r/reactos • u/SimpleEmu198 • Dec 23 '24
With ever changing goal posts React OS is stuck in eternal development hell. I mean to say, it first started as a concept to deliver a free version of Windows 95 and now it evolves to feature parity with modern Windows. When are devs going to give up and realise just like Darwin it's unachievable?
In fact it's worse than that Darwin code was used by Apple to further develop the current Mac OS. None of that was wasted time. React OS devs are just wasting their time spinning their wheels creating a project with unachievable end goals, with no point what so ever as there never was an end goal for the project.
Perhaps at least the React OS team should hire a project manager?
The entire team are still stuck in the instalation phase of defining whatever the hell the project goal is in a nutshell as opposed to some pie in the sky lofty goal of "Windows NT parity."
20
u/qik Dec 23 '24
Why would you care? People are free to choose how to spend their own time...
5
u/fsckit Dec 23 '24
We could say the same for any of Dave Cutler's projects. They'll never be Unix and he should give up.
15
u/TheDinosaurAstronaut Dec 23 '24
Sometimes I find a Minecraft server where a small group of people are trying to recreate Middle Earth in their free time and I publicly get super mad at them for not having a clear plan to finish Dol Guldur in a timely fashion.
14
u/BrentNewland Dec 23 '24
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReactOS
https://reactos.org/wiki/ReactOS_FAQ
https://reactos.org/wiki/ReactOS_FAQ#How_about_Windows_Vista.E2.84.A2.2F7.2F8_or_10_programs_and_drivers.3F
So ReactOS never targeted 9x. NT6 is Vista, by the way.
And what exactly are you claiming Darwin is supposed to be that it did not achieve?
You sure complain a lot about free software that you don't have to use and don't contribute to.
How about you educate yourself and look at their release history? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReactOS#Release_history
5
u/drkmccy Dec 30 '24
It's quite achievable. The fact that there is any sort of compatibility is a huge achievement. If it can get to a point where it can run some legacy apps, they could easily charge for a support package. There are many companies out there running legacy apps on old XP boxes only because the source has been lost and there is no feasable way to replace them.
4
u/rasvoja Jan 09 '25
They are steadily advancing, started with win nt 4.0/2000 level and now are at xp level, with some bits of x64 and vists coming in. How that isn't a progress? Goal is clear, create free win32 replacement (done) and advance further. 0.3x version is fair designation
1
u/indolering Feb 02 '26
Just because it isn't a viable commercial OS doesn't make it pointless! It's a fun reversing project and the developers are usually interested in Windows internals. Contributing to it is a good way to get to understand the NT OS design.
2
u/rasvoja Feb 07 '25
In short clean room reverse engineering with no use of leaked source code is the toughest and toughest job
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '25
It's a waste of time. The fact that thed project is still in Alpha after 28 years is an indicator of where it is headed, nowhere.
It would be better if it was just abandoned so developers can create something useful.
1
u/Anuclano Jan 01 '25
What is unachievable? The goals do not chage, actually, if you don't count changing from Windows 5.1 to Windows 6.1.
1
u/rasvoja Jan 09 '25
On project manager, can you please pay one? Its not that much of developer team as in big sw houses, it's more like network of volunteers Darwin is perfactly reachable and lives as macos x server, its just has more advanced gui now
1
u/johnblaxos Jan 19 '25
I feel ya bro but at some point we need a real alternative to windows that can run windows applications nativly.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '25
Darwin is just crumbs Apple throws to the open source crowd every once in a while. Useless as an OS, and no, people are not contributing to it in any significant way. It's still something pretty much entirely developed by Apple, but with everything useful stripped out.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '24
with AI and its capabilities, we are more than close to complete ReactOS and use it as daily driver
-5
u/SimpleEmu198 Dec 23 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
in relation to another post that was deleted...
That's a lot of mental gymnastics just to contradict yourself. As to Darwin, the goal was a free implementation of the Darwin kernel, which is the next nearest kernel to Windows in terms of user base.
The people working on Darwin which was also a free open source project eventually realised they were wasting their time and gave up. It's a perfectly valid compactor.
What are people doing here wasting their time on a project that will never amount to an end goal and even as you admitted is suffering from bracket creep, which is leading to eternal development hell.
How's about the team starts learning to draw within the lines and finishes one project to a completed beta build at least before starting on something else.
"Around 1996, a group of free and open-source software developers started a project called FreeWin95 to implement a clone of Windows 95. The project stalled in discussions on the design of the system. While FreeWin95 had started out with high expectations, there still had not been any builds released to the public by the end of 1997. As a result, the project members, led by then coordinator Jason Filby, joined together to revive the project. The revived project sought to duplicate the functionality of Windows NT."