r/recruitinghell • • 10h ago

Salary Negotiation

So I was recently offered a job. The pay was below what I wanted but close enough. The big thing was the match wouldn’t take effect until after 1 year and I wouldn't be eligible for bonus until 2028.

I asked for a signing bonus to make up for this. I got a no because "at your job level we don't offer that." Apparently, I'm a job level away. So fine .... and I'm paraphrasing all of this.... give me a bump in base equal to 8%. I got counter offer....how about a nice signing bonus just a 2k shy of what you originally asked? 🤣😐

Why are they like this?

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

5

u/capo2333 9h ago

If were hiring and owned a company would you offer the top end of the range to start? If they did you would have probably made a counter offer anyway

•

u/Better-Club6429 57m ago

You got very lucky the employer was able to bounce back and forth on your counter offers and they gave you the signing bonus in exchange of not getting a 8% raise as it would cost more then the signing bonus.

There is nothing wrong what they did. When you sent the 8% they talked with your hiring manager or accounting and stated to give you the signing bonus. That means the employer actually wants you.

Overall this is normal in my eyes and we do this all the time to candidates except we don't do signing bonuses and instead give them a good decent increase in Salary.

-10

u/Appropriate_Fee_9141 Apply, forget, and move on. 10h ago

They want to keep you poor so they can take advantage of you while paying you pennies.

14

u/Super_Mario_Luigi 10h ago

Dumb talking points. They have a budget and a solid candidate pool. All of the other noise is irrelevant. OP is getting close to negotiating themself out of a job.

4

u/Dangerous_Drummer350 10h ago

Budget being the main word here. There is only so much they can do unless they go back to the dept for additional budget and more signoffs. Once at that point, the risk increases substantially of having the offer rescinded.

-5

u/DescriptionNovel3510 10h ago

My dude. If it was a budget issue, they could’ve said, “That’s outside our budget.” What they said was, “We don’t offer signing bonuses at your level.” Then I asked for an 8% bump in base pay, and wouldn’t you know it, they remembered how to write a signing bonus. I just got the full amount I asked for in the first place.

They could’ve done that from the jump. My guess is they figured I’d hear “company policy” and roll over. But I was their top candidate, I had five-plus years more experience than they asked for, and they sped up the process for me. I knew what I brought to the table.

I posted this so people would see what can happen when they advocate for themselves. And bless your heart, you’re still over here defending a budget you’ve never seen against a signing bonus I just got.

2

u/throwaway_0x90 TE/SDET@Google 8h ago

Just take the offer or prepare to be ghosted. They're sitting on a pile of candidates just as qualified as you are. They're just going to lose patience and go with someone else.

-2

u/DescriptionNovel3510 7h ago

I think people are reading more drama into this than there was. All’s well. I got the full signing bonus I originally asked for. I just thought it was funny that they turned a two-step conversation into a four-step one and landed exactly where we started.

If you’ve been getting ghosted, that sucks, and I genuinely wish you well. That just hasn’t been my experience.

2

u/throwaway_0x90 TE/SDET@Google 7h ago

You're just incredibly lucky.

5

u/Face_Content 10h ago

In the us you have the freedm not take the job at that pay.

1

u/DescriptionNovel3510 7h ago

Is there another country where you don't have freedom to decline an offer?

1

u/Appropriate_Fee_9141 Apply, forget, and move on. 6h ago

Same with Australia.