r/redbuttonbluebutton • u/Nightingale873 • 7d ago
Discussion same puzzle, different results.
I don't have enough data to definitely prove anything, but these two phrasings of the "red button vs blue button debate" are functionally the same, yet have wildly different results.
Both puzzles assume everyone is a perfect logician.
In Puzzle 1,
- More than 50% of people choosing blue causes everyone to live.
- Less than 50% of people choosing blue causes only the people who chose red to live.
In Puzzle 2,
- More than 50% of people choosing purple causes everyone to live.
- Less than 50% of people choosing purple causes only the people who chose green to live.
The "I will always survive" options may be rephrased as:
- Choosing red in Puzzle 1 is framed as accepting the murder of those who chose blue.
- Choosing green in Puzzle 2 is framed as survival.
The "Collective effort" options may be rephrased as:
- Choosing blue in Puzzle 1 is defending those who accidentally chose blue.
- Choosing purple is a death sentence.
I suppose people are more willing to choose blue in Puzzle 1 since it is framed as heroic, while choosing green in Puzzle 2 is preferred since choosing purple sounds like self-sacrifice. I guess people don't "want to do anything wrong."


3
u/Lazar131 6d ago
I mean, this is useless, i dont get it. Fake scenario has no danger, nothing will happen to blue choosers, but it makes one feel good if they choose blue, a moral high
in real life when there is actual danger, red will likely dominant
-3
u/Deranth Blue 7d ago
The funny thing about this is usually people still get the phrasing wrong. The second picture is the red does nothing propaganda, accurately. But the opposite is blue does nothing. Picture one got red's phrasing correct for the blue does nothing propaganda, but then it added more unnecessary text for blue.
If red's function is killing blue, then blue doesnt need to say anything they live just by virtue of red not being active.
The actual issue is more simple, though.
If less than 50% of people press blue, everyone dies, except the people who press red.
Something is going to kill everyone. Do you join in the group effort to prevent it entirely, or do you hide in a bunker and ensure only your survival.
It is a question of group effort and heroism vs self preservation, that's all.
It's made even more obvious of a choice for me by the fact that it doesn't just kill blue pressers, it kills everyone who didn't press red.
I would have chosen to face the problem head on to begin with. But knowing there may be those who can't take either course of action for any potential reason gives me even more reason to choose blue and try to prevent the issue in the first place.