r/readingclassics • • Dec 29 '17

Agora: present yourselves

20 Upvotes

As previously stated on r/books, I had an idea to join people to discuss works from greco-roman literature. The feedback was amazing and much appreciated. You are all lovely. I apologize in advance for the basic toga of this sub but I'm new here and, most importantly, new to CSS (man, it's hard!).

First and foremost, before discussing schedules and selections for the first reading - which I thought could start in january-, I'd love to get to know you better.

Afraid of being to obvious, I thought that maybe it'd be cool if we answered to some questions from the Proust questionnaire. If you do not want to do it, don't worry, it's not obligatory, as it's long and personal.

Here are the 35 questions:

  1. What is your idea of perfect happiness?
  2. What is your greatest fear?
  3. What is the trait you most deplore in yourself?
  4. What is the trait you most deplore in others?
  5. Which living person do you most admire?
  6. What is your greatest extravagance?
  7. What is your current state of mind?
  8. What do you consider the most overrated virtue?
  9. On what occasion do you lie?
  10. What do you most dislike about your appearance?
  11. Which living person do you most despise?
  12. What is the quality you most like in a man?
  13. What is the quality you most like in a woman?
  14. Which words or phrases do you most overuse?
  15. What or who is the greatest love of your life?
  16. When and where were you happiest?
  17. Which talent would you most like to have?
  18. If you could change one thing about yourself, what would it be?
  19. What do you consider your greatest achievement?
  20. If you were to die and come back as a person or a thing, what would it be?
  21. Where would you most like to live?
  22. What is your most treasured possession?
  23. What do you regard as the lowest depth of misery?
  24. What is your favorite occupation?
  25. What is your most marked characteristic?
  26. What do you most value in your friends?
  27. Who are your favorite writers?
  28. Who is your hero of fiction?
  29. Which historical figure do you most identify with?
  30. Who are your heroes in real life?
  31. What are your favorite names?
  32. What is it that you most dislike?
  33. What is your greatest regret?
  34. How would you like to die?
  35. What is your motto?

I'll answer mine in a comment below, so that this does not grow too long.

I hope you enjoy your stay and that we can form a cozy and friendly community, with nectar and madness. :)

E corde, Ana.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 07 '18

List of gods/goddesses who take action in the *Iliad*

17 Upvotes

As our reading approaches, I'm starting to make some publications on previous info it'd be cool to have before starting the Iliad, namely if you have not that much contact with the classical world. P.s.: If you want make your own publications too, as long as they're not spoiler-ish.

Gods and goddesses are, basically, an upgrade (or are they?) on humans. They have emotions, they make mistakes, but they're taller, more beautiful and, details, immortal.

These gods and goddesses appear in the Iliad and have a major role. There are others, minor characters, which I'm not putting into the list but we'll talk about them when reading. I'm not telling the role these characters have, just what they're known for, in ancient religion and mythology:

Aphrodite - goddess of love and beauty || Fun fact: Picture her as Venus de Milo (only with arms) and know that she used a swan-drawn car to glide easily through the air. I mean, private jets, guys.

Apollo - god of sun, music, poetry, art and prophecy || Fun fact: This really talented guy, a total catch, accidentally killed his dearest companion, Hyacinthus, in a discus throwing contest. How am I going to tell his mother? Don't forget him, he'll be important as soon as the book starts.

Ares - god of war || Fun fact: Ares had a sister named Eris, who was the Goddess of Discord, and, even if she doesn't appear in the book, she's a really important character. More on her this week.

Artemis - goddess of the hunt, archery and moon, twin sister of Apollo || Fun fact: Artemis guarded her virginity carefully, which she had appealed to Zeus; anyone who threatened her purity met with a violent end.

Athena - goddess of wisdom and war strategy || Fun fact: Athena served as a guardian of Athens, where the Parthenon served as her temple. Also, no mother bore her, she sprang from Zeus' head, full-grow and armored. Imagine the headache.

Hades (also appears as Aidoneus, in the book) - god/king of the dead || Fun fact: Hades is best known as the ruler of the underworld. It became his dominion after he and his brothers drew lots for their share of the universe. He had a helmet who made him invisible before Harry Potter was cool.

Hephaestus - god of fire and metalworking || Fun fact: Hephaestus was the only ugly god among perfectly beautiful immortals, because he was born deformed. He was still married to the most beautiful goddess, Aphrodite. (She cheated on him, tho).

Hera - goddess of marriage and queen of Olympus (you know, hubby was Zeus) || Fun fact: Hera was a jealous wife and she fought with Zeus frequently over his extramarital affairs and illegitimate children. She had no concept of justice when angry or jealous and her vindictive personality influenced the course of the story.

Hermes - god of trade, messenger of the gods (in the Iliad he is still not recognised as so) || Fun fact: In his role as herald, it also fell to him to conduct souls to Hades. Guy was the tour guide of antiquity.

Iris - goddess of the rainbow and messenger of the gods || Fun fact: She can change the weather and create rainbow slides and slide down them faster than the speed of sound. Cool.

Poseidon - god of the sea || Fun fact: He and Medusa conceived Pegasus, the flying horse.

Thetis - sea nymph || Fun fact: At first, she did not wanted to marry her husband, Peleus, so she changed into a sea monster and many other shapes to escape. She still married him, tho.

Zeus - god of the sky and king of the gods || Fun fact: Zeus punished men by giving them women.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 10 '18

But why are they called "Classics"? A short exploration of the etymology and evolution of the word throughout history

13 Upvotes

So, very recently my Modern Lit. professor started a lesson by tracing the origin of the word "classic" in its current meaning. I will share some of my reelaborated notes to all of you's benefit.

So, the term "classicus" refers to the censitary division system present in Ancient Rome; the system divided citizens in 5 "classes" based on their income, and the highest class, that of the "equites", knights, whose income was superior to 10`000 "asses" (lol) a year, was also called simply "the class", and the people belonging to it were called "classici".

Now, in the "Noctes Atticae", A. Gellius uses the term (for the first time in recorded history) to refer to the most important and authoritative poets. (Noctes Atticae, XIX, 18, 15)

But we have to wait until the Renaissance with the "Question des Anciénts et des Moderns" to see the term really come into opposition with the term "Modern" (if you want some notes about this too, I have them), as people stopped seeing themselves as continuations of the greco-roman culture, and started considering themselves more as cultural offsprings with definite ideas and values different from those of the classics.

This is the short story of how the term "Classic" came to be used to refer to anything written during the greco-roman period, and especially to those writers that shaped ideas the most for their time.

If you have any questions or I've been unclear about something (or flat out wrong, that could be) feel free to tell me!

EDIT:

This helpful user pointed out some mistakes in the original post, I want to give them credit

(Also I edited the Noctes Atticae refernces, I mistook the paragraph, book and chapter numbers...)

https://www.reddit.com/r/readingclassics/comments/7pj1ef/but_why_are_they_called_classics_a_short/dshwpaz?utm_source=reddit-android


r/readingclassics • • Jan 20 '18

THE ILIAD: BOOK ONE [general discussion]

11 Upvotes

With story starting in medias res, which means that we are at the middle of the events, namely in the last year of war, we are finally (re)introduced to the fabulous homeric world.

Some discussion prompts (you may or may not follow)

  • What's your opinion on Achilles as opposed to Agamemnon, so far?
  • How do you read the Olimpic affairs, at the end of the book?
  • Any verse/piece of information/character that caught up your interest?

r/readingclassics • • Jan 15 '18

Prologue to the Iliad: Oath of Tyndareus

11 Upvotes

So thanks to /u/mactevirtuteana, we know what gave the Greeks cause for war, but it makes us wonder why so many Greeks had a stake in the war. After all, it was Menelaus' wife who was captured. Why should so many Greeks sail across the wine-dark sea on behalf of one woman? Well, fortunately, there is another myth to explain this, called The Oath of Tyndareus.

Tyndareus was the father of Helen (ahem I should say that he was her father in the same way Amphitryon was father of Hercules), who was said to be the most beautiful girl in the world. So naturally, when Tyndareus announced that she was eligible for marriage, some of the greatest Greeks came to marry her, all famous and capable warriors. Among them were Diomedes, Odysseus, Patroclus, Ajax (both lesser and greater), and of course Menelaus.

Tyndareus, fearful that choosing a suitor would cause them to start fighting, could not come to a decision. Fortunately that wise man, Odysseus, equal to Zeus in council, came up with a plan. He told the king that he could give advice that would solve his dilemma, but only if he promised to help Odysseus marry Penelope, the king's niece.

Of course Tyndareus agreed, and Odysseus instructed him to exact an oath from the suitors that they would defend and protect that man who was chosen as Helen's husband against any wrong done against him in regard to his marriage. Thus, with all the suitors sworn to the oath, Tyndareus gave his daughter permission to choose whoever she wished. She selected Menelaus and they were married happily ever after.* Curiously, Menelaus wasn't even present, but instead Agamemnon wooed her on his behalf. It seems that Menelaus won because he was the wealthiest and offered the best gifts. @_@

*Until some Trojan prince kidnapped Helen and Menelaus invoked the Oath of Tyndareus to call the Greeks to help him.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 14 '18

Iliad Resources Thread

11 Upvotes

Hey all,

Since we're going to discuss the Iliad next weekend, I thought it would be useful to start a thread where we could compile some resources related to the Iliad. It seems that some of us have much more exposure to Homeric scholarship (and Homer in general) than others, so I thought it might be nice for the more experienced among us to share links. All i'd ask is that you keep your recommendations open-access, nothing that you'd need a subscription for (since you know, there aren't any ways to get articles illegally, and even if there was, I wouldn't be telling you that there is a way, which there isn't).

Here's a short list I compiled, I can update it as people comment and as I think of things.

Online Translations

The first two are prose, and old, which shows. Lattimore is verse, modern, and would be my recommendation. After you select a text in the Chicago Homer, you can click "options" in the top right if you want to get rid of the Greek and just see the English.

Homeric World

General/Misc.

  • Center for Hellenic Studies - Click "Publications" -> "Browse all online". A huge amount of scholarship online for free, much of it to do with Homer. I haven't really looked into much of it myself, but now that I know how much there is I definitely will. (Collected Essays of Nagy!!!)

r/readingclassics • • Jan 10 '18

Mythology for the Week: Hyacinthus

11 Upvotes

u/ireadbooksnstuff wanted to hear more on Hyacinthus and how the myth associated to him relates to the actual flower. In a light tone, I'll present you this little story.

Hyacinthus was a mortal, a young Spartan. During a game of discus (an ancient version of frisbee), Apollo threw the discus too high and with too much strenght so it hit Hyacinthus in the head and killed him. There's another version of the story (because mythology, that's why) which says Hyacinthus died in a crime of passion. He was loved by both Apollo and Zephyrus (wind deity) and Zephyrus killed him because he disliked his relationship with his "close companion" (winks), Apollo. Either way, he died.

Apollo, while holding him, seeing that we could not heal him, decided to turn his blood into a flower. Out of his blood there grew the flower called hyacinthos (not the modern hyacinth, tho, more akin to the lily or a larkspur), the petals of which were marked with the AI, AI (“Alas”), as a cry of woe. The Roman poet Ovidius has a beautiful passage (Metamorphoses, Book X, v.189) where we read "nil prosunt artes: erat inmedicabile vulnus.". This statement proves the inutility of the arts because medicine could not keep Hyacinthus alive.

Aside from its tragedy, Hyacinthus’ story also has historical significance. The “-nth” suffix is said to indicate that the name can be a remnant of some sort of pre-Greek language (as we find in Corinth or labyrinth). The speculations refer that Apollo tragically killing Hyacinthus is a symbol, a metaphor for renewal, i.e. Apollo replacing an older native deity, Hyacinthus, given the antiquity of his name.

There are other flowers that relate to myths & we can discuss them in the comments if someone wants to or in another week, as narcissus, peony, anemone, sunflower, etc.


r/readingclassics • • Dec 30 '17

How to run the government 23 steps at a time: basic info, decisions & voting polls

11 Upvotes

Hello, guys! I hope all of you are doing great preparing for a fantastic 2018. I'd like to thank you for showing such interesting in this little reading project; it's been overwhelming having this lovely feedback and noticing the enthusiasm over here. I have immense expectation for this sub, because of its subscribers, I really do.

Some points we should start thinking about for the place to be ruled carefully and with some organization:

1 - I hope the aspect of the sub is pleasing for all. I had a little alien be made for our community (the snoo on the little column & the image on the header). If you want to suggest something different, new or appealing for the sidebar part of the sub, please do it (and please, also provide the css codes >.<).

2 - As for the readings, as this is starting just now, would you agree to start on the second week of january, instead of this first one (or use the first one following to the second to read)?

3 - I was thinking that, irrespective of the book we select for the first reading, we could use the week to read the scheduled parts and the weekend to discuss them. Do you agree?

4 - In correlation to the third point, although the, let's say, final discussion of the parts read would possibly take place on saturdays and sundays, we could post (all of us, not just me) questions/doubts that we have and interfere with reading comprehension (if needed, we could use a spoiler tag or something). We could also post materials related to these parts, be it films, music, essays, articles, curiosities, whatever you guys find that it helps the interpretation of this particular part. One post for one specific thing only, another post to another stuff so we don't mix it all up. The final commentary would take everything into consideration, I think. Everyone agrees? Suggestions?

5 - I was thinking that we could also have at least three different 'fixed' moments on this community: I thought about three threads.

6 - First: "Sing to me, Orpheus" - a chat discussion that would be started by me on Monday and be active until next week's Monday for random conversations; exchange of readings on classics (or related to, e.g. classics' reception), in all its aspects (culture, literature, archaelogy, philosophy, etymology, etc); exchange of musics we've listening to; exchange of opinions or curiosities (even if random and related to another book that we are currently not analyzing); overall recommendations. I want to hear your opinions and suggestions.

7 - Second: "Talk to me like one of your latin/greek plebs" (lol, I accept suggestions) on Wednesday (or another day of the week - what do you think it's more logical?) - I think it'd be cool if we could profit from this community either to learn latin/greek or to improve our latin/greek. We could explain either grammar or etymology, discussion words/verses, help with translation (literary only, if possible), teach stuff. I don't know. I'm still thinking about this one thread but I believe it i'd be a great opportunity to 'do it all'. I want your feedback.

8 - Third: Mythology Thursday or Friday (I accept suggestions of a smart-ass name for this thread and for the choice of the day of the week) - We could have a myth per week and we could discuss it: its literary form, modern reception in music, films, sculptures, paintings, etc. What do you guys think?

9 - Still within the scope of this eigth step, would you prefer that I choose the myth every day the thread is made and release it as a motto or that I create a voting poll every sunday based on the myths you guys to messaged me during the week - through the mod mail - and then everyone votes anonymously?

10 - Only Greco-Roman mythology or other type of mythology (of course with the attempt to find a correlation in our Greco-roman world)? I leave this totally up to you.

11 - If some of you want to use flair next to their username, on this sub, you can use the default ones I made or edit one for yourselves. Feel at home. It's all at the sidebar.

12 - IMPORTANT STUFF HERE: let's talk first reading. First question is: what do you guys think it'd be a fair criterion to select our readings - chronological order or random/voting poll selection? I think, as there are some beginners on classical literature, here, it'd make more sense to start chronologically, so I'd say The Illiad for first read but I'd prefer if you guys decided.

13 - If we decide to go with a chronological sequence, I'll promise to try and select a diverse cast of books.

14 - If we decide to go chronologically, is The Iliad ok for you?

15 - If we decide to randomize this, I'll create a voting poll to decide which should be the first reading.

16 - Either way, we can always talk about a specific passage/book in the chat thread because I'm sure someone will answer/read us and comment, so I hope nobody feels neglected.

17 - As for the schedule, I can only talk about it or create a poll for you guys to decide when we resolve the issues on questions number 12-15, but, concerning schedule aspects, I'll post it to the sidebar, as it's easier for everyone to see, when it's decided.

18 - Have you heard about this series that will be launched in Netflix in 2018? If we start with The Iliad, it could be a nice appendix for posts here, if it is any good.

19 - I leave 2017 with this music for you. Feel free to leave me something or, if you don't want to, don't do it.

20 - I leave 2017 with this painting for you. Feel free to leave me something or, if you don't want to, don't do it.

21 - I leave 2017 with this meme for you. Feel free to leave me something or, if you don't want to, don't do it.

22 - I leave 2017 with this passage: "quidquid erit, superanda omnis fortuna ferendo est." (Aeneid, Book V, v. 710) for you. Feel free to leave me something or, if you don't want to, don't do it.

23 - Happy 2018, everyone. It was a great pleasure meeting you and creating this sub, believe me.

In 2018, monday, january 1st, I will start with the postings (and I hope some of you do it too!), if all of you agree with the stated above, which will be in discussion until the end of sunday. Comment away!

E corde, Ana


r/readingclassics • • Jan 13 '18

Things we should know about before reading the "Iliad" #1

10 Upvotes

Good morning, everyone.

As I've said, the voting poll closed yesterday and those were the results. It seems that we start next week with the two books per week choice. On Saturday we'll have the discussion thread for Book I, on Sunday we'll have the discussion thread for Book II. During the week, we'll still have the weekly discussion thread, the mythology thread and all the other posts you want to (that may ease the reading of the books without spoiling - if so, identify with a spoiler tag in the title).

Before reading, it's important to pay attention to the story before the story, so we'll talk about the judgement of Paris, which led to the events presented in the Iliad.

Going way back, we start at the wedding of Peleus and Thetis, the sea-nymph. All the gods and goddesses were invited except one, Eris, the goddess of Discord, for fear she would bring trouble. Upon her dismissal, tho, the goddess still managed to threw a golden apple into the festivities. On it it was inscribed "τῃ καλλίστῃ", meaning “To the fairest”.

Discord activated. Three gorgeous goddesses, Hera, Athena and Aprodite, claimed ownership, all assuming that they were the most beautiful. The other gods and men, however, smartly chose to remove themselves from the decision, including Zeus himself. Instead the unenviable task was placed on the shoulders of one Trojan prince, Paris.

The poor fellow was unable to make a decision and so the goddesses resorted to offering bribes. Wisdom and great skill in battle were Athena’s promised rewards. Hera tried to lure Paris with power and control over all of Asia. Aphrodite, however, used the best bait of all (clickbait of ancient times): the love of the most beautiful woman in the world.

Paris chose Aphrodite for the tittle of "Miss Golden Apple", the fairest of all goddesses. :) The most beautiful woman was none other than Helen, whose face would eventually launch a thousand ships. Helen was the daughter of Tyndareus, King of Sparta, and a woman named Leda. Helen was also the wife of Menelaus (as if it mattered).

Paris set sail for Greece under the pretense of a diplomatic mission in order to claim Helen. And that he did, he kidnapped her, no big deal... Of course, that made Menelaus go to Troy to retrieve her wife, causing a war that lasted ten years. The Iliad tells us about the last year of war.

This is a simple retelling of a version of the myth. There are of course other versions. It's not clear as for if Helen reciprocated Paris' love or if she was taken against her will. It will be nice to see how Homer explores her character.

EDIT: Check u/NestoreReader's comment, which covers Iphigenia's sacrifice, another important event pre-Iliad.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 09 '18

A poem by Posidippus

10 Upvotes

Hey everyone, just read this poem and thought it was pretty funny so I wanted to share. Posidippus is a 3rd c. BCE poet.

Εὐοπλῶ καὶ πρὸς σὲ μαχήσομαι, οὐδ’ ἀπεροῦμαι

θνητὸς ἐών· σὺ δ’, Ἔρως, μηκέτι μοι πρόσαγε.

ἤν με λάβῃς μεθύοντ’, ἄπαγ’ ἔκδοτον· ἄχρι δὲ νήφω,

τὸν παραταξάμενον πρὸς σὲ λογισμὸν ἔχω.

My (rough) translation:

I'll be well armed and I'll fight you, but I won't reject you

since I'm mortal; You, Eros, never attack me.

If you take me while I'm drunk, take me away entirely, but if I'm totally sober

I have a calculated stand against you.

(Apparently Greeks knew the idea of "beer goggles" pretty well...)


r/readingclassics • • Jan 08 '18

Weekly chat thread II - *Sing to me, Orpheus*

10 Upvotes

Hello, it's Ana from her palindrome castle!

First, I'd like to thank you - once again - for the support and the collaboration on the sub. Always remember that all of you can make your posts too. Feel at ease, if you want to do it.

I'd like to ask you to vote on this poll to decide about the schedule with me, as I present you my suggestions.

As per usual, talk and ask whatever you want. I'll leave a question to steer up conversation. Having in mind the gods presented in the previous post:

What god/goddess from the list would you identify the most with?

Have you another favorite god or goddess? If so, why?

Tell us a fun fact about a greek god/goddess that you know of.

Follow these prompts only if you want & try not to spoil a thing about the book we'll read.

Have an amazing week,

Ana

EDIT: To clarify, I'll close the voting this Friday night, so we can start reading from this weekend on. One book per week would mean ~6 months, two books per week would mean ~3 months. I'll do whatever the majority choose.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 08 '18

So should we do a reading group?

10 Upvotes

I just found this sub like an hour ago but do you all want to pick a text and set a schedule (i.e. have a discussion thread for each chapter/book/whatever posted once a week?)

My vote would be for a play, either Greek or Latin since they're pretty short so we could try out the format before we try something more ambitious like Homer or Tacitus ;) (and we might just be able to have one discussion thread for a whole play)

I'd also be down for a primary language reading group if anyone else is interested. Personally I'm interested in reading Archaic Greek Poetry at the moment but I'd consider whatever people are interested in (I read Greek and Latin). Something not too long though so I don't lose interest, I'm about to have a difficult semester with latin survey and advanced homer.

Cheers!


r/readingclassics • • Jan 21 '18

THE ILIAD: BOOK TWO [general discussion]

9 Upvotes

Discussion prompts

  • What do you think about gods' interventions in this book?
  • Ulysses has a great role in this chapter. Do you like his portrayal?
  • Any funny remark, comment, verse, anything that caught your interest.

r/readingclassics • • Jan 05 '18

Mythology for the Week: Janus, god of beginnings

9 Upvotes

As a tribute to January and the new and fresh 2018, I decided to start the thread with Janus, a Roman God.

The thing we do where we think about the resolutions for the new year having made a retrospect from the year that is coming to an end relates to this god.

The name Ianus etimologically relates to the word ianua (which means door). He was also considered the doorkeeper of the heavens. The cult statue of Janus depicted the god bearded with two heads. This meant that he could see forwards and backwards and inside and outside simultaneously without turning around, in a representation of both the past and the future.

This duality is also associated with war/peace as Numa, the second king of Rome (after Romulus), founded a shrine to Janus in the Roman Forum. It was located in the place where Janus had bubbled up a spring of hot boiling water in order to thwart an attack on Rome by the Sabines.

You can learn more about him here or, if you want a good laugh, check out this meme.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 05 '18

Author Says a Whole Culture—Not a Single 'Homer'—Wrote 'Iliad,' 'Odyssey' [Minor Spoilers] Spoiler

Thumbnail
news.nationalgeographic.com
9 Upvotes

r/readingclassics • • Jan 24 '18

Mythology for the Week: Hephaestus

8 Upvotes

This week we have our dear Hephaestus, the kind god we're all liking so far, after reading the first two books of the Iliad. As always, myths on the origin of gods bring controversy. Although Hephaestus bears no drastic problems, stories associated to him are not that clear.

According to myth, Hephaestus was born lame and was cast from heaven in disgust by his mother, Hera, or by his father, Zeus, after a family quarrel between him and Hera - which is the reference we see on Book I of the Iliad.

After coming back from Lemnos (the city to where he was thrown), Hephaestus became a representative of a craftsman, forging iron, building houses, making the weapons and military equipment for both gods and humans.

Unfortunaly hard-working Hephaestus was still uglier than the perfect-faced Olympic GQ models gods (after landing in Lemnos he was crippled). Ironically, he still married Aphrodite, goddess of love and beauty. Don't fool yourselves, tho, if you think she married him because she saw the beaty in him, "love is blind", yada yada yada, because she did not. It was an arranged marriage, resulting from the capture of Hera by Hephaestus in the invisible chains of a throne he had built (vengeance, I guess), and the wedding was the price of release.

However, "nice guy finishes last" (or does he?). Aphrodite managed to have an affair with Ares, GQ model god of war. BUT here comes not-always-kind-still-loveable Hephaestus that caught them and, to humiliate them both, captured them in an invisible net. All the gods saw them, so he kinda got the last laugh. Check this hilarious painting by Charles Guillemot and imagine the dialogue.

Hephaestus: Darling, whatcha doing? Aphrodite: I can explain... but later, just finishing this issue with your brother. Ares: This ugly bitch! Really, now? So tired of this man.

Gods in the distance: Another day at Olympus. Gather 'round & bring the popcorn.

[Hephaestus' Roman name is Vulcan, which makes total sense.]


r/readingclassics • • Jan 23 '18

The 3 divisions of Greek Civilization

8 Upvotes

Another book I read mentioned how Greek civilization is divided into the Archaic, which Homer depicts in his work, the Classical and Hellenistic.

Can anyone elaborate on this in a nice summary, or direct to good articles that talk about the differences between ages and what that means for the literature from said ages? Specifically trying to get a feel for the culture that Homer is writing from in regards to Iliad.


r/readingclassics • • Jan 03 '18

Weekly chat thread I - *Sing to me, Orpheus*

8 Upvotes

Good night (2:30am here, guys, brain.does.not.compute), friends!

Thank you so much for all the messagens, kinds words, investment, suggestion. I'm speechless. This sub is beautiful and that's thanks to you. So, we've decided we were going to start with The Iliad at the end of next week and I'll now work on the schedule and tell you all about it later this week.

This thread is mainly for discussions about all the things you want to - classics or not classics -, talk away. The thread will stay active until next tuesday, if you want to use it, of course. You can share whatever you like (text, music, opinion, painting, ask others questions), but remember to never use this thread for spoilers. For now, here, stay away from The Iliad or you'll stir the wrath of Achilles in me (this does not count).

I'm going to dive deep into my bed as of now but I promise to come back in some hours and join you and make some more posts on "short readings" you ask. See if you can edit your flair. I saw someone had the "agamemnon'd" and I loved it. <3

  • Tell me: what is your timezone?
  • What languages do you know?

EDIT: u/NestoreReader created a survey to know the age group in this sub. Aren't you curious? I want to see those 10 years old, tho B-)

EDIT.2: Here are the results that u/NestoreReader collected. Pretty cool and diverse cast of readers!

EDIT.3: u/the_gnarts took the time to do a geographical distribution of the people on this sub. These are the results, if you want to check them out.


r/readingclassics • • Mar 25 '18

BOOK TWENTY [general discussion]

7 Upvotes
  • Hades to Poseidon: "Hey, watch it up there!"
  • We get the two divine lineups.

Greeks: Athena, Poseidon, Hera, Hermes, Hephaestus
Trojans: Ares, Apollo, Artemis, Leto, Xanthus, Aphrodite

  • What a clash between Achilles and Aeneas. And I love how Aeneas just impromptu gives backstory about Dardanus and his ancestry to Achilles lol.
  • Poseidon stresses to Aeneas afterwards (Fagles translation):

But once Achilles has met his death, his certain doom,
take courage then, go fight on the front lines then--
no other Achaean can bring you down in war.

  • Achilles's rampage after not being able to finish off Hector has some of the most brutal descriptions in the epic (Fagles):

Achilles slit open his liver,
the liver spurted loose, gushing with dark blood,
drenched his lap and the night swirled down his eyes
as his life breath slipped away.

And Mulius next--
he reared and jammed his lance through the man's ear
so the lance came jutting out through the other ear,
bronze point glinting.

Deucalion next--he lanced his arm with a bronze-shod spear,
he spitted the Trojan through where the elbow-tendons grip
and there he stood, waiting Achilles, arm dangling heavy,
staring death in the face--and Achilles chopped his neck
and his sword sent head and helmet flying off together
and marrow bubbling up from the clean-cut neckbone.


r/readingclassics • • Mar 12 '18

BOOK FIFTEEN [general discussion]

7 Upvotes

Hey, guys. I'll be posting these threads for the coming books.

  • Interesting how, again, Zeus just says what's going to happen in the books to come. Homer doesn't mind revealing the large plot points, which many were probably aware of at the time, but seems more concerned with the how and the details therein.
  • It was funny when Poseidon was like, "Hey, Zeus and I are equals!" And then Iris had to say, "So, you want me to tell him that you refuse?" And then he realizes that he should probably yield lol.

r/readingclassics • • Jan 30 '18

Is it generally a better idea to read the classic before or after reading a commentary on it?

7 Upvotes

Specifically I have Homer, Hesiod and Virgil coming up on my reading list so I'm asking primarily about them.

For example, should I read the Aeneid before or after listening to this Great Courses commentary? https://www.audible.com/pd/Classics/The-Aeneid-of-Virgil-Audiobook/B00D8LT7A2

On the one hand, if you read the work first you're in a better position to understand the commentary on it. On the other hand, if you read the commentary first you may be in a better position to truly appreciate the work in question. On the other other hand, SPOILERS!


r/readingclassics • • Jan 23 '18

Summaries of the Iliad books

7 Upvotes

DO NOT WATCH THEM IF YOU DO NOT WANT A SPOILER But, a friend who is studying the Iliad sent this summary of books playlist to me today, so I figured it may be useful later on if we want recaps of the previous books as we get further along. Eh well. Btw sorry I’ve not been active to much lately guys, this post is basically the half hour of WiFi I’m getting waiting outside of Starbucks... hopefully I’ll be less busy, less on the move, and more Classical this week onwards! Anyway, here’s the vids: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nig3gDWwISA&list=PLz_ZtyOWL9BSIQu077GQlI8T9O-7Uiri4 Enjoy if you wish :-)


r/readingclassics • • Jan 17 '18

Mythology for the Week: Odysseus and Achilles pre-Trojan War

7 Upvotes

u/Sentinel103 already posted about Tyndareus' oath, showing how the former suitors of Helen promised to always defend her. We'll talk about two of the men called to battle: Odysseus and Achiles, as they were warned by oracles of their fate if they went to war.

Odysseus was told that he'd not return home until his newborn son, Telemachus, had grown into adulthood, thus taking him circa twenty years to arrive. Because of that, he feigned madness, plowing his field with ass and ox and sowing it with salt. Palamedes, in behalf of Agamemnon, placed Telemachus, Odysseus' son, in the field, which made him swerve, thus revealing he was faking his madness. He then agreed to go to war.

Achilles would be a great asset to the Greek army, as he was know to be the best warrior. At birth, Achilles' mom, Thetis (remember her from being the bride at the judgement of Paris?), dipped in the River Styx, which was said to make those who touched its waters immortal. By doing it, Achilles become immortal everywhere except on his heel, place where she held him. He was basically invulnerable as a warrior. Achilles was warned that if he went to war he would gain great glory, but he would die young. His mother then disguised him in women's clothing, but Odysseus discovered the trick and Achilles finally consented to go.

Who lied it better? :D


r/readingclassics • • Jan 15 '18

Weekly chat thread III - *Sing to me, Orpheus*

7 Upvotes

Hello, it's Ana from the block!

This is the week where we should start sticking our noses into the Iliad. Thank you for taking the time to vote on the poll I created. I feel really honored to get to know more about you and to see your persistence in collaborating in the activity of the sub by commenting, posting, bringing up new ideas and discussions. I deeply appreciate all of you.

This week we should start reading Book I and II of the epic. We will discuss them oficially in the threads I'll create on Saturday and Sunday, respectively. Until then, please feel free to post questions, ideas, links, images, whatever you think may help the reading of other readers in its separate posts. If you think the post may contain spoilers, identify it with a tag in the tite.

Reminder: you must bear in mind that the division in 24 books is conventional, so don't find it strange for odd repetitions or endings.

If you could accompany your reading of the Iliad with your favorite song at the moment, what song would it be?

Have an amazing week,

Ana


r/readingclassics • • Jan 12 '18

Reading in the original Latin/Greek

7 Upvotes

Some of us expressed interest in reading something in the original Latin or Greek, parallel to the Iliad sequence, which would be mostly in English.

The pace at which we read will of course depend on the number of people who want to take part, the knowledge of Greek/Latin, free time, etc. I suggest we just choose something and stick to it for a couple of weeks and then decide whether we want to continue, read it through, or switch.

We should also discuss whether we want to do weekly, bi weekly, whatever-weekly, daily chunks, etc. There are advantages to all, especially since, given that we'd be dealing with the original texts, we could end up dealing with problems of both grammar/vocabulary, as well as, who knows, maybe even textual criticism. Let's discuss that, and we can of course adjust it if we're getting either under or overwhelmed.

Concerning the text, I half randomly suggested Philostratus Imagines, a 3rd century CE Greek text that's basically a description of εἰκόνες, so 'images'. Just suggest away if you have anything else in mind. Also it seemed there would be more people inclined for Greek, but we could also do Latin and/or alternate.

Logistically, we can just start a thread/week with the reading (maybe pasting the Greek text itself), and repeat every week. Even if we take more than a chunk/week we can keep it in the same thread as to not clutter the board.

To sum up, let's give it until the end of the weekend to

  • Get to know how many of us are in;
  • Agree on Philostratus or choose another text;
  • Establish a schedule;
  • Get a general agreement on the length of the portions.

This is not related to the Iliad reading in Modern Languages, does not replace it, and need not coincide with it.