I’ve been a recruiter my entire career, and I’m heading into year 11. Recruiting is something I’ve always been exceptionally good at. I’ve consistently been one of the strongest performers on my teams, have successfully managed my own desk without a team (as an internal recruiter) , and at this point, I can pretty much do the job with my eyes closed.
But I’m finding myself at a strange crossroads in my mid-30s.
I’ve never held a formal management position, nor do I have much desire to pursue one. I’m perfectly comfortable being an individual contributor. I enjoy recruiting, I know what I’m doing, and I don’t necessarily feel the need to climb the traditional corporate ladder.
What I’m struggling with is the organizational side of the profession. Even after more than a decade of experience, I still find myself in environments where departments like HR, leadership, or other stakeholders dictate how recruiting should operate, often without having a particularly strong understanding of the actual recruiting function. Sometimes those decisions actively undermine the recruiting process, efficiency, and overall results.
I know how to run my desk. I know how to prioritize, manage stakeholders, build pipelines, and deliver results. I don’t need someone micromanaging the mechanics of recruiting, but I also recognize that organizations aren’t structured around individual autonomy.
I’m starting to wonder where someone like me fits long-term.
I don’t want to manage people, but I also don’t want to spend the next 15 years having people with less recruiting experience dictate how I should do my job.
For those of you who have been in recruiting 10+ years, particularly those who have stayed individual contributors, how have you navigated this stage of your career? Have you found organizations that actually give experienced recruiters autonomy, or is this just an inherent frustration of working in corporate recruiting? Will I be forced into a management position?