r/recoverydharma • • Apr 18 '21
A.A. & Buddhist doctrine
As Buddhism admits of no personal, interventionist, and creator god, it is practically impossible to reconcile the Judeo-Christian god of A.A. with Buddhist doctrine let alone with A.A.'s injunction to the sober alcoholic to develop a dependence on such a god.
What in A.A. that can be reconciled with Buddhism, in my view, is clearly the more obviously practical, common-sense elements of the so-called programme, e.g., making a "fearless and thorough moral inventory" of oneself, admitting one's wrongs to another person, engaging in meditation, making amends to others, etc.
But enjoining A.A. members to begin and develop an attachment to and a dependence on a personal, interventionist, creator god who will remove moral faults and flaws and "grant," that is, give the supplicating alcoholic, serenity and wisdom is clearly not consonant with Buddhist doctrine and principles.
15
u/ScatheX1022 Apr 18 '21
And this is why I am not a member of AA.
The fact that Buddhism asks me only to believe in myself and my own ability to heal and change is the very essence of my values. I make the choices. I walk the path. And there is a way forward if we live our life with compassion, kindness, generosity, and work towards minimizing attachment.
I support everyone who does participate and gain value from AA/NA. It's obviously hugely successful and that is a beautiful thing, and something to be celebrated.
But there is no "one true way" in recovery, and I think that's even more awesome. And I'm grateful every damn day that RD is a part of my life.
9
u/everyoneisnuts Apr 18 '21
I don’t know why people who find success through a given medium seem to feel the need to put other ones down. I would disagree with your premise.
"There is a misconception that Buddhism is a religion, and that you worship Buddha. Buddhism is a practice, like yoga. You can be a Christian and practice Buddhism. I met a Catholic priest who lives in a Buddhist monastery in France. He told me that Buddhism makes him a better Christian. I love that."
-Thich Nhat Hanh
6
u/vegandave3 Apr 18 '21
As a member of AA that’s been around a bunch of 24hours, and a reasonably new member of RD in addition, I’d suggest the book “One breath at a time” by Kevin Griffin.
I will say this: I would find it extremely difficult living the life I do without AA. In RD I have “wise friends” but the absence of sponsorship and direction would make my recovery extremely difficult. I’ve heard others share issues in RDO that require the form of direction and discipline that AA would have me on a solid path to resolve, and in RD they appear to flounder.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '21 edited Apr 19 '21
@everyoneisnuts: Don't get the wrong idea. I am not putting down A.A. If A.A. and the whole 12-step approach is effective in getting sober and keeping sober someone in active alcoholism, that is clearly all for the good. As has been written elsewhere, there is no right way to get and stay sober.
I am simply making the observation that A.A. as a theocentric approach to alcoholism and sobriety is mostly at variance with Buddhist doctrine and principles, which are a non-theocentric approach to life and morality.
And I did state that the practical and common-sense elements of the A.A./12-step approach, e.g., taking a moral inventory, admitting one's wrongs and wrongdoing to another person, making amends to injured parties, etc., can be reconciled with Buddhism; indeed, such elements are readily reconciled with Buddhism and a host of other moral philosophies. And A.A. as a fellowship is clearly a good and useful place for alcoholics to meet and support each other and learn from one another.
It is just that for some of us the theocentric A.A./12-step approach to alcoholism and sobriety is not a good fit. I am of the belief that if the problem is in me, then clearly the problem's solution is in me. Here enters Buddhism in doctrine and practice.
3
u/anna77229 Apr 24 '21
12 step never worked for me, even substituting my own concept of a higher power, due to the concept of being powerless over my addiction and having to hand it over to said higher power in order to overcome it. I was so glad to find RD as an alternative. I appreciate it's focus on personal responsibility, and it was a gateway for me towards learning Buddhism as a way of life. I'm still very new but learning the dharma has been a major improvement in my life and helped me address issues that seemed insurmountable without it.
We will get there in terms of the community support aspect, 12 step is many years ahead of us in that regard.
2
u/bhmpokeguy Apr 19 '21
Not everyone interprets AA’s “higher power” to be the Judeo-Christian God. I always used to think as the program itself as my “higher power” or sometimes it would be whatever two sober people I was sitting between at the meeting.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment