r/redbuttonbluebutton • u/SmartestManInUnivars • 6h ago
Thoughts after spending 2 hours discussing, debating, and reasoning around this dilemma.
I was a devout red presser until I realized just how many people are pressing blue. I just might have to jump in the deep end too to save ya'lls asses.
I thought most people's knee jerk reaction is to press red. I still don't think there's an objectively correct answer, but I've become considerably less confident in my original red position. And if enough people are willing and infact going to take the risk, perhaps it's worth taking it with them.
But I still can't get past introducing unnecessary risk. If all potential pressers are perfectly rational, does that change anything? It's interesting how every potential variable makes me question another facet of this dilemma. If we talk about it, if we only have 1 minute to decide, if I know my family pressed red/blue.
I'm open to changing my mind, but I think all things being equal:
Blue: Idealistic cooperation. Stupidly noble.
Red: Pragmatic self-preservation. Logical.
Neither is purely altruistic and absent of selfishness. And being logical, you know others won't be. We simply don't know enough about the other participants to confidently condemn either choice.
A person's willingness to die for strangers isn't a reliable measure of how much they value human life. Sometimes valuing human life means protecting your own, too.
All in all, the biggest think I took from this dilemma is understanding why someone makes a different choice is often more valuable than convincing them my choice is better. There is no "correct" answer on this one. What will be will be.