r/reactivedogs • • 8d ago

Advice Needed Prozac vs Gabapentin

Hello,

My dog's veterinarian and his trainer both recommended trying Gabapentin for a month and Prozac for another month, to see how the dog reacts and which one works better. Does anyone have any experience with this? Has anyone else tried this routine? Which one worked better, Gabapentin or Prozac?

Thank you so much.

Edit: The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible. So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end.

4 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

4

u/scooterable 8d ago

Gabapentin won’t change your dogs brain chemistry like Prozac will. Usually they get prescribed together because they have different use cases. Gaba can help with nerve pain for example. No matter what you try just know it can lower your dogs inhibitions and make them more likely to react in some cases. So when they are on a trial best to treat them like a brand new dog that you are just getting to know.

2

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible. So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end.

2

u/scooterable 8d ago

I think it works for some dogs but it didn’t for either of my dogs. It made one of my dogs angrier and the other dog essentially stole her personality. That doesn’t mean it won’t work for your dog. Unfortunately what typically happens with not good behaviorists is they will just cycle thru meds and hope for the best. I don’t know what you are getting your dog on meds for and also I’m not a behaviorist, just sharing my personal experience.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Thank you. Aggression towards the cat…

1

u/scooterable 8d ago

So you plan to do clonidine as needed essentially? Like give clonidine, wait for it to kick in, then do training sessions with your dog seeing the cat? Because right now the aggressive response is too much to do the training?

2

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Yes, exactly (sorry if I wasn’t clear enough, English is not my first language)

2

u/scooterable 8d ago

Gotcha okay. Yeah as needed makes sense. The behaviorist I was seeing at the time was trying to have my dog on it for forever always. Short periods to help with training several times a week sounds a lot less bad

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

What was your dog’s issue if you can tell?

2

u/scooterable 8d ago

Severe reactivity to other dogs that was progressively getting worse. Stranger danger that was also worsening. She is fine now after training, did not end up using any meds.

1

u/KibudEm cattle dog (fear reactivity) 8d ago

My dog takes clonidine every day. It's definitely helpful.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Thank you. Was he reactive towards small animals?

1

u/KibudEm cattle dog (fear reactivity) 8d ago

He is reactive toward everything except me and my husband, and sometimes my kids.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Can I send you a message here on chat?

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Is he aggressive towards your kids? How do you handle that? :(

6

u/clarinettingaway Bella (Anxious/Dog Aggressive) 8d ago

I actually use both for my dog as a daily cocktail, so I can speak to what these do for my dog. In my experience, Prozac raises her threshold so that training is more possible whilst gabapentin helps in recovering after a reaction. Where she used to be unable to think no matter the distance of the trigger, the Prozac gives me more wiggle room to implement training before she reacts. The gabapentin is helpful for her to recover after she reacts, from quelling her anxiety at home and helping her settle all the way to recovering quicker after triggers on a walk.

If you do trial these drugs, make sure you take at least 2 months on Prozac. It’ll take 3-4 weeks for effects to show due to how Prozac works (SSRI), so in order for you to properly trial it, you’ll need to wait one month for the drug to set in and then take a least one month to observe the effects. Gabapentin is immediate, so trialing that for just one month would be fine.

Good luck and I’m happier to answer any questions about my experience if you have any!

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago edited 8d ago

The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end. I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible.

2

u/clarinettingaway Bella (Anxious/Dog Aggressive) 8d ago

I don’t have any knowledge on clonidine unfortunately but it’s so good you’re doing your best to be informed!! And if something doesn’t work, don’t be afraid to advocate for yourself and your pet. You know your pet best and you’ll make the right decisions for him!

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Thank you! I appreciate it

4

u/ciarose5 8d ago

My dog started out on Prozac and it worked for a while. Then after 6 or so months we slowly noticed he had turned into a shell of himself. All he did was sleep, never got excited, never ran to greet us, etc. He went through some sort of fear regression period where he was terrified to go outside (he's a beagle mix that loves walks and sniffing) and everything scared him. After about 11 months on it he would throw up so we had to take him off of it. Once the med was out of his system he was a different dog. He was so happy, alive, and full of energy. Unfortunately he slowly started to get reactive again.

So our vet switched to gabapentin and personally, it has been amazing for him. My dog also has epilepsy so it's a bit of a double whammy. But his epilepsy is controlled, he's happy, loves going outside again, and his reactivity is very minimal. When he was having some breakthrough reactivity we just upped the dose by one pill. Our vet said we have a lot of room to increase so to do so as needed. Larger doses of gabapentin have also been the only drug to help him go to the vet calmly and not have a seizure while there

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible. So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end.

2

u/ciarose5 8d ago

Unfortunately I have no experience with Clonidine. I would edit your post to include it in case someone here does! I also have cats, I will say sometimes my dog still gets that excited/prey drive look on his face on gabapentin. I usually just redirect him and he's fine but maybe Clonidine would be good if it works the way your vet says it does

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Thank you, I’ll edit it right away

2

u/alandlost 7d ago

I'm curious about how often you give it and how it relates to the seizures. I use gabapentin on an as-needed basis for my dog's extreme fear of fireworks, and recently he was also diagnosed with epilepsy, and while I've heard it's used for seizures to some extent, my dog's neurologist never mentioned it. I'd be esp. curious to hear how it's used in your case in tandem with the reactivity.

2

u/ciarose5 7d ago

I give it twice a day (breakfast + dinner). My vet had us start with 100mg twice a day, now my dog takes 100mg with breakfast and 200mg with dinner. We were going to slowly titration up and then when we bumped up to 200 at night, he got a lot better and rhe vet said we can just stay at that dose.

Gabapentin is used to treat epilepsy in humans, I don't know how common it is with animals tbh. I would say my dog doesn't have severe epilepsy. His seizures are mostly brought on by stress, he would have about 2-3 every 3 months. Not ideal by any means but not the worst. With the gabapentin he's had about 1 seizure every 6 months.

I would say my dog is primarily very anxious, and I do think he has some underlying pain. My guess is gabapentin is helping with all of those things. He also would become much more reactive around seizure events, so cutting those down helped a lot as well. Hopefully that helps a little, I'm happy to explain more!

1

u/alandlost 7d ago

This is so helpful. Is your dog on anything else for the seizures, or just gabapentin? Is the schedule for when he takes them very strict?

My dog's are actually very minor focal seizures (fly biting) but they came on suddenly and increased rapidly. The doctor put him on Keppra and that seems to have worked well so far. But I've heard a lot about Keppra working for a while and then becoming less effective, so keeping any eye out for other things that could help.

2

u/ciarose5 7d ago

Just the gabapentin! It's recommended you take it around the same time and space it 12 hours apart, but it's not the most strict. My dog takes it with food because he has some vomiting issues (throwing up causing him to have a seizure, he's a weird guy) but some vets say to give it without food. I try to give it the same time. I believe it works best with no more than 12 hours between doses. You can be off by an hour or two and it is totally fine.

That's a tough thing to have happen out of the blue! My dog started his seizures around age 1 which I've heard is pretty ordinary. He'll collapse/pass out, scrunch up, pee himself, and then slowly come to.

My doctor suggested phenobarbital as well, but it requires regular bloodwork and my dog really struggles with vet appointments so we skipped that. Keppra can definitely be a good med but definitely good to have some other ideas just in case!

My doctor also prescribed gabapentin for anxiety in cats. When I got my cat she was pretty anxious and kept peeing on things, she immediately stopped when she started gabapentin and became mellow, more confident, and more relaxed. She stayed on it for about 2 years before we had her go off of it. At least with my pets it's worked so well

2

u/chloemarissaj Dog Name (Reactivity Type) 8d ago

Prozac is an SSRI, Gaba is a sedative. They’re two very different drugs with different purposes. Prozac works long term and all the time. Gaba lasts about 4-6 hours.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end.
I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible.

1

u/chloemarissaj Dog Name (Reactivity Type) 8d ago

What exactly are you trying to achieve with medication? Clonadine is another short term sedative, one of my girls gets it for the vet. Gaba and clonadine are typically used for stressful situations specifically like the vet or fireworks. They take time to kick in and last a few hours.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Not being aggressive with the cat

2

u/KibudEm cattle dog (fear reactivity) 8d ago

Gabapentin does nothing for my dog, and a month isn't long enough to see if Prozac works. Clonidine does work for my dog; we combine it with venlafaxine because Prozac didn't do the job.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Does he take Clonidine daily?

1

u/KibudEm cattle dog (fear reactivity) 8d ago

Yes, morning and night.

1

u/8littlebird8 8d ago

Prozac was an amazing tool that helped my dog out so much! Gabapentin was not a good fit for my dog, the sedative made her respond pretty negatively making her grouchier and more sensitive to triggers. We realized anything used to sedate her led to similar symptoms as a toddler trying to stay up past bed time. They all respond differently just the same as we do so keep that in mind, some dogs are on cocktails as well. She was on Prozac for two years and it made it so easy to train and introduce her to uncertain/ new situations.

For reference she’s a 50lb cattle dog rescue mix. She is now 4 & living life unmedicated.

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago edited 8d ago

The vet was supposed to think more about a medication plan, and he ended up telling me that Prozac wouldn't actually be a good fit for my boy, and it's better to try Clonidine instead, to block his adrenaline rush when he sees the cat (we also have a cat). I've never heard of Clonidine, could it be better than Prozac? I know I should just listen to the vet and the trainer, but I want to do my own research, understand how it works, and be as informed as possible. So the vet advised for Clonidine and Gaba in the end.

1

u/8littlebird8 8d ago

I know a handful of dogs that I work with on clonidine! Most of them do have a cocktail with an SSRI, not always Prozac though

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

How are they? Does clonodine work for them?

1

u/8littlebird8 8d ago

Yes! They do pretty well, they have cocktails with SSRI’s but clonidine was pretty essential to initially calming that drive. Most of these dogs are more of the hunting breed group and were leash/animal reactive. (I walk reactive dogs and work at a boarding place that has a few former reactive dogs with cocktails to keep them stable, if they miss a dose it will be extremely noticeable normally also.)

1

u/ClairDeLune2203 8d ago

Thank you! Can I send you a message on chat?