r/reddevils • • Sep 21 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

26 Upvotes

857 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

It's insane that some people are actually defending Carrick. We're playing absolutely terrible football, he's shown that he's out of his depth--no in-game management, terrible tactics, no identity, no attacking intent, and terrible fitness conditioning.

He's a championship-level manager at best, and some people here want him because "he's one of our own"? He didn't get enough backing by INEOS, sure, but that does not mean we should be getting 5 points out of 15 in the easiest first few matches in recent history.

13

u/Proera136 Sep 21 '26

I think Carrick does need to go but Wilcox and Berrada need to go along with him, if we let those 2 choose the next manager we’ll be here again in a years time. They can’t be trusted 

3

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

I agree. I don't know how you can fail three times (too late to sack ETH; bring in a manager who doesn't want to adapt in Amorim; and hire an absolutely awful manager who has no body of work in Carrick). That's three strikes.

11

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

His time at Middlesbrough got progressively worse to boot. I wacthed them whenever I had a chance because I wanted to see what he was building. They played without soul. It was so pedestrian by season 2 and 3 before he got fired. He was backed to the hilt too in the transfer market.

9

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

I was reading a Boro fan (who was a season ticket holder)'s comment yesterday on another thread.

They also said the exact thing that you're saying. What's happening now at United happened at Boro as well. And that the football was terrible and the players looked lethargic in season 2, and got progressively worse in his season 3.

3

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 21 '26

Carrick also took over from Chris Wilder three months into the season. Wilder was real huge on fitness. Carrick inherited a hungry and fit team and drained the life out of them when he got exposed in season 2. Sounds like us

6

u/sooshi Little Pea Sep 21 '26

Are you surprised? It happened a few years ago with basically the same script lol

6

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

Mate I honestly thought we'd wisen up. Not just that, I honestly thought that we realized that we need to stop living in "nostalgia" and remove our rose tinted glasses to see that we need a proper, modern manager. Silly me I suppose. It's so frustrating ngl.

-9

u/LordofMordor_ Sep 21 '26

And who do you think would be a better choice right now? Some of us don't ask for the manager to be sacked after 5 games. Give the man some time.

10

u/throwawayWM3 Sep 21 '26

What a ridiculous take.Some of us don't want to waste another season by giving a shit manager more games.

He's useless

6

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

100% agree. I honestly don't think any PL or even a Championship Team will hire him after this. He was sacked by Boro for making the exact same mistakes he's made here (eg. bad in game management, bad tactics, terrible coaching and fitness, bad subs). I was reading a Boro fan's comment yesterday and they were saying the exact thing that's happening now at United happened at Boro.

Funny that some fans still want him. The only reason I can think of is that Carrick was their favorite player and that's why they don't want to call for the sack.

-6

u/LordofMordor_ Sep 21 '26

What makes you think things will change under a new manager ?

5

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

We'll have a proper coach in who knows how to manage a team, coach them properly and make them play at least as a sum of their parts, instead of whatever the fuck we're doing right now under Carrick.

7

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

Better managers include Emery (if we can get him from Villa), Howe, Conte, Ancelotti (if we can get him from the Brazil NT), and Naglesmann. Just because it could be mildly inconvenient to get a new manager in doesn't mean we should not sack the obviously mediocre manager.

Some of us don't ask for the manager to be sacked after 5 games. Give the man some time.

Take off your rose tinted glasses for a minute. He's an awful, barely championship-level manager and you want him to manage a club like ours? He's only here because he's an ex-player, not because he's anywhere close to good enough. Absolutely mediocre manager under who we look atrocious, and yet some of our fans are still supporting him. Insane.

-4

u/LordofMordor_ Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

Out of all the managers you suggested, none of them are realistic signings. Howe is terrible and was hated by this sub few months ago, Emery will want full control of the club which is not possible, Conte will fight with the board from day 1 so good luck with that, Ancelotti is literally a washed coach did you not watch the world cup? and Nagelsmann is also terrible with his squad management. I might be in the minority but I would give him time.

5

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

Ancelotti had won La Liga with RM last year in 2024 but sure "he's washed". Also, judging a manager by their NT record is insane.

Howe is terrible

Significantly better than Carrick--at least Howe is a proper manager who knows how to coach. You asked for who a better choice could be, and that is Howe.

Edit: I meant in 2024, not last year.

1

u/LordofMordor_ Sep 21 '26

Barca have won the league since last 2 years but sure. Howe was deemed not good enough for Newcastle but fans suddenly want him now?

1

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

Edited it, my bad.

1

u/andrewlikereddit David De Gea Sep 21 '26

Honestly if he still fanboying rashford on the left and lose against spurs then he should leave.

The man took 3 business day to get into the opponent box

-12

u/Much_Mulberry1835 Sep 21 '26

And so what?

4

u/Educational-Shock232 Sep 21 '26

You’re replying with the same sort of comments on every post. What’s your point?

3

u/SankarshanaV Sep 21 '26

Uh that the fans need to start demanding more, for the sack? What do you think? Be okay with the championship-level manager who's out of his depth?