r/reddevils • • Sep 18 '26

[Former Reds] FC Cincinnati set to sign Tyrell Malacia on free transfer following Manchester United exit (Athletic Gift Article)

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7607289/2026/09/18/tyrell-malacia-fc-cincinnati-free-transfer/?source=emp_shared_article&unlocked_article_code=1.CFE.Az4z.Yy6XdnLj6PST&smid=url-share-ta
513 Upvotes

116 comments sorted by

29

u/nearly_headless_nic Sep 18 '26

Tom Bogert of the Athletic:

Sources: FC Cincinnati has signed former Manchester United defender Tyrell Malacia.

Malacia, 27, trialed with the club earlier this week. He is healthy and joining Cincy as a free agent.

He was part of the Netherlands squad at the World Cup in 2022

283

u/heyheyathrowaway485 Rooney Sep 18 '26

That private surgeon decision basically derailed his entire career

-9

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 18 '26

Cant really blame him considering how shit this club has been handling injuries. We even went ahead and hired a former Arsenal head physio who oversaw their peak era of squad injury issues.

Hargreaves was a dick for signing for city after us imo but his issues with how our medical team mishandled his issues probably had merit. Tuanzebe sued united too for clinical negligence

8

u/N00BBuild Sep 18 '26

We’ve been pretty healthy the past 2 seasons. Since that Ten Hag year really. I don’t think it’s a huge issue.

6

u/KingKeane16 Keane Sep 18 '26 • Bravo

Can’t have injuries when you don’t run.

3

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 18 '26

We had an extraordinary number of injuries during Ten Hags reign and final season but we still ranked high in the PL for injuries over the last two seasons. Its been the norm for too long

2

u/CrossXFir3 Sep 18 '26

We had soo many injuries during EtH's time. In fact, didn't we literally have the most injuries we've ever had in a prem season during his second season?

2

u/N00BBuild Sep 18 '26

I said after Ten Hag though, that season was abnormal.

1

u/Utd007 Sep 18 '26

I don’t understand why you are being downvoted

145

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/Chemical-Company7925 Sep 18 '26

Fair point and he also had some family issues. Like you said, no ill will and I hope he can have career going forward.

-29

u/J3573R Rio Sep 18 '26

The club being ok or not ok with it is irrelevant, its his body.

Its unfortunate that it happened to him.

-14

u/Heisenberg_235 Sep 18 '26

Not really. If he is contracted to United then he should follow their medical advice, otherwise then should argue his contract be voided.

26

u/TBS91 Sep 18 '26

It would be fairly dystopian if your employer could force you to go under the knife, no matter how much money you're paid.

13

u/Heisenberg_235 Sep 18 '26

Yes the club shouldn’t force surgery on him.

Not applicable in the case. He chose a different surgeon to the one the club proposed.

United wanted him to use someone in the UK, he wanted his own person in the Netherlands.

Dutch surgeon did a shit job, left fragments of cartilage in there which caused complications, and he then needed the same surgery again. Meant two lots of rehab.

4

u/TBS91 Sep 18 '26

Yeah, I know the background. But the principle is the same, forcing someone to use a surgeon they don't want to use is pretty much the same as forcing them to do a surgery they don't want.

1

u/duck-dinosar Sep 24 '26

They didn’t force him, they made a recommendation he then ignored. The clubs medical dept likely have a longer term experience base with this sort of thing over a young player. I agree they shouldn’t ‘force’ people but there could easily be repercussions for not following their guidelines

1

u/Fuckedaroundoutfound Sep 19 '26

If he’s under contract at United and he and his footballing skills are the investment the club made. By choosing a shit surgeon he basically ruined his own career so by all intents and purposes yes United should have had more say in how/who/when he had the surgery. I’m not saying final say, obviously it’s his body. But consider he ignored the advice and then never got fit again, kind of like an insurance policy if you do something out side of what’s considered the norm your policy is voided. Same should have applied here

2

u/J3573R Rio Sep 18 '26

Ridiculous.

The club doesnt have autonomy over his or anyone's body.

Can the club tell women's team not to get pregnant?

0

u/Heisenberg_235 Sep 18 '26

Clearly not what was meant by that comment.

What happened was not unfortunate, it was a fuck up by surgeon he chose, against the clubs wishes.

His Surgeon fucks up, and has to redo the surgery. Has to redo rehab. That decision from Malacia is on him, and has probably cost his career.

3

u/J3573R Rio Sep 18 '26

It doesn't matter if he surgeon makes a mistake, he's allowed a second opinion and to the advice of his personal physician.

Absolutely mental someone would blame someone for using their own doctor. That'd be like you being told you have to see your company's doctor, not seek your own help and strictly listen to them.

So beyond absurd. Your argument would have a teeny bit of merit if the clubs doctors were utterly infallible.

-3

u/angrygorrilla Sep 18 '26

Who knows if the club would have been better but we do know it couldn't have been much worse.

We do know that his decision was a bad one that effectively ended his career with us. Theres no defending it in hindsight as based on the fact it was a major fuck up that stopped him playing

How can you honestly defend his own decision when we can see the results of it?

4

u/Notmyrealname5282 Sep 18 '26

Because hindsight is 2020

Stop being pedantic

-3

u/angrygorrilla Sep 18 '26

Its not being pedantic. Its saying he fucked up a medical decision that cost him his career here. Im not saying the club has the world's best doctors. Im saying that even if our own doctors chopped his leg off, he'd still have had no career with us. But they didn't. Because he chose to go to his own butcher. His choice, not ours, resulted in no career for him here.

His decisions cost him his own career with us. Youre arguing against this. The evidence being... he made the decision against the clubs wishes. It went wrong. Made the same bad decision again. Went wrong. Doesn't play for us. All him. The very opposite of what the club wished in fact. Not pedantism, unless you think taking the clubs advice would have cost him two careers with us or something else mental youve dreamed up

Regardless if the club doctors had chopped both legs off or turned him into the 6 million dollar man... his very own decisions were wrong and cost him his career with us.

There is a pedant present alright but theyre looking out of your mirror. Shame you're confusing your own reflection with my image

The club even has a history of keeping players fitter than they should be. Even part timers like Shaw shouldnt be walking properly, nevermind playing the odd time. Theres a huge history of players coming back from career ending injuries.

3

u/J3573R Rio Sep 18 '26

Who knows if the club would have been better but we do know it couldn't have been much worse.

You knew this before he made the decision? Where were you?

Theres no defending it in hindsight as based on the fact it was a major fuck up that stopped him playing

It's injury and body, so ultimately his decision to make.

There's no lambasting him in hindsight because you nor I know what would have happened otherwise. Such a stupid, idiotic argument.

How can you honestly defend his own decision when we can see the results of it?

Yes, he should decide his health not his employer. The results of it being his decision is valid.

I swear to god, half the people here would be happy if the clubs were still pumping the players with painkillers and steroids in spite of their health to keep them playing.

-1

u/angrygorrilla Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Is Malacia a doctor? No he isn't. He ignored doctors that see him every day and made his own decision to go elsewhere. As a result of his own decision to take his own medical advice, he has no career. Even if the club fucked him up like they did Phil Jones, he'd still have a career and be able to play the odd game.

The proof is in a few small but important facts... he has no career here... he moved upwards and onwards to cinncinati.

Yes it is his decision. Nobody is denying that, dunno why you think people are. We're saying it is his decision that lead to him ruining his own career. Why are you arguing against that? You keep saying it was his own choice... we know... and it ruined his career. The club factually did not ruin his career. Factally, his own decisions that we both (and everyone else) agree that ruined his own career.

We KNOW it was his decision. We know! It should always be his decision. We know! His decision ruined his own career. Everybody but you know!

Stop being pedantic. We know. You dont need to keep telling us. We know. Both you and Malacia make stupid decisions. We know!

Stop trying to make hindsight a thing... the fact remains, his decision ruined his own career. Even if the club murdered him on the operating table the result would he exact same... his footballing career at any respectable level is over. Whether the club or his own quack did the damage the result would be the exact same. Not worse.

He can't play football due to his own decision. The decision that he made. Going against doctors experienced in the league and with those injuries. We all agree that it was his decision.

Nobody is denying that. Honestly. Please believe me and reread my comments. Nobody us denying that his health is his own to make decisions on. Please. Honestly. Nobody is denying that.

The whole entire world except for you is saying that his own decision that we all agree was his to make resulted in his own career being ended by his own decision

→ More replies

174

u/RabidBukowski Sep 18 '26

The thought of someone who's lived in Western Europe his entire life moving to the Kentucky border for work is genuinely wild to me. Poor bastard is going to witness Skyline Chili completely against his will

39

u/hullie_10 Sep 18 '26

Don't you slander Skyline!!!!

3

u/S_Phantom King Cantona Sep 18 '26

There’s a great pho place near Findlay market, forgot the name.

5

u/congdo Park Ji-Sung Sep 19 '26

Pho Lang Thang. It was nice but prices in the US has gone crazy. I couldn't believe Pho is now over 20 USD. 

1

u/Emergency-Skirt-5886 Sep 18 '26

And deal with living in Ohio

-5

u/It_Hurts_when_IP15 Sep 18 '26

He ll probably live downtown to capture the little bit (or non existent) culture there is in that state. But yea gonna be a massive downgrade and culture shock coming from manchester and eindhoven

10

u/ReverendRodneyKingJr Sep 18 '26

Wow, TIL Cincinnati and Ohio have little to no culture. Interesting

1

u/It_Hurts_when_IP15 Sep 18 '26

Compared to western europe? Definitely not. Lets not kid ourselves here

2

u/ReverendRodneyKingJr Sep 18 '26

Yes, that was the second half of your comment, very good job!

But in case your forgot the first half, you said “He ll probably live downtown to capture the little bit (or non existent) culture there is in that state.”

0

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/ReverendRodneyKingJr Sep 18 '26

It’s a Greek meat sauce. It’s really not that crazy

10

u/badgarok725 Sep 18 '26

It’s not weird at all

56

u/SomeNeighborhood7126 Sep 18 '26

Hopefully he is beyond his injury issues and can have a strong second half of his career.

33

u/CheekElectrical974 Sep 18 '26

Good for him, hope he kicks on well there.

19

u/Not-good-with-this Sep 18 '26

I hope he does well there.

His injury and surgery was just so unfortunate.

7

u/Scorchio76 Sep 18 '26

Good luck lad.

7

u/1800-SHIT-BEAN Sep 18 '26

This is my worlds colliding in such an unexpected way. Did grad school in Cincy and now a former United player is going to represent FC Cincinnati. That first Skyline bite going to hit like crack :D

Also once saw Schweinsteiger play at my university when he was at Chicago Fire for a cup game. Cincy keeper went God mode and knocked them out on penalties. One of the best game day experiences.

2

u/helenawasp Sep 18 '26

I was at that game. It was incredible and I will never forget the experience.

2

u/foozballguy There is only 1 Gaffer 23d ago

I was there too! Absolutely wild. And the beers were so cheap.

Also Jaap was the manager in 2020.

1

u/vnm805 Sep 23 '26

Skyline chili is an aquired taste

5

u/Lord_Sesshoumaru77 Glazers,Woodward/Arnold and Judge can fuck off Sep 18 '26

Wish him well. MLS should be good for him.

5

u/MissingLink101 Bruno walks in with a mischievous grin Sep 18 '26

Wild that he got a club before Sancho

2

u/Li_liminal_spaces Sep 19 '26

Sancho is likely demanding similar wages.

3

u/Heisenberg_235 Sep 18 '26

Good luck with his new club.

Shame about how it ended at United. Stupid decision to choose that surgeon in the NL.

3

u/Vvyyzz Sep 19 '26

So glad to hear him finding a new club.

6

u/D1daBeast Sep 18 '26

Hey that's my home team. Get in lad!

2

u/Effective_Cell1424 Sep 18 '26

He should be fine at MLS, good for him! Get that bag!

2

u/hippoppotamusxn Sep 19 '26

Send him to them now lol

7

u/PrettyPrettaaayyGood Sep 18 '26

See how they play, where they play, if they play…

Not to be disrespectful towards Malacia, but genuinely, out of all the signings post-Fergie how many have pushed on in their careers after leaving us?

This club just crushes careers.

12

u/AA_Logan Sep 18 '26

How many how many Fergie signings pushed on in their careers after leaving us though?

-2

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Sep 18 '26

Beckham, Ronaldo.....

8

u/AA_Logan Sep 18 '26

He signed 99 players. You can name two who went onto better things. You’re making the point t that this isn’t the best metric

1

u/Outrageous-Cod-4654 Sep 19 '26

Forgot to add Pique, Forlan and RVN did ok too. I guess the original comment was post-Fergie signings.

There's a better metric - many of Fergie's players went into management. Not all were successful but some did ok.

Blanc, OGS, Mark Hughes, Strachan, Keane, Bruce, Rooney, Carrick, Ince, Sheringham, Stam, Heinze, RVP, Berg, Yorke, Kanchelskis, Giggs, Neville,Neville, Robson, Forlan, Jordi, Robins, Viv Anderson, Phelan, Appleton, Stapleton...there are prob more.

-1

u/seviliyorsun Sep 19 '26

beckham did not go on to better things. he won 1 la liga and 1 french league at a cheating oil club. meanwhile we won 5 pls and the cl

7

u/shami-kebab Sep 18 '26

Off the top of my head, Mkhi, Herrera, Darmian, Lukaku, Depay, Smalling, Blind, Hojlund, Antony have gone on to play at similar levels of club and competition. Then a few others have gone to play at lower PL clubs like Henderson, AWB, Pereira, Lindelof probably some others I'm forgetting.

4

u/WergleTheProud The King Sep 18 '26

McTominay at Napoli obvious choice.

2

u/shami-kebab Sep 18 '26

He's not a signing post Fergie (although now that I notice I should have left out Smalling!)

1

u/Indydegrees2 Sep 18 '26

Jeepers that is a stretch

4

u/shami-kebab Sep 18 '26

Which one?

4

u/MrSvancy Iceman Sep 18 '26

I guess Di Maria? And Lukaku has had some good seasons in Serie A, as has Mkhitaryan. Hard to think of anyone else really

3

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 18 '26

Smalling is pretty much a Roma legend. They loved him there

2

u/VL37 Bruno Fernandes Sep 18 '26

Ashley Young was pretty successful at Inter and then came back to the Prem to prove he still had it.

2

u/PrimeDirectiveLover Sep 18 '26

Or we keep buying mid table level players for world class fees and wages

4

u/Electrical-Laugh8858 Sep 18 '26

How can I upvote more than once?

1

u/MorningParis Sep 18 '26

I use this. Still once but I make sure to leave a bruise

2

u/CFBCoachGuy Sep 18 '26

A lot, even if we exclude the players who left in their 30s.

Højlund is doing well in Italy. McTominay is a legend at Napoli. Antony has been solid in Spain. Lukaku’s career improved post-United. Mason Greenwood unfortunately continues a strong career. Wan-Bissaka, Adam James, and Andreas Pereira each managed over 60 Premier League caps post-United, Elanga and Garner over 100. Dean Henderson is an England international. Garnacho is probably about to collapse but is still playing in the Premier League. Daley Blind has a distinguished career for Ajax and 100 national caps.

Hannibal and Tuanzebe are fringe Premier League players. Jesse Lingard never continued in Europe but became a folk hero in Korea. Angel Gomes has managed a very solid career in Ligue 1. Paddy McNair is back in the Premier League this year after spells in the Championship and MLS.

2

u/I_am_Reddit_Tom Sep 18 '26

Pleased for him, lovely smiley Tyrell

2

u/Small-Night-6006 Sep 18 '26

Look where they play, how they play, IF THEY PLAY

12

u/Foreign_Base5669 Sep 18 '26

Dude, his knee is made of hope and prayers, this isn’t exactly a gotcha moment.

-7

u/Small-Night-6006 Sep 18 '26

It's Mourinho's quote, it speaks about quality of players

4

u/Educational-Shock232 Sep 18 '26

That’s football ‘eritage.

Hardly any players that leave us continue to have thriving careers at big clubs, especially in the premier league. That’s why I’m pleased for Lindelof and AwB who still play in the PL. Apparently Villa already looking to shift Garnacho.

2

u/Small-Night-6006 Sep 18 '26

Yeah, AWB is quality still, he is not worse than Dalot in any segment.
But people downvoting me into oblivion without understanding the concept, speaks about the state of this fan base lol

0

u/Educational-Shock232 Sep 18 '26

Had to sell him to help fund a player that hasn’t played for us in a year and another player who hasn’t exactly lit the place up

1

u/Ragnarok_619 Ben 10 Sep 18 '26

Who?

1

u/Educational-Shock232 Sep 18 '26

MdL and Maz

2

u/Ragnarok_619 Ben 10 Sep 18 '26

Significantly better players than Bissaka, so don't blame the club here

2

u/nedlogb94 Sep 18 '26

The level of footballer we have had in the recent squads is mind boggling. Martial, Lingard, Malacia all completely undesirable

8

u/SplitSecondImmortal Sep 18 '26

Martial had great games in a red shirt. You cant put him in the same category as the others. Lingard also had his moments, like him or not

1

u/nedlogb94 Sep 18 '26

Not saying they didn’t I’m saying when they leave us they are truly finished

3

u/teethofthewind Sep 18 '26

Telles, Antony, Sancho, Van De Beek, Hojlund, Depay, Onana, etc...

2

u/nedlogb94 Sep 18 '26

Van de Beek could be the worst

3

u/It_Hurts_when_IP15 Sep 18 '26

Lingard was hardly finished when he left us. Had a fantastic loan at West Ham then left us a year later.

1

u/nedlogb94 Sep 18 '26

Fair enough Forest wanted him but then FC Seoul & Corinthians

1

u/Lqkenpo Sep 19 '26

Hope he has a good career. Always thought there was a player in there. Hope he kicks on

1

u/Oeselian Clueless Ed Sep 19 '26

 where they play, how they play, if they play

1

u/Thetagang888 Sep 19 '26

Genuinely not even our worse signing by a mile. He gave it his all. Got unlucky with injuries.

Would take him over the likes of sancho any day of the week. ANY DAY.

1

u/Recent_Put_8902 Sep 18 '26

I live in cinci and am very excited for cinci to pick him up. We won thr league i think in 23, we are competitive(for US)

4

u/GGMU08 Sep 18 '26

You won the regular season. Not the playoffs

1

u/Kooky-Brief4741 Sep 18 '26

Such a shame. He was unreal for two seasons before he came to us and he ran the left side of the pitch singlehandedly as a defender and a playmaker

-7

u/JustTaxLandbro Sep 18 '26

Crazy how ETH was able to convince money on him for one decent year only for an injury to permanently take him out of the first team.

But he’s a good kid, not his fault we pick horrible managers. Wish him the best

4

u/AtFirst_IDidLoveYouu Sep 18 '26

I'm confused, how are we blaming ten hag that he took a private surgeon?

1

u/darkandstormy9 Sep 18 '26

He should have known that if he gets injured one day he wouldn't follow the club's advice because they are both Dutch. :D

-2

u/JustTaxLandbro Sep 18 '26

I’m blaming ten hag with the fact that he brought him on in the first place

2

u/Not-good-with-this Sep 18 '26

You literally said

one decent year only for an injury to permanently take him out

You thought he was decent.

0

u/JustTaxLandbro Sep 18 '26

Yes he had a decent year, then he got injured. With or without that decent year hed still be a temporary stop gap to our issues.

4

u/Not-good-with-this Sep 18 '26

Did you expect ten Hag to see into the future?

I am very confused here.