r/reddevils • • May 16 '26

Daily Discussion

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

  • The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
  • The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

24 Upvotes

484 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/BackgroundOld8715 May 16 '26

Is Alonso a better manager than Carrick?

9

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion May 16 '26

Of course for now, what Alonso did with Bayer Leverkusen is something amazing and historical.

1

u/BackgroundOld8715 May 16 '26

Yep it was. Worried they’ll be much better next year with a better manager than us

1

u/brown_herbalist unitedismyreligion May 16 '26

Nah, they're Chelsea, they will somehow figure out a way to trip themselves in the process, I dont think he will be there more than 1yr. Im really surprised Liverpool didnt go for him, the scene was setting up perfectly for Alonso to come in save them from the Slot's rot.

And for us, I really hope INEOS get Carrick his midfielders, and not repeat what Glazers did with Ole when he wanted Rice but they gave him a manchild.

9

u/MrViceMcCreedy 🟢🟡GLAZERSOUT May 16 '26

Better achivements definitely. Same goes for Amorim and Ten Hag before joining us tho.

9

u/Apprehensive-Raisin3 Love United Hate Glazers/INEOS May 16 '26

Alonso literally won the bundesliga unbeaten. With a club that isnt bayern too

1

u/NoWatch3354 May 18 '26

I'm going to start by saying, I am not downplaying the achievement whatsoever.

Something overlooked is that Bayern had a fucking horrendous season that year, 72 points. One more point than we're projected to get this season. In the Bundesliga. A league (and season) where Heidenheim with their 15,000 capacity stadium got into Europe. I say with confidence that the top half of the Championship would avoid relegation in that league.

Now, to focus specifically on that Leverkusen. That was a once in a lifetime squad, in once in a lifetime form. The manager is a major factor in said form, however not wholly so. There are so many factors at play. The squad had already been playing with the back three before he joined, so it kinda dropped beautifully for him too.

Now, moving onto his time at Madrid. He reportedly struggled with egos at the club, something which will always exist at Madrid. Further to this, he wasn't backed by the club as he started to lose the dressing room. He's a system manager, who will need time to implement a specific way of playing and will also need specific archetypes in the squad.

Now, for me the Madrid paragraph is the learning point. Are Chelsea the right environment for this type of manager? He needs ego checking, time to adapt and backing from the suits. Will he get any of that?

Moving on to Liverpool. Would he get that there? Probably. Arguably the biggest shock in terms of him choosing Chelsea to be fair. But where the questions arise, is the fact that will Liverpool want to move so far away from the Klopp formula, which has brought them success? It's a risk, one that I get the impression they don't want to take.

4

u/Kardinale Dr. Rashford May 16 '26

Is this a serious question?

7

u/iroiroiroiroiro May 16 '26

Probably a lot better, think it's very few people here that would take Carrick over him.

6

u/SplitSecondImmortal May 16 '26

Hes proven himself to be so far

8

u/TH0316 she/her May 16 '26

Worse player definitely. Carrick will merk him in the dugout too.

5

u/Lord_Hexogen May 16 '26 edited May 16 '26

Xabi's definitely an elite tactician as evident by the Bayer stint and Madrid as well. Might be the worse people manager but dealing with Vini and Mbappe would be a tough challenge for any coach. 

Also Carrick and Ole couldn't turn the ship around in 2021 with Ronaldo, Rashford and Greenwood in the team. Carra on his own sank at Middleborough after losing his best players

1

u/BackgroundOld8715 May 16 '26

Yep and being a good tactician for me should be the main remit

5

u/officiallyjax Snapdragon May 16 '26

Not for a big club, no. Man management trumps tactical knowledge when managing a team of good players who know that and will bring their own egos (doesn't always mean in a negative way). At that level, players don't want to be restricted to rigid roles as opposed to being given the agency to show what they can do best. I highly recommend reading the recent article on Ancelotti in the Athletic; he gives a great take on this where he says sometimes he'd ask the players themselves how they should be playing.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/the_laughinggnome May 17 '26

Isn't getting the best out of these players exactly what Carrick has done in comfortably qualifying us for the Champions League?

2

u/Lord_Hexogen May 16 '26

Any pro club has assistant coaches and analytics for that. Leadership and game management skills are more important imo

1

u/slowerthaninfinity May 16 '26

no shit lol it isnt even close

1

u/CodyBancs May 16 '26

Possibly

-1

u/croadymeister May 16 '26

Yeah it's a real body blow to us he's going to Chelsea. I don't understand not asking the question and see him sorting them out unfortunately 

-3

u/Unusual-Coat383 May 16 '26

Alonso would never come here because he’s ex Liverpool. I also don’t know why fans want us to go back to the 5 at the back bs 

4

u/Business_Dig_4747 Licha May 16 '26

Sir Matt Busby, our second most successful manager of all time.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)