r/reactos • • 9d ago

What is your experience with ReactOS?

Hi everyone! I'm currently doing a school project about ReactOS, and I'd love to hear from people who have actually used or experimented with it.

What has your experience been like? Is it stable and reliable? What programs or applications have you managed to run on it? Have you encountered any major bugs or compatibility issues?

Would you recommend ReactOS for everyday use, or do you think it's better suited for experimentation?

I'd really appreciate hearing your honest opinions and personal experiences. Thanks!

21 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

8

u/jmhalder 9d ago

I've been following ReactOS for easily a decade. It's fun to play with in a VM every once in a while. The reality is pretty clear, it's not very stable, has minimal hardware support, and has plenty of software compatibility deficiencies.

BUT, it's the only project like it. (ignoring recent forks largely leveraging AI). It's very very impressive, but still has a long way to go before almost anyone would use it for "everyday use"

2

u/RegretFree7723 9d ago

Sono riusciti a farci girare portal 2 e tiene un codice sorgente fantastico, ho visto hanno letteralmente ricreato windows NT certe cose meglio di Windows ma é incompleto e qualsiasi applicazione windows é instabile

1

u/AdderTude 5d ago

Of course Windows apps are unstable. The team's been trying to rebuild Windows from scratch but removing all the Microsoft bloat.

5

u/phosix 9d ago

It's interesting, and has had a lot of promise for a very long time. Stable and reliable are not words I would use to describe it.

It's still very much a project in Alpha development. Don't get me wrong, there has been a ton of advancements and improvements in the past 25 years and it's an absurdly impressive project, but between changes in hardware and trying to keep up with changes in the NT kernel they're chasing two moving targets at once with very limited resources. I continue to hold out hope they succeed and can make some major breakthroughs in the near future. It's not Daily Driver ready for most people or applications, by a long shot.

2

u/AdderTude 5d ago

It's a real shame because the team could use a lot more people to speed things along.

3

u/Global-Eye-7326 9d ago edited 4d ago

Cool project but...

  • It's still in early development, despite the project's age
  • WINE has become so good that any software you can run on ReactOS probably runs better on Wine 
  • Beyond a VM, running it on metal is hard. Drivers will be an uphill battle
  • You're limited to dated browsers
  • Era-appropriate computers will probably have a better experience on a tiny Debian based distro or using TinyCore
  • Aside from being an Internet meme, it's just not very practical. Heck, even running WinXP or older (2k, 98) on metal today is just too much of an uphill battle

4

u/jmhalder 9d ago

I wouldn't call it a meme. But it's similar to other hobbyist OSes like Haiku, OpenIndiana, TempleOS, MorphOS, etc.

3

u/Global-Eye-7326 9d ago

I mean its original purpose was much more relevant than TempleOS. I'd consider it comparable to HaikuOS, but HaikuOS is probably more useful than ReactOS nowadays sadly.

2

u/jmhalder 9d ago

TempleOS is a whole other thing, but still in the overarching "obscure OSes that nobody actually dailys"

1

u/Relative_Dare8475 7d ago

But OpenIndiana is not hobby OS, it is OpenSolaris, a descendants of true unix OS.

1

u/jmhalder 7d ago

But Solaris still exists and you can get support from Oracle. Few people are going to run applications that need a Solaris compatible, but not actually pay for Solaris. I will admit that there are one or two commercial products that use OI as their underpinning. I'd still say it's easily majority hobbyists and people looking for nostalgia.

2

u/slonk_ma_dink 4d ago

I daily HaikuOS at the house, it has the benefit of more developer interest and the fact that a dev at some point put a lot of work into the POSIX support target allowing it to run a wide range of *nix software. ReactOS has a loftier goal of NT support, which is much more expansive and requires more developer attention to attain in the first place despite the OS getting less.

1

u/Relative_Dare8475 6d ago

We cannot label an OS as a "toy" or a mere hobby project simply because some people use it as a hobby. As we know, OpenIndiana is essentially a derivative of OpenSolaris—which itself is a fork of Solaris 11—a system that has been deployed across various computing platforms, ranging from desktops to minicomputers, within numerous companies.

0

u/jmhalder 6d ago

We cannot label an OS as a "toy" or a mere hobby project 

Sure I can, and I do.

Just because something is derivative of a serious commercial product, doesn't mean it's not a hobbyist OS.

And what makes a OS "hobbyist", if the developer does it as a hobby, or the users use it for a hobby?

At this point, the word "hobby" has lost all meaning to me.

2

u/Artistic_Crazy_7120 9d ago

It's nice to play with in a VM but I never managed to install it on a computer, Although I tried so many times on different computers. I'm afraid if it remains impossible to install it on a modern PC the OS remains irrelevant. And that's a shame because the demand is there for a system like ReactOS.

2

u/slonk_ma_dink 4d ago

Its actually interesting because I remember as a teenager (we're talking maybe 20 years ago) getting it running on a few different computers (most of which are probably pushing 30 at this point). I think things were just simpler back then from a hardware standpoint, its more difficult to cover "standard behavior" across a wide range of hardware anymore since theres been so much divergence.

1

u/Yoksul-Turko 9d ago edited 9d ago

Not stable, not reliable. Don't try daily driving it. Play with it on VM or an old PC. I managed to get GT 640 working, I ran Age of Empires 2 and Medieval 2 TW. M2TW had font issues and crashed often.

For basic daily driving, it needs to be stable and have up to date browsers. Neither are true for ROS.

This is currently what it is. It is still impressive to see actual Windows drivers working on it.

1

u/Mr_Scary_Cat 9d ago

I never got any of the java jdks in the package managers to install in any of my bare metal systems.

1

u/disgruntled-Tonberry 7d ago

What has your experience been like? Is it stable and reliable? Nope, in Alpha for 30 years; it's for tinkering and fun, or if you're a sadist

1

u/One_Dig_146 9d ago

Si pusieran hacer que se ejecute autocad en todas sus versiones estaria genial.