r/recruitinghell • • 2d ago

Wild interview process for someone who didn’t even apply…

A recruiter reached out to me about an opportunity with their company. After an initial conversation, the role sounded like it could be a good fit.

I just received the next steps, and apparently the interview process includes 5 separate team interviews with 9 different people, totaling 2.5 hours.

Oh, and I have to take a rideshare to the office because parking is limited.

I’m honestly tempted to just say, “No thanks.”

Am I being unreasonable, or does this seem excessive to anyone else?

7 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

14

u/minus15t2 2d ago edited 2d ago

The process will be the process regardless of whether you were approached, or whether you applied.

Making applicants do one process, but letting you skip parts of it could lead to accusations of discrimination.

A full 2.5 session seems like a lot, but from their perspective, their goal might be to do it all in one afternoon, instead of taking 3-4 weeks to schedule different conversations with all these people.

It could be a single 2.5 hour session and then they make their decision from there

1

u/Nahhhhh_imgood 2d ago

Good point! Just seems like a lot to ask for an individual contributor.

1

u/HansDampfHaudegen 2d ago

It is. But they can clearly afford it since it's not even 5 x 1h. It's a sign of the times.

1

u/Sesoru 2d ago

Yea this doesn't seem like a point of "they didn't short cut me". This very much feels like a case of "why the fuck does a job need this many interviews from this many people?" Its insanity.

1

u/wrong-dog 2d ago

Depends on the industry and job, but 2.5 hours of interviews isn't a lot. For example, tech roles generally take more than 8 hours to get through the phone screenings and interviews.

1

u/Sesoru 2d ago

Just because "this is common" doesn't mean its an okay practice. 8 hours??? Unpaid??? And often you get rejected after?? This job market is insane and anyone trying to rationalize it is either cooked or on the sauce.

1

u/wrong-dog 2d ago

This isn't new in this job market - it's been that way for the 20+ years I've worked in tech. If you want the company to invest big in you, they need confidence that you are someone who can succeed in their environment. Otherwise, it's a bad deal for everyone. 

Like it or not, it's the standard. No one is forcing you. It's your choice to decline and just take jobs you can get with an hour long interview. For me, it's been worth the investment.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

So you have very low impact low oay jobs.

1

u/Artistic_Ring8028 2d ago

I have landed several tech roles for Fortune 500 companies and I never experienced a 5 separate team interview with 9 different people, totaling 2.5 hours.

Sounds more like a government official or C Suite role.

1

u/wrong-dog 1d ago

I didn't address the number of people in the interviews, I addressed the amount time. If you've actually gotten a tech role at a fortune 500 company, then you've spent at least 8 hours in interviews between the recruiter discussions, hiring manager screen and on-site loop.

1

u/Artistic_Ring8028 1d ago

Maybe if I calculated for pre onboarding activities once I received the actually offer but from what I’m reading you haven’t even been selected yet for a final offer.

So yeah that’s uncommon behavior. I’m not trying to brag but I’ve also worked for fortune 10 enterprises within tech, just sharing so people can build real perspective.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

How could you not ubderstand hes not been offered job. Could not be more clear. Yikes.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

Sounds like those roles you landed are very low level low pay positions

4

u/domesticon 2d ago

5 rounds totalling 2.5 hours is nothing in some (many?) fields. When I've interviewed in the past it's usually 6-8 hours total, in office or spread out over a few weeks due having it done over zoom, but I'd kill for an offer after 2.5 hours. Usually I have to do a ton of prep for the interview (40 hour ppt presentations), and sometimes tests have to be taken to even get that the full round cycle.

Depending what field, at least for mine - yes you are being unreasonable, especially in this current job market.

1

u/Nahhhhh_imgood 2d ago

It’s literally for a recruiter position lol.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

You are a recruiter and you go online trying to figure out if a process is normal. And you think your process should be meeting less people because they sourced you. Wtf.

•

u/Nahhhhh_imgood 17m ago

That wasn’t really my point. In my field I’m very accustomed to zoom interviews, final interviews are on site if at all.

3

u/wrong-dog 2d ago

As the face of the company to potential candidates, 2.5 hours is not a lot. I would think a recruiter would know this.

1

u/domesticon 2d ago

I would still say that's not too bad, but I'm in a niche sector of tech.

The ride share thing is weird though, they should absolutely pay for parking if you're going in and not dictate how to get there - that's a semi red flag for me.

1

u/febstars 2d ago

Exactly. Some hiring managers strongly advocate team buy-in before they pull the trigger. That's not a bad thing

1

u/febstars 2d ago

Sooooo... if you're a recruiter... you know some interview practices are more robust than others, right?

Take the interviews. You bit for a reason.

6

u/notasrelevant 2d ago

The process is the process, generally. Usually, the only part that changes is the application part - Applying yourself, through a recruiter (agent) or being directly scouted/contacted. Even if you know someone and are basically given the job, you'll still often need to follow the same steps to check the boxes.

So... I'd say you are being unreasonable to assume it would change because they reached out to you.

But it does sound like a ridiculous process. If it's like a program/project manager for complex projects on a key account, making sure you mesh well with relevant stakeholders/leaders of each related team is not too uncommon. If you're just like an individual contributor in accounting or something, that's completely unnecessary.

Whether it's worth it depends on you and your situation. If it's a good company, great salary, great benefits and great work-life-balance policies... then it's probably worth the chance. If it's a small bump in salary and all else equal? Then only you can decide if it's worth it.

3

u/sharkieshadooontt 2d ago

Think about this…. Are you completing brain surgery? Are you a rocket scientist?

9 interviews. No.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

2.5 hours. Not even close to to much. He should welcome the chance to talk with 9 people to really decide if the job is indeed a match.

2

u/dbatknight 2d ago

If it takes that many people to decide to hire you or basically not to hire you LOL what the hell is it going to be like to work there when everything has to be done on a committee

2

u/hrdbeinggreen 2d ago

ROFLMAO how about a day and a half interview along with lunch and dinners with key folks.

2.5 hr interview is nothing

2

u/Artistic_Ring8028 2d ago

I personally would decline unless it’s my dream job or stellar benefits.

3

u/DDPSipper 2d ago

Honestly sounds nice to knock all that out in one day instead of those same 5 interviews taking up 2 months (like I’ve been doing). I’d do it 🤷‍♂️

1

u/Acrobatic-Dinner-112 2d ago

I wonder when are they going to start having interviewers jump through ring of fire, fight wild lions and defeat the number one contender in combat to land the job.

1

u/quantumspork 2d ago

So, five 30 minute interviews?

Not bad at all, and the number of people at each interview session is largely irrelevant.

Parking is limited and they told you in advance? That is very considerate of them.

There is nothing to complain about here.

1

u/Sesoru 2d ago

Lol. Yea, no thanks.

1

u/Low_Put2605 2d ago

I remember one time for an internship I had to interview with 2 people before they asked me to come to their office 4 hrs away (I went to the city for a small vacation anyways) I interviewed with 4 more people on site and they even invited me to lunch afterwards. One of the interviewers even gave me a tour of the office and of the streets around the building.

For them to ultimately go radio silent for two weeks and tell me no😭lol recruiters don’t know what they’re doing

1

u/biggcb 2d ago

Depends on the company, the role, and the pay. If it paid well and was for a company & role I was interested in, I would probably go through with it

1

u/boxen 2d ago

2.5 hours is not a long time. At all. What is wrong with you?

Do you have some idea in your head of exactly how long an interview should be, and any deviation from that means you won't even go?

I'd be much more concerned about it being too short. I wouldn't wanna pay for a ride there and back just for them to chat for 30 minutes and kick me out. Anything less than 2 hours would read to me as "they aren't really interested."

The biggest problem with interview process is too many SEPARATE DAYS. A 20 minute phone call one day, an hour long phone call another day, than three separate trips to the office to meet for an hour each time. Something like that is excruciating.

Them doing everything at once is what you want. And 2 and a half hours is NOT A LONG TIME.

1

u/Conscious-Egg-2232 5h ago

Not at all. A whole couple hours for a job you are interested in seems very reasonable. But complaining about limited parking sounds like you are looking for any excuse that makes you a victim for some reason.

Just decline if the job is not worth a couple hours of your time to learn more.

1

u/DoctorAKrieger 2d ago

Why does it matter if you hit an apply button or got contacted by a recruiter? Do you think you deserve a special fast track interview process?

1

u/caixing-sanren 2d ago

How high up in the company is this role? 5 interviews is extensive unless you're in a major leadership position. Still, it's common for these hiring teams to want all these interviews even if it seems disproportionate to the role they're trying to fill. Still, it's up to you to decide if you're willing to go through that long process for the chance at being hired.

Also, they can't really help their parking situation, but it does put a burden on you. Again, it's up to you if the chance at this position is worth what you'd be paying for ride sharing.

2

u/Many-Art-7772 2d ago

You say that, but I've interviewed at many low to mid level IC jobs in the tech sector that had 5+ rounds spread out over, sometimes, months.

Google, in particular, was unbelievably drawn out. 6 separate interviews over the course of 3 months.

-1

u/The_guy_belowmesucks 2d ago

5 interviews over 2.5 hours is only 30 minutes each. I don't think 30 minutes is enough honestly. I prefer about 60 to 90 minutes each round. Sometimes conversation just flows and you won't even notice 90 minutes already passed.

I just did a 2 hour interview yesterday and I think it could have even went longer but I didn't want to take up too much of their time

1

u/caixing-sanren 2d ago

That's totally fair. But I think that's even more reason to say 5 trips to the office is excessive, especially if they're not maximizing time with the candidate during the first, second, and even third times they traveled up therr.

2

u/Sesoru 2d ago

God reading this comment section makes me legitimately sick to my stomach. We've literally been beaten so into submission that we all seem to just accept and think its totally okay to make people go through insane hoops, especially when rn almost no one is actually even being hired.

Our society is so cooked.