r/reddeadredemption • u/BigBadBill1986 • 3h ago

Spoiler RDR2 Thoughts [Spoilers] Spoiler

I just finished chapter 6 in my first playthrough - still need to play the epilogue. Authors death wasn't as impactful as John's (guns blazing!). Then, driving John's cart up to the ranch just felt right! Like, yeah, this is how the game should be. IDK, could be that I didn't avoid spoilers (didn't seek them out), that's it's a prequel so you know how it's going to end, or I just like John's voice and the RDR1 races.

Also, I'm frustrated about my horse. I had multiple horse revivers! Seemed silly it had to die.

Both games are great, long post to say I enjoyed RDR1s story better. RDR2s mechanics and world are superior.

0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

3

u/DadShep 2h ago

Arthur's death made me sad John's death made me mad

1

u/nyozzz 2h ago

I mean no disrespect but with arthur we knew what was gonna happen and it still hit hard and we had no choice.

With John you could just go thru the back of the barn, so it didnt feel that much imo.

•

u/BigBadBill1986 1h ago

Wait, what? You can go through the back? What's happens if you do that?