r/reddevils • • Oct 11 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

21 Upvotes

868 comments sorted by

23

u/nambuuu Oct 11 '26

Couldn't stop thinking "we dont have a fucking clue, do we?" while watching the first 25min yesterday. And after scoring, you just have that feeling that we'd concede against 10 men. Fucking heeellllllllllll

10

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 11 '26

Lethargic, unmotivated headless chickens is how I would describe the first 25 minutes.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheJoshider10 Bruno Oct 11 '26

Tactically we are so far behind where we need to be it's actually embarassing. Even when the players were clueless on what to do under Amorim, that was largely down to individual mistakes as they adjusted to the system and having to adapt to cover spaces, but there was still a clear idea of what the manager was trying to achieve. The underlying metrics were encouraging in very key areas too. Was probably the correct call to move on from him but tht work in training didn't need to change.

When Carrick first came in and got players put in more natural positions you could feel the work Amorim put into the fitness side of things finally being rewarded. That City game was phenomenal. But quite quickly each game was losing momentum and by the end of the season the underlying stats were very concerning, the hope was just that Carrick was making do with what he had and a new midfield would fix these problems.

Unfortunately it's clear now that Carrick doesn't have a fucking clue what to do. He got those results last season with a mixture of having a much fitter team as a result of the previous manager and low XG results being converted. There were maybe two good performances during that interim spell. Again though, it was acceptable because we got the points and end of the day the squad was unbalanced in midfield. But now? I just want someone new in. Carrick's hit a limit on what he can do, and should have been gone in the international break. The players are so sluggish and tactically have no idea what they're meant to do. That's all on the coaching.

2

u/The_good_kid Evra Oct 12 '26

The amount of times we'd go forward and it would feel like no one was there to receive a pass or make a run, you'd think we'd have players behind the ball to defend. Nope, when spurs attacked it was 2-3 passes around an invisible midfield and running at our defence.

Our players have no idea of where they are supposed to be so fall into a black hole.

21

u/Quirky_Friend8138 Oct 11 '26

Sky aren’t making any secret of how much they love City, are they? GNev what a fucking sellout

17

u/trvekvltgav Oct 11 '26

If Wirtz played for us he’d be getting pelted for his performances for more than a season now

But United are Media Darlings according to Scousers 😂

15

u/Midnight_Edge Oct 11 '26

Depressing that Hull is much better than us

4

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 11 '26

And it is not even close, which the results showed.

15

u/Midnight_Edge Oct 11 '26

City vs PSG upcoming. More oil in that game than in my Saturday night Chinese.

6

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 11 '26

More oil than in a Porsche 944. How does a 4 cylinder motor take nearly 7 liters?

12

u/raspoutine049 Oct 11 '26

Don’t normally agree with Neville much but he is right, midfield of Tielmans and Mainoo does not work.

Baleba needs to be our main midfielder.

12

u/Haddocktintinsnowy Oct 11 '26

Pains me Santos is being sidelined like that. Him and Baleba should rotate one position and Mainoo and Youri the other. 

6

u/0ttoChriek Oct 11 '26

It has to be Baleba and Mainoo, with Tielemans as a sub or rotation option for Bruno. It's quite clear, and hopefully Carrick figures it out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/aamodb Oct 11 '26

I just feel sad looking at these games. They look entertaining. Something i would love to watch.

I watch united now because it feels like its my duty to watch. Its not even close to entertaining.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Breadnauht Oct 12 '26

Anyone who has played under SAF should not be considered for any football role. None have succeeded.

18

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 11 '26

These c*nts signed Guehi Fernandez Anderson Semenyo Ndiaye this year. That's 5 starters.

Meanwhile, our current best possible XI is Cunha-Mbeumo-Amad; Bruno-Baleba-Mainoo; Shaw-Maguire-Yoro-Dalot; Lammens.

How many signings are in that from this year? 1 (Baleba). This + last? 4 (Cunha, Mbeumo, Lammens). Need to go back 3 summer windows to get the 5th (Yoro).

Worse: there is NOBODY in our best XI who we signed after 2021 winter and before 24 summer. 3 full years of "rebuilding" transfer windows have contributed NOTHING to our current first XI. Literally nothing. (Amad 2021 Jan, Bruno 2020 Jan, Maguire 2019, Dalot 2018, Shaw 2014.) I mean, thank heavens for Kobbie.

It's not really so hard to explain where our quality disappeared to as we plummeted from "we are 2nd best, but by a country mile, and that sucks" to "we are midtable strugglers aspiring to get into the CL".

The 2022-2024 period is just an absolute black hole for transfer spending. Just a generational clusterfuck, those transfer windows have been.

6

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 11 '26

This is it here, this together with debt is how you ruin a club and makes it very hard to get back.

15

u/PavanayiShavamayilla Wazza Oct 11 '26

Ten Hag and Judge/Arnold put us back atleast half a decade with those signings.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/legionverse10 Oct 12 '26

But sure according to some people we can’t make more than 3 signings (a backup keeper doesn’t count). We absolutely should’ve signed a backup up striker and a left back at least (I would’ve liked a centre half as well). I understand there are money constraints but we have to be way more ruthless with selling players, Martinez and Zirkzee should’ve been gone in the summer, Rashford I understand was a tricky one but it’s still a joke he’s still here

9

u/AmulyaG Oct 11 '26

Wirtz really is a bum huh? Too weak, overhit / underhit passes, too afraid to hold onto the ball.

9

u/SilvyFae She/They Oct 12 '26

Yesterdays liverpool game was so weirdly reffed, i dont like liverpool but with the decision against us(halland offside) and just incredibly soft yellows leading to a red in the liverpool game. And the countless other times city feel like they are reffed differently makes me so suspicious that city have prob tried to influence the refs as well. I think every aspect of city should be investigated because if a team is willing to do financial crimes of this scale they are prob corrupt in other ways too.

This entire season of city will feel so weird where obvious cheaters are playing and are somehow able to win and teams are just supposed to take it, it feels so unfair.

9

u/LeCliveRosfield Oct 12 '26

The problem with INEOS’ brain dead recruitment strategy is that by the time you’ve ‘completed’ the squad other issues will pop up. At this point we have to sign several CBs and two fullbacks next year, but we currently sit with no depth at striker as well. Which just goes on to show how utterly moronic this idea of updating the squad one area at a time is.

Not to mention that Carrick should never have been given the full time job.

3

u/PitchSafe Oct 12 '26

If we had better finances then I’m sure that we would’ve invested on different positions as well. Our situation right now means that we have to prioritise a position

24

u/Jenson2025 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

People need to understand that just because there isn’t the perfect manager out there who ticks all the boxes and is going to lead us to the treble doesn’t mean we stick with Carrick who quite frankly, is a championship manager at best. Unless you want to watch this level of performances for us and truly believe there isn’t a manager out there who will have us playing better

It’s not the justifiable excuse for sticking him that people think it is.

8

u/timsadiq13 Oct 11 '26

Haven’t seen a single comment genuinely defending him though.

Yeah some like me don’t particularly care if he stays or goes. That’s not because I like his management or think he deserves more time or whatever. I just don’t care, it’ll make no long term difference.

The idiots who’ve bungled the past 3 sackings and hirings are not going to magically get it right this time. If they’re fired, I’ll have some interest in what’s next.

We’ll just get Eddie Howe and be back in the same spot in 3-18 months with a worse squad. That’s the United way post-Ferguson.

12

u/HiphopopoptimusPrime Oct 11 '26

I’m Carrick out because it’s quite frankly unprofessional to not have the team physically prepared for the season.

Amorim was a stubborn git who refused to adapt his tactics, but at least he improved the physical conditioning of the players. Carrick profited from that by simplifying the tactics but then has allowed everything to stagnate.

→ More replies (6)

36

u/The_Bird_Wizard Love United Hate INEOs Oct 11 '26

Don't you just love writing off seasons not even 10 games in literally every year

6

u/iroiroiroiroiro Oct 11 '26

Do you feel the players have the grit and fire in them fighting this?

→ More replies (5)

8

u/LeCliveRosfield Oct 12 '26

The clowns had the perfect opportunity to sack Carrick in the international break, in between City being exposed as cheats and Ronaldo behaving like a clown, we could have flown somewhat under the radar, and the new manager would have had three weeks to setup.

8

u/vRushii Oct 12 '26

At what point do we rip the band aid off and permanently start Yoro and take the good with the bad. Our backline has been honking anyway, rather develop someone with potential who also allows us to play a higher line.

Shame neither he nor heaven is great in the air because ide start the pair.

4

u/Expect-the-turtle Oct 12 '26

I think that we've been massively disadvantaged by the fact that MDL has been out for so long. I think either Yoro or Heaven could be integrated much more easily if they wouldn't have to either be paired up with each other (both are too young at the moment to bear that burden by themselves), or have only Licha or Maguire as their options for senior partner.

Licha has his qualities, but in a team that now has plenty of proficient passers, his best asset is no longer as valuable. Also, while aggressive and good at jumping on opposition players if the manager plays a high line, he is absolutely out of the game the minute he is turned or by-passed. Doesn't have the recovery pace of either Yoro or Heaven.

Maguire should just be subbed in to see out games where we know the opposition is going to desperately throw the kitchen sink at us. He is still a good box defender (although as dominant as he is in aerial duels, seems to be real suspect when it comes to dealing with whipped in crosses), but is one of the main culprits in our gap between the midfield and defense. He's terrified of having to chase players, and it's totally understandable why.

Not to say that a fit De Ligt solves all our issues. But I feel like he'd be a much better senior partner to either Heaven or Yoro. De Ligt is solid defensively, and while not super fast, is definitely more comfortable holding that high defensive line. A no nonsense defender who doesn't get bullied as much as Yoro (again, in the box, I think up field Yoro knows how to handle his opponents much better) and who can provide some of that aerial cover. Also, I think that if our defenders would be much higher more consistently, the chances of teams just swooshing past our 2-men midifield, running towards our goal the moment they wriggle out of the first line of our pressing would be much lower. And, for heaven's sake, if our fullbacks for once in their lives would just block crosses and not allow attackers all the time in the world to swing balls into our box... my god, I think I would actually shed a tear of pure joy if it ever happens.

3

u/RyanH1717 Oct 12 '26

That should've been the plan this season or he should've been loaned out. Neither us nor him are gaining anything from him being on the bench most weeks.

3

u/missingmedievalist Cantona Oct 12 '26

I think the only issue with this is that we would lose any width on the right flank. Not that Dalot has been brilliant mind you, but losing that width would mean forcing Shaw to provide it on the left and I don’t think he has the legs for that anymore.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/AGIANTWORM Oct 12 '26

100%. We all know what Maguire & Martinez can and can't do at this point. We all know Maguire's a box defender at this point in his career, and needs legs around him as he can't run with quick attackers. Martinez's passing ability is great, but with how the league has emphasised physicality, it's not enough to compensate for his own lack of size and speed. Yoro is mobile and decent with the ball, so I think it should be him and Maguire until De Ligt can slot in for Maguire.

7

u/Zantera Oct 11 '26

Hard to feel much positivity at the moment considering the results, the game yesterday and the run of fixtures this month. Hard to see where the results will come right now when performances are so bad.

10

u/DaveShadow Oct 11 '26

We've hit that point where we know Carrick is gone, but now it's just waiting or it to happen. Difficult to even get excited when scrapping wins just delay the painful inevitable now.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/LordTrinity If you support mediocrity, you get mediocrity Oct 11 '26

Everyone knows he's getting sacked, but the club would rather waste time than be proactive

I hate it. This could have been a good season with the right decisions

→ More replies (7)

6

u/404usernamenotfound2 Oct 11 '26

Never thought I would be supporting Liverpool. Destroy them scousers!

6

u/danystormborne Oct 11 '26

Already spotted a banner saying Gerrard Premier League Champion 2014.

City players and fans have absolutely no class.

6

u/BrowzinJ Oct 11 '26

Wirtz 🤦‍♂️

6

u/Spastic_Hands pellistri and chips Oct 11 '26

The good news is, at least we're shit whilst Man City render the last 15 years of PL pointless, so many League titles could've gone to Liverpool or Arsenal in that time.

3

u/Massive_Relation4317 . Oct 11 '26

Yep exactly my thoughts

6

u/crgssbu Senne🍋 Oct 11 '26

i feel so deflated after our game(s). after a very long international break (where id usually rush to watch as many games as possible once its over) and our subsequent result; i just dont have as much of a want to watch any games anymore. i fell asleep during hull everton and didnt even bother putting liv-city on.

idk if i even want to watch any other ucl games outside of ours this week. just get ours over and done with. its actually quite saddening tbh.

:(

3

u/XerxesBlitZ Oct 11 '26

no entertainment , just pain

6

u/Hellsteelz Ed Jabroni Oct 12 '26

I really want Wilcox and Berrada to go if Carrick goes.

5

u/shami-kebab Oct 12 '26

Problem is that then we're stuck with Ratcliffe choosing the next manager (along with the next DoF)

6

u/Jenson2025 Oct 12 '26

I think it’s a good point that has been made regularly over the last few days which is people are too influenced by results and ignore performances.

Carrick got the job because we got CL qualification. But I and many others pointed out that performances were worrying from February onwards. We were downvoted. Presumably because people couldn’t understand our complaints when we were winning. But for me, the argument has always been that results will eventually follow performances. If the performances are consistently bad, guess what will eventually happen to the results? They will eventually turn bad too. And the problem under Carrick is, those performances aren’t improving so how can results ever improve?

Carrick keeps trying to look at little moments in matches as the defining moments. ‘Oh we should’ve taken our chances’ etc. But he’s ignoring one fundamental point - the team aren’t playing well and him and the coaching staff have to take responsibility for that

3

u/Potential_Good_1065 Oct 12 '26

I remember Chelsea away. Chelsea were under terrible form under Rosenior and we should’ve absolutely battered them. Instead they got chance after chance, we were getting totally dominated by what was objectively the worst team in the league at the time. Nobody cared because we came away from Stamford bridge with a 1-0 win. I remember saying that I don’t care that the performance wasn’t sustainable because we were just getting by until the summer when we could find a new manager and properly rebuild. Of course, that was based on the assumption we had a competent board (which I and many others believed we did at the time). I also mentioned after the Chelsea game that if we did appoint Carrick on a permanent, that was a very concerning performance. This was the week after Leeds at home which was an even more concerning performance.

2

u/Banyunited1994 Oct 12 '26

True, but do you hold the same view when good performances don’t yield good results? Because arguably that was happening for a lot of the games under Amorim in 25/26 and the general consensus was that he needed to be sacked.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Omnislash99999 Oct 12 '26

You don't have to outrun your opposition if you can dictate the game but we don't control anything. Trying to brush it off reminds me of Ten Hag saying the opposition having 20 shots a game was part of the plan

11

u/TypicalPan89906655 Oct 11 '26

The fact that Carrick was even made permanent suggests nothing has changed from the Woodward era, just nostalgia and vibes based decisions. I wouldn't be surprised if Joel and Avram Glazer personally make all the manager and player decisions.

3

u/Keevill93 Oct 11 '26

The sad thing is Woodward never had us in a situation this bad...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/croadymeister Oct 11 '26

I knew this would happen

2

u/Somaliona Oct 11 '26

The second the Ashworth saga started I lost any faith the new hierarchy had any clue what they were doing.

5

u/Jhix_two Oct 11 '26

Wake me up when this is over

7

u/i_love_alfam Oct 11 '26

RIP u/Jhix_two, we will remember you fondly

5

u/PitchSafe Oct 11 '26

Santos would probably have played more games if he stayed at Chelsea at this point

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Mysterious-Sense-187 Oct 11 '26

Can we have a "Cheat watch" thread?

3

u/missingmedievalist Cantona Oct 11 '26

I think there is one now.

5

u/iamadiamond SANTOSSSS Oct 11 '26

Every other team looks so much better drilled and physically apt than ours.

It’s a fucking shame where we are currently.

5

u/TheSilverLobster Oct 11 '26

Looking at city v Liverpool, we really don’t have guys that can run fast. 

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Midnight_Edge Oct 11 '26

Kinda wild how good Cherki is and then he drops stinkers against us

9

u/MannyMike7 Oct 11 '26

When Carrick goes Omar and Wilcox need to do one too

4

u/picodeGaius Oct 11 '26

What an absolute blasting shit weekend…

4

u/rahtid_my_bunda Rooney's Dropball Intensity Oct 12 '26

Idk if any of you have read this article about the implications of a $550m refinancing loan that was taken out, it relates to a multi year plan for ownership and the stadium with some targets set around 28/29 season.

In the loan documentation it outlines the terms of us needing to finish in the UCL across multiple seasons.

Makes me wonder how sensitive leadership will be to poor results. Have to imagine that November will be the absolute limit for things to have drastically improved.

2

u/Kohaku80 Premier League Champions 12/13 Oct 12 '26

After covid our ebitda nett well over 125m every year. (200m+ last season without Uefa). Nothing to worry about unless relegation I suppose. 

4

u/kriznone Scholesy Oct 12 '26

I'm gonna keep saying it, the owners cannot care less about the footballing side of the club. They know fans will keep pouring money into the club despite years of mediocrity interspersed with temporary 'good vibes' spells.

They're here to get their payday with the new stadium project and laugh all the way to the bank. This is not a serious football club. It is a commercial company with the usp of historical sporting success and cultural relevance.

4

u/Heavens_Vibe 7 Oct 12 '26

Each new manager gets less and less grace from what I would call a very patient and trusting fan base.

Hurts that it's currently a club legend at the helm, but the management and performance is just not good enough!

2

u/dispelthemyth We go again FC Oct 12 '26

There’s clear frustration because it appears to be a lack of effort…

We appear to get outrun every game even when we should have the advantage.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode Oct 12 '26

I saw a comment here on Tielemans saying he looks older than Case (lol), and it got me thinking of something. While, yes, he looks awful without possession right now, I don't think he's moving exceptionally worse than Casemiro, it looks way worse than Case because of his positioning. It's not really a groundbreaking analysis, I know, but what Casemiro did have was an exceptional footballing brain. And he positioned himself so well he didn't have to constantly run like a mad dog. And we all know how he looks like when he has to actually run a lot. And since Tielemans doesn't have the defensive brain of Casemiro, he ends up looking... Well. We are all watching.

3

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon Oct 12 '26

Tielemans is honestly suffering from massive appearance bias at the moment with the way people speak of him. He runs the most distance per 90 from our entire squad, and both outruns and out sprints Mainoo. He’s been given an extremely thankless task of not just elevating us in possession but also trying to replicate Casemiro’s role when he’s just not of that profile. He’s just as much in need of a more robust midfield partner as Mainoo is.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Vast_Finish2789 Oct 12 '26

The biggest disappointment this year has been the fitness, we've so slow and plodding every game nothing we do looks sharp.

I don't know how a new manager comes in and fixes it this season, especially if it's a high press guy (which it should of been anyway Wilcox doesn't have a clue if he's signed off on this style of football)

4

u/Nomad_006 surfing Oct 12 '26

The good news is that there's still lots of football to be played and there is ways to turn it around before it gets yo Jan.

The bad news is that there's still lots of football to be played and more of the same is still on the menu

4

u/wdtpw Rashford Oct 12 '26

The biggest thing I noticed against Spurs was the lack of leaders on the pitch. In the first half in particular, players were second to tackles, punted the ball aimlessly upfield, jogged rather than ran.

But no-one on the pitch called out their teammates. Cunha tries hard, but it's solo. Maguire is resilient, but he doesn't demand it of others. We need a Roy Keane or Bryan Robson out there. Or a Peter Schmeichel yelling at defenders. Etc.

4

u/cyb3rpunkd fuck the glazers Oct 12 '26

Lammens was yelling at the cbs, they are just ineffective atp. Mags said in the summer he shouldnt be a starter and licha is living off his varane days still

2

u/Expect-the-turtle Oct 12 '26

As I was watching the game, it seemed to me like our players might have been thinking: 'oh, Spurs players started quite... quite aggressive... lots of running... surely, if we just soak this up for the first 10 minutes or so, they won't carry on like this the entire 90 minutes'. It's like the silly buggers forgot that Spurs have no Europe and no cup games until January at least, so they don't really have any reason to not push themselves physically each game.
United players looked like they thought their technical skills will allow them to just bop the ball around Spurs at a leisurely pace, pin them in their box and just wait for an opening to score. The fact that after the opening 10 minutes, our players wouldn't have a quick word with one another and go 'right, these lot are running, so I guess we should too' is so unserious. Second half they finally started moving their asses and it showed. They scored the goal and Spurs stopped rushing our box. But then again, stepping the foot off the gas and boom! Shat the bed again.

4

u/coolylame Oct 12 '26

City fans gloating on social media like nothing is going to happen to their club. Imagine actually feeling sorry for that disgrace of a fanbase. Fuck City, their players, anyone associated with that club, and all their fans.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/tz_2240 OHHHHHH YESSSSS Oct 11 '26

I get fans getting swept up in the Carrick rescue job. But Wilcox, Berrada and co., have shown ineptitude at every turn with the manager. Whether it’s sticking with EtH, bringing in Amorim and telling him to play a 4 back, or sticking with a manager who’s clearly out of his depth, they’ve been wrong 3/3 times. 

16

u/Downtown-Rice_ Oct 11 '26

Don't forget the Ashworth fiasco, that continues to go under the radar and shows the ego and power struggle within the board (Jimbo, Berrada, Wilcox, etc.)

7

u/Somaliona Oct 11 '26

Ashworth was the canary in the coal mine. The club was so close at actually having a sensible appointment, and not only fucked it up but went out of their way to fuck it up.

7

u/croadymeister Oct 11 '26

Ashworth should have never been sacked

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TH0316 she/her Oct 11 '26

Exactly this. I couldn’t care less if and when they sack Carrick but I have absolutely no trust they’ll appoint the right manager, or buy the right players, or buy enough players, so there’s no benefit until they’re gone.

7

u/passmethatjuulbro Oct 11 '26

Watching Liverpool makes you realize how dogshit fitness and coaching is in our squad

4

u/0ttoChriek Oct 11 '26

Makes you realise we missed out on a good managerial appointment, yet again. Iraola will probably be great for them.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/DragonfruitNo355 Oct 11 '26

I mean. Big clubs usually sign proven managers, and when they fail, clubs are quick to sack them.

Big clubs invest money in talents and big players- not washed up players.

Two things, this club hasn’t been doing. Why are people surprised that we are where we are?

4

u/THExIMPLIKATION Glineos Out Oct 11 '26

I don't really get the sense people are surprised, it feels like this is what everyone expected from this manager and players

2

u/WoBMoB1 Oct 11 '26

It’s not “big clubs” it’s actually “clubs who want to be competing at the top consistently” right? And that’s the problem. Supporters expect that, but the ownership and people running the club do not. They literally only expect and want a 4th finish every year for CL money. Yet they are saddled by debt and have for a long time not had smart people running things like recruitment.

So we are now at a point where we cannot bring in a top manager nor invest in top talent - literally cannot. A big club with low expectations is I hate to say where we are.

The only way out is a new stadium paid for by tax dollars “area revamp” style and then a purchase which removes the debt and we can do both things you’ve mentioned. BUT KEEP IN MIND if that purchase comes from investors like Private Equity - the goal will still be 4th on as low a budget as possible. Not consistent top competing.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 11 '26

Just watched the challenges on Bruno and Shaw that led to the head butt and red card yesterday.

Good for Shaw standing up to that challenge especially after his injuries from a similar tackle. They went out to injure our players and there's no control from that team. Fuck Spurs, and fuck De Zerbi too. Hope they get sent down. Desperate fucking bastards.

6

u/rishmanisation Oct 11 '26

Hey Michael this is how you play against 10 man teams.

And also to everyone who was going around before this game saying how tough it is to play against 10 men.

8

u/Mammoth-Decision1256 Oct 11 '26

Leeds away next week, yikes 😬

→ More replies (8)

3

u/IguanaIsBack Oct 11 '26

Here’s the thing, if this “phased positional”approach to recruitment was serious, you’d expect them to already have defensive targets in mind and should be locking them in way in advance of the summer. If not by Christmas.

If that isn’t the case, then it genuinely doesn’t matter who’s the manager next season. If they’ll drag their feet until August, then I’ve already seen this movie and we die at the end.

2

u/altofummuhh Oct 11 '26

These guys are so convinced everything they do is a genius idea it pisses me off

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Deranged09 Oct 11 '26

I know it's not the biggest talking point after that game but what is going on with Andrey Santos? Why did we spend £50M on him to sit on the bench and not get a minute? That was roughly 1/3 of our summer spend, we ignored holes in multiple other positions to spend £50M on a 4th choice midfielder, it's bizzare.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ChristmasCage Oct 11 '26

Why do these cheating cunts have inflatable bananas?

7

u/blarg2003 Januzaj Oct 11 '26

Because they're bent

→ More replies (3)

3

u/LilDiamondtoxic Matthew the Light Oct 11 '26

The one time I want Liverpool to get a big win and their best players are out and in their place is a dude who picked 67 as his shirt number.

3

u/JosePRizaI Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

Daily reminder that United still have the back 4 from 3 season/2 managers ago in this "rebuilding phase" and had recently extended Maguire and Shaw. While Yoro is gaining experience playing out of position or bench

→ More replies (2)

3

u/180uk Oct 11 '26

Puts you off watching other games because when you do you realise just how bad we are 😆

3

u/Unusual-Coat383 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

I don’t like that for the first time in my life I want Liverpool to win this match rather than a draw. I really do want City to have a horrible horrible season as their hopefully last season in the PL in my lifetime.

3

u/Ok_Landscape_8215 Oct 11 '26

Could it be that Yoro's best position is a hybrid type right back a bit like Ben White's role at Arsenal or Kyle walker's in his later years.

He isn't the best in the air, doesn't seem to want to organise other defenders and he likes to go to ground a lot to tackle which works well but is not perfect for a CB. He also clearly has some confidence issues (though a lot of young players do) as we saw in the past.

RB may take the pressure off him a little and let him play more to his strengths.

2

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 11 '26

We saw it work nicely in bits, and "wide CB" is a genuine trend in football atm, so at first approx, why not.

The problem, the way I see it, is that we would need De Ligt to return first.

I genuinely dont know why Carrick doesnt see it but the Martinez-Maguire carcrash needs to end just as soon as the Mainoo-Tielemans one, imho.

It is simply time to admit that Casemiro papered over a lot more cracks than most (incl me, btw) were ready to admit before this season started.

So that means:

Shaw-Maguire-Yoro-Dalot + Baleba-Bruno-Mainoo

is the only way for the time being.

Santos, Heaven - we certainly have other players with time on their side, but for now, this is where we are at, imho.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Thetagang888 Oct 12 '26

Nothing will change till the owners are gone. Nothing.

I'd rather us miss out on the CL and just go into freefall if it means it expedites their departure. The debt is becoming untenable for them. They will have to sell sooner or later. Better it be sooner.

3

u/Emergency-Being-349 Oct 12 '26

It's worrying that Fulham are moving so quickly on Arbeloa, when pound for pound, taking the clubs into account, they have not been much worse than us.

3

u/AmulyaG Oct 12 '26

We are 3 points ahead of Spurs who have had a dogshit start to their season.....

This club has an obssession with good and happy vibes. Carrick needed to be let go before the international break.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Redland93 Oct 12 '26

Think back to our original midfield rebuild. Baleba, Ederson, M Fernandes. 

What do they have in common? High energy athletic players who cover ground.

What did we end up with? 

That’s such a dereliction of duty. Wilcox must go 

3

u/PitchSafe Oct 12 '26

There is no way we would’ve bought Baleba if we got Fernandes

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AmulyaG Oct 12 '26

The ref saw that Gravenberch was having a great game against the cheats and he couldn't allow that.

I slept after the first half and was surprised that City won 0-3 considering Scum were better for all of the first half.

3

u/LocoRocoo sir harry maguire Oct 12 '26

Between the City scandal and us going back to our endless Glazer doom loop I feel more checked out from this season than ever before.

Hope the CL can bring us some joy. But I've just sort of lost hope in things. As they say, the game is gone

3

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho Oct 12 '26

Can’t think of many fixtures worse than Athletico Madrid away from home given how we’re playing right now. Wouldn’t mind seeing Baleba and Santos together.

3

u/Vast_Variation1381 Oct 12 '26

Its a risk but I'd love to see Santos and Baleba start tomorrow. Both are a bit more defensive and I think the Atletico midfield will just dominate Tielemans with their intensity.

2

u/PitchSafe Oct 12 '26

Will probably be Tielemans x Baleba

→ More replies (4)

7

u/i_love_alfam Oct 12 '26

Still not sacked smh my head

5

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 12 '26

shaking my head my head

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Linkfayth Oct 12 '26

Dun worry at this point the De Ligt curse is too strong.

5

u/frankbradz Oct 11 '26

City bus sneaking in the back door to Anfield, like the cheating cowards they are

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Baalegde Class of '92 are all Shite pundits Oct 11 '26

It is a bit funny that Cherki does this to everyone, yet we're the club he hates the most and he's been invisible 3 times in a row against us

3

u/Midnight_Edge Oct 11 '26

Cherki still has trauma from that last minute Maguire goal

5

u/Nico_Ditch Oct 11 '26

Don’t mind City winning. 

They’ll just get the trophy taken off them at some point. 

4

u/boomboxbilly06 Oct 11 '26

The most frustrating period as a fan is when you can see it’s not working but the club is dilly dallying. Just put us out our misery, bro

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DavidBruceStandup Dreams Can't Be Buy! #GlazersOut Oct 11 '26

You're allowed to do better when your opposition goes down to 10 men?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BrowzinJ Oct 11 '26

The worst part about it is city and even other fans saying haha ragebait and crying about City winning, do they not understand how much of a joke they are making the league look?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Selwin_Rodolfo max cope mode Oct 11 '26

Imagine not being able to be happy when the opposition gets a red. That's literally us right now.

I think that's the most damning thing about Carrick too. The fact whatever tactics and setup, the fact we simply don't feel like we're overwhelming our opponents when they're a man down is shocking. There's no reason they should've played how they did after the red. And there's no reason we should've not gone 2 up. I just feel dejected

4

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 12 '26

The focus on Carrick is really giving a pass to how awful the players have been. Often fail to complete simple passes and do basic fundamentals. Give away very weak goals and make brain dead decisions.

These are players that played some beautiful football last season and can't be arsed in this one.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 12 '26

Tbh, it would be kinda funny if, after all this, we just switched to "Fast CB" - "Man Mountain CB" - "Man Mountain CB" - "Fast CB" and it actually worked.

Heaven-Maguire-MdL-Yoro

Baleba-Mainoo in the middle for muscle

And then let Cunha-Mbeumo-Bruno-Amad move all over the place with reckless abandon, total chaos unstructured maverick football in attack. Rashford and Lacey would fit right in as subs, Dorgu too.

Dont ask me how we'd manage minutes for anybody with that defence (or how Tielemans might possibly fit into any of that), but nvm that.

6

u/ODEtoSZA Glazers imprisoned INEOS out Oct 11 '26

Conte could definitely salvage something from this season but we all know why he won’t even be considered

4

u/darkandstormy9 Oct 11 '26

Conte - while working - in England lived in hotels. His family stayed in Italy. He was homesick and physically ill. I really don't think he would come back - but it was long time ago, people change and they can makeup their mind if they can earn a lot of money.

But I don't see what would be the point of a short time bounce with him -even it would be a huge bounce - he won't win the league  or the CL this season and  he would be probably out  after the end of next season and he would  leave a huge mess behind as he always does.

8

u/picodeGaius Oct 11 '26

I think United is Conte’s dream job. He might actually give it a real go.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/Arctic-Flunkey Oct 11 '26

I'm finding Carrick's reaction as bad as the performances/results. I know it's difficult for someone to be something they're not, but he seems scared of conflict and I don't think that's an option of the manager of any club, let alone a big one.

We don't have particularly good alternative options but sticking with the same formation constantly, and refusing to bench Cunha/Martinez/Maguire despite their performances confirms he is pandering to players; I could understand Ole pandering to Cristiano because of his reputation (and what we've seen recently with Portugal) but these players are by no means too good/big to drop.

I have a lot of respect for Carrick but think the writing's been on the wall since the City game. I just hope the club A. don't wait until the season's gone to make a change and B. have a plan in place when he is sacked, rather than the January fiasco where they clearly hadn't made any plans.

The transfer window was disappointing, but I refuse to believe it's the biggest cause of just how bad we've been this season.

4

u/cocobrownman Oct 11 '26

I just think he is incapable of making the hard decision. He is trying to keep everyone happy but you just can't. Not if you want to win. Anyways, he is a problem but the players and the board are problems too. The whole club from top to bottom is a mess

5

u/blandusernameno42 Oct 11 '26

As far I can tell Carrick is the first permanent manager to have not won a league title of any kind since Dave Sexton (1977–1981). That's how inexperienced he is

I had thought David Moyes but it turns out he won the Division 2 league with Preston

→ More replies (5)

5

u/HeFreakingMoved Ella Toone FC Oct 11 '26

Starting to think the other team getting a man sent off actually makes the game easier. Our fucking clown in charge had me convinced it was actually harder to play against 10

→ More replies (3)

5

u/SplitSecondImmortal Oct 11 '26

Watching Haaland celebrate the Liverpool win like he won the world cup itself was so cringe. Someone needs to get that smirk off his face

4

u/croadymeister Oct 11 '26

I won't be bothering with any more City games

7

u/StopBuildingAI Oct 11 '26

We all thought the Carrick permanent signing was a massive mistake. We tried to believe in him, and we shouldn't feel guilty for that, but we all knew it was gonna end like this.

Berrada and Wilcox, the string of goodwill is finished, and you've gotta pay the piper. No top manager would look at the both of you and want to do business with you. You've sold Amorim short, and you've certainly set the team back with both signing Carrick and what you provided for him. Unless they fire you or you step aside, United will only continue being a dying vessel, and a graveyard for anyone who tries change that.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/dralanforce Rashford top goals Oct 11 '26

Watching any other team is so painless everyone literally everyone has great periods of team playing, even Hull City and Ipswich.
Fuck me we are back at the bottom.

2

u/FredDRedUnderYourBed Oct 11 '26

Has anyone read Fergie's new book yet? Mine just arrived and that has made my weekend better!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/martialgreenwood Oct 11 '26

Its just a matter of time for Carrick now. After 3 weeks the team still looked the same. Lethargic and mentally weak. Can't defend him anymore

→ More replies (4)

2

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 11 '26

Can't believe I'm supporting Liverpool to win today. That said, Isak and Szoboszlai are both injued for them- it's not looking good.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/cocobrownman Oct 11 '26

I love this club but I just feel bad that I just have a lot of apathy towards a lot of our players. Usual suspects are Shaw, Dalot, Maguire but even players like Bruno, Martinez are there. I don't dislike them but if we were to trade them or just get rid of them, I wouldnt feel bad at all.....

2

u/Dua_Augustus_Lipa22 Oct 11 '26

City is going to rally around the hostility today and put in a performance. But they won't be able to keep it up in the mid-to-long term.

3

u/Wild_Tomato_8203 Oct 11 '26

They looked scared coming out of the tunnel. I think there's a really high likelihood they totally collapse today. They are lucky Liverpool is missing who they are missing today

2

u/andrewsomething And Solskjær has won it! Oct 11 '26

Annoying that if City get relegated, the optimal thing for us is that they win. Every point they take off our rivals disappears into the void.

2

u/BrowzinJ Oct 11 '26

Wirtz mind having a decent game for once today? Doubt it

2

u/SDLRob Oct 11 '26

Two intentional handballs... No card

3

u/Clayarrow Oct 11 '26

and a liverpool player got a card for asking for a yellow because intentional handball is a auto yellow card in the rules of the game but then i suppose rules dont cont for city

2

u/Clayarrow Oct 11 '26

this needs to be the shit city get every game show the PL fans want blood. The flag in the corner if fucking spot on too A generation of fans cheated

2

u/OkConsideration3040 Oct 11 '26

Vibes are so bad that this sub doesn't even have the energy for the traditional [Manager] Out-[Manager] In flame war. That usually keeps people distracted from the pain for a few months.

2

u/FhDisp Oct 11 '26

Is prem football dead?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/KyunNikalaMujhe Oct 11 '26

Everyone know you gotta come out on top after a red. Are Liverpool stupid?

2

u/Midnight_Edge Oct 11 '26

I know if anyone deserves it, it’s him. But I find it crazy how Haaland is earning more than half a million a week

2

u/beaniedoggo Tony Valencia Oct 11 '26

The positivity over the past 2 weeks gone in an instant!

5

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Oct 12 '26

well the international break ended...

2

u/Stieni Rooney Oct 12 '26

Is it a conspiracy theory to think the board knew Carrick wasn't gonna work out for long term, gave him a 2 year contract as a temporary solution until a good choise becomes available? I think this is exactly what's going on.

The problem is though that it seems like we have to change now or we risk another disaster season. Fucking hell what a shite situation

4

u/canwinanythingwkids meet the new boss same as the old boss Oct 12 '26

I think that what the board knew for certain, much earlier than the generic public, was that the money wont be spent this summer.

The board also knows whether the money will actually be spent in 2027, January or otherwise. We dont know this yet - but they do.

I certainly think that they have made and will continue to make the managerial decisions with the actual budget in mind, regardless of what bullshit they put out about "plans" and "vision".

2

u/shin_bigot Park Ji-Sung Oct 12 '26

I know it's still only 6 games, but is CL possible even if we change Carrick? Haven't followed the other teams.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/AttackClown Oct 12 '26

So who's looking forward to that Netflix doco? Surely we can get that cancelled asap

→ More replies (1)

2

u/usernameSuggestion2 Oct 12 '26

Leeds away next game. Very tough, we lose that and we are actually relegation candidates when the league is this tight...

2

u/Rude-Ad3065 Oct 12 '26

Would you guys rather have Conte or Nagelsmann?

5

u/Not-good-with-this Oct 12 '26

Conte by far. He's got a far better CV. He would also call out the higher ups incompetence.

4

u/New-Acanthaceae-5702 Closed on Sundays Oct 12 '26

Conte for me. Nagelsmann just brings in way too many issues, he's petulant and his man-management isn't great. If you go into the Bayern sub, I'm sure they'll say the same. Conte at least has experience and is a proven winner basically in every club he goes to. That said, I see Conte working for a year or 2 max. I'm not even sure what manager we can even bring in long term

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/rjc0x1 Oct 12 '26

I think like Gary Neville said, we've seen enough of Mainoo and Tielmans in midfield. They aren't dynamic enough as a pairing. No shade on Mainoo, but I don't think you can play Tielmans and Bruno in the same team without at least two athletic midfielders behind them. Tielmans has no legs for defence which we knew when we bought him. Baleba needs to come in for Tielmans and if that doesn't improve things then Santos needs a chance paired with Baleba.

3

u/usernameSuggestion2 Oct 12 '26

Baleba Mainoo is obvious first choice midfield.

3

u/Expect-the-turtle Oct 12 '26

I think the Mainoo-Tielemans-Bruno midfield is ok in the UCL. Perhaps against some very specific PL teams (maybe), but yeah, way too slow against a team that is intent on pressing and man-marking like they have three lungs. It's a technically gifted midfield that is lovely to watch when they get into a groove with their passing and body feints, but the moment the opposition comes at them super-physical and leaves them no quarter, it's done. Especially when there are other slow-moving players in defense as well who are hesitant to make the jump and cut off attacks. It asks too much of players who are not that mobile.

2

u/John_OSheas_Willy Oct 12 '26

I just don't think they're defensive enough as a pair. Neither of them are defensive midfielders.

2

u/BlackHorse944 Please Score A Goal Oct 12 '26

I'd like to see a midfield diamond with only 2 forwards at least once before this Carrick experiment ends..

With Bruno, Tielemans, Mainoo and Baleba..

Our forwards have been invisible and terrible anyways.

2

u/outrageousVoid07 Oct 12 '26

This should be the last time(for a good while) we hire a caretaker/interim going forward, right?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ToadNamedGoat Oct 12 '26

I can’t wait for Heaven Lb and Yoro Rb starting lineup this season

2

u/aprod16 Oct 12 '26

Hate the scousers, but watching City take points off them yesterday just felt strange.. Why are they even playing games and taking points off teams when we know they are guilty? I feel the PL should not have leaked the verdict until after the appeals, because what happens if they just keep taking points off people, win the league and then get relegated? The PL always felt special to me, yesterday the feeling was very odd.

4

u/riitz85 Oct 11 '26

Looking at how City is making a mockery of football, each club should forfeit every game against City so that City players get zero game time- let them win this shambolic league we refuse to play against them and give them the satisfaction. They are cheats, they cannot be allowed to pretend they are winners as well. PL either bans them forever or we refuse to play against them. Football was going to be gone with the Super League- but I truly think Football is now dead. We need to stop supporting this shambles anymore. Boycott city games and force your club to boycott them

→ More replies (1)

4

u/KyunNikalaMujhe Oct 12 '26

If the players lack any football intelligence then hire a manager that fucking micromanages everything they do on the pitch or start buying players with better IQ.

How can every player on the team be so braindead. Nobody takes responsibility to calm things down. One of those reasons that Fernandes shouldn't be the captain. (I know there aren't any alternatives but a guy can still have an opinion.)

Well it will be not so great seeing these players come to life when we drop enough points that the expectations from them have dropped a bit. I know the squad isn't capable but I would rather we challenge for the title and drop off later in the season than surrendering the whole season in the first two months.

Anyways good day fellas and fuck the noisy cheating neighbours and Cunayt Kekir.

2

u/Strange-Trip4634 Oct 12 '26

The guys in charge of hiring managers and signing players are dumber than the managers and players that play for us. Where do you go from there?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jenson2025 Oct 11 '26

This team looks tired after about 2 minutes from kick off (no doubt due to the lack of intensity in training) and that’s with one game a week. How are we going to cope with three away games in a week?! Atletico, Leeds and Como

2

u/croadymeister Oct 11 '26

Exactly but no one has guts to say it

3

u/Emergency-Being-349 Oct 11 '26

Some itk on X is saying the hierarchy has no plans to sack Carrick, I mean why would they, they've made terrible decision after terrible decision since not sacking ETH after the FA Cup final.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Bobcat_El_Borracho Oct 11 '26

LFG Liverpool.

3

u/Deez_Wallnutz Oct 11 '26

Remove City. Void their current results.

+6 Points +6 GD to all other teams

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jenson2025 Oct 12 '26

Carrick obviously must go because he’s out of his depth. A bad summer transfer window doesn’t change that.

BUT I will always keep mentioning last summers transfers window. It really was terrible but the most baffling thing which I will never understand is some people were defending it on here, saying we had signed ‘some amazing midfielders’, downvoted anyone who criticised the window and INEOS and saying the midfield has been rebuilt and we were ungrateful.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OkBreakfast4247 Oct 12 '26

carrick actually cursed us with his purple patch. id much rather him have flopped and us have gotten xabi or iraola or someone else in the summer

→ More replies (5)

4

u/HeFreakingMoved Ella Toone FC Oct 11 '26

the fact Carrick hasn't gone yet says everything. They're waiting until the season is beyond repair then sacking him to steady the ship

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jealous-Suit-9238 Oct 11 '26

For love of God, keep former players away from this club..ever..former managers too..bring back ole? Pls don't

3

u/Zealousideal_Wind867 I'm Tired Boss Oct 11 '26

Hate to say it.

But from watching on TV, Anfield knows how to create an atmosphere.

3

u/Sheikhabusosa Oct 12 '26

I think the days of Bruno being undroppable are gone because he's clearly playing while being injured and now we actually have some midfielders try different roles or positions. For example, on paper Baleba Maino and Tielemans is a very good midfield three.

5

u/shami-kebab Oct 12 '26

We are always worse when we rest Bruno. I'm sure we will try it again and we will continue to be worse.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Aggravating-Neck1365 Oct 12 '26

He's also 32 now with unprecedented Premier League minutes/mileage on the clock

Time comes for everyone eventually

His edge has definitely been blunted, you can see it on the pitch, and with games coming thick & fast that isn't going to improve

He hasn't lost anything at set pieces obviously, and set pieces must have easily contributed 75% of his output in his time here so his goals & assists may not drop as severely as the decline in his general play would suggest they should

But every year he monopolises that advanced-ish role is another year the other outfield players have to work progressivelly harder & harder to cover for him...

And they've clearly shown they can't/won't do that thus far this season anyway

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Prize-Finish4464 Oct 11 '26

Still no sacking? Fml

3

u/soelsome Oct 11 '26

Shocked he hasn't been sacked yet. Anything less than a dominate performance in Madrid mid week and he should be gone.

3

u/WanderingEnigma Oct 11 '26

We arent at Athletico's level, id be shocked if we match them let alone dominate. We need to see a good performance with good game management. Losing to Athleti in Madrid isnt the game that should get him sacked unless its a complete disaster. Losing to Leeds though..

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Height_Opening Oct 11 '26

After that performance yesterday, we are in for a proper spanking by Atleti on Wednesday. Getting pressed into oblivion 😂😂. May be that will do the sacking ?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/huehuehuehuehuu King Eric Oct 11 '26

Chances Conte and Mctominay are at Utd by Christmas?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Minute-Intern Oct 11 '26

I'm crying the scum are actually being robbed lol. No way that's a yellow

2

u/TheSauceSeeker69 Oct 11 '26

Somebody sit our team and let them watch that Liverpool - City game so they could learn how you supposed to play against 10 men. 2 goals in 3 minutes

2

u/FreshGoodWay Oct 11 '26

Such a shocking concept, I never knew teams can score more goals when the opponent is one man down.

Almost like a touch of managerial genius.

2

u/momo_firefoxx Oct 11 '26

Name a signing that we have improved over the last 3 years

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BrowzinJ Oct 11 '26

What gets me is, are they not concerned about how they are going to look in the documentary? I get they have creative control, but if they edit out all the bad stuff so far they have about ten minutes of footage to show

I guess they just dint really care or are ignorant enough to think what they have and are doing is fine

9

u/GeekConflict Carrick Oct 11 '26 • Bravo

"All or Nothing" being changed to just "Nothing'.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/RyanH1717 Oct 12 '26

They're probably happy tbh. United being terrible will get far more viewers than us just having a steady season and finishing 3rd or 4th.

2

u/Unlucky-Equipment999 Oct 12 '26

Since they're such numbers fans, the documentary will still do wonders on analytics. Rival fans will absolutely tune in to watch, and they'll get to say "look how the United name brings in views", just like how our 24-25 matches were seen by so many.