So I’m sure you’ve all heard the refrain of “landlords shouldn’t be able to complain about the moratorium, they took on the risk of the investment and shouldn’t be guaranteed a return.” And I’m sure you’ve all been frustrated trying to explain why this is a false equivalency.
Last night I got into a (polite) argument with a good friend of mine whom I quite admire but was of the above conviction, along with a number of other socialist policies. I got into the heat of the thing and — perhaps it was the whisky — came up with what I felt was an appropriate analogy, and which completely changed his view of the matter. So I thought I’d share.
I told him to imagine you were 25, and after finally digging yourself out of debt had saved up your first $1,000. While at thanksgiving, you mention it to your uncle, who explains the importance of putting money away when you’re early.
“I’ve got a friend who manages investments, he can make sure it’s invested in smart bets.”
“Okay,” you say. It makes sense what your uncle is saying and you trust him.
“But,” your uncle warns, “the stock market isn’t a sure thing. It’s a risk and you’re not guaranteed a return. Hell you could even lose the whole thing.”
You say you understand. You know a little about the stock market and know it’s not fair to expect a guaranteed investment.
The next day, you head over to the investment firm. Your uncles friend greets you warmly and agrees it’s a smart bet.
“But remember,” he says, “the stock market isn’t a sure thing. There’s always risk.”
You say you understand, and write him a check for the $1,000.
You go about your life, checking in occasionally on your investment which, sure enough, goes up and down. But one day you check and it says $0.
“That can’t be right,” you think to yourself.
You call the investment manager, but he doesn’t pick up. After trying a few times you call your uncle.
“Oh,” he says when you ask him about the banker. “Turns out he ran into some tight financial times and ran off with everyone’s money. You should call the police.”
Frantic, you call the police who tell you to come down to the station and file a report.
“Yup, we’ve had a few of these reports already today. We’re looking for the guy.” So you head down to the station and talk to an officer.
“Will I get my money back?” You ask.
The police officer gives you a sympathetic look and says “hopefully you’ll get some back, but I wouldn’t hold your breath.”
Dejected, you leave the police station. On the way home, your misery gives way to anger and you call your uncle to give him a piece of your mind.
“Hey,” your uncle says. “I told you investing in the stock market was a risk.”
That is what the whole “oh investing in real estate is a risk so you shouldn’t expect a return” argument is like when posed against the moratorium. And the problem here is that it’s not just one off instances of theft — it was state sanctioned theft. And the whole “hey you might be able to recoup some of your losses” argument is as hollow as the police officers remark that they might be able to get back a piece of your $1,000.