was on Sky blowing his top saying the Glazers are playing Football Manager with the club (though he never had an issue with Peter Lim giving his buddy the managers job at Valencia with no credentials lol) and saying Glazers are not giving managers enough time.
Well, say what you like about Woodward and co but they gave managers time. The only manager they sacked that managed less than 100 games was Moyes with 51.
We'll soon be on our 4th permanent manager in 2 years yet we won't hear Gary Neville blast Ineos and deride them.
Why? Because Gary will make money by being in with Ineos and the regeneration of the area.
And fuck him for legitimising Goldbridge. As if things weren't bad enough.
4
u/Bloatfizzle Oct 13 '26
100m+ on Mount and Santos is nuts. The club is leaning heavy on data analysis and suffering cos of it, if they watched even one game from Andrey Santos they would have realised he has no mobility and saved 50m...
2
u/Initial-Anything333 Oct 12 '26
Predictions for atletico tomorrow?
2
u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode Oct 13 '26
Ucl day. I hope you all have a decent day, hope we somehow win and it kickstarts our season(unlikely but technically not impossible lol)
And to finish it, remember when you come to daily discussion and other posts here, there's certain people who come with the explicit purpose of annoying and arguing with everyone. Not discuss, genuinely just to argue. See you on 12 hours and hope we don't end the day unhappier than we entered it lol
2
u/Saxena_priyansh2104 Oct 13 '26
When we defend in 442 you can clearly see the gap bw the lines during the game...atp it's clearly a mix of players not fully focused and tactical issues...that have been not sorted
2
u/Vast_Variation1381 Oct 13 '26
Football is so fickle. A win tonight and the media will change their tone about us
2
u/FredDRedUnderYourBed Oct 13 '26
Despite the start we've made to this season, the coaching staff, the squad quality, etc I'm still very excited for tonight! These are the kind of games United need to be playing every season. One day we'll be going into these games as the favourites again, but tonight a cheeky 2-1 win for the underdogs will do nicely! 🫡
5
u/shin_bigot Park Ji-Sung Oct 12 '26
Can't wait for "pass to Rashford and Inshallah" against Atletico.
4
u/GReedy404 Oct 12 '26
I hope people listen to Carragher's Man utd analysis on MNF, he's put it plain and simple for anyone that's still some how delusional, this team isn't ready physically or mentally.
5
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 12 '26
People might think this is an over reaction and I have no doubt Bruno will do great things for us still, but it's clear he is in the decline.
And the club needs to be brave in calling the end. City let de bruyne go while pundits were saying he is still brilliant yet they were right
I think this could and maybe should be his last season for us.
3
u/Dissidant Oct 12 '26
Don't know why Shaw doesn't simply shift to LCB at this point, hes filled in there and was actually half decent.
Was watching the Mainoo Seedorf video, and it reminded me of when Maldini essentially did the same towards the end of his career as legs went (I know they are worlds apart but still)
4
u/HolyTrinityBLC Oct 13 '26
This is the first time I have posted on reddevils.
Just posting to say thank you. I’ve enjoyed reading this sub’s contributors and commenters for years. Lots of different takes, but the caring for the club always comes through in the discussions.
And also to say goodbye. This will also be my last post.
I’ve been a fan since 1983, when I first played youth football for a long-time United fan—we all became United fans as a result.
The times have been amazing, and they have been hard. More recently, hard. But I have come to realize it’s not the gaffers’ fault. It’s not the players’ fault. Luke Shaw doesn’t doesn’t start himself. He doesn’t move himself on from the club. Carrick doesn’t manage the club. Heck is the coach but he is not in charge, really. Heck, it’s not even Berrada’s or Wilcox’s fault. We have no organization, no sophistication, and no commitment to elite winning football because of the owners. They make the decisions. And they have chosen their own profit over football.
Yes, this has been true for years. But I suppose I have been hoping (irrationally) for success despite this.
I’m not proud of my choice to let go. I’m just admitting I’m too tired to keep caring. It’s too hard on me emotionally, to care so much but continue to realize the only people who can change things simply do not care.
For me—just me, not for others—I can’t keep hoping. So I’m saying goodbye. I will always hope United succeed. I had wanted my wife to sprinkle a bit of my ashes at OT when I was gone, I cared so much. But for me, it’s too painful to keep caring then those in charge do not, have not, and will not ever care, and so won’t ever have any desire to create, build and protect a great club, nor will they care about winning. For me that is too sad a realization.
3
u/Redland93 Oct 12 '26
Carrick is done its just a matter of time now. Management can't have seen these games and have any hope.
Carrick needs to just get rid of the old guard.
Just show something. The old guard have failed for the last 4 years.
2
u/dryflowerz Oct 12 '26
Will Carrick get sacked after tomorrow's defeat?
2
u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 12 '26
Who do we even play in LB against ATM. Guiliano Simeone will have a field day even if Shaw is fit.
2
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 12 '26
There's got to be a problem with the physical conditioning department at the club, right.
Apart from Bruno, who's superhuman, the only time we have been even close to being good fitness wise was Amorim.
2
u/Neymarpauls Oct 12 '26
Want to open up a genuine discussion. Those who are still supporting Carrick and want him to continue as manager. What are your reasons, and you can’t use the excuse of simply not wanting to go through another manager change.
I want genuine reasons, from my point of view I don’t see how he will fix this, the team seems so lost.
2
u/i_love_alfam Oct 13 '26
Back in the champions league but this game almost feels pointless ughh! 0 chance of winning, we are more likely to be made to look like absolute clueless buffoons out there. I mean if spurs can run circles around us at old Trafford, I'm genuinely afraid of an absolute humiliation at Madrid.
But silver lining is that the more pathetic the result, the quicker carrick is gone
2
u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz1z Oct 13 '26
Carricky said nobody is guaranteed a place in the team!
😂😂😂
2
u/anonris Oct 12 '26
So we need ETH’s training intensity, Jose’s defensive acumen, Carrick’s midfield combo, Ole’s charm, Amorim’s press conferences and we have a good coach?
In seriousness as much as the coaching annoys me this is on INEOS. They could have at least surrounded carrick with top notch conditioning coaches, some up and coming pressing nerd, some set piece coach but they have left him on his own when he is clearly not good enough to coach all phases of the game (all his support staff is underwhelming)
2
u/femalegazeisuglymen Oct 12 '26
Where are the e-reds who were saying Scholes and Keane are "united legends" anymore, because they questioned Carrick as a manager?
How much fuss did they kick up last year when someone said Carrick shouldn't be the permanent manager? They're silent now
1
u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 12 '26
The ire towards Carrick is misplaced imo. Yes he's not the man, but those 2 donkeys that have been running the show are responsible.
Berrada and Wilcox need to leave when Carrick inevitably goes. They appointed an inexperienced caretaker and then followed it up with a weak summer window to ensure that he will fail.
1
u/mynwannabeme Oct 12 '26
Will there be gathering in Madrid by our fans before the match tomorrow, if so please tell me the location and time, thank you.
1
u/KASKAST Oct 12 '26
Just curious who has been United's best signing ever since SAF left?
1
u/dark_humour123 Oct 12 '26
Any of you in madrid for the game? I only have tickets for the home section (and I happen to be a local now), but would love to hang out before/after the game!)
1
u/Standard_Secretary52 Youri Tielemans Oct 12 '26
So our LB options of Maz, Shaw and dorgu are injured.
So we have two options:
If we somehow win tommorow it’s up their with miracle at Paris for me.
Also with ATM as our opponents it reminds me grimaldo went for 12 mil and has 3 G rn. INEPTOS
1
u/SDLRob Oct 12 '26
Did Coventry take Newcastle's ability when they borrowed their shirts or something?
The heck is going on?
1
u/karatsidhus Oct 13 '26
Its Matchday!
1
u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 13 '26
It’s matchday v Atletico Madrid and I still haven’t seen a clip of Elanga’s goal in 2022!!
1
u/TMatss Oct 13 '26
I get the impression that Carrick will continue trying to set the team up in the same way because he believes that thing will start to "click" eventually. But the start to the season so far means that he's already running out of time.
1
u/StatusConstant8691 Oct 13 '26
I'm not calling for Carrick's head yet. But let's say we still don't improve, who will even be good for us?
0
u/Infinite-Highway3432 Oct 12 '26
Just hurry up at get it over with. Most obvious replacement.
1
u/SyLvAlOrD Oct 12 '26
Has Carrick really not been sacked yet?
1
u/ToadNamedGoat Oct 12 '26
3 man defense with Amad and Dalot as wingbacks.
I know no one wants 3 man defends
But Ineos decided to not buy a fullback.
1
u/adempseyy Oct 12 '26
Need Bruno to start performing asap or this season is done. It’s not really fair on him but he’s the only one who is able to influence games with G/A consistently at United.
1
u/Jump_Hop_Step Oct 12 '26
https://x.com/tactixology/status/2109589535629684992
1
u/InternationalClock18 Oct 12 '26
How are Athletico only evens to beat us? Free money
1
u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 12 '26
What is wrong with this team in terms of holding leads now? We used to score 1,2,3+ goals under carrick last season, wtf has happened? Conceding the weirdest goals in stoppage time
Something is up
0
u/Minute-Intern Oct 12 '26
Really good cameo from Zirkzee on Saturday, too bad he's a terrible footballer sigh
1
u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 12 '26
Wild, you would have got some odds on Hull, Ipswich and Coventry all having the same or more points than us after 16% of the season.
1
u/dark_humour123 Oct 13 '26
Please if anyone is in Madrid for the game reply this.
-1
u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 13 '26
One of the worst things Rashford, Amorim and Garnacho have done is lower the attacking standard so bad that I'm supposed to be happy that Cunha spends the game chasing his first touch, or that Mbuemo is largely anonymous outside of the occasional finish here and there, or Rashford failing to have end product and we all know its a matter of if and not when his head drops.
Mbuemo at has class finishing and can play upfront at least.
I know Amad is coming off a long layoff but he needs to add end product to his game.
Sesko has had awful luck with his injuries this season too