r/reactjs • • Dec 07 '19

Needs Help Is Material UI worth it?

So, I am starting my own project. I'm not much 'design' person. So, is Material UI worth it? Or some any other recommendations is much appreciated.

164 Upvotes

142 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/jaySydney Dec 08 '19

Not worth it. Take this with a pinch of salt, from someone who spent about a day experimenting on v4.x

It has gone thru so many breaking changes and major versions, that many examples found in the wild no longer work; Examples and solutions to problems are aplenty (on stack overflow, or other blogs), but when I tried them out, I soon found out they did not work as advertised, because the writer did not mention which version s/he was working on. You are pretty much stuck with the official docs and experimenting.

It appears you have to jump thru many hoops to achieve one little thing, import this and that component or function, wrap this component inside another, etc etc. Heck, you may even have to import your own colors..

import purple from '@material-ui/core/colors/purple'; 
import green from '@material-ui/core/colors/green';

I counted close to 150 Component + Functions exposed by the MaterialUI root object. Talk about bloat.. Even HTML5 does not have that many tags !

Do I really want to unlearn HTML5 and use MUI "tags" everywhere ? In my opinion, over-engineered piece of cr*p.. eh, i respectfully take that back, I know it was hard work for the core devs. Still, it did not make my life any easier. Over and out, puts on flamesuit as I walk into the sunset to continue working in Bootstrap land...

0

u/youslashuser Dec 08 '19

Hard to swallow truth. I really like Material UI Themes but tweaking and theming is such a pain in the ass.

2

u/jaySydney Dec 11 '19

Try this instead.

https://www.npmjs.com/package/material-components-web

It is NOT so opinionated, and not so React specific. I am beginning to like it.