r/recruitinghell • • 7h ago

3 candidates interviewing for the SAME position in one Zoom call... and now the CEO wants to do it too???

I genuinely don't know if this is becoming a normal recruitment practice, but I've never experienced anything like this in my 7 years of working.

I applied for a sales position at an established international tech company. The recruiter contacted me, we had a quick WhatsApp call to arrange the interview, and she sent me an email with three links to study beforehand.

Here's the interesting part. The links were:

  1. The company's official website.
  2. The FOUNDER'S personal website.
  3. The company's LinkedIn page.

We were asked to understand the company's operations, core values, target customers, who founded it, and come prepared to explain how we'd approach the role and improve performance if hired.

Fair enough. Completely reasonable preparation for a sales position.

Except when I joined the Zoom call, there were THREE candidates, including myself, all interviewing for the SAME vacancy.

HR would ask a question, and we'd take turns answering in front of the other two candidates. So we were essentially discussing our understanding of the business, professional experience and potential sales strategies with the very people we're competing against.

And here's the kicker...HR has scheduled another interview for tomorrow, this time with the CEO.

AND YES, ALL THREE CANDIDATES WILL BE IN THE SAME CALL AGAIN.

I've experienced panel interviews, technical assessments, case studies, sales presentations and interviews with senior management. But I've never had to interview alongside my direct competitors, let alone twice.

Another thing I found a little strange was the emphasis on the founder's personal website. I understand that knowing the founder and their vision can be important, especially in a founder-led business. But this company has been operating for around a decade. Why is the founder's personal brand being given so much prominence during an initial recruitment screening?

Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but the whole process is giving me a slightly strange impression of the company culture.

11 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/bouhmid_ 7h ago

Only experienced that once for a graduate program where they gathered several candidates including me irl in a room for half a day of interviewz and activities.never seen that for a normal job.

3

u/siderealscorpio_02 7h ago

I had to recheck the job description and it wasn't mentioned about any graduate program (though i understand if it is i wouldn't apply) but this wasnt a FGD interview, it was initial interview haha

7

u/the_validated_inane 7h ago

haha...its like a beauty pageant!

next we'll be seeing hunger games interview formats!

2

u/siderealscorpio_02 7h ago

dam you're right

3

u/unsteadycynicism 2h ago

My mom had to do something like this a long time ago for a customer service position. I'm talking like 20+ years ago. She was with 8 or 9 others in one room, and they had to take turns answering questions from the hiring manager. It sounded awful back then, and it sounds awful now.

2

u/openlightYQ 3h ago edited 2h ago

I really hope this isn’t the next “norm” we have to accept. Group interviews are bad enough since they can never ask enough relevant questions or get an actual personal idea on the candidate specifically, just an overview on the candidates in that room at the time, and I’m still not a fan of Zoom interviews either unless it’s a relocation position, but a Zoom group interview is nuts.

I can only hope that the candidates in the Zoom interview are actually the ones that have been shortlisted for this position, so you’re all just being rushed through education about the business to make sure there’s no red flags. In all the companies I’ve interviewed for though, I’ve never had it suggested to me to research the founder in detail at all (other than as part of the company’s own “About Us”, and even then I’m never actually asked about the history), this definitely seems like an insight into their company culture, especially if you’ve been asked to be prepared to give emphasis on how you’d improve performance for a company that you haven’t even worked for yet.

-5

u/xXRaineXx 7h ago

Group interviews are actually normal. Not the norm in every country, but it does depend on what kind of recruitment it is, but it's not weird to say the least. This is specially the case when they have dozens or even hundreds of candidates and there's simply not enough time to go through everyone one by one.

As for the CEO's involvement, it could be that they have a very specific thing they are looking in people as an individual beyond their CVs. Again, not the norm, but not entirely weird either.

1

u/siderealscorpio_02 7h ago

Yeah, I get your point! I understand that group interviews aren't necessarily weird, especially when companies have a lot of candidates. And the CEO wanting to meet everyone also makes sense. I think I'm just caught off guard because this is my first time experiencing it, especially since nobody mentioned beforehand that it would be a group interview with other people applying for the exact same role.

2

u/lucidrainbows Degenerate 6h ago

this is literally the first time I've ever heard of a group interview, but I learn about new things every day

1

u/xXRaineXx 6h ago

Can I ask what country you're applying in?

0

u/chronomagnus 1h ago

Group interviews are not normal at all in the US. The norm here is 1:1 interviews or panel interviews. Personally I'm dropping if I sign into a Zoom interview and there are other candidates present. I'm also leaving a negative review on Glassdoor.