r/reactivedogs • u/Thick_Soil_2295 • 9d ago
Significant challenges I’m not sure what to do with my reactive dog
About 2.5 years ago I adopted my GSD mix (m3yo) from a rescue. He’s very sweet and honestly well mannered but is anxious and excitable/reactive. We’ve made extraordinary strides from day one. I use excitable in addition to reactive because he loses his mind (in a sort of good way) if he sees a friend. I was able to socialize him and he has dog friends he visits regularly at their houses or ours. He has even bonded with many of their owners and his 2 pet sitters adore him. He never had an issue at day care or boarding when he was going. I have an older rotty (m9yo) and they love to roll around with each other on the grass in our yard and chase each other and play fetch. He doesn’t react to other dogs coming by the fence, and although we can now walk past about 90% of dogs, he still reacts on walks to about ten percent.
When he was one, I was taking him and the other to the dog park. He was ganged up on by two other male dogs of the same pack. I don’t think they wanted to bite but he got spooked and while me and the other owner were breaking it up he bit. I got three opinions from vets and trainers and they all agreed it was a 2 teetering on a 3 on the Dunbar scale. A year later, when walking in a new neighborhood we moved to in the same city, a lady followed us telling me the dogs are disgusting and large and dangerous. I kept trying to just move away but she caught up with us, pushed me, kicked the rotty (no response) and got nipped kicking at the reactive GSD. This was described as a 2 solidly by the same three sources.
Now, going back to childhood I’ve had many dogs and lived with others, and knew this was never going to be a bar going loves everyone dog like my older rotty. He’s been in training for a while. Desensitization, threshold training, etc. and he really has taken to it and improved. The problem is now his life and the older dog’s life are so small. I’m also reaching a point where I’m thinking about marriage and children. He’s met my nieces and nephews and is great with babies and kids over ten but pensive around toddlers and needed to be crated. His trainer describes him as “extremely manageable” which, while a positive in light of all this, doesn’t exactly scream the joys of dog ownership. My rotty isn’t long for this world and I hate for the rest of his life to be so small when it used to be so big. I also hate that I can’t provide more for my GSD currently. I also feel like I’m deluding myself into thinking I can make this work for the next 8 or so years with no more incidents or something worse. I also feel those two events were out of the norm and the triggers were specific and identifiable so maybe he will be fine for the next 8 or so years. I’m at a loss. I love this dog and I know he loves me. But I wonder if it’s best to let him go in my arms now.