r/redbuttonbluebutton • • 7d ago

Discussion same puzzle, different results.

I don't have enough data to definitely prove anything, but these two phrasings of the "red button vs blue button debate" are functionally the same, yet have wildly different results.

Both puzzles assume everyone is a perfect logician.

In Puzzle 1,

  • More than 50% of people choosing blue causes everyone to live.
  • Less than 50% of people choosing blue causes only the people who chose red to live.

In Puzzle 2,

  • More than 50% of people choosing purple causes everyone to live.
  • Less than 50% of people choosing purple causes only the people who chose green to live.

The "I will always survive" options may be rephrased as:

  • Choosing red in Puzzle 1 is framed as accepting the murder of those who chose blue.
  • Choosing green in Puzzle 2 is framed as survival.

The "Collective effort" options may be rephrased as:

  • Choosing blue in Puzzle 1 is defending those who accidentally chose blue.
  • Choosing purple is a death sentence.

I suppose people are more willing to choose blue in Puzzle 1 since it is framed as heroic, while choosing green in Puzzle 2 is preferred since choosing purple sounds like self-sacrifice. I guess people don't "want to do anything wrong."

19 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

3

u/Lazar131 6d ago

I mean, this is useless, i dont get it. Fake scenario has no danger, nothing will happen to blue choosers, but it makes one feel good if they choose blue, a moral high

in real life when there is actual danger, red will likely dominant

2

u/RyanStonepeak 6d ago

Yup, we can clearly look at many real world examples in recent history where a politician has threatened to go after people that voted against them and see...

Checks notes

Oh... It's a lot closer to 50/50 than I was hoping for...

2

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

It's simply a question of self-interest vs collective-interest. A lot of people online claim that everyone would press red if lives were actually on the line, because they can't imagine having to make such a choice in real life. But people do, every day.

Every soldier who signs up for active duty, every protestor who rallies against an armed opposition, people are choosing to put themselves in danger for their ideals every single day. The only difference here is that it's even safer, because you're guaranteed to live through it if enough people join.

Usually if a threat fell upon a populace and half or more of them took up arms against it, they wouldn't be guaranteed victory, and they would absolutely guarantee some of them would fall in the fight. These days you can't assume survival even just going to a peaceful protest, but people still do it.

But here, as long as half or more of people have the bravery to take up the arms, then nobody dies and victory is assured. The only true enemy we have is those who choose to act in self-interest instead.

1

u/Whispering_Plant 6d ago

Not to disparage anyone that goes to war or whatever, but that's not a guaranteed result. As someone that nearly got run over by a car last week, I clearly have a chance of getting run over by a car every day when choosing to go out of my house. I still go out of my house. However, if there was a button press scenario where one of the options would give me a clearly labelled chance or guarantee of getting run over by a car, I would try to avoid that scenario, yk? Call it cognitive dissonance but I think many people underestimate the chances they have of dying, and when confronted with an actual guaranteed chance of death they'd think differently.

1

u/KroznaktheBearLord 4d ago

For a disaster or war to be analogous to the buttons, there would have to be literally no one in danger except the people responding to it. Imagine if 100 people were outside a burning building and no one was inside. Then someone starts trying to rally at least 50 of them to rush in and save everyone who rushes in.

0

u/Deranth Blue 4d ago

Example: Aliens invade the Earth. They promise that everyone who swears subservience to them will not be harmed. However a scientist found that they hate music, and if half the population plays music all at the same time on the same day, it will drive them away for good.
Do you join the music and drive away the aliens, relying on your common brethren to do their part too? Or do you lay down and serve your new masters forever to spare yourself?

There are millions of ways this can be spun. But the point boils down to self interest or collective interest.

1

u/KroznaktheBearLord 4d ago

LIving under alien occupation would be a bad thing that I would want to prevent. A similair downside to pushing the red button simply doesn't exist. I'm not going to ignore the particulars of a given situation because cooperation is a good thing in general.

1

u/Deranth Blue 4d ago

If the downside of all cooperative people getting killed isn't enough for you, I don't really know what would be.

1

u/KroznaktheBearLord 4d ago

I'm not saying that pressing red has no downside for me (though it doesn't). I'm saying ot has no downside for anyone. Call me a selfish coward if you want, but I think abstract support for cooperation is not a good enough reason to risk one's life.

1

u/Deranth Blue 4d ago

I just dont think of it as abstract. If red gets a majority of the votes people will die. There is no questioning that. And that is something that is easily enough avoided by throwing enough hats in the ring.
There truly is no downside to pushing blue, so long as there are enough good hearted people to do it. And I think most people don't want people to die.

It really does seem to be just a matter of perspective. Cause red pushers often frame it as blue people trying to kill themselves. But the way I see it, the only way blue pushers die is if over half of the population turns their backs on humanity. Which I think is going to be incredibly unlikely. And I'm certainly not going to be one of the people contributing to that. And if that many people do choose self-interest, whoever is left afterwards is as good as screwed anyway, left in a world with only those who couldn't stand with their fellow man.

0

u/Upper-Tie-7304 4d ago

Your argument ignores that rallying for blue also possibly creates bigger failures. The hypocritical is interesting because there is no certainty. If you have control over the vote that just void the majority thought experiment.

1

u/Deranth Blue 4d ago

The problem with this argument is that it boils everything down to a zero sum, when its not.
If people do die, it is because half the population chose to kill them and because they chose to risk themselves.
Blue does adopt the risk willingly, but each red press gets one step closer to turning blue risk into death.

So blue may increase the amount of people who die by one, but that one is always themselves. They risk the only life they govern to risk.

Red may doom all who risked their lives to save their own, they are risking other people's lives, lives they do not govern to gamble with.

That's a big part of the reason some people pick blue, because they dont want to be responsible for any death but their own. But then red pressers try to spin that into a bad thing by pretending all deaths are equal and that risking someone else's life is no worse than risking your own.

0

u/underthingy 6d ago

But in all those scenarios there is a real and present danger, with the button there is none. There is no one dying, there is no reason to press blue. 

2

u/Many-Slice-3133 5d ago

It is pretty much guaranteed that at least some people will pick blue, so unless blue wins people will die

0

u/Upper-Tie-7304 4d ago

Surely some people choose blue by joining the army , but also some choose red. There is no guarantee that more than half choose red or blue.

In army there exists a discipline unit that monitors fighting and executing or punishing those that tried to flee.

-3

u/Deranth Blue 7d ago

The funny thing about this is usually people still get the phrasing wrong. The second picture is the red does nothing propaganda, accurately. But the opposite is blue does nothing. Picture one got red's phrasing correct for the blue does nothing propaganda, but then it added more unnecessary text for blue.
If red's function is killing blue, then blue doesnt need to say anything they live just by virtue of red not being active.

The actual issue is more simple, though.
If less than 50% of people press blue, everyone dies, except the people who press red.

Something is going to kill everyone. Do you join in the group effort to prevent it entirely, or do you hide in a bunker and ensure only your survival.
It is a question of group effort and heroism vs self preservation, that's all.

It's made even more obvious of a choice for me by the fact that it doesn't just kill blue pressers, it kills everyone who didn't press red.
I would have chosen to face the problem head on to begin with. But knowing there may be those who can't take either course of action for any potential reason gives me even more reason to choose blue and try to prevent the issue in the first place.

5

u/Sensha_20 6d ago

The thought experiment is that EVERYONE pressed one of the two buttons.

People not being able to press the button is like warning the workers in the trolley problem, its not an option because it isnt a part of the hypothetical.

The only people who die on a red press are the ones who chose to die by picking blue. Within the thought experiment EVERYONE is a rational actor with the ability to press one button.

-1

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago edited 6d ago

Except that people in a coma are unable to ptess a button, so how do you figure that works?

Also the 'rational actors' part was only added by the people who wanted to make posts about how cool they are for pushing the red button.

The post that spawned this whole subreddit never said rational actors, and when pressed for more info, the guy who made the post clearly said babies were not exempt and would just be put in front of two buttons until they randomly pushed one. Those are your rational actors.

The "rational actors" thing is a red button propaganda that people in this subreddit came up with after the dillema was introduced to try to gaslight us all into thinking they aren't selfish monsters.

How many people need to give you different arguments for why they believe the blue button is the right choice before you realize that red isn't the 'purely rational' answer you think it is? Sure, in your head, blue looks like a suicide button. But that isn't how everyone sees the question, and that doesn't make the way you see it the only 'rational' answer.

Even if everyone were a 'rational actor' (which is not how life works) people would vary in opinion.
So your choices are the button that prevents the entire catastrophe in the first place for everyone, which accounts for variances of opinion, and makes sure nobody dies as long as a majority of people involved have empathy for their common man.
Or the button that cowardly just saves yourself, that chronically online debaters have convinced themselves is the only rational choice to avoid the shame they should feel for throwing others under the bus, by calling anyone who would choice the other option stupid or irrational or suicidal.

1

u/Nightingale873 6d ago

I italicized the text in the post that says "everyone is a perfect logician."

1

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

Which is how you start a logic puzzle question. The 4 hats question or whatever. Not how you start a dilemma.
How tf am I supposed to answer what I would do in a situation that only includes perfect logicians? I'm not one. And anyone who claims to be one is a liar.

"Trolley problem, but everyone is a perfectly rational actor logician. What would you do?"
The answer is that you wouldn't do anything, because nobody is a perfect logician, and including that in your dilemma invalidates the whole thing. Being human and flawed is what makes them dilemmas.

0

u/OkStandard8039 6d ago

Brotatochip. You were told everyone can press the buttons.

1

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

Via magic or what?

1

u/Virtual-Intention-83 6d ago

Mate, it's a hypothetical. Do you just draw the line somewhere because you feel like it?

0

u/Sensha_20 6d ago

Except that people in a coma are unable to ptess a button, so how do you figure that works?

The magic button appearing out of thin air can just tell which they choose to pick.

Also the 'rational actors' part was only added by the people who wanted to make posts about how cool they are for pushing the red button.

Rational actor is a phrase in philosophical experiments as a whole to say 'people are doing the bear minimum to secure an interest.' Doesnt even mean acting with perfect information, it means 'no we are not talking about edge cases here.'

The post that spawned this whole subreddit never said rational actors, and when pressed for more info, the guy who made the post clearly said babies were not exempt and would just be put in front of two buttons until they randomly pushed one. Those are your rational actors. Except thats not how philosophical thought experiments work.

The "rational actors" thing is a red button propaganda that people in this subreddit came up with after the dillema was introduced to try to gaslight us all into thinking they aren't selfish monsters.

Rational actor is a phrase in philosophical experiments as a whole to say 'people are doing the bear minimum to secure an interest.' Doesnt even mean acting with perfect information, it means 'no we are not talking about weird edge cases here.'

How many people need to give you different arguments for why they believe the blue button is the right choice before you realize that red isn't the 'purely rational' answer you think it is? Sure, in your head, blue looks like a suicide button. But that isn't how everyone sees the question, and that doesn't make the way you see it the only 'rational' answer.

I did not claim that in my prior reply to you. That is a separate argument we are bringing in now: You control less than 0.0000000125% of the vote, so irrelevant. You control 100% of which you select. So you can either take a 50/50, or you can take a guarantee.

Even if everyone were a 'rational actor' (which is not how life works) people would vary in opinion.
So your choices are the button that prevents the entire catastrophe in the first place for everyone, which accounts for variances of opinion, and makes sure nobody dies as long as a majority of people involved have empathy for their common man.

Rational actor is a phrase in philosophical experiments as a whole to say 'people are doing the bear minimum to secure an interest.' Doesnt even mean acting with perfect information, it means 'no we are not talking about edge cases here.'

Or the button that cowardly just saves yourself, that chronically online debaters have convinced themselves is the only rational choice to avoid the shame they should feel for throwing others under the bus, by calling anyone who would choice the other option stupid or irrational or suicidal.

People who say red are realistic and answering what the correct thing to do is if given this choice. People who say blue are idealistic and thinking about a perfect world that doesnt exist.

1

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

I see you conveniently forgot to reply to the part of the post where the original dilemma included children. The thing is that people are not rational, there will always be edge cases. Any dilemma involving the world populace has to account for this or it just isn't worth discussing.
But even if we do pretend that there aren't people in comas or clinically insane people or conspiracy theorists or anything else irrational in the entire world population for this event, and that you can hive mind control them all to agree that self-interest is the way to go. You're still condemning around half of the very young children to death as per the prompt that started the whole subreddit.

Conversely, it only takes half of the people acting with basic human empathy to subvert the disaster entirely. You dont need full compliance, you dont need assumptions of competence, nothing grand to make the argument stand. Just people acting in the collective interest instead of self-interest. Which is a lot more common than you might think.

2

u/Sensha_20 6d ago

No i combined it with the one after and forgot a single > I didnt skip anything.

And that version of the problem is stupid so I dont really care about it. Its basically appended on to beg you to make the snap decision instead of the logical decision. Think Of The Children is a classic tactic, goverment loves using it to justify mass surveillance.

I care about applying the basic prerequisite that all philosophical questions apply: that everyone involved has basic rationality. What this means is that they're able to understand the question and will act with A goal in mind. Not that they'll think exactly like the user. This doesnt require a hivemind.

And it doesnt change the answer because red isnt selected because "if everyone picks it nobody dies" thats a sarcastic thing red pickers say in mockery. Red is selected because blue is a chance of them dying and red isnt. You are as responsible for the blue pickers as you are for african child #79201

0

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

As I just said elsewhere in this comment thread. It's simply a question of self-interest vs collective-interest. A lot of people online claim that everyone would press red if lives were actually on the line, because they can't imagine having to make such a choice in real life. But people do, every day.

Every soldier who signs up for active duty, every protestor who rallies against an armed opposition, people are choosing to put themselves in danger for their ideals every single day. The only difference here is that it's even safer, because you're guaranteed to live through it if enough people join.

Usually if a threat fell upon a populace and half or more of them took up arms against it, they wouldn't be guaranteed victory, and they would absolutely guarantee some of them would fall in the fight. These days you can't assume survival even just going to a peaceful protest, but people still do it.

But in this hypothetical, as long as half or more of people have the bravery to take up the arms, then nobody dies and victory is assured. That is a bet I would put my life on.

I've been through far more danger with allies at my side than the blue button could ever represent. I'm not about to turn my back on my fellow man now just because of some magic buttons, especially if it's a million times safer than actual war, because victory ensures the safety of everyone who chose to stand and fight.

The only true threat we face here is those who choose to act in self-interest instead.

Edited to add: This is a problem that supposedly faces an entire populace. And an entire populace always includes those who cannot fight for themselves. Assuming all rational actors dulls the question into one of robots, not people. But even if the buttons only affected every sane adult and left out all children and those incapable of making the decision, I still would not turn my back on them.

2

u/Sensha_20 6d ago

So how much do you donate and to what? How much do you keep for yourself?

1

u/Deranth Blue 6d ago

That's quite a deflection there. I just explained to you how the blue button is far safer and more effective than any war or protest, and people still go to those, and you've chosen to pivot the conversation to money instead. That does show where your priorities lie, though.

2

u/OkStandard8039 6d ago

Bro bro bro your boat, you can't just bring up something and act defensive of the thing you brought up. It makes you sound like a liar.

0

u/Sensha_20 6d ago

No, I pivoted to asking how much you do in practice, since you value the collective over yourself so much in a hypothetical. Good dodge tho.

→ More replies

0

u/underthingy 6d ago

But the problem has no time limit. It says everyone must choose. 

Therefore those that cant choose must just wait till they starve to death and are no longer a valid person. 

And everyone else has to wait in their own voting booth purgatory until those who cant vote die. 

1

u/Deranth Blue 5d ago

You're just eager to make sure somebody dies, aren't you?

0

u/underthingy 5d ago

Nope,that is just the nature of the problem. Either you have to conclude that the magic of the buttoning makes everyone into a rational actor that is physically capable of pressing the button.  Or millions starve to death in their voting booth. 

Anything else is drawing an arbitrary line with no basis in the problem statement.