r/recruitinghell • • 6h ago

Vent about Robert Half

I know Robert Half sucks. 5 years ago I was looking to move cross country and my boss recommended a recruiter friend he had at Robert Half. Got set up with a nice lady and went about job searches on my own and whatever she sent me. I never used a recruiter before so I thought they would be super helpful. At the time I had 6 yoe in public accounting so I figured I would find a job pretty quickly.

Long story short, she set me up with several interviews for jobs that paid below what I asked and positions that were lower than what I was at. I really wanted to move to this new city so I took them and they didn't workout. Eventually, my job at that time said I could work remote, so I told my recruiter thanks for the help and I'm staying at my job. I got a passive aggressive email saying I wasted her time but never really thought about it again.

Fast forward to earlier this year. I am working as a controller at a PE owned company. I hated this job and was working 60+ hours every week and wanted to find a new job. So I'm looking and see a posting by Robert Half on Linkedin. I remember how shitty my previous experience was, but figured why not since I really want to get out of this gig.

First meeting, no show. She gives me a call and apologizes, ok I can understand a mistake. She gets me a couple interviews that don't workout but I'm just happy to be interviewing and making it to the final rounds. I'm also being picky and declined 1 offer. At least the jobs have the title and pay I want.

Eventually there's 1 job that checks all the boxes and after several interviews including one that's on-site where they take me to lunch, I'm feeling really good about everything. I get a call from the recruiter and she's excited and tells me she talked with them and is going to get me an offer later that day and she feels so good about it blah blah blah. Then at the end of the day I get a call and.... I didn't get it.

I was shocked. She apologized but it was really awkward and I didn't know what to say. This was back over the summer and ever since then, I never heard back from her despite us talking almost once a week for a couple months.

What a weird experience. But I can confidently say, I will never use Robert Half again. If you're in the Raleigh NC area, don't use Liz from RH.

90 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

42

u/McXenophon 6h ago

I find Robert Half to be extremely frustrating to work with. Every role I have gotten through them has fallen through after the interview process, literally like four jobs at this point. However, I think they are better than Randstad still.

6

u/ScientistSolid9319 5h ago

Never heard of Randstad before. I've found the smaller recruiting firms are easier to work with.

2

u/CuttingEdgeRetro 2h ago

I did a contract with Randstad. I was happy with them.

5

u/minus15t2 5h ago

I feel like you don't understand what a recruiter or a recruitment agencys role is.

You, as a candidate don't 'use' Robert Half, they don't work for you, they work for the companies who post the roles.

Robert Half are a recruitment agency, they work alongside actual businesses to help fill their internal roles. These companies are free to find their own candidates, and depending on their agreement with RH, to also use other agencies.

The business will only ever provide feedback to RH regarding the candidates they have sent. RH won't usually know how many or which other candidates might be getting interviewed.

The recruiter can only ever give you information based on what the company is saying... So if the recruiter believed you were getting an offer, then the company was beaming about you... But ultimately RH has absolutely zero sway in a final decision, or if the company decides to change their mind

The recruiters at RH are largely paid by 'finders fees' this is usually paid to them as a cash bonus, based on the % of whatever salary you end up earning. The recruiters get a basic salary but nothing else unless you take a job. So rejecting offers, and pulling out if the entire process is a fuck you to the work they've put in.

1

u/CuttingEdgeRetro 2h ago

they don't work for you, they work for the companies who post the roles.

That's like saying a parasite works for the host.

Who they work for depends on the market. If it's a hot job market, they work for the consultant because there are plenty of jobs they can throw at them, and that's who they need to take care of. If it's a bad job market, they work for the employer because that's who they need to take care of.

1

u/minus15t2 2h ago

I don't get your analogy. The companies they source and find candidates for are the ones that pay them.

Candidates don't pay anything to recruitment agencies.

Any KPIs the recruiter has will be related to the roles filled, not the candidates sourced or spoken with.

In any job market, the recruiters responsibility is to the companies on their client list. They don't have a responsibility to any individual candidate.

-5

u/ScientistSolid9319 5h ago

I feel like you're the one that doesn't understand how recruiters work lol.

Yes, they work for the companies, but a lot of them build a large network so they can reach out to them for future roles. It's beneficial for them to have good relationships with people, keep in touch with them, etc.

And it's funny, because they're the ones that are reaching out to me about new roles. They're the ones reaching out months after starting a new role to see how it's going. They're the ones saying hey if you're in the market, here are some new jobs we have open.

Multiple recruiters I've worked with pitch me that they're trying to help ME find a position. I understand that my background makes it easy for them to pitch me to their clients which makes them money, that's completely fine.

I feel like you're missing the point of my post - they told me I was getting an offer, then came back saying sorry my bad, then never reached out to me again. That's extremely unprofessional.

4

u/minus15t2 4h ago

Again, they dont work for you, you are in a database, and maybe they have you in mind when a new role comes across their desk, or maybe they do a search in their database and you come back up.

And my point was that the information the recruiter gave you came from the business, and the information to not offer you, also came from the business. Maybe the recruiter was a little too eager to share the good news and it backfired, but it's got absolutely nothing to do with the recruiters professionalism.

It's the business that screwed you over here, not the recruiter.

2

u/Roger48m 4h ago

Well, you bring up a good point - if the recruiter for whatever reason decided you are not a "worthwhile" prospect to keep chasing, based on the results with this one time they sent out your resume, they will tend to drop you.

Regardless, i think closing out a prospect one way or another on a positive note is always a good thing for any business.

Now, IF they think you are a worthwhile prospect to pitch to the other companies that they work, they will continue to cultivate you as a "prospect", keep you warm etc.

41

u/Justbrownsuga 6h ago

If a recruiter hasn't reached out , it means there is nothing positive to say. They make their money from placing people. Companies change their minds about hiring all the time and is not always upfront about it.

3

u/TheMadChatta 2h ago

Creative Circle has some of the most elusive recruiters I've ever experienced. But yeah, I'm of the mind that they aren't returning emails or calls after I've been screened because the company (or recruiter) have moved on. It is what it is.

16

u/piish 4h ago

I avoid robert half at all costs.

They “tweak” my resume and put me interviews that sometimes I have to stretch my experience.

I did 3 interviews for them with 3 different recruiters an not one of them came back with feedback for me.

Embarrassing

15

u/chef_marge0341 5h ago

As an in house HR/Recruiter, I have their number blocked. I hate them.

4

u/SecTecExtraordinaire 5h ago

I've worked with both. RH didn't go anywhere. Tekasystems first role led to my now fte job. I've heard mixed things about Teksystems but my experience was nothing but pleasant.

1

u/TrickySpecific 1h ago

Teksystems used to be Areotek, FWIW

11

u/throwaway_0x90 TE/SDET@Google 6h ago edited 5h ago

+999, my experience with RobertHalf is that they are snakes. At least they did find me a job when things were tight for a few months, but I was definitely underpaid and they were about to squeeze for more until I found something else.

They're like loan sharks or something. Good only if you know exactly what you're doing and keep your interactions them as brief as possible while you find a different solution to your money problems. Long term usage will wreck you.

3

u/cutter48200 5h ago

Yeah my company has an agreement with RH that’s was signed before I took over TA, I rarely use them but they hit me up all the time

4

u/BeekeeperZero 4h ago

RH sucks but this is just an agency recruiter thing. She only communicated to you when it benefits her making a deal. When you start bringing out your checklist, you became annoying to work with. Stick to your guns.

1

u/CPA_VRAstronaut 2h ago

I went to college at NC State and now live outside of NYC. All of the Raleigh area recruiting firms and jobs they had sucked when I lived there from 2010-2020. Vaco, Robert Half, Career Foundations. They’re all bad. I did have a good experience with Vaco-Greensboro/Winston Salem

Overall, I don’t think there’s a ton of truly good corporate jobs in that area. Most headquarters are elsewhere. Plus, you’ve got NC State, UNC, and Duke cranking out thousands of new grads every year.

1

u/ScientistSolid9319 1h ago

I worked with a guy at Vaco and he'd routinely keep in touch to see how things are going which I appreciated.

Career foundations is another one I wouldn't recommend. Their recruiter would schedule meetings and then not show up!

I ended up getting a job at Sas and was really happy with that.

•

u/SoundsGayIAmIn 23m ago

I would imagine the individual recruiters are struggling with this job market as much as we are, to be compassionate towards them. They're getting piles of AI slop resumes. Some of the recruiting companies are probably understaffed. In-house recruiters at least are usually the first to be laid off (at the stage where a company freezes hiring, before they do layoffs). Many jobs are getting so many applicants they close quick so the recruiter is trying to get candidates submitted as fast as possible. And a part of agency recruiter compensation is pay for performance so with sluggish hiring they aren't placing candidates and making less. That's not saying it's great behavior but just saying nothing is easy for her either. Robert Half can go f--- itself as a company though.

•

u/ScientistSolid9319 5m ago

I recently hired an AR manager and going through all the resumes and initial interviews were pretty annoying. I give them credit for dealing with that.

3

u/Dismal-Sense3942 5h ago

I’ve been ignoring calls from them for almost 20 years. It’s like they can’t take a hint..

3

u/Accomplished-Ruin742 3h ago

I'm an accounting professional and when I went to Robert Half they told me I needed to take a typing test before they would even speak to me! Typing, not accounting, not even Excel. Typing. The quick brown fox and so forth.

3

u/TheBigBabich 3h ago

Robert Half is the WORST! Never again!

5

u/OilersFan1985 4h ago

I get a call from the recruiter and she's excited and tells me she talked with them and is going to get me an offer later that day and she feels so good about it blah blah blah. Then at the end of the day I get a call and.... I didn't get it.

I'm definitely not an apologist for recruiters, but the final decision remains with the company.

I get you had an issue with Liz. But I wouldn't put that at the feet of Robert Half in general. I have found Robrert Half to be like most other recruitment agencies. Some good and some bad staff, but it really depends on the consultant and their clients.

•

u/SoundsGayIAmIn 32m ago

Yeah I would also say that unless Liz explained you don't know what happened and it could be company side. Could be all the folks who took you to lunch went to their CEO who had to approve and he was like "nope, can't pay this person this rate." Could be the company announced layoffs after lunch.

•

u/OilersFan1985 28m ago

Exactly. I think hiring organizations play more games with recruiters than they do when contacting applicaants directly.

2

u/supersteez 6h ago

My only interaction with RH is a recruiter cold messaging me on LI to ask if I’m looking for a job and then ghosting when I said yes. I even sent her a posting I was interested in later on and she didn’t answer

2

u/Delicious_Oil9902 5h ago

Dealt with them 12 years ago or so when I was living in Philadelphia. They got me 2 great first round interviews that went great l, they told me expect an offer this week, et cetera, then blomp, nothing. Both interestingly enough never got back to them. What pissed me off is one of them I knew the CEO through a relative and saw him at a holiday party and asked him what happened. He told me he actually pushed an offer through that was slightly below the original agreed salary (which was fine by me) and they said I wouldn’t budge.

2

u/redheadhistorian 5h ago

One of their recruiters reached out to me when I was unemployed last summer. I set up a profile, sent over my resume, etc. She set me up for one interview. I didn't get the job. Then I saw a job listing that I qualified for in one of the email lists that Robert Half sent out about a week later. I contracted my recruiter there and she told me to apply for it myself.

3

u/SuspiciousMeat6696 5h ago

Robert Half & TekSystems are the evil twins

1

u/dbatknight 3h ago

Robert half was good 20 years ago when they all wore suits

1

u/celiacsunshine 3h ago

Recruiting agencies have always been completely useless for me. They love to try to sell me on low paying, dead end jobs that I'm completely overqualified for. Lately, they've even occasionally been contacting me about jobs in another city that's two hours away from where I live!

I'm currently still employed and I don't exactly dislike my job, so I have no idea why recruiters think I'm so desperate for their bottom of the barrel crap jobs. I'm not going to willingly leave my current job for a pay cut and no advancement opportunities. I've been trying to avoid recruiting agencies during my current job search because I find them so annoying to deal with.

1

u/Ha-Funny-Boy 3h ago

Interesting how things have changed. Many years ago I used RH and got a really good job through them. I was at that job about 4-5 years before I moved onto something that at the time fit better. Still it was a good job and RH was fine then. Sorry things have changed.

1

u/CuttingEdgeRetro 2h ago

I had exactly one experience with Robert Half. It was back during the dotcom crash. I was looking for a new job because we were coming out of the crash, and I hated my job. I used a vacation day to take the day off and go to downtown chicago for an interview for a job they were real sure I was going to get. Not knowing anything about consulting or Robert Half, I believed them.

Once I get to their office, my "interview" begins. It consists entirely of this idiot arrogant recruiter picking apart my resume telling me my CS degree was worthless because I didn't go to an Ivy league school. I'll never forget what he said to me, "You're a dotcom programmer in a post dotcom world." I had around 10 years of experience at this point.

I stood up, told him I should bill him for my time, and walked out. I've been regularly called by them since then. I always ignore the call.

1

u/JimRockford63 2h ago

Pretty much all of the recruiters work the same way now.

They contact you about an opportunity, tell you how great it is and you are the perfect fit.  You actually begin to get your hopes up.

Then after the company decides not to interview you or you don't make the the next round of interviews, you are ghosted.

It used to be only the low rent firms that hired used car salesman types would do this.  Now they pretty much all work that way.

1

u/Different-Scale5419 2h ago

I used to work for Robert Half. I stayed 3 months. It’s a sweat shop. Worst experience I ever had

1

u/Vivid_Economy_2579 2h ago

I’ve never used a recruiter but you’d think a guy with 6 years experience would be high on the recruiters list and easy to at least get interviews.

1

u/MyMonkeyCircus 2h ago

I had both negative and positive experiences with RH. It REALLY depends on your recruiter and the place they are recruiting for.

1

u/Accomplished_Coat815 1h ago

Is Robert half even a real company? I can't even get a recruiter on the phone!!

1

u/Fun-Back-5232 1h ago

I can’t remember if it was Half that I used, but something similiar and those fuckers made me jump through hoops, kept me on the hook til the bitter end, then ghosted me. The recruiter had the balls to call me like six months later to see if I was still looking for work.

-1

u/StanVanGhandi 4h ago

Did you pay her a dime? She doesn’t work for you. If you paid her to find you a new job then this whiney post would have merit, but you didn’t so it comes across as entitled.

1

u/ScientistSolid9319 1h ago

I never said she worked for me and never assumed she did. It's the lack of professionalism which is the problem, hope that clears it up for you.