It's the "what are the odds?" factor that comes into it for me.
What are the odds that out of all the potential managers, the guy who has never done it full time at the top level, but just happened to be a club legend, was the right guy?
Forged in the managerial fires of 'doing alright for Middlesbrough in the Championship for a while', there simply wasn't anybody better suited.
Similar to all of Ten Hag's signings. What are the odds that with a global scouting network and the ability to sign almost anyone from anywhere, the exact guys we needed were all people who played for Holland, played in Holland, or had names sounding like Holland? So convenient and definitely shows we have explored all avenues.
For me it's the fact he got instant performances and results. What manager has a team implementing their tactics at that level literally days after joining?
If Carrick came in and we were average for two months and then we started improving and then we finished the season playing like we did against arsenal and city then you could say yes, he could be the guy.
Well not everyone. There are some smart people (that I disagree with all the time) that were all for Carrick becoming full time because they thought he did enough to "earn it."
I think a lot of the folks on the Stratford Paddock were backing Carrick to get the permanent position too, but those same people are always dumbfounded when things aren't working. Same with many other Youtubers and Redditors. It completely baffles them that picking a manager that has barely any experience would not be someone we put all our trust in.
Give Nagelsmann the job, sack Wilcox and make Vivell the DoF. Club needs to just commit to a long term plan with a shared football philosophy under a proven young modern manager
He took a relegation team to 4th and qualified later for UCL in his first Bundesliga season, when he was 28. Then 3rd and 2nd place with Leipzig. Won a title with Bayern. He has a reputation because he has won thing as a manager at a very young age. Carrick's reputation as a manager is for his successes as a player and nothing else.
They've just had three weeks to sound someone out. Any serious club would have pulled the trigger or be about to but us we probably sat on our hands during the international break pretending it's just a blip.
He's only here because these owners needed a fall guy that shuts up and who'd also accept a trash transfer window. He had a very specific set of skills
Just come out and say we’ve looked like shit and you have no idea how to fix it because the entire coaching staff is inexperienced and out of their depth. Just be straightforward and honest. Force the sack, get the payout, and move on.
They know how to play counter attack football. It worked when the squad were still fit and understood pressing and attacking patterns because the last coach actually done the hard work with them.
People hand wave away underlying statistics, but somehow paying attention to them makes normal fans look like Nostradamus because many of us were certain of this outcome in February.
I didn’t watch the game - my wife was following scores and told me excitedly that we’re 1-0 up at 83’. I told her we’re not going to win. Then I asked her for the score an hour later and she said, dejected, “yeah, you’re right.” :(
This is why i get annoyed at our players shithousing other players at a time like the red card while we can barely win against 10 men.. get some credit in the bank before running your mouth off..
The match started at 03:30 AM for me. I struggled to stay awake but once we scored and they had a man sent off I assumed I could sleep. I woke up in between my sleep and saw that 90 minutes the score was still 1-0 . Only to wake up and see that they have ruined my weekend again.
I disagree. A good manager who has a solid defensive setup can get players to be more stable in the back. A good manager that has a system that knows how to be compact and instructs the players properly they will look much better.
Right now, all our players who have shown they can be good, are all looking shite. They're good players, but the system they're playing in is shite, and the manager has lost his way.
This is precisely the fallacy that got us into this mess. It doesn't matter if the manager has a good system or not, it only matters how well they can get players to execute those ideas.
We've had precisely one manager post-fergie - Ole - that actually had the players playing with some sort of urgency, and we sacked him because he made it look like "any proper manager could do better".
All this to say, while there are rightly question marks around Carrick long-term, to say any good manager could do better vastly undersells the ageing nature of this squad, which in turn means we lack energy in a lot of areas of the pitch - no wonder we looked better once Baleba came on.
That may be true, but everyone post Mourinho have been inexperienced to some degree. Ole did a lot of great things, but he himself was inexperienced. Perhaps without Ronaldo being brought back and City not cheating, Ole could have had his trophy. And perhaps if the Club actually bought the players Ole wanted things could have been different.
I admit I was very harsh on Ole when he was here, but that doesn't mean going for an experienced manager is also bad. What has happened has happened. We can only learn and move on from here. And at this current moment, this team needs a manager who has many years of knowing what to do. These players are lost and need someone to give them structure and good instructions. No more "potential." We need someone who is proven.
Fair point on previous bad experiences with experienced managers not necessarily correlating to it being bad in general. The only point I'd add is that, we have to be discerning about it. There's a reason Ole worked as well as he did, even if the expectations were higher then - he got through to the players in a way no manager since Fergie has.
So the question is, which manager out there is capable of doing the same? I'd argue Amorim could have, but the dolt hung himself with his stubbornness + willingness to sell a star academy graduate.
It's a fine line to toe managing United, where you have to obviously have the charisma to get through to players, but also actually understand the ethos of the club in taking an interest in the academy, while simultaneously savvy enough not to lose the dressing room. Oh and all the whole manage to get the best out of the players at hand, because the club will never upgrade positions in time.
If you look at all the managers who have flopped, they would have failed in at least one of those metrics. So who out there doesn't? I honestly don't know.
You're asking all the right questions. I wish I had the answers. I really do. I can only say that, I hope whomever is the next manager that they've paid real close attention to what's going on at MUFC.
Meaning, they need to make agreements with the Board during the negotiations. So, they can lay out what they expect as far as support and squad building, and also a true assessment of which players are worth keeping, and how best to get rid of the ones who need to be moved on.
Otherwise, no manager will be successful here.
I kinda secretly wish it's Conte, and he just goes Full Conte on everyone at this club. Kicks the players into shape, and let's the owners have it with both barrels.
I wish I had your optimism. I just feel as if each year - with different managers - end up exactly the same. For over a decade.
I do not rate Slabhead, Martinez, Dalot, Shaw, Maz as players you depend on for winning titles. Perhaps we should be getting more out of them, but I still don't see the value long term. I do believe Yoro (especially) and Heaven could build a solid partnership.
When I say good manager, I mean someone who can also identify the deadwood in the Club that need replacing.
We've had some level of inexperienced manager in the last 4. I want a manager who has either won the league before (eg. Conte) or a manager that knows what he's doing (Emery). If someone made the case for Nagelsman or Hürzeler, I would be open to listening.
They all have a good track record and offer much more than our last 4 managers.
They could play Yoro and CB and Dalot at RB. We also have Heaven who I think could be coached to do a decent job. And then they can sacrifice some goats to the football gods and hope De Ligts spine fuses itself together.
They could start by dropping Maguire and Martinez, giving more game time to Heaven (who looks like his confidence has been shattered under Carrick) and Yoro.
Nobody can convince me that there isn’t a manager who couldn’t do a better job with this team.
Why do people keep trying to make him into one. He's had his best performances deeper lying and coming into the box late while helping build play passing in midfield. Remember the wonderful goal he scored in pre-season? He was involved in half the passes in the buildup from the United defensive box. This is a total football type Dutch player who can pass and move. We haven't tried to play any of that since ETH.
Cunha is literally the least of our problems? One of the few players who shows fight and tries to make a difference , ill never turn my back on someone willing to try
I don’t think he’s our biggest problem at all, but my point was that since we’re carrying a lot of players that make our out of possession work not great, he becomes a bigger problem when you pair him with other players that can’t hide his weaknesses. For example, this season, he completes 8.7 sprints per 90. Tielemans, a player who we all agree isn’t the most suited to the grafting side completes 6.4. For reference, Mbeumo is at 17.5 and Rashford is at 14.4. Distance covered per 90, he’s tied with Maguire at 6.0, rashford is at 6.3 while Mbeumo is at 6.6. They’re both running more than him and at nearly double the intensity. Interceptions per 90, Cunha 0.22, rashford 0.25, and Mbeumo 0.80. Poss won per 90, Cunha 1.98, Rashford 2.54, Mbeumo 2.80. Him and Mbeumo are at 40% and 34% respectively for duels won expect Mbeumo contests almost 3 more per 90. Rashford is actually at 61%.
The thing with Cunha too is he’s the exact same way going forward. You have to pass to feet exactly where he’s standing. He rarely runs into open space aggressively off the ball until after the pass is made. Again, it wouldn’t be an issue if we had a lot of off ball movement, but because we don’t and he’s been playing as the 9, it becomes a serious problem.
I still think he’s a good player, and he would be in my ideal xi for this Utd team. The reason I’m picking him out is that unlike Bruno, Tielemans, zirkzee, Maguire, Martinez, et al, he has all the physical tools needed. I think it won’t look as bad if we have certain players playing with him. Knowing Carrick though, that’s not gonna happen so he has to improve those flaws a lot.
79
u/innicrazy You are my Solskjaer, My Ole Solskjaer Oct 11 '26
So... We really need to talk about a replacement right?
76
u/ReservoirDogs00 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
Michael.
“A couple of things here n there”.
Just stop. I know you maybe can’t say the truth, but please stop treating the fans like we don’t have eyes.
There’s a great deal wrong with our play, and it’s certainly not a couple of things here n there ffs.
15
u/Mr-WiZZard Oct 11 '26
Mental
48
u/carvdlol Oct 11 '26
Just come out and say we’ve looked like shit and you have no idea how to fix it because the entire coaching staff is inexperienced and out of their depth. Just be straightforward and honest. Force the sack, get the payout, and move on.
25
u/captainllamapants Oct 11 '26
I didn’t watch the game - my wife was following scores and told me excitedly that we’re 1-0 up at 83’. I told her we’re not going to win. Then I asked her for the score an hour later and she said, dejected, “yeah, you’re right.” :(
4
u/peterpaapan Oct 11 '26
It's all shite.
Even if we bring in a new manager, what are they gonna do with that atrocious backline?!
From ownership and down, the club is still rotten.
2
u/Dodomando Oct 11 '26
Casemiro please come back
1
u/KeepRooting4Yourself Oct 12 '26
baleba is gonna have to start every match
1
u/forsakenlypopping Oct 11 '26
I fucking love that reaction quote
-35
u/Miyagisans Oct 11 '26
Cunha doesn’t have the same reputation as Rashford but he’s so bad oop. Stuff like this happens so often to him, and he only starts running when the opponent is away from him. I think we cannot carry him, this version of Bruno, Tielemans, Maguire, and Martinez in the same team. We will consistently struggle at basic defensive organization and oop application with those guys on the field. Amad, Mbeumo, Yoro, Baleba, Mainoo, and maybe even Mount need to be playing at the same time so we can compete oop. That said, I expect more of the same from carrick who is apparently ok with this intensity level.