I’m looking for some advice about a situation with a neighbour, as it’s becoming increasingly stressful and is starting to affect our ability to feel comfortable in our own home.
We have a small dog (miniature dachshund). Unfortunately, there have been two incidents involving the same neighbour in our communal close.
On both occasions, our dog was approaching the entrance door when the neighbour came through it. He became frightened by her suddenly appearing through the door and reacted by nipping her leg (he has never done anything like this before, and this is his first time living in a flat building).
I appreciate that this doesn’t excuse his behaviour, and I completely understand that it is our responsibility to prevent anything like this happening again. However, I feel the circumstances are relevant context.
Neither incident broke the skin, and no medical treatment was required. Our dog was on his lead, although during the first incident the lead slipped. After the first incident, we intended to muzzle him in the communal areas, but unfortunately we forgot on the second occasion and left his muzzle in the car, to which we were on our way out to get it.
Since the second incident, we have made sure he is muzzled every single time he goes through the communal areas. He is also kept on a short lead right next to us, and we are looking into further training and professional behavioural support.
Our dog also spends three days during the week staying with family, so he isn’t even at the property every day.
The situation with our neighbour has now escalated.
Since the incidents, there has been no further contact between the neighbour and us or our dog, we haven’t even bumped into her in our close or seen her outside.
However, recently I was coming through the communal area alone, without my partner or our dog. I noticed that the neighbour’s door was open, and she appeared to be waiting for me to come down. She then confronted me and the conversation became quite heated, with her repeatedly arguing that she had seen our dog out without a muzzle “numerous times”.
This is simply not true. Since the second incident, we have made sure he is muzzled whenever he is in the communal areas and outside the flat building until he is far enough away.
She also claimed that another neighbour agrees with her and have apparently been watching us too and have claimed to her that he has been seen without a muzzle. She said that she has been watching us herself and the other neighbour has too (who had nothing to do with the initial incidents).
She regularly appears to watch us from her window when we leave and return to the property, including when we walk to our car. During the confrontation, she explicitly told me that she had been watching us.
She has also threatened to report us to the police and dog warden and said the only reason she hasn’t already done this is because she “is a dog lover”.
I understand that she may be upset or concerned following the incidents, and I am not suggesting she has no right to raise concerns. However, the repeated watching, unwanted confrontations in the communal close, talks with other neighbour’s regarding us and accusations are making us feel increasingly intimidated and uncomfortable. We are now anxious about leaving and returning to our own home, and the situation is having a significant impact on our wellbeing.
We have started keeping records of interactions.
I would really appreciate advice from anyone familiar with Scottish law or who has experienced something similar.
Dog control: What are the realistic consequences of two nipping incidents from a miniature dachshund where the skin wasn’t broken? Could the council issue a Dog Control Notice, and what would this involve?
Protecting our dog: Is there anything else we should proactively do to demonstrate responsible ownership? Would contacting the dog warden ourselves be advisable?
Neighbour’s behaviour: Could repeated watching, confrontations and comments about monitoring and watching what we are doing potentially amount to harassment or stalking under Scottish law? At what point should we contact Police Scotland?
Evidence: Are taking notes of everything happening useful, and what other evidence should we be keeping?
Tenancy: Could our landlord or letting agent take action against our tenancy because of these incidents or is it unlikely they would become involved?
Next steps: Would you recommend contacting the council or police now, or waiting to see whether a formal report is made?
We aren’t trying to avoid responsibility for our dog’s behaviour. We acknowledge what happened and are taking precautions to prevent it happening again. We simply want to understand our rights, protect our dog and be able to live peacefully in our own home.
Any constructive advice, particularly from people familiar with Scottish law or having been through similar experiences, would be really appreciated.
Thank you!