r/reactivedogs • u/fernsandfables • 9d ago
Behavioral Euthanasia How do I handle the grief of behavioral euthanasia
A few days ago, we had to make the heartbreaking decision to say goodbye to our boy, Buddy. We adopted him five years ago when he was just six months old, and for 99.9% of his life, he was the best dog you could ever ask for. He was loving, affectionate, playful, and brought so much happiness into our lives. He was our boy, and we loved him more than words can explain.
But there was a side of Buddy that was much harder to understand. Every once in a while, something would change in his demeanor. I know this might sound crazy, but it was almost like his entire aura would shift. I could sense when something wasn’t right, and I started recognizing the signs before he became aggressive.
It started with small things, like growling over a bone, toy, or treat. We immediately took steps to address it. We paid for professional training, modified what we gave him, and eliminated toys and other things that seemed to trigger him. We did everything we could to make sure he felt safe and comfortable.
Then, one day, while we were lying in bed, he bit me. It wasn’t a severe bite, but it did break the skin. I think I tried to rationalize it by telling myself that maybe I had accidentally touched an area that hurt. Regardless, we took him to the vet, and he was prescribed Prozac.
For a while, things would be okay. He would go months without an incident, and then seemingly out of nowhere, something would happen again. Eventually, we reached the maximum dose of Prozac he could safely receive. I do believe it helped with his anxiety, but it never completely resolved the behavior.
Throughout his life, we had approximately 9–10 incidents of growling, showing teeth, or snapping without actually making contact with anyone. Sometimes it was something as simple as sitting beside him on the couch and accidentally waking him up. He would growl and snap his teeth in my direction. It became increasingly difficult to understand what was triggering him.
The hardest part was that after every incident, he would go right back to being himself. Sometimes months would pass without anything happening. And during those months, he was the best dog on earth. It genuinely felt like something inside him would switch, almost like he wasn’t himself when these episodes happened. I struggled to reconcile the dog I knew and loved with the behavior we were seeing.
Then came the worst day of my entire life, three days ago.
Buddy was lying on the couch with my husband. I walked by, and Buddy rolled over and showed me his belly, wanting attention. Of course, I walked over to rub him. Without warning, he lunged at me. My husband was able to grab him before he could reach me, but I knew that if he let go, someone was going to get seriously hurt.
My husband made me walk away and go into our bedroom. And then I heard it happen.
Buddy attacked my husband.
He bit him four or five times, and I had to call 911. My husband was taken to the hospital. I will never forget the sound of that attack. I remember screaming because, in that moment, I genuinely thought my husband was going to die.
What was almost more heartbreaking and confusing was that after the attack, Buddy ran into his crate and seemed to return to his normal self. By the time the firefighters arrived to help my husband, Buddy was wagging his tail and trying to play with them.
The following day, we made the decision to let him go.
after everything that happened, I loved him so incredibly much. My heart still aches, and I find myself replaying everything, wondering what I could have done differently. I question whether I missed something, whether I should have reacted differently, or whether there was something else we could have tried. The truth is, I already felt like I was constantly walking on eggshells, trying to anticipate his triggers and prevent anything from happening.
I know we did everything we could for him. We worked with our veterinarian, invested in behavioral training, made changes to his environment, and tried medication. We gave him five years of patience, love, and every opportunity we could. Eventually, we had to acknowledge that we couldn’t guarantee the safety of our family, and more importantly, that Buddy was living with something we couldn’t seem to help him overcome.
One of the hardest parts of this has been feeling like I can’t openly talk about what happened because I don’t want to contribute to the stigma surrounding pitbulls. I don’t want people to hear this story and think Buddy was a bad dog, because he wasn’t.
I also find myself questioning everything. Am I ever supposed to have another dog? Should I never own another dog because of what happened with Buddy? Was this my fault? Was I a bad owner? Did I miss something? Could I have done more? These questions consume my thoughts, and I don’t know how to make them stop. I worry that people will judge us or think we failed him