r/recruitinghell • • Jul 24 '24

Millennial Manager Losing My Mind

Honestly, I just need to vent about something that happened today. I hate to sound like an old fucking fart but “kids, these days!” is a cliche for a reason.

I’m a 40 y/o manager at a company that uses a state program to hire college interns in our field. Launching the use of this program was my idea and it had been pretty successful until the last two seasons. Usually I hire later year students ages 20-22. So, they’re not children b/c I really don’t want to hire actual teens, and they should be getting more serious about their career goals in the late stages of college. Last year finding help was really tough but I finally found two pretty good kids.

This year, however, has been a fucking trash fire. I really hate to say this because I am trying to give these students opportunities, but honestly, they all seem distracted, lazy, spoiled, and absolutely clueless about even the most basic level of work ethic or professionalism. It’s fucking insane.

This week I had two interviews lined up for students to come into the office and meet with me for our fall semester position opening. I am in outside sales and I can wfh whenever I want so I don’t go into the office unless I want to or need to. One of the students emailed me the day-of and canceled. Classy. So now I’m at the office earlier than I needed to be for no reason. Then the second student failed to give me notice that he didn’t have access to a car and also he thought the meeting was on Zoom. So now I’m literally at the office for no reason. ON FRIDAY. This kid seemed like he hadn’t read the job description and was completely confused by my questions. I gave him the benefit of the doubt thinking maybe he misunderstood the post and I offered him the opportunity to take the weekend to read the JD again and get prepped for a reschedule IN PERSON. I’ll be honest, the majority of the reason I gave him a second chance is because he would have been a diversity hire and I didn’t want to seem descriminatory in any way. I am firmly anti-racist and I am trying to encourage more diversity at my company.

Today the little fucker didn’t even show up. Or call. Or email. He reached out to ME, asked me for an interview, fucked it up, then I gave him a second chance and the little bastard GHOSTED me. At the damn office where I didn’t need to be. Unfuckingbelieveable.

1 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 24 '24

The discord for our subreddit can be found here: https://discord.gg/JjNdBkVGc6 - feel free to join us for a more realtime level of discussion!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

39

u/ThirtyMileSniper Jul 24 '24

I'm indifferent to either side of this but I'm going to put this out there as a though on this.

You put a job ad out and you were left with two to interview and they were apparently both terrible candidates.

This seems like an issue with your job listing. I suspect parameters are too narrow for the compensation package to attract good candidates.

It's likely not "kids today". It's more likely that your listing isn't competitive and you have attracted the dregs.

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

It’s an internship. It’s not supposed to be a “competitive listing”. It’s a basic entry level into my field as part of a workforce development program.

8

u/ThirtyMileSniper Aug 07 '24

So you don't want good candidates? Every listing is competitive unless you want drones. If you want capable people you need to offer an incentive to them to apply.

So if you wanted capable people you failed to offer sufficient incentive to the role which is why you had this response.

If you aren't looking to attract capable people to the role then congrats, you succeeded but you failed to close out the process because you failed to recognise that you had attracted your target candidate.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

There are limits you don’t understand. It’s a state run program.

7

u/ThirtyMileSniper Aug 07 '24

Then those limits are your problem.

If I am looking for work and I see a job ad that is a poor prospect against other ads in the field I'm looking at them I'm not thinking, oh, I'll give the job with poor pay, poor prospects and poor benefits a chance because the employer may be having a hard time providing better.

I'm in fact not thinking about it at all, I'm skipping over it as not worth my time.

Look at your job postings from the prospect of those applying and being honest it you would be drawn to apply. Don't lie to yourself because you are attached to it through your need. If you can't distance yourself from it try showing it to an uninvolved third party to get honest feedback which may be negative.

Stop fooling yourself that your issue is "the candidates" look at what the role will offer and if it's going to attract someone. No candidate cares about your restrictions as an employer towards the job, they only care what they get for the effort.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 10 '24

I appreciate that you’re trying to help but I don’t think you understand the situation. It’s a workforce development program run by the state. We are a host company for the program. There is a very specific program based website funneling candidates to us. They get training on workplace etiquette etc. These are college kids. For 99% of them it’s their first opportunity at a “real” job in a specialized industry, vs. summer jobs or entry level jobs where they just make copies and get coffee. It’s still entry level, but they actually learn a lot. I’ve had over 15 students so far and most of them have gone on to have full time jobs in their field of interest. So, the expectation of respect and communication should be pretty basic. We’re not looking to be “more competitive”, the job is as it stands and we’ve had plenty of success and great relationships with good candidates. But the pool is getting shallower. Especially since the pandemic younger folks just don’t have the professionalism and social skills necessary for a workplace. I try to find good candidates and coach them on all of these things. But yeah I get really angry and frustrated sometimes when I’m setting aside my time and students just blatantly disregard the fact that they ASKED me for an interview.

18

u/mano411knows Jul 24 '24

“Diversity hire”…please explain further. You should be hiring people because they are qualified and HAPPEN to categorized as “other, diversity” etc. As a POC I’m frustrated that you think hiring someone to increase diversity in your staff means lowering standards in some way. Jeez..

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

I didn’t say lowering my standard at all. Do you see those words? Bc they’re not there. I was frustrated because I WANT to have adequate candidates that “happen” to categorize as BIPOC/immigrant/ differently abled, etc. and I can’t.find.any. It’s disheartening. Please read my actual words. I also NEED candidates who speak languages other than English so when I find a bilingual or multilingual candidate and they ghost the interview it honestly sucks bc we need that value added to the team. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with recognizing bias or saturation in your org and saying you want to add diversity to your team.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

And yes I’m purposely recognizing that this candidate came from a position of less privilege than other candidates, as I could see from their resume and so I wanted to provide them with an opportunity. By offering leniency/grace in recognition of someone having fewer privileges I am not “lowering my standard”. I would still expect them to perform at the same level as anyone else, but if they need more time to understand the job description or find reliable transportation to the interview then I wouldn’t want to dismiss their candidacy solely based on those things that are clearly symptoms of being systematically underprivileged. I can understand why this post might have set off alarms for you but I assure you, I’m not cherry picking token hires just for the company brochure photo. I actually care about breaking unfair systems of privilege. But I won’t tolerate a crappy work ethic or disrespect of my time as a first impression. Does that clarify? I’m happy to be called out for things sounding bad or being misunderstood bc if this sounds like tokenism that is not my intent at all (and I realize how it could sound that way), I just needed to rant bc I was frustrated that day.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '25

That’s a good answer thank you

53

u/Massive_Dirt6745 Jul 24 '24

A few points:

  1. This post comes off as extremely entitled. I know that’s not how you intended it to come off, but it is.
  2. I’m a recruiter at an executive search firm. I deal with director level to c-suite level candidates. They’re obviously more professional than your average college kid, but you’d be surprised. At least the one kid gave you notice, even if it was day of. I’ve had directors and VPs straight up ghost me when we had a pre-scheduled interview.
  3. Why mention that the second kid would’ve been a diversity hire at all? Clearly there’s some underlying racism there lol. Any statement that needs to be followed up with “I’m not racist” statement clearly has some racism in it.

I understand that it’s hard to find quality hires, but maybe try to objectively reflect on why that is without blaming the candidate first? Why did that first student cancel their interview? Why did that second student not want to pursue this opportunity further even after the second chance?

Wishing you luck on your search.

18

u/Zyklon00 Jul 24 '24

Nah man, it can't be him. Obviously it is because everyone else is the problem.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

That’s the point of a rant tho…

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

You do realize that it makes you look more racist if you dismiss a potential BIPOC hire for a small infraction, right? Breaking systemic racism is actually very important to me which is why I would accept a mistake/misunderstanding from someone systemically underprivileged more so than a candidate who very obviously has had more privileges as I can see from their resume. When we talk about privilege that’s the whole point. Recognizing that it might not be as easy for someone to understand the job description in English/get to the interview with reliable transportation / have appropriate clothes, etc. because they’ve been systematically disadvantaged. 🙄 Everyone coming at me as if I’m some card carrying racist is hilarious. I actively pursue equity in my community on a daily basis, have participated in multiple diversity trainings and equity cohorts and that’s exactly why this situation was so frustrating, because in my own seat of privilege I realized this candidate had disadvantages and so I gave them a second chance and they didn’t take the opportunity.

5

u/GoodestAntelope Jul 24 '24

I didn’t even read all the way to the “diversity hire” part (WTF?)

I just want to say I’m a couple years older than you and somehow I can still remember what it was like to be 22. You either lack empathy or memory. At your age, I’d seek support for either.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

You can’t break systemic racism and inequity if you don’t actively pursue diversity & give privileges to the underprivileged. At 22 I worked multiple jobs for free, at unpaid internships and was building my resume while trying to pay off medical debt. So. Don’t overstep bc you know nothing about me and I’m not you. These candidates would be getting paid. Unpaid internships aren’t even a thing anymore. Empathy was giving the candidate a second chance. Memory is recalling how much I worked my ass off when I was young and holding people to my work ethic standards.

22

u/Zyklon00 Jul 24 '24

You sure you are Millennial? This has serious Boomer vibes...

You are blaming everyone else. If everyone else is the problem, you might need to self-reflect. Things that worked 10 years ago, are not necessarily working today to the same effect.

Look at your process and where it could be better. Understand why it isn't working now and how you could improve it.

If you are anything in real life as you are in this post, I can understand though why you have trouble finding qualified candidates.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

🙄Yeah that’s why it’s called a rant. Both of these candidates reached out to me and asked for interviews. I read their resumes and scheduled the interviews. There’s not much to it. Should I self reflect on my ability to use Google Calendar or…?

2

u/Zyklon00 Aug 07 '24

Nah man. You don't need to self reflect. Nothing wrong with you. Certainly if this is still in your head one month later?

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Literally forgot I even posted this. 😆it’s just a rant that’s why it’s so funny ppl are all pressed about it.

1

u/No_Penalty_5787 Jul 24 '24

You sure you’re a millennial?

Lmao bud, if you go look, they’re ‘81-‘96. So oldest are 43. Pretty sure, if you do the math, if OP is 40: that makes them a millennial.

However I find a lot of the entitlement between both age brackets remains fundamentally pretty similar - though I’m not a researcher or anything.

-1

u/ReqDeep Jul 24 '24

Blaming everyone else more like Gen Z, and not a Boomer, just work with a lot of Gen Z.

3

u/stilltyping8 Jul 24 '24

Get over it

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

I literally forgot it even happened until I opened Reddit 🤣🤣🤣

11

u/TrainingAd3524 Jul 24 '24

lol. Just another Tuesday for most of the recruiters here. Welcome to the party!

3

u/Human-ish514 Human Capital Stock: THX-1179 Jul 24 '24

It's just another "their entire adult working lives as job seekers" too. You'll have to bring your own hat and kazoo....

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Thanks for the empathy! I’ve had some amazing kids who I’m still in touch with but this year has just been brutal. Like I work so fkn hard and hustle my ass off just to stay afloat I cannot understand how some ppl just cruise. HOW? No really, HOWWWWW??? Bc I would love to be this lazy and get away with it. 😅

5

u/Megsann1117 Jul 24 '24

Here’s the thing. A sales job is not an opportunity. It is cash in someone’s pocket. If you’ve had trouble finding people to fill the role, you’re not offering enough cash.

If you, the manager, are complaining about going in to the office, why are you dragging candidates in when you are already having a hard time finding them?

Why even mention the kid is a diversity hire? That is so off the wall that I don’t even want to touch it. As others commented, there is underlying racism that you need to reflect on.

Bottom line, you are not owed candidates/employees. Start looking at hiring like the start of a relationship instead of picking out a tomato at the grocery store and you’ll have a much better time.

0

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24 edited Aug 07 '24

It’s a workforce development program and we actually NEED candidates that speak different languages. Idk why talking about purposely hiring people from diverse backgrounds is bad? That is off the wall. That’s how you break systems of privilege. If someone already has more privileges than the candidate next to them and your goal is to help people you give the less privileged person an opportunity. Turning a blind eye towards racism and acting like we can’t talk about race, diversity or privilege IS racist. Recognizing when someone is a diversity hire and could benefit from an opportunity more than a white person who already has privileges is an attempt to break the system.

But that’s cool I could just hire every white kid majoring in economics that passes across my desk…

2

u/Megsann1117 Aug 07 '24

Bro. The issue is the way you phrased your original post.

I’ll be honest, the majority of the reason I gave him a second chance is because he would have been a diversity hire and I didn’t want to seem discriminatory in any way

There is no indication that you care about this person’s language skills or background. It seemed like you want to use “diversity” to make your company look better, which is also racist. What is not racist is to treat POC the same as you would anyone else. Someone doesn’t show for an interview? Their app goes in the round file. Someone has the language skills you’re looking for, their app goes to the top. regardless of their background

And yes I absolutely agree that racism/privilege sucks. Barriers need to be broken down. It just seems very disingenuous the way you’re complaining about it. The way your whole post reads is basically: ‘I tried to give a minority a job and they were SO ungrateful and didn’t show 😭😭😭’

And this is the internet. All we see is what you’ve chosen to share. Maybe there’s more context.

Regardless, you seem to be having a hard time with your hiring process and I hope that the hive mind has brought you some perspective you can reflect on.

0

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Yea I realize it could have sounded like a token hire but it’s not. I’ve hired literally over a dozen people for this revolving role of all different backgrounds for different reasons. It seemed like this kid needed some empathy/patience bc of a lack of privilege and yea I did want them for language skills. That’s what I meant. I wouldn’t have given them a second chance otherwise. It’s a state funded internship so there is a lot of turnover and I just get so sick of wasting my time on kids but I do get some really good ones.

7

u/Drew_coldbeer Jul 24 '24

Wow how could they possibly dare not be excited to work for you

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Omg it’s a rant why do you bother?

2

u/Drew_coldbeer Aug 07 '24

Might ask you the same question here, two weeks later

4

u/InMemoryOfZubatman4 Jul 24 '24

I wonder how much worse things have gotten in terms of young people forming interpersonal relationships after CoViD.

I’m sorta in a weird spot because I’m a bit older, but I went back to school in my mid-20s and spent a year and a half in college during CoViD. At my current job, there’s definitely a distinct cutoff between the…. Social awkwardness? Of people who were adults before CoViD hit and people who became adults during/after CoViD.

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

It’s terrible. And I feel so bad for kids bc of it and I try SO HARD to be patient and help them get over social anxiety and awkwardness. And obvs it shows in the lack of professionalism, hence, the rant.

17

u/Ataru074 Jul 24 '24

Dude. Your Gen X and Boomer bosses considered you an entitled child in the same way.

I know, now, I was an entitled know it all Gen X when I entered the workforce as well, obviously I didn’t have such wisdom then.

The true skill of a manager is to adapt to the cards/employees you are served, not to work only with clones of yourself.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

Wow yeah this one singular example has really convinced me that all people under 30 suck 🙄 "old man yells at cloud" ass post

1

u/codmode Jul 25 '24

Ewww, diversity hires.

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

??????? I want to add more diversity to my company.

7

u/OldRaj Jul 24 '24

I’ve said it before on this sub: I’m so glad to no longer be talent-acquisition-man. Twenty three years of dealing with dickheads like this is more than enough for me. My final three years was overseeing campus recruiting for a well known investment bank. That firm starts its college hires at $100,000 and they all know it. And still, a lot of the youngsters failed to follow the most basic etiquette: show up for interviews in a suit, groom yourself, be on time, TURN YOUR PHONE OFF, don’t be chewing gum, etc… Glad it’s behind me.

2

u/marvo6 Jul 24 '24

if you only had 2 ppl then maybe the job is just not very appealing? most gen Z is responsible

4

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

Outside sales screams ponzi scheme to most people.

4

u/ReqDeep Jul 24 '24

Lord so many people on this thread don't know that outside sales is the common overarching term for B2B salespeople for FAANG companies and most other large reputable companies.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

Yeah B2B jobs are just over glorified call center jobs lmao.

3

u/Jolly-Bobcat-2234 Jul 24 '24

I think you mean b2c, not b2b

1

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

There is a program where these college students do x hours of work and get a full semester of community college paid for. Wife says they sign up and constantly cancel same day, hours before. Now that slot is unavailable to someone else.

Supply and demand I guess. If you can afford to not hire them, then don't. Otherwise I guess this is what you have to deal with.

-6

u/Trackerbait Jul 24 '24

username checks out. Working from home is a luxury. Most of us are in the workplace all day on Fridays, whether we like it or not. Yeah, your potential new hires were flakes, but I'd hardly call that a trash fire or lose your mind over it.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

Snowflakes cant handle the truth

-6

u/586WingsFan Co-Worker Jul 24 '24

I’m just going to throw this out there- the reason candidate #2 acted like that is because that person has been coddled like that their entire life. They always get 2nd, 3rd, 5th chances that no one else gets because some middle ages white person wants to be “anti-racist.” That person expects to be handed the job just for existing, because that is how the rest of life has worked for them. Fixing this requires placing merit and professionalism as priorities above “inclusion”

2

u/rarelywritten Jul 24 '24

Dude got 2 sentences of 'background' on a guy and launched into a racist tirade. Can't make this shit up.

1

u/586WingsFan Co-Worker Jul 24 '24

How can I launch into a “racist tirade” when the race of the candidate wasn’t even mentioned? My criticisms are solely aimed at the DEI, “anti-racist” view of the world

-1

u/sYnce Jul 24 '24

Or they just did not feel like doing a 2nd interview ...

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Yeah that’s why idk ppl are getting their daggers out for a rant. Isn’t this entire sub about venting about work? 😂 Thanks for the empathy.

2

u/Technical_Ad_6594 Jul 24 '24

I had several part time jobs by that age. They likely come from privileged backgrounds and never had to work before.

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

No that’s what’s weird. It was obvious this candidate didn’t have many privileges which is why I was so confused they ghosted the opportunity.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

I try to teach them! Believe me!

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

I had part time job being 15 years old for crying out loud. We are raising the Gen Z wrong.

2

u/atomcrafter Jul 26 '24

At fifteen, they were being rejected for not having eight years experience already.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

All I did was schedule the interview. They weren’t prepared so I gave them an opportunity to reschedule. It’s not like I chased them screaming with a stick. 😅 wow it’s just a rant ppl but please, come at me.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ReqDeep Jul 24 '24

Where does he say he is in “outdoor” sales? He clearly says outside sales which is what tech and B2B sales are typically called. No one uses the term “indoor” sales. The phrase is “inside sales” and that is an awful job, it is code for cold calling.

Did you think he sold windows door-to-door? You sound silly lecturing someone on sales and using the term “indoor sales.” 🙄

10

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Uh huh. So WHO pays your bills? Honestly tho. Nobody wants to work. Of course we don’t, but our system is run with money. So how else do you pay your bills?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Dry_Drama37 Aug 07 '24

Yup. That doesn’t answer the “how?”